Scribd
Upload
10 views3 pages

Liam Pierce - 2018 Synthesis - Module 31 Chart

The document provides a chart for tracking the validity of sources related to the claim that eminent domain serves a purpose but is often corrupted, harming the poor. It categorizes various sources as pro, anti, or neutral towards eminent domain, while assessing their biases and relevance to the claim. The chart also includes quotes of significance from the sources to support or counter the claim.

Uploaded by

piercelm13
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
10 views3 pages

Liam Pierce - 2018 Synthesis - Module 31 Chart

The document provides a chart for tracking the validity of sources related to the claim that eminent domain serves a purpose but is often corrupted, harming the poor. It categorizes various sources as pro, anti, or neutral towards eminent domain, while assessing their biases and relevance to the claim. The chart also includes quotes of significance from the sources to support or counter the claim.

Uploaded by

piercelm13
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 3

Directions:

Use the chart below to track your understanding of the sources. The chart can be modified to
your personal preference. Remember, the idea is to quickly assess the validity of a source to
your argument.

Prompt: Cut and paste the directions from the FRQ page here:

MY Claim → Eminent Domain has a purpose in the government, however it’s


corrupted harming the poor and the doesn’t provide a solution for those whose
homes were bought.
Source Information Overview
Source A Source B Source C Source D Source E Source F

Document Legal doc Newspap Blog Report cartoon Newspaper


Type er article artical

Pro Eminent yes X X Yes X X


Domain

Anti Eminent X Yes Yes X yes yes


Domain

Neutral X X X X X X

Possible Bias None Yes No Yes only No it’s a article


Bias toward beyond “nonpartisa although it because documenting an
political being n” group is pro E.D there is event, however
system against but give it isn’t nothing the publisher
given it eminent lots of really about the could be by
being a domain evidence stating that author making it
legal against it should beyond his public.Beyond
document E.D be a thing cartoon on that I think that
or not Eminent it take a
rather it domain. documentary-
supplies like role
information
showing
what it did

Supports my Yes Yes Yes Yeah great Yes? I Yes


claim counter personally
wouldn’t
use this

Counters my Yes It Can no Yes and no No It can given that


claim that’s the the idea of ““I
quote think the council
below and mayor are
very well-
meaning people
trying to carry
out what would
be a very nice
bike path,
which we’ve
invested a good
deal of effort in,”

Can be used to
describe that
that not all
Eminent domain
cases are bad,
and the value of
such things can
be argued. I
wouldn’t use
this it’s too
weak.

Quote of eminent “New The Having N/A One option is to


Significance domain: London’s condemne completed pay Stebelton
establishin developm d property a carefully the full jury
g parks ent plan was often phased award and
and may hurt transferred redevelop move ahead.
setting a few to ment Another is to
aside small politically program in pay Stebelton
open property influential 2006, the the $37,000 and
space for owners, developers authority work out
future who will, and successfull an alternate
generation in any business y returned path that
s, case, be interests. more than doesn’t diminish
preserving fully one-third of the value of
places of compens the Stebelton’s
historic ated. But displaced land, said Gene
interest many household Hollins, the
and more s to the village solicitor.
remarkabl residents Freetown
e natural are likely community
beauty, to benefit , which
and if the city now Canal
protecting can shore numbers Winchester
environme up its about 200 wants the land
ntally tax base families. to link a bike
sensitive and path between
areas. attract Rager Road
= badly and the village
needed swimming pool.
jobs.” It used eminent
domain to take
a strip of
Stebelton’s 80-
acre property
and hired an
appraiser who
determined that
the $9,249
would be
enough
compensation.

You might also like