Module-5 Fallacy
Module-5 Fallacy
1. Relevance: The things you're saying should relate to what you're trying to prove.
2. Acceptability: The things you're saying should make sense and be logical.
3. Sufficiency: You need enough good reasons to prove your point.
4. Rebuttability: You should be ready to defend your argument against possible objections or challenges.
Ways Fallacies Happen: Fallacies usually happen because of mistakes in how we think or how we put arguments
together. Sometimes, it's because the reasoning is off, and other times, it's because the argument looks better
than it is because of some trick.
Types of Arguments:
• Deductive: These are like proofs in math. If the premises (starting points) are true, the conclusion has to be
true.
• Inductive: These are like making guesses based on evidence. Even if the evidence is good, the conclusion
might still be wrong.
Relation between Fallacies and Arguments: If an argument has a fallacy, it's not a good argument. It might not be
true or convincing. And if an argument isn't true or convincing, it probably has a fallacy in it somewhere.
Formal Fallacies:
• These are like mistakes in the structure or setup of an argument.
• You can spot them just by looking at how the argument is put together, kind of like seeing a crack in a wall.
• They only happen in certain types of arguments, specifically deductive ones, which are like logical proofs.
Informal Fallacies:
• These are more about mistakes in the content or meaning of an argument.
• You can't always see them just by looking at how the argument is arranged; you have to dig into what's
being said and how it's being said.
• They can happen in any kind of argument, whether it's about logic or just trying to make a point.
So, think of it like this: if a formal fallacy is like spotting a hole in the road just by looking at it, an informal fallacy is
like realizing the road might lead to the wrong place after you've been driving on it for a while and paying attention
to the signs.
FALLACIES OF RELEVANCE
• Example for Bandwagon Fallacy: "Everyone's buying the new phone, so you should too."
• Example for Appeal to Vanity: "If you use this perfume, you'll be as popular as the celebrity who wears it."
• Example for Appeal to Snobbery: "Only elite people use this brand of handbags. You'll stand out as
sophisticated if you have one."
• Example for Ad Hominem Abusive Fallacy: "You're just a loser, so your opinion doesn't count."
• Example for Ad Hominem Circumstantial Fallacy: "Of course, you'd say that you work for the company."
• Example for Tu Quoque Fallacy: "You're telling me not to smoke, but I've seen you smoke before."
5. Accident:
Example: "It's wrong to speed, but I was rushing my pregnant wife to the hospital."
Explanation: This is when a general rule is applied to a specific situation where it wasn't meant to apply.
6. Straw Man:
Example: "Opponent: We should invest more in education. Arguer: No, my opponent wants to bankrupt the
country with unnecessary spending."
Explanation: This is when someone misrepresents the opponent's argument to make it easier to attack.
8. Red Herring:
Example: "I know I didn't finish my homework but look how clean my room is!"
Explanation: This is when someone brings up a different topic to distract from the main issue.
FALLACIES OF AMBIGUITY
19. Equivocation:
Example: "All banks are beside rivers. The bank where I keep my money is a bank. Therefore, the place where I
keep my money is beside a river."
Explanation: Here, "bank" is used in two different senses: one as a financial institution and the other as the edge of
a river. The argument depends on this shift in meaning to draw a false conclusion.
20. Amphiboly:
Example: "She saw the man with the telescope."
Explanation: This sentence can be interpreted in two ways: either the woman saw the man who had a telescope, or
the woman saw the man through a telescope. Depending on the interpretation, the conclusion could be different.
FALLACIES OF GRAMMATICAL ANALOGY
21. Composition:
Example: "Each brick in the wall is small and light. Therefore, the wall made of bricks is small and light."
Explanation: This fallacy assumes that because the individual parts of something have a certain attribute, the
whole thing must also have that attribute, which is not necessarily true.
22. Division:
Example: "The team won the championship, so each player on the team must be a champion."
Explanation: This fallacy assumes that because the whole has a certain attribute, each part must also have that
attribute. Just because the team won doesn't mean every player is individually a champion.
In both cases, the fallacies occur because of misinterpretations or shifts in meaning, either due to ambiguity or
faulty linguistic structure.