CAPE Communication Studies Module 2 2023 Essay Notes
CAPE Communication Studies Module 2 2023 Essay Notes
3. To discuss ways in which the credibility can be improved. chosen Young Genius as your go-to academic support.
The article, “New Study Says Social Media Doesn’t Make Us Antisocial” by Taylor Bennet presents
the main idea that despite popular belief that excess social media use is a sign of antisocial
behaviour, studies have shown the opposite. Bennet’s purpose is to persuade readers to rethink
their views on the effects of excessive social media use and consider that it might instead be a
sign of hypersocial behaviour.
The writer uses organisational strategies such as comparison and contrast; and use of expert
opinion to achieve this purpose. The author begins the discourse by introducing the audience to
the idea that excessive social media use leads to antisocial behaviour. Later, the author mentions
the study conducted by McGill University that challenges this idea. By introducing the expert
opinion, the author signposts the counterargument and provides readers with clear direction. This
provides a contrast between the articles’ upper and lower half showing clearly the author’s shift in
perspective.
Furthermore, the author uses language techniques such as: 1st Person Point of View and
Anecdotes. The text begins by talking about the author’s own social media habits. Moreover, the
author uses personal pronouns such as “I” and “me”, throughout the article. This makes the topic
more relatable and elicits an emotional response from the readers. This is often used to further
engage readers to experience the writing from the writer’s perspective; as if they were their own
words.
When considering the article’s credibility, it is able to present the arguments in a clear, coherent
manner on a topic that is widely studied. Also, the information presented in the text is relevant to
the main point and purpose of the article. Thus, the information presented in this article is current
and relevant. However, the article falls short in terms of authority, accuracy and purpose. Taylor
Bennet does not hold an academic title such as Dr. or PhD, therefore lacks authority to make
judgements on psychological disorders such as antisocial behaviour. Furthermore, this was
presented in a blog, rather than a reputable journal, further dampening its credibility. To remedy
this, Taylor could consider partnering with a doctor who specialises in Psychiatry and create a
collaborative article rather than an independent one.
Particularly, the use of anecdotes polarises communication and leaves room for the reader to
uncritically accept the writer’s perspective.
In conclusion, the article attempts to persuade the readers that the new belief that excessive
social media use results in hypersocial behaviour rather than the traditional perspective that it
results in antisocial behaviour. The writer achieves this by using organisational strategies such as:
comparison and contrast; and expert opinion. The writer also uses language techniques such as:
1st person POV and anecdotal evidence. Overall, though the topic is timeless and the information is
relevant; the article lacks authority and falls short in accuracy and purpose.
The main idea is that despite popular belief that excessive social media use is a sign of antisocial
behaviour, studies have shown the opposite. Excessive social media use is a sign of hypersocial
behaviour.
WRITER’S PURPOSE:
The writer’s main purpose is to persuade readers to rethink their views on the effects of excessive
ORGANISATIONAL STRATEGIES
When trying to figure out the organisational strategies, it i important to consider the overall text-
structure. The five most common are: Sequenced, Descriptive, Argumentative, Problem-Solution
and Cause-Effect.
❌ Sequenced
❌ Descriptive
✅ Argumentative
❌ Problem-Solution
❌ Cause-Effect
Language Techniques are usually figurative devices. So, look out for those in the text.
In this question, you are not required to EVALUATE the credibility of the source, but rather to
comment on or suggest ways in which its credibility can be improved. While the phrasing of the
question may seem similar, there is a subtle difference. If you were asked to EVALUATE, a final
judgment on whether the source can be trusted would be required. However, since you are not
asked to do this, simply stating your opinion, supported by evidence, is perfectly fine.
* Note: The words in red represents the areas where credibility is affected in the writer’s piece.
The extract is a snippet from Barbara Lalla's novel, "Arch of Fire". It explores the idea of class
difference and shows Pearl's dream to own a mansion in Beverly Hills. Lalla helps the readers
understand the narrative through the use of different dialectal varieties; grammatical features of
Caribbean Creole; and the non-verbal communicative behaviours Peal uses.
The extract uses two dialectal varieties: Caribbean Standard English (CSE) for narration and
Standard Jamaican Creole (SJC) for dialogue. CSE clearly conveys the events in a clear and
coherent manner. Also, it highlights the contrast between Pearl and Adam's social positions, as
well as Pearl's aspirations. This is evident in the detailed descriptions of places like the "homes of
the affluent," which are never mentioned in the Creole dialogue. To further show the divide, the
narration describes the Cohon house on Oxford Close as "ancient" to Pearl, implying it is more
sophisticated than she is used to. In contrast, the Creole dialogue focuses on the houses' cost, with
Pearl’s husband suggesting they can't afford them. A stark contrast is also drawn between the
elegant narrative description, "plumes of deep pink bougainvillaea cascading," and Pearl’s clumsy
remark about the house being a “top-heavy thing,”. This further reiterates the clear division in class
Furthermore, creole grammar elements, such as zero copula and unmarked action verbs, are
prominently featured in the narrative. Pearl uses zero copula in her first question: "What they
keeping that old mausoleum for?" where the auxiliary verb "are" is omitted, reflecting her
background and social status. This makes her a more vivid and relatable character. Additionally,
Pearl's husband uses unmarked action verbs, as in "Or we come to look at that house?" where
"come" substitutes "came," but the context clarifies the past tense.
Pearl uses kinesics and vocalics as non-verbal communicative behaviors. When questioning why
the old mausoleum is being kept, she shrugs, possibly signaling uncertainty. Her second shrug,
paired with "Oh forget it," after her husband's silence on house prices, conveys indifference and
This contrast reinforces the theme of juxtaposition in the narrative. Moreover, at the end, Pearl’s
silence conveys multiple emotions, such as remorse for tricking her husband into driving through
Beverly Hills or even shame for being caught, realizing her childish games were unnecessary. This
is evident from the beginning of the extract, where her first instinct is to manipulate Adam, with the
narration describing her thinking about "how to get Adam to the house and convince him he had
discovered it for himself."
All in all, Lalla uses both Caribbean Standard English (CSE) and Standard Jamaican Creole (SJC) in
the narrative. Furthermore, Lalla employs features of Creole grammar such as “zero copula” and
“unmarked action verbs” to develop the characters' identities and make the narrative more
believable. Finally, non-verbal communicative techniques, such as shrugging her shoulders and
the silence at the end, help the reader understand Pearl as an individual.
The extract uses two dialectal varieties: Caribbean Standard English (CSE) for narration and
Standard Jamaican Creole (SJC) for dialogue.
When discussing language varieties, it is important to emphasize that there are two distinct
varieties present. Students who wish to address the language continuum—i.e., the basilect,
mesolect, and acrolect—must understand that these are not separate language varieties, but
rather refer to the different levels of Creole used.
Caribbean Standard
Grammatical Features English Creole
English
Pearl uses both kinesics and vocalics. Kinesics refers to body language and gestures, while
vocalics refers to vocal qualities such as tone, rate, and the use of verbal fillers etc.
In 2020, amidst the upheaval of the COVID-19 pandemic, our homes welcomed an unexpected
guest: the rise of smoking and vaping among students. With lockdowns and the suspension of
face-to-face schooling, these habits became all too common. Yet, as we adapt new hobbies, we
owe a it to ourselves. Our future where we can breathe easily in fresh airs and sunny skies.
Therefore, I propose that our church’s youth group spearhead an anti-smoking and anti-vaping
multimedia campaign, which epitomizes this message.
Our message will resonate by using inclusive language such as “us”, “we” and “our future”. This
establishes a sense of common purpose and responsibility. Moreover, drawing wisdom from the
Holy Bible, reinforces our campaign’s ethical foundation. This connection to timeless values not
only engrosses our moral imperative but also lends authority to our cause. It draws upon a
tradition of guiding principles which has span centuries.
As stewards of our community’s well-being, it is our duty to intervene. By addressing this pressing
issue among our peers, we fulfill our commitment to serve our community. We will also nurture our
own personal development. The impact or our intervention must not be understated! This is not
just a mere choice, but a necessity to safeguard the health and future of our generation.
We will effectively reach our peers, through multiple forms of digital technology. Social media
platforms will serve as our primary tool, leveraging their ubiquity and reach among youth.
Additionally, we will launch a weekly podcast discussing the consequences of smoking and
vaping, offering a fresh and engaging medium to share insights and foster dialogue. By meeting
our audience where they are—online and on-the-go—we ensure that our message resonates with
maximum impact.
In conclusion, through persuasion via ethos (i.e. similitude and establishing authority); and
innovative digital outreach; we will empower our peers to make informed choices and breathe
easier, knowing that our collective efforts pave the way for a tomorrow filled with vitality and
wellness.
MODULE 3 NOTES
RHETORICAL APPEALS, MULTIMEDIA CAMPAIGN AND INTERVENTIONS
According to Blinn College - Bryan Writing Center (2023), rhetorical appeals are the qualities of an
argument that make it truly persuasive. These appeals include pathos, ethos, and logos.
The pathos appeal, according to Aristotle, involves presenting an argument in a way that
influences the reader's judgment (Braet, 1992). Higgins & Walker (2012) provide examples of this
appeal, such as the use of metaphors and cultural references, including sports and pop culture, to
connect with the audience.
Braet (1992) describes the ethos appeal as framing an argument in a way that makes the speaker
or writer appear credible. Higgins & Walker (2012) offer several examples of ethos, including
inclination to succeed.
Finally, Braet (1992) explains the logos appeal as constructing arguments based on deductive
reasoning. In this appeal, the writer provides evidence to support their arguments as logically as
possible. Higgins & Walker (2012) identify examples of logos, such as argumentation, justification,
In the case of the interventions, it is important for the group to act out of a sense of duty and
service to the community, along with a commitment to personal development and self-
actualization.
REFERENCES
LIST OF SOURCES USED FOR RESEARCH
Cribb, V. M., & Rochford, S. (2017). The transcription and representation of spoken political
Haghtalab, N., Immorlica, N., Lucier, B., Mobius, M., & Mohan, D. (2022, May 26). Communicating
with Anecdotes. Retrieved from https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.13461
Hassan, F. F. I. H. (2018). Persuasive Personae: The Appeal to Religion and the Construction of
Higgins, C., & Walker, R. (2012). Ethos, logos, pathos: Strategies of persuasion in
Li, B., Cardier, B., Wang, T., & Metze, F. (2017, October 8). Annotating High-Level structures of short
stories and personal anecdotes. Retrieved from https://arxiv.org/abs/1710.06917