Faculty of : ……… Program:……….

Class/Section: ……………… Date: …………

Name of Faculty: ……………………. Name of Course: …………… Code: ……………

Hierarchical Decomposition

Hierarchical decomposition is a strategy used in complex problem-solving, particularly in the

field of artificial intelligence (AI) and software engineering, where a large problem is broken
down into smaller, more manageable sub-problems. Each sub-problem can be solved
independently, and the solutions are then combined to solve the original, overarching problem.
This technique helps in organizing complex systems and processes, making them easier to
understand, analyze, and solve.

In software development and AI planning, hierarchical decomposition is widely used in

planning algorithms, hierarchical task networks (HTN), project management, and system
design.

Key Concepts of Hierarchical Decomposition

1. Top-Down Approach: The process starts by analyzing the overall problem and
breaking it down step-by-step into smaller, simpler components or tasks.
2. Abstraction: Each level in the hierarchy represents a different level of abstraction. At
the top level, we deal with the broader goal, while at the lower levels, we focus on
specific, detailed sub-tasks.
3. Modularity: By breaking down a system into independent modules or components,
hierarchical decomposition promotes modular design, enabling reuse, easier testing, and
better management of complexity.
4. Hierarchical Task Networks (HTN): In AI, HTN planning involves decomposing a
complex task into simpler subtasks, where each subtask is easier to manage or automate.

How Hierarchical Decomposition Works

1. Identify the Main Task or Problem:

o Start by defining the overall task or goal.
o Example: In AI planning, the goal might be for a robot to deliver an item to a
specific location.
2. Break Down the Main Task into Sub-Tasks:
o The next step is to identify sub-tasks or sub-goals that need to be achieved to
fulfill the main goal.
Session 2024-25
 o Example: The task of "deliver an item" can be broken down into "navigate to the
item’s location", "pick up the item", and "navigate to the destination".
3. Continue Breaking Down Sub-Tasks:
o Each sub-task is further decomposed until you reach tasks that are simple
enough to execute directly without further decomposition.
o Example: "Navigate to the item’s location" might be broken down into "find the
shortest path", "avoid obstacles", and "move forward".
4. Manage Dependencies and Constraints:
o Consider dependencies between subtasks and ensure that subtasks are ordered in
such a way that dependencies are respected.
o Example: You can’t deliver an item unless you have picked it up.
5. Execution:
o Once all sub-tasks are defined, the plan can be executed either from the bottom-
up (executing small tasks first) or as a complete system.
6. Refinement:
o The decomposition process is iterative. After solving lower-level tasks,
refinement may occur where some subtasks need further breaking down or
adjustment.

Hierarchical Decomposition in AI Planning

In Hierarchical Task Network (HTN) planning, decomposition is the key idea where
planning is done hierarchically. Complex tasks are divided into smaller subtasks, and each
subtask is associated with methods for achieving it. This method is used in areas like robotics,
automated planning, and game AI.

Example in AI Planning:

1. Top-level Task: Delivering a package.

2. Subtasks:
o Navigate to the pickup location.
o Pick up the package.
o Navigate to the delivery location.
o Deliver the package.

Each of these tasks might require further decomposition. For instance, “navigate to the pickup
location” could involve finding the shortest route and avoiding obstacles.

Advantages in AI Planning:

 Scalability: Hierarchical decomposition allows complex problems to be tackled

incrementally, making it easier to scale.
 Flexibility: Once a task is broken into smaller tasks, new methods can be added or
modified independently.
 Reusability: Lower-level tasks can often be reused in different contexts, reducing
duplication of effort.

Session 2024-25
Analysis of Hierarchical Decomposition

Advantages of Hierarchical Decomposition

1. Reduces Complexity:
o By breaking a large, complex problem into smaller, manageable pieces,
hierarchical decomposition simplifies the problem-solving process. Each small
sub-problem can be tackled independently.
2. Modular Design:
o Hierarchical decomposition naturally leads to modularity. Each sub-task or
component can be developed, tested, and maintained independently, which is
useful in large projects or systems.
3. Improves Manageability:
o In project management or system design, hierarchical decomposition helps
managers or developers handle complexity by focusing on one part of the
problem at a time. This promotes clarity in design and decision-making.
4. Enhances Reusability:
o Sub-tasks or subcomponents can often be reused in different parts of the system
or in future projects. This promotes code reuse and reduces redundancy.
5. Supports Parallel Development:
o Since sub-tasks are relatively independent, they can be developed in parallel,
allowing for more efficient use of resources. Different teams can work on
different parts of the problem simultaneously.
6. Flexibility and Adaptation:
o If changes or new requirements arise, hierarchical decomposition allows you to
make modifications at different levels without affecting the entire system.
7. Better Control and Maintenance:
o Decomposed systems are easier to maintain. If an issue occurs, it can often be
traced to a specific module, reducing debugging time and improving system
reliability.

Challenges of Hierarchical Decomposition

1. Overhead of Decomposition:
o The process of decomposing a problem into sub-tasks may introduce
complexity, especially when dependencies between subtasks are intricate.
Managing these dependencies can be challenging.
2. Granularity Issues:
o Deciding the right level of granularity can be difficult. Over-decomposing may
lead to excessive fragmentation, while under-decomposing might result in
unmanageable sub-problems.
3. Coordination Overhead:
o In distributed or parallel development environments, coordinating the activities
of teams working on different sub-tasks might become difficult and introduce
additional overhead.
4. Integration Complexity:
o Once the individual sub-tasks or components are completed, they need to be
integrated. The integration process may be complex, particularly if the interfaces
between components are not well-defined.
5. Dependency Management:

Session 2024-25
 o Managing dependencies between subtasks can complicate the execution of the
plan. If one sub-task is delayed or fails, it can affect the entire system.

6. Scalability:
o As more and more levels of hierarchy are introduced, the decomposition process
itself can become complex and difficult to manage. At extreme levels, it may
become inefficient or counterproductive.

Imagine you have a big problem to solve, like planning for a Birthday Party. How can you
Solve the above problem using Hierarchical decomposition process.

To solve the problem of planning a birthday party using the hierarchical decomposition
process, you would break down the large, complex task into smaller, more manageable sub-
tasks, organizing them in a structured hierarchy. Here’s how you can approach it:
1. Define the Main Goal
Goal: Plan and execute a successful birthday party.

2. Identify Major Tasks

Break the main goal into major tasks. Each major task represents a high-level component of the
overall planning process.
1. Venue Selection
2. Guest Management
3. Catering
4. Entertainment
5. Decorations
6. Logistics and Coordination

3. Decompose Major Tasks into Sub-Tasks

Each major task is further divided into sub-tasks that are specific actions needed to accomplish
the main task.
1. Venue Selection
 Research: Identify potential venues.
 Visit: Tour the shortlisted venues.
 Compare: Evaluate venues based on cost, capacity, location, and amenities.
 Book: Secure the chosen venue by signing a contract and paying any deposits.
2. Guest Management
 Prepare Guest List: List all potential invitees.
 Send Invitations: Design and distribute invitations (digital or paper).
 Track RSVPs: Monitor responses and update the guest list.

Session 2024-25
  Seating Arrangements: Plan and organize seating based on the number of guests and
preferences.
3. Catering
 Select Menu: Choose food and drink options.
 Find Caterer: Research and select a catering service.
 Place Order: Finalize and confirm the menu with the caterer.
 Confirm Delivery: Ensure timely delivery and setup of food.
4. Entertainment
 Choose Activities: Decide on games, music, or other activities.
 Hire Entertainers: Book a DJ, band, or performers if needed.
 Plan Schedule: Organize the timing of entertainment activities.
 Prepare Equipment: Arrange for any necessary equipment or props.
5. Decorations
 Select Theme: Decide on a party theme or color scheme.
 Purchase/Make Decorations: Buy or create decorations that match the theme.
 Set Up: Arrange decorations at the venue.
6. Logistics and Coordination
 Plan Timeline: Create a schedule for the party day, including setup, event timing, and
cleanup.
 Coordinate with Vendors: Communicate with venue, caterer, and entertainers to
ensure everything is in place.
 Manage Budget: Track expenses and ensure costs are within budget.
 Handle Emergencies: Prepare for unexpected issues or last-minute changes.

4. Establish Dependencies and Priorities

Determine which tasks depend on others and sequence them accordingly. For example:
 Venue Selection must be completed before Guest Management can proceed, as you
need to finalize the venue to confirm the party date.
 Catering must be planned after the number of guests is known.
 Entertainment should be organized once the date and venue are set.

5. Create a Detailed Plan

 Develop a Timeline: Use tools like Gantt charts to map out the schedule for each task
and sub-task.
 Assign Responsibilities: Allocate tasks to individuals or teams if working with others.
 Set Milestones: Establish key deadlines for each major task to ensure timely
completion.

Session 2024-25
6. Execute and Monitor
 Follow the Plan: Carry out tasks as scheduled.
 Monitor Progress: Regularly check the status of each task and adjust as needed.
 Communicate: Keep all parties involved informed of progress and any changes.

7. Review and Adjust

 Post-Event Evaluation: Assess the success of the party based on feedback and
observations.
 Identify Improvements: Document what worked well and areas for improvement.
 Adjust for Future Events: Apply lessons learned to enhance planning for future
events.

Session 2024-25