Chapter 07 Training
Chapter 07 Training
Training Employees
• Learning
➢ Relatively permanent change in behavior
and human capabilities produced by
experience and practice
• Foundation for training programs
• Cognitive, skill-based, affective
• Performance
– Actions or behaviors relevant to the
organization’s goals
Examples of Types of Training Programs
Training in
Organizations
Tradeoff
between Training
selection and conducted in
training house vs.
• Train KSAOs that externally
can’t be selected
Needs Assessment
• Determining which employees need training
and what the content should be
– Can ensure that training resources are
wisely spent on areas in which there is a
demonstrated training need
– Resources are often wasted if needs
assessment is not done-wrong people
with wrong content
• Purposes of needs assessment
– Which training is needed?
– Where is training needed?
– Who needs to be trained, and how?
– What are some specific training
objectives and criteria?
– What are our resources?
Needs
Assessment &
Training
Objectives
• Levels of needs
assessment (Golstein,
1993); 3-step process
1. Organizational
Analysis
2. Job/Task Analysis
3. Person Analysis
Organizational Analysis
• Examines company wide goals/problems to
identify what training is needed and where.
• Objectives of the organization and how
they’re addressed by employee
performance
• Assess manager, peer, technological
support for transfer of training
• E.g., if managers are willing, give
time to trainees, how much, etc.
• Takes into account climate of organization
& its subunits
e.g. concern for safety in the production
unit
e.g. climate for transfer of training
• Identifies available resources to determine
how training be designed and the objectives.
Needs Assessment; three levels
• Organization level;
– E.g., if the organization values performance quality, training
should emphasize quality control.
– E.g., if the goal is to minimize injuries, training should focus
on principles of workplace safety
Sensory modalities
(auditory, visual,
kinesthetic)
Learning Presentation vs. written
materials
preferences Not good at reading
using spoken materials
Trainee Characteristics:
→ Motivation &
Attitudes
• How much trainees are interested in attending
training, learning, and transfer of skills.
– Research: Motivation is related to transfer
of training as well as good employee
attitude.
• Expectancy framework
– Do trainees think that the work
environment is favorable?
– Do they believe that putting effort in
training would really lead to learning?
– Affects motivation
Trainee Characteristics
→Trainee Readiness
– Experience
• Level of experience affects what
training design would yield most
effective results.
– Interacts with abilities
– experience, ability →shorter
and less structured training
programs
– experience, ability → longer
and more structured training would
be more beneficial
Design Factors
Overlearning Sequencing of
• Automaticity training
• Part vs. whole
• Massed vs. spaced
Feedback
• Spaced training
– Sessions short and spread
out over time.
– Rest intervals between
practice sessions
– Generally, results in more
efficient learning &
retention
– Tasks with high complexity
require longer rest period
e.g., flight simulations
Design Factors; Massed Training
• Can be more efficient;
– E.g., a one day absence less disruptive to the
workplace than four 2-hour absences, especially when
a replacement is necessary or the training location
requires much travel.
• BUT can produce boredom, which interferes with
learning
• Fatigue is another problem
– E.g., playing tennis for 10-hours a day will not be
feasible for some people
– E.g., when cramming for a test, the student may be
tired cognitively
Design Factors; Spaced
Training
• Can be more effective in the long run
• Better retention over time particularly
for skills that are required but not used
often (e.g., CPR; Cardiopulmonary
Resuscitation).
– Intervals depend on how long
material be remembered; the
longer the higher retention
• Especially for motor skills where
fatigue in a long session would
decrease learning, but also for mental
tasks
• E.g., keeping up with coursework is
superior to cramming
Work Environment
• Role-playing
– A type of simulation involving an interpersonal situation
• The trainee pretends to be doing a task.
– Used as part of modeling, but could also be based on information
acquired otherwise.
• The role play itself does not involve first observing another
person perform the behavior
– e.g. supervisory training
– Effective due to lots of practice and feedback--but costly, since few
trainees can be trained at once.
Off-Site Training
Methods
• Simulators; are tools designed to reproduce the
critical characteristics of the real work setting;
– Specialized equipment or materials imitate a
task situation.
– Trainees pretend the situation is real and carry
out the task.
– Good for training in use of equipment, but
also for business decision-making.
• E.g. cockpits to train pilots; trainees
utilize relevant KSAOs while performing,
like altitude control, navigation, use of
checklists, communicating with the co-
pilot and with the air traffic controllers.
• E.g., business decision simulation
– Advantages are practice and good transfer;
disadvantages are cost of the simulation and
of training few trainees at once.
– Computer games to teach KSAOs; very
expensive to develop
On-Site Training Methods
• On-the-Job Training
– Follows initial formal training
– Observe from more experienced employees
• May be informal
– It should be done systematically: identify
developmental goals, incorporate learning
principles, behavioral modeling, provide feedback
– If done systematically, it is more likely to be
effective
On-Site Training Methods
• Formal; Apprentice Training: apprentice → journeyman →
certified skill tradeperson
– An apprentice is an employee who serves as an assistant
to the trainer
– Used to teach a skilled trade (electrician, carpenter)
• 2 to 5 years;
• For some job, the other methods may not be feasible
– E.g., electrician, plummer
• Because the organization will not want to pay
someone for years of training
– To be effective it should include modeling, practice,
feedback, evaluation
On-the-Job Training
Methods
• Formal; Job Rotation: moving employees to
various jobs or departments in a company.
– Development of wider range of skills
• Entry level HR specialist might be rotated
through staffing, compensation, training
areas.
– Time period can be months
– Can be used to prepare potential employees
for future management responsibilities.
• New college graduates with an MBA
degree, might get rotated around several
departments like the HR, operations,
accounting to determine where they would
be most effective.
– Learn a lot about functions of these
departments
– Develop contacts in the organization
Other Training Methods
• Electronic training
– Encompasses all forms of
learning that use electronic
or digital resources
– Synchronous (real-time) or
asynchronous (self-paced)
– Blended learning
• Mentoring
– More experienced employee
offers career guidance,
counseling, and emotional
support
– Related to better
performance and quicker
promotion
• Executive coaching
Off-Site Training Methods: (e-learning)
Advantages Disadvantages
Flexibility in time and place No trainer to motivate employee;
Training materials easily incorporate gamification
modified/updated Time not set aside, so employee
Cost-effective; eliminates travelling to squeeze into work time; employees are
attend training sessions given a day off to attend training
Can result in equivalent or even better Completion rates are generally less
learning than classroom instructions than 25%
Can be combined with other methods
• Blended learning
More experienced employee offers career guidance,
counseling, and emotional support
Personal coach who Often focused on Coach can use Can be effective Concern: no
assists manager in communication 360-degree in raising self- consensus about
improving and leadership feedback as tool efficacy in ksaos required by
performance managerial coaches
Help interpret the
When performance feedback and abilities Coaches with
deficiencies, cost of devise an action diverse
finding a replacement plan backgrounds
is high, improve perf.
of well-performing
Delivery of a Training
Program
Set criteria
Steps to Design of
evaluation studies
Training Steps involved Choose measures
and collect data
Ineffective training
should be modified or
discontinued.
Evaluation: Set
criteria
Kirkpatrick (1976): useful to divide them into four types
1. Training-level criteria: what trainees can do at the end of training in
the training environment rather than on the job
– Reactions; important because the employee should have
confidence and motivation to use it
• E.g., feelings of satisfaction, perceptions of utility
• Assessed with questionnaires; e.g., student evaluations
• Determined by trainer’s style, interaction with the trainees,
motivation of trainees, organizational support for training
– Learning
• E.g., acquired declarative & procedural knowledge, retention
of declarative knowledge
• E.g., Given an exam
• Should be reliable and valid
Evaluation: Set
criteria
Kirkpatrick (1976): useful to divide them into four types
2. Performance-level criteria: examining transfer of training
– Behavior: whether the trainee is doing the things
learned
• e.g., acquired skill demonstrated on job,
productivity, errors, absenteeism etc.
• Learned to deal with angry customers, do they use it
when working?
– Results
• e.g., training utility in terms of organizational
outcomes: productivity gains, cost savings,
increased customer satisfaction
• Whether increased sales of an intended product?
Criteria
• Training criteria
– Reactions: Did employees like it?
• Questionnaire at end
– Learning: Did employees learn?
• Test at end of training
• Performance criteria
– Behavior: Did behavior change on the job?
• Ratings by supervisor
• Observe frequency of using
– Results: Were there organization benefits?
• Assessment of outcomes on the job
• Costs
• Sales
Evaluation: Did the
Training Work?
Employees assigned to
training or control group
Control group Trained employees
compared to controls
design Sometime control is
“placebo” training
Evaluation: Design of evaluation studies
• Did the trained group change significantly more than the control
group?
• Close association between groups cause spillover of information when
only control group used.
• Still problematic:
• Ones not getting training may resent not being in training, thus may
pressure trained employees not to apply it.
Evaluation: Did the Training Work?
• Choose measures; choosing actual measures of
those criteria
– Criterion determines measure to some extent.
– Reactions require a questionnaire, though you must
still choose its form and the particular questions.
– Learning criteria require knowledge and skills tests,
which might include a role play or simulation test.
– Performance criteria might be similar to those in
performance evaluations.
• Measuring trainee behavior or results in the job setting
rather than in training
Evaluation: Did the Training
Work?
• Collect data
– Collecting data in organizations can
be difficult.
• People aren’t always
cooperative.
• Might resist random
assignment;
– Means that the trained group
comes from one department
and the control group from
another; differences may be
caused by departmental
differences
– Choose the best possible design and
measures and try to adapt to
problems that arise.
• Plan ahead
• Modify when required
effectively
Evaluation: Did the Training
Work?
• Analyze and interpret data
– Data is analyzed with
inferential statistics.
• For the two simple
designs discussed, a t-
test might be used.