Levels: Perceptuazand Uotovskzlls
Levels: Perceptuazand Uotovskzlls
Levels: Perceptuazand Uotovskzlls
UNEK TAN
-Address correspondence to Prof. Dr. Uner Tan, Cukurova University, Faculty of Arts and
Sciences, 01330 Adana, Turkey or e-mail ([email protected]).
od, measuring the fingertip extensions, to study the sex-specific finger-
length patterns in various human populations. The results seemed to be con-
sistent with expected sexual dimorphism in the 2D:4D digit ratio reported
by many authors studying finger-length patterns (e.g., hIanning, et nl., 1998;
Tester & Campbell, 2007: Voracek, Reimer, Ertl, & Dressler, 2006; Voracek
& Dressler. 2007). The diflerence in the lengths of the distal extents be-
tween index and ring fingers, relative to the middle fingertip, is smaller in fe-
males than in males, suggesting nearl) equal-length index and ring fingers in
females as compared to males with longer ring than index fingers.
The importance of the theory of sexually dimorphic 2D:4D digit ratio is
the supposed prenatal origin of this trait: high prenatal testosterone and lo^
estrogen (lour 2D:4D ratio) may be responsible for the male pattern, while
low prenatal testosterone and high estrogen may be responsible for the fe-
male pattern. Accordingly, Manning. et al. (1998) have shoxrn in adults that
the 2D:4D ratio is negatively correlated with serum testosterone concentra-
tions and positively correlated with serum estrogen concentrations, suggest-
ing that men with lour 2D:4D ratios would ha\e had more testosterone and
less estrogen prenatally than men with high ratios. These authors did not
clarify if they measured the free or total testosterone concentrations. On the
other hand, the 2D:3D ratio was positively correlated with serum estrogen
levels in \\-omen, suggesting that women with high digit ratios u~ouldhave
had more estrogen prenatal13 than women with low digit ratios.
It was argued that the above results in adults would reflect prenatal hor-
mone levels, since digit ratios are determined prenatally by about the 13th
week (Phelps, 1952; Garn, Burdi, Babler, & Stinson. 1975). If adult sex hor-
mone levels are correlated with phjsical traits such as digit ratios, then
another sex hormone-dependent trait, body height, should also be related to
digit ratios in adults. However, there are inconsistent reports on this rarely
studied subject. For instance. Manning, et nl. (1998) could not find any sig-
nificant relationship between height and digit ratios, similar to Fink, Neave,
and Manning (2003) and Neave, Laing, Fink, and Manning (2003). How-
ever, Tester and Campbell (2007) reported a significant negatir-e correlation
between height and digit ratio ( r = -.25, p < .05).
Distal fingertip extensions relative to the middle finger were measured
in the present study instead of the whole finger lengths, since there is a tiny
sex difference in the digit length ratio (usually 0.98 mm in males and 0.99
mm in females), about .25 standard deviations (see Honekopp. Bartholdt,
Beier, & Liebert, 2007). Such a small difference uould be vulnerable to
many factors and easily disappear from sample to sample depending upon
too many factors. For instance, there was no significant sex difference in
2D:dD digit ratios in 300 English adults (Manning, Barley, KTalton, Lewis-
Jones, Trivers, Singh, et nl., 2000). Similarly, there are indeed a number of
FINGERTIP EXTEKSIONS AND HORTTIONE LEVELS 5
other null findings in the scientific literature (see Putz, Gaulin, Sporter, &
hlcBurnley, 2004). Therefore, replication is desirable. Null results are gener-
ally not published, for example, an earlier attempt to study the sexual di-
morphism in 2D:4D ratios of some Turkish samples (Tan & Okuyan, un-
published observations). In contrast, Peters, et al. (2002), measuring distal
fingertip-extension patterns, found larger sex differences than had been
observed for digit ratios. For these reasons, the method of measuring the
finger extensions relative to middle fingertip was used in the present study.
Body height, another hormonally influenced and sexually dinlorphic physical
trait, as well as serum estradiol and free testosterone concentrations, were
studied in relation to fingertip extensions, to study the proposed hormonal
correlates of sexuallj7 dimorphic finger-length patterns considering the rela-
tion of adult sex hormone concentrations to prenatal sex hormone levels (see
Jamison, hleier, & Campbell, 1993). Folloxving these considerations, it was
expected that: ( I ) a greater sex difference urould be found using measure-
ments of fingertip extensions relathe to middle fingertip than has been
previously reported; ( 2 ) body height would be a significant predictor of fin-
gertip extensions; (3) lengths of fingertip extensions and 4D:2D extension
ratios would be significant predictors of adult sex hormone concentrations.
~~ETHOD
The participants (264 women, 214 men) were Turkish university stu-
dents urho voluntarily participated in the study. Ages ranged from 20 to 22
bears. The extensions of the index i2nd) and ring (4th) fingertips relative to
the middle fingertip were measured using the apparatus originally built by
George (1930) and rebuilt in Pvlichael Peters' laboratories (see Peters, et al.,
2002). The participants were asked to place their palms flat on a surface and
to bring the tip of the middle finger into gentle contact ~ i t ah fixed vertical
block. There were parallel sliders on the right and left sides. The assistant
moved these sliders until their vertical surfaces came into gentle contact with
the tips of the index and ring fingers, so that the extensions of the 2nd and
4th fingertips relative to the middle fingertip could be measured in 0.5-mm
steps. Using this method, the distances (extensions) between the tip of the
middle finger and the tips of the index and ring fingers can be accurately
measured. The reliabilities of measurements from the same investigator wcre
assessed using the intraclass correlation coefficient routine (ICCs, two-way
mixed effects model with absolute agreement definition) in SPSS Version
12. The ICCs (X=21) were found to be .94 and .99 for the 4D:2D exten-
sion ratios from the right and left hands, respectively (right hand, F,,=
27.07, p < .001; left hand, F,, = 129.3, p < .0001). Sex differences in fingertip
extension ratios were also assessed with effect size (q2),Body height was re-
corded in cm with 1-mm accuracy.
The fingertip extension ratio 4D:2D was analyzed in the present study
instead of the ratio 2D:ID in analysis of finger-length patterns, to make the
results more consistent with studies related to finger-length patterns. Peters,
Mackenzie, and Bryden (2002) have also used the fingertip extension ratio
4D:2D in their study related to fingertip measurements.
To assess the serum testosterone and estrogen concentrations, intrave-
nous blood samples were taken between 10:OO and 14:00, when the fingertip
extensions were measured. After collecting the blood sample, the blood mias
stored at -IO°C. Serum concentrations of free testosterone and estradiol were
measured by radioimmunoassay using commercial kits (Diagnostic Systems
Laboratories, Webster, TX, USA).
Index Finger ( 2 0 )
Sex diffeere?zces.-The mean index fingertip extensions relative to the
middle fingertips of the right and left hands were significantly greater in
males than in females (see Table 1). Sex had a significant main effect on the
dependent variables, right and left index fingertip extensions (F,,4,1 = 60.3 1,
p < .OOOI; q2= 20). The sex difference was more pronounced for the right
hand than the left hand, namely, the mean difference between the index fin-
gertip extensions of males and females was found to be 2.7 mm (SE=0.2)
for the right hand, and 1.5 mm (SE=O.3) for the left hand. The mean index
fingertip extension for the right hand was significantly greater in males than
TABLE I
EXTENSIONS
(MM) OF SECOND AYD FOURTH FINGERTIPS RELATIVE TO
MIDDLEFIUGFRTIPS ~214) AND F E M ~ L (n
I N 'CIA1F 5 ( t = E S= 264)
-
-
F~npertloExtensron Sex 11.1 SD F D rlz
Female 9.1
Male 11.8
Female 9.2
Male 8.9
Female 1.1
Male 0.8
Left Hand
2D Female 10.i
Male 12.1
Female 8.7
Male 9.3
Fernale 0.9
Male 0.8
-... -
A\iotr.-2D = index fingertip extension; 4D = ring fingertip extension; 4D:ZD = ratio of ring to
index fingertip extensions.
FINGERTIP EXTENSIONS AND HORMONE LEVELS 7
in females (F,,,,= 118.69, p < .OOOI; q 2 =.20), similar to the left hand for
which there was a smaller effect size (F,,,,=31.44, p < .0001; q 2 =.06). Since
there was a significant positive correlation between the index fingertip ex-
tensions and the body height (see Table Z), the ratios of the lingertip exten-
sons to body heights were used instead of the raw measurements. Using this
procedure yielded essentially similar results, showing significantly less extend-
ed index fingertips in females than in males (F,,,,~ 5 . 2 8 p. < .01; q2= .08).
However, the mean differences between males' and females' fingertip exten-
sions were almost equal for the right and left hands, 0.009 mm (SE= 0.003)
for the right hand and 0.009 m n ~(SE=O.O03) for the left hand. So the inore
pronounced sex difference in the right hand was due to the effect of body
height.
Estradzol and testosterone.-Serutn estradiol concentration showed a
negative correlation with the index fingertip extensions of the right and left
hands in women (see Table 3). This suggests that high serum estradiol levels
may be related to smaller index fingertip extensions from the right and left
hands of females (see Table I). On the other hand, serum estradiol concen-
trations had a positive correlat~onwith index fingertip extensions in men
(see Table 3).
In comparison to estradiol, serum testosterone levels were found to be
positively correlated with the index fingertip extensions of the right and left
hands of both women and men (see Table 3). Higher testosterone concen-
trations were associated with larger index fingertip extensions and lo\r tcstos-
terone with smaller fingertip extensions.
In the total sample (see Table 3), the serum estradiol concentration was
negatively correlated with the index fingertip extensions of the right and left
hands, while serum testosterone concentration positively correlated with the
index fingertip extensions of the right and left hands. That is, higher estra-
diol levels were associated with lower index fingertip extensions as in the
sample of women; lower estradiol levels were associated with greater index
fingertip extensions, as in the sample of men.
Rzng Fznger (40)
Sex dzffrences.-The fingertip extensions of the ring fingers for the
right and left hands mere not significantly correlated with body height, as
contrasted to the positive correlations for the index fingers (see Table 2).
Sex had a main effect on ring fingertip extensions (I;,-,,= 6.3 1, p < .005;
q 2 =.02), however, onl) for the left hand ( F,,,, = 6.03, p < .05; q2= .01) and
not for the right hand ( F ,,,,=2.45, p > .lo; q2= .00). Controlling for helght
changed these results: sex had a significant effect on the ring fingertip exten-
sion of the right hand (F,,, =3.94, p < .O5; q Z =.03), the estimated marginal
means being 9.4 mm (SE= 0.4) for females and 8.1 mm (SE= 0.3) for males.
Sex had no significant effect on the fingertip extensions of the left hand
(F,,,, =3.04, p > .Oj: q2= .03), the estimated marginal ineans being 10.4 mm
( S E = 0.45) for females and 9.3 mm ( S E = 0.35) for males. These results indi-
cate that there were different ring fingertip extension patterns in males and
females.
TABLE 2
PEARSON
<~ORREI..ATION
COEFFICIENTS
FORHEIGHIAND FINGERTIP ( i =~ 161)
EXTESSIOKS
--
---- ~ .- --
--
Trait Height -
-
Right Hand Left Hand
-- .- ~p
2D 4D 2D 4D
Height .31t .11 .1O+ .03
Right Hand
2D .33t -3Of .4lt .II
4D .11 -.jot .02 .26f
Left Hand
2D .30t .41i .02 -.26i-
4D .04 .11 ,261. -.26t
R H 4D:2D -. 01 -,rot .Sot -.19t .11
L H 4D:2D 19" -.16"' .U7 -.i/t --
,707
--... ..- - - -
Note.-2D = index fingertip extension; 4D = ring fingertip extension; 4D:2D = ratio of ring to
index fingertip extensions. "p< .05. t p < .01.