Sources of Knowledge
Sources of Knowledge
5.1 INTRODUCTION
Ateacher must recognize the child as a natural
learner as he/she possesses the
ability to gain knowledge through various activities in which he/ she is
with right from birth. Children interact with their external engaged
world and construct
knowledge by reacting to various phenomena and they derive meaning. It is
important to know what knowledge is and what are the different kinds of
knowledge. As an elementary school teacher, it is necessary for you to know
howchildren construct knowledge and the kinds of learning support that
need to
be provided to them.
In this unit, you will read how learners develop knowledge through various
sources
like social customs, traditions, life experiences, inductive deductive reasoning,
social science enquiry method and scientific method. An understanding of these
concepts will enable you to adopt appropriate pedagogic practices that will
facilitate generation of knowledge by children.
5.2 OBJECTIVES
After reading this unit, you should be able to:
explain the meaning and concept of knowledge;
5
Pedagogie Practieex at
Elementary Levt
classify various forms of knowlcdgc with suitable cxamples;
examine relationship between knowledge and information;
explainthe process of constructionof knowledge;
differentiate between inductive and deductive method of reasoning with
cxamples;
discuss the scientific method of cnguiry for knowledge generation; and
describe the social inquiry approuch as a source of developing knowledge.
Kinds of knowledge
Knowledge is generally understood as being propositional. Aproposition is a
statement which conveys truth. This implies that the words or concepts which
constitute the sentences have to be meaningful. Sentences that assert and express
something are propositions. For example, all three sides of an equilateral triangle
are equal or birds have wings and so on. A proposition is made up of several
concepts, which together must constitute a meaningful statement. Aproposition
may be a fact, or a theory, or a law, a hypothesis, or assumption, or an inference,
etc. As in the first proposition, the concepts are - equilateral triangle has equal
sides. These concepts together in the statement create a meaningful statement,
which is a fact. In order to understand the proposition the concepts should be
known. In the earlier example, learners must have prior knowledge of the concept
equilateral triangle before they are taught the new proposition. Propositional
6
knowledge, thus, covers awide range of area of study. Propositional knowledge
is eNDISNd by adeclarative statement. Ii describes a fact or states of affairs, for Acquisition of Knowledge
CNanple, 'Cows are mammals' or '5+5=|0', And Methods of Inquiry
Iis generally agreed that we can have knowledge of something that is true and
it ix widely accepted that justified true belief is knowledge. For example, the sun
riNes in the cast, is abelief arrived at by daily observation for millions of years by
people (Hetherington, 2012).
So we must know what exactly constitutes propositional knowledge or knowledge.
We should knowtheconditions that determine knowing something.
Some of these conditions are discussed here:
Information is the meaning ascribed to various sensory stimuli (i.e. the empirical
perception). Information has to be made useful by ascertaining a set of patterns
contained in them. Also if this information is memorized, one accumulates
knowledge about these concepts. However, mere memorization of information
will not lead to further knowledge. The patterns need to be understood, analyzed
and integrated to expand the body of knowledge. Understanding and wisdom
imply cognitive ability, reasoning and analytical skills to apply the acquired
knowledge to solve problem situations. The wikipedia describes these concepts
through the Data, Information, Knowledge and Wisdom Model (DIKW Model)
by arranging them in ahierarchical manner. Typically information is defined in
terms of data, knowledge in terms of information and wisdom in terms of
knowledge (htp://www.systems-thinking org/dikw/dikw.htm).
Knowledge consists of facts, beliefs, truths, judgments, methodologies, know
how that is integrated over time to handle various barriers and situations. These
concepts have been discussed in the earlier section 5.2.
You willnow read how children expand their domain of knowledge by relating
their existing knowledge with the external world. This way they construct
knowledge and acquire learning experiences.
Activity 2
Lesson for Class 4 (ppl25-126, EVS, CIass IV, NCERT, 2007)
Ask the students to talk to a vegetable seller in their area. Give them a set of
questions to facilitate their survey about the life and work of the vegetable
sellers and ask them to preparea report. The questions can be;
1) What is his/her name?
2) How many people are there in hisher home? How
many are children?
3) What are the names of the children? How old are
they?
4) Whoamong the family members help in selling
vegetables?
5) Who stays with the vegetable cart/sit in the
shop?
6) What vegetables do they sell?
7) What time do they start work? For how
manyhours in a day do they work?
8) Ask them about any three vegetables that
they sell and fill this table:
Name of the vegetable
Price of the vegetable
Where does it come from?
What quantity of vegetable do they buy at one
time?
In which month do you usually get
this vegetable?
The reports prepared by the
Such a survey task will makechildren can be discussed in groups in the class.
children sensitive to the
disadvantaged people in the community. It will give lives of the poor and
the life and work of these them an understanding of
people.
11
Pedagogic Practices at
Elementary Level 5.5.1 Context of Learning
derive meaning through
AS Stated above, children construct knowledge and knowledge enables the
nteractions with their environment. Development of
1naividual to connect with the external world. It is important that whatever
own
cOncepts children learn, they should be able to relate these to their
Cxperiences. The learner should know what it means to know something and
now this knowledge is to be used. For example, when children enter class I, they
Dring with them a host of experiences - the flora and fauna they see, the weather
Patterns and seasons they enjoy, the gardens they visit and so on. But the classroom
interactions seldom provide them the opportunity to share and narrate these
experiences. For example in Class I, to develop the concepts of living and non
Iiving, a visit to the local park may be organized. Subsequently, children may be
asked to write names of ten living and ten non-living things, which they may
have seen during that visit, This would foster the ability to reflect in the children
and enable development of new knowledge based on their experiences.
Local context should be included in classroom learning. Children from coastal
areas willbe able to talk about shells, pebbles, fishes, seashores,whereas those
Trom hilly areas may narrate their experiences of birds, trees, rocks, stones. This
approach needs to be integrated in the teaching learning process instead of the
usual classroom practice in which children are given a list of words or pictures
from which they are to identify the living and non-living things.
Let us understand another example, lessons on pollution should be replete with
activities that engage children in examining the natural environment around them.
They could comment on the sources of air and water pollution as they experience
it in their daily lives. The knowledge of pollution could raise concerns about the
safety and health of human beings and develop an understanding of methods of
conservation and protection of the natural environment, while designing lessons
in social studies and language at the elementary the values enshrined the
constitution should be borne in mind. Pedagogically and ethically sound choices
of content and corresponding learning experiences should be designed so as to
introduce children to the diversities and complexities of the natural world.
Children should be able to compare life in different places with their local
communities and bring out the similarities and differences. Apart from the physical
and natural environment the local context also implies the socio -cultural world.
The Indian communities are arich storehouse of cultural knowledge. Experiences
in the socio-cultural world of the child should be heard and used in the classroom.
Local stories, fables, folklore, riddles, jokes, art, etc. are a potential source of
knowledge generation. Children belong to different communities,bring with
them rich histories and traditions that can enrich learning and knowledge in
schools. Children need to understand the plurality of society and diverse lifestyles
which are reflected in text books. As part of their social science lessons., they can
be made tointeract with the members of local self governing bodies like gram
panchayats or zila parishads. They can understand how decentralization addresses
local problem and civic issues more efficiently and effectively. Lessons can be
organized around songs and poems common sung in a particular region. This
will bring them closer to their community arts, folk music, traditions. (NCF
2005)
12
Activity 3 Acquisition of Knowledge
and Methods of Inquiry
Talk to children about how they decorate their houses.
out the different timnes and occasions and the locally This will also bring
which they use to decorate their houses. You can available materials
also discuss how
decorations vary depending on the festival or occasion. Ask them to bring
pictures, photographs depicting different areas ofhouses done up in a variety
of ways. The discussion can be based on some of these
questions:
1) Is there any specialway in which you decorate your
house?
2) When do you do so?
3) How do you decorate the house?
4) Discuss in groups when and how they decorate their houses.
5) Make a list of things with which you decorate your house.
(Source: pp35, Looking Around, Environmental Studies, Textbook for Class 3, NCERT, 2006).
There is need to build a rapport with the children so that they exprss themselves
freely and shed inhibitions about their ways of life. Such interactions not only
expand their knowledge and understanding about lives of people in other
communities and regions but also foster tolerance and respect for others in the
group.
Teachers need to have in-depth knowledge of the subject and also the ability to
explore the concepts in a variety of ways. For example, the concept of density
can be taught by relating with the concepts of visibility of the tip of icebergs, ice
berg floating on water or comparison between a needles sinking in water while
ships float. Teachers should facilitate learning of new concepts and knowledge
acquisition through problem solving approach. The learners should experience
the idea, artifact, first and then explanations, descriptions should be provided. A
changed classroom approach is required to enable the learner to construct
knowledge. The learner should be given the freedom to question the teachers,
discuss and debates the ideas of others in the group, design experiments, formulate
hypotheses, discuss results and compare findings with those of others. Students
validate their own ideas and beliefs and are able to interpret and relate to ideas
presented in the text. Learners develop the habit of self-directed learning and
also take responsibility of their learning.
14
Acquisition of Knowledge
and Methods of Inquiry
5) Tllustrate how learners can construct knowledge with a topic from the
subject you teach at the elementary level.
16
Acquisition of Knowledge
Aetivity4 and Methods of Inquiry
halesson for Class 3 students on postalcommunication, you can ask the
hildyn to discuss with elders at home on how letters were delivered in old
times, For example, the elders may tell their children that messengers were
carrving messages ofkings and subjects to far-off places. Similarly, trained
pigeons were used to send letters to distant places. Althoughchildren are
not exposed to these experiences, they tend to believe information us true
because they get them from the elders who are considered us authorities.
5.6.3 Customs and Traditions
Ourcustoms and traditions are arich source of knowledge. Many communities
in India are a storehouse of knowledge. All of us are used to certain patterns of
behaviors inour daily lives which are customary. For example, the food we eat,
dresses we wear, and cultural practices we adopt, and so on. All these are accepted
practices and serve as guides for our future behaviors. This is true especially in
school settings where customary and traditional practices are relied on. Children
belonging to diverse and heterogeneous communities bring in the class room a
varied set of experiences. Teachers can tap this rich resource of knowledge by
organizing group work or project studies based on local knowledge and practice.
For example, teachers can engage children in discussions about how their families
celebrate different festivals, or about different kinds of food habits in their
communities. However, one must exercise caution because all customary and
traditional practices may not hold true or be useful in the present context. Some
erroneous practices need to be discouraged and even rejected.
ACTIVITY 5
Allthe premises in this case are true but the conclusion does not follow
from the premises. Hence, to know that a conclusion is true the premise
should be true and the argument should be valid. In deductive argument the
conclusion is often contained within the premises.
b) Inductive reasoning where the premises provide the probable evidence to
Support the conclusion but not completely. Francis Bacon argued against the
practice of syllogistic (deductive) reasoning which derived conclusions from
authoritative premises. He believed that researchers should collect their own
data after careful observations and base their conclusion on this data. The
conclusion drawn in the process of inductive reasoning are not certain but
probable. The examples that follow will illustrate this:
1) Pigeon 1is grey.
Pigeon 2 is grey.
Pigeon 3is grey.
(Ten thousand and more pigeons)
Therefore, all pigeons are grey.
2) Gold is malleable and ductile.
Silver is malleable and ductile.
but the
In the first example, even though the ten thousand premises may be true
is not certain
next pigeon we come across may be white. Hence the conclusion
even though the premises are true. In the second example, the conclusion is also
not certain as there may be metals which are not malleable and ductile. The truth
is established based on earlier evidence or observation. Inductive arguments are
based on laws of nature, which are formulated on the basis of certain recurring
phenomena with uniformity. For example, it is an established law that:
1) all living things reproduce,
2) fish is an aquatic animal,
3) ice melts on heating.
We come across many such uniform patterns of occurrences based on which we
arrive at inductive arguments. In inductive reasoning, the conclusion is only
probable and not certain. (1GNOU, 2007).
The difference between deductive and inductive reasoning depends on the strength
of evidence to the premises, which the author believes, to provide for the
conclusion. The difference does not depend on the content of the subject matter
19
I'vdagogie ractices at
Klementary level of the argument. Much depends on the
author intends that the premises provide strength
of the justification, which the
for the
argumentmay cmcrge wherein the premises thoughconclusion. Alogically invalid
true, may provide no support
for the conclusion. Consider the example:
Allodd numbers are
Alleven numbers are
integers.
integers.
Therefore, allodd numbers are
even numbers.
lf the author argues that the premises are
then the argument true and thus the
becomes deductive, conclusion is true,
although a bad deductive
Limitations of inductive reasoning are that it too does not by argument.
toadvancement
of knowledge. The itself lead to
as many inherent
instances as can be observed. limitation is that it can be applied only
5.6.5 Scientific Method
The scientific method of
(ht p:/ www.iep.utm.
(Inductive-Deductive Method)
edu/ded-ind/)
He believed that acquiring knowledge was propounded by
The synthesis of investigators should arrive at conclusions by Francis Bacon.
in the scientific methods of reasoning and observations observing facts.
were combined
method method of generating to result
to Mouly
thus combines inductive and
(1978), the scientific
knowledge.(1GNOU,
deductive methods
2007).
of reasoning. Scientific
in which the
to their investigator first method consists of "a back and forth According
operates inductively from movement
implications, in order to check
their observation to hypotheses
compatibility with accepted knowledge". validity from the standpoint of
Therefore, scientific method aims at
arrived at discovering facts. But these facts have to be
of gaining through process of reflective thinking and enquiry.
a
it strives toknowledge from experience, authority,
attain knowledge customs,
Unlike methods
traditions,
through systematic process of folk-lore,
investigation. The basic steps involved in scientific enquiry and
1) method are:
experiencing a difficulty or aproblem situation,
2)defining the problem - the problem or
facts is defined in concrete
terms,
difficulty based on observation of
3) formulating
hypotheses or
solutions to the problem, intelligent guesses that are made about the probable
4) collecting
evidences or data to test the probable solutions or
These are collected through
observation, hypotheses.
5) experimentation
verifying testing the hypotheses: Evidences
or
or testing,
discard the hypotheses. are collected to confirm or
Based on these steps one can know
whether the knowledge
not. Hypotheses, based on
inductive and deductive methods,arrived
at is true or
lead to
consequences of the hypotheses. The hypotheses that are inconsistentthewithlogical
are removed. By combining both facts
inductive and deductive one arrives at reliable
knowledge. scientific method can be used to teach all
The
curriculum (Rao, Bapat, 2006) subjects in the
Let us take an example from Science at the
20
elementary level.
Aeauisstion of Knowledge
Experiment: Physieal Properties of Naturally Oceurring Acids and Methods of Inquiry
Material needed -Citrus and non- citrus fruits and vegetables (Lemon, armla,
banana, orange, grapes,cte.), test tube, blue litmus papcr, knife, sp00n and plate.
Procedure - Ask the students to sit in acircle. Display the fruits and vegetables.
Tell them to identify the citrus and non-citrus fruits,Cut thecitrus fruits and ask
the students to taste them. Squccze the juice of lemon into atest tube. Take some
juice and dip blue litmus papcr in the iuice. Instruct the students to observe the
change in color. Then ask the following questions:
Questions -
1) Which fruits taste sour?
2) Which fruits do not taste sour?
3) Why do the fruits taste sour?
4) What color does the blue litmus change to when dipped in lime juice?
Investigatory Questions
What kind of acids do some fruits contain?
What are the physical properties of naturally occurring acids'?
Conclusion
contain naturally
You will help the students to consolidate that citrus fruits
of
occurring acids,like citric acid, ascorbic acid and so on. Physicaltoproperties
red. (DEP
litmus
these acids are that they taste sour and turn blue color of
SSA, IGNOU, 2010)
Examine another example from English which employs the Scientific method.
Lesson: Idioms relating to body parts. For example:
1) He's got a finger in every pie.
2) Get it off my chest.
3) Had to pay through my nose.
4) Go to hand it to her.
Method
Ask the children to collect 20 idioms relating to body parts.
Next, look up the dictionary and find out the meaning of these idioms.
Write astory using these idioms.
This project should be an individual or group activity. Abilities to be developed:
creative thinking
Skills to be developed: writing (language skills)
Therefore, scientific method is being increasingly used in the classroom involving
statement of questions to be investigated, formulating tentative solutions or
hypotheses, suggesting the experiment, conducting the experiment, recording
observations, analyzing the data, generalizing and drawing conclusions. It is not
only useful as a laboratory method to understand scientific phenomena, but also
in finding answers and solutions to social phenomena (Rao, Bapat, 2006).
21
Pedagogie Practices t
Elementary Levet Check Your Progress item.
answers in the space provided after cach
Notes: a) Writey your
the end of the Unit.
Compare your answers with those given at
D)
acquisition.
6) Write down the steps of scientific method of knowledge
7) Select a topic from the subject you teach. Describe how you will apply
the scientific method of inquiry to provide learning experiences to
children in your class. Discuss the skills and concepts you will develop
through this approach.
5.9
REFERENCES/ SUGGESTED READINGS
Baehr, J.S., (2006). APriori and A
Philosophy posteriori. Internet Encyclopedia of
(http:/ www.
DEP-SSA, IGNOU iep.utm.edu/apriori/), accessed
(2010). Teaching of Science at Upper
on 02-05-2012
New Delhi: IGNOU Primary Level,
Harlen, W. and Elstgeest, J (1997).UNESCO
the Primary School, NBT, New Source Book for Science in
Delhi.
Classes 1 to 5, Environmental Studies,
In Source Book on
Assessment for
NCERT, 2008
Hetherington, S.(2012). Knowledge, Internet Encyclopedia of
(http://www.iep.utm.edu/knowledge), accessed on 03-05-2012 Philosophy
IGNOU(2007). Unit 5,
in Education (Block-2), Concept
and
Nature of Knowledge. In Knowledge
(MES -012, Education Nature and Purposes), New
Delhi: IGNOU
IGNOU (2007). Unit 2,Knowledge Generation:
In Perspective of Historical Perspective-1.
New Delhi: IGNOU Knowledge(Block-1), (MES -016, Educational Research),
Joyce, B.R. Weil, M. (1986). Jurisprudential Inquiry
Teaching, 3rd edn, Boston MA: Allyn and Bacon Model, in Models of
Kaushal, S. (2006). Social Inquiry Approach. In Sharma,
S.(Ed)
Constructivist Approaches to Teaching and Learning, Handbook for Teachers
of Secondary stage, NCERT: New Delhi
NCERT (2006). Looking Around, Environmental Studies, Textbook for
Class 3, New Delhi: NCERT.
Massailas, Byron. G. and Cox:, C. Benjamin (1966). Inquiry in the Social
Studies, New York: McGraw Hill.
Mouly, George J.(1978). Educational Research. In IGNOU(2011), Unit 1,
Methods of Acquiring Knowledge in Educational Research (Block-1), (MES
26 054, Methodology of Educational Research), New Delhi: SOE, IGNOU
NCERT, (2005). NationalCurriculum Framework, Nw Delhi: NCERT Acquisition of Knowledge
and Methods of Inquiry
Rao, M. and Bapat, B.P. (2006). Investigatory Approach.In Sharma, S. (Ea)
Constructivist Approaches to Teaching and Learning, Handbook for Teachers
of Secondary stage, New Delhi: NCERT
Russell, B.,(1992). Human Knowledge. Its Scope and Limits, London:
Routledge.
Scheffler, I..(1999). Epistemology and Education. In Mc Cormick, Rand
Paechter, C. (Eds). Learning and Knowledge. London: Sage.
Sharma, S. (2006).Constructivism, In Sharma, S.(Ed.) (2006): Constructivist
Approaches to Teaching and Learning, Handbook for Teachers of Secondery
Stage, New Delhi: NCERT
NCERT (2008). Source Book on Assessment for Classes I toV,
Environmental Studies, NCERT: New Delhi
Truncellito, D. A..( 2007). Epistemology, Internet Encyclopedia of
Philosophy (http://www.iep.utm.edu/epistemo), accessed on 02-05-2012
Web Resources (Accessed on 23-06-2012)
http://www.knowledgebase-script.com/demolarticle-914.html
http:/len.wikipedia.org/wiki/DIKW
htp://www.diferencebetween.netanguage/difference-between-knowledge-and
wisdom/
http://www.systems-thinking.org/dikw/dikw.htm
http://cdn.ttgtmedia.com/searchDataManagement/downloads/
Making_sense_of_data_and_information.pdf
http://www.success.co.il/is/zins_definitions dik.Pdf
http://www.cse.ust.hk/-dekai/600G/notes/KM_Slides_Ch02.pdf
htp://www.personal.psu.edu/glh10/istl10/topic/topic02/topic02_02.html
5.10 ANSWERS TO CHECK YOUR PROGRESS
1) Propositional Knowledge is the knowledge which conveys truth. It is
conveyed through words, terms or concepts contained in sentences which
are meaningful.
2) The two prerequisites of knowledge are that the proposition or sentence
asserting something must consist of true facts and beliefs. The other
requirement is that evidence or reason are required to believe that proposition.
3) Apriori knowledge is that which can be arrived at on
the basis of reason and
logic. It does not require experience to validate its truth.
Aposteriori knowledge is based on empirical
at through a scientific process of evidence and truth is arrived
observation
and verification.
4) The main features of
constructivist method of knowledge acquisition are:
i) learning is an active meaning making process,
27