AP Lang 2020 Practice 2 PDF
AP Lang 2020 Practice 2 PDF
and Composition
Practice Exam #2
and Notes
For the
Spring 2020
Exam
© 2020 College Board. College Board, Advanced Placement, AP,
AP, AP
AP Central,
Central, and
and the acorn logo are registered
registered
trademarks of College Board.
Visit College Board on the web: collegeboard.org.
collegeboard.org.
I. Practice Exam
Exam Content and Format. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
Administering the Practice Exam. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
Answer Sheet for Multiple-Choice Section. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
AP® English Language and Composition Practice Exam . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
You have 1 hour for this part. Open your Section I booklet and begin.
You may now open the Section II booklet and begin the reading period.
Note Start Time ________. Note Stop Time ________. After 40 minutes, say:
Note Start Time ________. Note Stop Time ________. After 40 minutes, say:
Collect a Section II booklet from each student and check that each student wrote
his or her answers on the lined pages corresponding to each question. Then say:
The exam is over. You are now dismissed.
Directions: This part consists of selections from nonfiction works and questions on their rhetorical situation, claims
and evidence, reasoning and organization, and style. After reading each passage, choose the best answer to each
question and then enter the letter in the corresponding space on the answer sheet.
Note: Pay particular attention to the requirements of questions that contain the words NOT, LEAST, or EXCEPT.
Questions 1 - 12. Read the following passage one anyway. Journal writing helps you to be more
carefully before you choose your answers. observant of your world, and a journal is a good place
to store story ideas for later projects.
(This passage is excerpted from an essay published Revise your writing until it’s as good as you can
by a science fiction writer in the late twentieth make it. All the reading, the writing, and the classes
century.) should help you do this. Check your writing, your
research (never neglect your research), and the
Take classes and go to writers’ workshops. Writing physical appearance of your manuscript. Let nothing
is communication. You need other people to let you substandard slip through. If you notice something that
know whether you’re communicating what you think needs fixing, fix it, no excuses. There will be plenty
you are and whether you’re doing it in ways that are that’s wrong that you won’t catch. Don’t make the
not only accessible and entertaining, but as mistake of ignoring flaws that are obvious to you.
compelling as you can make them. In other words, The moment you find yourself saying, “This doesn’t
you need to know that you’re telling a good story. You matter. It’s good enough.” Stop. Go back. Fix the
want to be the writer who keeps readers up late at flaw. Make a habit of doing your best.
night, not the one who drives them off to watch Submit your work for publication. First research
television. Workshops and classes are rented the markets that interest you. Seek out and study the
readers—rented audiences—for your work. Learn books or magazines of publishers to whom you want
from the comments, questions, and suggestions of to sell. Then submit your work. If the idea of doing
both the teacher and the class. These relative this scares you, fine. Go ahead and be afraid. But
strangers are more likely to tell you the truth about send your work out anyway. If it’s rejected, send it
your work than are your friends and family who may out again, and again. Rejections are painful, but
not want to hurt or offend you. One tiresome truth inevitable. They’re every writer’s rite of passage.
they might tell you, for instance, is that you need to Don’t give up on a piece of work that you can’t sell.
take a grammar class. If they say this, listen. Take the You may be able to sell it later to new publications or
class. Vocabulary and grammar are your primary to new editors of old publications. At worst, you
tools. They’re most effectively used, even most should be able to learn from your rejected work. You
effectively abused, by people who understand them. may even be able to use all or part of it in a new
No computer program, no friend or employee can take work. One way or another, writers can use, or at least
the place of a sound knowledge of your tools. learn from, everything.
Write. Write every day. Write whether you feel Here are some potential impediments for you to
like writing or not. Choose a time of day. Perhaps forget about:
you can get up an hour earlier, stay up an hour later, First forget inspiration. Habit is more dependable.
give up an hour of recreation, or even give up your Habit will sustain you whether you’re inspired or not.
lunch hour. If you can’t think of anything in your Habit will help you finish and polish your stories.
chosen genre, keep a journal. You should be keeping Inspiration won’t. Habit is persistence in practice.
(This passage is excerpted from an essay published The moment you find yourself saying, “This doesn’t
by a science fiction writer in the late twentieth matter. It’s good enough.” Stop. Go back. Fix the
century.) flaw. Make a habit of doing your best.
Submit your work for publication. First research
Take classes and go to writers’ workshops. Writing the markets that interest you. Seek out and study the
is communication. You need other people to let you books or magazines of publishers to whom you want
know whether you’re communicating what you think to sell. Then submit your work. If the idea of doing
you are and whether you’re doing it in ways that are this scares you, fine. Go ahead and be afraid. But
not only accessible and entertaining, but as send your work out anyway. If it’s rejected, send it
compelling as you can make them. In other words, out again, and again. Rejections are painful, but
you need to know that you’re telling a good story. You inevitable. They’re every writer’s rite of passage.
want to be the writer who keeps readers up late at Don’t give up on a piece of work that you can’t sell.
night, not the one who drives them off to watch You may be able to sell it later to new publications or
television. Workshops and classes are rented to new editors of old publications. At worst, you
readers—rented audiences—for your work. Learn should be able to learn from your rejected work. You
from the comments, questions, and suggestions of may even be able to use all or part of it in a new
both the teacher and the class. These relative work. One way or another, writers can use, or at least
strangers are more likely to tell you the truth about learn from, everything.
your work than are your friends and family who may Here are some potential impediments for you to
not want to hurt or offend you. One tiresome truth forget about:
they might tell you, for instance, is that you need to First forget inspiration. Habit is more dependable.
take a grammar class. If they say this, listen. Take the Habit will sustain you whether you’re inspired or not.
class. Vocabulary and grammar are your primary Habit will help you finish and polish your stories.
tools. They’re most effectively used, even most Inspiration won’t. Habit is persistence in practice.
effectively abused, by people who understand them. Forget talent. If you have it, fine. Use it. If you
No computer program, no friend or employee can take don’t have it, it doesn’t matter. As habit is more
the place of a sound knowledge of your tools. dependable than inspiration, continued learning is
Write. Write every day. Write whether you feel more dependable than talent. Never let pride or
like writing or not. Choose a time of day. Perhaps laziness prevent you from learning, improving your
you can get up an hour earlier, stay up an hour later, work, changing its direction when necessary.
give up an hour of recreation, or even give up your Persistence is essential to any writer—the persistence
lunch hour. If you can’t think of anything in your to finish your work, to keep writing in spite of
chosen genre, keep a journal. You should be keeping rejection, to keep reading, studying, submitting work
one anyway. Journal writing helps you to be more for sale. But stubbornness, the refusal to change
observant of your world, and a journal is a good place unproductive behavior or to revise unsalable work can
to store story ideas for later projects. be lethal to your writing hopes.
Revise your writing until it’s as good as you can Finally, don’t worry about imagination. You have
make it. All the reading, the writing, and the classes all the imagination you need, and all the reading,
should help you do this. Check your writing, your journal writing, and learning you will be doing will
research (never neglect your research), and the stimulate it. Play with your ideas. Have fun with
physical appearance of your manuscript. Let nothing them. Don’t worry about being silly or outrageous or
substandard slip through. If you notice something that wrong. So much of writing is fun. It’s first letting
needs fixing, fix it, no excuses. There will be plenty your interests and your imagination take you
that’s wrong that you won’t catch. Don’t make the anywhere at all. Once you’re able to do that, you’ll
mistake of ignoring flaws that are obvious to you. have more ideas than you can use.
(This passage is excerpted from an essay published The moment you find yourself saying, “This doesn’t
by a science fiction writer in the late twentieth matter. It’s good enough.” Stop. Go back. Fix the
century.) flaw. Make a habit of doing your best.
Submit your work for publication. First research
Take classes and go to writers’ workshops. Writing the markets that interest you. Seek out and study the
is communication. You need other people to let you books or magazines of publishers to whom you want
know whether you’re communicating what you think to sell. Then submit your work. If the idea of doing
you are and whether you’re doing it in ways that are this scares you, fine. Go ahead and be afraid. But
not only accessible and entertaining, but as send your work out anyway. If it’s rejected, send it
compelling as you can make them. In other words, out again, and again. Rejections are painful, but
you need to know that you’re telling a good story. You inevitable. They’re every writer’s rite of passage.
want to be the writer who keeps readers up late at Don’t give up on a piece of work that you can’t sell.
night, not the one who drives them off to watch You may be able to sell it later to new publications or
television. Workshops and classes are rented to new editors of old publications. At worst, you
readers—rented audiences—for your work. Learn should be able to learn from your rejected work. You
from the comments, questions, and suggestions of may even be able to use all or part of it in a new
both the teacher and the class. These relative work. One way or another, writers can use, or at least
strangers are more likely to tell you the truth about learn from, everything.
your work than are your friends and family who may Here are some potential impediments for you to
not want to hurt or offend you. One tiresome truth forget about:
they might tell you, for instance, is that you need to First forget inspiration. Habit is more dependable.
take a grammar class. If they say this, listen. Take the Habit will sustain you whether you’re inspired or not.
class. Vocabulary and grammar are your primary Habit will help you finish and polish your stories.
tools. They’re most effectively used, even most Inspiration won’t. Habit is persistence in practice.
effectively abused, by people who understand them. Forget talent. If you have it, fine. Use it. If you
No computer program, no friend or employee can take don’t have it, it doesn’t matter. As habit is more
the place of a sound knowledge of your tools. dependable than inspiration, continued learning is
Write. Write every day. Write whether you feel more dependable than talent. Never let pride or
like writing or not. Choose a time of day. Perhaps laziness prevent you from learning, improving your
you can get up an hour earlier, stay up an hour later, work, changing its direction when necessary.
give up an hour of recreation, or even give up your Persistence is essential to any writer—the persistence
lunch hour. If you can’t think of anything in your to finish your work, to keep writing in spite of
chosen genre, keep a journal. You should be keeping rejection, to keep reading, studying, submitting work
one anyway. Journal writing helps you to be more for sale. But stubbornness, the refusal to change
observant of your world, and a journal is a good place unproductive behavior or to revise unsalable work can
to store story ideas for later projects. be lethal to your writing hopes.
Revise your writing until it’s as good as you can Finally, don’t worry about imagination. You have
make it. All the reading, the writing, and the classes all the imagination you need, and all the reading,
should help you do this. Check your writing, your journal writing, and learning you will be doing will
research (never neglect your research), and the stimulate it. Play with your ideas. Have fun with
physical appearance of your manuscript. Let nothing them. Don’t worry about being silly or outrageous or
substandard slip through. If you notice something that wrong. So much of writing is fun. It’s first letting
needs fixing, fix it, no excuses. There will be plenty your interests and your imagination take you
that’s wrong that you won’t catch. Don’t make the anywhere at all. Once you’re able to do that, you’ll
mistake of ignoring flaws that are obvious to you. have more ideas than you can use.
(The following passage is excerpted from the preface setbacks. Various constituencies of the comparatively
of a book published in 2008 by a geography prosperous global core are walling off their affluent
professor.) realms from intrusion by poorer globals, hardening a
division between core and periphery that exacerbates
Numerous books and articles published in recent contrasts and stokes conflicts. The near-global
years argue, explicitly as well as implicitly, that the diffusion of various forms of English as a first or
human world today is so mobile, so interconnected, second language is promoting a cultural convergence,
and so integrative that it is, in one prominent and but the radicalization of religions has the opposite
much-repeated assessment, “flat.” Ancient and effect. The distribution of health and well-being
durable obstacles are no more, interaction is global, shows troubling signs of inequity and reversal.
free trade rules the globe, migration is ubiquitous, 1 Because people continue to congregate in places of
and the flow of ideas (and money and jobs) is so high environmental risk, especially in the crowded
pervasive that geography, in the perspective of more periphery, hundreds of millions find themselves in
than one observer, “is history.” The notion that place continuing jeopardy (as the 2004 tsunami, 4 in the
continues to play a key role in shaping humanity’s absence of coordinated warning systems, tragically
still-variegated mosaic is seen as obsolete, even confirmed). Inevitably, places of costly historic and
offensive and deterministic. Choice, not constraint, is current conflict take their toll as the “international
the mantra 2 of the new flat-world proponents. Join community” stands by without effective intervention,
the “forces of flattening” and you will enjoy the another form of jeopardy that afflicts the destinies of
benefits. Don’t, and you will fall off the edge. The millions. And males and females in the same locales
option is yours. have widely varying experiences, their destinies
But is it? From the vantage point of a high-floor diverging in sometimes agonizing ways. Even in the
room in the Shanghai Hyatt, the Mumbai Oberoi, or world’s cities, where the “rising tide lifts all boats”
the Dubai Hilton, 3 or from a business-class window promise of globalization should be especially evident,
seat on Singapore Airlines, the world seems flat power creates a high-relief topography of privilege
indeed. Millions of world-flatteners move every day and privation. Nor is the world’s divisive political
from hotel lobby to airport limo to first-class lounge, stockade 5 likely to be flattened anytime soon. Even
laptop in hand, uploading, outsourcing, offshoring as as states try to join in unions and associations, their
they travel, adjusting the air conditioning as they go. provinces and regions nurture nationalisms working
They are changing the world, these modern nomads, the other way. The power of place still holds the vast
and they are, in many ways, improving it—depending majority of us in its thrall.
of course on one’s definition of progress. But are they Of course, the question is not whether the world is
invariably agents of access and integration? Are they flat. Thomas Friedman, who coined the phrase,
lowering the barriers to participation or raising the concedes that he realizes “that the world is not flat.
stakes against it? Have their influence and impact Don’t worry, I know . . . I have engaged in literary
overpowered the imperatives of place, so that their license in titling [my] book to draw attention . . . .” It
very mobility symbolizes a confirmed irrelevance of is the process of “flattening” on which Friedman
location? wants to focus through his provocative title, “the
Not yet. The Earth, physically as well as culturally, single most important trend in the world today,” that is
still is very rough terrain, and in crucial ways its at issue. And in certain respects the global playing
regional compartments continue to trap billions in field is leveling, but in other ways the reverse appears
circumstances that spell disadvantage. The power of to be true. Notions of a flat world raise expectations
place and the fate of people are linked by many of growing access and increasing opportunity that are
strands ranging from physical area and natural mantras of globalization but are all too often at
environment to durable culture and local tradition. variance with reality. Powerful forces, natural as well
This book, therefore, views a world in which progress as human, slow the flattening process in a contest that
toward convergence is countered by stagnation, even will determine the future of the planet.
1
widespread
2
slogan
3
luxury hotels
4
In December 2004, a series of immense ocean waves hit the coasts of
several South and Southeast Asian countries, causing catastrophic
destruction in the region.
5
enclosure
(A) Opportunities that disproportionately (A) indicate that the author is quoting an
benefit affluent communities established source rather than making a
(B) Frequent conflict among groups with subjective claim
different cultural values (B) signal a skeptical tone that reflects the
(C) Dangers that disproportionately affect author’s doubts about the existence of
certain communities such a community
(D) Overcrowding that exacerbates public (C) underline how specifically the term
health problems “international community” is being
defined
(E) Environmental degradation that makes
such areas nearly uninhabitable (D) emphasize the need for global cooperation
when effective intervention is required
(E) protect the author from allegations that he
19. In the eighth sentence of the third paragraph, the is claiming credit for a phrase coined by
author mentions “the absence of coordinated others
warning systems” to amplify his point about the
(A) convergence of a type of living experience 21. In the final sentence of the third paragraph (“The
(B) prohibitive costs of global intervention power of place . . . thrall”), which of the
programs following best describes the effect of removing
the words “the vast majority of”?
(C) depopulation of locations at high
environmental risk
(A) The author’s claim would become logically
(D) opposition expressed toward regional inconsistent.
nationalism
(B) The author’s claim would be obscured by
(E) the hazards of inhabiting certain the introduction of ambiguity.
geographical areas
(C) The author’s claim would lose its popular
appeal.
(D) The author’s claim would be narrowed by
its limitation to a smaller group.
(E) The author’s claim would be broadened by
the removal of a qualification.
(The following passage is excerpted from the preface setbacks. Various constituencies of the comparatively
of a book published in 2008 by a geography prosperous global core are walling off their affluent
professor.) realms from intrusion by poorer globals, hardening a
division between core and periphery that exacerbates
Numerous books and articles published in recent contrasts and stokes conflicts. The near-global
years argue, explicitly as well as implicitly, that the diffusion of various forms of English as a first or
human world today is so mobile, so interconnected, second language is promoting a cultural convergence,
and so integrative that it is, in one prominent and but the radicalization of religions has the opposite
much-repeated assessment, “flat.” Ancient and effect. The distribution of health and well-being
durable obstacles are no more, interaction is global, shows troubling signs of inequity and reversal.
free trade rules the globe, migration is ubiquitous, 1 Because people continue to congregate in places of
and the flow of ideas (and money and jobs) is so high environmental risk, especially in the crowded
pervasive that geography, in the perspective of more periphery, hundreds of millions find themselves in
than one observer, “is history.” The notion that place continuing jeopardy (as the 2004 tsunami, 4 in the
continues to play a key role in shaping humanity’s absence of coordinated warning systems, tragically
still-variegated mosaic is seen as obsolete, even confirmed). Inevitably, places of costly historic and
offensive and deterministic. Choice, not constraint, is current conflict take their toll as the “international
the mantra 2 of the new flat-world proponents. Join community” stands by without effective intervention,
the “forces of flattening” and you will enjoy the another form of jeopardy that afflicts the destinies of
benefits. Don’t, and you will fall off the edge. The millions. And males and females in the same locales
option is yours. have widely varying experiences, their destinies
But is it? From the vantage point of a high-floor diverging in sometimes agonizing ways. Even in the
room in the Shanghai Hyatt, the Mumbai Oberoi, or world’s cities, where the “rising tide lifts all boats”
the Dubai Hilton, 3 or from a business-class window promise of globalization should be especially evident,
seat on Singapore Airlines, the world seems flat power creates a high-relief topography of privilege
indeed. Millions of world-flatteners move every day and privation. Nor is the world’s divisive political
from hotel lobby to airport limo to first-class lounge, stockade 5 likely to be flattened anytime soon. Even
laptop in hand, uploading, outsourcing, offshoring as as states try to join in unions and associations, their
they travel, adjusting the air conditioning as they go. provinces and regions nurture nationalisms working
They are changing the world, these modern nomads, the other way. The power of place still holds the vast
and they are, in many ways, improving it—depending majority of us in its thrall.
of course on one’s definition of progress. But are they Of course, the question is not whether the world is
invariably agents of access and integration? Are they flat. Thomas Friedman, who coined the phrase,
lowering the barriers to participation or raising the concedes that he realizes “that the world is not flat.
stakes against it? Have their influence and impact Don’t worry, I know . . . I have engaged in literary
overpowered the imperatives of place, so that their license in titling [my] book to draw attention . . . .” It
very mobility symbolizes a confirmed irrelevance of is the process of “flattening” on which Friedman
location? wants to focus through his provocative title, “the
Not yet. The Earth, physically as well as culturally, single most important trend in the world today,” that is
still is very rough terrain, and in crucial ways its at issue. And in certain respects the global playing
regional compartments continue to trap billions in field is leveling, but in other ways the reverse appears
circumstances that spell disadvantage. The power of to be true. Notions of a flat world raise expectations
place and the fate of people are linked by many of growing access and increasing opportunity that are
strands ranging from physical area and natural mantras of globalization but are all too often at
environment to durable culture and local tradition. variance with reality. Powerful forces, natural as well
This book, therefore, views a world in which progress as human, slow the flattening process in a contest that
toward convergence is countered by stagnation, even will determine the future of the planet.
1
widespread
2
slogan
3
luxury hotels
4
In December 2004, a series of immense ocean waves hit the coasts of
several South and Southeast Asian countries, causing catastrophic
destruction in the region.
5
enclosure
(1) Many people living near the Mississippi River (A) Nuisances can be either permanent or
see mayflies as a nuisance. (2) The mayflies’ sudden temporary.
entrance to life in the air, their languid flying and (B) This river, however, offers beautiful
resting on objects at their convenience, and their scenery to nature lovers.
deaths seemed a bother to humans.
(C) And all bugs seem to be nuisances to
(3) Adult mayflies’ short lifespans are at the heart
humans.
of the problem. (4) Throughout a couple of weeks
each summer, the nymphs (juvenile mayflies), which (D) I was one of those people.
have developed underwater for the past few months, (E) I have lived on this river for three years.
hatch into millions of mature mayflies with
nonfunctioning mouths. (5) These adult mayflies
mate, lay eggs on and near the water, and then die
within a day or two, sometimes in piles multiple feet
high that create treacherous driving conditions for 26. The writer is considering deleting the underlined
humans. (6) These perishing insects impact portion of sentence 4 (reproduced below).
nondriving humans as well by collecting on air Throughout a couple of weeks each summer,
conditioner compressors and the like, often preventing the nymphs (juvenile mayflies), which have
them from functioning. (7) In fact, often street lights developed underwater for the past few months,
are shut off in order to decrease the number of hatch into millions of mature mayflies with
mayflies congregating near them. (8) And, believe it non-functioning mouths.
or not, the wings and skin of mayflies cause an
allergic reaction on the skin of some folk. (9) The Should the writer keep or delete the underlined
bodies of these mayflies are long and thin and support text?
large wings.
(10) Despite these nuisances, I have come to value (A) Keep it, because it provides more
these somewhat unsightly creatures. (11) For description of the mayflies’ physical
example, because they need clean water to survive, characteristics.
their presence indicates to humans the health of a (B) Keep it, because it explains a term that may
body of fresh water. (12) In fact, they have been used be unfamiliar to some readers.
to assess the quality of water in fresh water areas. (C) Keep it, because it assists in developing the
(13) In addition, the nymphs, with their functioning writer’s thesis.
mouths, contribute to the cleanliness of the water by
eating algae and decaying vegetation. (14) Therefore, (D) Delete it, because it does not enhance the
they are important indicators of the health of a discussion of adult mayflies.
human’s environment. (15) Moreover, clean bodies of (E) Delete it, because it reflects the writer’s
fresh water attract human recreational activity. bias against mayflies.
(16) Mayflies impact the economies of humans who
live near healthy rivers and lakes—both tourists and
locals spend money to enjoy activities in and near the
water.
(The passage below is a draft.) 32. Which of the following sentences, if added after
sentence 16, would provide the best concluding
(1) Many people living near the Mississippi River sentence for the passage?
see mayflies as a nuisance. (2) The mayflies’ sudden
entrance to life in the air, their languid flying and (A) Robust economies are important to
resting on objects at their convenience, and their humans, and they enhance lifestyles
deaths seemed a bother to humans. across the board; therefore, humans
(3) Adult mayflies’ short lifespans are at the heart should respect the lives of mayflies.
of the problem. (4) Throughout a couple of weeks (B) Yes, mayflies definitely impact the quality
each summer, the nymphs (juvenile mayflies), which of fresh water, so humans should desire to
have developed underwater for the past few months, keep these pesky insects around.
hatch into millions of mature mayflies with
(C) Since there are both good and bad
nonfunctioning mouths. (5) These adult mayflies
consequences from living with mayflies,
mate, lay eggs on and near the water, and then die
individuals should make their own
within a day or two, sometimes in piles multiple feet
decisions about whether or not the bad
high that create treacherous driving conditions for
outweighs the good.
humans. (6) These perishing insects impact
nondriving humans as well by collecting on air (D) Clearly there are both negative and positive
conditioner compressors and the like, often preventing aspects to coexisting with mayflies, but
them from functioning. (7) In fact, often street lights the long-lasting positives outweigh the
are shut off in order to decrease the number of temporary negatives.
mayflies congregating near them. (8) And, believe it (E) It is easy to see, then, that tourists might
or not, the wings and skin of mayflies cause an have a different perspective than locals do
allergic reaction on the skin of some folk. (9) The about the life cycle of mayflies and its
bodies of these mayflies are long and thin and support many effects on humans.
large wings.
(10) Despite these nuisances, I have come to value
these somewhat unsightly creatures. (11) For
example, because they need clean water to survive,
their presence indicates to humans the health of a
body of fresh water. (12) In fact, they have been used
to assess the quality of water in fresh water areas.
(13) In addition, the nymphs, with their functioning
mouths, contribute to the cleanliness of the water by
eating algae and decaying vegetation. (14) Therefore,
they are important indicators of the health of a
human’s environment. (15) Moreover, clean bodies of
fresh water attract human recreational activity.
(16) Mayflies impact the economies of humans who
live near healthy rivers and lakes—both tourists and
locals spend money to enjoy activities in and near the
water.
(1) To work or not to work, that is the question. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor
(2) Or, at least it’s a question many teens consider Statistics (USBLS), the state with the highest
during their summer break. (3) According to the U.S. employment rate for teens is Mississippi at 77
Bureau of Labor Statistics (USBLS), the state with the percent, and the lowest is North Dakota at 51
highest employment rate for teens is Mississippi at percent.
77 percent, and the lowest is North Dakota at
Which of the following versions of the
51 percent.
underlined portion of sentence 3 most effectively
(4) Why are teens not working as much? (5) That
accomplishes this goal?
depends. (6) Middle- and upper-class teens are
choosing not to work, while lower-income teens have
(A) (as it is now)
less access to jobs. (7) Teens with access to part-time
jobs often select what they perceive as better (B) the number of teens working summer jobs
alternatives (e.g., community service, volunteer work, has dropped from 60 percent to 30
unpaid internships, and academics) that have percent since the 1980s
nonfinancial benefits. (8) In fact, the USBLS reports (C) 22 percent of high school females were
the number of teens in summer school rose from employed as compared to 19 percent of
10 percent to 45 percent from 1985 to 2018. males
(9) Teenagers in my neighborhood, meanwhile, must (D) the employment rate for teens with some
need some extra money because I see numerous signs college or an associate degree is 79
at the local grocery store advertising personal percent
lawn-mowing and babysitting services. (E) 11,847,000 teens between the ages of 16
(10) Some lament the decrease in teen and 19 do not have any kind of job
employment. (11) According to the Center for Work
Ethic Development, part-time jobs teach the soft skills
that future employers value: “Although it might seem
unrelated, scooping ice cream or working retail can
make you a better doctor, accountant, teacher or
benefit any other career path you might choose.”
(12) These soft skills include social and emotional
intelligence, work ethic, responsibility, and a positive
attitude. (13) Depending on what teens do instead,
these traits can be developed in other ways.
(14) To work or not to work isn’t the most
important question. (15) The focus should be on what
teenagers do to develop soft skills—the people skills,
the work ethic, the communication skills—that will
help them regardless of the path they will take in life.
(16) Thus, it is very important for teenagers to get
back into the workforce so they can develop the work
ethic they need to be successful.
(The passage below is a draft.) 37. The writer is considering deleting sentence 9
(reproduced below) from the passage.
(1) To work or not to work, that is the question.
(2) Or, at least it’s a question many teens consider Teenagers in my neighborhood, meanwhile,
during their summer break. (3) According to the U.S. must need some extra money because I see
Bureau of Labor Statistics (USBLS), the state with the numerous signs at the local grocery store
highest employment rate for teens is Mississippi at advertising personal lawn-mowing and
77 percent, and the lowest is North Dakota at babysitting services.
51 percent.
Should the writer keep or delete this sentence?
(4) Why are teens not working as much? (5) That
depends. (6) Middle- and upper-class teens are (A) Keep it, because the evidence it provides is
choosing not to work, while lower-income teens have likely to appeal to the audience’s values
less access to jobs. (7) Teens with access to part-time in terms of their experience with
jobs often select what they perceive as better teenagers seeking part-time employment.
alternatives (e.g., community service, volunteer work,
unpaid internships, and academics) that have (B) Keep it, because it provides anecdotal
nonfinancial benefits. (8) In fact, the USBLS reports evidence about teen employment that is
the number of teens in summer school rose from expanded on later in the passage.
10 percent to 45 percent from 1985 to 2018. (C) Delete it, because the writer’s choice of
(9) Teenagers in my neighborhood, meanwhile, must diction creates an inappropriately
need some extra money because I see numerous signs informal tone.
at the local grocery store advertising personal (D) Delete it, because the anecdote about local
lawn-mowing and babysitting services. teenagers weakens the reasoning of the
(10) Some lament the decrease in teen argument at this point of the passage.
employment. (11) According to the Center for Work (E) Delete it, because the example it provides
Ethic Development, part-time jobs teach the soft skills undermines the credibility of the writer as
that future employers value: “Although it might seem someone knowledgeable about teen
unrelated, scooping ice cream or working retail can employment.
make you a better doctor, accountant, teacher or
benefit any other career path you might choose.”
(12) These soft skills include social and emotional
intelligence, work ethic, responsibility, and a positive
attitude. (13) Depending on what teens do instead,
these traits can be developed in other ways.
(14) To work or not to work isn’t the most
important question. (15) The focus should be on what
teenagers do to develop soft skills—the people skills,
the work ethic, the communication skills—that will
help them regardless of the path they will take in life.
(16) Thus, it is very important for teenagers to get
back into the workforce so they can develop the work
ethic they need to be successful.
(A) generous
(B) interesting
(C) obvious
(D) routine
(E) desirable
(1) From Toronto, Canada, to Songdo, South From Toronto, Canada, to Songdo, South
Korea, cities around the world are promoting Korea, cities around the world are promoting
themselves as “smart cities.” (2) Smart-city initiatives themselves as “smart cities.”
cover a remarkable range of public infrastructure,
Which of the following choices would best
including waste receptacles that signal when they
accomplish this goal?
need to be emptied, systems that broadcast locations
of available communal bicycles, and electricity grids
(A) because these two cities desire to be global
that distribute energy in response to usage patterns.
technology leaders, especially in
(3) Many people are excited about these new
engineering and data collection
technologies, and, as civil engineering professor and
infrastructure expert Shoshanna Saxe explains, they (B) meaning that these cities attract the
are intended to improve infrastructure by collecting smartest companies so they can, in turn,
data and responding automatically. (4) As Saxe and provide high-paying jobs to local
other urbanists have argued, however, that premise residents and attract the best and the
should be questioned. brightest from around the world
(5) Adding sensors for data collection to public (C) cities prepared to move into global markets
services such as water and electricity distribution and economies that transcend the typical
introduces new vulnerability to urban infrastructure. geographic limitations of older, more
(6) Saxe and other experienced city planners worry traditional cities
that networked digital infrastructure would be more (D) communities that use the latest digital
akin to a smartphone or computer. (7) Although smart technology, particularly computer
infrastructure promises more efficient delivery of systems that respond to input from
services and may deliver on that promise in the networks of sensors, to deliver city
beginning, it is susceptible to failure in ways that services efficiently and improve urban life
conventional infrastructure is not. (E) even though “smart” has little to do with
their intelligence and much more to do
with the ways in which the cities will
respond to the growing physical needs of
their populations
(The passage below is a draft.) 44. The writer is considering adding the clause
“devices that work optimally only for a few
(1) From Toronto, Canada, to Songdo, South years before bugs in their programming
Korea, cities around the world are promoting introduce glitches and errors” to the end of
themselves as “smart cities.” (2) Smart-city initiatives sentence 6 (reproduced below), adjusting the
cover a remarkable range of public infrastructure, punctuation as needed.
including waste receptacles that signal when they
need to be emptied, systems that broadcast locations Saxe and other experienced city planners
of available communal bicycles, and electricity grids worry that networked digital infrastructure
that distribute energy in response to usage patterns. would be more akin to a smartphone or
(3) Many people are excited about these new computer.
technologies, and, as civil engineering professor and
Should the writer add this clause to the end of
infrastructure expert Shoshanna Saxe explains, they
sentence 6 ?
are intended to improve infrastructure by collecting
data and responding automatically. (4) As Saxe and (A) Yes, because it demonstrates that Saxe and
other urbanists have argued, however, that premise other city planners are experts on the
should be questioned. subject of smart cities who are familiar
(5) Adding sensors for data collection to public with the latest technology.
services such as water and electricity distribution
introduces new vulnerability to urban infrastructure. (B) Yes, because the additional information
(6) Saxe and other experienced city planners worry clarifies a comparison to a more familiar
that networked digital infrastructure would be more technology that also breaks or becomes
akin to a smartphone or computer. (7) Although smart obsolete relatively quickly.
infrastructure promises more efficient delivery of (C) No, because it makes Saxe seem like a
services and may deliver on that promise in the biased observer by portraying her as
beginning, it is susceptible to failure in ways that being opposed to technological
conventional infrastructure is not. innovations of any kind.
(D) No, because the statement in sentence 6 is
so clear that it does not need any
qualification.
(E) No, because the word “bugs” is ambiguous
and could confuse readers who are
unfamiliar with technological jargon.
Octavia E. Butler, “Furor Scribendi” from BloodChild and Other Stories. Copyright ©1996, 2005 by
Octavia E. Butler. Reprinted with the permission of The Permissions Company, LLC on behalf of
Seven Stories Press, www.sevenstories.com.
At a Glance Instructions
The questions for Section II are printed in this booklet. You may use this booklet to
Total Time
2 hours and 15 minutes
organize your answers and for scratch work, but you must write your answers on the lined
Number of Questions
pages provided for each question.
3 The proctor will announce the beginning and end of the reading period. You are advised to
Percent of Total Score spend the 15-minute period reading Question 1, analyzing and evaluating the sources, and
55% planning your answer. You may read the other essay questions at this time. You may begin
Writing Instrument writing your response before the reading period is over.
Pen with black or dark
blue ink Section II of this exam requires answers in essay form. Each essay will be judged on its
Reading Period clarity and effectiveness in dealing with the assigned topic and on the quality of the writing.
Quality is far more important than quantity. You should check your essays for accuracy of
Time punctuation, spelling, and diction; you are advised, however, not to attempt many longer
15 minutes. Use this
time to read the corrections.
question and plan your
answer to Question 1, Write clearly and legibly. Number each answer as the question is numbered in the exam.
the synthesis question. Begin each answer on a new page. Do not skip lines. Cross out any errors you make;
You may begin writing crossed-out work will not be scored.
your response before
the reading period is Manage your time carefully. You may proceed freely from one question to the next. You
over. may review your responses if you finish before the end of the exam is announced.
Writing Period
Time
2 hours
Suggested Time
40 minutes per question
Weight
The questions are
weighted equally.
Question 1
“Meatless Monday” is an initiative promoted in the United States by the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public
Health as well as by a number of environmental and animal welfare organizations. It seeks to encourage people to
eat meat-free meals once per week and gives them recipes and other resources to do so. Some institutions, such as
schools, are considering adopting this practice.
Carefully read the following six sources, including the introductory information for each source. Write an essay that
synthesizes material from at least three of the sources and develops your position on whether school cafeterias in
your area should participate in Meatless Monday.
Source A (MacDonald and Reitmeier)
Source B (Steinfeld et al.)
Source C (Ritchie)
Source D (Steussy)
Source E (Enzinna)
Source F (graph)
The following is excerpted from a book about food production and consumption in the United States.
During WWI, 1 there were campaigns for Meatless Tuesday and Wheatless Wednesday to remind US citizens to
reduce their consumption of foods in limited supply and to conserve food for the war effort. Meatless days were also
encouraged during WWII 2 when meat, sugar, and other foods were rationed. These campaigns were effective in
bringing US citizens together and sharing sacrifices for the war effort. During the 1960s when new nutrition
research linked certain foods with diseases, such as red meat and dietary fat with heart disease, public campaigns to
reduce the intake of these foods were common. A new approach in public campaigning to influence food
consumption was launched in 2003. Sid Lerner, an advertising agent, in collaboration with faculty at Johns Hopkins
Bloomberg School of Public Health’s Center for a Livable Future, created the Meatless Monday campaign. The
campaign was initially part of a Healthy Monday initiative to encourage people to give up bad habits from the
weekend and start healthier habits at the beginning of the week. The Meatless Monday component of that initiative
grabbed a great deal of attention. The platform of the Meatless Monday campaign is that Americans consume too
much meat and not eating meat one day a week will improve health. Reducing the impact of meat production on the
environment also became part of the platform.
The Meatless Monday campaign gained substantial support from celebrities and is now a global movement. The
Meatless Monday website (www.meatlessmonday.com) includes articles and promotional material to encourage
groups to create Meatless Monday movements in their communities, schools, and workplaces. Recipes, diet ideas,
and suggestions for meatless meals are presented in blogs, magazines, websites, and newspapers by chefs,
journalists, nutritionists, and celebrities. The journalist Michael Pollan stated on The Oprah Winfrey Show in 2009
that if everybody in America participated in a Meatless Monday, it would have the equivalent effect on the
environment of taking 20 million midsize sedans off the road. This statistic is difficult to verify but is easy to
remember and repeat. Paul McCartney, 3 a vegetarian, and his daughters started a Meat Free Monday nonprofit
organization with the aim of “. . . raising awareness of the detrimental environmental impact of eating meat, and to
encourage people to help slow climate change, preserve precious natural resources and improve their health by
having at least one meat free day each week” (www.meatfreemondays.com).
1
the First World War
2
the Second World War
3
English musician most famous as a member of the rock and roll band the Beatles
The following is excepted from a report published by the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United
Nations.
In terms of nutrition, livestock food products globally contributed an average of 17 percent of energy and 33 percent
of protein to dietary intakes in 2003 (FAO, 2006b). There are stark differences between countries and country
groups, with meat consumption ranging in 2003 from only 5 kg per person and year in India to 123 kg in the United
States (FAO, 2006b). Because developing countries still have low intakes of animal food the share of livestock
products in the “global average diet” is expected to continue to rise to reach the OECD 1 country averages of about
30 percent of dietary energy and 50 percent of protein intake. In terms of health and nutrition, therefore, livestock
products are a welcome addition to the diets of many poor and under- or malnourished people who frequently suffer
from protein and vitamin deficiencies as well as from lack of important trace minerals. Children in particular have
shown to benefit greatly in terms of physical and mental health when modest amounts of milk, meat or eggs are
added to their diets, as shown by long-term research carried out in Kenya (Neumann, 2003). In contrast, a large
number of non-communicable diseases among the more wealthy segments of the world’s population are associated
with high intakes of animal source foods, in particular animal fats and red meat: cardio-vascular disease, diabetes
and certain types of cancer. While not being addressed by this assessment, it may well be argued that environmental
damage by livestock may be significantly reduced by lowering excessive consumption of livestock products among
wealthy people. International and national public institutions (e.g. WHO 2 and Tufts University, 1998) have
consistently recommended lower intakes of animal fat and red meat in most developed countries. . . .
Livestock compete for crops but provide a buffer against grain shortages. In simple numeric terms, livestock actually
detract more from total food supply than they provide. Livestock now consume more human edible protein than they
produce. In fact, livestock consume 77 million tonnes of protein contained in feedstuff that could potentially be used
for human nutrition, whereas only 58 million tonnes of protein are contained in food products that livestock supply.
In terms of dietary energy, the relative loss is much higher. This is a result of the recent trend towards more
concentrate-based diets for pigs and poultry, with nutritional requirements more similar to humans than ruminants. 3
1
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development
2
World Health Organization
3
Animals such as cattle, sheep, deer, etc.
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, 2016, H. Steinfeld; P. Gerber; T. Wassenaar; V. Castel; M. Rosales; C. de Haan, Livestock’s Long
Shadow, http://www.fao.org/3/a-a0701e.pdf. Reproduced with permission.
The following was adapted from a graph in a news article about meat consumption in different parts of the
world. The data was compiled by the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization.
The following is excerpted from a newspaper article about the introduction of a Meatless Monday program in
New York City schools.
Meat’s been expelled from New York City schools on Mondays. But the substitute might not be much better.
Mayor Bill de Blasio announced this week that all New York City public schools will have Meatless
Mondays—meaning that cafeterias would serve only vegetarian meals on the first day of the week—starting this
fall. De Blasio debuted the news by proudly digging into a grilled cheese and a pile of baked beans at PS 130 in
Kensington, one of the 15 Brooklyn schools that participated in a Meatless Monday pilot program starting in spring
2018. Officials say they were successful in getting kids to actually eat and enjoy the meatless options—which
include vegetarian tacos, chili and, yes, grilled cheese—so they decided to expand the program to the rest of the
city’s 1,800 schools.
De Blasio and school officials are patting themselves on the back for the move, which they say is good for kids’ and
the planet’s health. They point out that using less meat will cut down on greenhouse gas emissions and one in five
NYC kindergartners is obese.
But meatless doesn’t always mean better for you, according to health experts.
“There’s a very easy way to be less healthy by going meatless,” says Amy Shapiro, a registered dietitian and
nutritionist based in Noho who has three kids in the NYC public-school system. “My kids might get a big pretzel or
garlic bread at school—I don’t know where the nutrients are, but I know it’s meatless.”
Robin Barrie, a nutritionist who specializes in kids’ eating, agrees—and doesn’t think de Blasio should look so smug
about that cheesy sandwich.
“Grilled cheese as part of a healthy balanced diet is fine,” says Barrie. “But I don’t consider it healthy on its own.
The saturated fat in a grilled cheese is almost the same as the saturated fat in red meat.”
Plus, the one-day-a-week shift will have a limited impact if the rest of the week’s menu isn’t nutritious, says Barrie,
who has worked with schools, including PS 6 on the Upper East Side, on their menus. At PS 130, where de Blasio
announced the plan, vegetarian chili and veggie tacos are on the menu for the next two Mondays, but the following
Tuesdays bring hamburgers and cheeseburgers—not exactly a dietary win.
And the kids are savvy to the fact that their “healthy” day goes by quickly. When asked about whether her
classmates were annoyed by Meatless Mondays, 14-year-old Ella Rindler of PS 130 told CBS New York, “Some
people say, ‘I want my chicken nuggets,’ but they serve that on other days.”
That’s why selling kids on healthy meatless meals is going to be such a challenge for New York City cafeterias, says
Emily Burson, founder of California-based school-menu consulting company School Nutrition Plus.
“The [meals] with cheese are the biggest hits because it’s familiar to them,” Burson says. “That’s what they see on
So, sure, kids will chow down on grilled cheese, but “it’s a little harder” to convince kids to eat vegetarian meals that
are also legitimately healthy, she says.
From New York Post. © 2019 New York Post. All rights reserved. Used under license.
The following is excerpted from a magazine article about an advocacy group that counters the arguments of beef
industry critics such as author and activist Michael Pollan.
[Carrin] Flores, a graduate student in veterinary medicine at Washington State University-Pullman, plans to work in
the beef industry when she finishes. But she’s already a graduate of the Masters of Beef Advocacy (MBA), an
industry-funded program that trains college students to fight back against critics of big agribusiness, like Michael
Pollan.
“Pollan,” Flores tells me over beers at Dupus Boomer’s, a campus bar, “is really our enemy right now.” More than
35,000 college students were assigned one of his books last year; The Omnivore’s Dilemma is one of the most
widely read titles on US campuses. Flores and her fellow big beef advocates hope to counter that. “In the future,”
she says, “we’re the ones who are going to tell you about your beef.”
Since its launch in March 2009, the MBA has trained nearly 3,000 students and farmers to spread the “positive beef
message,” offering online lessons on how to combat PETA and organizing a Twitter and Facebook “Food Fight”
against its “campus critics.” Daren Williams, the communications director for the National Cattlemen’s Beef
Association, helped start the MBA with $240,000 from the Beef Checkoff program, the beef industry’s PR wing. He
says the MBA’s “focus has really become young people on the big land-grant campuses,” from which more than
one-fifth of future farmers and industry leaders will emerge. . . .
“Some of what you are hearing is organic, grassroots debate—they have different opinions about agriculture and
beef production—and that’s good for a democracy,” says Pollan, who teaches journalism at the University of
California-Berkeley (where I was his student). Yet he’s wary of the interests behind the campaign, noting that a PR
firm funded by McDonald’s reportedly urged elementary schools not to let Fast Food Nation author Eric Schlosser
speak to kids.
Asked if the MBA is just a phony PR campaign for Big Ag, Flores is emphatic: “[. . .] We’re just worried about our
futures in agriculture.” The dozen or so MBA grads and young farmers I spoke to shared similar anxieties. “We
know the environment is in crisis and we don’t want to contribute to that,” says Crystal Young, a recent graduate of
Kansas State University, where she received degrees in animal science and journalism. “But we’re also farmers, so
the hard thing for us is to take into account all the criticisms of conventional agriculture, and to also continue to feed
the world on the scale we are doing now. I think a lot of young people are primarily worried they won’t be able to
have a career in farming at all in the future.”
© Mother Jones
The following is adapted from a graph created by the United States Department of Agriculture.
The following passage is biologist Hope Jahren’s prologue to her 2016 memoir Lab Girl. A prologue is an
introduction that provides background information to set the context for a literary work. Jahren uses this prologue to
give a basic understanding of the kind of work she does and why she considers it to be important. Read the passage
carefully. Write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Jahren makes to convey the message of the importance
of her work.
In your response you should do the following:
• Respond to the prompt with a thesis that analyzes the writer’s rhetorical choices.
• Select and use evidence to support your line of reasoning.
• Explain how the evidence supports your line of reasoning.
• Demonstrate an understanding of the rhetorical situation.
• Use appropriate grammar and punctuation in communicating your argument.
People love the ocean. People are always asking 30 one of the few things left in the world that people
me why I don’t study the ocean, because, after all, I cannot make. What you saw was invented more than
live in Hawaii. I tell them that it’s because the ocean four hundred million years ago near the equator.
Line is a lonely, empty place. There is six hundred times Perhaps you were lucky enough to see a tree. That
5 more life on land than there is in the ocean, and this tree was designed about three hundred million years
fact mostly comes down to plants. The average ocean 35 ago, The mining of the atmosphere, the cell-laying,
plant is one cell that lives for about twenty days. The the wax-spackling, plumbing, and pigmentation took
average land plant is a two-ton tree that lives for more a few months at most, giving rise to nothing more or
than one hundred years. The mass ratio of plants to less perfect than a leaf. There are about as many
10 animals in the ocean is close to four, while the ratio leaves on one tree as there are hairs on your head. It’s
on land is closer to a thousand. Plant numbers are 40 really impressive.
staggering: there are eighty billion trees just within Now focus your gaze on just one leaf.
the protected forests of the western United States. People don’t know how to make a leaf, but they
The ratio of trees to people in America is well over know how to destroy one. In the last ten years, we’ve
15 two hundred. As a rule, people live among plants but cut down more than fifty billion trees. One-third of
they don’t really see them. Since I’ve discovered 45 the Earth’s land used to be covered in forest. Every
these numbers, I can see little else. ten years, we cut down about 1 percent of this total
So humor me for a minute, and look out your forest, never to be regrown. That represents a land
window. area about the size of France. One France after
20 What did you see? You probably saw things that another, for decades, has been wiped from the globe.
people make. These include other people, cars, 50 That’s more than one trillion leaves that are ripped
buildings, and sidewalks. After just a few years of from their source of nourishment every single day.
design, engineering, mining, forging, digging, And it seems like nobody cares. But we should care.
welding, bricklaying, window-framing, spackling, We should care for the same basic reason that we are
25 plumbing, wiring, and painting, people can make a always bound to care: because someone died who
hundred-story skyscraper capable of casting a 55 didn’t have to.
thousand-foot shadow. It’s really impressive. Someone died?
Now look again. Maybe I can convince you. I look at an awful lot of
Did you see something green? If you did, you saw leaves. I look at them and I ask questions. I start by
In The Machine in the Garden: Technology and the Pastoral Ideal in America (1964), a book on the relationship
between technology and culture in the United States, cultural historian Leo Marx describes a defining human conflict
in the modern age. On the one hand, Marx argues, “the machine” attracts us because technology amplifies human
power, increasing the efficiency of human labor and expanding human wealth; on the other hand, it threatens to
destroy “the garden,” the spaces and activities where humans find comfort and rest.
Write an essay that argues your position on the extent to which it is possible to achieve a harmonious balance
between the ideals represented by the machine and the garden.
In your response you should do the following:
• Respond to the prompt with a thesis that presents a defensible position.
• Provide evidence to support your line of reasoning.
• Explain how the evidence supports your line of reasoning.
• Use appropriate grammar and punctuation in communicating your argument.
END OF EXAM
________________________________
Question 1
Skill Essential Knowledge Unit
1.A: Identify and describe RHS-1.C: The purpose of a 1
components of the rhetorical text is what the writer hopes to
situation: the exigence, audience, accomplish with it. Writers may
purpose, context, and message. have more than one purpose in a
text.
(A) Incorrect. In the seventh paragraph, the author tells the audience
that talent is less important than persistence and determination.
Throughout the passage, the author describes the different tasks that
are important to success as a writer, emphasizing the superiority of
consistency and persistence to talent.
(B) Incorrect. The author does emphasize the difficulty of successfully
establishing a career as a writer, but the passage is not intended to
discourage the audience from pursuing this career. The passage is
framed as a series of specific suggestions that aspiring writers can
act on, which would not be an appropriate structure if the author
intended to discourage her audience from the aspiration to be a
writer.
(C) Incorrect. The passage does offer a variety of suggestions for
improving one’s writing. However, its suggestions are not made in
the context of an educational program, and the intended audience
is clearly meant to be aspiring writers rather than instructors of
composition and rhetoric. Also, while the suggestions in the passage
may contradict some ideas people have about how writers create their
work, there is no indication that the author’s suggestions to work hard
and study the appropriate subject matter are particularly new ideas.
(D) Correct. Throughout the passage, the author emphasizes the need for
aspiring writers to work hard. She describes the need to seek out and
accept criticism, continually compose and revise one’s writing, study
relevant subject matter, and avoid thinking of writing in terms that
might discourage consistent work.
(E) Incorrect. The author discusses the importance of studying grammar
in the passage, and she does mention that the audience may
mistakenly believe that they do not need to study grammar. However,
her discussion of studying grammar is part of her broader purpose
of showing the audience that hard work is necessary to become a
successful writer.
Question 13
Skill Essential Knowledge Unit
1.A: Identify and describe RHS-1.B: The exigence is the 1
components of the rhetorical part of a rhetorical situation that
situation: the exigence, audience, inspires, stimulates, provokes, or
purpose, context, and message. prompts writers to create a text.
(A) Incorrect. Although there are indications throughout the passage that
the author believes greater resources should be devoted to solving
certain pressing problems, he never addresses this issue directly, and
there is nothing to suggest that it prompted him to write this text.
(B) Incorrect. The author does mention the existence of global
organizations but does not indicate that he finds them menacing or that
their proliferation provoked him to write this text.
(C) Incorrect. The author does discuss the extent to which disparate groups
of people communicate but does not suggest that facilitating such
communication prompted him to write this text.
(D) Correct. The exigence is the part of a rhetorical situation that inspires,
stimulates, provokes, or prompts writers to create texts. In the first
paragraph, the author indicates that many people have come to believe
that cultural differences and geographical separation have been
diminished so much that the world has been rendered “flat.” The author
does not completely agree with this view and has been prompted to
write this text by his belief that this “flat world” view should receive
greater scrutiny.
(E) Incorrect. The author does discuss the view that the world is rapidly
becoming more homogeneous but expresses doubts about this view
and does not suggest that the potentially reductive effect of such
homogenization prompted him to write this text.
Question 17
Skill Essential Knowledge Unit
3.C: Explain ways claims are CLE-1.AB: When writers concede, 9
qualified through modifiers, they accept all or a portion of a
counterarguments, and alternative competing position or claim as
perspectives. correct, agree that the competing
position or claim is correct under
a different set of circumstances,
or acknowledge the limitations of
their own argument.
(A) Incorrect. The author describes the diffusion of English as “promoting
cultural convergence,” a tendency that is highlighted by people who
argue that the world is “flattening” and that the particular qualities
of places are becoming less important. The diffusion of English thus
does not challenge an assumption of other arguments but rather
challenges the author’s own argument that place is still very important
by conceding that there is one trend, the diffusion of English, in which
place really is becoming less important.
(B) Incorrect. The author’s thesis is that many forces are slowing global
convergence, whereas the author acknowledges that the diffusion of
English has the opposite effect of promoting global convergence. The
global diffusion of English is therefore introduced as a concession to
the perspective of “flat-world proponents” that this trend is indeed an
example of global culture becoming more standardized. By conceding
that there is one area where the claims of flat-world proponents largely
hold true, the author demonstrates that he is carefully considering the
arguments of others.
(C) Incorrect. The author mentions two different effects in the sentence,
but he attributes them to two different causes: he claims that cultural
convergence is caused by the diffusion of the English language and
that cultural divergence is caused by the radicalization of religions. The
author mentions the diffusion of English in the sentence to concede
that in this area the claims of “flat-world proponents” are largely
accurate, and place is becoming less important. By conceding that
another argument is true in certain respects, the author demonstrates
that he is carefully considering other perspectives.
Question 18
Skill Essential Knowledge Unit
5.C: Recognize and explain the REO-1.J: When developing ideas 3
use of methods of development to through cause-effect, writers
accomplish a purpose. present a cause, assert effects or
consequences of that cause, or
present a series of causes and the
subsequent effect(s).
(A) Incorrect. Although the passage does note that people from affluent
communities get disproportionate benefits from globalization, the
author does not mention the concentration of populations in “places
of high environmental risk” to make this point. Instead, the author
argues about the disadvantages that certain populations face from this
concentration, specifically mentioning the toll that the 2004 tsunami
had on people living in areas of heightened environmental risk.
(B) Incorrect. Although the author mentions “places of costly historic and
current conflict” and the causes of such conflict in the next sentence,
he does not relate these places to places facing “high environmental
risk.” The effect that the author associates with the tendency of people
to “congregate in places of high environmental risk” is increased danger
from disasters, such as the 2004 tsunami.
(C) Correct. The author argues that because certain communities gather
in environmentally endangered areas, they are at higher risk than other
communities are. The author also provides the example of the 2004
tsunami as evidence of these dangers.
(D) Incorrect. Although the author does mention the “crowded periphery”
and points to the “inequity and reversal” of the distribution of health,
he does not explicitly connect these two.
(E) Incorrect. The author mentions the natural environment as one of the
many factors that determine disadvantage, but he does not argue that
the congregating of people in particular areas causes environmental
degradation.
“Meatless Monday” is an initiative promoted in the United States by the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg
School of Public Health as well as by a number of environmental and animal welfare organizations.
It seeks to encourage people to eat meat-free meals once per week and gives them recipes and
other resources to do so. Some institutions, such as schools, are considering adopting this practice.
Carefully read the following six sources, including the introductory information for each source.
Write an essay that synthesizes material from at least three of the sources and develops your
position on whether school cafeterias in your area should participate in Meatless Monday.
Source A (MacDonald and Reitmeier)
Source B (Steinfeld et al.)
Source C (Ritchie)
Source D (Steussy)
Source E (Enzinna)
Source F (graph)
In your response you should do the following:
• Respond to the prompt with a thesis that presents a defensible position.
• Select and use evidence from at least three of the provided sources to support your line of
reasoning. Indicate clearly the sources used through direct quotation, paraphrase, or summary.
Sources may be cited as Source A, Source B, etc., or by using the description in parentheses.
• Explain how the evidence supports your line of reasoning.
• Use appropriate grammar and punctuation in communicating your argument.
113
Reporting
Scoring Criteria
Category
Row C 0 points 1 point
Sophistication Does not meet the criteria for one point. Demonstrates sophistication of thought and/or a complex understanding of the
(0–1 points) rhetorical situation.
Additional Notes:
• This point should be awarded only if the sophistication of thought or complex understanding is part of the student’s argument, not merely a phrase or
reference.
Question 2: Rhetorical Analysis 6 points
The following passage is biologist Hope Jahren’s prologue to her 2016 memoir Lab Girl. A prologue
is an introduction that provides background information to set the context for a literary work.
Jahren uses this prologue to give a basic understanding of the kind of work she does and why she
considers it to be important. Read the passage carefully. Write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical
choices Jahren makes to convey the message of the importance of her work.
In your response you should do the following:
• Respond to the prompt with a thesis that analyzes the writer’s rhetorical choices.
• Select and use evidence to support your line of reasoning.
• Explain how the evidence supports your line of reasoning.
• Demonstrate an understanding of the rhetorical situation.
• Use appropriate grammar and punctuation in communicating your argument.
Additional Notes:
• The thesis may be more than one sentence, provided the sentences are in close proximity.
• The thesis may be anywhere within the response.
• For a thesis to be defensible, the passage must include at least minimal evidence that could be used to support that thesis; however, the student need
not cite that evidence to earn the thesis point.
• The thesis may establish a line of reasoning that structures the essay, but it needn’t do so to earn the thesis point.
• A thesis that meets the criteria can be awarded the point whether or not the rest of the response successfully supports that line of reasoning.
Reporting
Scoring Criteria
Category
Row B 0 points 1 point 2 points 3 points 4 points
Evidence Simply restates thesis (if EVIDENCE: EVIDENCE: EVIDENCE: EVIDENCE:
AND present), repeats provided Provides evidence that is mostly Provides some specific, relevant Provides specific evidence to Provides specific evidence to
information, or offers general. evidence. support all claims in a line of support all claims in a line of
Commentary
information irrelevant to the AND AND reasoning. reasoning.
prompt. AND AND
(0–4 points) COMMENTARY: COMMENTARY:
Summarizes the evidence Explains how some of the COMMENTARY: COMMENTARY:
1.A
but does not explain how the evidence relates to the Explains how some of the Consistently explains how the
2.A
evidence supports the student’s student’s argument, but no line evidence supports a line of evidence supports a line of
4.A argument. of reasoning is established, or reasoning. reasoning.
6.A the line of reasoning is faulty. AND AND
6.B
Explains how at least one Explains how multiple rhetorical
6.C
rhetorical choice in the passage choices in the passage
contributes to the writer’s contribute to the writer’s
argument, purpose, or message. argument, purpose, or message.
Decision Rules and Scoring Notes
Typical responses that earn Typical responses that earn Typical responses that earn Typical responses that earn Typical responses that earn
0 points: 1 point: 2 points: 3 points: 4 points:
• Are incoherent or do not • Tend to focus on summary • Consist of a mix of specific • Uniformly offer evidence to • Uniformly offer evidence to
address the prompt. or description of a passage evidence and broad support claims. support claims.
• May be just opinion with rather than specific details generalities. • Focus on the importance of • Focus on the importance of
no textual references or techniques. • May contain some simplistic, specific words and details specific words and details
or references that are • Mention rhetorical choices inaccurate, or repetitive from the passage to build an from the passage to build an
irrelevant. with little or no explanation. explanations that don’t argument. argument.
strengthen the argument. • Organize an argument as a • Organize and support
• May make one point well, line of reasoning composed an argument as a line of
but either do not make of multiple supporting reasoning composed of
multiple supporting claims claims. multiple supporting claims,
or do not adequately • Commentary may fail to each with adequate evidence
support more than one integrate some evidence or that is clearly explained.
claim. fail to support a key claim. • Explain how the writer’s
• Do not explain the use of rhetorical choices
connections or progression contributes to the student’s
between the student’s interpretation of the passage.
claims, so a line of reasoning
is not clearly established.
Additional Notes:
117
argument, purpose, or message of the passage.
Reporting
Scoring Criteria
Category
Row C 0 points 1 point
Sophistication Does not meet the criteria for one point. Demonstrates sophistication of thought and/or a complex understanding of the
(0–1 points) rhetorical situation.
Additional Notes:
• This point should be awarded only if the sophistication of thought or complex understanding is part of the student’s argument, not merely a phrase or
reference.
Question 3: Argument Essay 6 points
In The Machine in the Garden: Technology and the Pastoral Ideal in America (1964), a book on
the relationship between technology and culture in the United States, cultural historian Leo Marx
describes a defining human conflict in the modern age. On the one hand, Marx argues, “the
machine” attracts us because technology amplifies human power, increasing the efficiency of
human labor and expanding human wealth; on the other hand, it threatens to destroy “the garden,”
the spaces and activities where humans find comfort and rest.
Write an essay that argues your position on the extent to which it is possible to achieve a
harmonious balance between the ideals represented by the machine and the garden.
In your response you should do the following:
• Respond to the prompt with a thesis that presents a defensible position
• Provide evidence to support your line of reasoning.
• Explain how the evidence supports your line of reasoning.
• Use appropriate grammar and punctuation in communicating your argument.
Examples that do not earn this point: Examples that earn this point:
Do not take a position Present a defensible position that responds to the prompt
• “The ‘machine’ and the ‘garden’ represent different values, and • “The ideals of ‘the machine’ and ‘the garden’ do not have to be in conflict with one
they can be difficult to balance.” another; in fact, if technology is used responsibly and effectively, it can increase the
Address the topic of the prompt but are not defensible—it is an comfort and relaxation offered by ‘the garden.’”
obvious fact stated as a claim • “The way that social media has come to dominate every aspect of our lives shows
• “Technology has made incredible strides in making people’s work that the machine and the garden cannot be balanced. At least some of the time, it
more efficient.” is necessary to unplug and spend time away from the machine.”
Additional Notes:
• The thesis may be more than one sentence, provided the sentences are in close proximity.
• The thesis may be anywhere within the response.
• The thesis may establish a line of reasoning that structures the essay, but it needn’t do so to earn the thesis point.
• A thesis that meets the criteria can be awarded the point whether or not the rest of the response successfully supports that line of reasoning.
Reporting
Scoring Criteria
Category
Row B 0 points 1 point 2 points 3 points 4 points
Evidence Simply restates thesis (if EVIDENCE: EVIDENCE: EVIDENCE: EVIDENCE:
AND present), repeats provided Provides evidence that is Provides some specific, Provides specific evidence to Provides specific evidence to
Commentary information, or offers mostly general. relevant evidence support all claims in a line of support all claims in a line of
information irrelevant to the AND AND reasoning. reasoning.
(0–4 points) prompt. AND AND
COMMENTARY: COMMENTARY:
2.A
Summarizes the evidence Explains how some of the COMMENTARY: COMMENTARY:
4.A
but does not explain how evidence relates to the Explains how some of the Consistently explains how the
the evidence supports the student’s argument, but evidence supports a line of evidence supports a line of
6.A
argument. no line of reasoning is reasoning. reasoning.
6.B
established, or the line of
6.C
reasoning is faulty.
121
Reporting
Scoring Criteria
Category
Row C 0 points 1 point
Sophistication Does not meet the criteria for one point. Demonstrates sophistication of thought and/or a complex understanding of the
(0–1 points) rhetorical situation.
Additional Notes:
• This point should be awarded only if the sophistication of thought or complex understanding is part of the student’s argument, not merely a phrase or
reference.
Contact Us
apcentral.collegeboard.org
AP Canada Office
2950 Douglas Street, Suite 550
Victoria, BC, Canada V8T 4N4
250-472-8561
800-667-4548 (toll free in Canada only)
Email: [email protected]