Copy of Elective - IX
Copy of Elective - IX
Explore relationship between structure and architecture and with the various forms based on the
aspirations and intentions of the designers
The varieties of relationship can be very wide, ranging between the extremes of Complete
domination of
1. Architecture
2. Structure
3. Total disregard of structural requirements in the determination of both the form of a building
and of its aesthetic treatment
Ornamentation of Structure:
Definition: A basic structural framework (beam and column) is enhanced with
decorative elements.
Historical Examples: Greek and Roman architecture (Doric, Ionic, Corinthian orders).
Modern Examples: Contemporary buildings continue using structural ornamentation in various
styles.
Key Idea: The structure is primarily functional, and ornamentation is added later for aesthetic
appeal.
Structure as Ornament :
Concept: Structural elements are intentionally designed to be visually prominent rather than
hidden.
Characteristics:
The structure itself serves as decoration.
Design prioritizes aesthetics over technical efficiency.
Structural components (e.g., bracing, cantilevers, exposed services) create visual appeal.
Examples:
Lloyd’s Headquarters (London): Externalized steel services and structural bracing enhance
aesthetics.
Centre Pompidou (Paris): Exposed pipes, ducts, and structural framework create a rhythmic
design.
Ribbed Structure Example: Structural repetition and detailing enhance the architectural effect.
Design Approach:
Instead of hiding structural elements, they are showcased deliberately.
Even though a simpler structure could save materials, the design emphasizes artistic
expression.
Comparison with Ornamentation of Structure:
Ornamentation of Structure: Basic structure with added decorative elements.
Structure as Ornament: Structure itself is visually dominant and artistic.
Conclusion: The structure’s visual presence defines the building’s character, making it a key
aesthetic component.
LECTURE 7 :- CONNECTING STRUCTURE AND ARCHITECTURE
Introduction
Lecture 7 expands upon the concepts introduced in the previous lecture, delving deeper into the
intricate relationships between architecture and structure. This lecture introduces three more
categories that describe the dynamic interaction between structure and architecture. These
categories include: Structure as Architecture, Structure Accepted in Architecture, and Structure
Ignored in Architecture. The lecture aims to highlight how structural components can be
manipulated to not only fulfill functional requirements but also contribute to the visual and
aesthetic qualities of a building.
Structure as Architecture
This category refers to instances where the structural components themselves form the essence
of the architectural design. Here, the structural form is not just a supporting element but is central
to the building’s aesthetic identity. In these designs, the structure is visually prominent and often
defines the overall architectural form.
In these cases, the structure is used as a design tool that enhances the visual experience. The
architecture derives its character from the way the structure is designed, with functional and
aesthetic elements intertwined. The building's appearance and its structural integrity are seen as
equally important, contributing to a unified design vision.
○ Examples:
■ Eiffel Tower (Paris, France): The Eiffel Tower is one of the most iconic
examples of structure as architecture. Its iron framework is both functional
and ornamental, with the structure itself becoming the central visual feature of
the building. The architectural expression emerges from the elegant
arrangement of structural elements.
■ Millennium Dome (London, UK): The Millennium Dome employs a
tensioned fabric structure, which allows for large, column-free spans. The
design prioritizes the structure, allowing it to become a prominent
architectural feature. The building’s form is defined by the way its structural
system is configured, creating an open, expansive interior space.
■ John Hancock Building (Chicago, USA): This skyscraper uses a truss-tube
structural system that allows it to resist lateral loads. The structural
components are not hidden but are instead integrated into the design,
contributing to the building’s overall visual identity. The structure’s
prominence enhances the architectural expression of the building.
■ Burj Khalifa (Dubai, UAE): The tallest building in the world, the Burj Khalifa,
utilizes a bundled tube structural system. This design not only provides the
necessary stability against lateral forces but also contributes to the striking
architectural form of the skyscraper. The synergy between the structural
system and architectural design is evident in this monumental structure.
Structure Accepted in Architecture
In this category, structural elements are acknowledged and incorporated into the architectural
design without significantly altering the form. The structural system is visible and celebrated for its
functionality, but it does not dominate the overall aesthetic. Instead, the structure is integrated
into the design in a way that supports the architectural intent.
This approach allows the structure to play a visible role in the design while ensuring that the
architectural goals are not compromised. It highlights the importance of understanding the
structural system and integrating it seamlessly into the building’s aesthetic.
Examples:
■ Pantheon (Rome, Italy): The Pantheon is a classical example where the structural elements are
both accepted and celebrated. The massive dome, supported by a cylindrical base, is a structural
feature that also serves as the central architectural element of the design. The harmony between
structure and form is one of the hallmarks of this iconic building.
■ Chrysler Building (New York, USA): The Chrysler Building is a prominent example where the
steel structure is both accepted and integrated into the architectural design. The sleek, streamlined
design of the skyscraper celebrates the industrial aesthetics of steel, contributing to the overall
elegance of the building.
■ Habitat 67 (Montreal, Canada): This modular housing project incorporates the structural system
into the design without overshadowing the architectural intent. The modules are stacked in a way
that supports the overall aesthetic while allowing for functional, residential living spaces.
6. Technological Advancements
Technological advancements continue to shape the future of structural design. The advent of 3D
printing, for example, allows for the rapid prototyping of complex structures, while building
performance simulation software helps predict how buildings will perform under various loads
and conditions.
LECTURE 10:- LEARNING FROM ANIMAL ARCHITECTURE
Mechanics of Structures:
The study of structures is often divided into two broad categories: statics and dynamics. Statics
examines how forces are distributed in a system when the structure is in equilibrium, i.e.,
forces acting on a building cancel out, resulting in a stable and unchanging state. Dynamics,
on the other hand, studies the response of structures to moving or changing loads. This is
essential for understanding how buildings behave under varying conditions such as wind or
seismic forces.
Types of Structural Forces: Structural forces are responsible for causing various types of
stress and deformation within a building. These forces include:
Compression: Forces that push or compress an object, shortening its length.
Tension: Forces that stretch an object, increasing its length.
Shear: Forces acting parallel to a material’s surface, which can cause sliding or shearing.
Bending: This is a combined effect of compression and tension, resulting in the curvature
of an element.
Torsion: Twisting forces that cause an object to rotate around its axis.
Stress and Strain:
Stress: Stress is the internal resistance of a material to deformation under an applied force. It is
typically expressed as force per unit area and can take different forms such as compressive,
tensile, or shear stress.
Strain: Strain is the deformation of a material in response to stress, calculated as the change in
length divided by the original length of the material.
Material Properties: Material properties play a significant role in determining the performance of
structural elements. Some of the key material properties discussed include:
Young’s Modulus: The ratio of stress to strain in a material, indicating its stiffness.
Poisson’s Ratio: A measure of the material's ability to deform in multiple directions when
subjected to stress.
Thermal Loads: Thermal expansion occurs when materials expand or contract due to temperature
changes. This can affect the integrity of structural elements. To accommodate thermal expansion
and contraction, expansion joints are included in the design of buildings.
Structural Requirements: To ensure that a building functions properly and safely, the structure must
meet the four key S's:
Strength: The material’s ability to resist forces without failure.
Stiffness: The material’s ability to resist deformation under applied loads.
Stability: The capacity of a structure to maintain its upright position and prevent buckling or
collapse.
Synergy: The interplay between different structural elements to form an efficient and stable
system.
LECTURE 12:- STRUCTURAL REQUIREMENTS
Primary Functions of Structures: The main function of any building’s structure is to support
and resist various types of loads. These include:
Dead Loads: These are the static loads from the building’s own weight, including
structural elements like walls and floors.
Live Loads: These are variable loads resulting from people, furniture, and other movable
items within the building.
Thermal Loads: Temperature fluctuations can cause materials to expand or contract,
influencing the overall stability of the structure.
Lateral Loads: Forces that act horizontally on the structure, such as those caused by
wind, earthquakes, or other external factors.
Dynamic Loads: These loads include impacts or other short-duration forces that vary
over time.
Essential Properties of Structures: Structures must have four key properties to effectively
resist loads and maintain stability:
Static Equilibrium: Ensuring that all forces and moments acting on a structure are
balanced.
Stability: The structure must be designed in a way that prevents collapse or tipping under
various conditions.
Strength: The materials used must have sufficient strength to withstand applied loads
without failure.
Rigidity: The structure must be stiff enough to resist excessive deformation and maintain
its shape under load.
Equilibrium Conditions: To ensure a structure’s stability, the following conditions must be
satisfied:
Net Horizontal Forces = 0
Net Vertical Forces = 0
Net Moments = 0
Geometric Stability: The shape and arrangement of structural elements significantly influence
a structure’s stability. For example:
A pyramid shape is inherently stable because of its broad base and tapering top, which
distributes the load effectively.
An inverted pyramid is unstable and would require additional support to maintain
equilibrium.
Examples of Stability: Real-world examples help illustrate structural stability:
The Cinepolis Headquarters demonstrates how centralized mass and projections are
used to create a balanced structure.
The Gateshead Millennium Bridge utilizes tension cables to maintain stability, despite its
seemingly unstable design.
Displacement and Overturning: Structures must be designed to resist lateral forces such as
wind or seismic activity, which can cause displacement and even overturning. Proper design,
including anchoring and reinforcement, is crucial to prevent such failures.
Buckling: Buckling occurs when compressive forces cause a structure to become laterally
unstable. To mitigate buckling, diagonal bracing or rigid frames can be used to strengthen the
structure and prevent deformation.
Displacement and Overturning: Structures must be designed to resist lateral forces such as wind
or seismic activity, which can cause displacement and even overturning. Proper design,
including anchoring and reinforcement, is crucial to prevent such failures.
Buckling: Buckling occurs when compressive forces cause a structure to become laterally
unstable. To mitigate buckling, diagonal bracing or rigid frames can be used to strengthen the
structure and prevent deformation.
Strength and Rigidity: Ensuring both strength and rigidity involves careful planning and analysis:
Assessment of Loads: All potential loads that may act on the structure must be identified.
Structural Analysis: How the structure will perform under these loads must be analyzed to
ensure safety.
Element Sizing: The proper cross-sections and materials must be selected to provide the
necessary strength and rigidity.
LECTURE 13:- BASIC STRUCTURAL ARRANGEMENTS
Structural Properties: The lecture began with a review of the forces acting on building
structures, including:
Compression: Forces that shorten an object.
Tension: Forces that elongate an object.
Bending: A combination of compression and tension caused by loads.
Supporting and Supported Structures: It is important to distinguish between supporting
structures (which bear the loads) and supported structures (which transfer loads to
supporting structures). For instance, a tabletop is supported by its legs, which transfer the
load to the ground.
Types of Structural Supports: Different types of supports are employed to stabilize
structures:
Roller Support: Allows horizontal movement but restricts vertical movement.
Pin Supports: Restricts both horizontal and vertical movements but permits rotation.
Rigid Supports: Fix all movements and provide maximum stability.
Basic Structural Elements: The four primary structural elements are:
Walls: Vertical components that support or divide spaces.
Slabs: Horizontal surfaces that form floors and ceilings.
Beams: Horizontal members that support loads and transfer them to columns.
Columns: Vertical members that carry loads from beams or slabs to the foundation.
Load Transfer Mechanism: Load transfer within a building follows a systematic path:
Loads on slabs are transferred to beams, which then carry the load to columns and
ultimately to the foundation and soil.
Structural Arrangements: Three common structural arrangements were discussed:
Wall-Slab System: Traditional arrangement where walls support the slabs.
Post-Lintel System: Vertical columns support horizontal beams, allowing for greater
openings in walls.
Post-Slab System: Slabs are directly supported by columns, without the use of beams.
Examples of Structural Arrangements:
Wall-Slab System: Used in traditional buildings with thick walls supporting slabs.
Post-Lintel System: Seen in classical structures such as the Parthenon.
Post-Slab System: Modern designs where slabs are supported by columns, providing
open spaces for flexible layouts.
Importance of Material Selection: Material selection is critical in structural design, affecting
the stability, strength, and efficiency of the building. Even if the arrangement of structural
elements remains the same, the materials used can significantly alter the performance of the
structure.
LECTURE 14:- STRUCTURAL FORMS AND SHAPES – A DETAILED
OVERVIEW
Density of Materials
The density of a material is critical in determining the weight and load-bearing capacity of the
structure. While denser materials often offer higher strength, they may also contribute to the
overall weight of the building, making them more difficult to handle or transport. The choice of
material must strike a balance between density and performance requirements for the specific
design.
Hardness
Hardness indicates how well a material resists wear, scratches, or permanent deformation.
Materials that are harder tend to be more durable and are preferred in applications that experience
significant friction or wear.
Ductility and Brittleness
Ductility is the ability of a material to undergo significant deformation before breaking. This
property is important in providing warning signs of failure. Brittleness, on the other hand, is
undesirable in materials used for structural elements because they tend to fail without much
deformation, often with disastrous consequences.
Elasticity and Toughness
Elasticity allows a material to return to its original shape once the applied stress is
removed. This property ensures that a material can perform well under fluctuating loads
without permanent deformation.
Toughness, on the other hand, is a material's ability to absorb energy before fracturing.
This property is particularly important for materials used in environments that experience
dynamic loads or impacts.
Overview of Structural Materials
The lecture covered a wide range of structural materials, each with its own advantages and
limitations:
■ Timber: A natural material that is lightweight and strong in tension and compression, but it is
susceptible to fire and moisture.
■ Masonry: A durable material that performs well in compression but is weak under tension.
■ Concrete: A versatile material that is excellent in compression but weak in tension unless
reinforced.
■ Steel: Strong in both tension and compression, steel is also ductile but is expensive and
prone to rust.
■ Reinforced Concrete: A composite material combining concrete’s compressive strength with
steel’s tensile strength, making it ideal for high-rise buildings.
■ Composite Materials: Lightweight materials that combine the properties of different
substances, offering enhanced performance for specific applications.