Design-Build Contracts: A

Comprehensive Overview
Design-build is a project delivery method that has been around for centuries, but it has seen a
resurgence of interest in modern construction. Projections estimate that nearly half of all
construction spending will utilize this model by 20261. Unlike the traditional design-bid-build
approach, where the owner hires separate entities for design and construction, design-build
streamlines the process by awarding a single contract to one entity (the design-builder)
responsible for both the design and construction phases of a project. This approach offers
several advantages that can significantly benefit project owners2.

Advantages of Design-Build Contracts

Design-build contracts offer numerous advantages over traditional construction methods,

making them an attractive option for various projects. Some of the key advantages include:

1. Single Point of Responsibility

One of the most significant advantages of design-build is the single point of responsibility. The
owner has only one entity to contact for all project-related matters, from design to construction.
This simplifies communication, streamlines decision-making, and eliminates the need for the
owner to mediate disputes between the designer and contractor4.

2. Streamlined Process

Design-build contracts promote a more efficient and streamlined construction process. By

integrating the design and construction phases, the project can move more swiftly, with fewer
delays and interruptions. This often leads to shorter project durations compared to traditional
methods. Moreover, design-build can lead to simplified construction drawings, further enhancing
efficiency5.

3. Cost Efficiency

Design-build contracts can contribute to cost savings in several ways. The design-builder can
optimize construction techniques and materials from the beginning, potentially lowering costs.
The integrated approach reduces the likelihood of expensive redesigns or modifications during
construction. The streamlined process can minimize overhead costs and reduce the need for
change orders. Additionally, design-build allows for earlier knowledge of firm costs, enabling
better budget planning and control2.

4. Reduced Risk

Design-build contracts typically shift more project risk to the design-builder. This can benefit the
owner, as any cost overruns linked to design errors or construction delays are generally the
responsibility of the design-builder, not the owner. This includes design liability, which is
transferred from the owner to the design-build firm1. Design-build also leads to fewer claims and
less litigation due to the collaborative nature of the process and the allocation of risk to those
best equipped to manage it2.

5. Enhanced Collaboration

Design-build fosters collaboration between the designer and the contractor. By working together
from the outset, they can better understand each other's perspectives, identify potential
challenges early on, and develop innovative solutions that meet the owner's needs and budget.
For example, the contractor can provide early input on design and material choices, ensuring
constructability and cost-effectiveness1.

6. Fostering Innovation

The collaborative nature of design-build encourages innovation in the construction process. The
design and construction teams can work together to explore new ideas, materials, and
technologies that can improve the project's quality, efficiency, and sustainability. Design-build
 allows for customization of the design to the site conditions, enabling more efficient and effective
solutions5.

7. Improved Quality Control

With unified responsibility, the design-builder has a vested interest in delivering high-quality
work that adheres to the specified criteria. This can lead to improved quality control throughout
the project, minimizing the risk of defects and ensuring that the final product meets the owner's
expectations. Design-build inherently promotes higher quality project outcomes due to the
integrated approach and shared responsibility2.

8. Faster Project Completion

Design-build contracts often result in faster project completion due to the streamlined process
and the ability to overlap design and construction phases. This can be particularly
advantageous for projects with tight deadlines or where time is of the essence10. Design-build
can facilitate fast-tracking schedules by allowing construction to begin on certain phases while
design is still being finalized for others5.

Potential Drawbacks and Challenges of Design-Build

Contracts

While design-build offers numerous advantages, it's essential to be aware of potential

drawbacks and challenges:

●​ Reduced Owner Control: The owner may have less control over the design process
compared to traditional methods8.
●​ Potential for Higher Costs: Without competitive bidding for the construction phase, the
overall project cost may be higher. However, it's important to note that while initial cost
estimates might be higher, the final cost could be lower due to fewer unforeseen
complications during construction9.
●​ Reliance on the Design-Builder: The owner is heavily reliant on the design-builder's
 competence and integrity1.
●​ Limited Design Flexibility: Once the design-build contract is awarded, making significant
changes to the design can be more challenging and costly11.
●​ Disputes over Design Assumptions: Owners often assert that their designs are preliminary
and should not be relied upon, which can lead to disputes with contractors who may argue
that they are entitled to rely on the accuracy of the provided designs14.
●​ Potential for Compromise on Design Innovation: There is a possibility of compromise on
design innovation in design-build contracts as the focus might shift towards cost-effectiveness
and constructability14.
●​ Contractor Prioritizing Cost Savings: The contractor might select materials and
construction techniques that minimize their costs or complexity at the expense of better
options, potentially sacrificing long-term durability or maintenance for immediate cost
savings6.
●​ Need for Thorough RFP and High Degree of Trust: The design-build concept is still
unfamiliar to many owners, so expectations must be clearly communicated in a thorough
RFP. A high degree of trust must be established between the owner and contractor due to
fewer checks and balances in subcontractor negotiations and payment requests9.
●​ Contractual Considerations: The design-build contract needs to include a reasonable risk
assessment, a clear process for handling changes, and a prescriptive take on
communications to ensure smooth project execution1.
●​ Clearly Defined Requirements and Open Communication: To mitigate risks, it is essential
for clients to clearly define their requirements, maintain open communication with the
design-build firm, and ensure that contracts include clauses that protect their interests, such
as detailed performance specifications, caps on change order costs, and clear dispute
resolution mechanisms6.

How Design-Build Contracts Streamline the

Construction Process

Design-build contracts streamline the construction process in several ways:

●​ Project Initiation: The owner defines the project scope, goals, and budget6.
●​ Selection of Design-Builder: The owner selects a design-builder based on qualifications,
experience, and proposed approach. This selection process emphasizes not just cost, but
also the design-builder's ability to meet design and construction timelines and their
understanding of the owner's vision and needs4.
●​ Early Involvement of the Contractor: The contractor is involved in the project from the
beginning, providing valuable input during the design phase. This helps to ensure that the
design is constructible and cost-effective1.
●​ Project Design: The design phase is collaborative and integrated with construction
considerations. The design-build team works closely with the owner to develop the design,
ensuring it aligns with the owner's requirements and budget6.
●​ Overlapping Phases: Design and construction phases can overlap, allowing construction to
begin before the final design is complete. This can significantly shorten the overall project
timeline5.
●​ Site Inspection and Selection: Engineers and surveyors inspect the site to assess its
suitability for the project, considering factors such as soil conditions, topography, and existing
infrastructure15.
●​ Construction Execution: The design-builder manages the physical construction of the
project, coordinating all activities and ensuring adherence to safety standards. The contractor
plays a crucial role in coordinating construction activities to ensure that the project is
completed on time and within the specified budget5.
●​ Safety Reports and Procedures: Safety is paramount in design-build projects. The
design-builder implements safety procedures and generates reports to ensure compliance
with safety standards and regulations15.
●​ Project Closeout and Post-Construction Review: Once construction is completed, the
project undergoes a thorough inspection and review process. A simplified checklist of items to
be addressed during project sign-off includes architects signing a completion form, the owner
confirming payment completion, scheduling inspections, and handing over key documents to
the owner15.

Fostering Collaboration in Design-Build Contracts

Design-build contracts promote collaboration between the designer and the contractor in several
 ways:

●​ Joint Responsibility: Both the designer and the contractor are jointly responsible for the
project's success. This encourages them to work together closely and share their expertise to
achieve the best possible outcome7.
●​ Early Communication: The design and construction teams communicate from the outset,
fostering a shared understanding of the project goals, challenges, and solutions. For instance,
during project conception, collaboration with design-build teams offers the advantage of
pulling in the architects and engineers early to help shape the project1.
●​ Integrated Decision-Making: Decisions are made collaboratively, with input from both the
designer and the contractor. This ensures that all perspectives are considered and that the
best decisions are made for the project7.
●​ Mutual Respect and Trust: Design-build fosters a culture of mutual respect and trust
between the designer and the contractor. This creates a more positive and productive working
relationship, leading to better project outcomes2.

Promoting Innovation in Design-Build Contracts

Design-build contracts promote innovation in the construction process by:

●​ Encouraging Creativity: The collaborative environment encourages the design and

construction teams to think outside the box and explore new ideas and solutions. For
example, in a warehousing project, the design-builder might consider various lighting options
to meet performance requirements while optimizing cost-effectiveness and energy efficiency7.
●​ Facilitating Value Engineering: The early involvement of the contractor allows for value
engineering from the beginning, optimizing the design for cost-effectiveness and
constructability. For instance, the contractor can provide input on material choices and
construction techniques to achieve the desired design intent while minimizing costs7.
●​ Embracing New Technologies: Design-build teams are more likely to embrace new
technologies and construction methods that can improve efficiency, sustainability, and
quality7.
 Suitable Projects for Design-Build Contracts

While design-build can be used for various projects, some are particularly well-suited for this
approach:

●​ Projects with Tight Schedules: Design-build's ability to accelerate project delivery makes it
ideal for projects with tight deadlines10.
●​ Complex Projects: The single point of responsibility and collaborative approach are
beneficial for managing the complexities of large or intricate projects10.
●​ Projects with a Focus on Innovation: Design-build fosters innovation, making it suitable for
projects that require creative solutions or the use of new technologies7.
●​ Projects with a Fixed Budget: The early knowledge of firm costs and reduced risk of cost
overruns make design-build attractive for projects with fixed budgets2.

In addition to the above, there are a few other design-build procurement approaches worth
considering:

●​ Two-Step Best Value Design-Build: This approach involves a two-step procurement

process. First, the most highly qualified design-builders are identified. Then, design and cost
proposals are sought from these qualified candidates. The owner selects the design-builder
offering the best value proposal, considering a combination of design, project approach, and
contract price2.
●​ Progressive Design-Build: In this approach, the design-builder is selected primarily based
on qualifications. After selection, the owner and design-builder collaborate to progressively
advance the design and cost model toward a mutually agreeable design concept and contract
price2.
●​ Design-Build-Maintain: Design-build procurements can be combined with long-term
maintenance activities to generate additional project benefits from a lifecycle asset
management perspective. In this approach, the design-builder is also responsible for the
maintenance of the facility after construction is completed3.

Examples of projects that commonly use design-build include:

 Project Type Examples

Infrastructure Bridges, roads, railways, dams

Government Buildings Courts, city hall, prisons

Commercial Buildings Banks, office parks, shopping malls

Healthcare Facilities Hospitals, pharmacies, wellness centers

Residential Buildings Single homes, housing developments

Industrial Facilities Warehouses, factories, manufacturing

facilities

Military Facilities Bases, radar stations, training facilities

Energy Projects Power stations, communication towers,

dams

Sports Facilities Stadiums, gyms, public swimming pools

Legal Aspects of Design-Build Contracts

While design-build offers a streamlined approach, it's important to be aware of the unique legal
aspects associated with this project delivery method. Some key legal considerations include:
●​ Liability: Design-build contracts typically place the responsibility for both design and
construction on the design-builder. This can lead to complex liability issues, especially when
design errors or defects occur14.
●​ Insurance Coverage: Adequate insurance coverage is crucial in design-build projects to
protect all parties involved. The design-builder needs to have insurance that covers both
design and construction liabilities16.
●​ Bonding: Bonding requirements may vary depending on the project and jurisdiction. It's
essential to ensure that the design-builder has the necessary bonds in place to protect the
owner's interests16.
●​ Public Procurement Requirements: Design-build projects in the public sector are subject to
specific procurement regulations and statutes. Compliance with these requirements is crucial
to ensure a fair and transparent procurement process16.
●​ Licensing: Design-build entities need to have the appropriate licenses and qualifications to
perform both design and construction services16.
●​ Historical Context: California public contract law has historically been hostile to design-build
due to concerns about competitive bidding and potential conflicts of interest. However,
legislation has been enacted to allow for the use of design-build in certain circumstances8.

Conclusion

Design-build contracts offer a streamlined and collaborative approach to construction project

delivery. By integrating design and construction under a single contract, this method can lead to
faster project completion, cost savings, reduced risk, and enhanced innovation. While some
potential drawbacks exist, the advantages of design-build make it an attractive option for various
construction projects.

Key takeaways from the research material include:

●​ Early Contractor Involvement: The early involvement of the contractor in the design
process is crucial for ensuring constructability, cost-effectiveness, and innovation.
●​ Project Risk: Design-build shifts the design liability and much of the project risk to the
design-builder, potentially benefiting the owner.
●​ Collaboration and Trust: Design-build fosters collaboration and trust between the designer
 and contractor, leading to better project outcomes.

When considering design-build, it's essential to:

●​ Carefully evaluate the project's specific needs and goals.

●​ Select a qualified and experienced design-builder with a proven track record.
●​ Clearly define project requirements and expectations in the contract.
●​ Maintain open communication with the design-builder throughout the project.
●​ Thoroughly vet the design-build contractor by asking questions related to both design
and construction aspects9.

By carefully considering these factors and addressing potential challenges, owners can
leverage the benefits of design-build to achieve successful project outcomes.

Works cited

1. The Design-Build Method of Project Delivery Explained - Procore, accessed February 11,
2025, https://www.procore.com/library/design-build-construction
2. What Is Design-Build? - DBIA, accessed February 11, 2025,
https://dbia.org/what-is-design-build/
3. Design Build - FHWA - Center for Innovative Finance Support - Alternative Project Delivery
Defined: New Build facilities, accessed February 11, 2025,
https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/ipd/alternative_project_delivery/defined/new_build_facilities/design_bu
ild.aspx
4. What Is Design-Build Construction? - ACE Building Service, accessed February 11, 2025,
https://www.acebuildingservice.com/what-is-design-build-construction
5. Design-Build Contract: Purpose, How They Work, When to Use, accessed February 11, 2025,
https://www.contractscounsel.com/t/us/design-build-contract
6. Complete Overview of Design-Build Contracts - RunSensible, accessed February 11, 2025,
https://www.runsensible.com/blog/complete-overview-of-design-build-contracts/
7. 3 Key Reasons to Use Design-Build for Your Next Construction Project - ARCO/Murray,
accessed February 11, 2025,
https://www.arcomurray.com/3-key-reasons-to-use-design-build-for-your-next-construction-proje
ct/
8. Design-Build Contracts as an Alternative Method for the Construction of Public Buildings -
League of California Cities, accessed February 11, 2025,
https://www.cacities.org/Resources-Documents/Member-Engagement/Professional-Department
s/City-Attorneys/Library/2003/9-2003-Annual_Niece_Design-Build-Contracts-as-an-A
9. Pros and Cons of Hiring a Design-Build Contractor - CBF Contracting, accessed February 11,
2025, https://cbfcontractinginc.com/pros-cons-hiring-design-build-contractor/
10. When to Use Design Build - hm-ec.com, accessed February 11, 2025,
https://www.hm-ec.com/blog-posts/when-to-use-the-design-build-approach-choosing-the-right-d
elivery-method-hm
11. Pros and Cons of Design Build - accesstopower, accessed February 11, 2025,
https://www.accesstopower.com/blog/pros-and-cons-of-design-build
12. Design-Build vs Design-Bid-Build: Key Differences, Benefits, and Contract Frameworks,
accessed February 11, 2025,
https://learn.aiacontracts.com/articles/6484325-what-is-the-difference-between-design-build-and
-design-bid-build/
13. Design-Bid-Build vs. Design-Build: Pros & Cons | Dumpsters.com, accessed February 11,
2025, https://www.dumpsters.com/blog/design-bid-build-vs-design-build
14. LEGAL IMPLICATIONS OF DESIGN AND BUILD CONTRACTS: A FOCUS ON LIABILITY
AND WARRANTIES, accessed February 11, 2025,
https://www.legal500.com/developments/thought-leadership/legal-implications-of-design-and-bui
ld-contracts-a-focus-on-liability-and-warranties/
15. Use Design and Build Contracts for Seamless Project Delivery - PandaDoc, accessed
February 11, 2025, https://www.pandadoc.com/blog/design-and-build-contract/
16. Legal Aspects of the Design-Build Method of Construction Delivery. - DTIC, accessed
February 11, 2025, https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/tr/pdf/ADA359466.pdf