Source
Source
Department of Public Health, Brigham Young University, College of Life Sciences, Provo, Utah
Abstract
Introduction: This study explores parental and sibling mental health challenges associated with
a child having autism spectrum disorder (ASD). Potential moderator and mediator effects of the
association between ASD and family mental health are also considered, along with interventions
health effects on mothers, fathers, and siblings of children with ASD. The accessed literature
came from an electronic search conducted through October 2021. Well-known databases were
emotional, communication, sleep, and delayed social problems, parents of children with ASD
experience greater familial stress. Mothers tend to experience more stress, anxiety, and
depression than fathers do. Fathers tend to experience stress due to the mother’s mental health
challenges as well as a lack of confidence in raising a child with ASD. Added stress for both
parties comes from strained marital relationships and other factors. Studies of siblings of children
with ASD have shown positive effects in terms of self-concept and social competence, whereas
other studies have shown negative effects like low levels of prosocial behaviors, feelings of
loneliness, and delays in developing social skills. Older male siblings have greater risk for
behavioral and emotional difficulties and siblings later in the birth order have greater risk of
Discussion: Mothers gain greater positive outcomes by receiving assistance from family, friends,
and professionals. Fathers feel empowered when involved in educational interventions that
3
Mental Health of Families with ASD
demonstrate how to care for their child with ASD. Constructive outcomes are achieved for
Keywords
Introduction
Autism derives from the word autos, signifying a person who keeps to him/herself, isolated from
surrounding interactions [1]. The term “autism” was first used in 1908 to describe a group of
schizophrenic patients who were unaware of the world around them. In the 1940s, Leo Kanner
children. This was the primary observational insight in acknowledging autism as a definite
syndrome [2]. Now, more than 80 years later, a stronger definition and understanding of autism
deficits in social communication and social interactions across different contexts, restricted and
repetitive patterns of behavior, and unusual responses to sensory stimuli [3]. Social challenges
include avoiding personal interactions and having difficulty expressing emotion [4].
Communication challenges consist of delayed or absent speech [5]. Behavioral challenges may
In the United States, approximately 1 in 54 children are diagnosed with autism according to a
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) report based on data in 2016 [3]. Autism is
more common in whites and males [3]. It is classified as a developmental disorder because of its
manifestations in the initial years of life, most commonly at 20-30 months, but can be detected as
4
Mental Health of Families with ASD
early as 18 months [5]. From ages 0-3, children typically hit certain milestones (e.g, walking,
talking, sharing, and expressing emotions) [9]. Delays in these milestones indicates the
possibility of autism [9]. Children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) face unique encounters
throughout the school years, such as a change of routine and familiarity due to change in
classmates, teachers, or subjects, which may cause disruption and discouragement for children
with ASD [9]. Improved education and increased awareness of the special challenges faced by
There is no known cure for ASD, but some of the symptoms may be effectively regulated.
Therapies and testing are underway to govern the core deficits of ASD [11]. Some therapies
include neuro-feedback training and speech therapy to enhance cognitive skills, virtual
psycho-education therapy to increase learning rate and attention control, and assistive tools to
develop reading and comprehending skills [1]. Treatments and studies regarding the subject are
well documented and advancing rapidly [1]. Treatment outcomes demonstrate various effects on
children with ASD, but often overlook how the impact of the outcomes may differ if caregiver
Researchers have found that parents of children with ASD are at greater risk of stress
proliferation (i.e., a tendency of stressors to cause more stressors in other domains of life)
[13]. It has long been recognized that autism is associated with several family stressors such as
communication problems, marital conflict, lack of bonding, erratic sleep patterns, problems with
changes in routine, splinter effects, reduced ability to socialize, need for respite, future related
worry, and unique financial matters [14]. The arrival of a child with a disability has the potential
5
Mental Health of Families with ASD
to either weaken family relationships or be a source of unity in the family [15]. Responses may
differ between mothers, fathers, and siblings as they work to understand, teach, and care for a
child with ASD. Identifying differences in responses among the mother, father, and siblings may
allow for further emphasis to be placed on positive interventions that can improve possible
mental health challenges [14]. Families are encouraged to participate as a group in making
program decisions for the affected child and to receive coping and training skills through
With mental pressures associated with raising a child with ASD, studies have predominantly
been focused on mothers of children with ASD [16-18], which is consistent with women most
often being the primary care provider. One study found that caregivers of children with ASD are
mostly the biological parents (95%), and predominately the mother (89%) [19]. However, the
father is sometimes the primary care provider and, likewise, plays an equally important role in
raising a child with ASD [20]. In addition to parents, it is important to consider how siblings of
those with ASD are affected and ways in which they cope [21]. The ASD child’s age, gender,
issues, and more may influence the families overall mental health outcomes [21-28].
The primary purpose of the current study was to identify parental and sibling mental health
outcomes associated with ASD children; identify moderator (e.g., age and gender of the child)
and mediator (e.g., parenting stress, marital conflict, family and economic pressure, future-
related worry) effects of the association between ASD and family mental health; and review
Methods
siblings of children with ASD were reviewed. The accessed literature was found through an
electronic search that was conducted through 2021. Literature was accessed using four well-
known databases (i.e., Medline, Embase, Cochrane, and Scopus). Search terms included
stress in siblings OR parental stress OR AND children with autism spectrum disorder OR
children with ASD. The authors independently reviewed the titles and abstracts of articles to
identify relevant studies for full-text review. Additionally, the authors sought to distinguish
certain characteristics of the mothers, fathers, and siblings of children with ASD (e.g, mental
health, age and gender of the ASD child, and the parental gender of focus) and the behavioral
A total of 84 studies published in the scientific literature during the period 2000 to 2021 were
Results
Study designs identified in this paper were primarily cross-sectional surveys (n = 67), followed
by literature reviews (n = 5), longitudinal studies (n = 4), meta-analyses (n = 5), diary studies (n
= 2), and a case-control study (n = 1). The surveys incorporated several validated instruments for
measuring autism; behavioral problems; parental stress, anxiety, and depression; adaptability;
resilience; coping; and more. The literature reviews identified an increased risk of family mental
7
Mental Health of Families with ASD
health problems in homes with ASD children, that stigma negatively influenced parental mental
health, and that ASD children have an increased risk of sleep disorders [23, 29-32]. The
longitudinal studies identified higher mental health problems in parents of ASD children and
found that home training, interventions, and coping strategies can lower parental stress and other
mental health problems [33-36]. The meta-analyses focused on interventions that do not require a
specialist in treating individuals with ASD [37]; identified higher risk of depression and
psychiatric difficulties in parents of children with ASD [38, 39]; correlated short- and long-term
sleep duration with depression [40]; showed that parental stress can be significantly reduced
through mindfulness or relaxation training; and that parent style and satisfaction can be improved
through parental education [41]. The two diary studies covered different topics. The first
identified poorer partner relationships in parents of ASD children [42], and the second found that
mothers of ASD children had higher rates of mental health problems, in part because of greater
time pressure, but social support was an effective means for lowering maternal mental health
problems [43]. The case-control study identified factors associated with stress in mothers of
children with autism [44]. Parental mental health is directly related to ASD.
Among the 84 studies, 21 focused on comparing mental health outcomes of mothers and fathers
of children with ASD; 33 assessed the direct relationship between parental mental health and
ASD; 33 assessed indirect relationships between parental mental health and ASD; 8 considered
sibling mental health; 23 presented ways to reduce mental health problems; and 5 explored
The primary outcome variables considered in the studies were stress (n = 42), anxiety (n = 16),
depression (n = 28), and other (e.g., family unity, happiness and fulfillment, personal strength,
personal maturity and growth, greater social network, physical health) (n = 53). Research
8
Mental Health of Families with ASD
indicates that stress mediates the association between having a child with ASD and anxiety or
depression [45-47]. In the current study, several papers found an increased risk of both stress and
anxiety [45, 47-49, 52, 54, 55] and stress and depression [30, 45, 47, 49-57] among mothers
One study involving female caregivers found that stress was associated with avoidance strategies
(self-blame, denial, emotional venting, and disengagement) [57]. One study involving male
caregivers found that stress was associated with nervousness, hopelessness, and worthlessness
[58]. Increased physical health problems associated with having an ASD child may further
contribute to parental stress [19, 28, 58]. Several studies found that parental stress was positively
associated with the severity of their child’s ASD [59 60 61]. Other factors contributing to
parental stress include behavioral problems [24, 55, 58, 62-66]; social disability [50, 61, 66, 67];
spousal relationship problems and partner depression [51, 68]; being a sole parent or caregiver
[60]; economic burden [29]; eating, sleeping, and emotional problems [24, 69]; cooccurring
ADHD and OCD [70]; and concern for the child’s future, poor health, and permanency of the
condition [29, 65]. Parental stress may also be associated with the ASD child’s age and sex. One
study found that stress was greater if the child was less than age 12 because younger age are
more likely associated with the initial diagnosis and treatment [69]. Another study focusing on
preschool aged children with ASD found that fathers had greater stress if their child was female
[25]. This study of preschoolers also found that age 5 was associated with greater parental stress.
More severe depression and lower health-related quality of life was associated with an older
Of the studies identified in this paper, 19 involved mothers only, 3 involved fathers only, 53
Mothers
Mothers are often the focus in studies of children with ASD, as they tend to spend a higher
proportion of time with their child. The accumulation of research indicates that mothers
experience stress at levels that make them more susceptible to anxiety, depression, and cellular
aging beyond their years [54, 71]. This section highlights selected outcomes, causes of mental
health problems, positive outcomes, and interventions and self-redirection for women of children
with ASD.
Studies have consistently shown that mothers of children with ASD experience higher stress
compared with mothers of normally developing children [44, 53-56, 63]. In one study, 42% of
mothers hit a clinical level of stress and an additional 28% had moderately elevated stress [34].
In many cases, stress can be severe enough to result in insomnia [72], withdrawal [44], anxiety
[27, 46, 49], and depression [49, 51]. However, not all studies found stress to be a precursor of
Behavioral problems (e.g, hurting others, damaging property, and self-injury) in ASD children
have been associated with maternal stress [52, 62], anxiety [66], depression [34, 66], and lower
life satisfaction [73]. Behavioral problems in ASD children have been identified as the strongest
predictor of maternal psychological distress [55, 59]. Research has shown that child behavior
difficulties mediate the association between ASD symptoms and maternal stress [63, 74]. Higher
severity of challenging behaviors in children with ASD positively correlate with higher levels of
In a study linking maternal depression with child behavioral problems, maternal depression was
also associated with maternal anxiety symptoms and poor mood, low parenting efficacy and
social support, and poor coping styles [34]. When a child’s disruptive behavior extends into
public settings, levels of maternal stress, anxiety or depression significantly increase [66].
Increased stress may be particularly present when the mother of an ASD child is not able to
Studies demonstrate that women find refuge in social interactions, whether it is with
organizations or with close friends or family [43, 75, 76]. Research has also shown that for
women of children with ASD, social support correlates with greater optimism, which, in turn,
leads to lower levels of stress and depression [43, 50]. In a study assessing the association
between behavior and emotional problems and maternal life satisfaction, the negative effect of
these problems on life satisfaction occurred when there was little or no perceived social support
[75]. Having no childcare support, low satisfaction with their healthcare provider, and needing to
work outside the home have further been associated with depression in mothers of children with
ASD [76].
Positive Outcomes
Although it has been shown that mothers are more inclined than fathers to develop stress,
anxiety, and depression while raising a child with ASD [36, 47, 49, 52, 55, 69, 77], it has also
been shown that mothers tend to experience more positive outcomes than fathers [48,, 51 55, 78,
79]. Families of children with ASD often experience resilience by making positive meaning of
disability, mobilization of resources, becoming a closer and more united family, developing a
greater appreciation for life and in others, and gaining spiritual strength [80]. One study found
that mother’s perception of positive contributions of having an ASD child, such as learning by
11
Mental Health of Families with ASD
experience, happiness and fulfillment, personal strength and family closeness, understanding the
purpose of life, personal maturity and growth, awareness of future issues, greater social network,
career and job growth, and pride and correction, are higher than father’s perceptions [48].
In a study assessing mental health in mothers with a disabled child, their mental health was
positively associated with participation in healthy activity, feelings of empowerment, and the
child’s psychosocial health [71]. A sense of competence, taking things a day at a time, and
emotional support from a spouse can effectively promote maternal well-being when raising a
It has been shown that maternal anxiety and depression can decrease by using interventions to
monitor and lower core symptoms of children with ASD [82]. Interventions may include
promoting healthy activities and empowerment among mothers of ASD children, as well as
addressing the psychological needs of the child [71]. They may also focus on regulating severe
behavior problems of children with ASD. Researchers say that this requires dedication to a
dependable routine of the child’s schedule and guidance on proper behavior in order to decrease
maternal stress [59]. Interventions aimed to lower maternal stress among mothers of ASD
children may consider the child’s needs and behaviors; the mother’s personal needs and ability to
organize; familial and spousal relationships; service availability and adequacy; and the
environment in which the family lives [66, 80, 83]. In addition, positive social exchange with
one’s spouse was shown to be a primary means of lowering depressive symptoms in mothers of
Mothers of autistic children may redefine what constitutes the fulfillment of various human
needs and/or seek to find alternative ways to fulfill them. In one study, mothers of children
with ASD placed less emphasis on their own careers and focused more on their parental
role; spent more leisure time with extended family members; put less emphasis on what
others thought about their child’s behavior; put more emphasis on spousal support and the
parental role in discussions about marriage; entertained more than one interpretation
about their child’s behavior; and showed a tendency toward a greater overall tolerance of
Fathers
Fewer studies have assessed mental health and social outcomes of fathers of children with ASD.
This is likely because fathers are generally less involved than mothers in raising children with
ASD [31]. Nevertheless, it has been shown that fathers are fully capable of promoting father-
child social interactions wherein the child responds well to them [85]. This section highlights
selected mental health outcome measures, with more emphasis on differences between fathers
Fathers, like mothers of ASD children experience higher stress [25, 33, 51, 87]. In one study,
17% of fathers of ASD children had higher risk for psychological distress; 16% experienced poor
global health; and 16-18% engaged in adverse health behaviors (e.g., alcohol abuse, cigarette
smoking) [58]. In another study, father’s stress was linked more to the child’s externalizing
behaviors and mother’s stress was linked more to the child’s eating, sleeping, and emotional
regulation [69].
13
Mental Health of Families with ASD
Research has found that fathers are more likely than mothers of ASD children to ignore their
own mental health issues [87], express less emotion, seek less social support, and have poorer
coping skills [69]. For example, mothers do better than fathers in coping (e.g., by communicating
questions and seeking information), while fathers tend to just avoid the stressful situation (e.g.,
going to work) [69]. Both mothers and fathers of ASD children experience significantly higher
levels of anxiety and depression [36], but fathers appear to have lower levels of anxiety than
mothers [88]. While research has found that fathers also have lower levels of stress than mothers
of children with ASD [36, 47, 49, 52, 55, 69, 77, 89], mothers adapt better to stress and stress is a
Negative social exchange with one’s spouse has been shown to have a positive association with
depressive symptoms for both fathers and mothers of children with ASD [74]. An older study
explained that although mothers may be more susceptible to stress, depression, and parental
burnout, if parental roles change (with fathers assuming a greater role in providing direct care)
stress levels may become more equally shared [90]. In the same study, three main outcomes were
related to increase stress in fathers of children with ASD: strained marriage, poor self-
One study evaluated parental coping mechanisms such as escape/avoidance, which is a strategy
of trying to nullify or forget the challenge at hand [91]. The escape/avoidance mechanism often
results in social isolation and neglect of the marital relationship. Stress may arise in the marital
relationship when the couple neglects to spend time together [62]. While mothers are often the
primary care provider, it is important for fathers to equally care for children with ASD [91].
Studies have shown that the stress of the family unit (e.g. spousal relationship, sibling
14
Mental Health of Families with ASD
Intervention
A quasi-experimental research design was used to examine parental stress through the Parenting
Stress Index-Short Form (PSI) before and after testing an intervention [33]. The intervention was
a father-based initiative, where the father was taught four methods: following the child’s lead in
play; imitating and exaggerating the child’s actions, to prevent parent-child reciprocity; effective
communication through clear signals; commenting on child’s actions rather than asking
The PSI is a self-report questionnaire that measures stress by assessing the parent’s perceptions
of both self and child. A PSI score of 90 is considered clinical. At pretest, mothers and fathers
reported an average PSI level of 96.4 and 90.5, respectively. After a 12-week training for an
intervention program, the mother’s average PSI level dropped to 89.9 and the father's PSI fell to
83.7. The results were significant for mothers. Although the decrease in the fathers’ mean score
was notable, it was not statistically significant because of the large variability in the scores [33].
In general, interventions that educate fathers on caring for their child with ASD that include
working alongside their spouse in raising their child have shown positive results in stress relief
Empowerment
Empowerment (ability to actively satisfy one’s needs, gain control of one’s life, overcome
obstacles) has been studied in both fathers [92] and mothers [71] of children with ASD. Higher
empowerment corresponds with better mental health [71]. Unfortunately, empowerment tends to
15
Mental Health of Families with ASD
be lower in fathers of children with ASD than fathers of normal developing children [92]. Social
Fathers of children with ASD often lack confidence in feeling capable of raising their child [92].
If fathers gain a better understanding of the disorder and the available services for their child and
family, they may feel more empowered and confident in fulfilling their role in caring for their
child [92]. However, implementing certain coping strategies may help lower paternal stress. For
example, researchers found that fathers demonstrated lower levels of stress due to their ability to
use different strategies of coping in relation to their child with ASD. Because of these different
coping strategies, fathers were able to bear their child’s behaviors in an adaptive manner that
Parental Unit
Sometimes studies do not differentiate by “father” or “mother,” but classify parents as a unit. For
example, in a study of high-functioning children with autism, parental stress was evaluated along
with sibling adjustment and family functioning [86]. Parents of children with high-functioning
autism showed greater stress than parents of children with no psychological disorder. The fact
that these children were high functioning did not compensate for the increased stress parents
experienced because of their child’s primary symptoms. In another study, parents of toddlers that
had ASD experienced increased stress compared with parents of toddlers with developmental
One study found that family support had a direct, positive effect on family quality of life and
indirect effect on family quality of life through stress [94]. Another study showed that social
support had a positive effect on family cohesion and adaptability [95]. Specifically, social
16
Mental Health of Families with ASD
support in the form of subjective support (an individual’s level of satisfaction of being
supported) and utilization support (degree individuals make use of available social support), but
not objective support (visual or actual social support), were found to increase family cohesion
and adaptability.
In a study assessing the partner relationship in families with ASD children, individual optimism,
benefit finding, coping strategies, and social (instrumental and emotional) support positively
related to relationship satisfaction [96]. Note that instrumental support involves seeking advice
assistance from another. Emotional support involves seeking moral support (sympathy or
understanding).
Though many parents experience hardships from raising a child with ASD, there are some
benefits that warrant consideration. Some positive outcomes described by parents of children
with ASD are personal growth, empowerment to help others, spiritual growth, stronger couple
relationships, a more united family unit, and new career discoveries [78]. Another study found
that the greatest factor contributing to positive outcomes in a mother’s mental health was when
there were informational and emotional social exchanges from both within and outside the
family [75].
Divorce
When comparing couples with and without a child with ASD, a significantly higher rate of
divorce occurred in families with an autistic child [97]. Divorce remained high through the ASD
child’s childhood, adolescence, and early adulthood. Divorce was more likely for younger
maternal age when the ASD child was born and if the child was born later in the birth order [97].
17
Mental Health of Families with ASD
Sleep
Children with ASD tend to have higher levels of sleep disorders [32, 98], which contributes to
disrupted sleep and maternal stress [68, 99]. The majority of children with ASD follow a sleep-
wake pattern for sleeping and experience a sleep onset delay [98]. For several reasons, sleep for a
child with ASD is a major concern and challenge for parents. Difficulty to sleep interferes with
brain development, thus creating additional difficult behaviors for parents to monitor [32].
Difficulty to develop a regular sleep schedule for children with ASD disrupts the parent’s sleep
cycle. A meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies, which included 25,271 participants for
short sleep duration and 23,663 participants for long sleep duration, found that adults who
followed short or long sleep duration patterns had a greater risk of depression [40]. The authors
indicated that short duration sleep patterns induced depression from a lack of sleep and long
duration sleep patterns were induced from a lack of physical activity [40].
Siblings
Considering siblings is important because they, like their parents, have various experiences of
coping with parental stress and individual consequences of working with a sibling who has ASD.
Yet the subsystems (mother-father relationship, sibling relationships, and peer relationships)
make the sibling relationship complicated. A review study found mixed results with respect to
outcome and adjustment variables for siblings of individuals with ASD [23]. While some studies
showed positive effects in terms of self-concept and social competence, other studies showed
negative effects like low levels of prosocial behaviors (actions to help other people), increased
developing social skills. One study found that siblings of children with ASD without a diagnosed
18
Mental Health of Families with ASD
disorder are not at increased risk of psychosocial problems, compared to children in the general
population [100]. In another study, siblings of children with ASD had similar
emotional/behavioral adjustment but less involvement and more avoidance of their sibling as
normally developing children [101]. Older male siblings in this study were at greater risk for
behavioral/emotional difficulties. A study of siblings of children with ASD found that while the
firstborn child does not experience greater likelihood of feeling lonely and socially dissatisfied, a
sibling of an ASD child later in the birth order is more likely to feel lonely and socially
dissatisfied [102].
Both mothers and fathers are more likely to rate siblings of ASD children as having more
emotional problems and lower prosocial behavior when compared with normally developing
children [103, 104]. These studies involving parent’s perceptions may differ from sibling’s
perceptions. For example, one study found that overall, siblings did not feel negative emotions
toward the affected sibling while parents often reported a more negative perception of the impact
In one paper, sibling relationships were studied by using the Family Systems Framework, which
recognizes the interrelatedness and evolving dynamics of the family unit. The authors suggest
children toward their sibling with ASD [106]. In order to promote positive sibling involvement
and family functioning the authors identified key features that should be addressed such as
developmental level, communication status, and areas of strength, challenge, and interest.
19
Mental Health of Families with ASD
Discussion
Children with ASD bring new life changes for mothers, fathers, and siblings. There have been
several studies that have focused on how children with ASD can influence the mental health of
their mothers. The mental health of fathers and siblings of children with ASD have received less
attention. The aim of this review was to present the mental health effects commonly experienced
by parents of children with ASD, identify how ASD affects family mental health, and discuss
some of the interventions and positive effects associated with ASD children.
Severity and behavioral problems like self-injury and disruptive public outbursts in ASD
children are the primary causes of parental psychological stress [24, 55, 58-66]. There is
considerable evidence that a proliferation of stress results for mothers and father of children with
ASD [13, 25, 33, 51, 87]. This proliferation relates negatively to hope, confidence, self-worth,
communication, marriage, bonding, sleep, socialization, finances, and more [14, 24, 29, 50, 57,
58, 61, 65-67, 69, 70]. Stress also increases the risk of anxiety and/or depression [45-47].
Increased sleep disorders in ASD children and resulting sleep disturbances in parents is a
potential mediating cause of parental depression [40]. Research has found that stress-induced
There is some evidence that social support is a moderator of the association between ASD child
behavior and maternal depression [73]. The association between ASD and parental stress may
also be moderated by the child’s age and sex [25-27]. Behavioral difficulties may mediate the
association between ASD and maternal stress [63, 74]. In turn, stress may mediate the
association between ASD and anxiety and/or depression [36, 46, 48].
20
Mental Health of Families with ASD
Differences were observed in the mental health between mothers and fathers of children with
ASD, with mothers more inclined than fathers to experience stress, anxiety, and depression [36,
47, 49, 52, 55, 69, 77, 89]. However, mothers adapt better to stress [33, 47, 48, 55] and
experience more positive outcomes (e.g., learning by experience, happiness and fulfillment,
personal strength and family closeness, understanding the purpose of life, personal maturity and
growth, awareness of future issues, greater social network, higher spiritual strength, career and
job growth, and pride and correction) than fathers [48, 51, 55, 78, 79, 80]. This may be because
fathers are typically less involved than mothers in raising ASD children [31], are more likely to
ignore their own mental health issues [87], express less emotion, seek less social support, have
Fewer studies have considered mental health and social factors of siblings of children with ASD.
Some studies showed siblings of ASD children to have higher self-concept and social
competence, but lower prosocial behaviors, increased behavior problems, feelings of loneliness,
less involved and more avoidant of their siblings, and delays in developing social skills [23,
101]. The risk of negative outcomes may be greater for ASD siblings born later in the birth order
[102] and older males [101]. It may be that siblings of ASD children are more likely to have
mental health and social problems because they are more likely to be on the spectrum [100].
Promoting positive sibling involvement and family functioning should consider the ASD
sibling’s developmental level, communication status, and areas of strength, challenge, and
interest [106].
A common theme among the possible interventions is that fathers who co-care for their child
with ASD are able to increase in direct father-child nurturing [51]. Additionally, fathers who
invest time in being involved in gaining education and a larger understanding of ASD, are then
21
Mental Health of Families with ASD
able to implement the learned resources that are available for assisting in the care of their child
with ASD [51]. As a result, fathers will be more empowered, less likely to avoid caring for the
child with ASD, and stronger marriages will ensue, thereby contributing to a unified effort in the
child rearing process [51]. Mothers appear to require more social support from counselors,
organizations, family and friends than fathers [73]. Parent and family focused interventions may
be effective in improving parental well-being and familial quality of life [33, 37, 41, 59, 66, 71,
Notwithstanding the many challenges, studies have also identified positive aspects of raising a
child with ASD. These include stronger family perceived relationships, a sense of
accomplishment by the parents as they see their child progress, a greater sense of personal
growth and empowerment, a closer and more united family, a greater appreciation for life and in
others, spiritual strength, and joy in raising their child with ASD [79, 80]. Mother’s perception of
positive contributions of their ASD children are greater than fathers [48, 51, 55, 78, 79].
Some limitations and recommendations are in order. First, most studies are based on cross-
sectional designs, which may be prone to misrepresentation if low response rates and recall bias
exists. These studies are not effective at identify temporal sequences of events. Second, some
studies reviewed used small sample sizes or convenience samples. Small sample size and lack of
random selection may cause misleading results. Hence, generalization of these studies should be
made with caution. Third, some studies were susceptible to confounding factors, although
several of the studies adjusted their results for potential confounders (e.g. child’s age,
socioeconomic status, employment status, education levels of parents, family systems and
relationships apart from the child with ASD, marital relationship, and definitions of stress levels,
etc.). Despite these limitations, there were several strengths to the reviewed studies. Many of the
22
Mental Health of Families with ASD
studies were able to test specific interventions to evaluate how they affected the mental health of
mothers, fathers, and siblings. Some of the studies tested for a specific variable (i.e. child’s age,
certain behaviors), which allowed for assessment of potential mediating or moderating effects.
REFERENCES
1. Bhat S, Acharya UR, Adeli H, Bairy GM, Adeli A. (2014). Autism: Cause factors, early
5. Eaves LC, Ho HH. The very early identification of autism: Outcome to age 4½-5. Autism
6. Camodeca A. Description of criterion validity of the autism spectrum rating scales 6-18
parent report: Initial exploration in a large community sample. Child Psychiatry Hum Dev.
2019;50(6):987-1001. 10.1007/s10578-019-00899-0
7. Muskat B, Riosa PB, Nicholas DB, Roberts W, Stoddart KP, Zwaigenbaum L. Autism comes
to the hospital: The experiences of patients with autism spectrum disorder, their parents and
10.1177/1362361314531341
8. Grinker RR. Unstrange minds: Remapping the world of autism. New York: Basic Books.
2007.
23
Mental Health of Families with ASD
with-autism/autism-through-the-lifespan/.
10. Breik N, Kuo IF, Bugden S, Moffat M, Alessi-Severini S. Treating children with ASD: The
https://doi.org/10.18433/jpps29829.
11. Wang Y, Wang MJ, Rong Y, Hui-Zhong H, Chang-Jiang Y. Oxytocin therapy for core
2019;64:63-75. 10.1016/j.rasd.2019.03.007.
12. Karst JS, Hecke AV. Parent and family impact of autism spectrum disorders: A review and
proposed model for intervention evaluation. Clin Child Fam Psychol Rev. 2012;15(3):247-
277. 10.1007/s10567-012-0119-6
13. Benson PR. The impact of child symptom severity on depressed mood among parents of
children with ASD: The mediating role of stress proliferation. J Autism Dev Disord.
2006;36:685-695.
14. Norton P, Drew C. Autism and potential family stressors. Am J Fam Ther. 1994;22(1):67-76.
10.1080/01926189408251298
15. Shelton TL, Jeppson ES, Johnson BH. Family-centered care for children with special health-
care needs. Washington, DC: Association for the Care of Children’s Health. 1987.
16. Acharya S, Sharma K. Lived experiences of mothers raising children with autism in Chitwan
17. Papadopoulos D. Mothers’ experiences and challenges raising a child with autism spectrum
18. Navot N, Jorgenson AG, Webb SJ. Maternal experience raising girls with autism spectrum
19. Hoefman R, Payakachat N, van Exel J, Kuhlthau K, Kovacs E, Payne J, et al. Caring for a
child with autism spectrum disorder and parents’ quality of life: Application of the CarerQol.
20. Lashewicz BM, Shipton L, Lien K. Meta-synthesis of fathers’ experiences raising children
21. Friedrich WN. Predictors of the coping behavior of mothers of handicapped children. J
22. Khamis V. Psychological distress among parents of children with mental retardation in the
23. Meadan H, Stoner JB, Angell ME. Review of literature related to the social, emotional, and
behavioral adjustment of siblings of individuals with autism spectrum disorder. J Dev Phys
Shinnar S. Parental stress in families of children with autism and other developmental
children with autism spectrum disorders. J Autism Dev Disord. 2014; 44(7):1609-1620.
10.1007/s10803-013-2028-z
outpatient service for children with developmental disorders. Australasian Psychiatry. 2019;
27(2):152-156. 10.1177/1039856218815754
27. Kousha M, Attar HA, Shoar Z. Anxiety, depression, and quality of life in Iranian mothers of
children with autism spectrum disorder. Journal of Child Health Care. 2016;20(3):405–414.
10.1177/1367493515598644
28. Kwok SYCL, Leung CLK, Wong DFK. Marital satisfaction of Chinese mothers of children
https://doi.org/10.1111/jir.12116
29. Meadan H, Halle JW, Ebata AT. Families with children who have autism spectrum disorders:
relationship between autism stigma and informal caregiver mental health. J Autism Dev
Disord. 2019;49(4):1665-1685.
31. Rankin JA, Paisley CA, Tomeny TS, Eldred SW. Fathers of youth with autism spectrum
disorder: A systematic review of the impact of fathers’ involvement on youth, families, and
00294-0
32. Souders MC, Zavodny S, Eriksen W, Sinko R, Connell J, Kerns C, et al. Sleep in children
0782-x
33. Bendixen RM, Elder JH, Donaldson S, Kairalla JA, Valcante G, Ferdig RE. Effects of a
34. Carter AS, Martínea-Pedraza F de L, Gray SAO. Stability and individual change in
depressive symptoms among mothers raising young children with ASD: Maternal and child
35. Gray DE. Coping over time: The parents of children with autism. J Intellect Disabil Res.
2006;50(Pt12):970-976.
36. Marquis SM, McGrail K, Hayes M. Mental health of parents of children with a
2020;74(2):173-178.
37. Fida A, Naveed S, Waqas A. Non-specialist mediated interventions for autism spectrum
10.3928/02793695-20190322-01
38. Scherer N, Verhey I, Kuper H. Depression and anxiety in parents of children with intellectual
2019;14(7):e0219888.
39. Yirmiya N, Shaked M. Psychiatric disorders in parents of children with autism: A meta-
40. Zhai L, Zhang H, Zhang D. Sleep duration and depression among adults: A meta-analysis of
interventions for older children or adults with ASD and parent wellbeing outcomes: A
10.1016/j.rasd.2019.101450.
27
Mental Health of Families with ASD
42. Hartley SL, DaWalt LS, Schultz HM. Daily couple experiences and parent affect in families
43. Sawyer MG, Bittman M, La Greca AM, Crettenden AD, Harchak TF, Martin J. Time
demands of caring for children with autism: What are the implications for maternal mental
44. Duarte CS, Bordin IA, Yazigi L, Mooney J. Factors associated with stress in mothers of
45. Chan KKS, Lam CB, Law NCW, Cheung RYM. From child autistic symptoms to parental
46. Fassett-Carman AN, DiDomenico GE, Steiger J, Snyder HR. Clarifying stress-internalizing
associations: Stress frequency and appraisals of severity and controllability are differentially
47. Ang K, Loh P. Mental health and coping in parents of children with autism spectrum disorder
2019;49(5):2129-2145. 10.1007/s10803-019-03900-w
48. García-López C, Recio P, Pozo P, Sarriá E. Psychological distress, disorder severity, and
49. Davis NO, Carter AS. Parenting stress in mothers and fathers of toddlers with autism
2008;38(7):1278-1291.
28
Mental Health of Families with ASD
50. Ekas NV, Lickenbrock DM, Whitman TL. Optimism, social support, and well-being in
mothers of children with autism spectrum disorder. J Autism Dev Disord. 2010;40(10):1274-
84. 10.1007/s10803-010-0986-y
51. Hastings RP, Koyshoff H, Ward NJ, Espinosa FD, Brown T, Remington B. System analysis
of stress and positive perceptions in mothers and fathers of pre-school children with autism. J
52. Hastings RP. Child behavior problems and partner mental health as correlates of stress in
mothers and fathers of children with autism. J Intellect Disabil Res. 2003;47(Pt 4-5):232-237.
53. Hoffman CD, Sweeney DP, Hodge D, Lopez-Wagner MC. Parenting stress and closeness:
Mothers of typically developing children and mothers of children with autism. Focus Autism
54. Huang X, Zhang H, Chen S. Neuropsychiatric symptoms, parenting stress and social support
in Chinese mothers of children with autism spectrum disorder. Curr Med Sci.
2019;39(2):291-297. 10.1007/s11596-019-2033-3
55. Jones L, Totsika V, Hastings R, Petalas M. Gender differences when parenting children with
2013;43(9):2090–2098. 10.1007/s10803-012-1756-9
56. Phetrasuwan S, Shandor M. Parenting stress in mothers of children with autism spectrum
6155.2009.00188.x
57. Whitehead, K., Dorstyn, D. & Ward, L. Psychological adjustment in families affected by
58. Seymour M, Giallo R, Wood C. The psychological and physical health of fathers of children
with autism spectrum disorder compared to fathers of children with long-term disabilities and
10.1016/j.ridd.2017.07.018
59. Argumedes M, Lanovaz MJ, Larivee S. Brief report: Impact of challenging behavior on
parenting stress in mothers and fathers of children with autism spectrum disorders. J Autism
autism spectrum disorder: A study from Muscat, Oman. Perspect Psychiatr Care.
2019;55(4):600-606. 10.1111/ppc.12374
61. Hastings RP, Johnson E. Stress in UK families conducting intensive home-based behavioral
intervention for their young child with autism. J Autism Dev Disord. 2001;31;327-336.
62. Brobst JB, Clopton JR, Hendrick SS. Parenting children with autism spectrum disorders: The
10.1177/1088357608323699
children with autism without intellectual disability. Mediation of behavioral problems and
64. Spratt EG, Saylor CF, Macias MM. Assessing parenting stress in multiple samples of
10.1037/1091-7527.25.4.435
30
Mental Health of Families with ASD
65. Gallagher S, Hannigan A. Depression and chronic health conditions in parents of children
with and without developmental disabilities: The growing up in Ireland cohort study. Res
correlates of parenting stress in children with autism spectrum disorder and serious
01423-7
67. Sim A, Vaz S, Cordier R, Joosten A, Parsons D, Smith C, Falkmer T. Factors associated with
2018;21(3):155-165.
68. Jose P, Sundaram S, Varma RP. Buffering effect of spousal support on stress levels in
mothers of children with a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder in Kerala, India. J Neurosci
69. Grebe SC, Mire SS, Kim H, Keller-Margulis MA. Comparing fathers’ and mothers’
perspectives about their child’s autism spectrum disorder. J Autism Dev Disord. 2021. doi:
10.1007/s10803-021-05077-7.
70. Stewart SB, Greene DJ, Lessov-Schlaggar CN, Church JA, Schlaggar BL. Clinical correlates
of parenting stress in children with Tourette syndrome and in typically developing children. J
71. Bourke-Taylor H, Pallant JF, Law M, Howie L. Predicting mental health among mothers of
school aged children with developmental disabilities: The relative contribution of child,
10.1016/j.ridd.2012.04.011
31
Mental Health of Families with ASD
72. Riahi F, Izadi-Mazidi S. Comparison between the mental health of mothers of children with
73. Halstead EJ, Griffith GM, Hastings RP. Social support, coping and positive perceptions as
potential protective factors for the well-being of mothers of children with intellectual and
10.1080/20473869.2017.1329192
74. Siu QKY, Yi H, Chan RCH, Chio FHN, Chan DFY, Mak WWS. The role of child problem
behaviors in autism spectrum symptoms and parenting stress: A primary school-based study.
75. Hickey EJ, Dubois L, Hartley SL. Positive and negative social exchanges experienced by
10.1177/1362361316687117
76. Naheed A, Islam MS, Hossain SW, et al. Burden of major depressive disorder and quality of
life among mothers of children with autism spectrum disorder in urban Bangladesh. Autism
Comparison of parental stress among mothers and fathers of children with autistic spectrum
10.1007/s10803-018-3784-6.
32
Mental Health of Families with ASD
79. Kayfitz AD, Gragg MN, Orr RR. Positive experiences of mothers and fathers of children
3148.2009.00539.x
80. Bayat M. Evidence of resilience in families of children with autism. J Intellect Disabil Res.
2007;51(9):702-714. 10.1111/j.1365-2788.2007.00960.x
81. Navot N, Jorgenson AG, Vander Stoep A, Toth K, Webb SJ. Family planning and family
vision in mothers after diagnosis of a child with autism spectrum disorder. Autism.
2016;20(5):605-615. 10.1177/1362361315602134
82. Zhou W, Liu D, Xiong X, Xu H. Emotional problems in mothers of autistic children and their
correlation with socioeconomic status and the children’s core symptoms. Medicine
83. Bourke-Taylor HM, Howie L, Law M. Impact of caring for a school aged child with a
10.1111/j.1440-1630.2009.00817.x
84. Tunali B, Power TG. Coping by redefinition: Cognitive appraisals in mothers of children
with autism and children without autism. J Autism Dev Disord. 2002;32(1):25-34.
10.1023/A:1017999906420
85. Elder J, Donaldson S, Kairalla J, Valcante G, Bendixen R, Ferdig R, et al. In-home training
for fathers of children with autism: A follow up study and evaluation of four individual
86. Rao PA, Beidel DC. The impact of children with high-functioning autism on parental stress,
87. Hu X., Han, Z.R., Bai, L. et al. The mediating role of parenting stress in the relations
between parental emotion regulation and parenting behaviors in Chinese families of children
with autism spectrum disorders: A dyadic analysis. J Autism Dev Disord. 49:3983–3998
(2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10803-019-04103-z
88. Bujnowska A, Rodríguez C, García T, Areces D, Marsh N. Parenting and future anxiety: The
impact of having a child with developmental disabilities. Int J Environ Res Public Health.
2019;16(4):668. 10.3390/ijerph16040668
89. Herring S, Gray K, Taffe J, Tonge B, Sweeney D, Einfeld S. Behaviour and emotional
Associations with parental mental health and family functioning. J Int Disabil Res.
2006;50(12):874-882.
90. Rodrigue JR, Morgan SB, Geffken GR. Psychosocial adaptation of fathers of children with
autism, down syndrome, and normal development. J Autism Dev Disord. 1992;22(2):249-
263.10.1007/BF01058154.
91. Twoy R, Connolly PM, Novak JM. Coping strategies used by parents of children with
92. Pisula E, Banasiak A. Empowerment in Polish fathers of children with autism and Down
syndrome: The role of social support and coping with stress – a preliminary report. J Intellect
stress, family support and family quality of life: A structural equation modeling approach. Re
95. Lei X, Kantor J. Social support and family functioning in Chinese families of children with
96. Ekas NV, Timmons L, Pruitt M, Ghilain C, Alessandri M. The power of positivity:
2362-4.
97. Hartley SL, Barker ET, Seltzer MM, Floyd F, Greenberg J, Orsmond G, et al. The relative
risk and timing of divorce in families of children with an autism spectrum disorder.
98. Chen H, Yang T, Chen J, Chen L, Dai Y, Zhang J, et al. Sleep problems in children with
99. Levin A, Scher A. Sleep problems in young children with autism spectrum disorders: A study
of parenting stress, mothers’ sleep-related cognitions, and bedtime behaviors. CNS Neurosci
100. Benson, PR, Karlof KL. Child, parent, and family predictors of latter adjustment in
101. Walton KM, Ingersoll BR. Psychosocial adjustment and sibling relationships in siblings
of children with autism spectrum disorder: Risk and protective factors. Journal Autism Dev
dissatisfaction in siblings of children with autism spectrum disorders: The role of birth order
021-05308-x
103. Griffith GM, Hastings RP, Petalas MA. Brief report: Fathers’ and mothers’ ratings of
behavioral and emotional problems in siblings of children with autism spectrum disorder. J
104. Hastings RP. Brief report: Behavioral adjustment of siblings of children with autism. J
105. Shivers CM, McGregor CM. Brief report: Sibling feelings toward their brother or sister
409.10.1007/s10803-018-3694-7
106. Wright BM, Benigno JP. Autism spectrum disorder and sibling relationships: Exploring
implications for intervention using a family systems framework. Ame J Speech Lang Pathol.
2019;28(2):759-767. 10.1044/2018_AJSLP-18-0088
107. Van Praag HM. Can stress cause depression? Prog Neuro Psychopharm Bio Psych.
2004;28(5):891-907. 10.1016/j.pnpbp.2004.05.031
108. Tafet GE, Nemeroff CB. The links between stress and depression:
Outcome
Source Measurement Study Design Population Child Factors Summary
Variables
Prevalence of depressive
symptoms among caregivers
of children with ASD was
Random sample of
Alshekaili et 71%. The high percent could
Patient Healthcare Cross- 80 parents with Severe
al., 2019 [60] Depression be due to the child having
Questionnaire-9 sectional children with ASD disability
BC severe disability.
(Oman)
Unemployment and being
the sole parent/caregiver
correlated with depression.
Active-avoidance coping
Ages 7-17 was the most common
Diagnostic
years. Most approach for adjusting, and
Statistical Manual
with ASD, this correlated highest with
of Mental
106 mothers and 97 some with greater depression, anxiety
Disorders—Fifth Stress
Ang & Loh, Cross- fathers from Asia. Asperger’s and stress. Mothers
Edition (DSM-5); Anxiety
2019 [47] AE sectional 97% were married disorder, and experienced significantly
depression, anxiety, Depression
(Asia) some with greater stress levels than
stress (self-reported
pervasive fathers. However, while
questionnaires);
developmental stress was a major precursor
COPE
disorder to depression for fathers, but
not for mothers.
Argumedes et Sociodemographic Cross- 42 families; 10 ASD child had Stress High severity of ASD and
al., 2018 [59] questionnaire; sectional father; 27 mothers; to present at challenging behaviors were
BE Childhood rating 5 couples (Canada) least one associated with increased
Scale; Parenting challenging risk of stress. Reductions in
Stress Index-3 ed. behavior (e.g. challenging child behavior
hitting, with family centered support
property correlated with reduced
damage, self- parenting stress.
2
Mental Health of Families with ASD
injury)
Bayat 2007 Walsh’s resilience Cross- 175 parents and Ages 2-18; Positive Families of children with
[80] F theory. sectional other primary 53% had severe outcomes; ASD often experience
caregivers autism. Family unity resilience by making
(USA) 60% had some positive meaning of
sort of disability, mobilization of
aggressive resources, becoming a closer
behavior. and more united family,
developing a greater
appreciation for life and in
others, and gaining spiritual
strength.
Questionnaire
(SDQ); Parenting psychosocial problems,
Stress Index; compared to children in the
Family Climate general population.
Index
Maternal mental health was
negatively associated with
152 mothers (94 their child’s unmet service
with ASD, 29 with needs and challenging
Bourke-Taylor Short Form 36 V.2;
Cross- cerebral palsy, and Mother’s mental behaviors, but positively
et al., 2012 Pediatric Quality of Ages 5-18
sectional 19 with attention health associated with maternal
[71] BC Life Parent Report
deficit hyperactivity participation in healthy
disorder) (Australia) activity, maternal
empowerment, and the
child’s psychosocial health.
The five main categories that
were associated with
maternal mental health were
(1) the child’s needs and
behaviors; (2) the mother’s
personal needs and ability to
Emotional organize; (3) familial and
Bourke-Taylor Purposive sample of
Qualitative Cross- distress (e.g. spousal relationships; (4)
et al., 2010 8 participants
assessment sectional daily challenges service availability and
[83] BC (Australia)
to mental health) adequacy; (5) and the
environment in which the
family lives. The study
aimed to find solutions to
these five issues. A study
limitation was its small
sample size.
Brobst et al., Parental Stress Cross- 25 couples with Mild severity Stress Parents of ASD children
2009 [62] A Index Short Form sectional ASD children; 20 experienced more stress and
4
Mental Health of Families with ASD
Scale (CES-D);
Satisfaction with
Life Scale;
roles were discussed.
Psychological
Well-Being Scale
(PWB)
Four common skills were
taught to fathers, based on
social interaction theory.
Fathers were then asked to
Autism Diagnostic
teach the mothers what they
Interview-Revised
had learned. They found that
(ADI-R); Autism
Ages 3-7 years; Four skills fathers and mothers were
Diagnostic
Elder et al., Cross- 18 males and 1 associated with equally capable of achieving
Observation 18 dyads (USA)
2010 [85] E sectional female with in-home training positive social reciprocity in
Schedule (ADOS);
ASD interventions parents and children with
Vineland Adaptive
autism. The main point
Behavior Scales-
emphasized was that fathers
Survey Form;
are fully capable of
promoting father-child social
interactions and that the
child responds well to them.
Questionnaire on
Resources and Parents of toddlers that had
Families of 46
Stress (QRS); Brief ASD experienced increased
ASD, 25
Symptom stress compared with parents
Estes et al., Cross- developmentally Ages 18-30
Inventory (BSI); Stress of toddlers with
2013[93] B sectional delayed, and 25 months
Aberrant Behavior developmental delay without
typically developing
Checklist; Vineland ASD and typical
(USA)
Adaptive Behavior development children.
Scales (VABS)
Fassett- DSM-5 Level 1; Cross- 356 (70% female) Ages 18-25 (M Depression This study explains how
Carman et al., Cross Cutting sectional were recruited from = 20.8) Anxiety stress can lead to anxiety
8
Mental Health of Families with ASD
Diagnostic and
Statistical Manual
of Mental Disorder Child emotional and
(DSM)-IV; behavioral problems
Psychoeducational Parents of 123 Stress contributed more to mother
Profile; Vineland children with Child behavioral stress, parental mental health
Cross-
Herring et al., Adaptive autistic disorder and and emotional problems, and perceived
sectional (3 20-51 months
2006 [89] AC Behaviour Scales pervasive problems Family family dysfunction. Father
time points)
parent interview; developmental functioning reported significantly less
Adaptive disorder (Australia) Mental health stress than mothers in
Behaviour relation to parenting their
Composite; Reynell child with ASD.
Developmental
Language Scales
Mothers reported more
positive and negative social
exchanges with family,
friends, and health
professionals than fathers.
Mothers experienced all
three social exchanges
176 families
PANSE; Center for Cross- (informational, emotional,
(couples that had
Hickey et al., epidemiological sectional Ages 5-12; Depression and social); Fathers
been in relationship
2017 [75] A Studies-Depression Dyadic 85% males Social exchange experienced more
for more than 3
Scale Models informational and emotional;
years) (USA)
Not having social exchanges
was a significant indicator of
depression. Positive and
negative social exchanges
with one’s spouse were the
biggest factor related to
depressive symptoms.
Higgins et al., Family Cross- 53 Mean = 10 Marital Having a child with ASD
15
Mental Health of Families with ASD
Adaptability and
Cohesion
may lower marital
Evaluation Scales
happiness, family
(FACES II); happiness
adaptability, and family
Quality Marriage parents/caregivers Family cohesion
years and 10 cohesion. No evidence of
2005[] BC Index (QMI); sectional of children with Family
months lower self-esteem. Coping
Rosenberg Self- ASD (Australia) adaptability
strategies were not
Esteem Scale; Coping strategies
associated with marital or
Coping Health
family adjustment.
Inventory for
Patients (CHIP)
Quality of Well-
Being Scale Fulfillment
Many parents had fulfillment
(QWB-SA); Relationship
in caring for their child with
Primary Caregiver problems Mental
ASD. However, parents
Questionnaire; health problems
often experienced problems
Centers for (including
balancing care for their child
Hoefman et Epidemiologic depression,
Cross- 224 families with and other daily activities,
al., 2014 [19] Studies Depression Ages 4-17 problems with
sectional ASD child (USA) had financial challenges or
F Scale (CES-D); daily activities,
suffered from depression.
CarerQol-VAS; financial
CarerQol was shown to be
CarerQol-7D; Self- problems,
valid in assessing the impact
Rated Burden disability-related
of caregiving on parents of
(SRB) Scale; support, physical
children with ASD.
Family Quality of health problems).
Life Scale (FQLS)
Hoffman et al., Parenting Stress Cross- Mothers of children 20 female ASD Stress Mothers of children with
2009 [53] BF Index sectional with autism (104) children, 84 Depression ASD reported higher levels
and mothers of male ASD of stress and depression than
typically developing children; 136 mothers of normally
children (342) female normal developing children.
(USA) developing Although mothers of ASD
child, 205 male children deal with more
16
Mental Health of Families with ASD
normal
developing
children (Ages
3-16) (M = 8.6 stress, they still feel they
in the ASD have a close relationship
group and 8 in with their child.
the normal
developing
group)
Mothers and fathers who had
difficulties coping with
emotional challenges had
greater perceived stress
when caring for their child
Difficulties in with ASD. Higher stress
Emotion perception then resulted in
Regulation Scale Ages 7-12 (M fewer bonding behaviors,
(DERS); Parenting = 10.4); more overprotection, and
Hu et al., 2019 Cross- 211 mother-father
Stress Inventory- clinical Stress less care for their child.
[87] ABC sectional pairs (China)
Short Form (PSI- diagnosis of Mothers were more easily
SF); Parenting ASD overwhelmed by emotional
Bonding regulation. On the other
Instrument (PBI) hand, fathers were more
likely to ignore their own
mental health issues.
Mothers’ stress was not
associated with their
spouses’ care behaviors.
Huang et al., Revised Autism Cross- 80 mothers of ASD 34 low- Stress Neuropsychiatric symptoms
2019 [54] BC Diagnostic sectional children (China) functioning Anxiety and parental stress are
Inventory; ASD and 46 Depression significantly greater in
Neuropsychiatric high- Apathy mothers of ASD children.
inventory; functioning Irritability Low-functioning ASD was
17
Mental Health of Families with ASD
functioning autism
Index, Family experienced significantly
Environment Scale; functioning, greater stress than parents of
psychological psychological children without
problems; problems, psychological disorders,
symptom-90- general physical depending on the
2009 [86] B Revised, SF-36; sectional fathers (USA) and mental characteristics of the
Piers-Harris health, sibling children. Higher intellectual
Children’s Self- adjustment, child functioning of the high
Concept Scale; behavior functioning child with
Child Behavior problems autism did not compensate
Checklist for the greater stress
experience by the parents.
Mothers of children with
32 mothers of autism experienced
Riahi & Izadi- General Health children with Mental Health significantly more mental
Cross-
mazidi, 2012 Questionnaire autism and 29 Anxiety health problems, anxiety,
sectional
[72] B (GHQ) mothers of children Insomnia and insomnia than mothers
without the disorder with normal functioning
children.
Childhood Autism
Rating Scale
Mothers and fathers had
(CARS); Wechsler
stress reaching a clinical
Preschool and
threshold. Fathers’ stress
Primary Scale of
was associated with the
Intelligence
Rivard et al., Cross- 118 fathers and 118 Pre-school child’s sex and age.
(WPPSI-III); Stress
2014 [25] AB sectional mothers (Canada) aged children Mothers’ stress was
Adaptive Behavior
positively associated with
Assessment
the child’s age. The father
System-II (ABAS-
had greater stress if the
II); Parenting Stress
autistic child was female.
Index-Short Form
(PSI/SF)
26
Mental Health of Families with ASD
Stress Index-Short
children (China) child behavioral problems.
Form (PSI-SF)
The parental stress index
Childhood Autism
positively correlates with the
Soltanifar et Rating Scale-Parent 42 couples with
Cross- childhood autism rating
al., 2015 [77] (CARS-P); children with ASD Ages 2-12 Stress
sectional scale. Mothers have
A Parenting Stress (Iran)
significantly higher stress
Index
than fathers.
ASD children are more
prone to sleep problems due
to arousal dysregulation and
sensory hyper-reactivity.
Souders et al., Literature
Sleep disorder Improving sleep in ASD
2017 [32] E Review
cases may involve sleep
education, ecological and
behavioral interventions, and
exogenous melatonin.
Parents of children
with developmental,
behavioral, Behavior problems in the
neurological, and ASD child was the greatest
Parenting Stress emotional problems factor contributing to high
Spratt et al., Index-Short Form; Cross- (57), parental stress. They
Ages 4-12 Stress
2007 [64] E Family Resource sectional intraventricular conclude that clinics and
Scale hemorrhage mental health professionals
documented at birth need to collaborate to help
(70), and neural parents deal with this stress.
tube defects (45)
(USA)
Stewart et al., Parenting Stress Cross- 74 Children with Stress Parents of children with
2015 [70] BC Index Short Form sectional Tourette syndrome, Tourette syndrome had
(PSI-SF) 48 normally increased stress compared
developing children with the parents of normally
29
Mental Health of Families with ASD
Scale (SRS),
Sibling Inventory
of normally
of Behavior (SIB); avoidant of their sibling as
developing
Center for normally developing
children, all
Epidemiologic children. Older male siblings
recruited through
Studies Depression were at greater risk for
Interactive Autism
Scale (CES-D); behavioral/emotional
Network (IAN)
Family Impact difficulties.
(USA)
Questionnaire
(FIQ)
Depression Anxiety
Stress Scales-21
Item (DASS-21);
Connor Davidson
Resilience Scale Psychological outcomes
(CD-RISC-25); primarily related to
Short Form individual coping responses.
Developmental Avoidance strategies (self-
Cross-
Whitehead et Behaviour 438 female Stress Anxiety blame, denial, emotional
sectional; Ages < 18 with
al., 2015 [57] Checklist (DBC- caregivers Depression venting, and disengagement)
national ASD
E P24); Locus of (Australia) Resilience associated with stress,
survey
Control of anxiety, and depression.
Behaviour Scale Planning, acceptance, and
(LCB); Brief positive reframing
COPE; Social characterize resilience.
Support Index
(SSI); Service
Obstacles Scale
(SOS)
Yirmiya & Meta- Anxiety Parents of children with
Shaked, 2005 analysis Depression ASD experience higher risk
[39] B Mania of psychiatric difficulties.
Obsessions
32
Mental Health of Families with ASD
Neuroticism
Schizophrenia
Psychiatric
disorders
Chinese version of Perceived family support
the Beach Center and family quality of life
FQOL scale; was low and parental stress
Zeng et al., Family Support Cross- Ages 7-12 (M Stress Family was high. Family support
226 parents (China)
2020 [94] C Scale; Parenting sectional = 10.3) quality of life had a direct, positive effect
Stress Inventory- on family quality of life and
Short Form (PSI- indirect effect on family
SF) quality of life through stress.
7 prospective
studies resulting in
25,271 participants Short and long sleep
Zhai et al., Meta- for a short sleep duration was significantly
Adults Depression
2015 [40] E analysis duration and 23,663 associated with increased
participants for a risk of depression in adults
long sleep duration
(China)
Mothers of ASD children
have higher levels of anxiety
9-item Patient 167 mothers who and depression. The study
The majority
Health spent at least 4 indicates that maternal
Zhou et al., Cross- were boys with Anxiety
Questionnaire; 7- hours/day with anxiety and depression can
2019 [82] E sectional average age of Depression
item Generalized ASD individual be lowered by using
5 years
Anxiety Scale (China) interventions to monitor and
lower core symptoms of
children with ASD.
A Compared mental health between mothers and fathers
B Parental mental health directly related to ASD
C Parental mental health indirectly related to ASD
D Sibling mental health
33
Mental Health of Families with ASD