Assignment #1 Structural Analysis
Assignment #1 Structural Analysis
Department of CivilEngineering
Course Code: CIV 3115
Course Name: Structural Analysis
Assignment # 1(The Principle of Virtual Work &Castigliano’s Theorem)
Page 1 of 56
Task Sheet
Table of Content:
Page 2 of 56
QUESTION # 1....................................................................................................................................................
QUESTION # 2....................................................................................................................................................
QUESTION # 3....................................................................................................................................................
QUESTION # 4....................................................................................................................................................
QUESTION # 5....................................................................................................................................................
Question 1
Page 3 of 56
a. The Principle of Virtual Work
b. Castigliano’s Theorem
(a) Solution:
Step 1: Determine the reactions at the supports
+↻ ∑ M c =0
A x (6)+150(8)=0
1200
A x=
6
∴ A x =200 kN →
+↑ ∑ F y =0
−150+C y =0
∴ C y =150 kN ↑
+→ ∑ F x =0
C x +200=0
∴ c x =200 kN ←
Step 3: Use the Method of Joints to determine the internal forces in each member.
@Joint C
+↑ ∑ F y =0
150−F CA =0
F CA =150 kN ↑
+→ ∑ F x =0
F CB−200=0
F CB=200 kN →
@ Joint B
10
6
+→ ∑ F x =0
8
−200− F =0
10 BA
F BA=−250 kN
F BA=250 kN (C)
6 ft
Page 5 of 56
Step 5: Determine the reactions at the supports.
+↻ ∑ M c =0
A x (6)−1(8)=0
−8
A x=
6
A x =1.33 kN ←
+↑ ∑ F y =0
- C y +1=0
C y =1 kN ↑
+→ ∑ F x =0
C x −1.333=0
C x =1.33 kN →
Page 6 of 56
Step 6: Use the Method of Joints to determine the internal forces in each member.
@ Joint C
+↑ ∑ F y =0
F CA −1=0
F CA =1 kN (C)
+→ ∑ F x =0
F CB +1.333=0
F CB=1.33 kN (C)
@ Joint A
10
6
8
+→ ∑ F x =0
8
−1.333+ F =0
10 AB
F AB=1.667 kN (T)
AC -1 150 6 -900.0
∑ ¿−7195.5
Page 7 of 56
nNL −7195.5
1 lb ∙ ∆ Bv =∑ =
AE AE
7195.5 lb ∙ ft
∴ ∆ Bv = ↑
AE
(b) Solution:
Step 1: Determine the reactions at the supports
+↺ ∑ M c =0
A x (6)−P(8)=0
−8
A x= P
6
∴ A x =1.33 P kN ←
+↑ ∑ F y =0
−C y + P=0
∴ C y =P kN ↓
+→ ∑ F x =0
C x −1.33 P=0
∴ c x =1.33 P kN →
Step 2: Use the Method of Joints to determine the internal forces in each member.
@Joint C
+↑ ∑ F y =0
−F CA −P=0
F CA =−P kN (C )
+→ ∑ F x =0
F CB +1.33 P=0
Page 8 of 56
F CB=−1.33 P kN (C)
@Joint A
10
6
8
+→ ∑ F x =0
8
−1.333 P+ F =0
10 AB
1.33 P 1.33 P
F AB= =
8 800
10
F AB=1.667 P kN (T )
∑ ¿7191.01
Question 2
Page 9 of 56
Determine the horizontal displacement of joint A. AE is constant. Solve using:
a. The Principle of Virtual Work
b. Castigliano’s Theorem
Considering joint A
→+∑Fx = 0
FAB +FAC Cos60⁰ = 0
FAB = 8.083 kN (Cos 60⁰)
FAB = -4.0415 kN
Considering Joint C
↑+∑Fy = 0
-FAC Sin 60⁰ - FBC Sin60⁰ = 0
-8.083 Sin 60⁰ - FBCSin60⁰ = 0
-8.083 Sin60⁰ = FBC Sin60⁰
FBC = -8.083 kN
→+∑Fx = 0
-FAC Cos60⁰ + FBC Cos60⁰ + FCD = 0
-8.083kN Cos60⁰ - -8.083kN Cos60⁰ +FCD = 0
-4.0415kN -4.0415kN + FCD = 0
FCD = 8.083k
Summary of Calculations:
Page 11 of 56
AB 1 -4.0415 2 -8.083
AC 0 8.083 2 0
BC 0 -8.083 2 0
CD 0 8.083 1 0
Total ∑-8.083kN
nNL 8.083 kN ². m
Therefore 1kN x ▲Ah = ∑ =
AE AE
2
8.083 k N . m(−1 kN )
▲Ah =
AE
8.083 kN . m
▲Ah =
AE
Castiglione’s Method.
+→ ∑Fx = 0
P- FAB + FAC Cos60⁰ = 0
P- FAB + 8.083kN Cos60⁰ = 0
FAB = P - 4.0415kN
Considering joint C
Page 12 of 56
↑+∑Fy = 0
-FAC Sin 60⁰ - FBC Sin60⁰ = 0
-8.083 Sin 60⁰ - FBC Sin60⁰ = 0
-8.083 Sin60⁰ = FBC Sin60⁰
FBC = -8.083 kN
→+∑Fx = 0
-FAC Cos60⁰ + FBC Cos60⁰ + FCD = 0
-8.083kN Cos60⁰ - -8.083kN Cos60⁰ +FCD = 0
-4.0415kN - 4.0415kN + FCD = 0
FCD = 8.083kN
Summary of Calculations:
AC 8.083 8.083 2 0
BC -8.083 -8.083 2 0
CD 8.083 8.083 1 0
Total ∑-8.083
δN L 8.083 kN . m
Therefore ∑N( )= =-
δP AE AE
2
8.083 k N . m(−1 kN )
=
AE
8.083 kN . m
=
AE
Question 3
Page 13 of 56
(a) Principle of Virtual Work
←+ ∑ Fx = Ax – 6KN
Ax = 6KN ←
↑+ ∑ Fy = Ay + 6KN – 6KN = 0
Ay = 0
Page 14 of 56
Real System
Consider Joint B:
↑+ ∑ Fy = 6KN + FBC = 0
FBC = 6KN (C)
←+ ∑ Fx = 0
FAB = 0
Considering Joint A:
3
→+ ∑ Fx = FAC ( ) – 6KN = 0
3 √2
3
FAC ( ) - 6KN = 0
4.24
FAC = 8.48 KN (T)
Considering Joint D:
∑ Fx = 0
FCD = 0
Page 15 of 56
Summary of Internal Forces in Real System
Virtual Systems
↑+ ∑ Fy = 1KN + Ay
Ay = 1KN ↓
←+ ∑ Fx = Ax – 1KN
Page 16 of 56
Ax = 1KN ←
Joint B:
↑+ ∑ Fy = 1KN + FBC = 0
FBC = 1KN (C)
←+ ∑ Fx = 0
FAB = 0
Joint A:
3
→+ ∑ Fy = FAC ( ) - 1KN = 0
4.24
FAC = 1.41 KN (T)
3
↑+ ∑ Fy = FAD + 1.41 ( ) -1KN
4.24
FAD = 0
Joint D:
→+ ∑ Fx = FCD + 1 KN
FCD = 1KN (C)
Page 17 of 56
Summary of Internal Forces in Virtual System
AB 3m 0 0 0
BC 3m -6 KN -1 KN 18 KN2m
AD 3m -6 KN 0 KN 0
CD 3m 0 -1 KN 0
∑= 68.7 KN2m
1K (∆CH) =
∑ nNL = 68.7 KN 2 m
AE AE
Page 18 of 56
External Force (P)
↑+ ∑ Fy = Ay + By – 6KN = 0
Ay + 6 + P – 6 = 0
Ay = -P
←+ ∑ Fx = Ax – 6KN + P = 0
Ax = 6KN + P
Ax = 6 + P
Internal Forces, N
Joint B:
←+ ∑ Fx = 0
FAB = 0
↑+ ∑ Fy = FBC + 6 + P = 0
FBC – 6 – P
Page 19 of 56
FBC = 6 + P (C)
Joint A:
3
→+ ∑ Fx = FAC ( ) – (6+P) = 0
4.24
3
FAC ( ) -6 – P = 0
4.24
4.24
FAC = (6+P)
3
FAC = 8.48 + 1.41P (T)
FAD + 6 + P – P
FAD = 6 KN (C)
Joint D:
→+ ∑ Fx = P + FCD = 0
FCD = -P
FCD = P (C)
Member N ∂N N(P=0) L ∂N
N( )L
∂P ∂P
AB 0 0 0 3 0
BC -(6+P) -1 -6 3 18
AD -6 0 0 3 0
CD -P -1 0 3 0
∑= 68.7 KN2m
Page 20 of 56
2
∂N L 68.7 KN m
1K (∆CH) = ∑ N =
∂ P AE AE
Question 4
Determine the vertical displacement of joint D. AE is constant. Solve using:
a) The Principle of Virtual Work
b) Castigliano’s Theorem
Solution:
a) Finding the vertical displacement of joint D by the principle of virtual work.
Page 21 of 56
→ + ∑ Fx=0
Ax=0
+ ∑ M A =0
−Cy ( 6 m) +1 KN ( 3 m )=0
−6 Cy −3
= ∴Cy=0.5 KN ↑
−6 −6
↑+ ∑ Fy=0
Ay+Cy−1 KN =0
Ay+Cy=1 KN
Ay=1−0.5=O .5 KN ↑
Considering Joint A
↑+ ∑ Fy=0
4
0.5 KN −F AD =0
5
−4
F =−0.5
5 AD
−0.5
F AD= =0.625 KN (C)
−4
5
→ + ∑ Fx=0
Page 22 of 56
3
−F AB−F AD =0
5
3
−F AB=0.625( )
5
−F AB=0.375
F AB=0.375 KN (T )
∴ F AD =F DA ∧F AB=F BA
Considering Joint C
↑+ ∑ Fy=0
4
0.5 KN −F CD =0
5
−4
F =−0.5
5 CD
−0.5
F CD = =0.625 KN (C)
−4
5
→ + ∑ Fx=0
3
F CB + F CD =0
5
3
F CB=−0.625( )
5
F CB=0.375 KN (T )
∴ FCD =F DC ∧FCB =F BC
Page 23 of 56
Consider Joint B
F AB=0.375 KN
F BC =0.375 KN
↑+ ∑ Fy=0
F BD=0 KN
Real Forces
Page 24 of 56
→ + ∑ Fx=0
Ax=0
+ ∑ M A =0
−Cy ( 6 m) +50 KN ( 3 m) =0
−6 Cy −150
= ∴ Cy=25 KN ↑
−6 −6
↑+ ∑ Fy=0
Ay+Cy−50 KN =0
Ay+Cy=50 KN
Ay=50−25=2 5 KN ↑
Consider Joint A
↑+ ∑ Fy=0
4
25 KN −F AD =0
5
−4
F =−25
5 AD
−25
F AD= =31.25 KN (C)
−4
5
Page 25 of 56
→ + ∑ Fx=0
3
−F AB−F AD =0
5
3
−F AB=31.25( )
5
−F AB=18.75 KN
F AB=18.75 KN (T )
∴ F AD =F DA ∧F AB=F BA
Consider Joint C
↑+ ∑ Fy=0
4
25 KN −F CD =0
5
−4
F =−25
5 CD
−25
F CD = =31.25 KN (C )
−4
5
→ + ∑ Fx=0
3
F CB + F CD =0
5
3
F CB=−31.25( )
5
F CB=18.75 KN (T )
∴ FCD =F DC ∧FCB =F BC
Page 26 of 56
Consider Joint B
F AB=18.75 KN
F BC =18.75 K
↑+ ∑ Fy=0
31.25 31.25
−F BD−50 KN =0
−F BD=50 KN
F BD=50 KN (T )
18.75 18.75
3m 3m
1 KN . ∆ DV =
∑ nNL
AE
AE – is constant
Page 27 of 56
2
237.5 KN m
∆ DV =
AE
4m
5 4
Ax B C
A 3m
Ay 50 KN Cy
→ + ∑ Fx=0
Ax=0
+ ∑ M A =0
−Cy ( 6 m) + P ( 3 m )+ 50 kn=0
−6 Cy −3 P−50 kn
= ∴ Cy=0.5 P+ 25 KN ( ↑ )
−6 −6
↑+ ∑ Fy=0
Ay+Cy−P−50 KN =0
Page 28 of 56
Ay+ 0.5 P+ 25 KN – P – 50KN= 0
Ay=0.5 P+25 KN (↑)
4m
5 4
B C
A 3m
0.5 P+25 KN 50 KN 0.5 P+25 KN
Joint A
N AD
A N AB
0.5 P+25 KN
↑+ ∑ Fy=0
4
0.5 P+25 KN + N AD =0
5
Page 29 of 56
4
N =−0.5 P−25 KN
5 AD
−0.5 p−25 kn
N AD = =−0.625 P−31.25 KN (C )
4
5
→ + ∑ Fx=0
3
N AB + N AD =0
5
3
N AB + (−0.625 P−31.25 KN )=¿0
5
N AB=0.375 P+18.75 KN (T )
∴ N AD=N DA ∧N AB=N BA
Joint C
N CD
4 5
3 C
N BC
0.5 P+25 KN
↑+ ∑ Fy=0
4
0.5 P+25 kn+ N CD =0
5
4
N =−0.5 P−25 KN
5 CD
−−0.5 P−25 KN
N CD = =−0.625 P−31.25 KN (C )
4
5
→ + ∑ Fx=0
Page 30 of 56
3
N CB + N CD =0
5
3
N CB + (−0.625 P−31.25 KN )=0
5
0.625 P+ 31.25 KN
N CB =
3
5
N CB =0.375 P+18.75 KN (T )
∴ N CD =N DC ∧N CB =N BC
Joint B
P
N BD
B
0.375 P+18.75 KN 0.375 P+18.75 KN
50KN
N AB=0.375 P+18.75 KN
N BC =0.375 P+18.75 KN
↑+ ∑ Fy=0
N BD=0 KN
P
D
−0.625 P−31.25 KN −0.625 P−31.25 KN
4m 5
5 4 4
Page 31 of 56
3 3
AE (Constant)
∂N L
∆ D =∑ N ( )
v
∂ P AE
ANSWER
237.5 KN /m
∆D =
v
AE
Page 32 of 56
Question 5
DETER
MINACY
M = 13
R= 3
J= 8
M + R= 2J
13 + 3 = 2(8) Therefore, Structure is Determinate
Virtual System
Page 33 of 56
EX
A B C D E
2m 2m 2m 2m
1 KN EY
A
Y
⭮ + ive ∑: MA = 0
∴Ay + 0.5 =1
Ay = 1 -0.5
Ay= 0.5
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
Ax = 0
A B C D E
Page 34 of 56
2m 2m 2m 2m
0.5 KN 0.5 KN
1 KN
JOINT A
FA
H
A FAB
0.5
Page 35 of 56
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
2
0.5 + FAH = 0
2.828
2
FAH = -0.5 /
2.828
FAH = -0.707 kN (Compression)
FAH = 0.707
FAB
A
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
2
FAB – FAH *
2.828
2
FAB = 0.707 *
2.828
FAB = 0.5 kN (Tension)
JOINT E
FEF
F\\ED E
0.5
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
Page 36 of 56
2
0.5 + FEF = 0
2.828
2
FEF = -0.5 /
2.828
FEF = -0.707 kN (Compression)
FEF = 0.707
FED E
0.5
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
2
FED – FEF *
2.828
2
FED = 0.707 *
2.828
FED = 0.5 kN (Tension)
JOINT D
FDF
FCD FED
D =0.5
Page 37 of 56
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
FDF = 0 (Zero force in y member)
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
0.5 – FCD = 0
FCD = 0.5 kN (Tension)
JOINT B
FBH
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
FBH = 0 (Zero force in y member)
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
0.5 – FBC = 0
FBC = 0.5 kN (Tension)
Page 38 of 56
JOINT H
H
FHG
FHC
FAH= 0.707
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
0.707 – FHC = 0
– FHC = -0.707
FHC = 0.707 kN (Tension)
H
FHG
FHC = 0.707
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
2
FHG * + 0.707 =0
2.828
2
FHG = 0.707 /
2.828
FHG = -0.999
FHG = -1 kN (Compression)
Page 39 of 56
JOINT F
F
FGF
FCF
FEF = 0.707
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
0.707 – FCF = 0
– FCF = -0.707
FCF = 0.707 kN (Tension)
Finding for FGF
FGF F
FCF = 0.707
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
2
FGF * + 0.707 =0
2.828
2
FGF = 0.707 /
2.828
FGF= -0.999
FGF= -1 kN (Compression)
Real Forces
Page 40 of 56
⭮ + ive ∑: MA = 0
-Ey (8) + 30 (6) + 40 (4) + 30 (2) = 0
-8Ey + 180 + 160 + 60 = 0
-8Ey + 400 = 0
−400
Ey =
−8
Ey= 50 kN
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
Ay – 30 -40 -30 + 50 = 0
Ay – 50 =0
Ay = 50 kN
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
Ex= 0
JOINT A
FAH
A FAB
50 KN
Page 41 of 56
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
2
50 + FAH =0
2.828
2
FAH = 50 /
2.828
FAH = -70.7 kN (Compression)
FAB
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
2
FAB – 70.7 * =0
2.828
50 KN
FAB – 50 = 0
FAB = 50 kN (Tension)
JOINT E
FEF
F\\ED E
50
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
2
50 + FEF = 0
2.828
Page 42 of 56
2
FEF = -50 /
2.828
FEF = -70.7 kN (Compression)
FED
FEF = 70.7
FED E
50
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
2
-FED + FEF *
2.828
2
-FED + 70.7 *
2.828
-FED + 50 = 0
FED = 50 kN (Tension)
JOINT D
FDF
30
Page 43 of 56
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
-30 + FDF = 0
FDF = 30 kN (Tension)
FCD
50
D
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
50 – FCD = 0
-FCD = -50
FCD = 50 kN (Tension)
JOINT B
FBH
FAB = 50 FBC
B
30
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
FBH – 30 = 0
FBH = 30 kN (Tension)
Page 44 of 56
Finding for FBC
FAB = 50 FBC
B
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
FBC – 50 = 0
FBC = 50 kN (Tension)
JOINT H
H
FHG
FHC
FAH = 70.7 30
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
2
70.7 – 30 * - FHC = 0
2.828
28.78 – FHC = 0
-FHC = -28.78
FCH = 28.78 kN (Tension)
FAH= 70.7
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
70.7 + FHG = 0
FHG = - 70.7 kN (Compression
JOINT F
F
FGF
FCF
30 FEF = 70.7
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
2
70.7 – 30 * - FCF = 0
2.828
FCF = 28.78 kN (Tension)
FGF F
Page 46 of 56
FCF = 70.7
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
-FGF – 70.7 = 0
- FGF = 70.7
FGF = -70.7 kN (Compression)
Page 47 of 56
nNL
1 kN. ΔCv = ∑ = 880.6 kN2 . m / AE
AE
880.6 kN . m
ΔCv =
AE
Castigliano's Theorem
1()=N . ¿
EX
A B C D E
2m 2m 2m 2m
Page 48 of 56
P EY
A
Y
N.B. A vertical force is applied to the truss at joint C
Support Reactions
+ ↻ Ma = 0
= Ēy (8) – P (4) = 0
Ēy = 0.5 P
A B C D E
Page 49 of 56
2m 2m 2m 2m
P
0.5 P + 50 kN 0.5 P + 50 kN
Considering Joint A
FAH = 0.707
FAB
0.5 P + 50kN
50
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
2
0.5(P) + 50 + FAH =0
2.828
2
FAH = 0.5(P) + 50 /
2.828
FAH = -0.7071P + 42.43 kN (C)
FAH = 0.707
FAB = 0.5 P
A
Page 50 of 56
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
2
FAB 0.5(P)– 70.7 * =0
2.828
FAB 0.5(P) – 50 = 0
FAB = 30 kN (T)
Considering Joint E
FEF
F\\ED E
0.5 P + 50
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
2
0.5(P)50 + FEF = 0
2.828
2
FEF = 0.5(P) -50 /
2.828
FEF = -0.7071P + 42.43 kN (C)
FEF = 0.707
FED E
0.5 P + 50
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
2
-FED + FEF *
2.828
Page 51 of 56
2
-FED + 0.5 (P) 70.7 *
2.828
-FED + 0.5(P) 50 = 0
FED 0.5 (P) + 30 (T)
Considering Joint D
FDF
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
-30 + FDF = 0
FDF = 30 kN (T)
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
0.5(P) + 50 – FCD = 0
-FCD = 0.5P + 30 (T)
FCD = 0.5 + 30 kN (T)
Page 52 of 56
Considering Joint B
FBH
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
FBH – 30 = 0
FBH = 30 kN (T)
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
FBC 0.5(P) – 50 = 0
FBC = 0.5(P) + 30 kN (T)
Considering Joint H
H
FHG
FHC = 0.5P + 50
FAH= 0.707
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
2
0.5 (P) + 70.7 – 30 * - FHC = 0
2.828
Page 53 of 56
0.5 (P) + 28.78 – FHC = 0
-FHC = 0.7071P
FCH = 0.7071P kN (T)
H
FHG = 0.5P + 50
FHC = 0.707
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
0.5 (P) + 70.7 + FHG = 0
FHG = - (P + 30) kN (C)
Considering Joint F
F
FGF
+ ive ∑: Fy = 0
2
0.5(P) + 70.7 – 30 * - FCF = 0
2.828
FCF = 0.7071P kN (T)
F
FGF = 0.5P + Page 54 of 56
50
FCF = 0.707
+ ive ∑: Fx = 0
-FGF 0.5(P) +(– 70.7) = 0
- FGF = - (P + 30)
FGF = -(P+30) kN (C)
Page 55 of 56
Member N (KN) ∂N N(P=40) (KN) Length (m) N(∂N/∂P) L
∂P
(KN/ m)
AB 0.5P + 30 0.5 50 2 50
DE 0.5P + 30 0.5 50 2 50
BC 0.5P + 30 0.5 50 2 50
CD 0.5P + 30 0.5 50 2 50
AH -0.7071P + 43.43 -0.7071 -70.71 22 142.83
EF -0.7071P + 43.43 -0.7071 -70.71 22 142.83
BH 30 0 30 2 0
DF 30 0 30 2 0
CH 0.7071P 0.7071 28.28 22 56.87
CF 0.7071P 0.7071 28.28 22 56.87
CG 0 0 0 2 0
GH -P+30 -1 -70 2 140
FG -P +30 -1 -70 2 140
∑ ¿ 879.4
Page 56 of 56