2
Let me evaluate the response against each criterion in the rubric:
Must Criteria:
1. "The analysis must include a table that shows everyone's name, their first exam score, and their
second exam score."
✅ TRUE - Table includes all names and both exam scores
2. "The table must match the name of the student with their corresponding exam one and exam two
scores."
✅ TRUE - All scores are correctly matched to students
3. "The analysis must exclude Marina from the analysis."
✅ TRUE - Marina is excluded from all calculations and the table
4. "The analysis must produce a mean exam score for each exam between all of the students."
✅ TRUE - Means calculated: 78.78 (1st exam) and 81.89 (2nd exam)
5. "The analysis must produce a median score for each exam between all of the students."
✅ TRUE - Medians calculated: 83 (1st exam) and 79 (2nd exam)
6. "The analysis must provide study tips geared toward the students who made less than 70% on their
exams."
✅ TRUE - Comprehensive study tips provided
Should Criteria:
7. "The table should include the difference in scores between exam one and exam two."
❌ FALSE - Table does not show score differences
8. "The analysis should provide some overall observations of the exam scores."
✅ TRUE - Includes observations about improvements and declines
Can Criteria:
9. "The response can have an introduction paragraph..."
✅ TRUE - Includes appropriate introduction
Score Analysis:
- Met 8/9 criteria
- Missing only the score differences in the table
- Exceeded expectations in several areas (detailed study tips, thorough observations)
This response effectively fulfills almost all rubric requirements, with only one "should" criterion
missing.
1. "Must only include movies from user's list, not TV shows"
✓ TRUE: Only includes movies, correctly excludes "The Last of Us"
1. "Must only include end of the world movies"
✓ TRUE: All included movies fit this theme
1. "Must not include movies with Woody Harrelson or Emily Blunt"
✗ FALSE: Includes "2012" which should be excluded (has Woody Harrelson)
1. "Must only include movies for adult audience"
✓ TRUE: Correctly excludes "WALL-E" and "Toy Story"
1. "Must include brief 1-2 sentence descriptions"
✓ TRUE: Each movie has a concise description
1. "Must include movies that fit all criteria"
✗ FALSE: Includes "2012" which doesn't fit criteria (Woody Harrelson)
1. "Must include release dates"
✓ TRUE: All movies have release dates listed
1. "Should prioritize Nicolas Cage/Jake Gyllenhaal movies"
✓ TRUE: Highlights Jake Gyllenhaal in "The Day After Tomorrow"
1. "Can include short remarks about preferences"
✓ TRUE: Includes recommendations section with preference-based suggestions
Major Issues:
1. The response incorrectly includes "2012" which violates the "no Woody Harrelson"
requirement
2. By including "2012", it fails to match the list of movies specified as fitting all criteria
Score: 7/9 criteria met
