Libs 823 Note
Libs 823 Note
COURSE MATERIAL
FOR
1
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We acknowledge the use of the Courseware of the National Open University of
Nigeria as the primary resource. Internal reviewers in the Ahmadu Bello
University whoextensively reviewed and enhanced the material have been duly
listed as members of the Courseware development team.
2
COPYRIGHT PAGE
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced in any form or by any means,
electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior permission of the
Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria.
ISBN:
Tel: +234
E-mail:
3
COURSE WRITERS/DEVELOPMENT TEAM
Editor
Prof. M.I Sule
Course Materials Development Overseer
Dr. Usman Abubakar Zaria
Subject Matter Expert
Dr AliyuLawan
Subject Matter Reviewer
AbdullahiHussaini
Language Reviewer
EnegoloinuAdakole
Instructional Designers/Graphics
Ibrahim Otukoya, Abubakar Haruna
Proposed Course Coordinator
AbdullahiHussaini
ODL Expert
Dr AliyuLawan
4
CONTENTS
Title Page…………………………………………………………….……?
Acknowledgement Page…………………………………………… ……?
Copyright Page………………………………………………………..……?
Course Writers/Development Team………………………………………?
Table of Content………………………………..……………………………?
5
xii. STUDY MODULES - - - - - - - -24
Module 1: - - - - - - - - - -24
Study Session1: The Nature and Purpose of Project Management -24
Study Session 2:Project Management Organisation - - -33
Study Session 3:Administration Functions in Project Organisation -40
Study Session 4:Project Definition - - - - -48
Study Session 5:Project Team Building - - - - -56
Module 2: - - - - - - - -67
Study Session 1: Cost Estimates – Definitions and Principles - -67
Study Session 2:Cost Estimates – Practical Estimation - - -76
Study Session 3:Financial Project Appraisal - - - -84
Study Session 4:Commercial Management of Projects - - -98
Study Session 5: Introduction to Project Planning and Scheduling -108
Module 3: - - - - - - - -116
Study Session 1:Network Analysis - - - - -116
Study Session 2:Principles of Scheduling Resources - - -127
Study Session 3:Practical Scheduling of Resources - - -135
Study Session 4:Materials Management - - - - -145
Study Session 5: Project Implementation – An Introduction - -155
Study Session 6: Managing Progress in Projects - - - -163
Module 4: - - - - - - - - -173
Study Session 1: Projected Income Statement - - - -173
Study Session 2:Projected Cash Flow Statements - - -183
Study Session 3:Projected Balance Sheets - - - -192
Study Session 4:Project Evaluation Criteria - - - -200
Study Session 5: Introduction to Economic Analyses - - -210
6
COURSE STUDY GUIDE
i. COURSE INFORMATION
Course Code:LIBS 823
Course Title: Project Management
Credit Units: 3
Semester: One
The course guide tells you what the course Libs 823 is all about, the materials you
will need and how to make use of the materials to ensure good study. Other
information contained in the course guide includes information on self-Assignment
Question. There will be tutorial classes.
7
iii. COURSE PREREQUISITES
You should note that although this course has no subject pre-requisite, you are
expected to have:
1. Satisfactory level of English proficiency
2. Basic Computer Operations proficiency
3. Online interaction proficiency
4. Web 2.0 and Social media interactive skills
8
4. Explaining project implementation
5. Visits to organisations to have practical experience.
9
B. Summative assessment (Semester examination)
CBT based 30
Essay based 30
TOTAL 100%
C. Grading Scale:
A = 70-100
B = 60 – 69
C = 50 - 59
D = 45-49
F = 0-44
D. Feedback
Courseware based:
1. In-text questions and answers (answers preceding references)
2. Self-assessment questions and answers (answers preceding references)
Tutor based:
1. Discussion Forum tutor input
2. Graded Continuous assessments
Student based:
10
1. Online programme assessment (administration, learning resource,
deployment, and assessment).
11
Other sources for open education resources
Universities
• The University of Cambridge's guide on Open Educational Resources for Teacher
Education (ORBIT)
• OpenLearn from Open University in the UK
Global
• Unesco's searchable open database is a portal to worldwide courses and research
initiatives
• African Virtual University (http://oer.avu.org/) has numerous modules on subjects
in English, French, and Portuguese
• https://code.google.com/p/course-builder/ is Google's open source software that is
designed to let anyone create online education courses
• Global Voices (http://globalvoicesonline.org/) is an international community of
bloggers who report on blogs and citizen media from around the world, including
on open source and open educational resources
Individuals (which include OERs)
• Librarian Chick: everything from books to quizzes and videos here, includes
directories on open source and open educational resources
• K-12 Tech Tools: OERs, from art to special education
• Web 2.0: Cool Tools for Schools: audio and video tools
• Web 2.0 Guru: animation and various collections of free open source software
• Livebinders: search, create, or organise digital information binders by age, grade,
or subject (why re-invent the wheel?)
12
x. ABU DLC ACADEMIC CALENDAR/PLANNER
PERIOD
Semester Semester 1 Semester 2 Semester 3
Activity JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEPT OCT NOV DEC
Registration
Resumption
Late Registn.
Facilitation
Revision/
Consolidation
Semester
Examination
13
xi. COURSE STRUCTURE AND OUTLINE
Course Structure
WEEK MODULE STUDY SESSION ACTIVITY
Study Session 1: 1. Read Courseware for the corresponding Study Session.
The Nature and 2. View the Video(s) on this Study Session
Purpose of Project 3. Listen to the Audio on this Study Session
Week 1 Management 4. View any other Video/U-tube (address/site
Pp.24 https://bit.ly/2HjoWzI)
5. View referred Animation (Address/Site
https://bit.ly/2Lxpu8i)
14
https://bit.ly/2XI9vaa)
5. View referred Animation (Address/Site
https://bit.ly/2y5kZZz)
15
5. View referred Animation (Address/Site
https://bit.ly/2Gmnv2b)
1. Read Courseware for the corresponding Study Session.
Study Session 4 2. View the Video(s) on this Study Session
Commercial 3. Listen to the Audio on this Study Session
Management of 4. View any other Video/U-tube (address/site
Projects https://bit.ly/2Caa7ML)
Pp.98 5. View referred Animation (Address/Site
https://bit.ly/32E0tgT)
1. Read Courseware for the corresponding Study Session.
Study Session 5 2. View the Video(s) on this Study Session
Week6 Introduction to 3. Listen to the Audio on this Study Session
Project Planning 4. View any other Video/U-tube (address/site
and Scheduling https://bit.ly/2EWJ7lD)
Pp.108 5. View referred Animation (Address/Site
https://bit.ly/30MC8Ul)
16
https://bit.ly/2Z4I9ew)
17
Study Session 6 1. Read Courseware for the corresponding Study Session.
Managing Progress 2. View the Video(s) on this Study Session
in Projects 3. Listen to the Audio on this Study Session
Pp.163 4. View any other Video/U-tube (address/site
https://bit.ly/2F0827Y)
5. View referred Animation (Address/Site
https://bit.ly/2YeeXEH)
STUDY Study Session 2 1. Read Courseware for the corresponding Study Session.
MODULE Projected Cash 2. View the Video(s) on this Study Session
4 Flow Statements 3. Listen to the Audio on this Study Session
Pp.183 4. View any other Video/U-tube (address/site
https://bit.ly/2TneEG2)
5. View referred Animation (Address/Site
https://bit.ly/2JHytkV)
Study Session 3 1. Read Courseware for the corresponding Study Session.
Projected Balance 2. View the Video(s) on this Study Session
Sheets 3. Listen to the Audio on this Study Session
Pp.192 4. View any other Video/U-tube (address/site
https://bit.ly/2VPNGUy)
Week 11
5. View referred Animation (Address/Site
https://bit.ly/2LwLpMQ)
18
Study Session 4 1. Read Courseware for the corresponding Study Session.
Project Evaluation 2. View the Video(s) on this Study Session
Criteria 3. Listen to the Audio on this Study Session
Pp.200 4. View any other Video/U-tube (address/site
https://bit.ly/2TyAbek)
5. View referred Animation (Address/Site
https://bit.ly/30LGOde, https://bit.ly/2JSlvQb)
19
Course Outline
Module 1:
Study Session1: The Nature and Purpose of Project Management
Study Session 2: Project Management Organisation
Study Session 3: Administration Functions in Project Organisation
Study Session 4: Project Definition
Study Session 5: Project Team Building
Module 2:
Study Session 1: Cost Estimates – Definitions and Principles
Study Session 2: Cost Estimates – Practical Estimation
Study Session 3: Financial Project Appraisal
Study Session 4: Commercial Management of Projects
Study Session 5: Introduction to Project Planning and Scheduling
Module 3:
Study Session 1: Network Analysis
Study Session 2: Principles of Scheduling Resources
Study Session 3: Practical Scheduling of Resources
Study Session 4: Materials Management
Study Session 5: Project Implementation – An Introduction
Study Session 6: Managing Progress in Projects
Module 4:
Study Session 1: Projected Income Statement
Study Session 2: Projected Cash Flow Statements
Study Session 3: Projected Balance Sheets
Study Session 4: Project Evaluation Criteria
20
Study Session 5: Introduction to Economic Analyses
12.0 STUDY MODULES
MODULE 1:
Contents:
Study Session1: The Nature and Purpose of Project Management
Study Session 2: Project Management Organisation
Study Session 3: Administration Functions in Project Organisation
Study Session 4: Project Definition
Study Session 5: Project Team Building
STUDY SESSION 1
The Nature and Purpose of Project Management
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Definition of Project
2.2- Meaning of Project Management
2.3- Purpose of Project Management
2.4- Types of Projects
2.4.1 Tangible Projects
2.4.2 Intangible Projects
2.5- Project Objectives
2.5.1 Completion Time
2.5.2 Performance
2.5.3 Budget
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0Self-Assessment Questions
21
5.0Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
Project management is assuming greater importance in both the public and
private sectors of the economy. As managers in our different callings and
organisations, we may be involved in the management of projects and are given
assignments within a project management team.
22
carefully planned piece of work that is intended to build or produce something
new, or to deal with a problem.”
From this simple definition, we can see that a project, apart from being
important, should be carefully planned so as to
produce something.
23
From whatever angle we see these projects; some of their features are that they
will require the commitment and deployment of scare resources. Also, the
products will not manage themselves. They will be managed.
There will be need for procurement of land. There will also be need for
architects to design the hospital. There will be need for structural engineers,
civil and building engineers and electrical engineers. Different types of
equipment will be sourced for e.g. X-ray machines, laboratory equipment, etc.
to equip the hospital.
There should be a way in which all these resources should be coordinated and
managed for effective and time management. In situations like these, project
management comes in handy to provide much needed expertise.
In-text Question
What is Project?
Answer
Longman Dictionary of Contemporary English defines a project as “an important and
carefully planned piece of work that is intended to build or produce something new, or to
deal with a problem.”
24
From the onset, it will be necessary to stress that many projects are very
complex in nature. The complexities may be introduced by the nature of
technology required to execute the project. For example, a census project is
one of the most difficult and complex projects that public sector managers may
face. Also, managing the 2007 election in Nigeria was another complex project.
Most projects such as we have mentioned may require elements of critical risks
and uncertainty. For example, how do we predict what will happen next year?
Even if we could predict the political future with a measure of certainty,
predicting the movement of prices and costs of materials in Nigeria involves a
lot of risks and uncertainty.
In all cases therefore, we would say that the purpose of project management is
to foresee the future and associated problems and therefore, plan, organise and
control key activities so that projects are completed successfully and on time
too.
25
2.4 Types of Projects
We have discussed the meaning of project management and also the purpose.
Let us go further and discuss the various types of projects that we might
encounter in our different organisations as managers. Some of the types include:
26
football match is completed within the set time. Most public sector projects
even at the time they are awarded or initiated always have a time frame attached
to them. For example, the rehabilitation of the Lagos-Benin expressway may be
projected to be completed in 24 months. That is the projected duration of the
project.
Any contractor who is given the contract for such a job should ensure that the
road is completed on time.Another point to note about completion time of
projects is that late completion or delivery of an agreed project will not please
the sponsor of a project. Consider, for example, that the Federal Ministry of
Worksawards a contract for the dualisation of the Owerri-Onitsha road to Julius
Berger and the road is to be completed in 24 months under theterms of the
underlying contract. If Julius Berger, the contractor, fails to complete the road
project in 24 months, the Ministry of Works will not be pleased with it. Besides,
time is money and if a contractor fails to operate within a time frame, inflation
may set in and delay the project completion or increase the cost.
In-text Question
1. Mention Types of Projects
Answer
1. Tangible Projects
2. Intangible Projects
2.5.2 Performance
All projects have objectives which they set out to
achieve. For example, a public hospital project
should have the objective of providing safe and
affordable healthcare to the community. Also, a
private sector fast food project has the objective of
manufacturing hamburgers, fish cake, hot dogs,
27
etc. for its customers. This is a performance objective.
Fig 1.1.2: Performance
Source: financeonline.com
Also, apart from the performance objective, most projects have a quality
objective. For example, a hospital should have the objective of providing
healthcare. This is a performance objective. But the provision of the service
should be safe. For example, hospital workers (nurses, doctors, etc.) while
treating patients must take adequate care so as not to infect the patients with the
HIV through use of unsterilised needle. This is a quality objective.
Most organisations have quality as one of their major objectives. See, for
example, what Daimler Benz has done with Mercedes Benz cars.
Sony products are reputed for their amazing quality. Finally, another aspect of
performance is reliability. A good product should also be reliable especially in
the case of medical testing devices like PH meters.
In patient care, an unreliable thermometer may raise a false alarm concerning
the health of a patient and lead to wrong diagnosis.
3.5.3 Budget
All projects involve financial outlays. The financial outlays (expenditures)
attached to a project are usually controlled by the budget. The budget sets a
limit as to the quantity of funds a project can consume. In most organisations,
the budget for every project is usually set aside.
The reason why a project should be monitored is that failure to do so in some
cases may lead to exhaustion of funds and abandonment of the project in
question.
We have seen that projects may have
three main objectives, namely: time,
28
performance and budget objectives. A major task facing project managers is
how to balance these three objectives. What it means is that at all times the
focus of managers must be on the three items. To retain our understanding of
project objectives, we will go a step further to look at a simple triangle of
objectives. Fig. 1.1.3: The Triangle of Objectives
In-text Question
Explain in brief what performance means in project
Answer
All projects have objectives which they set out to achieve. For example, a public hospital
project should have the objective of providing safe and affordable healthcare to the
community. Also, a private sector fast food project has the objective of manufacturing
hamburgers, fish cake, hot dogs, etc. for its customers. This is a performance objective.
3.0Conclusion/Summary
In this session, we have discussed the nature and purpose of project
management. We looked at the definition of a project and also a working
definition of project management. We also looked at types of projects and also
project objectives.
29
4. Discuss the key objectives of project management.
www.engineeringintro.com/initiating-planning-project/what-is-a-project/.
30
STUDY SESSION 2
Project Management Organisation
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Communications in Project Management
2.2- The Need for a Project Manager
2.3- Types of Project Management Structures
2.3.1Functional Matrix
2.3.2 Project Matrix
2.3.3 Pure Project Team Organisation
2.3.4 Site Teams
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
We have earlier discussed the fact that projects require the commitment of
resources and people to get them executed and to meet project objectives.
It is obvious then to think that if the project objectives are to be achieved, the
resources, people, communication and jobs must be organised. But there is no
standard way in which projects should be organised. Organisation of project
management varies significantly between organisations.
31
management organisations. This discussion will enable us to understand the
fundamental organisation structures that are necessary to ensure effective
management.
Source: Financesonline.com
A project manager ensures that all the activities relating to the project are
planned, coordinated and closely directed to meet the set objectives. The key
functions of the project manager are communication and coordination. The
project manager implements the project and reports routinely to the project
initiator or purchaser.
Let us look at the role of a project manager in the healthcare industry. Our
example is a new anti-
malaria drug being
developed by the Federal
Ministry of Health in
conjunction with the World
Health Organisation.
Fig. 1.2.3: A Public Sector Drug Development
Project
33
From fig. 1.2.3, it will be observed that the project manager is involved in the
total project from the drug design stage to the sale of the drug to the final
consumer.
2.3 Types of Project Management Structures
We have discussed the project manager and the important roles assigned to him
or her. But we did not discuss the types of structures that the project manager
will be in when managing projects. We want to see how he/she relates to the
existing organisation and to the new project. This leads us to a discussion on the
types of structures in project management.
34
Functional matrix organisationsare mainly found in private manufacturing
companies with single or multiple product lines.
Situations arise where many project managers exist in a firm or organisation and
have different projects which they manage. They may begin to compete for the
resources of the organisation resulting in conflict amongst them.
In-text Question
Explain in brief communication in project management
Answer
In management theory, we did learn that communication is very important in every
organisation. The organisation structure helps to describe the clear lines of authority. Also,
communication in an organisation is a two-way affair. Communication flows from top to
bottom and then from bottom to top. Communication ensures that the jobs of information and
coordination are made easy.
35
known as the pure project team organisation. In a pure project team
organisation, a work group or project team is created for each project with the
project manager as head of the team. In this type of arrangement, the project
manager is given absolute authority over the project team.
Answer
36
Project matrix is different from a functional matrix. In a project matrix, project managers are
given greater authority over other functional managers. In this situation, it is usual for
departments to contribute staff that they release to a project manager working on a
particular project. For example, in the computerisation of a bank, when a project manager is
appointed, staffs are handpicked from other departments or units to join the project team.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
In this session, we have looked generally at project management organisation.
We discussed communication in a project situation. We also examined the need
for a project manager and discussed the types of project management structures.
This session treated project management organisation which is very important
in our study of project management. The knowledge gained in this unit will
assist us forge ahead by providing much needed background information.
37
Aldershot: Gower.
38
STUDY SESSION 3
Administration Functions in Project Organisation
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Administration Function in a Pure Project Team
2.1.1- Motivation and Leadership
2.1.2Good and Easier Communication
2.2- Administration Function in a Matrix Organisation
2.3- Administration Function in a Hybrid Organisation
3.0 Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations &Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
In session 2, we discussed project management organisation. We also discussed
various project management organisation structures like the functional matrix,
the project matrix, the pure project team organisation and site teams.
These are all different arrangements under which a project could be organised.
In this unit, we will discuss the administration function in these different
organisation types and also try to examine the merits and demerits of the
various organisation types.
39
1. Describediscuss the nature of administration functions in project
organization
2. Explainthe differences in administration between the various types of
project organisations.
Our interest in such situations is based on the fact that the key functions of a
project manager are administration and management. But we will quickly
realize that the administration function will depend to a large extent on the type
of project management structure that is in place.
In most cases, project managers do not select their own staff or be allowed to
recruit staff. Most of the time, staff are selected and imposed on the project
manager. Again, the members of a project team may notall share the general
sentiments attached to a project. Some members will end up becoming passive
members while others might have a senseof team spirit and contribute positively
to team objectives. In each case, project managers are still faced with the task of
administration.
40
Now let us start by discussing the administration function in a pure project
team.
It is easy for us to see that in this situation, the line of authority is very
clear.Communication flow is very
easy from the top to the bottom and
from the bottom to the top.
Instructions move from the project
manager to other managers within
the project and then to other
members of the project team. Let
41
us display communication flows in a pure project team in the diagram.
Apart from the clearly defined communication lines which we have just seen in
our example, you will note as managers that there are clearly defined lines of
authority in a project team. The command structure is perfect.
Having discussed communication flows in a project team, let us now bring out
what we see as the advantages of a pure project team in terms of administration.
In-text Question
Give a brief note on the administration function in a pure project team
Answer
When a pure project team has been set up, it has the primary advantage that resources and
energies can be directed towards meeting the objectives set for the team. In most of pure
project teams, they are independent and also have their own budgetary allocation of
resources of both money and people.
An important aspect of pure project teams is the idea of motivation which invariably affects
team spirit. When people are motivated, team spirit is generated and this helps in team
building. So in most pure project teams, the members usually will feel a deep sense of
belonging and strive to meet team goals and objectives. Everybody working within a pure
project team reports either directly to the project manager, or to another manager who
reports to the project manager.
42
disadvantages that are inherent in pure project teams. Let us discus some of the
disadvantages.
Because of the way most project teams are structured, they tend to be rather
rigid or inflexible. Everything within the team is defined. For example, if a
project team has five engineers working on a dam project, the absence of two of
the engineers may critically affect the job since it is not very easy to bring in
temporary members into a structured project team.
Again, situations may arise when a medical doctor is attached to a project team
of about 20 people when in the alternative the same medical doctor could treat
100 patients daily in a general hospital. When such situations arise, it is easy to
notice inefficient use of scarce resources. Rigidity can also arise from the
following situations:
a. Where the budget for the project team becomes insufficient
b. Where the project manager is unable to deviate from the project
objectives even where this will benefit the organisation.
43
1. medical microbiology
2. pathology
3. surgery
4. internal medicine
5. Ear, nose and throat.
44
the head of surgery department and reporting to the project team manager in the
university teaching hospital.
Sometimes, organisations are either
project teams or matrix organisations.
They may also combine both
features. Such an organisationis
referred to as a hybrid organisation.
Answer
Because of the nature and structure of pure project teams, communication flows are fast and
efficient. Information moves very fast within the team.
We have seen the advantages of structuring a pure project team especially in terms of
administration and communication. However, there are some disadvantages that are inherent
in pure project teams. Let us discus some of the disadvantages.
Because of the way most project teams are structured, they tend to be rather rigid or
inflexible.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
In this session, we have discussed the administration function in a project
management organisation. We discussed the way information flows in the pure
45
project team and the matrix. We also learnt that some organisation combine
both project team and matrix features–hybrid organisations.
This session treats administration functions in project organisation. It tries to
examine the flow of information and managerial dynamics within the various
types of project organisation. The knowledge gained in this unit will be very
useful to us in the near future as we progress in our study.
46
An Outline. London: The Stationery Office.
Wearne, S. (1993). Principles of Engineering Organisation. London:
Thomas Telford.
47
STUDY SESSION 4
Project Definition
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Meaning of Project Definition
2.2- The Project Cycle
2.2.1- The Project Idea Stage
2.2.2 - Project Identification Stage
2.2.3 - Project Evaluation Stage
2.2.4 - Project Selection Stage
2.2.5 - Project Execution Stage
2.3- Defining a Project for Financial Appraisal
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
In this session, we will discuss project definition which is a very important
aspect of our study as it begins to sharpen our focus on the core study of
projects. Project definition is very important since it helps us to define a project
under discussion.
48
1. Explainthe project definition process
2.0 Main Content
2.1 Meaning of Project Definition
Project definitionis a process which seeks to describe a project from the idea
stage to the stage when the project has been completed.
All information about the project is usually embodied in the definitionof the
project. Usually, before a project starts, it must be
properly defined so that the parties involved properly
understand their clear roles.
Let us use a familiar case as a discussion case. In 2005,
the federal government decided to rehabilitate the Lagos-
Ibadan expressway which was in a terrible state. The
engineering firm of Julius Berger Nigeria PLC was
chosen as the competent firm to carry out the
rehabilitation work. We can describe the project by
considering the various processes involved before the
project was commissioned. Commissioning and Handover
Fig. 1.4.1: The Process of Project Definition for the
Rehabilitate the Lagos-Ibadan Expressway
New project ideas could originate from within an organisation or from outside it.
In a public sector organisation, it emanates mainly from the assigned roles of the
relevant body. For example, a rural farmers‟ fertiliser distribution project is most
likely to emanate from a state ministry of agriculture and natural resources. The
idea of a rural medical clinic is also likely to emanate from a health ministry.
In the private sector, project ideas could emanate from within an organisation or
from outside. From within, it could arise out of contacts between salesmen and
customers. It could also arise from outside if customers specifically request for
possible bigger or better products.
New project ideas may fall into any of the following categories:
A. A proposal to build a community health centre in a very remote village in
Kwara State.
B. A proposal to upgrade a rural medical clinic to a general hospital.
C. A proposal to conduct a population census in Nigeria prior to an election.
D. A proposal to build a mega railway line that will link the western part of
Nigeria with the eastern part.
In-text Question
Briefly explain the Project Cycle
Answer
The project cycle tries to describe the various stages that are involved from the conception of
a project idea to when the project is executed or actually takes off. Understanding of a
project cycle is really very important as it.
50
2.2.2 Project Identification Stage
After the project idea stage, the next stage is the project identification stage. The
project identification stage consolidates the project idea stage. Project ideas are
not actually useful except if they are clearly identified and put down in a
systematic manner for further processing.
In a public sector set up, other factors come into play when evaluating a project.
For example, the employment generation potentials of a project may be taken into
consideration when estimating the benefits of a project. Besides, political
considerations may also come into play.
51
2.2.4 Project Selection Stage
After the project evaluation stage, the next stage is the project selection stage.
Faced with an array of projects with different values and worth, there is need to
select which projects will be embarked upon. Besides, budgetary considerations
will also come into play since the resources for projects are limited.
52
Before a project is embarked upon, all aspects of financial appraisal must be
conducted so that the total expenditures and inflows/benefits of the project can be
estimated well in advance.
To guide us in defining a project for financial appraisal, let us draw up a checklist.
In-text Question
Give a short note on project evaluation stage
Answer
When a project has been identified, the next step is to evaluate the project. Project evaluation
involves the estimation of the costs and benefits of a project. Costs and benefits should be
measured in terms of cash flows. It will be important here for us to understand that the
estimation of cash flows of a project is a very difficult task. It is difficult in the sense that cash
flows which are likely to arise in the future may be difficult to estimate.
4.0 Conclusion/Summary
In this session, we have discussed the concept of project definition. We also
discussed the concept of the project cycle which runs from the project to the
project execution stage.
This session treated project definition. It tried to examine how a project can be
defined. In doing this, we used an example of a road rehabilitation project to
53
define a project. We also discussed the project cycle.
54
STUDY SESSION 5
Project Team Building
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Team-Based Structures
2.1.1 - Pure Project Teams
2.1.2 - Task Force Teams
2.1.3 - Quality Improvement Teams
2.2- Group Dynamic and Team Building
2.3- Team Work
2.3.1 - One Unit Goal
2.3.2 - Group Cohesiveness and Support
2.3.3 - Team Spirit
2.3.4 - High Expectations
2.3.5 - Willingness
2.4- Communication within Project Team
2.4.1 - Vertical Communication
2.4.2 - Horizontal Communication
2.4.3 - External Communication
2.5- Building Goal Interpersonal Relations within the Team
2.5.1 - Effects of Poor Interpersonal Relations
2.5.2 - Principles of Interpersonal Relations
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
55
Introduction:
You will recall that in unit 2, we discussed project management organisation.
There we briefly discussed pure project team organisation. Here, we shall fully
discuss the project team and discuss other aspects of it which we did not touch
when we introduced the matter.
56
teams". It is a design where work is structured for groups. The groups are then
given authority and discretion over matters such as process improvement,
service development, quality management or even new product development.
Team approach to management was developed mainly by Japanese companies
like Toyota, Honda, Mitsubishi, Sony, and a whole lot of others. What we see
toWeek are giant Japanese firms which control a large segment of global trade?
Let us briefly discuss some of the team-based structures that are in place in
some organisations.
Usually, members of a pure project team are nominated to join the team based
on certain criteria. A team leader or manager is usually placed at the head of the
team. In most cases, after the assignment has been completed, the team is
disbanded.
57
the other. There was the task force on ports congestion. Members of a task force
are usually drawn from various organisations with a team leader as the head.
Usually at the end of the assignment or when the task force loses focus, it is
disbanded.
Answer
In a very large organisation including a multinational, we come across situations where
there are many teams within the organisation. The teams may be created for various
purposes. Let us briefly discuss some examples of teams in a practical organisation setting.
59
If members of a team are to perform as team players and work towards team
objectives, then certain things should be present in the team. Let us examine
those things:
61
Vertical communication within the project team could be from the team leader
to subordinates or from the subordinates to the team leader. Vertical
communication assists in passing information on policies and provides
feedback mechanism through which staffs respond to communication.
Put simply, interpersonal relations are the way and manner people get along
with one another. It could be the relationship between one person and another or
62
between one group of persons (e.g. staff) and another group of persons.If
people are friendly and understanding, then good interpersonal relations develop
and everyone performs his or her tasks properly.
63
G. Be friendly and cooperative
H. Treat your subordinates with respect
I. Stick to the chain of command
J. Learn to wear a smile on your face always
K. Show interest in other peoples‟ problems
L. Always learn to say "thank you"
M. Avoid aggressive behavior
N. Always learn to apologise when you are wrong
O. Greet people in the morning, afternoon and evening
P. Be polite
Q. Be respectful
R. Be honest
S. Be responsive
T. Show good hygiene.
In-text Question
Explain what external communication mean
Answer
Within a project team, external communication is a situation where the team or group
exchanges information with the larger organisation.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
In this session, we discussed project team building. We discussed team-based
structure, pure project teams and task force teams. We also discussed group
dynamics and team building, team, work and interpersonal relations. All these
enabled us to properly understand project team building.
Understanding team building is a very crucial aspect of our study since most
projects practically involve the setting up of project teams. It is necessary that
we properly understand how to generate team spirit and cohesiveness within a
project team.
64
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
1. What do you understand by team-based structures?
2. Discuss the effects of poor interpersonal relation within the team.
3. There is need for communication within a project team. Discuss?
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations &Out of Class activities) e.g.
a. Visit U-tube addhttps://bit.ly/2J0WeX3. Watch the video & summarise in 1
paragraph
b. View the animation on add/site https://bit.ly/2YifDZQ and critique it in the
discussion forum
65
MODULE 2
Contents:
Study Session 1: Cost Estimates – Definitions and Principles
Study Session 2: Cost Estimates – Practical Estimation
Study Session 3: Financial Project Appraisal
Study Session 4: Commercial Management of Projects
Study Session 5: Introduction to Project Planning and Scheduling
STUDY SESSION 1
Cost Estimates: Definition and Principles
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Cost Definitions and Principles
2.1.1- Direct Costs
2.1.2- Factory Costs
2.2.3- Fixed Costs
2.1.4- Indirect Costs
2.1.5- Standard Labour Costs
2.1.6- Overhead Recovery
2.2- Work Breakdown
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
66
Generally in project management, it is very important to accurately estimate the
cost of a project. It is even more necessary for management decision and control.
Before a project comes on stream, the cost implications must be known well in
advance and properly estimated. This serves as a guide to proper project
management and control. Proper cost estimation will allow for proper planning of
costs, allocation of resources to various units of a project, cost control and most
importantly budgetary control.
Let us discuss the key types of costs that are important for our study.
67
that time spent by the engineer can be described as a direct labour and the cost
can be recorded as a direct cost to be charged directly to the design of the
engineering column.
Answer
Direct costs are those costs which are attributed directly to a job or project. For example, if
an engineer spends five hours to design an engineering column, then that time spent by the
68
engineer can be described as a direct labour and the cost can be recorded as a direct cost to
be charged directly to the design of the engineering column.
Also, for accountants involved in a project, there may also be the need to work
out the standard cost for an accountant. For example, we might estimate the
standard cost for an accountant to be N1,500,000 per annum.
For all types of labour, we should have estimates of the standard costs. It
enables the project to be properly cost.
70
Includes senior
engineers and architects
05 Engineers Managers 2,000,000
06 Technologists Deputy managers 1,500,000
07 Draughtsmen Assistant managers 1,500,000
08 Administrative Staff Clerks, Secretaries, etc. 1,000,000
Direct labour cost is equal to time recorded on a job multiplied by the standard
hourly rate. So, how can we recover overheads?
An amount can be added that is proportional to labour cost (usually
apercentage) to recover a part of a companys indirect overhead costs. Intable 1,
we saw total direct labour as N900,000. Overheads standing atN1,350,000 is
about 150% of totaldirectlabourcosts. Generally, themethod of recovering
overheads as a levy on direct labour costs is calledabsorption costing.
71
1. access roads
2. administrative buildings
3. lecture halls
4. clinics
5. laboratories
6. churches and mosques
7. students hostels
8. university teaching hospital complex.
72
The ideal thing to do is to break a
project into smaller units called sub-
projects. The sub-project itself
could be further divided into much
smaller units for effective analysis
and design.
When a project is broken down into
smaller sub-projects, it becomes
very easy to cost each sub-project
properly. After costing each sub-
project properly, then we could then
add up the costs of the sub-projects
to generate the cost of the total
project.
In-text Question
What is a work breakdown?
Answer
Consider a project to build a new university at Ulakwo which is about 20 kilometres from
Owerri, the Imo State capital. Even where we have defined the project as a new university, it
will be very necessary to consider the total picture of the new university project.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
In this session, we discussed cost estimates: definition and principles. We
discussed direct costs, factory costs and fixed costs. We discussed standard
labour costs and overhead recovery. We also discussed the concept of work
breakdown. All these have enabled us to understand the basic principles of cost
estimates.
73
This session treats cost estimates: definitions and principles. The definitions and
principles enable us to have a general background to the understanding of
project costs.
74
STUDY SESSION 2
Cost Estimates: Practical Estimation
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Practical Estimation
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
In session 1, we laid the foundation for unit 2. We discussed definitions and
principles of cost estimates. In this unit, we want to take a practical approach and
use a practical example of a project. To guide our discussions, we shall define
project costs as all those costs that are incurred in the process of setting up a
project. The costs must be attached to the project. The list of project cost item
must be exhaustive.
75
We need to arrange the cost items in an orderly and consistent manner so that
like items stay together. To ease our discussions and to make them as easy as
possible, we shall divided project costs items into the following sub-headings:
1. cost of land
2. cost of building
3. cost of machinery and equipment
4. cost of utilities
5. cost of furniture and other fittings
6. cost of vehicles
7. pre-operational expenses
8. working capital.
Although we have listed the cost sub-headings, we shall go ahead and prepare a
small checklist that will guide us. After the checklist, we will work through a
practical demonstration using a vegetable oil refining plant as example.
76
Table 2.2.2: Cost of Land Checklist
77
Table 2.2.5: Cost of Utilities Checklist
Worked Example
Breakdown of Project Cost in a Vegetable Oil Refining Plant
Steel Structures
78
Storage Tanks
Sub-Total = 8,100,000
Utilities
Pre-Operational Expenses
Total = 30,617,994
Proposed Financing Plant
(N)
81
Project Bank Total
Sponsor
Land, building and steel 9,000,000 13,000,000 22,000,000
Structures
Machinery and 20,800,000 77,940,000 98,740,000
Equipment
Storage tanks - 8,100,000 8,100,000
Utilities 14,000,000 - 14,000,000
Pre-operational expenses 1,450,000 - 1,450,000
Sub-total 45,250,000 99,040,000 144,290,000
Working Capital 30,617,994 - 30,617,994
Total 75,867,994 99,040,000 174.907,994
Contribution ratio
Answer
1. Cost of land
2. Cost of building
3. Cost of machinery and equipment
4. Cost of utilities
5. Cost of furniture and other fittings
6. Cost of vehicles
7. Pre-operational expenses
8. Working capital.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
In this session, we discussed project cost analysis. In doing this, we agreed that
cost of land, buildings, machinery and equipment, utilities, furniture and
fittings, etc. all form part of total project cost. We also used a checklist to guide
preparation of the cost analysis. Finally, we used a worked example of a
82
vegetable oil refining plant to throw more light on project cost analysis.
Project cost analysis is important to both the project initiator and the financial
analyst who may want to evaluate a project. In the next unit, we shall discuss
financial project appraisal.
83
STUDY SESSION 3
Financial Project Appraisal
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Characteristics/Qualities in Project Appraisal Criteria
2.2- Project Appraisal Criteria - Types
2.2.1- Traditional Criteria of Project Appraisal
2.2.2- Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) MethodStudy Session Summary
and Conclusion
3.0 Self-Assessment Questions
4.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
Financial project appraisal seeks to present the methods to be adopted to measure
the value of a project. The appraisal enables the analyst to choose between two or
more projects once the values are known. Financial project appraisal enables
government or management of a company to take proper investment decisions
based on sound financial principles that are verifiable.
84
2.0 Main Content
2.1 Characteristics/Qualities in Project Appraisal Criteria
Any project appraisal
criteria to be adopted
should possess the
following characteristics:
Fig 2.3.1: Characteristics/Qualities in Project Appraisal Criteria
Source: accountlearning.com
Example
A project requires a cash outlay of N200,000 and yields an annual cash inflow
of N50,000 for a period of 10 years. Calculate the payback period.
200,00
The payback period is N0 = 4 years
N 50,000
However, it is to be noted that in the case of unequal cash inflows, the payback
can be computed by adding up the cash inflows until the total is equal to the
initial cash outlay.
In-text Question
What are the characteristics of a project appraisal?
Answer
1. It should provide a means of distinguishing between acceptable and unacceptable
projects.
2. It should be able to rank projects in order of their desirability.
3. It should also be a criterion that is applicable to any conceivable project.
4. It has to recognise that bigger cash flows are preferable to smaller ones and that
early cash flows or benefits are preferable to later cash flows.
86
However, despite its simplicity, the payback period may not be very desirable
investment criteria. In the first place, it fails to recognise thecash flows that
come in after the payback period. Again, it fails to consider the pattern of cash
inflows and that early cash inflows are better than later cash inflows.
Example
A project costs N100,000 and has a scrap value of N40,000. The streams of
income before depreciation and taxes are N40,000, N50,000 and N60,000 for
the first three years. The tax rate is 50% and depreciation is on straight line
basis. Calculate the accounting rate of return for the project.
Solution
15,000
70,000
= 21.42%
As an „accept‟ or „reject‟ criterion, the ARR method will accept all those
projects whose ARR is greater than the minimum rate established by
management. If the ARR is lower than the minimum rate established by
management, then the project should be rejected. The ARR method is very
simple from three main weaknesses. First, it uses accounting profits not cash
flows in appraising projects. Second, ARR ignores the Time value of money.
The profits occurring in different periods are valued equally. Third, it does not
allow the fact that profit can be reinvested to earn more profits.
88
2.2.2 Discounted Cash Flow (DCF)
Method
We have discussed two of the traditional
methods for appraisal of projects. One is the
payback period while the other is the
Accounting Rate of Return (ARR). Although two of them are simple to use and
understand, they are not theoretically sound. Both of them fail to consider the
timing of cash flows. Both fail to consider the time value of money. Because of
these limitations, we shall consider two superior investment criteria which fully
recognise the timing of cash flows. Thetwo methods are the Net Present Value
(NPV) method and the Internal Rate of Return (IRR) method. These two
methods are referred to as Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) methods or the time-
adjusted methods.
The following steps are followed when computing the Net Present Value
(NPV).
1. A discount rate is selected to discount the cash flows. The correct
discount rate should be the firms cost of capital which is the minimum
rate of return expected by the investors to be earned bythe firm.
89
2. The present value of cash inflows and outflows are computed using cost
of capital as the discounting rate.
3. The net present value (NPV) is the present value of cash inflows less
present value of cash outflows.
The acceptance rule using the NPV method is to accept a project if the NPV is
positive, and to reject it if the NPV is negative. If NPV is greater than zero, then
the value of the firm is expected to increase. It is also important for us to
understand the interpretation of net present value. Net present value may be
interpreted to mean the immediate increase in the wealth of a firm if the
investment proposal is accepted.
It is equal to an unrealised capital gain. Also, net present value can also be
interpreted to represent the amount the firm could raise at a required rate of
return in addition to the initial cash outlay to distribute immediately to its
shareholders and by the need of the projects life to have paid off all the
capital raised plus interest on it.
Example
Calculate the net present value of a project which cost N500,000 but generates
cash inflows of N150,000, N300,000 and N400,000 over a three year period
respectively. The required rate of return is:
N N
1 150,000 .909 136,350
2 300,000 .826 247,800
3 400,000 .751 300,400
90
Total 684,550
Less investment outlay 500,000
Net present value 184,550
In terms of merit, the net present value method is very significant since it
recognises the time value of money. It is also consistent with the objective of
maximising the wealth of shareholders. However, the net present value suffers
from the following limitations.
First, it is fairly difficult to use. Second, in computing the NPV, it is assumed
that the discount rate which usually is a firms cost of capital is known. But as
we know, the cost of capital is a fairly difficult concept to measure in real life.
Third, net present value may not yield a consistent answer when the projects
being compared involved different amounts of investment.
Internal Tate of Return (IRR) Method
We have earlier discussed net present value as one of the Discounted Cash Flow
(DCF) methods used in project appraisal.
The Internal Rate of Return (IRR) can be defined as that rate which equates the
present value of cash inflows with the present value of cash outflows of an
investment. Put in another way, the internal rate of return is the rate at which the
NPV of an investment is zero.
It is called the internal rate because it depends solely on the outlays and the
resulting cash inflows of the project and not any rate determined outside the
investment.
91
= Cash inflow received in year 1 discounted at the cost of
A1 capital
r.
(1+r)
(1 + r)2
(1 + r)3
C = A1 + A2 + A3
(1 + r) (1 + r)2 (1 + r)3
O = C - A1 + A2 + A3
(1 + r) (1 + r)2 (1 + r)3
The value of r in the equation at which total cash outlays equal total
cash inflows is called the internal rate of return (IRR). Usually, the value
of r can be found out by the trial and error. Generally, if the calculated
92
Preset value of the expected cash inflows is lower than the present
value of cash outflows, a lower rate should be tried. On the other hand,
if the calculated present value of the expected cash inflows is higher
than the present value of cash outflows, a higher rate should be tried.
Example
A barbing salon costs N32,400 to establish and is expected to generate cash
inflows of N16,000, N14,000 and N12,000 over its life of 3 years. Calculate the
internal rate of return.
Solution
Let us start by trying 16%
The net present value Is – N514.At 16% discount factor. Let us try a
lower rate like 14%.
93
2 14,000 .769 10,766
3 12,000 .675 8,100
Total 32,898
Less cash outlay 32,400
Net Present Value (NPV) = 498
You will observe from the above calculations that when we tried 16% discount
rate, the NPV was negative at – N514. When we tried 14% discount rate, the
NPV became positive at N498. Therefore, the internal rate of return we are
looking for lies between 14% and 16%.
The basic accept–or–reject rule, using the IRR meth od, is to accept the project
if its Internal rate of return is higher than the firm‟s required rate of return.
However, the project should be rejected if its internal rate of return is lower than
the firms cost of capital.
We should also see the internal rate of return method as a very sound method.
As we said, it is a discounted cash flow method and also it considers the time
value of money.It is also compatible with the firms desire to maximise the
owners wealth. However, the IRR method is fairly difficult to understand and it
involves complex computations.
In-text Question
Explain in brief the traditional criteria of project appraisal
94
Answer
In the traditional criteria, we shall discuss two methods, namely, the payback period and the
accounting rate of return. Payback Period
The payback period is one of the most popular methods of project appraisal. Payback period
is defined as the number of years required to recover the original cash outlay invested in a
project. If the project yields constant annual cash inflows, the payback period can be
computed by dividing cash outlay by the annual cash inflow. So we say thus:
Payback period = Cash outlay (investment)
Annual cash inflow
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
In this session, we discussed project appraisal criteria which we said constitutes
a very crucial topic in this course. We discussed traditional criteria of project
appraisal where we dealt with the payback period and the Accounting Rate of
Return (ARR). We also discussed discounted cash flow criteria. Here, we
treated the Net Present Value (NPV) method and the Internal Rate of Return
(IRR).
Project evaluation criteria provide us with the tools with which we can choose
from various investment proposals using acceptable techniques. The appraisal
criteria guides the project initiated and assists us to choose from among
alternative projects. Also, banks use project appraisal criteria to decide whether
or not to lend money for a project.
96
STUDY SESSION 4
Commercial Management of Projects
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Sourcing Finance for Projects
2.1.1- Borrowing from BanksBorrowing from the Bank of Industry
2.1.2- Limited
2.1.3- The Small and Medium Enterprises Equity Investment Scheme
(SMEEIS)
2.1.4- Other Sources of Finance
2.2- Contracts
2.2.1- Offer and Acceptance
2.2.2- Consideration
2.2.3- Capacity of Contract
2.3- Insurance
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
In the last session, we discussed financial project appraisal. In discussing financial
project appraisal, we saw the various appraisal methods used in evaluating
projects. The appraisal methods enable investors to choose among competing
projects.In this session, we shall discuss commercial management of projects.
Commercial management of projects focuses attention on the keys areas, namely:
1. sourcing finance for projects
2. contracts
97
3. insurance.
Let us now discuss the various types of finance that are available from the
banks.
Banks Loans
Banks normally grant loans to eligible business organisations to enable them
undertake capital investments in sectors like agriculture, industry, and
commerce.
98
Loans when granted are for specific reasons like purchase of manufacturing
equipment, etc. Loans are usually payable over a fixed period of time and at
agreed interest rates, and most banks will insist that the borrowers provide
collateral security when borrowing from them.
Bank Overdraft
Bank overdrafts are advanced in most cases to organisations for enhancing of
working capital. Most organisations obtain
bank overdrafts and deploy them towards
purchase of raw materials for manufacture
of goods or to procure finished goods for
resale. Usually, bank overdrafts are for
short periods of time like for one year. In
practice, overdrafts are renewable. Fig 2.4.2: Bank Overdraft
Source: billsblills.com
Lease Finance
A lease is a contract whereby one party (the lessee) hires equipment from
another party (the lessor) in a way that the lessee uses the equipment without
purchasing it. In return, the lessee pays lease rentals and at the end of the lease
period may have the option to purchase the equipment.
Lease finance is becoming a more popular type of finance for firms that do not
want to purchase equipment.
Answer
A key function of a bank is to lend money to individuals and organisations. Small businesses
may be owned by individuals or by organisations and they too are entitled to approach banks
for the various loan facilities.
100
investment by the bank. The investment by the bank enables them to grow and
expand their business.
The limitation under the scheme is that the investing bank must not take more
than 40% equity investment in a small and medium business.
2.1.4 Other Sources of Finance
Other sources of finance for the small business are:
101
1. Finance houses
2. Mortgage banks
3. Microfinance banks.
2.2 Contracts
Most projects involve contracts between the project and other parties such as
suppliers or land owners. Ordinarily, all contracts made by a project contractor
and suppliers should be in writing and also properly drafted. The type of
contracts that a project may execute will vary depending on the nature of the
project in question and the third party concerned.
However, for all contracts, several conditions must be satisfied for a legally
binding contract to exist. The following are some of the conditions:
2.2.2 Consideration
In every contract, there must be a consideration. A contract must result in each
party promising the other a
valuable benefit. For most
projects, this means that one
party promises to deliver some
stated goods, property or service at a specified date and the other party will also
102
promise to accept the stated goods and pay for them.
Most projects must have a contract scope. The contract scope specifies the
scope of the contract, i.e. where it begins and where it ends. Some of the various
contract scopes are described below:
A. Build–own–operate–maintain (BOOM)
B. Build–own–operate–transfer (BOOT)
C. Build–own–train–operate (BOTO)
D. Operate–maintain–train – (OMT)
E. Turnkey (TK)
103
2.2 Insurance
A major aspect of commercial management of projects is the issue of
insurance. Insurance has to do with the management of risks. Every
organisation faces risks, and so do all projects especially if they are start-up
projects.
B
When a project is initiated, part of management's responsibility is to identify the
various risks likely to arise and devise ways to manage or minimise the risks. So
in most cases, the priority of management is to ensure that all physical and
commercial risks facing a project are reduced to the barest minimum.
Let us discuss some of the risks identified and types of insurance that can apply
particularly with respect to projects and their management.
104
2. Infringement of property rights
3. Accidents
4. Professional negligence as in the case of medical doctors
5. Contractors all risk insurance to protect work in progress against fire,
storm, theft and malicious damage
6. Accident and sickness insurance.
In-text Question
What is capacity to contract?
Answer
Another condition for a contract to exist is the issue of capacity. The parties to a contract
must have the capacity to contract. For example, a minor may not have the capacity to enter
into a contract. For a firm, the powers and the capacity to contract can be found in the
memorandum and articles of association.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
In this session, we discussed commercial management of projects. We also
discussed various sources of funds for projects as well as contracts in respect of
projects. These discussions threw more light on the commercial management of
projects.
105
a. Visit U-tube addhttps://bit.ly/2Caa7ML. Watch the video & summarise in 1
paragraph
b. View the animation on add/site https://bit.ly/32E0tgT and critique it in the
discussion forum
106
STUDY SESSION 5
Introduction to Project Planning and Scheduling
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Factors Affecting Project Planning
2.2- Project Plan and Schedule – Meaning
2.3- The Planning Time Frame
2.3.1- Free Planning Approach
2.3.2- Target-led Planning Approach
2.4- Project Matrix Charts
2.5- Bar Charts
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
All projects involve commitment of resources towards certain pre-set objectives.
And in most cases, there is always a time frame or deadline for the
implementation of the project. It is therefore, safe to assume that there must be a
plan of some sort if the envisaged projectwill be completed on time. Most
projects are complicated in nature and have to be properly planned.
107
2. Discuss project planning and scheduling.
108
Fig. 2.5.2: Internal Working Factors Affecting a Project Planning
On the other hand, a project schedule is obtained by doing further work on the
project plan. The resources needed to execute the plan must have been
estimated and then taken into account.We can therefore, describe a project
schedule as a working document that results from matching the organisations
available resources to the project plan. From the foregoing, we can say that
project plans and scheduling go hand in hand. They are usually linked.
Answer
A project plan is the listing or display that emerges when major project activities have been
estimated, subjected to their logical sequences and timed. In an ideal situation, network
analysis is usually a preferred method for producing a project plan.
110
On the other hand, a project schedule is obtained by doing further work on the project plan.
The resources needed to execute the plan must have been estimated and then taken into
account.
111
Table2.5. 2: Simple Matrix for Assigning Medical Students to Wards in a
Medical Training Project
112
In using the bar chart, the project manager will usually identify each task within
a project and then go ahead to allocate a time frame for the completion of
each task. With this information, the bar chart is then constructed.
In-text Question
Explain the project matrix charts
Answer
Matrix charts list one set of factors at the extreme left-hand side of tabulation and on the
right-hand side, factors directly associated with them across columns.
There are many variations of the matrix chart. In project management, matrix charts are very
useful for managers who have the responsibility of allocating tasks to different people in a
project team. Matrix charts are very useful for planning and controlling projects. The matrix
charts can be used to allocate people to tasks, or tasks to people. In some cases, the matrix
chart is used to allocate people to machines.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
In this session, we discussed the introduction to project planning and
scheduling. We also discussed external and internal factors affecting project
planning. We discussed project plans and schedules.
We looked into the planning time frame as well as the project matrix charts and
bar charts. All these help to improve our understanding of project planning and
scheduling.This session treats project planning and scheduling. It discusses the
introductory elements necessary to understand project planning and schedules.
It tries to expose how plans and schedules can assist in project execution.
113
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
1. Give meanings to project plan and project schedule. Is there any
relationship between them?
2. Distinguished between free planning approach and target-led approach in
relation to project time frame.
3. Discuss the external factors that affect project planning.
4. How does a project plan differ from a project schedule?
114
MODULE 3
Contents:
Study Session 1: Network Analysis
Study Session 2: Principles of Scheduling Resources
Study Session 3: Practical Scheduling of Resources
Study Session 4: Materials Management
Study Session 5: Project Implementation – An Introduction
Study Session 6: Managing Progress in Projects
STUDY SESSION 1
Network Analysis
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Network Notation System
2.1.1- Arrow Network
2.1.2- Activity Duration
2.1.3- Dummy Activities (Dummies)
2.1.4- The Forward Pass
2.2- Critical Path Analysis Using Precedence Notation
2.2.1- Identification Numbers
2.2.2- Logical Dependencies
2.2.3- Activity Duration Estimates and Descriptions
2.3- Implementing Network Analysis
2.3.1- Arranging a Project Meeting
2.3.2- Identifying Critical Details in Network Planning
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
115
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
Generally, we shall use the term “network analysis” to describe several planning
methods which owe their origin to developments in Europe. Network analysis
achieved great prominence during World War II and was used successfully for the
planning of the United States of America defence projects. When we discussed
charts, we saw that they were really easy to construct and also could be easy to
understand.
A major strength of network analysis is that it enables all the tasks in a project to
be clearly defined. The tasks deemed to be very critical are also identified and
completion times of every task estimated.
116
2.0 Main Content
2.1 Net Notation Systems
In the literature, there are several network notation systems. Each network
system usually reflects the thinking of its inventors.
Now take a look at fig. 1. Each circle represents a project event such as the start
or finish of an activity. The arrow joining any two events shows the activity or
time needed to progress from one event to another.
The numbers inside the circles are used to identify the events. If you note
carefully, activities 1, 2, 3 must be completed before thinking of moving ahead
to any other activity.
Another issue that should be clearly understood in network analysis is the
issue of direction. Conventionally, activity arrows are drawn from left to right.
117
Another important element in arrow diagrams is the issue of logical
dependencies. In an arrow diagram, no event can be considered complete until
all the activities that lead into it have been completed.
You will observe that the estimated duration for every activity is also indicated
in the diagram.
118
2.1.3 Dummy Activities (Dummies)
There is more than one path to the completion of the network activities.
If you note properly, there are three possible routes to the final event 6.
One of the possible routes passes through the dotted linking event 4 to event 3.
The dotted arrow linking event 4 to event 3 is called a dummy activity. A
dummy activity does not represent work and so has no time duration. A dummy
activity though having zero time duration acts as a logical link or constraint on
activities that follows it.
Also you are to note that numbers written above event circles indicate the
earliest possible time by which the event can be completed. This can be
calculated by adding the activity durations from left to right. Where more than
one path exists, the longest path determines the earliest possible event time.
119
Numbers below the event circle are found by subtracting activity durations from
right to left from the final event again taking the longest path.
In-text Question
Arrow networks are called by various names, itemize them
Answer
1. Critical Path Methods (CPM)
2. Critical Path Analysis (CPA)
3. Programme Evaluation and Review Technique (PERT).
Also, in the fig. 3, we are using the forward pass is complicated because there
are many routes to the project completion. For example, we might be tempted to
think that the earliest possible time for event 3 might be 1
+ 2 = 3 if the route of events 1, 2 and 3 are taken. That might not be really
true. Event 3 may not be achieved until the end of week 5 because of the longer
path through the dummy (activity path of 4 to 3).
Generally, it is important to
note that the flow of work in
a precedence diagram is
from left to right.
121
2.2.3 Activity Duration Estimates and Descriptions
Now let us go back to our simple project which we discussed in section 3.1.2 of
this session.
You are to note that fig. 5 shows the estimated duration, earliest start and finish
times for the three activities in the hospital project.
122
In this section, we shall discuss the procedures and methods used in the
implementation of network analysis in an organisation. We shall take them one
by one.
In most cases, the project manager is appointed with members of the project
team. The first step in a project meeting is to assemble all the members of the
team and hold a brainstorming session. In an ideal situation, members of the
project team will be chosen from various units or departments and also will be
senior members of staff.
During the brainstorming session, the project will be laid bare and all the
activities connected with the project will be discussed. Here the basic network
of the project will be drawn so that all the team members can see it and make
their own contributions.
Ideally, a digital projector can be used for the brainstorming exercise. In this
case, arrow notations are better. After a lot of discussions have taken place, a
final network analysis diagram will be produced which temporarily serves as
the guide to the execution of the project.
123
is to identify the critical details in a network. Such critical details will include
the following:
A. Identification of all activities
involved in the project
B. Allocation of activities to people
C. Work authorisations
D. Work supervisors
E. Start and finish times for every
activity
F. Obtaining building permits where
necessary
G. Issue of invitations to tender for
supply of materials or equipment
H. Receipt of tenders
I. Approval of tenders
J. Supplies of materials deadlines
K. Handover of project.
Fig. 2.1.6: Details in Purchasing Sequence for Supply of Medical Equipment to a Hospital
In-text Question
What is a logical dependency?
Answer
In the precedence system, all activities are joined by lines. You should recollect that they
differ from arrow networks which use arrows to link activities. Now back to precedence
systems. The precedence notation system allows the project manager the complete freedom to
display relationships between various activities.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
This session has treated network analysis which we saw as a very important
management tool in project management. We discussed network notation
124
systems especially arrow networks. We also discussed activity duration, dummy
activities and critical path analysis using precedence notation. Finally, we
discussed the identification of critical details in network planning.
Network analysis is a management tool in the practice of project management.
It equips project managers with the necessary skills for managing various
projects. It emphasises the breakdown and analysis of project activities in a
sequence that leads to project conclusion.
125
STUDY SESSION 2
Principles of Scheduling Resources
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Project Resources
2.2- Priority Rules for Scheduling Resources
2.2.1- Resource Limited Scheduling
2.2.2- Time Limited Scheduling
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
Research shows that scheduling of resources is a fairly complex topic because of
the complexities of various types of projects in the environment.
Resources scheduling can be seen from many view -points. It can be seen from
point of view of a large industrial establishment like Nigerian Breweries Plc.
where it is employed in the formulation of long-term plans. Resources scheduling
can even take a wider dimension when one considers the complexities involved in
running a refinery that produces petrol, diesel, kerosene, engine oil, aviation
fuel and other petrochemicals.
We are not going to discuss resources scheduling from wider perspectives. Rather,
we shall discuss it from the point of view of a project manager whose concern is
basically with the short-term operations of a business or a specific project.
126
Resources scheduling problems differ from firm to firm or from organisation to
organisation. An organisation which has a large percentage of its labour force as
causal labour may not have the problem of scheduling of its labour resources. On
the other hand, an organisation that handles its projects using its own workforce
cannot ignore scheduling of resources. This is more applicable to engineering and
road construction companies.
127
Source: stakeholdermap.com
1. Land
2. Natural gas
3. Water
4. Rubber
5. Cocoa
6. Cement
7. Granite
8. Sand
9. Generator
10. Factory buildings
11. Offices
12.Labour (causal labour)
13.Labour (management)
14. Computers
15. Radio Stations
16. X-ray machine
17. Blow molding machine
18. Dam
19. Tractor
20. Time
129
(16) (17) (18)
130
In-text Question
Mention the types of resources needed before the project is commence
Answer
1. Land
2. Natural gas
3. Water
4. Rubber
5. Cocoa
6. Cement
7. Granite
8. Sand
9. Generator
Source: zilicus.com
131
In a situation where time is of essence in a project, the scheduling should be
time-limited. For example, if a university is due to reopen in October and it is
expected that a new students‟ hostel under construction will accommodate
2,000 new students, it means that at least the new students‟ hostel should be
ready by September of the same year.When a project is subjected to time-
limited scheduling, overtime and hiring of excess labour usually resorted to in
order to meet the time schedule.
Answer
Scheduling of resources is based on two options or priority rules. One option is whether the
scheduling of the resources should be resource-limited or time limited. We shall now
consider each of the options.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
In this session, we discussed principles of scheduling resources. We discussed
the meaning of resources and also the priority rules for scheduling resources.
The options available to the project manager are resource-limited scheduling
and time-limited scheduling of resources.
Principles of scheduling resources guide the project manager in project
management. It provides project managers with tools with which to schedule
resources.
133
STUDY SESSION 3
Practical Scheduling of Resources
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Factors in Project Resource Scheduling
2.2- Labour Resources to be scheduled
2.3- Scheduling Labour Costs
2.4- Scheduling Costs for other Materials
2.5- Scheduling Cash Flows
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
In the last session, we discussed principles of scheduling resources. We defined
the meaning of resources and also the priority rules for scheduling resources.
We also discussed the options available to the project manager for scheduling of
resources.
134
2.0 Main Content
2.1 Factors in Project Resource
Scheduling
In practical terms, before
practical scheduling can be
carried out, the appointed
project manager with his or her
team will first of all be faced
with a number of critical
questions that concern the
project in question.
They may have to highlight
problems associated with the
project and offer solutions. Let
us now look at fig. 1 which
highlights competing factors in project resource scheduling. Fig. 2.3.1: Competing
136
Usually, the project accountant collects information about project activities
from the project manager. He/She then matches the material cost with the
associated activity.
Based on the network analysis, the accountant is issued with the priority list
for the project so that adequate purchase arrangements could be made. The
cost of materials to be scheduled will vary depending on the nature of the
project, the activities involved and of course the duration of the identified
activities.
In-text Question
Mention the activities that take place in labour resources to be scheduled
Answer
1. Project layout design
2. Civil engineering jobs
3. Mechanical engineering jobs
4. Structural engineering jobs
5. Electrical engineering jobs
6. Plumbing and hydro engineering jobs
7. Production engineering jobs
8. Chemical engineering jobs.
Source: nutcache.com
137
It is also very important to note that the cash flow schedule is not an accounting
statement or schedule. It is basically a schedule that shows the receipts of
money and the spending of money in relation to a project.
The cash flow schedule is divided into two sections, namely: the cash inflow
section and the cash outflow section. Two of them combine to form the cash
schedule.
The cash inflow section of the cash schedule shows the various sources of cash
for a project. Sources of cash for a project may vary. In the private sector
projects, they will consist mainly of equity or bank loans. But that is
understandable.
However, the sources of funds for a public sector project might be different.
They may consist of local government, state or federal government funds. Also,
public sector projects might attract external funds sources from outside Nigeria.
138
At a glance, therefore, the project manager can see what activities will come up
at different times and the amount of funds they will require.
In more complex cases, the cash flow schedule will highlight when the project
will require external funding, etc.
139
Table 2.3.1: Cash Flow Schedule for a
Refinery Project
Million
March
Bank of Industry loan 10,000 - -
European Investment Bank loan - - 10,000
Federal
Government of Nigeria - 10,000 -
Equity
10,000 10,000 10,000
Total Cash Inflows
- 4,000 4,800
Inflows Less Outflows 4,000 4,800 -
Opening Cash Balance
Closing Cash Balance
140
Table 2.3.2: Cash Flow Schedule for
a Hospital Project
N‟ Million
April May June
Cash
Inflows
World Health Organisation grant 200 100 -
Federal Government of Nigeria equity 300 - 50
TOTAL CASH INFLOWS 500 100 50
CASH
OUTFLOWS
Engineering design 10 - -
Civil engineering works 100 10 -
Structural engineering
works 30 10 -
Electrical engineering works 10 10 -
Wards and offices 200 30 -
Hospital equipment 100 10 10
Drugs and medicaments - - 30
Salary and wages 40 40 10
Total Cash Outflows 490 110 50
Inflows Less Outflows 10 (10) -
Opening Cash Balance - 10 -
Closing Cash Balance 10 - -
141
Table 2.2.3: Steps in Project
Resource Scheduling
Objectives
Sequence Analysis
4. Estimate all task durations and You may use a bar chart
Analysis
Resources
In-text Question
Give a brief explanation on scheduling cash flows
Answer
Cash flow schedules basically are schedules which show inflows (income) of a project and
also outflows (expenditures) of a project.
As we discussed earlier, money is a very critical resource. Again, it is to be stressed that most
resources for a project will be paid for with money. Therefore, schedules which show how
money will flow in a project is very important.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
In this session, we discussed practical scheduling or resources. We looked at the
142
competing factors in project resource scheduling. We discussed labour
resources to be schedules and the scheduling of labour costs. Wethen discussed
project cash flow schedules. We concluded the unit by highlighting steps in
project resources scheduling.
143
STUDY SESSION 4
Materials Management
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- The Purchasing Cycle
2.2- Commercial Conditions of Purchase
2.3- Timing of Purchase Orders and Deliveries
2.4- Call-Off Orders
2.5- Purchasing for Capital Projects
2.6- Stores Administration
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
Materials management concentrates on the key aspects of purchasing and
control that take place after a purchase order has been issued for materials of a
project. Also, materials management concentrates on the purchasing procedures
in projects defined as capital projects.
144
when they are delivered to the project stores or sites. Stores management is also
part of materials management.
145
that certain materials are in short supply. Fig 3.4.1: The
Purchasing Cycle
After the need for materials has been identified, the next stage in the purchasing
cycle is to specify the materials or goods to be purchased. It is important to
specify the required materials especially if they are engineering or specialist
goods. They may even be chemicals which are also specialist goods not sold
everywhere.
In practice, however, for larger projects, project managers should engage the
services of legal experts to draft the local purchase orders so as to reduce losses
from legal actions.
In-text Question
Mention four commercial conditions of purchase
Answer
1. Goods mean the supply and delivery of the goods specified in line with the
organisation‟s purchase order.
2. Payment terms: Payment may be made on delivery or against shipping documents.
147
3. Prices: Prices are usually fixed for the period of the contract (LPO) and cannot be
varied.
4. Quality of the goods or materials shall conform to description or specification given
by the organisation to the supplier.
Every activity should have an earliest start time and earliest finish time. It
follows logically therefore, that if the project manager knows when an activity
should commerce, and then he/she should ensure that the materials required
for an activity must be in place before the start of the activity. For example,
if the foundation for a stadium project is scheduled to start on December 1, then
the cement for the foundation laying must be on
the project site latest by November 29 of the same
year.
148
In management of timing of orders and deliveries, project managers are relying
on just-in-time (JIT) management techniques which were perfected by the
Japanese. Just-in-time approach to purchasing and manufacture was adopted to
reduce stock holdings by manufacturers to almost zero.Just-in-time techniques
require that suppliers of materials should supply them direct to the work site at
the right time.
Purchasing managers, fully aware of the time lag between issue of purchase
orders and deliveries from suppliers, should plan purchases properly so as not to
frustrate project activities due to late deliveries or non-delivery of materials.
If all the materials required for the university project are ordered at once, then
there will be no storage space to receive the goods. In practice, if a large
quantity of a particular material is required for a project, then the delivery of the
materials (e.g. cement) can be arranged to be made in batches arranged between
the purchaser and the supplier. This type of order is known as a call-off order.
This is so-called because the materials are called off as they are required to
149
suit a project schedule. However, call-off orders delay expenditures which will
only be incurred when materials are delivered.
Capital projects involve large commitment of resources (money and people) and
therefore, it is important for us to understand the structure for managing
purchases relating to them.
150
Table 3.4.1: A purchasing schedule for a capital project
Title Schedule
Project Manager Responsible to the client for scheduling and
supervising all project activities until completion.
Project Engineer Assists the project manager. Provides support to the
purchase agent. Writes the purchase specifications
for every item or equipment to be purchased.
Purchase Agent Assists the project engineer. Issues invitation to
tender to suppliers. Maintains suppliers records.
Foreign Suppliers Prepare equipment bids and send same to the
purchase agent. Proceeds with supply if bid is
successful.
Site Manager Examines equipment on arrival and arranges
storage.
Local Suppliers Supply equipment and materials direct to site
manager.
Answer
Consider for example, a situation where a new university is to be built at Bauchi. The
university will contain students' hostels, lecture halls, administrative buildings, senate
buildings, roads, playgrounds, etc. The project no doubt will gulp billions of naira to
151
complete and will also require a lot of cement, sand, concrete, wood, electrical parts,
plumbing parts, etc.
If all the materials required for the university project are ordered at once, then there will be
no storage space to receive the goods. In practice, if a large quantity of a particular material
is required for a project, then the delivery of the materials (e.g. cement) can be arranged to
be made in batches arranged between the purchaser and the supplier. This type of order is
known as a call-off order.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
In this session, we discussed materials management generally. We discussed the
purchasing cycle, commercial conditions of purchase, the timing of purchase
orders and deliveries. Call-off orders was also discussed in addition to
purchasing for capital projects. All these helped us to improve our
understanding of project management.
152
discussion forum
6.0 References/Further Readings
Farmer, D & Van Weele, A. J. (Eds.) (1995). Gower Handbook of Purchasing
Management. (2nd ed.). Aldershot: Gower.
Lamar, L. Dobler, D. W. & Burt, D. N. (1996). Purchasing and Supply
Management. (6th ed.). Maiden Head: McGraw-Hill.
153
STUDY SESSION 5
Project Implementation: An Introduction
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Project Implementation Stages
2.1.1-Project Authorisation
2.1.2- Project Documentation
2.1.3- Organisation of the Project
2.1.4- Tasks Allocation
2.1.5- Project Kick-Off
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
In practical terms, project implementation starts from the time that a project has
been conceived, designed and authorisation duly given to proceed on the project.
Authorisation can be given by a customer or project owner.
A project owner may be, for example, the Federal Ministry of Works and the
project in question may be the dualisation of the Owerri-Onitsha highway.
Project implementation runs through the entire process of organisational
initiation of a project to its full implementation. Project implementation highlights
the basic principles and processes that are to be followed to ensure that a project is
eventually implemented.
154
1.0 Study Session Learning Outcomes
After studying this session, I expect you to be able to:
1. Explain the process of project implementation
2. Discuss project implementation.
Even in a private sector setting where a project will be executed in-house, there
155
must be a formal written authorisation from the private organisation. The
authorisation document will state essential information on the project. It will state
the nature of the project and the scope of work to be undertaken. It will also state
the project amount.
156
We could have the following pattern of identification numbers.
Answer
When project authorisation occurs, it means that the project manager has been given proper
authority and instruction to proceed with a project.
In a public sector setting, project authorisation may involve the ministry signing a formal
contract with the project contractor or project manager as the case may be.
Even in a private sector setting where a project will be executed in-house, there must be a
formal written authorisation from the private organisation. The authorisation document will
state essential information on the project. It will state the nature of the project and the scope
of work to be undertaken.
The identification numbers are usually entered into a project register. Other
information that should be entered in the register with respect to every project
will be:
157
G. The structural engineers for the project
H. The mechanical engineers
I. The electrical engineers
J. The supervising agent
K. Project start date
L. Project finish date
With the advent of the computer and information technology, most project
registers are available in computer systems and this makes the retrieval of
information about any project very easy.
158
You will recall that network analysis identifies the principal activities that are
involved in a project. That we have understood. In tasks allocation, the project
manager identifies every activity that will be undertaken and goes ahead to
allocate the tasks to the various sessions.
In practice, most project managers will arrange a pre-kick-off meeting with key
team members. The objective of the pre-kick-off meeting usually is to ensure
that all critical aspects of a project have been covered and also to evaluate the
readiness of all team members and leaders towards ensuring the success of the
project.
Answer
Once the project documentation stage of a project has been concluded, the next stage in the
implementation process is the organisation of the project. In most situations, the project
manager as the leader of the project team with his close subordinates will draw up the
comprehensive organisation chart for the project which will clearly detail the following
information:
1. Teams that will work at head office level
2. Teams that will work at the project sites
3. Principal sub-contractors and their locations
4. Supervising agencies
5. Other logistics.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
160
In this session, we treated project implementation. We discussed the various
stages of project implementation. We discussed project authorisation, project
documentation and organisation of a project, tasks allocation and project kick-
off. All these are essential stages in project implementation.
This session treats project implementation at an introductory level. It highlights
the key stages that are involved when a project is being implemented. Project
implementation is not a one-off thing. It is an on-going process.
161
STUDY SESSION 6
Managing Progress in Projects
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Managing Progress
2.2- Management by Walk About
2.3- Managing Sub-Contractors and Agency Staff
2.4- Construction Site Management
2.5- Conduct of Project Meetings
2.6- Project Progress Reports
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
In the last session, we discussed project implementation. We discussed the
various stages of project implementation which include project authorisation,
project documentation and organisation of a project, tasks allocation and project
kick-off.
In this session, we shall discuss managing progress in projects. This unit will
conclude our study of project management.
162
1.0 Study Session Learning Outcomes
After studying this session, I expect you to be able to:
1. Explain managing progress in projects
2. Discuss the management of progress in projects.
Source: settlingufree.blogspot.com
When we discussed network analysis, we saw that every activity in a project has
duration. Duration refers to how long it will take to finish an activity. We also
noted that every activity has an earliest start time and earliest finish time. In
managing progress, the project manager must compare the progress achieved on
every activity against the planned schedule.
In situations where the project site is far away from the head office or
headquarters, it becomes very necessary for the project manager through the
necessary communication lines with the site managers to get on the spot progress
of work at various locations.
163
Practically, there is resort to the use of a progress report questionnaire. The
progress report questionnaire is designed to measure the progress of work in a
project. It will usually describe the various activities in the project, their durations,
earliest start dates and earliest finish dates. The respondent to the questionnaire is
expected complete the relevant columns. Headquarters uses the questionnaire to
monitor progress of various projects.
Consider, for example, a project that involves the construction of a student’s‟
hostel. A progress report questionnaire is shown in table 3.6.1:
The frequency of the reports will depend on the nature of the projects. Where
computer systems are available, data and information on various activities can be
keyed in at the various project sites.
This type of visits to the project sites is known as management by walk about.
Apart from seeing things as they are on the site, one advantage of scheduled visits
to sites is that it helps to boost the morale of workers at the site when they see
their project managers and team members at the site reviewing progress. During
such scheduled visits, project managers may take photographs of the project site
which serve as documents at the headquarters. Photographs also will document
the level of construction progress especially for a building project.
It has to be stressed that when a project is being monitored the control areas relate
to:
1. The state of progress at the various levels of activity of the project.
2. Manpower deployment and utilisation including shortages.
3. Expenditures of the projects and whether they are within the project budget.
165
Depending on their scope, most projects have their main contractor andalso sub-
contractors. Sub-contractors are usually engaged in projects especially where they
are required to undertake tasks for which they are specialised and which may not
be available to the main contractor. For example, the design and construction of a
National Stadium at Abuja definitely involved the main contractor and a lot of
other sub-contractors with different areas of specialisation.
Let us assume that Company A was awarded the contract to construct the new
national stadium at Abuja at a cost of N20 billion. In this case, Company A is the
main contractor but it has to engage many sub-contractors for various jobs related
to the stadium project. A lot of sub-contractors may be hired for the following
jobs:
1 Foundations and piling jobs - Trevi Foundation Ltd.
Wood works - Ashly and Bred Ltd.
2
3 Plumbing works - Asea, Orly& Co.
Electrical works - Newman Nig. Ltd.
4
Painting - Bonalux Painters Ltd.
5
If you take a good look at the jobs that the sub-contractors were engaged to do,
you will realise that they are outside the areas of competence of Company A
which is the main contractor to the stadium project. So when we are talking of
managing progress in a project, the project should be seen in totality.
Although the main contractor has the duty to supervise and manage the progress
of the sub-contractor, the project manager's function is all encompassing. The
project manager supervises and monitors progress in a project from a holistic
point of view.
166
Apart from managing sub-contractors, some projects involve the use of agency
staff that may either be deployed to work at the main contractor‟s location or
deployed to work at other designated locations.Usually, a main contractor resorts
to the use of agency staff on a temporary basis; this usually is to cover staff
shortage which normally arises in the course of project execution. All agency staff
that are absorbed to work at the main contractor's premises must be properly
supervised and monitored. A practical way of doing this will be to have induction
training for them at the inception of the project.
In-text Question
Briefly explain management by walk about
Answer
The ideal methods in managing progress in projects involve the use of reports from team
members on the various aspects of the project they are involved in. In that respect, all project
team leaders usually will prepare periodic project reports which will be sent to the
project manager for review and further action. But whilst the preparation of periodic reports
is commendable, a practical project manager must be prepared to pay scheduled and
unscheduled visits to the project sites to get firsthand information on the state of work at the
site.
167
for proper coordination and management of construction sites.
Fig 3.6.2: Construction Site Management
Source: jupitersiteservices.co.uk
All these facilities must be on site with other necessary items. If there is no power
or water at the site, the project manager or main contractor must ensure that these
are also provided. The health of the site workers must also be taken care of. In this
case, local arrangements will have to be made to provide regular and emergency
medical services to the staff at project sites. In more complex cases, banking
facilities in addition to catering services will need to be provided for the workers
at the project site.
To ensure the best out of project meetings, the agenda for the meeting should be
given well in advance to the various members so that they can study it and prepare
their reports where necessary.
As we have indicated earlier, the objective of many project meetings is to evaluate
progress of work. Also, meetings serve as avenues to identify problems associated
with a project. At times, problems (especially engineering problems) arise
during a project implementation. We discover that in most cases, teams working
independently may be unable to solve the engineering problems. Such engineering
problems if they arise may be brought to the attention of a larger audience, i.e. the
project meeting. Also, project meetings may highlight interdepartmental or inter
team problems which may be affecting work progress.
169
2.6 Project Progress Reports
Progress reports are usually addressed to any of the following:
1. Company management
2. Customer or client, e.g. The Federal Ministry of Works.
The progress report seeks to set out details of the technical and financial status of
projects especially to compare the results achieved so far with the target objectives
of the project. In most project contracts, reports may be required to be sent in
weekly or monthly depending on the nature of the project. The progress report
should contain, amongst other things, the following:
Answer
A lot of projects may involve construction sites and the management of these sites are crucial
if projects are to be properly executed. Also, in many projects, the headquarters of the project
manager may be very far away from the various construction sites. Take, for example, MTN
which is involved in communications. The construction and deployment of communications
masts nationwide involve many construction sites. Work at all of these sites must be properly
supervised and managed.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
In this session, we have generally discussed managing progress in projects a
very vital part of our study of project management. We discussed the concept of
management by walk about which is a more practical approach to managing
progress in projects. We also discussed the management of sub-contractors and
170
agency staff, construction site management, project meetings as well as project
progress reports.
This session treats managing progress in projects. It tries to examine the key
features in the management of progress in a project. The importance of
managing progress by walkabout cannot be underestimated in project
management.
171
MODULE 4
Project Income and Evaluation
Contents:
Study Session 1: Projected Income Statement
Study Session 2: Projected Cash Flow Statements
Study Session 3: Projected Balance Sheets
Study Session 4: Project Evaluation Criteria
Study Session 5: Introduction to Economic Analyses
STUDY SESSION 1
Projected Income Statement
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Projected Income State
2.2- The Structure in the Projected Income Statement
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
The key basis for financial planning and project evaluation is financial
information. The financial information is required to record, compare and
evaluate a firm‘s earning power and ability. In an already existing project, the
financial information is already provided since it is a historical data. The
income statement or the profit and loss account is a summary of revenues,
172
expenses and net profit of an enterprise for a period of time. This serves as a
measure of the firm‘s profitability over the period. For an on-going project or
firm, when prepared, the income statement becomes a historical statement. The
projected income statement is a forecast of the revenues, expenses and the net
profit of an enterprise or project.
173
Also financial institutions are interested in a projected income statement.
Practically, when any firm approaches a financial institution for financial
assistance, the firm is expected to prepare a business plan or a project feasibility
study which contains, amongst other things, the projected income statement.
Financial institutions need to study the projected income statement to evaluate
the revenues, expenses and profitability of the investment project. When they do
this, they will also test the cash flows of the project to see whether the proposed
project can repay any loan granted together with the interest.
Other people that might be interested in the projected income statement are
potential investors. Potential investors need to examine the projected income
statement to decide whether or not they will invest in a firm.
174
A hospital may specialize in surgery and provide surgical services to its
customers for whom it collects relevant payments, which when added up, make
up the revenues.
Finally, a firm can earn revenue by loaning its economic resources. For
example, a bank lends money to customers and earns interest income.
The projection for revenues can cover various periods. In most organisations,
revenue projections for project evaluation purposes stretch over a period of
three years. Some banks ask for five year revenue forecasts. In the revenue
projections care must be taken so as not to overstate the revenues or understate
them.
175
In-text Question
Explain in brief the projected income statement
Answer
The projected income statement is usually needed by a variety of people. Some of the users of
the projected income statement might have direct interest in the firm while others have
indirect interest. The owners or sponsors of a project have a direct interest in the projected
income statement. It is so because they are entrusting their investment to the firm.
2. Expenses
The cost of earning revenue is known as the expense. Expenses are different
from costs. Cost is the outlay incurred to acquire some asset.
For example, when a car is purchased by a company for its business, the sum
used to purchase the vehicle is the cost of the vehicle. If the vehicle uses fuel for
the firm‘s operations, that constitutes an expense. In projecting the expenses of
a firm‘s investment, a lot of factors are usually taken into consideration.
Source: myob.com
1. Revenue Projections
From the proposed production plan, the following is the revenue profile for the
project in year one (year 2007).
176
Consumption of Utilities and Chemicals per Ton of Bleached and Refined
Vegetable Oil
Steam at 50 psig = 70kg
Barometric water = 6 m3
Clean water in circulation = 7 m3
Fuel oil = 4 kg
Bleaching earth = 15 kg
Citric acid = 200 gms
Phosphoric acid (for dosing) = 300 gm
177
Table 4.1.2: Project manufacturing Account for a vegetable Oil
Projected Manufacturing Account for Year Ending 31st December
Table 4.1.3: Projected Trading Profit and Loss Account for a Vegetable Oil Refining
178
Projected Trading, profit and Loss Account for the Year Ending
In-text Question
What is revenue?
Answer
Ordinarily, revenues are the value of output of goods or services that an enterprise supplies
to its customers. Revenues, therefore, arise when a firm produces or manufactures goods
which it sells to third parties for a fee. Secondly, revenues can arise when a firm is engaged
in the buying and selling of goods. It purchases goods which it later resells at a profit or a
loss as the case may be.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
We have discussed the projected income statement. We discussed the structure
of the projected income statement, revenues, expenses and net profit concepts.
Finally we used as an example to demonstrate a projected income statement.
We have treated the projected income statement in this unit. The projected
income statement is one of the most important items in project evaluation from
the project sponsor‘s position or from the bank or analyst‘s position.
179
2. Discuss the likely users of a projected income statement.
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations &Out of Class activities) e.g.
a. Visit U-tube addhttps://bit.ly/2NSpXAj. Watch the video & summarise in 1
paragraph
b. View the animation on add/site https://bit.ly/2M2fhjy and critique it in the
discussion forum
180
STUDY SESSION 2
Projected Cash Flow Statements
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Projected Cash Flow Statements – Meaning and uses
2.2- The Structure of the Projected Cash Flow Statement
2.2.1- Cash Inflows
2.2.2- Cash Outflows
2.2.3- Sensitivity Analysis
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
In session 1 we discussed the projected income statement. There we discussed
the concept of revenues and expenses and also net profit. We also discussed the
fact that the projected income statement is used by a variety of users like the
project initiators, bankers and financial analysts. In this unit, we shall
discuss the projected cash flow statements.
181
2.0 Main Content
2.1 Projected Cash Flow Statement – Meaning and Uses
It is important to understand and analyse the projected cash flows of the firm. We
shall begin our discussion by defining a cash flow statement. A cash flow
statement is a statement that shows the
actual receipt of cash (inflows) and the
disbursement of cash (out flows) of a
firm or project. Having said that, we can
now go ahead to define a projected cash
flow statement. Fig 4.2.1: Projected Cash Flow Statement – Meaning and Uses
A projected cash flow statement is a statement which shows the forecasts of actual
receipts of cash (inflows) and the disbursement of cash (outflows) of a firm or
project. There are many users of information contained in projected cash flow
statements. The first user of the projected cash flow statement is the project
sponsor or initiator.
The project sponsor or initiator is interested in knowing well in advance the future
cash flows of the firm. This is important because the future financing needs of the
firm have to be known well in advance. The project initiator needs to distinguish
between credit sales and cash sales.
If the project initiator does not distinguish between credit sales and cash sales,
then his/her project may suffer cash flow problems. The initiator may not be able
to estimate the amount of cash needs of the project as well as timing of the cash
needs.
Similarly, providers of finance especially the lending banks are usually very
interested in the projected cash flow statement. They need to determine the firm‘s
ability to service debt. The debt in question may be existing debts or future debts.
Ability to service debts is a function of future cash flows.
182
Projected cash flow statements assist us to evaluate a firm‘s future performance
and of course financial condition that enables the project evaluator answer the
following questions.
1. What is the nature of the firm‘s projected cash flow statement?
2. Will the projected cash flow be able to service the project‘s debts (loan,
overdraft + interest)?
a. When will the project need financing and to what extent?
b. How should the loan or overdraft or finance be structured?
c. How stable are the cash flows?
Answer
A projected cash flow statement is a statement which shows the forecasts of actual receipts of
cash (inflows) and the disbursement of cash (outflows) of a firm or project. There are many
users of information contained in projected cash flow statements. The first user of the
projected cash flow statement is the project sponsor or initiator.
183
Table 4.2.1: A Three Month Projected Flow Statement Niger Limited Cash
Inflows January
184
The loan will usually have the following features:
A. The loan amount will be specific
B. The loan has an interest rate attached to it.
C. The loan will be repaid in agreed installments.
D. Cash Sales
The sales figure is the most important in a projected cash flow statement.
Projections for sales pose one of the most difficult challenges in cash flow
projections. We must quickly distinguish between total sales, credit sales and cash
sales. Total sales are the total value of goods or service sold to third parties. Credit
sales refer to sales for which payment is not made immediately. The figure for
credit sales is usually transferred to the debtors list. Cash sales are the difference
between total sales revenue and credit sales.
As far as we are concerned, the cash sale is the most important component of sales
and it is the one that appears in the projected cash flow statement. Credit sales are
only reflected in the cash flow when they are converted to cash. For example, if in
January 2007, a company sells four cars at a credit of N10,000,000. In the cash
flow for January 2007, there will be no entry for cash sales. But if in February
2007, the company receives a cash payment of N5,000,000, then that figure will
appear in the inflows column for February 2007.
The basic rule is that only actual cash received is usually entered in the inflow
column. In actual practice, projecting for cash sales will involve exhaustive
consideration of the following:
A. General economic outlook in the country
B. The industry outlook. What is the demand situation like? What is the supply
situation?
185
C. What is the structure of competition and how fierce is it?
D. What will be the effect of competition on prices in the firm‘s area of
operation?
186
Sensitivity analysis provides the tool for subjecting a project‘s cash flow s to
adverse market situations. Sensitivity analysis seeks to adjust revenues for risk
and also costs. In conducting sensitivity analysis, we say that we are adjusting a
project‘s cash flows for risk. If we conduct sensitivity analysis on a cash flow, we
may do that by making one, two or three of the following assumptions:
1. Due to intense competition the project will not be able to make the earlier
normal sales volume. Cash revenues will drop.
2. Due to excess supply, prices in the market will fall, that will reduce cash
revenues.
3. The prices of raw materials and other items will rise. A close examination
will reveal that the impact of any of the above will have the effect of
reducing the cash revenues of a project.
We now state that if a normal projected cash flow statement is reconstructed to
accommodate the fact that the market could be worse, we say that the
reconstructed cash flow is now called a risk ―adjusted cash flow statement. The
risk- adjusted cash flow is a pessimistic cash flow and should be admired by
analysts.
Sensitivity analysis is a tool for subjecting cash flows to risk analysis. The key
objective of the sensitivity analysis is to forecast a worst-case scenario for a
project. Other ways of conducting a sensitivity analysis is to assume that expenses
attached to a project will increase.
Table 4.2.2: A Three Month Risk-Adjusted Projected Cash Flow Statement
Niger Limited
187
In-text Question
Briefly explain capital introduced
Answer
Every firm or project should have a capital. At the time a project conceived or is being
expanded, the owners of the firm usually bring in what is known as capital.
In a limited liability company, the share-holders usually contribute the capital of the firm. In
cash flow construction, capital is usually entered as an inflow. The reason is clear. When you
introduce capital, you bring in cash.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
We have discussed projected cash flow statements. We discussed the nature of
cash flow statements and their users. We also examined the structure of cash
flow statements. We used an example to show what a projected cash flow
statement looks like. We also constructed a risk adjusted cash flow statement.
In this session we treated projected cash flow statements which we said
constitutes a very vital document used in the evaluation of projects. The cash
flow gives us a picture of cash inflows and outflows together with timing.
189
STUDY SESSION 3
The Projected Balance Sheet
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Meaning of a Balance Sheet
2.2- Components of a Balance Sheet
2.2.1- Assets
2.2.2- Liabilities
2.3- Construction of the Projected Balance Sheet
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
In session 2, we discussed the projected cash flow statement. There, we
discussed inflows and outflows (outgoings) of a firm or project. We also
discussed the structure of the projected cash flow statement and went a step
further to provide an example of a projected cash flow statement. In this unit,
we shall discuss the projected balance sheet.
190
2.0 Main Content
2.1 Meaning of a Balance Sheet
Before we delve into the projected balance sheet proper, it is very important for
us to first understand what a balance sheet is. The balance sheet or the statement
of financial position is one of the most important financial statements. It shows
the financial condition or better still,
the statement of affairs of a firm or
business. We Will therefore, define a
projected balance sheet as a forecast
of a future balance sheet as at a
future date. Fig 4.3.1: Balance Sheet
Source: explania.com
2.2.1 Assets
When we are talking of assets generally, we are talking about the valuable
possessions owned by the firm, valued in monetary terms. They will include
land and buildings, stock of goods, raw materials, cash, vehicles and other
valuables. But generally we can classify assets under the following headings:
A. Current assets
B. Investments
C. Fixed assets
Let’s us now discuss each of them:
191
Current Assets
The current assets of a firm or business are those assets which are held in the
form of cash or expected to be converted into cash in a period or within the
accounting period of the firm. In actual practice, the accounting period is
usually of one-year duration. The current assets of the firm will include the
following:
A. Cash
B. Book debts (debtors).
C. Prepaid expenses
D. Marketable securities.
E. Stock
Let us start with cash which is one of the most liquid current assets. Cash will
mean cash on hand or cash in the bank.
Another current asset which is important is book debts (debtors). Book debts
are sometimes called account receivables. These are amounts due from debtors
to whom goods have been sold or service rendered. Some of the book debts may
be realised by the firm. If they are not realized they turn into what is called bad
debts and may be written off later.
Prepaid expenses are also current assets. They are expenses of future periods
that are paid in advance. An example of prepaid expenses is rent which may be
payable in advance by a firm. For example in January 2007, a firm may pay rent
for its office for January 2007 to December, 2007. If in April, 2007, the
financial year of the firm ends, it will regard the portion of rent paid from May
2007 to December, 2007 as a prepaid expense which invariably is a current
asset.
192
Stock (inventory) is another current asset and includes raw material, work in
process and finished goods. The raw materials and work in process are required
for maintenance of the production function of the firm.Finished goods usually
will be already packed and kept ready for purchase by customers of the
business. Marketable securities are the firm‘s short term investment in shares,
bonds and other securities. The securities are usually marketable and can be
converted into cash in a very short time.
Investments
Investments represent the firm‘s investments in shares, debentures and bonds of
either firms or the government. By their nature, the investments are long term. It
is important to note that the investments yield income to the firm.
Fixed Assets
Fixed assets are long-term assets held for periods longer than one year. They are
usually held for use in the firm‘s business. Fixed assets include land, buildings,
machinery and equipment, vehicles, etc.
We have briefly seen what the assets are. We shall now move over and discuss
liabilities.
In-text Question
Define assets
Answer
When we are talking of assets generally, we are talking about the valuable possessions
owned by the firm, valued in monetary terms. They will include land and buildings, stock of
goods, raw materials, cash, vehicles and other valuables.
2.2.2 Liabilities
193
When we talk of liabilities, we mean the debts that are payable by the firm or
business to creditors. They may represent various obligations due to various
third parties arising from various business transactions.
Current Liabilities
Current Liabilities are those debts that are payable in a short period usually
within a year. One of the major current liabilities is the bank overdraft. Most
banks grant their customers overdraft which are repayable within a period of
one year. The other type of current liability includes provisions for taxes and
dividends. These are liabilities that will mature within one year.
Another type of liability is expenses payable. The firm may expenses to public
power supply organisation or have rents to be paid.
194
debenture is an obligation on the part of a firm to pay interest and principal
under the terms of the debenture.
However one of the most stable types of long term liability is owners‘ equity.
Owner‘s equity represents the owners‘ interest in the firm. In practical terms,
the total assets of a firm less the liabilities realized on the interest. The owners
interest in the firm consist of
A. Paid up share capital and
B. Retained earnings (undistributed profits).
195
Table 4.3.1: A Projected Balance Sheet
In-text Question
What is a liability?
Answer
Liabilities mean the debts that are payable by the firm or business to creditors. They may
represent various obligations due to various third parties arising from various business
transactions.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
196
We have discussed the projected balance sheet. We first discussed assets
generally and then went ahead to discuss liabilities. We discussed the
construction of the projected balance sheet and provided a checklist for the
projection for both assets and liabilities.
We have treated the projected balance sheet. The projected balance sheet as we
discussed is a forecast of a future balance sheet as at a future date. It will show
what the assets will be and also what the liabilities will be. It is a very important
document in project evaluation.
197
STUDY SESSION 4
Project Evaluation Criteria
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Traditional Criteria of Project Evaluation
2.2- The Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Method
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
Let us recall that the focus of this course is project evaluation. From unit 1, we
discussed the project cycle. From there we moved on to discuss factors
affecting location of projects. We also discussed capacity and production
planning, demand analysis, supply analysis, project cost analysis, projected
income statements, cash flows and the balance sheet.
All these have set the stage for us to tie the discussions. We now want to discuss
a very crucial aspect of this course, which is the project evaluation criterion.
Project evaluation criteria seek to present the methods to be adopted to measure
the value of an investment project. The evaluation enables us to choose between
two or more projects once the values are known. Any project evaluation
criterion to be adopted should possess the following characteristics:
1. It should provide a means to distinguish between acceptable and
unacceptable projects.
198
2. It should also be able to rank projects in order of their desirability.
3. It should be a criterion that is applicable to any conceivable project.
4. It should recognise that bigger cash flows are preferable to smaller ones.
5. It should recognise that early cash flows or benefits are preferable to later
cash flows or benefits.
Although there are a lot of project evaluation criteria in the literature, we shall
discuss the most widely accepted criteria which are the traditional criteria and
the discounted cash flow (DCF) criteria
A project requires a cash outlay of N200,000 and yields an annual cash inflow
of N50,000 for a period of 10 years; calculate the payback period.
However, it is to be noted that in the case of unequal cash inflows, the payback
period can be computed by adding up the cash inflows until the total is equal to
the initial cash outlay. The payback period is greatly admired by project
evaluators because it is very simple to understand. Another good virtue of the
payback period is that it costs less than most of the other sophisticated methods.
However, despite its simplicity, the payback period may not be a desirable
investment criterion. In the first place, it fails to recognise the cash flows that
come in after the payback period. Again it fails to consider the pattern of cash
inflows and that early cash inflows rather than later cash inflows.
Despite its weakness, the payback period is very popular analogy. It tries to
emphasizes early recovery of an investment. This means that it gives an insight
into the cash inflows of the project.
200
The Accounting Rate of Return (ARR) Method
The accounting rate of return (ARR) is a method that uses accounting
information to measure the profitability of an investment. The accounting
rate of return (ARR) is computed by dividing average income after taxes by the
average investment.
Example
A project costs N100, 000 and has a scrap value of N40, 000. The stream of
income before depreciation and taxes are N40, 000, N50, 000 and N60, 000 for
the first three years. The tax rate is 50% and depreciation is on straight line
basis. Calculate the accounting rate of return for the project.
Solution
201
Book value of investment
As an accept or reject criterion, the ARR method will accept all those projects
whose ARR is greater than the minimum rate established by management. If the
ARR is lower than the minimum rate established by management, then the
project should be rejected. The ARR method is very simple to understand and
use. It can also be easily calculated using accounting information.
However, the ARR suffers from three main weaknesses. First it uses accounting
profits not cash flows in appraising projects. Secondly ARR ignores the time
value of money. The profits occurring in different periods are valued equally.
Thirdly, it does not allow the fact that profit can be reinvested to earn more
profits.
In-text Question
Explain briefly the payback period
Answer
The payback period is one of the most popular methods of project evaluation. The payback
period is defined as the number of years required to recover the original cash outlay invested
in a project. If the project yields constant annual cash inflows, the payback period can be
computed by dividing cash outlay by the annual cash inflow.
202
2.2 Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Methods
We have discussed two of the traditional methods used in the evaluation of
projects. One is the payback period while the other is the accounting rate of
return (ARR). Although two of them are simple to use and understand, they are
not theoretically sound. Both of them fail to consider the timing of cash flows.
Both fail to consider the time value of money.
The two methods are the net present value (NPV) method and the internal rate
of return (IRR) method. These two methods are referred to as discounted cash
flow (DCF) methods or the time-adjusted methods.
The following steps are followed when computing the net present value (NPV).
1. A discount rate is selected to discount the cash flows. The correct
discount rate should be the firm‘s cost of capital which is the minimum
rate of return expected by the investors to be earned by the firm.
2. The present value of cash inflows and outflows are computed using cost
of capital as the discounting rate.
3. The net present value (NPV) is the present value of cash inflows less
present value of cash outflows.
203
The acceptance rule using the NPV method is to accept a project if the NPV is
positive, and to reject it if the NPV is negative.
If NPV is greater than zero, then the value of the firm is expected to increase. It
is also important for us to understand the interpretation of NPV. The net present
value may be interpreted to mean the immediate increase in the wealth of a
firm if the investment proposal is accepted. It is equal to an unrealized capital
gain. The net present value can also be interpreted to represent the amount the
firm could raise at a required rate of return in addition to the initial cash outlay
to distribute immediately to its shareholders and by the end of the project life to
have paid off all the capital raised plus interest on it.
Example
Calculate the net present value of a project which cost N500,000. But generates
cash inflows of N150,000, N300,000 and N400,000 over a three year period.
The required rate of return is 10%.
Solution
In terms of merit, the NPV method is very significant since it recognizes the
time value of money. It also is consistent with the objective of maximizing the
wealth of shareholders. However, the NPV suffers from the following
limitations. Firstly, it is fairly difficult to use.
204
Secondly, in computing the NPV, it is assumed that the discount rate which
usually is a firm‘s cost of capital is known. But as we know, the cost of capital
is a fairly difficult concept to measure in real life.
Thirdly, NPV may not yield a consistent answer when the projects being
compared involve different amounts of investment.
The value of R in the equation at which total cash outlays equal total cash
inflows is called the internal rate of return (IRR). Usually the value of R can be
205
found out by trial and error. Generally, if the calculated present value of the
expected cash inflows is lower than the present value of cash outflows, a lower
rate should be tried. On the other hand, if the calculated present value of the
expected cash inflows is higher than the present value of cash outflows, a higher
rate should be tried.
Example
A barbers‘ shop costs N32,400 to establish and is expected to generate cash
inflows of N16,000,N14,000 and N12,000 over its life of three years. Calculate
the internal rate of return.
Solution
You will observe from the above calculations that when we tried 16% discount
rate, the NPV was negative at –N514, when we tried 14%discount rate, the NPV
became positive at N498. Therefore, the internal rate of return we are looking
for lies between 14% and 16%.
206
The basic accept-or-reject rule, using the IRR method, is to accept the project if
its internal rate of return is higher than the firm‘s required rate of return.
However, the project should be rejected if its internal rate of return is lower than
the firms cost of capital. It is important that we understand the interpretation of
the internal rate of return (IRR).
The internal rate of return (IRR) represents the highest rate of interest a firm
would be ready to pay on funds borrowed to finance the project without being
financially worse-off, by repaying the loan principal plus accrued interest out of
the cash inflows generated by the project.
We should also see the internal rate of return method as a very sound method.
As we said, it is a discounted cash flow method and also it considers the time
value of money. It is also compatible with the firm‘s desire to maximise the
owners‘ wealth. However the IRR method is fairly difficult to understand and it
involves complex computations.
In-text Question
Mention the two methods of the time-adjusted methods.
Answer
The two methods are the
1. The net present value (NPV) method and
2. The internal rate of return (IRR) method.
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
We have discussed project evaluation criteria which we said constitute a very
crucial topic in this course. We discussed traditional criteria of project
evaluation. Here we mentioned the payback period and the accounting rate of
return (ARR). We also discussed discounted cash inflow criteria. Here we
mentioned the net present value (NPV) method and the Internal Rate of Return
(IRR).
207
Project evaluation criteria provide us with the tools with which we can choose
from various investment proposals using acceptable techniques. The evaluation
criteria guide the project initiator and assist him/her to choose among alternative
projects. Also banks use project evaluation criteria to decide whether or not to
lend money for a project.
208
STUDY SESSION 5
Introduction to Economic Analysis
Section and Subsection Headings:
Introduction
1.0 Learning Outcomes
2.0 Main Content
2.1- Financial Analysis and Economic Analysis- A Comparison
2.2- The Nature of Economic Analysis
2.3- Adjustments to Financial Analysis
2.4- Linkage Effects of a Project
3.0Study Session Summary and Conclusion
4.0 Self-Assessment Questions
5.0 Additional Activities (Videos, Animations & Out of Class activities)
6.0 References/Further Readings
Introduction:
Generally, in a project analysis situation, most analyses focus on the cash
inflows and outflows of a project. Critical expenses and incomes are usually
compared to determine whether a project should be undertaken or not. But
expenses and revenues in most financial analyses are mainly the consideration
of a private investor.
209
community, the state and the nation?
2. Will the project generate employment at various levels in the macro
environment?
3. Will the project lead to economic growth?
4. What are the linkages that the project has, i.e., forward or backward
linkages?
5. Will the project generate more technical knowledge?
The questions that we have asked are not exhaustive but only go to demonstrate
the type of questions that economic analyses seek to answer.
Financial analysis equally tries to allocate resources but from a micro view point.
So, both financial and economic analyses solve resource allocation problems.
210
Financial analysis tries to concern itself
with issues of both benefits and costs
arising from a project. In the financial
analysis, the concern of the analysis is to
evaluate the stream of costs attached to a
project and deduct same from the stream of
benefits. Fig 4.5.1: Financial Analysis and Economic Analysis
Source: chalkstreet.com
If the stream of benefits is greater than the stream of costs, then project in question
has a positive value and should be accepted, all things being equal. However, if
the stream of costs is greater than the stream of benefits, then the project in
question has a negative value and should not be accepted, all things being equal.
Economic analysis also concerns itself with costs and benefits arising from a
project. If the stream of benefits is greater than the stream of costs, then the
project in question has a positive value and should be accepted.
However, if the stream of costs is greater than the stream of benefits, then the
project in question has a negative value and should not be accepted, all things
being equal. So we could say that financial analysis and economic analysis both
concern themselves with costs and benefits arising from a project. In the end, they
provide answers to the question of whether a project should be acceptable or not.
In evaluating projects, both use discounting and compounding techniques to arrive
at their answers.
211
the fact that a project is acceptable or not to the society as a whole. So while
financial analysis has a micro objective, economic analysis has a macro objective.
For example in financial analysis, costs and benefits arising from a project are
usually defined in monetary variables such as profits. But economic analysis goes
really beyond the vague definitions of profit. In Economic analysis, costs are
defined in terms of opportunity costs or foregone costs to the society as a whole.
Generally, according to the net present worth theory, a project is acceptable if the
net present worth is positive. If the net present worth is negative, the project will
be rejected.
212
Benefit-Cost Ratio
If you divide the present worth of benefits of a project by the present worth of
its costs, then you have what is known as the benefit-cost ratio. We can write thus:
Benefit-Cost ratio = Present worth of benefits
-------------------------------
Present worth of costs
Generally, a project is acceptable if the benefit-cost ratio is greater than 1 (one).
If the benefit-cost ratio is exactly 1 (one), that project is a break even project.
Under the internal rate of return evaluation method, a project will be acceptable if
its internal rate of return is higher than the firm‘s required rate of return.
The starting point of economic analysis is the financial analysis of a project which
should be properly concluded before embarking on an economic analysis. Some
adjustments will be made to the calculations to arrive at economic data.
In-text Question
Define financial analysis
Answer
Financial analysis tries to solve resource allocation problems. It tries to use information
from projects to determine whether projects should come on stream or not. Economic
analysis also tries to solve resource allocation problems in an economy.
First, it may be necessary to include or exclude some costs and benefits which
may have been included or excluded from the financial analysis.
Secondly, some project inputs and outputs may have to be revalued if their
shadow prices differ significantly from their market prices.
213
2.3 Adjustments to Financial Analyses
We have stated that the starting point of an economic analysis is a financial
analysis, so if we have financial data on financial analysis, we need to make some
adjustments to the financial analysis to arrive at economic analysis data. We shall
now consider some of the adjustments:
Transfer Payments
Transfer payments represent transfer of resources from one section of society to
another. They do not make any claim on the country‘s resources and as such, their
impact should be clearly distinguished and analyzed in the economic analysis.
One of the first transfer payments we shall consider is interest. Interest is a reward
for capital. For example, if a project is
funded through a bank loan, the interest
component is included in the profit and loss
statement.
Source: thetyee.ca
In effect, both figures are equal and cancel out without any net increase to society
of funds. Therefore in economic analysis, interest charges are excluded since they
only represent transfer payments.
The second transfer payment we shall consider is tax. When a project is profitable
it is expected to pay taxes to the government at the ruling rate. In computing the
profit of a project taxes are deducted to arrive at net profit. Taxes therefore appear
214
as outgoing cash flows. Taxes represent transfer payments from a project to
government.
In the economic analysis of a project, taxes are excluded because from the point of
view of the society, they are only a transfer of resources from one section of the
economy to another.
Generally, there are two types of linkage effects which we shall briefly discuss:
215
Forward linkage is the stimulus given to industries that use the products of a
project. A case in point is a flour manufacturing project. Flour has so many uses.
If a flour mill is located in an environment, it will lead to the establishment of
such projects as bakeries which will use the flour.
Also, the establishment of a car assembly plant will lead to the establishment of
tyre manufacturing plants that need to supply tyres to the car assembly plant.
Under the scheme, young farmers will be allocated hectares of land for subsidized
cassava cultivation. Such inputs like fertilizers will be heavily subsidized while
technical advice will be provided by the World Bank/ Nigerian agricultural
experts.
In-text Question
What is a forward linkage effect?
Answer
Forward linkage is the stimulus given to industries that use the products of a project. A case
in point is a flour manufacturing project.
216
3.0 Conclusion/Summary
In this session, we discussed the nature of economic analysis and compared it
with the financial analysis of a project. We discussed net present benefit cost
ratio and the internal rate of return (IRR).
Introduction to economic analysis has provided us with the tools to conduct
economic analyses, with financial analyses as a starting point.
217
XIII Glossary
Abandonment Rates: A measurement of the number of job applicants that start
but do not finish completing a job application on a company’s ATS (applicant
tracking system). When job-seekers start the process and then drop out, that’s a
failure for the employer.
Base Wage Rate (or base rate): The monthly salary or hourly wage paid for a
job, irrespective of benefits, bonuses or overtime.
Benchmark Job: A job commonly found in the workforce for which pay and
other relevant data are readily available. Benchmark jobs are used to make pay
comparisons and job evaluations.
219
automating thank you’s, shares and even follows – all examples of blind
engagement which have the potential to hurt brand reputation.
Broker: An individual who acts as an agent for a buyer and a seller and charges
a commission for his/her services. An example of a large brokerage firm is
Marsh. An example of a state firm is ABD in California.
Compensatory Time-Off plan: The practice of giving employees paid time off
that can be used in the future in lieu of paying them overtime for hours worked
in excess of 40 per week. While an acceptable practice in the public sector, the
FLSA places very strict limitations on the use of compensatory time off for
private sector employers.
221
Competency-Based Pay: Competency-based pay, alternately known as skill-
based and knowledge-based pay, determines compensation by the type, breadth
and depth of skills that employees gain and use in their positions.
Cost-Per-Hire: The costs linked to recruiting talent. These costs can include
advertising, agency fees, relocation costs, and training costs.
222
Crowdsourcing: Obtaining services or contributions from a large independent
group of people (usually from an online community) rather than from traditional
employees or suppliers.
Deregulation: The removal or revision of laws that regulate the supply of goods
and services.
Equity theory: The idea that people desire to be treated fairly and thus compare
their own contributions to the workplace—and resulting rewards—against those
of their coworkers, to determine if they are being treated fairly.
224
Factor comparison: A systematic and scientific comparison, that instead of
ranking complete jobs, ranks according to a series of factors. These factors
include mental effort, physical effort, skill needed, responsibility, supervisory
responsibility, working conditions, etc.
Fair Credit Reporting Act: A United States federal law that regulates the
collection, dissemination, and use of consumer information. In an HR setting
employers that run background checks on job candidates or employees must
comply with the Fair Credit Reporting Act.
Gender Pay Gap: the average difference between men’s and women’s
aggregate hourly earnings.
Glass Ceiling: A term used to describe the barriers – often unseen – that keep
minorities and women from career advancement regardless of their
qualifications.
Job analysis: The process of gathering information about the requirements and
necessary skills of a job in order to create a job description.
226
Job Description: A written statement that explains the responsibilities and
qualifications of a given job, based on a job analysis. The job description
usually includes specific required tasks as well as an overview of the position
and whom the employee reports to.
Job evaluation: A comparison of one job with other jobs in a company for the
purpose of assessing fair compensation.
Key Performance Indicators (KPIs): Tasks that are central to the success of a
business and show, when measured, whether the business is advancing toward
its strategic goals.
KSAs: The Knowledge, Skills and Abilities an employee needs to meet the
requirements of a job.
Labor force participation rate: The ratio between the labor force (all those
currently employed or seeking work) and the nation’s total working-age
population.
Labor law posting: Federal and state regulations requiring employers to post in
conspicuous places a variety of labor law posters with information regarding
employee rights
Long-term care insurance: Helps provide for the cost of long-term care
beyond a predetermined period, and is generally not covered by health
insurance, Medicare, or Medicaid.
227
LIFO (Last In, First Out): A method of determining who should be laid off in
which the most recent hires are laid off first.
228
Minimum wage: The lowest amount an employer can pay an hourly employee.
This rate is set by the federal government.
Mobile Recruiting: Using mobile technologies to find and connect with people
(candidates) who use mobile devices (e.g., phone).
Momtrepreneur: A woman who has children and runs a business at the same
time.
Negotiation: Bargaining between two or more parties with the goal of reaching
consensus or resolving a problem.
Nepotism: Preferential hiring of relatives and friends, even though others might
be more qualified for those positions.
Nonexempt Employee: An employee who does not meet any one of the Fair
Labor Standards Act exemption tests and is paid on an hourly basis and covered
by wage and hour laws regarding hours worked and overtime pay.
Orientation: Introducing new hires to the organization and its policies, benefits
and culture. Training and familiarization with each department are sometimes
included.
Pareto chart: A quality assurance tool that ranks information, like reasons for
certain problems, in descending order. The goal is to identify the most serious
problems so improvements can be made.
Premium only plan (POP): Section 125 is part of the IRS Code that allows
employees to convert a taxable cash benefit (salary) into non-taxable benefits,
so they may pay for qualified benefit premiums before any taxes are deducted
from their paychecks. The Premium only plan allows for certain employee paid
group insurance premiums to be paid with pre-tax dollars.
Recruitment: The process of finding and hiring the best-qualified candidate for
a position.
232
Scalability: The degrees to which the system, network, or process of a
computer’s hardware or software can be expanded in size, volume, or number of
users served and continue to function properly. An analogous business model of
economic growth refers to a businesses ability to expand to a greater capacity.
Social HR: The extent to which human resource departments leverage social
media tools (Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter, etc.) to conduct human resource
activities (recruiting, employment branding, etc.) aimed at aligning HR goals to
the company’s business goals.
Social Media: Forms of electronic communication (as Web sites for social
networking and microblogging) through which users create online communities
to share information, ideas, personal messages, and other content (as videos).
Tangible rewards: Gifts in the form of merchandise, gift certificates, etc. that
can be physically held or touched.
Title VII: Federal law that prohibits employers from discriminating against
employees on the basis of sex, race, color, national origin, and religion.
234
Transformational Leadership: A systematic form of leadership that enhances
the motivation, morale and performance of followers through change,
innovation, and group dynamics.
Unconscious Bias: Implicit or unconscious bias happens when our brains make
quick judgments and assessments of people, or situations, without us realizing.
Unconscious bias can heavily influence recruitment and selection decision.
Union: Workers who organize a united group, usually related to the kind of
work they do, to collectively bargain for better work conditions, pay or benefit
increases, etc.
Video Interview: A job interview that takes place through a video technology
platform instead of in person.
Virtual HR: The use of various types of technology to provide employees with
self-serve options. Voice response systems, employee kiosks are common
methods.
Wage drift: The difference between basic pay and total earnings, due to a
variety of possible factors such as overtime, bonuses, gender, age and
performance.
Work-life Balance: The attempt to balance work and personal life in order to
have a better quality of life. A person with a balanced life is an asset to his or
her business, as he or she experiences greater fulfillment at work and at home.
235
planning. Many e-recruitment software providers include modules for
workforce planning.
236