Day2-Process Analysis I - S
Day2-Process Analysis I - S
0
Lecture 1 Review
• Competitive priorities are the operational strengths that allow a company to succeed in the
marketplace.
• Porter's Generic Competitive Strategies (ways of competing): Defines three primary ways
organizations can achieve a competitive advantage in their market.
• Cost Leadership: Compete by offering the lowest price in the market while maintaining
acceptable quality.
• Differentiation: Compete by offering unique products or services that provide value to
customers.
• Focus: Target a specific market niche to serve the unique needs of a particular group.
1
Lecture 1 Review
2
Update
• Research indicates that differentiation and cost leadership can co-exist. However,
Porter insists that each generic strategy requires a different culture and a totally
different philosophy. Yet, the problem is that Porter’s generic strategies
are too broad.
3
Example: Amazon
• At the same time, Amazon differentiates itself through unique features and
services that add value to customers: Amazon Prime differentiates Amazon by
offering fast delivery, exclusive content (movies, TV shows, music), and drone
delivery.
4
Example: Costco
• Costco’s core strategy revolves around providing products at the lowest possible
prices.
• Bulk Sales: By selling products in large quantities, Costco reduces per-unit costs
and passes savings to customers.
• Costco also differentiates itself in ways that enhance its customer value
proposition, even while maintaining low prices. Membership Exclusivity
• The membership model itself creates differentiation
5
Review: What is Operations Management?
• What is “Operations”
• The set of activities that creates value in the form of goods and services by
transforming inputs into outputs
• Without Operations: No goods or services to sell.
6
Operations
Value Added
Transformation/ Outputs:
Inputs:
Materials Conversion Goods,
Services
Information Activities
7
Process vs Operations
Example: A Restaurant
• Operations: Coordinating staff schedules, supply chain management, managing
inventory, and overseeing the entire dining experience.
• Processes: Taking customer orders, Preparing meals in the kitchen, Delivering
food to tables.
8
What is a process?
• A process is a group of related tasks with
specific input and output.
• Planning, analyzing, and improving processes
is the essence of the operations management.
9
What are the
differences
between the
processes
10
Process Strategy
11
Process Strategy vs Operations Strategy
12
Process Strategies Overview
14
Process Focus Strategy
15
Process focus
16
1. Process Focus (Job Shop/Intermittent)
• Custom manufacturing workshops (e.g., handmade furniture)
• Hospitals (patient-specific treatments)
• Consulting Firms
• Characteristics:
• Facilities are organized around specific activities or processes
• General purpose equipment and skilled workers
• Low volume, high variety
• Flexible processes, often customized per order
17
Advantages
18
Disadvantages
19
Repetitive Focus Strategy
• These plants utilize highly standardized assembly line
processes to produce vehicles efficiently while still offering
a range of models, colors, and features to meet diverse
customer preferences.
• These plants usually use modular production which allows
for flexibility in assembling different models and
configurations..
• Modules are parts or components previously prepared.
• Larger quantities than in a process focus strategy but with
less customization.
20
Repetitive Focus Strategy
• Highly standardized processes to deliver consistent
quality and service across its global network of
restaurants while offering a variety of menu items to
cater to different tastes and preferences.
21
Repetitive Focus Strategy: Harley-Davidson
22
2. Repetitive focus
• Repetitive focus involves the systematic assembly or
production of items in a repetitive manner using pre-made
modules or components.
23
2. Repetitive Focus (Assembly Line)
• Automobile manufacturing (e.g., Ford assembly line)
• Electronics (e.g., smartphone assembly)
• Characteristics:
• Facilities often organized as assembly lines.
• Characterized by modules with parts and assemblies made previously
• Create more standardized products in larger quantities compared to
process focused facilities.
• Low flexibility than process focused facilities but more efficient
• Skill requirement are lower than in process focused strategy.
• Moderate Volume, Moderate Variety
24
Advantages
25
Disadvantages
26
3. Product Focus
• By manufacturing large quantities of the same product,
Intel reduces per-unit costs, enhancing profitability and
competitiveness.
27
3. Product Focus
28
3. Product Focus
29
3. Product focus
30
3. Product Focus (Continuous Flow/Line Flow)
• Products such as glass, paper, tin sheets, lightbulbs, beer, and potato chips
• Characteristics:
• Facilities often organized by product
• High volume, low variety of products
• Highly standardized, long, continuous production
• Generally less skilled labor
• Specialized equipment (high levels of automation)
31
Advantages
• The variable cost is low due to the high
volume and the system requires a very
small workforce.
• Standardized processes ensure
uniformity in product quality
• Fast and high production volumes
32
Disadvantages
• Required a large investment in plant
and highly specialized equipment.
• Limited producing variety item
• Overproduction or underutilization
during demand fluctuations.
33
34
4. Mass customization
• Nike By You: mass customization in 1999
• User-Friendly Customization Interface allows customers
to personalize their own footwear, apparel, and
accessories.
• Enhanced customer satisfaction
• Brand differentiation
35
4. Mass customization
36
4. Mass Customization
• Characteristics:
• Rapid process design
• High volume, high variety
• Combines efficiency with customization
• Uses flexible processes for personalized products
37
Advantages
38
Disadvantage
39
40
Comparison of processes
41
Example 1: Custom Design Studio
42
Example 2: FreshSip Bottling Co.
43
Example 3: StyleMySneakers
• An online sneaker retailer allows customers to design their own shoes by choosing
colors, materials, and patterns. Once orders are placed, the sneakers are produced
on an automated assembly line that uses modular components to match customer
preferences.
• Question:
What type of process strategy does StyleMySneakers use?
A. Process focus
B. Product focus
C. Mass customization
D. Repetitive focus
44
Example 4: TailoredTech Computers
45
Example 5: SpeedyAuto Assembly
• A car manufacturer produces different car models using standardized parts. Each
model shares a common platform, but features like interior trims, colors, and
engines can vary based on customer orders.
• Question:
What type of process strategy does SpeedyAuto Assembly use?
A. Process focus
B. Product focus
C. Mass customization
D. Repetitive focus
46
Discussion
• You are the operations manager of a startup launching customizable tech gadgets.
How would you decide on a process strategy?
47
Process Analysis
48
Process Flow
Diagram
49
Process Flow Diagram
50
Flow Unit
The flow unit is what is tracked through the process and generally defines the process
output of interest.
51
Basic Flowcharting Shapes
Storage
Triangle
52
53
Building A Flowchart
1. Determine objectives
2. Define units of flow (i.e., patients, products, data)
3. List all Activities
4. Sequence the Steps
5. Arrange the Steps Sequentially
6. Map out process
7. Validate chart (with user, expert, or observation)
54
Create a flow chart for making coffee at home
55
Time-Function Mapping
• A second tool for process analysis and design is also a flowchart, but with time
added on the horizontal axis.
• With time-function mapping, nodes indicate the activities and the arrows indicate
the flow direction, with time on the horizontal axis.
• This type of analysis allows users to identify and eliminate waste such as extra
steps, duplication, and delay
56
Excerpted from Elaine J. Labach, “Faster, Better, and Cheaper,” Target no. 5: 43 with permission of the Association for Manufacturing
Excellence,
57
Value Stream Mapping
58
Value Stream Mapping
• It helps you visualize more than just the single-process level, enabling you to see
the flow of work across all the processes.
• Depicts how all processes are linked
• Includes both the material and information flow
• It identifies the source of waste and minimizes it.
• Waste: to any stage in the value stream that does not contribute to the overall
value proposition for the final consumer.
59
Service
Blueprinting
60
Service Blueprinting
61
Service Blueprinting
62
Service Blueprinting
63
Service Blueprinting
• Potential Failure Points: Areas in the service process where errors or disruptions
can occur.
✓Example: A website crashing during online order placement.
• Poka-Yoke Techniques: Refers to designing systems or processes in such a way
that errors are either prevented or immediately detected and corrected
✓Example: Confirmation prompts in online forms to reduce user input errors.
64
Process Charts
• Uses symbols to indicate activities
• Includes time for each activity and
distance for transportation activities
• Identifies value-adding activities (e.g.,
operation) and waste (e.g.,
transportation, inspection, delay and
storage)
65
Process Charts
• Process charts use symbols, time, and distance to provide an objective and
structured way to analyze and record the activities that make up a process.
• Identifying all value-added operations (as opposed to inspection, storage, delay,
and transportation, which add no value) allows us to determine the percent of
value added to total activities
66
What Are The Key Metrics in
Process Analysis
67
How to measure a process?
68
Process Capacity
69
Types of capacity
Types of
capacity
Takes into account the realities of the production
process. It considers factors such as scheduled
Effective Capacity maintenance, worker breaks, and typical delays in the
supply chain. As such, effective capacity is often lower
than design capacity.
70
Example
• A restaurant is designed with 50 tables, and under ideal conditions, it can serve 200
customers per hour (assuming 4 customers per table and fast turnover).
➢This is the maximum theoretical capacity the restaurant can handle based on its
design.
• In real-world conditions:
➢There are natural constraints like time taken to clean tables, customers spending longer
than expected, and occasional staff shortages.
➢Under these normal operating conditions, the restaurant can realistically serve 150
customers per hour.
➢This is the realistic maximum capacity, accounting for disruptions and inefficiencies.
71
Utilization
• Utilization: The ratio of the actual output to the maximum possible output
(capacity) during a given period.
Actual Output
Utilization=
Design Capacity
72
Efficiency
73
Example
74
Note!
• In case we are given both the design capacity and effective capacity and asked to
find either Utilization and Efficiency, we should distinguish between them.
• However, if only one measure of capacity is given both terms Utilization and
Efficiency are used interchangeably.
75
Utilization and Efficiency
• A utilization rate of 85% is considered ideal for most businesses. The higher the
rate, the more a business is using all of its available resources, which is beneficial
to productivity.
• However, a singular focus on utilization rates may leave little or no time for
maintenance, repairs or accidents.
• An efficiency of 100% indicates that products and goods are being made at the
lowest average cost.
• In reality, many companies may operate at a significantly lower percentage
depending on their business needs. Usually, a business compares its current
efficiency rate to past measurements or with their competitors in their field to
decide on a desired efficiency rating.
76
Cycle time
• Cars coming in from one end and cars coming out, and we are standing out and
watching the cars as they leave.
• In the literature there are two different definition for Cycle time. We use the
definition in this lecture note for our analysis:
Cycle time: The average time between the completion of successive units in a
process.
78
Flow time
25 minutes
Even though there's a car coming out every 10 minutes, when the red car goes in, it took it 25
minutes to go through the car wash to come out at the other end.
This 25 minutes we will call the flow time or the throughput time.
Flow time: the time it takes a part to get through an entire process beginning to end.
Flow time includes both processing time and any time the unit spans between steps.
79
Process time
• Process time is the amount of time it takes to complete a task or item in a process
• Process time is the average time that a unit is worked on.
• Process time is flow time less idle time.
• Based on process time, we can compute the capacity
1
𝐂𝐚𝐩𝐚𝐜𝐢𝐭𝐲 𝐨𝐟 𝐚 𝐬𝐭𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧 =
𝐏𝐫𝐨𝐜𝐞𝐬𝐬 𝐭𝐢𝐦𝐞 𝐨𝐟 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐬𝐭𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧
80
Example
81
Example (Cont)
• The sequence involves…….. minutes of idling time with Task A and…… minutes
of idling time for Task C. This is where inefficiency takes place.
• Eliminating The Slowest Task In The System is The Key For Cycle Time
Optimization
82
Note!
• The overall cycle time is determined by the slowest process in the entire sequence.
• In this example, there are 3 different tasks to produce 1 unit. Task A takes 3
minutes, Task B takes 7 minutes, Task C takes 4 minutes. The slowest task
(process) in this sequence is Task B which takes 7 minutes.
• This becomes the cycle time of entire sequence.
83
Example
• 3 sequential activities: A, B, C
• A: Preparation, B: Bake ,and C: package and label
• 4 resources: Operator1, operator2, operator 3, oven
• To produce each batch of muffin, operator 1 prepare the material, operator 2 put
the batch in the oven, operator 3 take the batch out and does packaging and
labeling.
84
Example (Cont)
85
Example
• Suppose there are 2 ovens, calculate the processing time and capacity of the oven?
B
20 minutes
B
20 minutes
86
Example
• Suppose that there are 2 ovens, calculate the flow time. And capacity of the system
87
Example
A warehouse has a process for packing orders that consists of the following steps:
1. Pick items from shelves: 5 minutes.
2. Pack items into a box: 3 minutes.
3. Label and seal the box: 2 minutes.
• Additional Details:
✓There is only one worker who completes all steps.
✓Orders may spend 4 minutes waiting between each step due to task switching and
coordination.
✓Calculate the process time and flow time.
88
89
Capacity and strategy
• Sustained profits come from building competitive advantage, not just from a good
financial return on a specific process.
• Capacity decisions must be integrated into the organization's mission and strategy.
Strategy on a Page : 5 Steps to Create a Winning Strategy - Skefto
90
Managing Demand
91
Scenarios in Demand and Capacity: Capacity Matches
Demand
• Implications:
• Optimal resource utilization
• Balanced workload for employees and equipment.
• High customer satisfaction due to timely delivery of
goods/services.
92
Scenarios in Demand and Capacity: Demand Exceeds
Capacity
• Implications:
• Long customer wait times or service delays.
• Loss of customers to competitors if needs aren’t met.
93
Balancing Demand and Capacity- Demand Exceeds
Capacity
94
Scenarios in Demand and Capacity: Capacity Exceeds
Demand
• Implications:
• Idle resources and underutilized staff or equipment.
• Higher operational costs per unit of output due to fixed costs
being spread over fewer units.
95
Balancing Demand and Capacity- Capacity Exceeds Demand
96
Matching Demand with Capacity
• Managing Demand
• Too much demand
• Short-term solution: Discourage demand (raise price, longer leadtime, etc)
• Long-term solution: Increase capacity in the long term
• Seasonal demand
• Offer products with complementary demand patterns
• For example, the demand for swim suits tend to be higher in summer than winter. If the manufacturer
established a high capacity (e.g., hired many workers) to satisfy the strong demand in summer, the
capacity will be wasted in winter due to low demand. The manufacturer can use the capacity to
produce a product with complementary demand pattern, such as winter jackets. (So in winter, the
workers can focus on producing winter jackets.)
97
Demand Management in Service Sector
98
Capacity Management in Service Sector
• When managing demand is not feasible, then managing capacity through changes
in full-time, temporary, or part-time staff may be an option.
• For instance, hospitals may find capacity limited by a shortage of board-certificate
radiologists willing to cover the graveyard shifts.
• Getting fast and reliable radiology readings can be the difference between life and
death for an emergency patient.
• When an overnight reading is required, the image can be sent by email to a doctor
in Europe or Australia for immediate analysis.
99
Question
100
Question
101
• In the lecture example, what is the average cycle time for cars leaving a car
wash if one car leaves every 10 minutes?
A) 0.1 cars/minute
B) 6 cars/hour
C) 10 minutes per car
D) 60 minutes per car
102
Discussion
103