First Draft
First Draft
Janice:
Causes of Endangerment:
o Habitat Destruction: Deforestation and agricultural expansion
have reduced bamboo forests, which are the primary food
source for pandas.
o Climate Change: Rising temperatures and environmental
changes have impacted bamboo growth, further limiting the
pandas' food supply.
Conservation Status:
o Establishing 67 Giant Panda Nature Reserves has
significantly contributed to the breeding of captive pandas, its
population is showing signs of recovery. The Giant Panda
classified as "Vulnerable" on the IUCN Red List.
Causes of Endangerment:
o Poaching: Tigers are heavily poached for their skin and bones,
which are sold at high prices on the black market.
o Habitat Loss: Deforestation, infrastructure development, and
agricultural expansion have fragmented tiger habitats.
Conservation Status:
o Bengal Tigers are classified as "Endangered". The Indian
government has implemented the "Project Tiger" initiative,
establishing 27 tiger reserves covering over 37,000 square
kilometers to protect tigers and reduce human-wildlife conflict.
For example, pandas from the Ya'an Bifengxia Panda Base have been
leased to institutions such as the National Zoo in Washington, USA, and
the Kobe Oji Zoo in Japan. While the initial intention was to promote
global awareness and conservation efforts for pandas, a veterinarian
working at the breeding research base revealed that the focus has shifted
toward turning panda welfare and conservation into economic profit.
The natural conception success rate for pandas is extremely low, so
artificial insemination is often required. Unfortunately, this process is
reportedly very painful for the pandas. Moreover, transporting pandas to
other countries remains highly controversial, as they are forced to adapt to
unsuitable climates and food sources, conditions that appear to
contradict the original goal of conservation.
3. Balancing Conservation Efforts with Human Needs
While conservation efforts aim to protect endangered species, they often
raise conflicts with human livelihoods, particularly in regions where
resources are limited.
a. Case Study: India’s Project Tiger and Its Social Implications
Legislative Measures
1: Food Industry
“First, let’s talk about the food industry. One of the biggest ethical dilemmas here is
balancing animal welfare with the global demand for food.
For example, factory farming often involves cruel practices, such as keeping animals in
confined spaces, performing painful procedures like mutilations, and using inhumane
slaughtering methods.
So, I’ll ask you: Would you be willing to replace your steak with a plant-based or labgrown
alternative if it reduced animal suffering?”
2: Fashion Industry
“Next, let’s look at the fashion industry. Here, the ethical dilemma is about the appeal of
materials like leather and fur versus the harm they cause to animals.
For instance, traditional leather production requires raising and killing animals, while fur
involves even more direct suffering. In response, some brands are moving toward
synthetic alternatives or innovative materials like mushroom leather or apple leather.
These alternatives are better for animal welfare and, in some cases, better for the
environment. However, not everyone is convinced that they can match the quality or
prestige of traditional materials.
What do you think? Can these alternatives truly replace the appeal of leather and fur?”
3: Scientific Research
“Finally, let’s discuss scientific research. The ethical dilemma here is the trade-off
between medical advancements and animal suffering.
For example, animal testing has contributed to life-saving medical breakthroughs, but it
often comes at the cost of animal welfare. Animals in research facilities are subjected
to painful procedures and spend their lives in cages.
Thankfully, new technologies like cell cultures and computer modeling are helping us
reduce reliance on animal testing. But these methods are still in development and can’t
completely replace animals just yet.
This raises a tough question: Should we accept slower medical progress in order to
protect animals from suffering?”
Conclusion
“In conclusion, whether it’s about what we eat, what we wear, or the scientific progress
we pursue, ethical dilemmas involving animals are complex. They require us to make
thoughtful decisions and consider the impact of our choices.
So, I’ll leave you with this question: As a society, how far are we willing to go to prioritize
animals without compromising human needs