STAATUS Index 2022 Report
STAATUS Index 2022 Report
Abstract 3
Executive Summary 4
Key Findings 6
Introduction 8
Methodology 10
Recommendations 40
Conclusion 47
Index; the inaugural study in 2021 was one of the Inform the development of impactful policies
first national analyses of American attitudes and programs that can improve the status of We are delighted to collaborate also with leading
towards Asian Americans in 20 years. Asian Americans in the U.S. AAPI research and data organizations, AAPI Data
and StopAAPIHate.
Given the urgency to understand the root causes of The survey was conducted in partnership with our
prejudice and racism against Asian Americans, the esteemed Academic Advisory Committee:
survey addresses long-standing stereotypes (e.g.,
Professor Paul Watanabe, University of
the “model minority” and “perpetual foreigner”) as
Massachusetts/Boston, Chai
well as current perceptions that lead to
Professor Russell Jeung, San Francisco State
scapegoating and violence against the Asian
University
American community.
3
Executive Summary
Asian Americans face a somber reality in 2022: with a representative sample of Americans across On one hand, Americans see the contributions
Despite a new administration, a relative decline in racial groups, demographics, and geographies. The of Asian Americans to the U.S. and view Asian
the severity of the COVID-19 pandemic, and an data from 5,113 respondents provide multiple Americans in stereotypical “model minority”
improved economy, attacks against the Asian important issues and opportunities: terms as nice, smart, hard-working, and
American community continue to increase at The U.S. is in the midst of a racial crisis, and successful in business2.
alarming rates. there is broad agreement that people of color On the other, an increasing percentage of
are much more discriminated against and much Americans in 2022 question the loyalty of Asian
No longer can we blame the current wave of anti-
less advantaged than White Americans. Americans and blame Asian Americans for the
Asian American hate and violence on a single
Like Black and Latino Americans, Asian COVID-19 epidemic, fueling the “perpetual
politician or on a pandemic.
Americans face high levels of discrimination, yet foreigner” stereotype.
The root causes are deeper, systemic and tied to many Americans are unaware of the spike in
the xenophobia, fear, and “othering”1 of Asian anti-Asian American racism and hate over the
Americans, manifested in harmful stereotypes and past year.
misperceptions, that have persisted in our society Asian Americans are least likely among all racial
since Asians first arrived in the U.S. groups to feel we belong and are accepted in
the U.S., even if born in the U.S.
This year’s expanded STAATUS Index builds on the
work of the ground-breaking 2021 study to better
understand these stereotypes and misperceptions
4
In addition to providing an annual diagnosis of the Narrative change in news media, social media,
status of Asian Americans in U.S. society, the Index and entertainment is also necessary to foster
also provides potential solutions to address the belonging and acceptance for Asian
stereotypes and misperceptions that contribute to Americans; this will provide more accurate and
racism and violence against Asian Americans: multi-dimensional stories about Asian
Education is the most recommended solution Americans to overcome ignorance related to
overall to combat anti-Asian racism. We need the “model minority” and “perpetual foreigner”
to support organizations preserving, stereotypes.
commemorating, and teaching the long and
Further data and research about Asian
diverse histories of Asian Americans and Pacific
American stereotypes and misperceptions is
Islanders alongside the histories of African
critical as well to provide a deeper
Americans, Native Americans, Latinos, and
understanding of sentiment in the U.S. towards
other peoples of color and as part of the history
Asian Americans and track our progress in these
of systemic racism in the United States; invest in
areas.
teacher training and resources related to Asian
American and Pacific Islander history both At LAAUNCH and TAAF, we are committed to
inside and outside of the classroom. working with our partners, academic leaders,
Resources, support, and protection are needed community-based organizations, and multiracial
for victims of anti-Asian racism and the Asian allies in these areas to improve the status of Asian
American community more broadly. Americans and to promote prosperity and
belonging for all Americans.
5
Key Findings
Race Relations Black, Latino, and Asian Americans see Asian Compared to 2021, Americans in 2022 are more
The majority of Americans recognize that Asian Americans as people of color, whereas White likely to question the loyalty of Asian Americans
Americans, Black Americans, Latino Americans, Americans see Asian Americans as more similar and blame Asian Americans for COVID-19.
and Native Americans are being discriminated to themselves. Asian Americans overwhelmingly
Visibility and Awareness
against and that White Americans are most see themselves as people of color.
M ost Americans cannot name a prominent
advantaged by far. Perceptions and Stereotypes Asian American when asked, and top names
Nearly one-third of Americans overall are
The majority of Americans still see Asian cited again are martial artist actors from
unaware that attacks against Asian Americans
Americans in “model minority” terms — as smart, decades ago.
are increasing.
nice, and hard-working — and believe Americans still primarily see Asian American
Belonging and Acceptance (incorrectly) that Asian Americans are well actors in stereotypical and negative roles in TV
Across all racial groups, Asian Americans are represented in leadership positions in corporate and movies.
among the least likely to feel that they America.
completely belong and are accepted in the Over 70% of Americans believe Asian Americans
U.S.; this is especially true for younger Asian have benefited the U.S., especially in the areas
Americans and Asian American women. of positive economic impact, academic
Asian Americans born in the U.S. are less likely to excellence, and medical advancements.
feel they belong and are accepted than those
born in a foreign country.
6
Recommendations
7
Introduction
The STAATUS Index is based on multiple dimensions of competency and sociability. In a examples include the persecution and eventual
frameworks from social psychology, including the landmark study by Professors Katz and Braly4 that mass murder of the Armenians during the fall of the
Stereotype Content Model developed by Professor launched stereotype research in 1933, Japanese Ottoman Empire, the Jews before and during World
Susan Fiske3 in 2002 to analyze how dominant people were seen as intelligent, industrious, War II, and the Tutsis during the Rwandan Civil War
groups use two primary dimensions — competency progressive, and shrewd (competent), but shy and from 1990–1994. Professor Peter Glick, who
and sociability — to assess the relative threat of quiet (unsociable). Similarly, Chinese people were specializes in bias, stereotypes, and discrimination
“other” groups. In multiple studies, Asian Americans, seen as sly (implying competence), but research said in 2002, “when a history of envious
Jews, and female professionals are found to be conservative, tradition-loving, superstitious, and prejudice collides with a precipitous decline in a
clustered into an outgroup that is generally loyal to family (implying a lack of mainstream society’s life conditions, successful minorities are at
respected but disliked. These groups are sociability). A replication of this study in 2001 grave risk.”5 His prediction speaks directly to the
stereotyped as high in competence, resulting in confirmed these stereotypes: both Chinese and racism and violence Asian Americans are facing
respect, but viewed as having low sociability, Japanese people were seen as especially today during the dual crises of the COVID-19
resulting in dislike. This combination of perceptions intelligent, industrious, and scientifically-minded pandemic and increasing geopolitical and
engenders a mix of admiration, resentment, and (highly competent), but also loyal to family and economic competition between the U.S. and China.
envy. reserved (not sociable with dominant group).
While stereotyping can lead to extreme outcomes
Stereotyping of Asian Americans has been tracked History has shown repeatedly that “envious such as violence, this harmful behavior also has
for decades, and a review of these studies stereotyping” during times of crisis can lead to serious mental health implications, specifically on
illustrates that the dominant group often scapegoating, violence, and even genocide. Tragic Asian Americans’ sense of belonging. In a 1992
characterizes Asian Americans along the
8
study, Professor Hagerty et al.6 posited that a sense 1 https://www.theguardian.com/inequality/2017/nov/08/us-vs-them-the-
of belonging is a vital mental health concept that sinister-techniques-of-othering-and-how-to-avoid-them
2 https://www.npr.org/2021/05/25/999874296/6-charts-that-dismantle-the-
has two defining attributes: “(a) valued involvement trope-of-asian-americans-as-a-model-minority
or the experience of feeling valued, needed, or 3 Lin MH, Kwan VS, Cheung A, Fiske ST. Stereotype content model explains
prejudice for an envied outgroup: Scale of anti-Asian American Stereotypes.
accepted; and (b) fit, the perception that the Pers Soc Psychol Bull. 2005 Jan;31(1):34-47. doi: 10.1177/0146167204271320.
PMID: 15574660.
individual’s characteristics articulate with the
4 Katz, D., & Braly, K. (1933). Racial stereotypes of one hundred college
system or environment.” students. The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 28(3), 280–290.
https://doi.org/10.1037/h0074049
5 Glick, Peter. (2002). Sacrificial Lambs Dressed in Wolves’ Clothing: Envious
Belonging, as articulated by John A Powell of the Prejudice, Ideology, and the Scapegoating of Jews. Understanding
Haas Institute for a Fair and Inclusive Society at UC Genocide: The Social Psychology of the Holocaust. 10.1093/
acprof:oso/9780195133622.003.0006.
Berkeley, is the opposite of “othering,” when 6 HAGERTY, BONNIE M. K.; PATUSKY, KATHLEEN Developing a Measure Of
Sense of Belonging, Nursing Research: January 1995 - Volume 44 - Issue 1 -
societies undergoing major change experience
p 9-13
anxiety and exclude specific groups viewed as 7 https://www.theguardian.com/inequality/2017/nov/08/us-vs-them-the-
sinister-techniques-of-othering-and-how-to-avoid-them
potential threats to the “favored” group.7
Politicians and other leaders promote Asian
American stereotypes and misperceptions to
achieve their own agendas. Quantifying and
addressing this “culture of fear” are major
outcomes of the STAATUS Index.
9
Methodology
The results in this report are based on a national Given the unique identities and perceptions of the
survey of 5,113 U.S. residents, age 18 and over, Native Hawaiian and Pacific Islander (NHPI)
including 2,840 Whites or Caucasians, 888 Blacks or population, the focus of the STAATUS Index is on
African Americans, 1,023 Latinos or Hispanic the Asian American population. Further research is
Americans, and 1,074 Asians or Asian Americans. needed to analyze the perceptions and attitudes
The survey was conducted online in English towards the NHPI community.
between February 10 to February 28, 2022 by
Savanta Research.
10
Results and Analysis
We structure our analysis into five sections covering
distinct themes.
In Race Relations, we provide an update on In Visibility and Awareness, we study how Asian
Americans’ perceptions of racial issues in the U.S. Americans are seen and recognized in the U.S.
with a focus on anti-Asian American discrimination public consciousness and in TV and movies.
and racism.
Finally, in Recommendations, we suggest guidelines
In Belonging and Acceptance, we delve into the and actions based on the findings of the STAATUS
question of whether Asian Americans and other Index for community leaders and policymakers to
racial groups of color feel like they belong and are combat anti-Asian American discrimination and
11
Section ONE
Race Relations in
America
Getting worse
50%
26%
% of Americans who think the
relationships are… Staying the same
Improving
20%
Race relations in America
are getting worse
The majority of Americans believe race relations in
Not Sure
4%
the U.S. have declined in the last five years. By
contrast, only 20% of Americans believe race
relations have improved.
13
Race rel ations in america
By Political Affiliation
The pessimism concerning race relations is shared Democrat 48% 27% 22% 3%
by respondents across the political spectrum;
about half of all Democrats, Republicans, and
Republican 51% 25% 20% 3%
Independents believe race relations have gotten Independent 51% 26% 19% 4%
worse.
By Race
We also see broad consensus on the crisis of
America’s race relations across race and gender.
Black Americans 46% 28% 21% 5%
By Gender
Men 49% 25% 22% 4%
The majority of
Americans recognize
that Asian Americans are
being discriminated
56%
of Americans say Asian Americans
are being discriminated against
against
When asked how different racial groups are being
treated, 56% of respondents say Asian Americans
are being discriminated against, while only 6% say
Asian Americans are more advantaged compared
to other groups.
6%
say Asian Americans
are more advantaged
15
Race relations in america
Latino
Black American
8% 81% 63% 59%
Respondents
Asian American
8% 69% 54% 71%
Respondents
16
Race rel ations in america
Black Americans
17
Race relations in america
29%
Extremely Increased
Nearly one-third of
Americans are unaware
that attacks against
Asian Americans are
increasing 38%
The Center for the Study of Hate and Extremism at Somewhat Increased In the past 12 months, assaults, hate
California State University, San Bernardino, reports crimes or any other form of racism
that anti-Asian hate crimes increased 339% in 2021 against Asian Americans have...
compared to 2020. AAPI Data reports that one in six
Asian American adults experienced a hate crime or
hate incident in 2021, up from one in eight in 2020.
StopAAPIHate reports that assaults increased from 26%
Stayed the Same
10.8% of the total hate incidents reported to their
platform in 2020 to 16.6% in 2021.
5%
Somewhat Decreased
Yet despite these statistics, over 30% of Americans are
unaware of the increased attacks on Asian Americans 2%
or believe they have actually decreased. Extremely Decreased
18
Race relations in america
21% 5%
Americans College degree
By Political Leaning
The lack of awareness about anti-Asian American Very conservative 34% 8%
hate attacks points to an opportunity and need for
the news media to better report and inform the Somewhat conservative 30% 5%
public about these acts of violence and hate Moderate 28% 8%
incidents.
Somewhat liberal 16% 8%
Very liberal 15% 7%
19
Section TWO
Belonging and
Acceptance
Asian Americans are among the
least likely racial groups in the U.S.
to feel that they completely belong
ck A m e r i c a n s
n d 33 % of B l a
A m e r i c a n s a th ey b e l o n g
of Asi a n t th ey fe e l l i ke Compared to
t e l y a g re e th a of Latino Am 42%
com p l e th e U .S. e r i
and 61% of W cans
e a c ce p te d i n hite
and ar Americans
Belonging and Acceptance
By Age
Younger Asian 18–24 19%
Americans and Asian
27%
American women are 25–34
Men 33%
22
Belonging and Acceptance
23
Belonging and Acceptance
Latino Americans
57%
All Americans 69%
24
White Americans
B e lo n g i n g a n d Acce pta n ce
By Age
18–24 63%
Younger Americans see
25–34 51%
Asian Americans very
differently from older 35–44 46%
25
Section Three
Perceptions and
Stereotypes
Perceptions and Stereotypes
A majority of Americans
believe Asian Americans 50%
are well represented in of Americans said somewhat or
extremely well represented
companies and large
corporations
According to research from Ascend, however, Asian
Americans are the most likely to be hired as
professionals but are the least likely among all
racial groups to become executives.
6%
of executive, senior officer, and manager roles
are actually filled by Asian Americans
28 *Andy Kiersz, “Asian Americans Still Aren't Reaching the C-Suite - and It All Comes down to Promotions.
These 4 Charts Put the Problem in Perspective.,” Business Insider (Business Insider, May 26, 2021).
Perceptions and Stereotypes
29
Perceptions and Stereotypes
21%
academic
Over 70% of Americans excellence
30
Perceptions and Stereotypes
These contributions are % of Americans who said Asian Americans have “strongly benefited”
or “benefited” the U.S.
recognized across the
political spectrum 71% 72% 75%
71% of Democrats, 72% of Independents, and 75% of of Democrats of Independents of Republicans
Republicans believe Asian Americans have
benefited the U.S.
31
Perceptions and Stereotypes
32
Perceptions and Stereotypes
2022
33
Section Four
Visibility and
Awareness
58%
11% All other
Don't know
Most Americans cannot
name a prominent Asian
American when asked
7%
3%
In 2022, 58% of respondents are unable to name a Jackie Chan
prominent Asian American, highlighting once again
the invisibility of Asian Americans in the eyes of
most Americans.
Kamala Harris
4% 5% Bruce Lee 1%
Lucy Liu
3%
Among Asian Americans named by respondents, Margaret Cho
Andrew Yang
fame from his recent Olympic gold medal, Nathan 1% 1% 1%
1%
Chen is also mentioned.
Sanjay Gupta Jet Li
1% 1%
Jeremy Lin
29%
Kung Fu/Martial Arts/Expert
Criminal/Gangs/
Drug Dealers/Villain
American men are often
portrayed in which types
of character roles?
Similarly, Americans
primarily see Asian
American men in 9% 4%
Smart/
8%
Doctor
stereotypical and Intelligent
movies 4%
Nerdy/Nerd
37
Visibility and Awareness Black Americans 74%
Asian Americans 88%
Latino Americans 76%
The vast majority of White Americans 68%
Americans across all
“I would be interested to see more Asian American
racial groups express characters in TV and the movies.”
interest to see more Yes Not Sure No
Asian American actors
On a positive note, 71% of Americans said they
18–24 83%
would like to see more Asian Americans in TV and
movies, with younger and very liberal respondents
25–34 78%
the most keen. Perhaps the popularity of TV shows
and movies such as Squid Game, Shang-Chi and 35–44 73%
the Legend of the Ten Rings, and Quantico has
increased the interests of the general public for 45–54 70%
more Asian American content.
55–64 64%
38
65+ 62%
Visibility and Awareness
Where do you get most of your perceptions or knowledge about Asian Americans?
Asian Americans Black Americans Latino Americans White Americans
Recommendations
Do you think that anti-Asian American
racism is a problem that should be
addressed by Americans?
Americans should be No
addressed
41
Visibility and Awareness
82%
% of Americans who think that anti-Asian American racism
is a problem that should be addressed by Americans
Metro areas where Asians account for more than 10% of the population
77% of Liberals
Metro areas where Asians account for 5–10% of the population
73%
Metro areas where Asians account for 3–5% of the population
71%
Metro areas where Asians account for less than 3% of the population
65% 63%
of Conservatives
42
Recommendations
Education is the
information Americans and others Asian Americans Other
43
R e c o m m e n d at i o n s
A large percentage of 8%
Building railroads
Americans lack 3%
COVID
Asian Americans, 4%
Vietnam War
War II
42%
2%
Food
2%
17%
Korean War
Don’t know
4% WWII Internment
44
2% bill passage
War/wars
Recommendations
45
2%
War/Wars
Recommendations
As shown by the data in the STAATUS Index, there is Secondly, we must provide resources to victims of
a critical need to address the lack of: anti-Asian racism and explore ways to mobilize
Knowledge and understanding about Asian support and protection for Asian Americans who
Americans remain vulnerable to anti-Asian racism.
Safety and protection for the Asian American To create greater belonging and acceptance for
community Asian Americans and other communities of color,
Belonging and acceptance for Asian Americans we need to support the production of creative
and other communities of color media (movies, television, music, and other forms of
As a priority, we must preserve, commemorate, and storytelling) that feature Asian American actors and
teach our diverse histories, narratives, and performers in the full expression of our humanity to
experiences, including and especially the historical counter stereotypical portrayals of Asian Americans
and ongoing impact of systemic racism on Asian that have negatively affected our community for
Americans and Pacific Islanders and the histories of generations.
cross-racial solidarity. This teaching and learning Finally, we need to work together across the racial
must take place at all levels of education and divides with other concerned organizations to find
amongst the broader American public. common solutions to the declining state of race
relations and the growing inequality, racial animus,
and discrimination that affect us all.
46
Conclusion
For the past two years, Asian Americans have lived In the 2021 survey, respondents pointed to Trump minority” that has harmed not only our community
in a period of mourning, anger, fear, and exhaustion and COVID-19 as the main reasons for anti-Asian but also other communities of color.
from the devastation of COVID-19 and the surge in American sentiment, but this year’s findings remind
In its second year, the STAATUS Index provides a
anti-Asian violence, bigotry, and hate crimes. At a us again of the underlying racist and xenophobic
clear path forward. The majority of Americans
time when attacks against our community have tropes associated with Asians as “perpetual
believe that addressing anti-Asian racism is a
increased, we have seen a corresponding rise in foreigners” that have led to the systematic racism,
problem that should be addressed, and have
anti-Asian American sentiment among non-Asian discrimination, violence, and exclusion against our
pointed to education as the most recommended
Americans, particularly those who are less community for generations.
solution. Teaching about Asian Americans’
educated and more marginalized.
Compared to last year, a greater percentage of experiences in our curricula — alongside those of
Compared to last year’s STAATUS Index, non-Asian Americans cannot name a single prominent Asian African Americans, Native Americans, and Latino
Americans are more likely to say that Asian American: 58% cannot come up with a single name, Americans — will help educate Americans about
Americans are at least partly responsible for and 42% cannot identify a single policy or the fraught history of Asian America. And seeing
COVID-19. They are also more likely to agree that experience about Asian Americans. This invisibility our narratives represented alongside those of other
referring to the coronavirus as the “Wuhan virus” or points to the moral urgency to educate the Americans will also enhance Asian Americans’
“Chinese virus” is appropriate — disregarding the broader American public about the diverse sense of belonging.
World Health Organization’s advice of not histories, experiences, and attitudes of Asian
That younger and U.S.-born Asian Americans are
attaching locations or ethnicity to disease in order Americans. In doing so, we aim to disrupt the
less likely to feel like they belong in the U.S. reflects
to avoid stigmatization. narrow, pernicious stereotype of the “model
47
the invisibility of Asian Americans in our high school belonging will lay the foundation for the next
and university curricula, as well as in movies, in generation of leaders who will shape both
media, and in leadership. How many years will it perceptions and policy.
take before Jackie Chan and Bruce Lee are no
We look forward to a better future for Asian
longer cited as the most prominent Asian
Americans, and to tracking our progress with the
Americans in our survey? What will it take for Asian
STAATUS Index in the years to come.
American women to be cast in more diverse roles in
TV and movies? And when will Americans realize
that Asian Americans are severely
underrepresented on corporate boards and
university leadership?
48
Acknowledgements Our Partners
Academic Advisory Committee
Paul Watanabe, Professor, UMass Boston, Chai
Russell Jeung, Professor, San Francisco State
Universit Contact Information
Erika Lee, Professor, University of Minnesot
Jennifer Lee, Professor, Columbia Universit Website
Pei-Te Lien, Professor, University of California,
https://staatus-index.org/
Santa Barbar
Mike Hoa Nguyen, Professor, University of Denve Email
Karthick Ramakrishnan, Professor, University of
California, Riversid [email protected]
Karen Umemoto, Professor, University of
Social Media
California, Los Angeles
twitter @go_laaunch @taaforg
Baileigh Allen
Edelman
Savanta Research
Evergreen Strategy Group
instagram @go_laaunch @taaforg
The DataFace
Enfranchisement
facebook-f /golaaunch /taaforg
Kim Granlund
LAAUNCH team
linkedin-in /laaunch /taaforg
Jonas Tungodden TAAF team
49