SPM Unit 4
SPM Unit 4
Creating the Framework – Collecting the Data: Partial Completion Reporting – Risk Reporting –
Visualizing Progress: Gantt chart – Slip chart – Ball Charts – The Timeline – Cost Monitoring –
Earned Value Analysis – Prioritizing Monitoring – Getting the Project Back to Target – Change
Control
PART – A
Creating Framework
1. Define a checkpoint (R)
Checkpoints provide a basis for analysis and evaluation, to determine whether the project
is proceeding as planned, and to take corrective action as needed.
Checkpoint is a scheduled meeting or review session where the project team assesses the
current progress of the project against its planned objectives and milestones. Checkpoints
are used to ensure that the project is on track, identify any issues or risks, and make
necessary adjustments to the project plan.
7. How would you identify and assess the impact of the new data privacy regulation
risk? (A)
Identify the risk by staying informed about regulatory changes and consulting legal
experts if needed. Assess the impact on project timelines, data handling practices, and
compliance requirements.
IFETCE-R 2019 Academic year 2024-2025
8. Write about staff time. . (U)
The staff time booked to a project indicates the work carried out and the charges to the
project. It does not, however, tell the project manager what has been produced or whether
tasks are on schedule.
It is therefore common to adapt or enhance existing accounting data collection systems to
meet the needs of project control. Weekly timesheets, for example, are frequently adapted
by breaking jobs down to activity level and requiring information about work done in
addition to time spent
Visualizing progress and cost monitoring
9. A project has a budget of $100,000. After two months, you find the following
expenditures: (A)
Planned Budget: $50,000
Actual Expenditure: $60,000
Calculate the budget variance and explain its implications for the project.
Planned Budget (PV): $50,000
Actual Expenditure (AC): $60,000
Budget Variance (BV): BV = PV - AC = $50,000 - $60,000 = -$10,000
The project is over budget by $10,000.
This indicates that costs are higher than planned, potentially impacting resource
allocation and future budgeting decisions.
It may necessitate corrective actions such as revising spending plans, reallocating
resources, or negotiating costs with vendors.
11. Distinguish between Earned Value Analysis and Earned Value Management (U)
Earned Value Analysis Earned Value Management
EVA is a quantitative technique used to EVM uses EVA as one of its tools, but is
evaluate project performance by analyzing larger in scope
schedule and cost variances
EVA stops with the compute portion EVM is all about using that data in trends
analysis and forecasting.
EVA is a technique focused specifically on EVM is a broader management
performance measurement. methodology that encompasses EVA along
with other management processes.
EVA is used for periodic analysis of EVM is used for overall project control,
project performance. integrating planning, measurement,
forecasting, and management.
IFETCE-R 2019 Academic year 2024-2025
12. What are the levels of prioritizing monitoring? (R)
Prioritizing monitoring in software project monitoring and control involves establishing
different levels of priority to ensure that the most critical aspects of the project receive
appropriate attention
Critical, High, Medium, Low, Deferred
13. Differentiate Budgeted cost of work scheduled and Budgeted cost of work
performed. (U)
Budgeted cost of work scheduled Budgeted cost of work performed
BCWS represents the planned value of the BCWP, also known as Earned Value (EV),
work scheduled to be completed by a represents the budgeted cost of the work
specific point in time. that has actually been completed by a
specific point in time
BCWS is used to establish a baseline BCWP is used to assess how much of the
against which actual progress can be planned work has been completed and to
measured. compare it with the planned schedule
(BCWS) and actual cost (AC).
BCWS is calculated by summing the BCWP is calculated by summing the
budgeted costs for all the tasks that are budgeted costs for all the tasks that have
scheduled to be completed by a certain date been actually completed by a certain date.
Formula: BCWS = Σ (Planned Cost of Formula: BCWP = Σ (Planned Cost of
Scheduled Tasks) Completed Tasks)
16. The Slip chart indicates that the current rate of task slippage is 2 days per week. If
the project is 10 weeks long and is currently at week 5, how much longer will the
project take to complete if the slippage rate continues? (A)
Remaining Duration: 5 weeks
Slippage Rate: 2 days per week
Total Additional Days: 5 weeks * 2 days/week = 10 days
Extended Completion Time: 10 days beyond the original schedule
IFETCE-R 2019 Academic year 2024-2025
The project will take an additional 10 days to complete beyond the original end date.
17. Compare and contrast Ball chart and Gantt chart. (U)
Ball chart Gantt chart
18. You have three teams (Team A, Team B, Team C) working on different projects. A
Ball chart represents the workload (X-axis) vs. efficiency (Y-axis) with the size of the
balls indicating the number of team members. (A)
20. How the Pareto chart is used? Why is it called as 80-20 rule? (A)
A Pareto chart is a special example of a bar chart. For a Pareto chart, the bars are ordered
by frequency counts from highest to lowest. These charts are often used to identify areas
to focus on first in process improvement.
The 80-20 rule, also known as the Pareto Principle, is a familiar saying that asserts that
80% of outcomes (or outputs) result from 20% of all causes (or inputs) for any given
event.
IFETCE-R 2019 Academic year 2024-2025
22. How EVA is used to measure the performance of the Organisation? (R)
EVA is the incremental difference in the rate of return (RoR) over a company's cost of
capital. Essentially, it is used to measure the value a company generates from funds
invested in it. If a company's EVA is negative, it means the company is not generating
value from the funds invested into the business.
23. A project with a BAC of $500,000 has reached its completion. The EV is $500,000,
and the AC is $450,000. What can you infer from these values, and what are the
final CPI and CV? (A)
Cost Performance Index (CPI): CPI = EV / AC = $500,000 / $450,000 = 1.11
Cost Variance (CV): CV = EV - AC = $500,000 - $450,000 = $50,000
25. What is cost variance (CV) and schedule variance (SV)? (U)
The schedule and cost variance formulas are expressed as follows: Schedule Variance
(SV) = Earned Value (EV) - Planned Value (PV) Cost Variance (CV) = Earned Value
(EV) - Actual Cost (AC)
Cost variance (also referred to as CV) is the difference between project costs estimated
during the planning phase and the actual costs.
Schedule Variance (or SV) is a metric that shows whether a project is ahead or behind
schedule. It is used in conjunction with Earned Value Management (EVM) to help project
managers monitor the schedule and cost of the project.
26. A project has a total budget (Budget at Completion, BAC) of $100,000. After two
months, the Planned Value (PV) is $40,000, the Earned Value (EV) is $35,000, and
the Actual Cost (AC) is $50,000. Calculate the Schedule Variance (SV), Cost
Variance (CV), Schedule Performance Index (SPI), and Cost Performance Index
(CPI). What do these values indicate about the project's performance? (A)
Schedule Variance (SV): SV = EV - PV = $35,000 - $40,000 = -$5,000
Cost Variance (CV): CV = EV - AC = $35,000 - $50,000 = -$15,000
Schedule Performance Index (SPI): SPI = EV / PV = $35,000 / $40,000 = 0.875
IFETCE-R 2019 Academic year 2024-2025
Cost Performance Index (CPI): CPI = EV / AC = $35,000 / $50,000 = 0.7
27. After three months, a project manager finds that the EV is $120,000, the PV is
$150,000, and the AC is $140,000. The BAC is $300,000. What corrective actions
might the project manager consider based on the EVA metrics? (A)
Schedule Variance (SV): SV = EV - PV = $120,000 - $150,000 = -$30,000
Cost Variance (CV): CV = EV - AC = $120,000 - $140,000 = -$20,000
Schedule Performance Index (SPI): SPI = EV / PV = $120,000 / $150,000 = 0.8
Cost Performance Index (CPI): CPI = EV / AC = $120,000 / $140,000 = 0.857
28. Your timeline chart for a project includes several milestones: (A)
Initial Planning: January 15
Design Phase Completion: February 28
Development Phase Completion: April 15
Testing Phase Completion: May 31
Final Review and Launch: June 30
If the Design Phase is delayed by two weeks, how will this affect the subsequent
milestones?
Initial Planning: January 15 (no change)
Design Phase Completion: February 28 → March 14 (delayed by two weeks)
Development Phase Completion: April 15 → April 29 (shifted accordingly)
Testing Phase Completion: May 31 → June 14 (shifted accordingly)
Final Review and Launch: June 30 → July 14 (shifted accordingly
All subsequent milestones will be delayed by two weeks to accommodate the delay in the
Design Phase.
29. Name the popular visual tools used for monitoring and tracking the project
progress. (A)
Network Diagrams.
Critical Path Method or CPM
Gantt Chart
PERT Chart
Project Management Software for Calendar
Change Control
30. You are leading a construction project to build a new residential complex. During
the project execution, unforeseen weather conditions delay the foundation work.
Explain how change control can mitigate risks associated with schedule delays and
cost overruns. (A)
IFETCE-R 2019 Academic year 2024-2025
Impact Assessment: The first step is to assess the impact of the weather delay on the
project schedule and budget. This involves understanding how the delay affects
subsequent construction activities, critical path timelines, and resource availability.
Change Request Initiation: Initiate a formal change request to document the delay and
its impact on the project. This includes detailing the revised project schedule, adjustments
needed in resource allocation, and any additional costs incurred due to the delay.
Evaluation and Approval: Necessity ,Feasibility, Cost Implications
PART- B
Slip chart – visual indication of activities that are not progressing to schedule.
Alternative view of Gantt chart by providing a visual indication of those activities
which are not on schedule. The more bend in the greater the variation in the project
plan. If the slip line deviates more towards the non achievement of project objectives
then it has to be reconsidered. Additional slip lines can be included at regular
intervals.
Ball charts – way of showing or not targets have been met or not. It is represented in
the form of circles that indicate the start and the end point completion of activities.
Circles of the ball chart mostly contain only two dates the original and the revised
one. An activity is denoted by a red circle and green color denotes that the activity is
ahead of its schedule. Slippage in the project completion date but it is overcome by
the timeline charts.
Gantt Chart
Theprogressreportsoftheactivityarenormallyrepresentedasashadedactivitybar
which indicates the percentage of activity completion.
Additionalsliplinescanbeincludedatregularintervalsastheyarebuild
provides the project manager a clear idea about the projects progress.
Ball Chart Technique
Ballchartsarerepresentedintheformofcirclesthatindicatethestartandt
heendpointcompletion of activities.
Initially,thecirclescontaintheoriginalscheduleddatesandwhenrevisi
onsaredone,theseconddates are introduced inside the circle until the
activity is started or completed.
Circles of bar chart will at most contain only two dates the original
and the revised one or the original and the actual dates.
Ball charts are pictorially shown as below:
IFETCE-R 2019 Academic year 2024-2025
BallChart
An activity is denoted by a red circle (colored darker in the figure)
when the start and the end dates are later than the target dates whereas
green circle (colored lighter in the figure)denotes that the activity is ahead
of its schedule.
The color to the circles reminds the project team about the status of each
activity.
In general, all the three types of chart techniques do not show
clearly the slippage in the project completion date for the project lifecycle.
This is overcome by timeline charts
Timeline chart
The timeline chart is useful both during the execution of a project and as part of
the post-implementation review. Analysis of the timeline chart, and the reasons
for the changes, can indicate failures in the estimation process or other errors that
might, with that knowledge, be avoided in future.
Heatmaps:
Heatmaps use color gradients to represent data values across a matrix. In project
management, they can show resource utilization, task priorities, or risk severity.
Benefits: Offers a quick visual summary of where attention or action is needed most
urgently based on predefined criteria. Highlights outliers or areas of concern.
Burndown Charts:
Benefits: Indicates if the project is on track to finish within the estimated timeframe.
IFETCE-R 2019 Academic year 2024-2025
Helps in predicting project completion based on current progress rates.
2 Explain in detail about Earned Value Analysis and also list the various parameters 16 R
. used for EVA.
Earned Value Analysis involves comparing the planned performance of a project (as
per the baseline) against actual performance to determine variances and forecast
future performance. It integrates three key elements: Planned Value (PV), Earned
IFETCE-R 2019 Academic year 2024-2025
Value (EV), and Actual Cost (AC).
Earned Value Analysis uses several parameters to measure project performance and
calculate variances:
3 During a routine project review, you identify a potential risk related to supplier 16 A
. delays in delivering critical materials. How would you report this risk to
stakeholders and propose contingency plans to minimize its impact on project
timelines?
During the routine project review, identify and document the risk of supplier delays in
delivering critical materials. Assess the potential impact of these delays on project
timelines, milestones, and overall project objectives.
Nature of the Risk: Describe the specific supplier delays and their potential causes
(e.g., production issues, logistics challenges).
Probability and Severity: Assess the likelihood of the delays occurring and the
severity of their impact on project deliverables.
Root Causes: Identify any underlying reasons contributing to the supplier delays to
provide context for stakeholders.
Stakeholder Communication:
Clearly articulate the implications of the supplier delays on project schedules and
milestones, ensuring stakeholders understand the severity and urgency of the
situation.
Mitigation Strategies:
Alternative Suppliers: Identify backup suppliers or vendors who can provide similar
critical materials within the required timeframe.
Outline actionable steps and responsibilities for implementing each contingency plan.
Assign roles to team members responsible for monitoring supplier communications
and executing alternative sourcing strategies if necessary.
Estimate the additional costs and resource requirements associated with implementing
contingency plans. Provide a cost-benefit analysis to justify the proposed strategies
and ensure alignment with project budget constraints.
Timeline Adjustment:
4 (ii) During the development phase of a software project, you discover that the cost of 8 A
hiring additional developers is higher than initially budgeted. This is due to an
unforeseen increase in market rates for skilled developers. How would you handle
this unexpected increase in resource costs to ensure the project remains within
budget?
Review Current Budget: Analyze the current budget to understand how the
IFETCE-R 2019 Academic year 2024-2025
increased cost affects the overall project budget.
Identify the Shortfall: Calculate the difference between the initially budgeted
amount and the new, higher cost for hiring additional developers.
2. Reallocate Resources
Identify Non-Critical Areas: Look for areas within the project where funds
can be reallocated without impacting critical deliverables. This may include
non-essential features or phases that can be deferred.
Optimize Resource Utilization: Evaluate if existing team members can take
on additional responsibilities to reduce the need for hiring extra developers.
3. Negotiate Rates
Revise Budget: Update the project budget to reflect the new costs and
reallocated funds.
Adjust Schedule: Make necessary adjustments to the project schedule to
accommodate changes in resource allocation and timelines.
Baseline Documentation: Ensure all changes are documented and baselines
are updated to reflect the revised budget and schedule.
Creating the baseline budget: This is the first stage in setting up EVA. This budget is
based on the project plan. It predicts the earned value through time. Normally, it is
measured in person hours or workdays, for example: in a software development
project.
Monitoring Earned Value: The second stage is monitoring the earned value as the
project progresses. This is achieved by monitoring the completion of each task.
Actual cost(AC) is the actual cost of each task and it can be analyzed and collected.
Schedule Variance(SV): This is the third stage which is measured in cost as EV-PV
which is the deviation between planned work and completed work.
EV=35000
SV=35000-40000 = -5000
Here the calculated SV value is negative and hence we conclude that the project is
behind the original schedule.
Time variance(TV): The difference between the current time and the time when the
achievement of the earned value was planned to occur.
Cost Variance(CV): This value is the difference between the actual cost and the
earned value. Using this value we can estimate the accuracy of the original cost
scheduled for the project. If the CV values are found to be negative, we conclude the
project is over cost.
Definition: The budgeted cost for the work actually completed by a specific
date.
Purpose: Measures the value of work performed in terms of the budget
assigned to it.
Definition: The actual cost incurred for the work completed by a specific
date.
Purpose: Tracks the real expenditures for work done.
Formula:
o Typical formula: EAC=BAC×ACEVEAC = BAC \times
\frac{AC}{EV}EAC=BAC×EVAC
o Alternative formula: EAC=AC+(BAC−EV)EAC = AC + (BAC -
EV)EAC=AC+(BAC−EV)
Purpose: Forecasts the total cost of the project at completion based on current
performance.
Planning:
Establish Baselines: Define the project scope, schedule, and budget. Create
detailed plans for how the project will be executed, monitored, and controlled.
Set Objectives and KPIs: Determine the key performance indicators (KPIs)
and project milestones that will be used to measure project progress and
success.
(ii) Describe a scenario where effective cost monitoring led to project success. 8 U
Initial Challenges: During the initial phases of the project, the project
manager and team identified several challenges:
1. Cost Control: Effective monitoring allowed the project team to keep costs
within the approved budget despite initial market uncertainties and scope
adjustments.
2. Timely Decision-Making: Early identification of cost variances enabled the
team to make informed decisions swiftly, minimizing the financial impact on
the project.
3. Adherence to Timeline: By managing costs effectively, the project
maintained progress according to the revised schedule, ensuring timely
completion.
4. Client Satisfaction: Transparent communication and proactive cost
management strategies enhanced client trust and satisfaction. The client
appreciated the project's adherence to financial constraints without
compromising quality.
SOLUTION
IFETCE-R 2019 Academic year 2024-2025
GIVEN,
BAC= 900000, AC = 100000
PV = planned completion % * BAC
= 15% * 900000
= 15/100 * 900000
=135000
EV = actual completion % * BAC
= 10% * 900000
= 10 / 100 * 900000
= 90000
CPI = EV / AC
= 90000 / 100000
= 0.9
SPI = EV / PV
= 90000/ 135000
= 0.67
0.67 * 60
= 40 mins
ii) Assume you are project manager and you are asked to compute EVA for project 8 A
contains 20 tasks. The project schedule indicates15 tasks should have been
completed, due to continuous change requests 9 tasks are completed by the defined
dead line. Assume the actual cost of work performed is 50 dollar. Calculate the values
of schedule performance index, schedule variance, cost performance index, cost
variance, percent scheduled for completion and percent complete. The following
scheduling data (in person days) are available.
1 8 6.5
IFETCE-R 2019 Academic year 2024-2025
2 12 14
3 10 13
4 5.5 7.5
5 13 9
6 10.5 8.5
7 12 11.5
8 7 8
9 9.5 8
10 8 -
11 7 -
12 9 -
13 12 -
14 7 -
15 12 -
16 10 -
17 5 -
18 9.5 -
19 7 -
20 13 -
SOLUTION:
GIVEN
Scheduled tasks= 15,
Completed tasks= 9,
Actual cost of work performed= 50 dollar
From that Tabular column,
BCWP= Sum of actual effort of completed tasks
= 86
Recovery Planning
2. Corrective Actions
Corrective actions are applied when immediate and focused interventions are needed
to address specific issues impacting project performance. They are often employed
for addressing isolated or urgent issues that, if left unattended, could escalate and
project success.
In practice, these two strategies are often integrated and complement each other in
project management:
ii)AssumeYou are managing a project which is into six months of its execution. You 8 A
are now reviewing the project status and you have ascertained that project is behind
schedule. The actual cost of Activity A is 2,00,000 and that of Activity B is
1,00,000. The planned value of these activities are 1,80,000 and 80,000 respectively.
The Activity A is 100% complete. However, Activity B is only 75% complete.
Calculate the schedule performance index and cost performance index of the project.
SOLUTION
Since we have percentage completion data of each activity we can calculate the
earned value. In order to calculate earned value of each activity multiply %
completion and the planned value. Therefore, 100% x 1,80,000 = 1,80,000 and 75% x
80,000 = 60,000/-
Actual Cost
Tasks Planned Value (PV) % Completion Earned Value
(AC)
Activity A ₹ 1,80,000 ₹ 2,00,000 100% ₹ 1,80,000
Activity B ₹ 80,000 ₹ 1,00,000 75% ₹ 60,000
Now, calculate the cumulative data for the period. Thereafter add planned value,
actual costs and earned value of both the activities.
Tasks Planned Value (PV) Actual Cost (AC) % Completion Earned Value
Activity A ₹ 1,80,000 ₹ 2,00,000 100% ₹ 1,80,000
Activity B ₹ 80,000 ₹ 1,00,000 75% ₹ 60,000
Cumulative ₹ 2,60,000 ₹ 3,00,000 – ₹ 2,40,000
IFETCE-R 2019 Academic year 2024-2025
Since both SPI and CPI are less than one, the project is behind schedule and is
experiencing cost overrun.