The Structural Engineer January 2025
The Structural Engineer January 2025
President’s
end-of-term report
Designing bamboo
connections
Reimagining
a project brief
A way out
of the woods?
How real-world examples of regenerative practice
are pointing our industry to a brighter future
Feature
16 One hundred years of progress: Midland
10
Counties Regional Group centenary
Climate action
19 Structural Engineers Declare: collectively
making an impact
20 A project reimagined: the questions I wished I
had asked
Professional guidance
24 A new Eurocode, EN 1994-1-102, for
composite dowel shear connectors
28 CROSS Safety Alert: Smoke vents rendered
inoperable by building work
Technical
30 Design of a connection with metal plates and
screws in natural bamboo – worked example
30
Opinion
36 Viewpoint: Regenerative design – disrupting
the industry
January 2025
40 Verulam
42 Book review: Designing zero carbon
buildings: embodied and operational
emissions in achieving true zero
At the back
43 Spotlight on Structures
Issue 1
HAZEL HILL WOOD © IAN POOLE
44 Diary dates
46 Regional focus
48 Services directory
50 TheStructuralEngineer Jobs
Volume 103
24
3
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
PRESIDENT
Mohamad Al-Dah
CEng, FIStructE
CHIEF EXECUTIVE
Yasmin Becker
EDITORIAL
HEAD OF PUBLISHING
Lee Baldwin
MANAGING EDITOR
Robin Jones
t: +44 (0) 20 7201 9822
e: [email protected]
EDITORIAL ENQUIRIES
Will Brown
t: +44 (0) 20 7201 9121
e: [email protected]
ADVERTISING
Robin Jones Managing Editor
DISPLAY SALES
t: +44 (0) 1223 378025
e: [email protected]
Reasons for
RECRUITMENT SALES
t: +44 (0) 1223 378045
e: [email protected]
DESIGN
CPL One SENIOR DESIGNER
optimism
James Baldwin
PRODUCTION
CPL One PRODUCTION EDITOR
Amy Bennett
5
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
Institution news
Industry news IStructE issues guidance on structural submissions for
New web platform examines Gateways 2 and 3
the future of timber The Institution of Structural Engineers has complies with Building Regulations.
As the construction industry looks to published technical guidance on preparing ‘Each Gateway must be passed before a
low-carbon solutions, timber is gaining the structural aspects of Gateways 2 and 3 development can proceed to the next stage.
popularity as a renewable material. But submissions for higher-risk buildings (HRBs) This is therefore important guidance as in
with growing demand for wood, there is a under the Building Safety Act. the UK approx. 2000 HRBs are constructed
need to protect our forests and plant more Created with leading authors from industry, annually – buildings at least seven storeys/18m,
trees to provide material, sequester carbon including Arup and Aecom, Structural and containing at least two residential units.
and enhance biodiversity. submissions for higher-risk buildings under There is also an existing stock of 12 500 HRBs
Evolving Forests, with support from the Building Safety Act: guidance for for which new construction
the timber supply chain and funding Gateways 2 and 3 details works need approval.’
from Built by Nature, the Forestry the statutory framework The guide covers numerous
Commission, Scottish Forestry Trust and for such submissions interlinked aspects of the
Egger, has been investigating whether for both new-build and Gateways 2 and 3 submission
forest conservation and timber use can in-scope work to existing stages, such as the statutory
truly coexist. HRBs, and provides framework, legal issues,
The result is a new web platform recommendations on recommended content, quality
featuring film, audio and articles content. control and compliance, and
exploring this crucial question. Topics Patrick Hayes, the possible impact on design
covered include: IStructE’s Technical and procurement practices.
| bioregionalism Director and one of the
| investment authors, said: ‘This is a The guidance is
| species critical process, so this available to buy from
| radical realism guide supports structural the IStructE bookshop at
| responsibility. engineers to prepare www.istructe.org/
Gateways 2 and 3 resources/guidance/
Find out more at www.evolvingforests. submissions. These must structural-submissions-for-
com/future-of-timber. verify that a building design higher-risk-buildings/.
Industry news
New viability tool to
Industry news
facilitate building upwards
with timber New study reveals pathways to close ‘carbon gap’ in UK concrete
A pan-European consortium of
production
developers, designers and engineers has A recently released scoping study from the such as e cient use of concrete and reducing
launched a platform to accelerate the Lower Carbon Concrete Group (LCCG) and clinker content can kickstart progress, the
practice of extending buildings vertically Climate Group’s ConcreteZero initiative highlights report underscores that urgent, concerted and
using bio-based materials. viable solutions to close the ‘carbon gap’ in coordinated action across the sector is essential
Known as ‘Optoppen’ – a Dutch UK concrete production by the early to mid- to fully close the carbon gap.
term translating as ‘topping up’ – the 2030s. Concrete production is responsible for Welcoming the report, IStructE Head of
development method takes advantage around 8% of global CO2 emissions, making Climate Action, Will Arnold, said: ‘This timely
of the spare loadbearing capacity of the decarbonising the industry an urgent priority. report from ConcreteZero and the LCCG
majority of existing buildings in Europe: Led by Bruce Martin MIStructE, Associate highlights what many in the industry already
additional storeys can be added using Director at Expedition Engineering, the study know: concrete production is not decarbonising
lightweight timber. defines the carbon gap as the difference at the pace required to align with the UK’s
The platform hosts case studies, between projected emissions from concrete net-zero laws. The report clearly demonstrates
policy information and a brand-new production and a Paris-aligned pathway to net that while it is technically and financially viable
viability tool. Built by Mule Studio and zero that is outlined in to accelerate decarbonisation
based on Whitby Wood’s structural the UK government’s back up to pace, this will need
calculations, the tool allows users to easily Industrial Decarbonisation the concrete industry to pull all
and quickly assess which buildings can be Strategy. Focusing the levers at once.’
extended, and by how much, with a figure on the embodied The findings of the report are
for the carbon emissions stored in the carbon of concrete, the also likely to be applicable to
additional floors. study explores several concrete markets beyond the
Supported by network and grant- measures to significantly UK, making it relevant reading
making fund, Built by Nature, and led reduce emissions. for IStructE members across
by engineering consultancy Whitby The analysis identifies the globe.
Wood, the project team in the UK, the the concept of ‘Goldilocks
Netherlands and Spain has brought years pathways’ – viable Download the report at
of experience working on both residential routes to achieving www.theclimategroup.
and o ce-space Optoppen pro ects. net-zero emissions that org/our-work/news/report-
balance current best study-unveils-key-
Access the Optoppen platform at practices with innovative solutions-close-carbon-
www.optoppen.org. technological advances. gap-uk-concrete-
While existing solutions production.
6
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
CARES Ad-Feb
pp06-07 2024-Structural Engineer-Editorial.indd
TSE_Jan25_News.indd 7 1 16/02/2024 16:45
18/12/2024 09:35
Upfront News
Institution news
Institution news IStructE releases critical safety guidance for design of reinforced
IStructE seeks test case concrete transfer slabs
examples for structural A group of structural engineering experts led consistency in the design approaches adopted
safety cases by the Institution of Structural Engineers has for transfer slabs. Industry should be pushing
The Institution is aiming to issue guidance compiled a new guide to help building designers, for designers, contractors and assessors to
for members early in 2025 on structural contractors and assessors better understand the understand the inherent complexities, safety
input into safety cases for higher-risk complexities of transfer slabs. implications, and sustainability issues of adopting
buildings under the Building Safety Design of transfer slabs has been created this construction method.
Act. We wish to include anonymised by AECOM, the IStructE, MPA The Concrete Patrick Hayes, Technical Director at IStructE,
case studies in the guidance and invite Centre, and Imperial College London, with said: ‘At present, there is no industry-wide
members willing to share their experiences technical reviews provided by Buro Happold and guidance for the design of a transfer slab,
in preparing safety case reports, including Simpson TWS. The guide is intended for the especially for punching shear. To do this work
any feedback they have received on their design of new transfer slabs. The assessment of successfully, an engineer needs to have a great
proposals, to get in touch. All information existing slabs is not covered. understanding of the behaviours of concrete,
will be anonymised. It provides guidance on how column shears interact,
concept design, design for disproportionate collapse, and
To share your experiences, please robustness, and suitable construction se uence effects. It s a
contact [email protected]. methods for the assessment complex process.
of punching shear in transfer e ve therefore worked together
slabs. The recommended with industry on this guide to fill
Institution news punching shear assessment a significant knowledge gap in
methods differ significantly the design of reinforced concrete
Opt out of printed copies of
from the methods used in buildings with transfer slabs that has
The Structural Engineer in typical flat slabs. a potentially ma or impact on safety.
your IStructE account Despite being a
The Institution is pleased to now widespread typology, the The guide is free to access
offer members a simple way to opt document suggests that at www.istructe.org/
out of receiving printed copies of The there is currently a lack of resources/guidance/design-of-
Structural Engineer. understanding, robustness and transfer-slabs/.
In response to feedback from members
looking to reduce their carbon footprint, a
new opt-out facility has been created in the Industry news
MyAccount area of the IStructE website. If Entries are open for UK engineering innovation award
you d like to go digital-only, log in to your
account, navigate to Contact preferences The 56th annual MacRobert Award for Dr Alison Vincent CBE FREng, recently
and check the relevant box. If you change UK engineering innovation is open for entries, appointed as Chair of the MacRobert Award
your mind at a later date, you can opt back seeking the best of British engineering innovation judging panel, says: ‘We welcome applications
into print in the same way. for 2025. from all engineering disciplines, companies
The MacRobert Award recognises outstanding of all sizes, to recognises the importance of
Make your choice at engineering innovations developed in the UK engineering innovation in driving economic
www.istructe.org/myaccount. that can demonstrate commercial success and growth and addressing some of the greatest
a tangible benefit to society. The winning team societal challenges.
receives a £50 000 cash prize, the MacRobert Finalists for the award will be announced
Award gold medal, national publicity, and in June 2025, with the winner unveiled at the
an exclusive weekend away at Douneside Academy Awards Dinner in London in July.
House in the heart of the MacRobert estate in
Aberdeenshire. The award is presented and To enter the award, visit https://
run by the Royal Academy of Engineering and macrobertaward.raeng.org.uk/about-
the MacRobert Trust, with support from the the-award/how-to-apply. Entries close on
Worshipful Company of Engineers. Friday 31 January 2025.
Over more than five decades the MacRobert
Award has been remarkably accurate in
ROYAL ACADEMY OF ENGINEERING
8
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
9
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
Reflections on my residency
A year of collective
engineering with purpose
ways around the world, reminding us of the
power we hold when we come together for the
greater good. This collective effort has sparked
important conversations, influenced practice,
A A E OO and demonstrated the leadership role structural
CEng, FIStructE engineers can play in addressing societal and
2024 President of The Institution of Structural Engineers environmental challenges.
a turin e cellence
odcasts with old Medallists
A call to action turnin This year, I also had the privilege of helping to
As my year as President draws to a close, I ideas into awareness and action launch a podcast series featuring past old
want to take a moment to thank you for your In anuary, I invited you to oin me in a call Medallists of our Institution. My desire here
support and trust in me as President and to action an invitation to address some of was to capture the human characteristics of
reflect on what we ve accomplished together. the pressing challenges and opportunities these extraordinary engineers, not only because
2024 has been a year of knowledge sharing, of our time, to think bigger about the impact it is incredibly interesting and valuable to learn
collaboration and action (Figure 1). of our work, and to consider how each of from, but because I wanted to create e ual
Together, we have continued to strengthen the us could contribute to a better future for all. access for everybody to hear and be inspired
impact and legacy of the Institution, to support The response was extraordinary. Across our by this impactful group of eminent people.
and gain input from membership, to consolidate global membership, engineers committed to These conversations allowed us to capture
our global standing as technically eminent in meaningful actions, from progressing the impact the stories and insight of some of our most
the structural engineering world, and to create of reducing embodied carbon in construction, accomplished members individuals whose
new paths to broaden access and support more to sharing knowledge on technical development work has shaped the world around us in
members through the whole life of their careers. and emerging trends, and championing demonstrably impactful ways.
I feel incredibly privileged to have served in inclusivity for the benefit of people and our It was inspiring to hear them reflect on their
this role and the achievements we celebrate are planet, at scale (Figure 2). early influences and inspiration, the innovations
not mine alone – they are the outcomes of a hat began as an idea to celebrate the they championed, and the lessons they learned.
shared commitment to our profession, its future, positive impact of structural engineering uickly Most surprising for me was the common thread
and the global communities we serve. gained interest and momentum in diverse that, in their own way, they are all explorers,
both in and out of engineering. Curious,
passionate, seekers of new experiences, who
were all looking for ways to do better, be better,
explore another way.
These podcasts have resonated widely, not
ust as a celebration of excellence but as a
source of learning and inspiration for engineers
and others at all stages of their careers. Through
these stories, we ve connected the remarkable
achievements of the past with the ambitions of
the present and the opportunities of the future.
A big thank you to Paul ast, Chris ise, Mike
Cook, Albert illiamson-Taylor, Dame o Da
Silva and ames Ding for their contributions.
10
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
10 11 25 10 1 /12/2024 10:10
President’s end-of-year report Upfront
BENJ DAVIES
AI, innovation in methods of construction, and
the journey to net-zero-carbon materials, we’ve
delved into the ways our profession can adapt
and innovate to meet current and impending
future challenges.
These conversations have rea rmed the
critical role of engineers as essential leaders
in creating a safe and better built environment
for all.
11
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
10 11 25 11 1 /12/2024 10:10
Upfront News
Institution news
Institution election/transfer/reinstatement lists
12
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
13
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
14
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
HSIEH, Ying-Ching Member (Chartered Member EGBE, Prince Idanemugo Technician (1)
LEWIS, Ben Further Learning) (15) ERDOGDU, Mert Mustafa HILTON, James
MARLOW, Elisabeth Catherine BAUOMY, Akram Fouad FLETCHER, Hamish Donald
MILLS, Caroline Louise CHAN, Ka Hei Thomas Graduate (277)
REYNOLDS, Andrea Kathleen CHAN, Kong Ki FRAINE, William
SAMA, Srinivas CHAU, Kimmy Ka Ki FROST, Patrick John Student (576)
SIEN, Hay Wah Michael DEMBRY, Tom FURMSTON, Mark Andrew
TULLY, Richard IKIN, Jamie GIRLING, David John REINSTATEMENTS
TURPIN, Malcolm Douglas KAN, Kwok Man John GRAY, Samuel Member (9)
WONG, David Pak Sang KONG, Pok Man GULIGA, Nicusor CHAN, Cheuk Ming
LAKE, Kelvin John GURNEY, Richard Anthony Francis DALY, James Francis
Member (49) LAM, Chin Ho HAMBLING, Max FAULKNER, Howard William
AU, Wai Man LAM, Tsz Yan HANNIGAN, Katherine FERRIS, Robert Stephen
BALTZOPOULOS, Demetrios LEE, Ka Man HAZELL, Max LOK, Sang Lee
BOTH, Alexandru Stefan LO, Cheuk Yin HO, Kwing Lok Rod SMITH, Joseph
BUDGE, Daniel Richard LUI, Cheuk Him HO, Pui Chung SPARLING, Daniel Thomas
CAUSER, Craig MANDAL, Dharmendu HUNG, Sing Yi TO, Moon Tong
CHAN, Chau Wong INGRAM, Grant WONG, Chi Hung
CHAN, Mei Ching Member (Incorporated-Member KARAKOULLIS, Nicholas Jason
CHAN, Pak Him Bridging Route) (2) KHAN, Haris Mohammed Graduate (40)
CHENG, WAI LIM WILLIAM CHAPPELL, Matthew KIRAN, K M
CHEUNG, Hok Kan POWELL, Jack KOMALAVALLY, Shalini Madhu Student (1)
CHEUNG, Yu Tat KRISHNAMURTHY, Kumaran
CHIU, Wing Shan Member (Chartered Member KUROKAWA, Issei RESIGNATIONS
EPITA KADUWA GAMAGE, Yamuna MRA) (7) LARGAIOLLI, Federica The Membership Committee
Kanthi ARBUTHNOTT, Edmund LAW, Shing Cheong has accepted, with regret, the
GOCK, Ka Chun Alan CHEUNG, Hok Kun LAZAROU, Stavros following resignations:
HUGHES, Conor LO, Leong Hin LYNN, Ciaran
INBARAJ HEPZHIBAI, Peter MARTIN HERRERO, Ester MAIN, Samuel Fellow (7)
JERRY, Thomas SANKARAN, Mahesh MARGRAVE-JONES, Samuel Rhys ADAMS, Alfrico Deloy
KAO, Kwan WALSH, Dwain MARTINEZ, Jonny Alexander BROHN, David Malcolm
KARUVATTIL, Sajeeb ZENG, Yu MILEHAM, Scott Andrew Sexton DORBER, Peter Alan
KEI, Ho Pang MODASIA, Jayan JACKSON, Edward John
KONG, Ka Chun Member (Research and MOORE, Sebastian Giles PATES, John Henry
KOREN, Matthew Josef Development) (2) MUHAMMAD, Zandy SO, Yau Chi
KRUZ, Mary Sornarani AUGUSTHUS NELSON, NABI, Hussain TOWNSEND, Gerald Hughes
KWOK, Tsz Hin Levingshan NGUYEN, Michael
LAI, Chun Ngai KECHIDI, Smail NIXON, Henry Oliver Member (3)
LEE, Anthony Chak Fung NYAGOLOVA, Yordanka CATHCART, John Pringle
LEUNG, Ka Yu Incorporated-Member (4) PARRY, Alexander PILCHER, Barry
LEUNG , Tsz Lok EVANS, Nigel PETKUNE, Natalja POLLARD, David
LI, Yuyang GILLIES, James Richard REHMAN, Abdul
LIANG, Kyle OWENS, David Edward ROTHWELL, Conor Peter Gingles Graduate (18)
MA, Hin Fung SMITH, Aaron Luke SAVILLE, Mark
MATEJKO, Grzegorz SEKANINA, David DEATHS
MCCONVILLE, Shaun Associate (Standard) (74) SHETTY KONDADI, Hamsaraj The deaths of the following are
MCLEAN, Caroline Irene AHMAD, Abdul Fateh SMIT, Talita reported with regret:
NG, Tik San AL-KWATLY AYUSO, Ismael SNOOK, Harry Paul
PEET, Samuel Richard ASHRAF, Haroon SO, Ka Man Fellow (5)
RAJAMPETA, Bhanu Kumar ASIF, Rizwan Saeed STANCHEV, Hristo Hristov BLACKBURN, Keith Chalkley
READING, Jimmy AUGER, Samuel Henry Ross THEONAS, Apostolos FOOT, Royston Eric
RUTHERFORD, James BARNISKYTE, Ieva THIERS MOGGIA, Rodrigo HUGHES, Barry Peter
SREENATH, N D BELL, Thomas Roger TONG, Chun Kit HARYOTT, Richard Baskcomb
TRUEMAN, Samuel BLACKIE, Andrew Robert WEST, Matthew James MACLEOD, Iain Alasdair
UNG, Hoi-Leng BONCIO, Simone WIERZCHOWSKI, Przemyslaw
WAN, Yiu Ho BROWN, Thomas WOOD, David Anthony Member (1)
WONG, Cho Chun BUCHAN, Gordon WOOD, James Michael George RIVETT, John Martin
YANG, Shijia CHAN, Ngai ZHU, Lin
YEUNG, Chong Kuen CHAN, Wai To Incorporated-Member (1)
YU, Ji Tung CHAU, Hiu Fung Kelvin Associate (International SCOUGALL, John
YUEN, Hon Lam DE ANDRADE, Paulo Geovane Agreement) (3)
ZHAO, Peng DE GOUVEIA DE GOUVEIA, CHAN, Cho Yiu
Gilberto MAYET, Azhar
DI CORTE, Roberta WAN CHOW WAH, Kevin
15
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
16
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
17
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
FIGURE 6: Midland Counties Regional Group celebrates centenary with IStructE President Tanya de Hoog and Chief Executive Yasmin Becker
18
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
The 2024 UK Structural Engineers a second-hand market for various barrier is the gap in knowledge and
Declare summit, held in October, building materials. creative problem-solving within the
brought together industry leaders, One of the most hopeful themes industry. Structural engineers often
engineers and advocates to from the summit was the evidence of feel constrained by the status quo
address the urgent climate and tangible shifts in industry practices, or hesitant to push for innovative
biodiversity crises, highlighting the from counting embodied carbon solutions that might disrupt it.
role of structural engineers in steering to increasingly using recycled and Furthermore, although the market is
the industry towards a sustainable, reclaimed materials. This gradual shift shifting, regulatory and industry-wide
regenerative future. shows the power of collective action changes are needed to incentivise
Speakers included architect and hints at what can be achieved with regenerative practices fully.
and environmental activist Duncan continued commitment.
Baker Brown, who highlighted the Engineers do indeed have the power Focus for 2025 and beyond
need for designs that contribute to make a substantial difference if Looking ahead to 2025, we urge
proactively to environmental restoration we are dedicated to driving change. structural engineers to prioritise
in response to the climate and Even small steps – like choosing a few critical areas.
ecological emergency, while Dr Mike materials with lower carbon footprints First, adopting net-zero-carbon
Bather of the University of Liverpool or reducing biodiversity loss in minor practices must become the norm
delved into the ethical dimension of ways – can cumulatively make a across all projects, not just ambitious
engineering, reminding attendees meaningful impact. or high-profile ones. Engineers should
that our decisions have far-reaching continue expanding the reuse of
impacts on global communities Challenges ahead existing materials, developing new
affected by climate breakdown. But despite the progress, significant ways to reduce the embodied carbon
A panel on new career pathways challenges remain. Progress is still in structures, and encouraging
emphasised the growing demand happening too slowly to meet the clients to retain and upgrade existing
for engineers with expertise in scale of the crises we face. One key buildings whenever possible, rather
sustainability, demonstrating than demolishing them.
how structural engineers are Furthermore, engineers must
increasingly viewed as leaders in the enhance our influence with clients,
environmental movement. colleagues and stakeholders about
We also learned about new
developments in low-carbon
ADOPTING the impact of design choices on the
environment. Engineers are not just
concrete, the truth about sand and NET-ZERO-CARBON problem-solvers but also advocates for
its ecological and societal impact, PRACTICES MUST change. As such, we can push for the
as well as a case study for the reuse
of timber. This was followed by a
BECOME THE NORM integration of sustainable practices at
every stage of the project life cycle.
session on practical solutions to ACROSS ALL PROJECTS
foster regenerative design, and how Finally
artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming We encourage all structural
decision-making in biodiversity. engineers to join the declaration
Watch the presentations and support the initiative. Please let
Reasons for hope If you d like to nd out more
us know how you can contribute at
Many attendees are already [email protected].
about the discussions at the
measuring embodied carbon on
2024 summit, you can watch the
most of their projects, but the
presentations on the IStructE
consensus was that there is room to
website at www.istructe.org/
go further. For instance, there is now a Diego Padilla-Philipps, Gary Elliott and
resources/training/structural-
greater emphasis on reusing materials Rosie Camburn are co-chairs of UK
engineers-declare-summit-2024/.
where possible – using second-hand Structural Engineers Declare
steel, reusing stone, and creating (www.structuralengineersdeclare.com).
19
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
Case study
A project reimagined:
the questions I wished I
had asked
Having attended the Institution’s ‘Net-zero structural design’ course, Ruth Eve revisits a
previous project to examine how her new understanding of the hierarchy of net-zero design
could have unlocked carbon savings if the right questions had been asked at the right time.
Introduction can show us how to reduce the embodied understanding as to whether or not a design
I like to think that as engineers we always carbon of our designs. But with so much is good .
strive to build clever: aiming for least weight guidance out there, where is the best place to It s easy to feel a bit like the villain once we
(or use less stuff ) is a basic design principle. start And what if your pro ect is already under calculate our material volumes and carbon
I have always instinctively supported way? emissions. Even when we ve developed our
refurbishment pro ects, and aspired to find e now all recognise that, like safety, schemes in the least impactful way, we re still
ways to use recycled and reclaimed materials sustainability must be incorporated into our left responsible for the release of hundreds or
where possible. As engineers, we also all designs from inception. e know that working thousands of tonnes of carbon each year (a
know how to collaborate and support our through schemes and materials options for single new house can emit between 50t and
clients and professional colleagues to achieve pro ects, and doing the maths on embodied 100t of CO2).
such technical re uirements. carbon, is not only important, but is getting
But as the depth and breadth of the climate quicker and easier as we all become more A wider perspective
emergency reveals itself to us all, and the familiar with the argon. But while calculating hen I recently attended the Institution s
carbon reduction clock runs down (Figure 1)1, and specifying low-impact options is Net-zero structural design training course
construction remains one of the world s most important, it is a relatively small slice of the (which I highly recommend; see www.istructe.
impactful industries, with more urgent action triangular-shaped pie (Figure 2). Calculating org/events for details), I had something of
clearly needed. There is an abundance of carbon does not produce low-carbon an engineering epiphany. It came about
guidance, technical papers and courses that solutions in of itself, but it does change our when we applied the Institution s so-called
20
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
21
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
how easy it is to actually ask these questions, with us earlier in the decision-making process,
particularly the more strategic aspects of build allowing us to ask some key questions and
nothing and build less. I know that earlier in
my career I would not have felt empowered
I PONDER OVER make alternative proposals. While the biggest
impact can typically be made at early design
enough to ask, and perhaps it feels a bit more HOW BEST TO stages, whatever stage a project is at, there is
than a little impolite to try and influence a client HAVE THESE scope to have a positive influence throughout
in this way with the risk of being deemed a
little too ‘draconian’. I ponder over how best
CONVERSATIONS the project.
Maybe a rhubarb factory in the basement
to have these conversations supportively and SUPPORTIVELY is a wild idea… but perhaps with humility and
to encourage our clients, project manager curiosity we can all find space to ask some
and construction manager colleagues to ‘stupid’ questions, and use our collective
incorporate ‘appropriate time and resources’ – and will they usher them through with ease? expertise and ingenuity to find new ideas
to seeking sustainable outcomes, in the same Or will the mechanics of the process be too that fundamentally change the shape of our
way that they do for their duties to safety under time-consuming? (And will anyone get paid projects for the better.
the Construction (Design and Management) for this?) Nonetheless, I’m still keen to test the
Regulations. The belief that green projects theory, and perhaps have the conversation
are more expensive could be only a lack of anyway to find out what might have been Ruth Eve
understanding about what is achievable. And possible. I’m also excited to promote this BEng(Hons), CEng, MIStructE
the vagaries in assessing and measuring the quick method to my colleagues, internally and
wider benefits. And disadvantages such as externally, because I know that great clients Ruth is a Director of Glanville Consultants in
impact to ecosystems. And perhaps a little bit and design teams will respond positively if we Didcot, UK. She is an experienced structural
of a lack of imagination. can demonstrate an ability to tune into what engineer leading a small team within a small to
I’m also still interested to see whether the they need at the right moment and show them medium-sized multidisciplinary consultancy. Her
planners I interact with will support such what is possible. Maybe then on the next goal is to develop and deliver more sustainable
changes that explicitly target reducing carbon project with the same client, they will engage practices across all teams.
22
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
Ruth
Who is this
Why does the library
displacing in the What other
Build nothing
need to be relocated?
What is happening to new building? buildings
the old library building? Are they going does the
Do we need a library? to a new council own?
building?
Repurpose the
Build less
The existing 4-storey
concrete frame likely roof level or car
has structural capacity park level?
for an extra storey. (Low head room)
efficiently
library less
Introduce support (Reduce ‘attractive’/
columns and lower loading) used less?
the height?
Minimise
waste Entrance cladding
is precast bespoke
concrete – use
something recycled?
1) MCC Carbon Clock [Online] Available at: www. | Climate Change Committee (2020) The Sixth Carbon
mcc-berlin.net/en/research/co2-budget.html (Accessed: Budget: Buildings [Online] Available at: www.theccc.
November 2024) org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/Sector-summary-
Buildings.pdf (Accessed: November 2024)
2) Arnold W. (s.d.) The hierarchy of net-zero design | Di Benedetto D. (2021) ‘Climate jargon buster’, The
[Online] Available at: www.istructe.org/resources/blog/the- Structural Engineer, 99 (6), pp. 10–11; https://doi.
hierarchy-of-net-zero-design/ (Accessed: November 2024) org/10.56330/JKRR9002
3) Halliwell E. (2024) ‘Putting the net-zero hierarchy into | Laidler P. (2021) ‘Measuring carbon – a small practice
practice: Build nothing’, The Structural Engineer, 102 (1), perspective’, The Structural Engineer, 99 (9), pp. 14–18;
pp 10–11; https://doi.org/10.56330/WSKW8501 https://doi.org/10.56330/IRFX7299
| MIT Climate Portal [Online] Available at: https://climate.
4) Hayes C. (2024) ‘Putting the net-zero hierarchy into
mit.edu/ (Accessed: November 2024)
practice: Build less’, The Structural Engineer, 102 (2),
| Orr J.J., Cooke M., Ibell T.J., Smith C.
pp 18–19; https://doi.org/10.56330/MGEK3688
and Watson N. (2022) Design for zero, London:
5) Halliwell E. (2024) ‘Putting the net-zero hierarchy into IStructE Ltd
practice: Build clever, The Structural Engineer, 102 (3), | Watson N. (2024) ‘Measuring carbon in structures –
pp 10–11; https://doi.org/10.56330/WZIY7163 advice for small practices’, The Structural Engineer,
102 (6), pp. 15–17; https://doi.org/10.56330/HQTK6546
6) Moynihan M. (2024) ‘Putting the net-zero hierarchy into
| White M. (2022) ‘Engineering in the climate emergency:
practice: uild e ciently, The Structural Engineer, 102 (11),
doing less, better’, The Structural Engineer, 100 (10),
pp 10–11; https://doi.org/10.56330/GSRU2454
pp. 10–12; https://doi.org/10.56330/MHVF1963
7) Raworth K. (2017) Doughnut economics, London:
Penguin
23
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
A new Eurocode, EN
1994-1-102, for composite
dowel shear connectors
Roger Johnson, Wojciech Lorenc and Wolfgang Kurz provide a brief edge of the steel web, to act as dowels
overview of a new part to Eurocode 4, covering composite dowels, in the slab above.
The use of cut teeth has enabled
which is currently in development for planned publication in 2026. a wide range of beam cross-sections
to be developed. Parts (a) to (e) of
Figure 2 show precast beams with in
Introduction continuous spans up to 55.6m and a situ concrete added later. Such beams
A new part of Eurocode 4, EN 1994-1- multistorey car park, all using beams can be erected side-by-side, or with
102, Composite dowels ( Part 102 ) is with composite dowel connectors. gaps bridged by precast permanent
expected to reach ormal Vote stage Figure 4 shows a 37m span of the formwork for the deck concrete
in 2025, and to be published in 2026. It Elblag bridge, Poland. The end regions overhead. Part (f) shows a double-
defines a composite dowel as a shear of each span have concrete webs composite cross-section for a shallow-
connector cut from hot-rolled steel extending to the bottom flange of the deck railway bridge, cast in situ. Part
sections, plates or bars, and encased steel inverted-T sections. Figure 1 (g) shows a shallow floor cast in situ.
in reinforced concrete to achieve shows two of the steel beams where, Many of these cross-sections enable
composite action’. from left to right, the steel connectors the dowel connectors to be located at
The steel component is usually a will be embedded in a concrete web, a level such that the shear transfer is
steel web plate with teeth cut along will be bars through elongated holes, in a region of low longitudinal tension.
its top edge (Figures 1 and 2), or a and will be embedded in the concrete Inverted-T and I sections are also
separate toothed strip welded to the deck slab. At supports, the web is useful for shallow-floor construction
top flange of a steel I-section. Figure reinforced concrete; at mid-span it is within buildings.
3 shows the teeth (dark-coloured) on entirely steel. The current Eurocode 4 requires
beams of 18m span that will support resistance to beam vertical shear to be
deep metal decking for a composite New types of cross-section provided entirely by the steel web. This
floor slab in a multistorey car park. for brid e dec s and floor is appropriate for sections of type (c).
Where reinforcing bars are used, structures But type (a) needs resistance from both
they are threaded through over-size The first generation of connectors were steel and concrete materials, while type
holes in the steel web of an I-section, of the bar-through-holes type, known (g) is essentially reinforced concrete
as used in shallow-floor construction. as Perfobond eiste and developed in alone. Hence Part 1-102 provides a
This Eurocode has been drafted the 1980s. They were used in a 213m new design method, allowing shear
mainly by the Polish and German span composite bridge in Venezuela. resistance to be shared between
engineers responsible for its many ater, construction was simplified by steel and concrete in any proportion,
innovations1,2. Their publications omitting steel top flanges and replacing for those beams defined as hybrid
describe over 20 bridges with the bars with teeth cut into the top composite members’.
Eurocode EN 1994-1-102
The new Part 1-102 is a little over a
quarter the length of the new EN 1994-
1-1. It allows for further development
24
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
COURTESY OF G. SEIDL
from bars threaded through holes in
the webs of steel beams. Simple rules
for their resistance to shear are given
in Annex I of the next edition of EN
1994-1-1, with more advanced rules in
Annex B of Part 1-102.
All dimensions of a dowel connector
are given as multiples of its wavelength, FIGURE 2: Cross-sections of beams and
which can range from 150 to 500mm deck structures with composite dowel connectors
for dowels eligible for the new Ductility
Category D2 (corresponding to 6mm
slip, as for studs). Its thickness can be Two modes are similar to those for Resistance of a hybrid
between 4 and 40mm, which matches stud shear connectors. The other two section to vertical shear
the thickness of most steel web modes are for pry-out or splitting at A lever arm ZH is determined from
plates. The height of the largest shape adjacent concrete surfaces, for which the stress distribution (elastic or
included in Annex A can be between local reinforcement is specified. Rules plastic) used for resistance to bending.
60 and 200mm. A dowel connector for fatigue strength, using EN 1993-1- The design shear flow vl,Ed,max for
can replace many studs. 9, are given for two of the shapes. both materials in the web is given
Resistance to static longitudinal The rules for global analysis, by vl,Ed,max = VEd / ZH, where VEd is the
shear of a composite dowel shear resistance to bending, and partial shear design vertical shear3.
connector is the least from the four connection consist mainly of references The steel web is designed for
failure modes for which rules are given. to EN 1994-1-1. vl,Ed,max by the method of Eurocode
25
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
COURTESY OF W. LORENC
River at Kraków, Poland.
The cost of extra web reinforcement
and more complex formwork seems
to be offset by saving on steel
consumption. Each of the larger
connectors can replace many studs.
Tendering for some of the bridges
succeeded against more traditional
designs, though these had not been
optimised. There is more concrete and
less steel, so the comparisons also
depend on location.
Roger Johnson
FIGURE 4: lblag bridge, oland (20 )
Roger Johnson is Emeritus Professor
of Civil Engineering at the University of
3. The concrete web is also designed Warwick, UK.
COURTESY OF W. LORENC
for vl,Ed,max, and uses truss action with
stirrups, from Eurocode 2. Typical
stirrups are shown in Figure 5. The Wojciech Lorenc
main stirrups (1) pass through the
dowels and transfer shear to the steel Wojciech Lorenc is Professor of Civil
Tee. They provide the truss action, ngineering at Wroc aw niversity of
which resists the vertical shear in Science and Technology, Poland.
the concrete web. They also provide
resistance to spalling of the concrete
below and beside the dowel. Wolfgang Kurz
There are also confinement stirrups
(2) anchored on each side of the steel Wolfgang Kurz is Professor for Steel
web. They assist the concrete to resist Structures at the University of
the longitudinal force from the dowel. Kaiserslautern-Landau (RPTU),
Each set encloses longitudinal bars Germany.
at its bottom corners. For cross-
sections like type (a) in Figure 2, where
steel webs extend over the whole FIGURE 5: Stirrups for
web height, all vertical shear may be partial-depth concrete web
assigned to the steel webs only.
REFERENCES
orenc W. ur W. and
Seidl . ‘Hybrid steel–
concrete sections for bridges:
efinition and basis for design’, Eng.
Struct., 270, 114902; https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.engstruct.2022.114902
26
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
Conference themes
• Performance-based design
• Risk-based design approaches
The Institution is delighted
• Assessing and managing risks associated
to announce our upcoming with building adaption
hybrid conference, dedicated • Avoiding common design construction errors
to enhancing structural safety • The design build contract: mitigating the
across the built environment. inherent risks
Apply now:
istructe.org/events/hq/2025/structural-safety-risk-management-conference
21687_structural_safety_conference_FP.indd
pp24-27 TSE_January25_Composite dowels Prof1 Guidance.indd 27 11/12/2024 11: 10:15
19/12/2024 2
Professional guidance CROSS Safety Alert
28
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
What is CROSS?
FIGURE 2: Elevation of residential building with AOVs – the AOVs
are indistinguishable from standard windows Collaborative eporting for afer tructures
(C O ) helps professionals to make structures
safer by publishing safety information based
safety) should identify all AOVs and In England, the Responsible Person on the reports it receives and information in the
consideration should be given to under The Fire Safety (England) public domain.
providing temporary signage indicating Regulations 2022 – Regulation 7 is also C O operates internationally in the , ,
that they are to be kept operable and obligated to report faults in essential and ustralasia. ll regions cover structural safety,
clear from obstruction. firefighting e uipment for high-rise while C O - also covers re safety.
Consideration should also be given residential buildings. This includes
by industry to providing permanent, but when e uipment is disabled.
discrete, signage on AOVs. This might
read Automatic Opening Vent do not
obstruct’. This need not interfere with The full CROSS Safety Alert, including
the building’s architecture. links to guidance mentioned, is
Improved training is recommended available on the CROSS website
for all those in the construction industry at www.cross-safety.org/uk/
who work onsite to raise awareness safety-information/cross-safety-
of the existence of AOVs and their fire alert/smoke-vents-rendered-
safety function. inoperable-building-work.
29
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
Design of a connection
with metal plates and
screws in natural bamboo
– worked example
DOMINIKA MALKOWSKA connection methods have been developed over the loss of strength, is especially important for
BSc, MSc, PhD the past decades, but their standardisation structures built in earthquake-prone zones,
Research Associate, University of Bristol; is still quite limited. For more comprehensive which is often where bamboo is used. Since
Project Engineer, Milner Associates, UK information about bamboo design, the reader most failure modes of bamboo members are
is directed to the series published previously in brittle, connections are often the only source
The Structural Engineer (2016–17)3–6. of ductility within a structure. Stiffness is
JAMES NORMAN especially important for structures where too
MEng, PhD, CEng, MICE, FIStructE Bamboo connections much connection slip impacts the ability of
Professor of Sustainable Design, One of the most popular ways to connect the structure to transfer the loads as it was
University of Bristol, UK bamboo culms is to use dowel-type fasteners, designed, e.g. in trusses.
including dowels, bolts, screws, nails and Although standardisation of bamboo is still at
DAVID TRUJILLO similar. This worked example presents a an early stage, recent developments led to the
connection design using screws and metal publication of ISO 22156:2021, which currently
MSc, DIC, PhD, CEng, MIStructE
plates, similar to a common connection is the most comprehensive design standard
Assistant Professor, Coventry University;
method in timber structures. Traditionally, the for bamboo. However, for dowelled-type
Head of Bio-based Materials, Atelier One, UK
use of screws in natural, round bamboo has connections, the standard provides equations
been unpopular due to the risk of splitting. for a single fastener only, which makes the
While splitting is commonly observed in nailed guidance too limited for multiple screws.
Introduction connections due to the increase in tangential Despite the lack of guidance for multiple-
Interest in bamboo has been increasing in stress arising upon the nail insertion, self- fastener connections, ISO 22156:2021 provides
recent years as the construction industry and tapping screws, unlike nails, do not displace a generic method to design a connection using
governments seek ways to reduce their carbon the material but rather cut it out with the values obtained through experimental testing.
footprints in response to climate change, and thread while being drilled in. Also, when The worked example will use an adaptation of
utilising bio-based materials offers a means predrilling is used, most fibres are similarly cut this method, i.e. the design factors provided in
to do so. Bamboo, just like timber, has the and not displaced. the code will be applied to the characteristic
ability to capture and store atmospheric CO2; The use of screws in bamboo connections capacity values, which follow from a design
but, unlike timber, it grows at a high speed, has several benefits. irst, unlike the common guide available in the literature8.
with only about five years re uired for the culm bolted connection combined with mortar The example will cover a perpendicular joint
(bamboo stem) to reach full maturity. infill, connecting with screws is cement-free, consisting of two culms placed orthogonally,
Such rapid growth means that using which means that the connection meets the forming a ‘T’. The ‘stem’ of the T-shaped joint
bamboo construction products can achieve ‘design for disassembly’ principles by allowing will be loaded in tension.
a net cooling effect much faster than with for easy recovery of the elements when the It is important to mention that ISO
timber products1. Therefore, provided the structure is disassembled. 22156:2021 specifies a minimum ductility ratio
bamboo comes from sustainably managed Second, multiple small-diameter screws (the ratio of the experimentally determined
sources, and the structure is designed with (6mm or less), unlike a single bolt (usually ultimate displacement to the yield displacement)
durability in mind, bamboo structures can 9–16mm diameter) in the traditional connection, of 1.25 for any loadbearing structure. For
considerably reduce the anthropogenic carbon enhance robustness against splitting (as connections with screws, this threshold has
footprint compared with other construction required by ISO 22156:20217), i.e. the ability been satisfied for loading parallel to fibre when
methods, especially when transportation of the connection to redistribute load in the certain design principles are followed, as will be
distances are minimised2. case of an unforeseen loss of one or more shown in the worked example.
Typically, bamboo culms are hollow inside individual fasteners due to cracking. Moreover, This method has currently been proven only
and their wall thickness is relatively small. This connections with screws, if designed correctly, for Moso, a common Southeast Asian bamboo
feature, combined with very high anisotropy can be stiffer and more ductile than bolted species, and a limited number of screws.
resulting from most fibres running parallel connections8. However, the example illustrates how, with
to the axis of the stem, significantly hinders Ductility, which is a measure of a structure’s further testing, a more universal set of design
connection design. Despite this, many ability to undergo large deformation before equations could be developed.
30
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
Worked example
Brief
| Screws must be between 3 and 5mm in | The tapered tip of the screw must protrude | Flat plates are allowed as long as the
nominal (outer thread) diameter (Figure 2). to the inside of the culm (no taper in the gap between the plate and bamboo is
| Bamboo wall thickness must be min. 6mm. bamboo wall). The length of the screw under 1mm. For dnom = 4mm, this can
| All types of self-tapping screws can be used must therefore be equal to (or larger than): be achieved with 4no. screws staggered
(screws used typically for wood). steel plate thickness + bamboo thickness across the fibre (a2) at dnom. This means that
| The screw hole in the bamboo may be + tapered tip length. In typical scenarios, a for connections with more than 4 × 4mm
predrilled (optional). screw length of 25mm will su ce. dnom screws, a curved plate is required.
| The screw hole clearance in the plate is | The screw must be fully threaded. Thread | The steel plate can span across bamboo
crucial for stiff connections no more than type (of a self-tapping screw) does not nodes, as long as there is no gap between
0.1mm clearance (between outer thread affect the performance. the plate and bamboo.
and plate hole) is allowed if stiffness is of | The screw head should preferably be of a | Staggering of screws requires each screw
importance. Meeting this requirement may pan button flat type (not countersunk). to be placed on an individual fibre line (no
be di cult in regions where drill bits of | A countersunk head should only be used two screws aligned).
small sizes are di cult to obtain. In such if the screw hole in the plate can be | Generic considerations of corrosion apply
situations, it is recommended to try to countersunk (this can be done in relatively in the same way as in timber structures
match the available screw sizes and drill bit thick plates only). (e.g. stainless steel screws and a mild steel
sizes to pick a combination that will result in | The bamboo internode is not filled plate pose a risk of galvanic corrosion).
the smallest possible clearance. with mortar.
31
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
Design assumptions
The T-shaped oint can be configured in to fibre in the horizontal member is likely to Therefore, options A and B are less viable
various ways, with some examples shown in result in a brittle failure and low capacity9, than option C, where the horizontal culm is
Figure 3. In each case, the connection at the while in configuration B, loading in withdrawal not affected by the screws as it is loaded in
vertical culm exerts loading parallel to fibre, re uires a large number of screws due to low compression perpendicular to fibre due to the
while the loading on the horizontal culm differs. capacity in withdrawal10,11, and the plate must steel plate alone. This implies that design C is
In configuration A, loading perpendicular be stiffened to avoid steel bending failure. the best option.
FIGURE 3:
otential configurations
of T-shaped joint
Choosing option C ( -shaped plate wrapped The listed properties are part of the input and therefore must be assumed at the start
around the horizontal culm Figure 4), the of the design process.
following checks need to be considered:
Steel design assumptions:
| ateral loading parallel to fibre on vertical | Plate:
culm covered in this example | Thickness ts = 1.2mm
| Compression perpendicular to fibre on | Mild steel with minimum yield strength 250MPa (refer to EN 1995-1-1:200412
horizontal culm to be calculated to ISO Table 4.1 for corrosion protection re uirements)
22156:2021 sec. 10.11 not covered in | 4.0mm diameter holes
this example | Screws:
| Tensile, bearing and block shear failure of | Carbon steel (refer to EN 1995-1-1:2004 Table 4.1 for corrosion protection
the steel plate not covered in this example re uirements)
| ully threaded
| Pan head
| Nominal diameter dnom 4mm (e ual to outer thread)
| Root diameter dr = 2.5mm
| Number of screws at each side of the culm n 4 ( screws in total)
| Spacing between screws along fibre a1 = 15dr
| Spacing between screws across fibre a2 = dnom (all screws are staggered)
FIGURE 4:
U-shaped plate wrapped
around horizontal culm
32
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
a1 15d r
a1 / d r 15
dr 2.5mm
ts / d r 0.48
6 .0
FIGURE 5:
Decision tree for
staggered screws
The values obtained from EC5 are comparable to the bamboo equation
value, but they lead to a conservative assumption, with the estimated
strength at least 23% lower than with the bamboo equation.
33
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
EN 1995-1-1:200412 Characteristic equation for a single shear steel-to-bamboo connection The characteristic bending moment My,k
(EC5) loaded parallel to fibre of the screw may either be taken from the
manufacturer’s data sheet or, if unknown,
Malkowska et al. The equation for bamboo is the same as the equation for timber – EC5 following from EC5 eq. 8.14:
(2023)8 eq. 8.10d single shear steel to timber. Although the equation for timber
is valid for thick plates (fastener diameter larger than plate thickness), for
bamboo this equation is also valid for thin plates (fastener diameter less
My,k 0.3 fu,k (1.1dr )2.6
than half plate thickness) as long as the design principles listed above for
bamboo are followed. Assuming the minimum tensile strength
of the screw fu,k = 600 N/mm2:
4My,k Fax,k
Fy,0,k nef fh,k d ef tb 2 2
1
fh,k d ef t b 4
single culm side:
2 Fy,0,k 10 472N
ISO 22156:20217 Modification factor for service class and load duration CDF: CDF = 0.65 – duration factor corresponds
– section 6.3 to the load component having the shortest
duration (in this example it will be assumed
Service class
that the imposed load on the roof is a
Load duration transient load)
1 2
( 2 ) ( C 20 )
Transient 0. 0.
Instantaneous .0 0.
34
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
REFERENCES
ISO 22156:20217 Allowable joint design capacity Total design lateral 1) Göswein V., Arehart J., Phan-huy C.,
– section 10.4 capacity parallel to fibre: Pomponi F. and Habert G. (2022) ‘Barriers
and opportunities of fast-growing biobased
Fy,0 Fy,0,k CDF 1 / FS j material use in buildings’, Build. Cities, 3 (1),
Fy,0 10 472 0.65 1 2 pp. 745–755; https://doi.org/10.5334/bc.254
3.4kN 2) Kuehl L. and Yiping K. (2012) arbon o -
setting with bamboo’, INBAR Working Paper
71, Beijing, China: International Network for
Fy,0 3.4kN Bamboo and Rattan
Check
3) Kaminski S., Lawrence A. and Trujillo
F 3.2kN D. (2016) ‘Structural use of bamboo. Part
1: Introduction to bamboo’, The Structural
OK Engineer, 94 (8), pp. 40–43; https://doi.
org/10.56330/PNSC8891
Malkowska et al. Minimum spacing: 4) Kaminski S., Lawrence A., Trujillo D. and
a1 15d r King C. (2016) ‘Structural use of bamboo. Part
(2023)8
2: Durability and preservation’, The Structural
between screws along fibre: 15 2.5mm Engineer, 94 (10), pp. 38–43; https://doi.
a1 38mm org/10.56330/TRBW8039
5) Kaminski S., Lawrence A., Trujillo D.,
Feltham I. and López L.F. (2016) ‘Structural
use of bamboo. Part 3: Design values’, The
between screws across fibre: Structural Engineer, 94 (12), pp. 42–45;
https://doi.org/10.56330/JCLL5610
a2,min 1.6d r d nom 6) Kaminski S., Lawrence A., Trujillo D.,
Feltham I. and López L.F. (2017) ‘Structural
use of bamboo. Part 4: Element design
loaded end: equations’, The Structural Engineer, 95 (3), pp.
24–27; https://doi.org/10.56330/SXJG3169
7) International Organization for
Standardization (2021) ISO 22156:2021
Bamboo structures. Bamboo culms. Structural
design, Geneva: ISO
8) Malkowska D., Trujillo D., Toumpanaki
E. and Norman J. (2023) ‘Study of screwed
bamboo connection loaded parallel to fibre’,
Constr. Build. Mater., 398, 132532; https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2023.132532
9) Malkowska D., Laux T., Trujillo D. and
Norman J. (2022) ‘Adaptation of a wood
theoretical fracture model for predicting
splitting capacity of dowelled connections
in bamboo’, Constr. Build. Mater.,
357, 129358; https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
conbuildmat.2022.129358
10) Trujillo D. And Malkowska D. (2018)
‘Empirically derived connection design
properties for Guadua bamboo’, Constr.
Build. Mater., 163, pp. 9–20; https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2017.12.065
11) Harries K.A., Morrill P., Gauss C. et al.
(2019) ‘Screw withdrawal capacity of full-
culm P. edulis bamboo’, Constr. Build. Mater.,
216, 531–541; https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
conbuildmat.2019.05.009
12) British Standards Institution (2004) BS EN
1995-1-1:2004+A2:2014 Eurocode 5: Design of
timber structures. General. Common rules and
rules for buildings, London: BSI
13) British Standards Institution (2024) BS
FIGURE 6: Sketch of connection
EN 1993-1-8:2024 Eurocode 3. Design of steel
structures. Joints, London: BSI
A pan head wood screw 4 mm (outer thread) diameter x 25 mm long 14) Asociación Colombiana de Ingeniería
Sísmica (2010) NSR-10: Reglamento
B 1.2 mm thick mild steel plate Colombiano de Construcción Sismo
Resistente, ‘Título G: Estructuras de Madera y
Estructuras de Guadua’ [in Spanish], Bogotá
D.C., Colombia
35
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
Viewpoint
Regenerative design –
disrupting the industry
Ian Poole draws on his e periences of a regenerative design programme to offer e amples
of radical initiatives being implemented today which present a path to a regenerative future.
Introduction world to adopt the concept which aims | Nature-based materials include bamboo
In 2024, I was fortunate to participate in to raise the social foundation without structures5, hemp blocks6, algae-based
the Regenerative Design ab hosted by exceeding environmental limits. tiles7 and mycelium bricks8.
Constructivist. This article aims to summarise | France has written ecocide into law through | Nature-based design uses nature as
the ‘disruptive innovations’ discussed in the its Climate and Resilience Act3. This makes inspiration. There are several examples
lab which provide a reason to be optimistic damaging the environment a criminal where designers have used incredibly
about our future. offence. An ecocide bill was proposed to e cient forms which minimise material use,
In the lab, we used the three-horizons the ouse of ords in the recently. such as dendriform structures9 and the
model1 to undertake this exercise. This | The ell-being of uture enerations Act Munich Olympic Park10.
involves future gazing to imagine a has been introduced in Wales4, making | Nature-based systems see us learn
regenerative construction industry, and then it a requirement to consider the impacts from the complexity of systems within
looking at present-day initiatives that align of developments on future generations in the natural world to inform design flows
with changes we need to get us there. I have the region. to create feedback loops and stronger
grouped the ideas into themes as collectively connections in the supply chain. The Ellen
named by the group in the lab. These holistic and radical acts provide an MacArthur Foundation has provided an
alternative to business-as-usual policy, giving example by applying this thinking to the
Holistic policy intervention voices to the environment and future citizens, circular economy11.
Policy measures are crucial as they can lead placing these at the heart rather than the
to wider change through follow-on impacts on periphery of decision making. Rethinking end of use
design decisions, standards and regulations. There has been a shift in attitude towards
These can affect every pro ect in the region Nature-based solutions buildings at the end of their use in the past
the policy impacts, and often beyond. Some Nature-based solutions cover a wide range few years, particularly in ondon. Examples of
disruptive examples of policy intervention are of initiatives, which utilise biomimicry to learn disruptive initiatives in this space include:
offered below. from the e ciencies of patterns which have | the Don’t Waste Buildings campaign
| Amsterdam has applied the doughnut developed in the natural world over millennia. (www.linkedin.com/groups/ 002 /),
economics principles to its 2020–25 city Nature-based solutions can be used in the which has spread awareness and
strategy2. This makes it the first city in the construction industry in three ways. knowledge of the importance of
retrofit in tackling climate change and
biodiversity loss
| the reater ondon Authority Circular
Box 1. Key UK industry initiatives for climate action
Economy planning policy (S17)12, which
| ETI initiative: activism and publications www.leti.uk/ has shifted the approach taken to large
| Engineers Climate and Biodiversity Emergency Declarations developments in ondon, ensuring
www.engineersdeclare.com/ retention is fully considered
| IStructE climate action resources www.istructe.org/resources/climate-emergency/ | the evin McCloud-backed proposal for
| Architects Declare Regenerative Architecture a Grade III listed building designation13,
Indexhttps://architecturetoday.co.uk/the-regenerative-architecture-index/ which demonstrates thought leadership
| Building blocks to transform the built environment in how planning reform could support a
https://uk.architectsdeclare.com/resources circular economy
| The regenerative structural engineer | the initial refusal of planning for a
www.istructe.org/resources/guidance/the-regenerative-structural-engineer/ carbon-intensive demolition and rebuild
| The Embodied Biodiversity Impacts of Construction Materials report https://expedition. of the Marks Spencer building on
uk.com pro ect embodied-biodiversity-impacts-of-construction-materials Oxford Street14, which sent a clear signal
| Part proposal for embodied carbon regulation https: part-z.uk to the market on the importance of
| UK Net Zero Carbon Buildings Standard www.nzcbuildings.co.uk investigating retention options of large
schemes in ondon.
36
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
ANDREW THORNE
Energy Development (BedZED) (www.
zedfactory.com/bedzed) and Cannock
Mill (Figure 1)20 which demonstrate the
potential and benefits of community
led development, and clearly show the
demand and economic benefits associated
with these schemes.
Community-driven outcomes
With a strong link to community agency,
community-driven outcomes enable places to
thrive. ood examples of this include:
| CIVIC SQUARE, Birmingham
(Figure 2; https://civicsquare.cc/),
which is demonstrating neighbourhood-
scale civic infrastructure for social and
ecological transition
| the Climate Assembly in the UK (www.
climateassembly.uk/) and the Citizens’
Convention on Climate in France (www.
conventioncitoyennepourleclimat.fr/en/),
which directly involve the public in the
preparation of the law
| the London Collective (https://ldn-
collective.com/), which is an example in
FIGURE 1: Cannock Mill is a cohousing development creating a the construction industry of an initiative
thriving community through the shared commitment of residents focused on place-based outcomes.
37
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
REFERENCES
38
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
9) Arslan Selçuk S., Gülle N.B. and Mutlu Avinç spencer-refused-permission-to-demolish-and- lifeandstyle/2024/jan/30/we-just-held-hands-and-
G. (2022) ‘Tree-like structures in architecture: rebuild-oxford-street-store (Accessed: November jumped-how-one-of-britains-happiest-healthiest-
revisiting Frei Otto’s branching columns through 2024) communes-was-built (Accessed: November 2024)
parametric tools’, Sage Open, 12 (3); https://doi. 15) Brown D.G., Pimentel R.J. and Sansom M.R. 21) Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003 (asp 2)
org/10.1177/21582440221119479 [Online] Available at: www.legislation.gov.uk/
(2019) P427: Structural steel reuse: Assessment,
10) Barba J.J. (2015) ‘Frei Otto. Modeling with testing and design principles, Ascot: SCI asp/2003/2/contents (Accessed: November 2024)
soap films’, Metalocus [Online] Available at:
Enfield ouncil Online platform 22) DeSouza P.R. (2021) Knowledge commons
www.metalocus.es/en/news/frei-otto-video-
launched to recycle building materials [Online] and enclosures [Online] Available at: www.
modeling-soap-films (Accessed: November 2024)
Available at: www.enfield.gov.uk/news-and- unesco.org/en/articles/knowledge-commons-
11) Ellen MacArthur Foundation (2021) The events/2022/07/online-platform-launched-to- and-enclosures (Accessed: November 2024)
butterfly diagram: visualising the circular recycle-building-materials (Accessed: November 23) Safdie S. (2024) Permaculture: definition,
economy [Online] Available at: www. 2024) principles and examples [Online] Available at:
ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/circular-economy-
17) Stella A. (2024) ‘Material passports: an https://greenly.earth/en-gb/blog/ecology-news/
diagram (Accessed: November 2024)
enabling solution for material use?’, The permaculture-definition-principles-and-examples
12) Greater London Authority (2020) Circular Structural Engineer, 102 (6), pp. 18–22; https://doi. (Accessed: November 2024)
Economy Statement Guidance (Draft for org/10.56330/FUVO4863 24) O’Neill S. (2023) Everything you need to know
consultation). 1.4 Policy context [Online]
18) Scottish Government (2019) Place Principle: about eco-labels [Online] Available at: www.
Available at: www.london.gov.uk/publications/
introduction [Online] Available at: www.gov. foodsteps.earth/post/everything-you-need-to-
circular-economy-statement-guidance
scot/publications/place-principle-introduction/ know-about-eco-labels (Accessed: November
(Accessed: November 2024)
(Accessed: November 2024) 2024)
13) Arnold W. (2022) ‘Could a Grade III listing
19) Scottish Government (2013) Meanwhile use 25) Sustainable Ventures (s.d.) Restorative
for buildings halt the UK’s tide of demolition?’,
leases and guidance for landlords design for our new London workspace [Online]
Architects’ Journal [Online] Available at: www.
[Online] Available at: www.gov.uk/government/ Available at: www.sustainableventures.co.uk/
architectsjournal.co.uk/news/opinion/could-a-
collections/meanwhile-use-leases-and-guidance- sustainable-stories/restorative-design-workspace
grade-iii-listing-for-buildings-halt-the-uks-tide-
for-landlords (Accessed: November 2024) (Accessed: November 2024)
of-demolition (Accessed: November 2024)
14) Butler S. (2023) ‘Marks & Spencer refused haudhuri A. ‘“We just held hands 26) Brown B. (2021) Atlas of the Heart,
permission to demolish and rebuild Oxford Street and jumped!” How one of Britain’s happiest, London: Vermilion
store’, The Guardian [Online] Available at: www. healthiest communes was built’, The Guardian 27) Robinson K.S. (2020) The Ministry for the
theguardian.com/business/2023/jul/20/marks- [Online] Available at: www.theguardian.com/ Future, London: Orbit
The future
of structural
design
The world is changing, fast. In this new
thought leadership title, the authors
try to answer the question “What is the
future of structural design?”
Central to their response is an examination
of the role of uncertainty in the design
process. This book is a “What if?” rather Pre-order now:
than a “How to” – founded in the theory of istructe.org/resources/guidance/
reliability and risk-based design. the-future-of-structural-design
Verulam
Send letters to…
All contributions to Verulam should be
submitted via email to: [email protected]
40
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
41
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
Review
primary focus on operational carbon emissions means that this book offers less
for structural engineers than the title implies, concludes Paul Astle.
Designing zero carbon in all stages of a building’s life-cycle. It assessment ( CA) methodologies,
buildings: embodied
should be noted that previous versions standard guidelines require these
of this book did not include embodied benefits to be reported separately from
and operational carbon; this is evident in the depth of
detail and guidance provided.
the boundaries of a whole-life carbon
assessment. Additionally, the inclusion
emissions in achieving The book introduces embodied of biogenic carbon in timber and other
42
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
Tubular sandwich cross-sections to the design of customised complex- engineering applications requiring high
fabricated with Wire Arc Additive shaped elements. Among these metal AM resistance against buckling failure.
Manufacturing for jumbo structural processes, wire arc additive manufacturing In detail, the engineered geometrical
members (WAAM) stands out, enabling the fabrication shape of TSSs offers higher freedom to
Lidiana Arrèa, Vittoria Laghia, Alejandro of complex large-scale structural elements, structural designers able to optimise the
Marqués Paolab and Michele Palermoa which are essential for applications in design based on different target structural
a
Department of Civil, Chemical, the construction sector. ithin offshore performances. However, to properly account
Environmental and Materials Engineering, engineering applications, submerged steel for the specific manufacturing constraints,
University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy members of offshore acket structures, computational design approaches and
b
AITIIP Centro Tecnológico, Zaragoza, Spain exposed to significant compressive radial advanced numerical simulations should
pressure, are typically made by circular assist the designer towards a feasible
Innovations in the field of robotics and hollow section (CHS) tubular members. In structural solution. The present study aims
production processes have led to the this regard, the present work focuses on at exploring the potential capabilities of
exploration of new manufacturing techniques, the initial investigations of new geometrical TSSs. First, the geometrical properties and
offering greater freedom in size and shape shapes for jumbo tubular cross-sections potential structural performances of TSSs
of metal additively manufactured (AM) of steel members, referred to as tubular are investigated. Then, two different case
components. This has opened the doors sandwich sections (TSS), for structural studies are presented to illustrate different
target structural performances. The first one
illustrates the application of a parametric
approach to design e cient TSSs of uniform
thickness leading to the creation of a first
catalogue of uniform TSSs. The first proof of
concept of uniform TSS is provided by the
manufacturing of two samples realised with
WAAM technology. The second case study
investigates the structural behaviour of non-
uniform TSS member specifically designed to
resist high radial compressions. For this aim,
linear and non-linear finite element buckling
analyses are carried out also considering the
effect of initial geometrical irregularities. The
structural performances of the TSS member
are compared with those of an equivalent
C S member, demonstrating a significant
increase in the critical pressure of TSS, even
when considering geometrical irregularities.
43
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
Diary dates
charge to attend. Registration
is not typically required
Meetings may be online or
in person.
For Regional Group events,
check the website for the
latest information. Note that more current information may be available
from the Institution website: www.istructe.org/events
44
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
Looking to reduce
your carbon footprint?
e re excited to offer you a simple way to opt out of receiving
printed copies of The Structural Engineer magazine. By choosing
the digital-only format, you ll help us minimise our carbon
emissions, and support our shared commitment to driving
sustainability within the structural engineering profession.
Why go digital only?
• Eco-friendly: Reduce your carbon footprint and contribute
to resource conservation.
• Convenient: Access every issue from anywhere, at any time,
on any device.
Regional
focus
In this feature, we share news, updates and initiatives
from the Institution’s regional group network around the
world. If you have a story to share, get in touch at
[email protected]. The next deadline is 1 March 2025.
Bedfordshire and Adjoining Counties and East Anglia the issues that can arise. Attendees were guided through the facility,
Site visit to galvanising facility in Haverhill observing each stage from pre-treatment to final inspection, and it
was surprising to see how many non-structural items were galvanised at
On 10 October, members of the Bedfordshire and Ad oining Counties the plant.
and East Anglia regional groups visited the Wedge Group’s Acrow The event included an engaging Q&A session, allowing members to
alvanizing facility in averhill, Suffolk. This plant, a successor to the delve into technical details and discuss industry trends with the facility’s
original Acrow props plant, carries a rich historical legacy. Interestingly, experts, often stretching a number of members’ fading chemistry
Acrow props were named after the company’s solicitor, Mr A. Crow. knowledge! Overall, the visit was both educational and engaging,
The visit offered a detailed look into the galvanising process and providing valuable insights into modern galvanising practices.
Singapore Regional Group committee members on stage at members’ appreciation night and Structural Awards 2024
46
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
Hong Kong
Inspiring the next generation:
Commitment to civil
engineering
East Midlands
A centenary of structural engineering
membership
The East Midlands Regional Group gathered recently to celebrate the
centenary of structural engineering membership across the Midlands.
The event marked the past and future of structural engineers across the
region, acknowledging the expertise of past and present members.
IStructE President Tanya de Hoog, CEO Yasmin Becker, Jo Renold-
Smith, Chair of the East Midlands Group, and Mahesh Sankaran, Chair of
the Midland Counties Group, joined the celebrations.
Renold-Smith said: ‘This event celebrated the work of the IStructE
and its members who work to design structures that are safe and that
make e cient and effective use of materials the aim is to provide a built
environment that benefits us all.
The Midlands Counties branch was originally established in 1924 with
83 members in 10 counties. Then President Major James Petrie OBE
hosted the inaugural meeting on 22 November 1924 stating that ‘the Tanya de Hoog, Yasmin Becker and
Midlands were a stronghold of structural engineering . Jo Renold-Smith at centenary celebration event
47
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
SOFTWARE
Want to
Enables the specification of plated members up to 2.3 metres deep, with
thicknesses ranging from 8 mm to 120 mm.
Get in touch
Supports both composite and non-composite design configurations.
CM
media team
CY
Allows users to design for fire ratings ranging from 15 minutes to 120
CMY minutes, in 15-minute increments, suitable for all project types.
48
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
+
• No Job Too Large or Too Small!
• Free 24 Hour Fee Quotations
Quikport Quikjoint
Phone: +44 (0)1202 603031
E: [email protected] cadsconsulting.com
multispan comprehensive
to BS5950 & EuroCode3
ANALYSIS & DESIGN
£2965
a saving of £550
Quikpor t for por tal frame For a trial or online demo contact
linear elastic, force- Sigma-X
deflection and stability
e: [email protected]
codified designs.
w: www.sigma-x.net
Quikjoint for simple or
t (UK): + 44 (0)203 603 1442
moment connection codified
designs
t (Irl): + 353 (0)86 85 45 425
UK’s Leading RC
Detailing Service
• 2D Drawings & Bar Bending Schedules
• 3D Reinforcement Models in Revit
• Local Project Coordinators in UK
• Expert Detailers You Can Rely On!
• ISO9001:2015 Certified Checking
• No Job Too Large or Too Small!
Want to advertise • Free 24 Hour Fee Quotations
your products
and services?
Phone: +44 (0)1202 603031 | E: [email protected]
Get in touch with
the TSE media team
49
thestructuralengineer.org | January 2025
chartered
structural
engineer We’re looking for a senior structural
£65,000 - £80,000 engineer, with minimum 10 years’
experience in a UK or Ireland
Preferably 5 years post chartership experience in structural design practice, to lead
our team in Brighton.
general building structures with familiarity of steel,
concrete, masonry and timber design.
Please see our website for more details.
structural
consultants To apply, in confidence, please send a CV to:
[email protected]
ASSOCIATE DESIGNATE
Salary banding of £60k to £70k
Senior Project Engineer We are a multidisciplinary team of construction
Play a key role in developing and regenerating city of
professionals. Creative and practical in our approach.
Leicester. From improving access for buses, cyclists, and We invite engineers with flare and enthusiasm to join
pedestrians to leading innovative schemes, we’ve got plenty our boutique Firm of multi-disciplinary engineering,
of exciting projects in the pipeline. And you’ll be at the heart architectural and conservation professionals.
of it. It’s about shaping Leicester’s future – helping the city With decades of experience, we provide quality and
to grow and succeed by planning, leading, and delivering a innovation at the heart of all we do. For example, a beautiful
range of projects. And with a commitment to more investment, new home with deep basement pool in windblown sand or
you’ll find lots more opportunities to increase your skills and profiled into a coastal cliff. Commercial, Schools and Fire
knowledge, as you help us create a city to be proud of. From Stations. Historic structures such as the iconic St Andrews
start to finish, you’ll engineer design of major highway, bridge, House, HQ of the Scottish Government, with probably
transport infrastructure projects. This includes planning of Europe’s most extensive ICCP steel frame treatment.
works, production of tenders including documentation and
costings and procurement to delivery of all maintenance and Be part of our growth in Cornwall.
construction programmes. Working within an innovative Design Office you would
Conditions: Full Time / 37 Hours Per Week / Permanent lead on a wide range of projects encompassing structural
Salary: £44,428 – £47,420 per year
investigations, professional appraisals, new builds,
geotechnical, civil, coastal structures and supporting Expert
Location: Based primarily at 90 Leycroft Road, you’ll be Evidence in construction disputes. A multi-disciplinary
required to undertake site visits in and around the city.
engineering role; you will act as an Associate.
Website URL: https://jobs.leicester.gov.uk
Please provide a brief CV and contact details to
Closing date: 13th January 2025 [email protected]
50
January 2025 | thestructuralengineer.org
Our five options offer various levels of targeting and visibility. These include:
£1,475
Volume 101 | Issue 11
October 2023
| Issue 10
Volume 101
Thermal effects on
building structures AWARDS SPECIAL
Historical defects:
High-alumina cement
Quay Quarter
Tower, Sydney
Spanning
continents
How British, European and US engineers
competed to develop South America’s
19th century railways
ent
refurbishm
Reuse and
Nov/Dec print book.indb 1
challenges
and required
skills 01/11/2023 14:05
What are
the risks, existing buildings?
or modifying
when adapting
12:03
27/09/2023
v2.indd 1
pp01 TSE_Oct23_Cover
For more information and to get in touch with the media team,
contact Caroline Harland / [email protected] / +44 (0) 1223 378 045
*Available from October 2022
Book now