Draft TND Chapter 0508
Draft TND Chapter 0508
CHAPTER 18
A Introduction
The design of TND projects requires a greater focus on supporting pedestrian, bicycle
and transit activity, thereby putting motor vehicle movement in a less dominant position.
A well designed TND is created using tools that many professionals are not accustomed
to using, and therefore this chapter is intended to provide best practices to facilitate
proper design of TND projects. Consequently, the emphasis varies from the rest of the
Green Book where the focus is on establishing minimum standards. In order to provide
a design that accomplishes the goals set out in this chapter, designers will be guided by
providing design criteria based on the context of the built environment established for a
portion of the community which has clearly defined characteristics necessary to achieve
the goals for compact livable development patterns, also called “Smart Growth.”
This chapter is intended to provide guidance for planning and designing Greenfield
(new), infill TND and urban renewal projects. It is also intended to clearly differentiate
the differences between CSD and TND projects to maximize the possibility of proper
design. This is important since the street geometry, adjacent land use, and other
elements will either support transit, pedestrian and bicycle activity or create an
environment that is not very supportive to those modes.
Subsequent sections in this chapter will help the professional understand why and how
to apply design features.
The characteristics of CSD typically include separated land uses, where housing, retail,
office and industrial uses are isolated from one another. Housing is usually further
separated into neighborhoods such that apartments, condominiums and other higher
density housing are separate from single family housing. Single family housing is often
further separated into various price levels. Public services such as parks, schools, post
offices, and health facilities are at such a large scale and separated from other uses that
they can only be reached by motor vehicle.
In CSD, big box retail, office parks and other commerce can only be sustained in an
auto dominant environment since they must have a regional market to succeed.
Finally, the roadway system is hierarchal and very much like a plumbing system where
“local” streets with lower traffic volumes feed into “collector” streets with higher levels of
traffic, then finally onto the “arterial”, where speeds and volumes are typically much
higher. Block sizes are large to minimize the number of intersections. This type of
roadway network puts essentially all trips onto the arterial with little to no alternate
routes for travelers.
Design speeds are rarely less than 35 mph and may be as high as 50 mph. Thus longer
distance through traffic is mixed with shorter trip traffic accessing local services. Higher
volume, high speed streets fronted by the walls of subdivisions or surface parking lots of
commercial developments result in a built environment that is hostile to pedestrian,
transit and bicycle modes of transportation. See Figure 1 below for an illustration of
conventional suburban development.
Conventional Suburban
Development
Traditional Neighborhood
Development
Figure 1
Traditional Neighborhood Development in contrast is very supportive to pedestrian,
bicycle and transit modes. Land uses are mixed, with retail, office, civic buildings and
residential interwoven throughout the community, and many times located in the same
buildings. Block sizes are a smaller scale to improve walkability and to create a fine
network of streets, providing a variety of routes for all users.
Multi-family and single family housing are located in close proximity or adjacent to each
other, and homes of various size and price are mixed into neighborhoods. On street
parking is favored over surface parking and one way streets are rarely used. Travel
speeds for motor vehicles are ideally kept in the range of 20-35 mph. This creates and
environment that is safer and more comfortable for pedestrians and bicyclists.
B CONTEXT
Context is the environment the roadway is built in which includes buildings, adjacent
land use, historic, cultural, and other characteristics that form the built and natural
environment of a given place. The ITE Proposed Recommended Practice for Context
Sensitive Solutions in Designing Major Urban Thoroughfares for Walkable Communities
refers to as the Transect Zones used in this document as “Context Zones.” They are in
fact the same.
In order to more clearly define the various contexts or transects used throughout the
remaining portions of the document, the transects and their related characteristics are
listed in Table 1 below and illustrated in Figure 2 below.
Table 1
C PLANNING CRITERIA
Planning for Traditional Neighborhood Development occurs at several levels, the region,
the city/town, the community, the block and finally the building. Planning should be
holistic, looking carefully at the relationship between land use, buildings and
transportation in an integrated fashion. This approach and the use of form based codes
can create development patterns that support more traditional development patterns
that balance pedestrian, transit and bicycling with motor vehicle modes of
transportation. The following sections help to define considerations for developing
communities at different scales in order to increase the potential for creating traditional
neighborhood development patterns.
The principles for defining or creating the context should be considered based on the
scale of community that is being evaluated, developed or redeveloped.
• The city should retain its natural infrastructure and visual character derived from
its location and climate, including topography, landscape and coastline
• Growth strategies should encourage infill and redevelopment
• New development should be structured to reinforce a pattern of neighborhoods
and urban centers, focused growth at transit nodes rather than along corridors.
• Transportation corridors should be planned and reserved in coordination with
land use.
• Green corridors should be encouraged to enhance and connect the urbanized
areas.
• The city should include a framework of transit, pedestrian, and bicycle systems
that provide alternatives to automobile use.
• A diversity of land use should be distributed throughout the city to enable a
variety of economic activity, workplace, residence, recreation and civic activity.
• Affordable and workforce housing should be distributed throughout the city to
match job opportunities and to avoid concentrations of poverty.
The following principles are intended to offer guidance on the most appropriate setting
for the design principles of this chapter. The principles are not intended to be criteria,
but it is recommended that at least seven of the principles or their intent be reflected in
a project or community setting for it to be considered a TND.
NOTE TO TEAM: Discussion needs to occur on the following principles since
some of these should not be optional. Possibly establish those that are “non-
negotiable” and allow flexibility with others.
• Is designed with low speed, low volume, interconnected streets with short block
lengths that are between 150 to 400 feet and cul-de-sacs only where no
alternative exists
• Orients buildings close to the street with off-street parking located to the side or
back of buildings as not to interfere with pedestrian activity
• Uses on-street parking to buffer the sidewalk, calm traffic, and offer diverse
parking options
• Varies residential densities, lot sizes, and housing types, while maintaining an
average gross density of at least eight dwellings per acre and higher density in
the core
• Has only the minimum rights-of-way necessary for the street, median, planting
strips, sidewalks, utilities, and maintenance and which are appropriate to
adjacent land uses and building types
• Locates arterial highways, major collector roads, and other high-volume corridors
at the edge of the TND, not through the TND
C.1 Definitions
NOTE TO TEAM: Should definitions be placed at beginning of section where text
is first located or some other location?
o Alley - A narrow street, especially one through the middle of a block giving
access to the rear of lots or buildings.
o Avenue (AV) - a thoroughfare of high vehicular capacity and low speed.
Avenues are short distance connectors between urban centers. Avenues may
be equipped with a landscaped median. Avenues become collectors upon
exiting urban areas.
o Boulevard - a boulevard is usually a thoroughfare, divided with a median
down the center.
o Context – the financial, environmental, historical, cultural, land use types,
activities and built environment which help to establish the configuration of
roadways.
o Context sensitive solutions (CSS) - is a collaborative, interdisciplinary
approach that involves all stakeholders to develop a transportation facility that
fits its physical setting and preserves scenic, aesthetic, historic and
environmental resources, while maintaining safety and mobility. CSS is an
approach that considers the total context within which a transportation
improvement project will exist.
o Design Speed - is the velocity at which a thoroughfare tends to be driven
without the constraints of signage or enforcement.
o Human scale - describes buildings, block structure and other aspects of the
built environment which are designed in consideration for pedestrians and
bicyclists, their rate of travel and other physical needs
o Lane –
o Liner Building - a building specifically designed to mask a parking lot or a
parking garage from the frontage.
o Live-Work - a dwelling unit that contains a commercial component in the unit.
o Mixed Use Development - the practice of allowing more than one type of use
in a building or set of buildings. This can mean some combination of
residential, commercial, industrial, office, institutional, or other land uses.
o Modern Roundabout - a circular intersection with specific design and traffic
control features. These features include yield control of all entering traffic,
channelized approaches, and appropriate geometric curvature to ensure that
travel speeds on the circulatory roadway are typically less than 30 mph.
Modern Roundabout
Pedestrian Shed
o Private Frontage - the privately held area between the r/w line and the
building facade.
o Public Frontage - the area between the curb of the thoroughfare and the r/w
line. Elements of the public frontage include the type of curb, walk, planter,
street tree and streetlight.
o Rear Alley/Lane - a vehicular driveway located to the rear of lots providing
access to service areas and parking, and containing utility easements.
o Retail - premises available for the sale of merchandise and food service.
o Smart Growth - an urban planning and transportation theory that concentrates
growth in the center of a city to avoid urban sprawl; and advocates compact,
transit-oriented, walkable, bicycle friendly land use, including mixed used
development with a range of housing choices.
o Road - a local, rural and suburban thoroughfare of low vehicular speed and
capacity. Its public frontage consists of swales drained by percolation and a
walking path or bicycle trail along one or both sides. This type is allocated to
the more rural Transect Zones (T1-T3).
o Setback - the area of a lot measured from the r/w line to a building facade or
elevation.
o Street - a local urban thoroughfare of low speed and capacity. This type is
permitted within the more urban Transect Zones (T4-T6).
o Terminated Vista - a building or feature located at the end of a thoroughfare in
a position of prominence.
Terminated Vista
Land use considerations for TNDs are outlined in the Planning Criteria section
and are applied at a variety of scales. A well-integrated or “fine grained” land
use mix within buildings and blocks is essential. These buildings and blocks
aggregate into neighborhoods, which should be designed with a mix of uses to
form a comprehensive planning unit that aggregates into larger villages, towns,
and regions. Except at the regional scale, each of these scales requires land
uses to be designed at a pedestrian scale and to be served by “complete streets”
that safely and attractively accommodate many modes of travel.
The proposed land uses, residential densities, building size and placement,
proposed parking (on-street and off-street) and circulation, the location and use
of open space, and the development phasing are all considerations in facility
design for TNDs. ITE recommends a high level of connectivity, short blocks that
provide many choices of routes to destinations, and a fine-grained urban land
use and lot pattern. Higher residential density and nonresidential intensity, as
measured by floor area ratios of building area to site area, are required for well-
designed TNDs.
C.3 Networks
All of the factors, traffic volume, trip characteristics, speed and level of service, in
the functional classification system are related to the mobility of motor vehicles;
these factors do not provide for or address bicyclists or pedestrians; and do not
consider the context or land use of the surrounding environment. This approach,
while appropriate for high speed rural and suburban roadways, does not provide
designers with guidance on how to design for a pedestrian supportive
environment or in a context sensitive manner.
The thoroughfare types described here provide mobility for all modes of
transportation with a greater focus on the pedestrian. The functional classification
system can be generally applied to the thoroughfare types in this chapter. What
designers should recognize is the need for greater flexibility in applying design
criteria based more heavily on context and the need to create a safe environment
for pedestrians, rather than strictly following the conventional application of
functional classification in determining geometric criteria.
General Principles
a. The Thoroughfares are intended for use by vehicular, transit, bicycle, and
pedestrian traffic and to provide access to Lots and Open Spaces.
b. The Thoroughfares consist of vehicular lanes and Public Frontages. The lanes
provide the traffic and parking capacity. Thoroughfares consist of vehicular
lanes in a variety of widths for parked and for moving vehicles. The Public
Frontages contribute to the character of the Transect Zone. They may include
swales, sidewalks, curbing, planters, bicycle paths and street trees.
c. Thoroughfares should be designed in context with the urban form and desired
design speed of the Transect Zones through which they pass. The Public
Frontages that pass from one Transect Zone to another should be adjusted
accordingly.
The terms for thoroughfare types that are used fin Traditional Neighborhood
Design include:
HW-Highway
A Highway is a long-distance, high-capacity and high-speed thoroughfare that
connect cities and towns. A Highway should have infrequent intersections and
driveway entrances, and should have sidewalks and abutting buildings buffered
by landscape where possible; otherwise it becomes strip development which
interferes with traffic flow and pedestrian comfort.
Highway frontages may have curbs or open swales drained by percolation. They
have no parking. Buildings may front a wide sidewalk or be set back. Highways
can be rural linear parks, with a median and naturalistic landscaping and bicycle
and pedestrian paths traversing the landscape independently.
RD-Road
A Road is a local, slow-movement thoroughfare suitable for less urban transect
zones. Roads provide frontage for low-density buildings with a substantial
setback. Roads have narrow pavement and open swales drained by percolation,
with or without sidewalks. The landscaping may be informal with multiple species
arrayed in naturalistic clusters.
ST-Street
A Street is a local, multi-movement thoroughfare suitable for all urbanized
transect Zones and all frontages and uses. A Street is urban in character, with
raised curbs, drainage inlets, wide sidewalks, parallel parking, and trees in
individual or continuous planters aligned in an allee. Character may vary
somewhat, however, responding to the commercial or residential uses lining the
Street.
DR-Drive
A Drive is a local movement thoroughfare along the edge of a wide right-of-way
or an open space. One side of a Drive may have the urban character of a Street
or Boulevard with sidewalk and buildings; the other side may have the qualities of
a parkway such as along a railroad track with naturalistic planting. Alternatively, a
Drive may have an urban character with landscape and formal planting, such as
along the bayfront or riverfront.
AV-Avenue
An Avenue is a limited distance, slow or free-movement thoroughfare connecting
proximate locations within an urbanized area. Unlike a Boulevard, in its truest
form, an avenue’s length is finite and its axis is terminated. It always has a
substantial planted median. An Avenue may be conceived as an elongated
square.
The Avenue is appropriate for the approach to a civic building. At urban centers,
the median may be wide enough to hold monuments and even buildings. In
residential areas, the median may be planted naturalistically to become a
parkway or green.
Avenue Frontages have raised curbs drained by inlets and wide sidewalks
separated from the vehicular lanes by narrow continuous planters, preferably
with parking on both sides. The landscaping consists of a single tree species
aligned in a regularly spaced allee in individual or continuous planters.
BV-Boulevard
A Boulevard is a long-distance, high capacity multi-movement Thoroughfare,
outside of neighborhoods and at neighborhood edges. A Boulevard may be lined
by parallel parking, with wide sidewalks, and trees in continuous or individual
planters.
Boulevards may have central or side medians with slip roads. Side medians
segregate slower traffic and parking activity at the edges from through traffic at
the center.
Boulevards have sidewalks with raised curbs along both sides, drainage by
inlets, parallel parking, sidewalks, and trees aligned in a regularly spaced allee in
individual or continuous planters.
PP-Pedestrian Passage
A Pedestrian Passage is a narrow connector restricted to pedestrian use and
limited vehicular use that passes between buildings or between a building and a
public open space. Passages provide shortcuts through long blocks and connect
rear parking areas with frontages. In T3, Pedestrian Passages may be unpaved
and informally landscaped. In T4, T5 and T6, they should be paved and
landscaped and may provide limited vehicular access. When in civic zones,
passages should correspond with their context and abutting transect zones.
AL-Alley
An Alley is a narrow vehicular access-way at the rear or side of buildings
providing service and parking access, and utility easements. Alleys have no
sidewalks, landscaping, or building frontage requirements. They accommodate
trucks and dumpsters, and may be paved from building face to building face, with
drainage by inverted concrete crown. In older residential neighborhoods Alleys
may be unpaved.
D DESIGN PRINCIPLES
D.1 Introduction/Definitions
o
NOTE TO TEAM: Please provide feedback on terms and speed ranges
Movement Types
Yield: Drivers must proceed slowly and with extreme care and must yield in
order to pass a parked car or approaching vehicle. Functional equivalent of traffic
calming. Design speed of 20 mph or less; this type can accommodate bicycle
routes.
Slow: Drivers can proceed carefully with an occasional stop to allow a pedestrian
to cross or another car to park. Drivers should feel uncomfortable exceeding
design speed due to presence of parked cars, enclosure, tight turn radii, and
other design elements. Design speed of 20-25 mph; this type can accommodate
bicycle routes.
Free: Drivers can expect to travel generally without delay at the design speed;
street design supports safe pedestrian movement at the higher design speed.
This movement type is appropriate for Thoroughfares designed to traverse longer
distances or that connect to higher intensity locations. Design speed of 25-30
mph; this type can accommodate bicycle routes.
Speed: Drivers can expect travel similar to conventional street design, but with
continued emphasis on pedestrian safety and comfort. Design speed of 30-35
mph. Bicycle safety to be assessed by Thoroughfare.
[Urban roadside is the space between the face of building or R/W line to the curb face,
also known as “public frontage”.]
E.1 Introduction/Definitions
E.2 Edge Zone
F TRAVELED WAY
[The traveled way is the central part of the thoroughfare between the curb faces where
vehicle movement and on street parking occurs.]
Alleys and narrow roadways that act as shared spaces can have design speeds
as low as 10 mph, as noted in CHAPTER 16 – RESIDENTIAL STREET DESIGN
F.3 Medians
Ensure that on street parking does not conflict with the placement of any
neighborhood traffic control devices, as addressed in CHAPTER 15 – TRAFFIC
CONTROL DEVICES.
F.5 Mid-Block Crossings
Bicycle Lanes may be made part of Thoroughfares that have sufficient paving
width to accommodate bicyclists’ safety. A City-wide bicycle plan may designate
an interconnected network serving bicyclists with a series of routes that include
Bicycle Lanes as well as Bicycle Routes that give bicycles priority, such as those
Thoroughfares which parallel major corridors and which can be reconfigured to
limit conflicts between automobiles and bicycles.
G INTERSECTIONS
G.1 Introduction/Definitions
H GENERAL
Additional issues for further discussion and consideration, with examples of treatments,
identify existing projects for review, pictures, graphics, and reference documents
I OTHER SOURCES
REFERENCES
The following is a list of the publications used in the preparation of this chapter: