Module 6
Module 6
Development
Mapping Innovation:
Levers of innovation-
Business model innovation
i)Value proposition. ii)supply chain. iii) target customer
Technology innovation
i)Products & services ii)Process technologies iii)Enabling technologies
Case-Apple Computers took the industry by surprise when it launched iTunes and iPod, not so much because these
were innovations that nobody had ever thought of before in the PC arena. Instead, it was the strategy of combining
technology change and business model change into a one-two innovation punch. And the iTunes/iPod
combination is only starting to generate new concepts; iPod special edition with U2 (the famous rock band), which
opens up rich partnership opportunities with content providers. Apple has put its mark again on the direction of the
PC industry—a mark that will be tough to erase.
Case-As innovation leaders like Apple, Toyota, Dell, Nucor Steel, Sony, and others have shown, making important
changes to key parts of the dominant business model or the essential technology can redirect the competitive
vectors of an entire industry.
Innovation provides the opportunity for a company to put its mark on the evolution of business. By setting the rules
of the game in their industries, these companies have taken a leadership position and play the game that favors them
the most.
Innovation Is the Power to Redefine the
Industry
Innovation is not only a weapon in competitive markets; it has proven itself as an
important source to redefine philanthropy and government under the umbrella of social
innovation and social entrepreneurship.
Case-The idea of micro-credits, with Grameen Bank as the best-known example of these, has
dramatically changed the standard of living of thousands of people who were trapped in a
vicious circle where high-interest loans captured all the value from their work and kept them
in poverty. Micro-credits are very small loans, as small as $30–$40, that offer individuals the
chance to start or grow a business. Used to foster economic improvement for individuals,
families, and regions, they are commonly made available in emerging countries and
struggling economies. Micro-credit entities improve the risk profile of these loans through
careful selection, social control, and diversification. Lower risk translates into better interest
rates and the possibility for these people to significantly increase their standard of living.
Innovation Is the Power to Redefine the
Industry
Unleashing an innovation and expecting the market to reward the
company with sustained growth and success is a common mistake.
Case- Boeing launched the highly successful 777, and established the norm for
commercial airplanes in the 21st century. However, Boeing has not been able
to maintain dominance of the industry, and Airbus has challenged its
leadership, surpassing it in sales in 2004. All companies have seen their market
advantages derived from breakthrough innovations whittled away and
eventually reversed by competitors. A block- buster innovation is not a
guarantee of success, just an opportunity.
What to do?
It must be followed up with a successive stream of innovations, from
incremental to radical.
A business model is the strategy that a company uses to create, sell and deliver
value to its potential customers. Business model change is driven by the
following areas
• Value proposition: what the company sells and delivers to the market.
• Supply chain: how the product or service is created and delivered to the
market.
• Target customer: who the potential customers are, people that might be
interested in the product that the company sells.
Levers for change
Business Model Change
Value proposition
Changes in value proposition (what the company sells and delivers to the market)
may be an entire development of a new product or service and, also, the improvement
of products or services that the company is already offering in its portfolio.
Case- automobile industries often present vehicles adding new features above the
previous models and also offering new post-sales services. In the information and
computing industry, a clear example of change of value proposition is IBM. From
1991 until 2005, the core business of IBM was technology manufacture focusing on
hardware such servers and laptops. In 2005, the company decided to move away from
the hardware business, doing a big change in the value propositions of its products
and services and it started to focus on software and consulting. According to Gartner
consulting group, IBM led the market in the areas of software and middleware in
2012. The change in the value proposition of IBM is an example of how companies
can obtain success in their business implementing changes in the value proposition of
their products or services
Levers for change
Business Model Change
Supply chain
The second aspect of business model change is supply chain, how the product
or service is created and delivered to the market. These kinds of changes are
never visible to the final customers. During this step, the company’s goal is to
gain and develop relationships with entity organisations or partners in order to
improve manufacturing processes, distribution or sales processes.
Innovations can come from updating the contracts with the suppliers, involving
them in participating in the successes and failures of the market. Also, the
innovations may come from careful management relationships with
complementary assets.
Case- Microsoft started its business in the video game market with the Xbox
console. Microsoft needed to obtain new relationships with game developers in
order to produce these new assets, video games
Papers and parcels
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ICGnjoiRF-I
Levers for change
Business Model Change
Target customer
Changing is the target of the potential customers of the company’s products or
services. This change usually starts when the company finds a segment of
potential customers that are not related with its marketing, sales and
distribution strategies into the market. This lever is not as common as value
proposition and supply chain but the company should not overlook this
possibility when it is looking for new opportunities to innovate because lever is
an important trait of innovation -staycation for local
Levers for change
Business Model Change
Technology Change
Most of the time, new technologies are the result of investing money in
innovation projects. Companies focus a lot of attention in the new technologies
because these products provide the organization with the growth and
development in the market. Technological changes influence innovation in
three different ways
• Offering Product and service
• Process technologies
• Enabling technologies
Levers for change
Business Model Change
Product and service offering
A change in the company's products or services or creating a new product or
service in the market is a kind of innovation that is really easy to detect by the
customer. With fast-changing markets, consumers expect new features from
innovative products.
For example, in fields like smartphones or tablets, the customers want new
hardware or software innovations.
Thus for the company, this is the way to make the difference compared to its
competitors' products. This type of innovation has an important influence on
the company's success but it is not the only model of technological innovation.
Levers for change
Business Model Change
Process technologies
When talking about technology innovation, the main idea is to create a new product or
service or just to improve the products or services that the company already has in the
market. For example, in the smartphone market, one way to innovate is to improve the
hardware doing the microprocessor faster and lighter or to make sure that it consumes less
power. Also, creating new apps, making the customer's life easier is an interesting way to
innovate in this field.
The idea of creating or improving products and services is really important but it is
important not to forget other aspects such as manufacturing and the service delivery process.
These procedures are as decisive as the ideas of creating or improving new products or
services and they will determine the success of the firm. The manufacturing and delivery
processes are invisible to the customer but help the company in the competition. Through
robust processes in manufacturing and delivery, the firm could reduce the cost of
manufacturing (choosing the best material to develop the products) as well as improving the
quality of the products and services. Also, with a good delivery process, the company will
save time distributing its products and services to its customers, which means increasing the
profits
Innovation and Strategy
The innovation strategy has to be related to the business strategy. The key
innovation aspects will be dependent on the strategy and the competitive
environment. It is vital that all people involved in the innovation process will
have a clear idea about the innovation strategy and they must understand it.
There are broadly two types of innovation strategies-
1. Play-to-Win
2. Play-Not-to-Lose Strategies
Play-to-Win Strategy (PTW)
The most important target of Play-to-Win Strategy (PTW) is to generate
important competitive advantages and sometimes, the company's competitors
will not be able to develop them in a short time. To start to launch this kind of
strategy, the innovation investment has to provide the company with one of the
key resources of the organization competitive advantages. PTW tries to
transform the organization investing a lot of resources in new technologies
and business models in order to create new ideas or products. It also exceeds
its competitors in the incremental, semi-radical and radical innovation.
These investments are completely needed to obtain competitive success in the
organization
Play-to-Win Strategy (PTW)
Advantages:
• Opportunity for Growth: This strategy focuses on taking risks, being innovative, and trying new
things. By doing so, businesses can discover new opportunities for growth and expansion.
• Competitive Advantage: Playing to win allows businesses to differentiate themselves from their
competitors by offering unique products or services.
• Customer Engagement: The Play to Win strategy can help businesses create excitement and
engagement with their customers by introducing new products and experiences.
Disadvantages:
• High Risk: This strategy involves taking risks, and if those risks do not pay off, it can result in
significant losses.
• Requires Investment: To play to win, businesses need to invest in research, development, and
innovation, which can be expensive.
• Limited Control: The Play to Win strategy relies on external factors such as market trends and
consumer behavior. Businesses may have limited control over these factors, which can impact their
success.
Play-to-Win Strategy (PTW)
Clear examples of this strategy are the high-technology startups. Often, they
must be very focused on a new idea, technology or business model but the
failure rate of these kinds of companies is very high. One of the reasons for this
high failure rate is that they do not have a strong investment portfolio, which
makes the PTW pretty risky
A successful example of this kind of strategy is Amazon. In the 1990s, it created
a new business model in the book market. Previously it was not possible to buy
a single book on the internet; the books were sold by pallets. Using a new
software technology and creating a new delivering service, Amazon has been
known as for increasing the product portfolio using a PTW in the right way. [
Play-not-to-lose (PNTL)
Play-not-to-lose (PNTL) is a strategy that uses more incremental innovation
than the PTW strategy. The most important target in this strategy is to
guarantee that the company can stay in the market, taking estimated risks
and moving close to their competitors. It is important that companies that follow
this strategy stay alert to the new improvements their competitors develop.
By doing so, these companies will be able to implement internal changes in their
processes to wear down the competitors and to look for the best moment to
change to a PTW strategy.
This strategy is a good option until an organization launches a new product
with a high semi-radical or radical innovation. When it occurs, the company
that uses PNTL does not have enough resources to compete with these
innovations. They are not able to compete with success in this environment
Play-not-to-lose (PNTL)
Advantages:
• Security: This strategy is focused on maintaining the status quo and avoiding unnecessary
risks. This can provide a sense of security and stability for the business.
• Controlled Growth: By avoiding major risks, businesses can achieve stable, controlled
growth.
• Consistent Results: By relying on proven methods, businesses can consistently achieve
positive results.
Disadvantages:
• Lack of Innovation: The Play not to Lose strategy can result in a lack of innovation and
creativity, which can make it difficult for businesses to stand out from their competitors.
• Missed Opportunities: By avoiding risks, businesses may miss out on opportunities for
growth and expansion.
• Stagnation: Without taking risks and innovating, businesses can become stagnant and fail to
adapt to changes in the market.
PTW vs PNTL
• Market conditions: The choice of strategy may depend on the current
market conditions. In a stable market with low competition, a Play not to
Lose strategy may be effective. However, in a highly competitive market
with rapid changes and innovation, a Play to Win strategy may be more
appropriate.
• Risk tolerance: The choice of strategy may also depend on the risk
tolerance of the company's management and shareholders. Some companies
may have a higher risk tolerance and may be willing to take significant
risks, while others may be more conservative and prefer to avoid major
risks.
• Timing: The timing of the strategy may also be crucial. For example, a
company may adopt a Play to Win strategy during a period of growth and
expansion, but switch to a Play not to Lose strategy during a period of
stability or economic downturn
Setting future goals