Curve Tracing in Cartesian Coordinates
Curve Tracing in Cartesian Coordinates
The object of curve tracing is to find the approximate shape of a curve without the labour of
plotting a large number of points. Before tracing the curves defined by y = f(x) or f (x, y) =0,
we discuss some properties such as asymptotes, singular points, curvature etc. of the curves
y = f (x) which give us a ‘frame’ within which we can draw the curve. These properties tell us
the shape of the curve after we have plotted only a few points. Now we shall discuss them in
detail.
If the Cartesian equation f (x, y) = 0 of the curve is given, the students will find that he
can invariable solve it either for y, or for x. There will be some cases, where the Cartesian
equation of the curve can not be solved either for y or for x but can be solved for r (in terms
of ) when transformed into polar coordinates. In case of parametric equations, if they can be
easily transformed into Cartesian coordinates by eliminating the parameter, then there is no
new case, otherwise they can be discussed in parametric form itself.
We use the following information to trace the curve whose equation is given in Cartesian
coordinates.
1. Symmetry: Determine if the curve has any symmetry by applying the following rules:
(a) If all the powers of y occurring in the equation of curve are even, the curve is
symmetrical about x-axis. In this case the shape of the curve above and below the axis of x is
symmetrical. We may sketch the curve above the x-axis, i.e. for y > 0 and draw its reflection
2 x2 y2
below the x-axis. For example, the parabola y = 4ax or the ellipse 2 2 1 .
a b
(b) If all the powers of x occurring in the equation of curve are even, then curve is
symmetrical about y-axis. For example, x 2 4ay .
From these two conditions we conclude that if the powers of x and y are even, the curve is
symmetrical about both the axes. For example, the circle x 2 y 2 a 2 or the ellipse
x2 y 2
1.
a2 b2
(c) If x and y can be interchanged without any change in the equation of curve then the
(d) If the equation of curve remains unchanged on changing the signs of x and y, the
2. Origin and tangents at origin. Find whether curve passes through origin or not i.e.
(0, 0) satisfies the equation of curve or not. If the curve passes through the origin, find
the equation of tangents at the origin by equating the lowest degree terms of the equation
to zero.
If the curve passes through origin and is given by a rational, integral, algebraic
equation, the equation of the tangent or tangents at the origin is obtained by equating to
zero the terms of the lowest degree in the equation of the curve.
For example, the curve a 2 y 2 x 2 (a 2 x 2 ) passes through the origin. The lowest degree
terms (degree 2) in equation is a 2 y 2 x 2 a 2 . Equating this to zero, we have
. 3. Points of intersection with the axes. Putting y = 0 in the equation of curve we can
find the points where the curve cuts the x-axis. For example x3 y = x + 1. Putting y = 0 we
Similarly, putting x = 0 in the equation of curve, we can find the points where the
When such points are known we can find the equation of tangents at these points by
shifting the origin to these points one by one. Then tangents at these new origins are obtained
by equating the lowest degree terms to zero. For example, in the curve x 3 y x 1, the curve
cuts the x-axis at ( 1, 0).
X 13 Y
X or X 3 1 3 X 2 3 X Y X
or X 3Y Y 3 X 2Y 3 XY X 0
X + Y= 0
or x + 1 + y = 0 or x + y = 1 is the equation of tangent at ( 1, 0).
4. Asymptotes. A straight line at a finite distance from the origin, which touches the curve at
infinity, is called an asymptote to the curve.
dy
Yy X x
dx
dy dy
or Y X yx .
dx dx
dy dy
If an asymptote exists, then as x , and y x should tend to finite limits say m
dx dx
and c respectively. If this condition is satisfied then the asymptote would be
Y mX c
lim dy lim dy
Hence, m and yx c.
x dx x dx
lim y lim dy
or 0
x x x dx
lim y
or m
x x
which shows that the m of an asymptote is equal to the limit of (y/x) as x tends to infinity.
The asymptotes to the curve are determined by using the following rules:
(i) Asymptote parallel to x-axis: The asymptote or asymptotes parallel to the axis of x can
be obtained by equating to zero the coefficient of the highest power of x, provided this is not
merely a constant.
(ii) Asymptote parallel to y-axis: The asymptotes parallel to the axis of y are obtained by
equating to zero the coefficient of the highest degree terms in y, provided this is not merely a
constant.
NOTE A curve of degree n cannot have more than n asymptotes real or imaginary.
(iii) Method for finding the asymptotes of general algebraic curve. Let the equation of
curve be
a y
0
n
a1 y n 1 x a2 y n 2 x 2 ... an x n b1 y n 1 b2 y n 2 x ... bn x n 1
c2 y n 2 c3 y n 3 x ... cn x n 2 ... 0 (1)
y y
xn n x n 1 ... 0
n 1
x x
where n y / x , n 1 y / x , ... are expression of nth and (n-1)th, ... degree in (y/x).
y 1 y 1 y
n n1 2 n 2 ... 0 (2)
x x x x x
lim y
Now taking the limit as x such that ( ) = m, excluding the case of asymptotes
x x
y
parallel to the y-axis in which lim ( ) is infinite, we get
x x
n m 0 (3)
This equation which is of degree n in m, determines the values of m which occurs in the
equation y = mx + c. In general, Eq.(3) will have n values of m corresponding to the n
branches of the curve (1).Some of the values of m, may, however, be imaginary or coincident.
1 y x y 1 2
n y/x n 1 y/x ... 2
2 n 1 y/x 3 n 2 y/x ... 0
x x x x
as lim yx y c . Equation (4) determines one value of c for each value of m obtained
x
y m1 x c1 ; y m2 x c2 ;...
(i) Put x= 1 and y = m in the highest degree (nth degree) terms of the curve and put the
obtained expression equal to n m , (if the highest degree curve is of degree nth).
(ii) Put x= 1 and y = m in (n -1)th degree) terms of the curve and put the obtained expression
equal to n1 m .
(iii) Put x= 1 and y = m in (n -2)th degree) terms of the curve and put the obtained expression
equal to n 2 m .
To find m, put n m 0 and solve this equation to find all the values of m. Then the values
n1 m
of c are obtained by using equation (4) as c
n (m)
However, if any value of m obtained from Eq. (3) satisfies Eq.(4) i..e.
n (m) 0 and n 1 m 0 , it means that the two values of m are identical ( showing two
mutual parallel asymptotes) and consequently the values of c cannot be determined from Eq.
(4). In such cases, we differentiate Eq. (2) twice with respect to x, multiply by as suitable
power of x and take the limit as x , then
1 2
c n m c n 1 m n 2 m 0 , (5)
2!
which will give two values of c corresponding to two identical values of m; in other words we
get a pair of parallel asymptotes. Similarly if m has three identical values, then proceeding in
the same way, we get
1 3 c2
c n m n1 m cn 2 m n3 m 0 . (6)
3! 2!
y 3 x 2 y 2 xy 2 2 x 3 7 xy 3 y 2 2 x 2 2 x 2 y 1 0 . (i)
Solution Putting y = mx + c in the above equation and rearranging the equation in descending
powers of x, we get
x 3 m 3 2m 2 m 2 x 2 3m 2 c c 4mc 7m 3m 2 2 x 3mc 2 2c 2 7c
+ 6mc 2 m 2) c 3 3c 2 2c 1 0 .
m 3 2m 2 m 2 0
or
m m2 1 2 m2 1 0
or m 1 m 1 m 2 0
or m = - 1, 1, and 2.
Now the corresponding values of c are given by equating the coefficient of x2 to zero i.e.
c 3m 2 1 4m 3m 2 7m 2 0
3m 2 7m 2
or c
3m 2 4m 1
y x y yx y 2 0 .
3
x 4 m 1 m x 3 c 6c m 6c m2 4c m3 x 2 9c 2 m 6m2c 2 3c 2 m m2
3
x 3c 3 4m c 3 c 2c m c 4 c 2 2 0 . (i)
c - 6c m + 6c m2 - 4c m3 = 0 (ii)
For m =1, the Eq. (ii) becomes an identity and gives no definite values of c. Now,
equating the coefficient of x2 to zero, we get
9c 2 m 6m 2 c 2 3c 2 m m 2 0
Putting m = 1, this equation again becomes an identity. Therefore we now equate the
coefficient of x to zero
3c 3 4mc 3 c 2cm 0
For m =1, 3c 3 4c 3 c 2c 0 or c 3 c 0 or c 0, 1 .
Solution Putting x =1 and y = m in the third degree terms and equating to zero, we get
3 m 1 2m m 2 2m 3 0
or 1 2m m 2 1 2m 0 m 1 , 1
2
Now φ3 m 2 2m 6m 2
Also 2 m 3m 3m 2
φ2 m 3m 3m 2
Therefore c= - .
φ3 m 2 2m 6m 2
1 1
For m , c .
2 2
For m 1, c 1 .
For m 1, c 0 .
x 1
Hence all the asymptotes are y = x+1; y = - x and y = - .
2 2
If some particular value of m found from n m 0 makes φn m zero but do not make
n 1 m zero, then the Eq. (4) for determining the corresponding value of c becomes
0. c n 1 m 0
m 2 0 and mc 2a 0
The first equation gives m = 0. Then second equation reduces to -2a = 0 which is impossible.
Hence y2 = 4ax has no asymptotes.
Example 5 Find the asymptotes of the curve y 2 x 2 a 2 x .
Solution Equating to zero the coefficient of highest degree term in y i.e. y2 to zero, we get
x 2 a 2 0 i.e. x a
Again, equating to zero the coefficient of highest degree term in x i.e. x2 to zero, we
have
y 2 0 y 0,
Thus all the four asymptotes have been found. Hence all the asymptotes are x = ± a, y = 0.
y2 x x2 y 2 y2 x2 0 (i)
This equation is of third degree, so it can not have more than three asymptotes.
y -1 = 0 or y =1
x -2 = 0 or x =2
Oblique asymptotes: Putting x = 1 and y = m in third degree, second degree and first degree
terms respectively of Eq. (i), we get
3 ( m ) m 2 m
2 ( m ) 2 m 2 1
2 ( m) 2m 2 1
Now c is given by c
3 (m) 2m 1
For m = 0, c = 1 and hence the asymptote is y = 0.x + 1or y = 1. This asymptote is parallel to
X-axis.
The method of substituting y = mx + c and equating to zero the coefficients of the two highest
powers of x applies only to algebraic curves. In case of non-algebraic curves the asymptotes
can be found in simple cases by applying the definition.
dy
Solution We have sec 2 x .
dx
Y tan x sec 2 x X x
Now, as x from the left, y and the distance of (x, y) from the origin tend to
2
infinity. Hence to obtain the asymptote we must take the limit of Eq. (i) as x which
2
gives
π X = .
Y.0 0 X
2 2
5. Region where the curve does not exist. If the value of y becomes imaginary for a certain
set of value of x, say a < x < b, then the curve does not lie in the region bounded by the lines
x = a and x = b. A similar remark applies to the value of x when expressed in terms of y.
6. Special points. To get more accuracy in the shape of the curve, prepare a table (if
necessary) for certain values of x and y and draw the curve passing through them.
1. Putting x = - x and y = - y,, the equation of curve remains unchanged therefore the curve is
symmetrical in the opposite quadrants.
2. The curve passes through origin. The tangent at origin is y = 0 i.e. x-axis.
axis.
5.. From the given equation of curve we find that for x > 0; y > 0 and for x < 0; y < 0.Hence
the curve lies in first and third quadrants.
With the help of all these points the shape of the curve is shown in adjoining Figure 2.20.
1. Since the equation of curve contains even powers of x only, therefore curve is symmetrical
about y-axis.
2. The curve passes through origin. The tangent at origin is y =0 i.e. x- axis.
which shows that x is imaginary if y < 0 and y > a. Therefore the curve lies between the lines
y = 0 and y = a.
1. The given curve is symmetrical about the x-axis since it contains only even power y.
3. The curve cuts the x-axis at (2a, 0). Shifting the origin at (2a, 0) we find that x =2a is the
Figure-2.22
4. The curve has only one real asymptote x = 0 i.e. y-axis is asymptote.
2a x
y 2a ,
x
which shows that y is imaginary if x < 0 and x > 2a. Therefore the curve does not exist
for x < 0 and x > 2a i.e. the curve lies between x = 0 and x = 2a.
1. The curve is symmetrical about the x-axis since it contains only even powers of y.
Figure-2.23
2. The curve passes through the origin (0, 0). The equation of tangent at the origin is y = ± x
i..e two real and distinct tangents which shows that (0,0) is a node.
3. The curve cuts the coordinates axes at (0, 0) and (a, 0). Shifting the origin at (a, 0) we find
5. From the equation of curve, we find that when x > a, y2 is negative or y is imaginary.
Hence the curve does not exist for values of x > a. Also as x decreases from 0 to - , y
increases from 0 to .
2. The curve passes through the origin (0,0).The equation of tangents at the origin is x = 0
i.e. y-axis.
3. The curve cuts the x-axis at (0, 0) and (a,0). Shifting the origin to (a,0) we find that
π
equations of tangents at (a,0) are y = ± 1 whose inclinations to the x-axis are tan1 1 i.e. .
3 3 6
5. From the given equation of curve we see that for negative values of x i.e. x < 0, y2 is
negative i.e. y is imaginary. Hence the curve does not exist for x < 0. Also as x increases from
a to , y increases from 0 to . The shape of the curve is shown in the figure 2.24.
Figure -2.24
ax
EXAMPLE 6 Trace the curve y 2 x 2 .
ax
Figure-2.25
2. The curve passes through origin (0, 0) and the equations of tangents at origin are
3. Putting y = 0, we have x =0, -a i.e. the curve cuts the x-axis at (0,0) and (-a, 0). Shifting the
Again putting x = 0, y = 0 i.e. the curve cuts the y-axis only at the origin.
5. For x < - a, the curve does not exist. Similarly for x > a the curve does not exist. Also
as x a, y 2 .
2. The curve passes through the origin. The line x = 0 i.e. y-axis is tangent line at the origin.
Figure-2.26
3. When x = 0, y =0 i.e. the curve crosses the y-axis only at the origin. Again when y = 0,
x =0, ± 1 i.e. the curve crosses the x-axis at the points (0,0), (1,0) and (-1,0). Shifting the
origin at (1, 0) and (-1, 0), we find that equations of tangent line at these points are x = 1 and
x = -1 respectively.
5. We have dy
1 1 3x2
and
d2y
1 18 xy 4
2 y 1 3x2
2
.
2
dx 3 y dx 2 9 y6
dy 1
Also 0 when x .
dx 3
1/3
These values of x will give the maximum or minimum value of y which are 1 1
3 3 3
1/3
and 1 1 1/3
respectively i.e. 2 2 1 / 3 respectively.
and
3 3 3 3 3
y 3 x 1 x 1 x
When x > 0 but < 1, y is positive. When x > 1, y is negative and tends to as x .
Similarly when x lies between 0 and -1, y is negative and when x is negative and numerically
greater than 1, y is positive and tends to as x tends to .
From these points the approximate shape of curve is given in adjoining Figure 2.26.
1. The given curve is symmetrical about both axis, about y = x, y = - x and in the opposite
quadrants.
2. The curve passes through the origin. The tangents at the origin are x 2 y 2 0
3. The curve crosses the coordinate axes only at the origin. For y = x, we get 2x6 = a2x4,
or x = 0, x = ± a which shows that the curve crosses the line y = x at (0,0), a , a and
2 2 2
a a .The value of dy at a a a a
, , is -1 i.e. tangent to the curve at ,
2 2 dx 2 2 2 2
3π
is inclined to the x – axis at an angle .
4
With the above data and using symmetry, the shape of the curve is shown in the Figure 2.27.
Figure-2.27
2. The curve passes through the origin. The tangents at the origin are y2 = 0 or y = 0 and
Figure-2.28
1. The curve is not symmetrical about the coordinate axis or about the line y = x or in
opposite quadrants.
2. The curve does not pass through origin.
3. The curve cuts the x-axis at ( -6, 0) and y-axis at (0, 1), (0, 2), (0, 3).
4. The given curve has no asymptotes.
5. From the given equation, it is clear that when 0 < y < 1, x is negative as all the three
factors are negative and becomes zero when y = 1.
When 1 < y < 2, x is positive as one factor is positive and two factors are negative. Also x
becomes zero when y = 2.
When 2 < y < 3, x is negative as two factors are positive and one factor is negative. Also x
becomes zero when y = 3.
When y > 3, x is positive and when y < 0, x is negative.
6. Form the following the table of values of x and y:
With the help of these points the shape of the curve is shown in the figure 2.29.
Figure- 2.29
1. The curve is symmetrical about both the coordinate axis since the equation contains even
powers of both x and y.
2. The curve passes through origin. Tangents at origin are given by x 2 y 2 0 y x
which represents two real and distinct tangents at the origin. Hence the origin is a node.
3. Putting x = 0 in (i), we get y2 = 0 y 0 .Therefore curve cuts the y-axis
axis at (0, 0).Again
putting y = 0 in (i), we get x 2 a 2 0 x a , i.e. curve cuts the x-axis
x at (a, 0) and
(-a,, 0).In order to find the equation of tangent at ((a,, 0), we shift the origin at (a,
( 0). If
(X, Y) are the new co-ordinates,
ordinates, then we have
X x a x X a and Y y 0 y Y
Substituting these values in Eq. (i), we get
x -a -a/2
/2 0 a/2 a
y 0 0.39 a 0 0.39 a 0
With the help of these points the shape of the curve is shown in the figure 2.30.
Figure-2.30