What Makes A Good Layout
What Makes A Good Layout
Layout involves the relative positioning of transformed resources within operations and
processes and the allocation of tasks to the resources, which together dictate the flow of
transformed resources through the operation or process .
Page 1 of 8
Cell Layout
Product Layout
Advantages:
Flexibility: Suitable for large, customized products or projects that require specific, individual
designs.
Less Material Movement: Reduces the need for moving the product, which can be difficult or
expensive for large projects.
Customized Production: Allows for the production of highly specialized and unique products.
Disadvantages:
High Transportation Costs: Bringing all necessary resources to the product can increase
transportation costs for materials, tools, and personnel.
Coordination Challenges: Since different departments or teams need to bring their resources
to the product, coordination and scheduling can be complex.
Space Requirements: Requires a large, open workspace to accommodate the product and the
movement of resources.
Common Applications:
Construction Projects: Buildings, bridges, and roads are examples of fixed-position layouts
where the structure being built remains stationary.
Shipbuilding: Ships are constructed in dry docks, and resources are brought to the site.
Aircraft Manufacturing: Aircraft are assembled in one location due to their size, with
components and personnel moving to the aircraft for assembly.
Page 2 of 8
In summary, a fixed-position layout is best suited for industries or projects where the product is
large, immobile, or highly customized, and the efficiency comes from moving resources rather
than the product.
Advantages:
Flexibility: It allows for greater flexibility in handling a wide variety of products and
processes. Since similar equipment is grouped, it can accommodate custom jobs or
varying production requirements.
Specialization: Workers and machines are specialized in their specific tasks, leading to
better quality and expertise in each function.
Efficient Use of Equipment: Machines and resources are shared across multiple
products or tasks, improving equipment utilization.
Disadvantages:
Complex Scheduling: Because products or materials can follow different paths,
scheduling and coordinating tasks can be more complicated compared to other layouts,
like a product layout.
Longer Lead Times: Materials and products may need to travel longer distances
between processes, which can increase production time and handling costs.
Material Handling Costs: Since products have to be moved between functional areas,
material handling can be more complex and expensive.
Page 3 of 8
Space Requirements: It may require more space because of the distance between
different functional areas.
Common Applications:
Job Shops: Workshops that produce small batches of custom products, such as precision
machining shops or metal fabrication shops.
Hospitals: Functional layouts are often used in healthcare settings, where different
departments (such as radiology, surgery, and laboratory) are organized by function.
Service Industries: Banks, post offices, or repair shops where specific tasks are
performed in designated areas (like a teller counter, loan department, etc.).
A cellular layout (or cell layout) is a type of facility layout that groups different
machines or workstations together to create a "cell" that is dedicated to producing a family of
similar products. This layout design is often used to streamline production processes by
combining the efficiency of a product layout with the flexibility of a functional layout.
Advantages:
Page 4 of 8
Reduced Setup Time: Because the cell is dedicated to a product family, machines often
require less frequent changeover, which reduces setup time.
Improved Flow and Reduced WIP (Work-in-Process): Cellular layouts promote
smoother workflow, with materials flowing directly from one process to another, reducing
the amount of work-in-process inventory.
Increased Flexibility: While it’s more structured than a functional layout, cellular layout
maintains flexibility to handle variations within a product family.
Improved Quality and Communication: Workers are often close to one another, which
can enhance communication, teamwork, and problem-solving within the cell.
Reduced Material Handling Costs: Since products stay within the cell, there is less
need to transport them long distances between functional departments, reducing handling
costs.
Disadvantages:
Initial Setup Cost: Establishing cells may require significant initial investment in
reorganizing equipment and cross-training workers.
Limited Flexibility Outside the Cell: While the cell is flexible within a product family, it
may not be as adaptable to significant changes in product design or to new product
families.
Balancing Workloads: Achieving an even workload across different machines or workers
in the cell can be challenging, which may result in bottlenecks or idle time.
Common Applications:
Manufacturing: Cellular layouts are widely used in industries that produce a wide variety
of products in small to medium batches, such as electronics, automotive, and appliance
manufacturing.
Lean Production Systems: Cellular layouts are often a key component in lean
manufacturing systems, which aim to eliminate waste, reduce production times, and
improve efficiency.
Healthcare: Cellular layouts are used in laboratories or healthcare settings to improve
patient flow and testing procedures, where related processes (like blood testing and
diagnostics) are grouped together in a "cell."
Page 5 of 8
The raw materials enter the cell, and the finished legs exit the cell ready for the next stage
in production.
In Summary A cellular layout combines the benefits of both functional and product layouts by
grouping different processes into small, efficient production cells dedicated to similar products.
This layout improves workflow, reduces lead times, and enhances flexibility for moderate batch
production while maintaining the ability to produce a variety of products within the same family.
It is commonly used in industries where both efficiency and flexibility are needed.
A product layout, also known as a line layout, is a type of facility layout where
equipment, workstations, and tasks are arranged in a sequence that matches the steps involved
in producing a specific product. This layout is designed for mass production, where the same
product or similar products are produced in large volumes. In a product layout, the production
process is organized into a continuous flow, and the product moves from one station to the next
in a linear path.
Advantages:
Efficient Production: The flow of materials and products is smooth and predictable,
leading to efficient production with minimal interruptions.
Reduced Handling Costs: Since products move in a straight line from one process to the
next, there is less need for complex material handling, reducing costs.
Specialization: Workers and machines are highly specialized, performing the same tasks
repeatedly, which leads to higher productivity and consistent quality.
Shorter Production Time: The continuous flow and streamlined processes reduce the
time it takes to produce a unit, making it ideal for large-scale production.
Disadvantages:
Inflexibility: Product layouts are not well-suited for producing a wide variety of products
or for handling changes in product design. The layout is highly specialized for one product
or a small range of products.
Page 6 of 8
High Setup Costs: Setting up a product layout requires a significant initial investment in
equipment, conveyor systems, and specialized machinery.
Vulnerability to Disruptions: Since the process is sequential, a breakdown at one
station can halt the entire production line, causing delays.
Repetitive Tasks: Workers may perform the same tasks repeatedly, which can lead to
low job satisfaction and potential ergonomic issues.
Common Applications:
Mass Production Industries: Product layouts are ideal for industries that produce large
volumes of standardized products, such as:
o Automobile Manufacturing: Cars, trucks, and motorcycles.
Summary:
A product layout is ideal for organizations focused on mass production of standardized
products. The layout is organized in a sequential flow, promoting efficient production, reducing
material handling, and ensuring consistent quality. However, this layout is less flexible and can
be costly to set up, making it best suited for industries where high-volume production of similar
products is the primary goal.
Page 7 of 8
Page 8 of 8