• Syntax= how words are put together into sentences • Origin: Greek ‘ a putting together’, ‘arrangement’
• Words 🡪 phrases🡪 clauses 🡪 sentences
• Syntax falls between morphology (words) and semantics (word meaning) Syntax: a cognitive science • Syntax reflects human ability to describe and think about mental, abstract notions. • It is how we subconsciously go from sounds to meaning • we subconsciouly arrange words to make an infinite number of meaningful phrases, clauses, sentences using a finite number of syntactic rules (rules about how we arrange words) Chomsky and Generative Grammar • The dominant theory of syntax was put forward by Noam Chomsky in1957: Generative Grammar • Generative grammar was developed and given other names such as the Transformational Grammar (TG). Generative Grammar • The main tenet of Generative Grammar is that an infinite number of sentences can be generated using a finite number of grammar rules that govern the syntax of our sentences. Example: In English the subject comes before the verb in simple, declarative non-interrogative, non-emphatic sentences. This rule generates an unlimited number of sentences Syntax methods • To formulate syntax rules, linguists follow the scientific method. • This methods involves: 1- Observing data 2- Making some generalizations about patterns in the data 3- develop a hypothesis (plural:‘hypotheses’) that explain these generalizations 4- testing the hypothesis 5- Revising the hypothesis (using new data) 6- testing the hypothesis again If the hypothesis is valid, a theory can be established. Syntactic / grammar rules • The rule S comes before V in simple declarative sentences was formulated based on the scientific methods previously described. • 2 types of rules-> 2 types of grammar Prescriptive: how people should speak Descriptive: how people actually speak Competence vs Performance • This relates to the notions competence and performance Competence: the unconscious knowledge of language Performance: the use of language ‘Competence is the speaker-hearer’s knowledge of language, while performance is the actual use of language in concrete situations’ - Chomsky • Competence is - Phonological - Morphological - Syntactic - Semantic Does syntax study competence or performance? • Chomsky’s syntax is interested in competence not in performance. • Why? • Because performance, the actual use of language in speaking is full of imperfections: mistakes, slips of the tongue, hesitations, repetition, false starts, etc. it is almost impossible to study from a syntactic viewpoint. • Syntax is therefore concerned with competence, the native speaker’s knowledge of grammar rules because this knowledge is perfect. Characteristics of syntactic competence • 1. Creativity
The knowledge of syntactic rules enables
speakers to produce and understand sentences never heard before Characteristics of syntactic competence 2. Grammaticality Knowledge of syntax allows speakers to decide about the grammaticality of sentences: A. The girl found X B. The girl found a coin of 25 cents √ A. Like I sailing X B. I like sailing. √ Characteristics of syntactic competence • 3. Recognition of different structures with equivalent meanings Example: an active sentence and its passive equivalent A. All students read the novel. B. The novel was read by all students. A and B have the same meaning. Characteristics of syntactic competence • 4. Recognition of syntactic ambiguity: the case of identical structures with different meaning The ability to recognize ambiguous expressions and assign different interpretations to them. Practice • Exercise1 A. Identify the ambiguity in the following sentences
1. The old lady hit the thief with an umbrella.
2. We bought the house on the hill.
B. Using immediate constituent analysis (phrases),
analyze the two sentences in A. Does this method help to capture the ambiguity in the sentences? • Exercise2 Identify ambiguity in the following sentences, and give all possible interpretations. 1- Samantha is eager to please. 2- Samantha is easy to please. 3- Visiting relatives can be tiresome. 4- The shooting of the hunters occurred at dawn 5- The tourist objected to the guide that they couldn’t hear. 6- Flying planes can be dangerous 7- The Chinese history teacher is absent. 8- They took the animal to the small animal hospital. 9- The computer is ready for use. 10- I saw an elephant in my pajamas.