LAB20704
LAB20704
Note: The source of the technical material in this volume is the Professional
Engineering Development Program (PEDP) of Engineering Services.
Warning: The material contained in this document was developed for Saudi
Aramco and is intended for the exclusive use of Saudi Aramco’s
employees. Any material contained in this document which is not
already in the public domain may not be copied, reproduced, sold, given,
or disclosed to third parties, or otherwise used in whole, or in part,
without the written permission of the Vice President, Engineering
Services, Saudi Aramco.
CONTENTS PAGES
OIL FIELD WATERS, ASSOCIATED PROBLEMS, AND DISPOSAL
METHODS ............................................................................................................. 1
Produced Water ........................................................................................... 1
Injection Water ............................................................................................ 3
Reasons for Treating Oil Field Waters ........................................................ 3
Disposal of Produced Water and Desalter Wash Water .............................. 3
FACTORS AFFECTING FORMATION, PREVENTION, AND REMOVAL
OF MINERAL SCALES IN OIL FIELD WATERS............................................... 4
Common Scales........................................................................................... 4
Factors Influencing Scale Formation........................................................... 4
Concentration of the Scale Forming Ions ........................................ 4
pH .................................................................................................... 6
Temperature ..................................................................................... 9
Pressure.......................................................................................... 10
Total Dissolved Solids ................................................................... 12
Scale Prevention ........................................................................................ 14
Avoiding Incompatible Waters ...................................................... 14
Dilution .......................................................................................... 14
pH Control ..................................................................................... 14
Removal of Scale-Forming Ions .................................................... 16
Scale Control Chemicals................................................................ 16
Nonchemical Scale Control Devices.............................................. 16
Scale Removal........................................................................................... 16
Identification of the Scale .............................................................. 16
Chemical Cleaners ......................................................................... 18
Pressure.......................................................................................... 31
Water Velocity ............................................................................... 31
Galvanic Effects............................................................................. 31
Deposits and Concentration Cells .................................................. 31
Cavitation....................................................................................... 32
Methods for Corrosion Control ................................................................. 32
Exclusion of Oxygen ..................................................................... 32
Inhibitors........................................................................................ 33
Coatings and Linings ..................................................................... 33
Cathodic Protection........................................................................ 34
Materials Selection......................................................................... 34
Chemical Removal of Dissolved Gases ......................................... 34
Design Factors ............................................................................... 35
Corrosion Monitoring................................................................................ 35
Coupons ......................................................................................... 35
Polarization Resistance Probes ...................................................... 40
Electrical Resistance Probes .......................................................... 40
Hydrogen Probes ........................................................................... 43
Chemical Analysis ......................................................................... 45
EQUIPMENT FOR REMOVAL OF GASES, SOLIDS, AND DISPERSED
OIL........................................................................................................................ 46
Dissolved Gas Removal ............................................................................ 46
Oxygen........................................................................................... 46
Hydrogen Sulfide........................................................................... 50
Carbon Dioxide.............................................................................. 50
REFERENCES...................................................................................................... 63
Oil-Bearing
Aquifer 1 Aquifer 2 Seawater
Formation
Barium -- -- 10 --
(Ba)
Carbonate -- -- -- 20
(CO3)
Strontium 14 40 950 -
(Sr)
After passing through production traps where some water may be separated from crude, the
remaining BS&W is removed from the crude in a desalting train. In this process, wash water,
which is usually from shallow wells, is injected into the crude to aid in the removal of BS&W.
This water also requires proper treatment.
Injection Water
Injection water is water that is injected (pumped) into the ground in order to pressurize oil
reserves. It assists in increasing the yield of oil from the field. Water injected at the outer
edges of a reservoir will push oil towards the producing wells within the reservoir.
Seawater is the primary source of injection water in Saudi Aramco. Other sources are also
used:
• Produced water
• Well water from other subsurface zones or shallow aquifers.
Injection water must be of high quality to allow trouble free injection over a long period of
time. It must be free of matter which would cause plugging of the formation.
Reasons for Treating Oil Field Waters
Oil field water must be treated as follows to:
• Prevent scale formation.
• Mitigate microbiological fouling and corrosion.
• Prevent corrosion.
• Remove suspended solids.
Scale formation must be prevented to avoid the plugging of formations, piping, pumps, and
other equipment. Microbiological fouling and corrosion must be mitigated to avoid plugging
and damage to formations and equipment. Corrosion must be minimized to protect equipment
and to prevent the contamination of the water with corrosion products which would cause
fouling and plugging of equipment and formations. Suspended solids need to be removed
from injection waters to prevent the plugging of formations and equipment.
Disposal of Produced Water and Desalter Wash Water
Wash water, when it exits a desalting train, is referred to as oily water. This water goes to a
water/oil separator (WOSEP). The purpose of the WOSEP is to remove oil from this water to
allow it to be used in injection wells. Also, washwater is taken from water wells and is
degassed before it is used in desalters. If not handled properly this wastewater also causes
corrosion, fouling, and scale.
Similar equations can be written for calcium carbonate, barium, and strontium sulfate. The
term on the right of the second equation is called the ion activity product, IAP. The values in
the brackets are the activities of the ions. Activities are the effective concentrations of the ions
in units of molarity (moles/liter) and have been corrected for the diluting effect of other ions
present. When the IAP exceeds the Ksp value, a precipitate forms. Ksp values for the common
scales at standard conditions, 25 °C (77 °F) and 1 atmosphere, are shown below.
Ksp
A low Ksp corresponds to a low solubility. Under standard conditions, barium sulfate is the
least soluble and calcium sulfate is the most soluble of the four compounds.
Often the term IAP/Ksp is calculated from a water analysis. It has the following significance:
IAP/Ksp
pH
The pH of the water has an effect on the solubility of calcium carbonate. This effect is due to
the fact that the carbonate ion exists interchangeably with the bicarbonate ion and dissolved
carbon dioxide.
CO2 + OH- ——> HCO3- + OH- ——> CO3-2 + H2O
The ion that predominates is based on the pH of the water as shown in Figure 2. At ambient
temperature, when the pH is greater than about 7.5, the carbonate ion appears; consequently
the driving force for the formation of calcium carbonate scale increases as the pH increases.
100
H 2CO 3
10 –
HCO 3
–
CO 3
1.0
0.1
3 5 7 9 11
pH
The pH of the water has little affect on the formation of the sulfate scales.
Temperature
The solubility product constant varies with temperature. The solubility of calcium carbonate
decreases as temperature increases (Figure 4).
Temperature has less effect on calcium sulfate (gypsum). The solubility increases slightly up
to about 38 °C (100 °F) and then decreases at higher temperatures. Barium sulfate solubility
increases up to about 100 °C (212 °F) and then decreases. The solubility of strontium sulfate
decreases with increasing temperature.
Pressure
The solubility of all scales in water increases with increasing pressure. This occurs because
there is a decrease in volume when a scale dissolves, as shown below.
Ca+2 + SO4-2 + H2O ——> CaSO4 (solid) + H2O
volume of solution < volume of solid + water
Pressure affects solubility in proportion to the change in volume. In low TDS water where the
change in volume from solution to solid + water is relatively large this effect is significant.
There is less effect in a high TDS water.
The calcium carbonate solubility is also greatly affected by the partial pressure of carbon
dioxide in contact with the water. As the partial pressure of carbon dioxide increases, the
solubility of calcium carbonate increases. This relationship is shown in Figure 5.
Figure 6 shows the effect of TDS on the solubility of calcium carbonate at 25 °C (77 °F) and
14.7 psig carbon dioxide.
Scale Prevention
Several options that are available for preventing scale formation are as follows:
• Avoiding incompatible water
• Dilution
• pH control
• Removal of scale forming ions
• Scale control chemicals
• Non chemical scale control devices
Chemical Cleaners
Inhibited acids, converters, chelants, caustic, and hydrocarbon solvents are available for
removing scales and deposits of corrosion products. The temperature and contact time greatly
affect the speed and effectiveness of cleanings.
Inhibited acids are commonly used to remove calcium carbonate deposits. Hydrochloric acid
effectively dissolves the scale and converts carbonate to carbon dioxide gas. Due to the
corrosive nature of hydrochloric acid, and the fact that it will generate deadly hydrogen
sulfide gas if sulfides are present, cleaning should only be performed by experienced
personnel. Chelants are compounds which dissolve hardness ions by preferentially binding to
them. They are less corrosive than acid, but are less efficient and expensive; consequently,
they are used less frequently.
Acids are ineffective on calcium sulfate scales. Inorganic converters, e.g., ammonium
carbonate, can be used to convert calcium sulfate to calcium carbonate, which can then be
removed with acid. Organic converters, such as sodium citrate, cause calcium sulfate to
become soft and swell so it can then be flushed with water. 10 % caustic (NaOH) will dissolve
up to 12.5 % gypsum scale, and 55 g/l NaCl will dissolve three times as much gypsum as will
fresh water at 40 °C (104 °F).
Proprietary scale dissolvers are required to remove barium and strontium sulfates. These are
special chelants which are often slow acting and quite costly.
Both fill-and-soak and recirculating methods can be used depending on the equipment to be
cleaned. The presence of hydrocarbon films on a scale may greatly slow its removal with the
cleaner. Two-step procedures, solvent to remove hydrocarbon, followed by cleaner to
dissolve the scale, may be required.
Iron Bacteria
Iron bacteria convert soluble iron ions into insoluble iron hydroxide. The insolubility is a
function of the precipitated oxide which forms in a sheath around the bacteria. Iron bacteria
are aerobic, but can exist with as low as 0.5 mg/l oxygen in the water. They occur in open
ponds, supply wells, filters, lines, equipment, and injection wells. The coating and slime
masses associated with the iron bacteria set up corrosion cells, cause fouling and plugging,
and may set up an aerobic environment for SRBs.
Sulfate-Reducing BacteriaSlime Formers
The term slime-forming bacteria does not refer to a single group of organisms. There are
many bacteria which can produce a slimy capsule that can cause plugging in injection wells
and other equipment. It is difficult to specifically count slime-forming bacteria. It is assumed
that when a high total count is measured it is indicative of slime forming. Slime formers can
exist in fresh and saline waters, although they are more common in waters of low salinity.
They may exist in either aerobic or anaerobic environments. Slime formers create mucous-
like mats in open ponds, masses in shallow supply wells, viscous matter in filters, lines,
equipment, and injection wells.
Identifying and Counting Bacteria
Microscopic Techniques
A trained microbiologist can quickly identify iron and slime-forming bacteria with a phase-
contrast microscope. Epifluorescence microscopy allows rapid direct counting of the bacteria
population in a sample. Specific stains are used to make the living organisms emit light
(fluoresce) when irradiated with a special lamp. It is easy to distinguish the living bacteria
from nonliving particles of similar shape and size; therefore, it is a powerful tool for quickly
estimating the number of living organisms in a sample.
Culturing and Serial Dilution
Culturing bacteria is a technique for growing species of bacteria in a controlled laboratory
environment so that the types of bacteria in a sample of water can be counted. In this
technique a measured volume of water sample is placed in a culture medium which is a
solution containing water, food, and an indicator which turns turbid or a color when bacteria
are present. The culture is incubated for a period of time and then the presence or absence of
bacteria is determined. Different types of bacteria require different media; media can be
formulated so that only specific types of bacteria can grow in it. The number of each type of
bacteria can be estimated by running tests in different media at several dilutions.
Extinction dilution, or serial dilution, is a field technique which can be used to enumerate
bacteria. The American Petroleum Institute has published a recommended practice, API RP
38, for examining injection water used by many laboratories. Other media can also be used to
match the water of interest. The test uses several serum bottles filled with 9 ml of sterile
growth media. One ml of water sample is injected into the first bottle and mixed; one ml of
the solution in the first bottle is injected into the second bottle; one ml of solution in the
second bottle is injected into the third bottle with a new sterile syringe. This procedure is
continued until six or seven bottles are filled. Each is diluted by a factor of ten as shown
below. After filling, the bottles must be set aside for one month before they are read.
Bottle Dilution Number of Bacteria
1 1/10 1-10
2 1/100 10-100
3 1/1000 100-1000
4 1/10,000 1000-10,000
5 1/100,000 10,000-100,000
6 1/1 million 100,000-1 million
7 1/10 million 1 million-10 million
For example, if bacteria are indicated in bottles 1 through 5, but not bottles 6 or 7, then
10,000 to 100,000 bacteria were present in the initial 1 ml of water.
General bacteria counts of less than 10,000 per ml are usually not significant. If 100,000 per
ml or greater are found, the system should be investigated further for signs of bacterial fouling
and plugging. The presence of any SRB is considered to be a problem. Remember that these
tests detect free floating bacteria. The presence of a few floaters indicates that a great many
bacteria may be attached to piping and equipment.
Dip slide test kits for total aerobic bacteria, fungi and yeasts, and sulfide generators are
commercially available from companies like MTC under the name Easicult® test. In these kits
the media is fixed to a dip slide, dipped in the water, placed back in a holder, incubated, and
the results are read by comparing the slide to a color chart. These kits are inexpensive, easy to
use, and useful for routine monitoring of a system. When sampling water for culturing or
other microbiological testing, precautions must be taken to avoid exposing the water to any
tubing, container, or other equipment which has not been sterilized. Sterile containers must be
used to ship samples to the lab, and samples must be refrigerated and delivered to the lab
within eight hours. For field analysis it is best if the water sample is taken from a flowing
sample port directly with a sterile syringe.
ATP Analysis
ATP (adenosine triphosphate) is present in the cells of all living organisms and is destroyed
shortly after cell death. ATP Analysis is therefore useful in detecting the presence of viable
bacteria in water. It is particularly useful in determining if a bactericide is effective in killing
organisms in a system. The test method is based on the reaction of ATP with luciferin in the
presence of the luciferase enzyme, which emits light. The amount of light emitted by the
luciferase enzyme in the bacteria is measured by a photometer and corresponds to the number
present. This test provides a very rapid count of the bacteria and other organisms in a water. It
is not able to discern types of bacteria, e.g., slime formers and SRB.
Robbins Device
The Robbins Device allows an estimate of the number of sessile bacteria in a water system. It
was developed by Robbins and Costerton at the University of Calgary. It consists of a device
with small sterile steel studs inserted into a slipstream of the stream of interest. The studs are
mounted flush with the pipe wall and provide a surface on which sessile bacteria can grow.
After a given exposure time the studs can be removed and the number of bacteria on each
stud can be determined by a number of methods. Such probes are commercially available
from treatment companies.
Rapid Check II
Conoco has developed a test for SRB. The latest version is called RapidCheck II. It is not
based on culture growth, but instead involves immunoassay technology which uses purified
antibodies to detect the APS reductase enzyme present in all SRB. In the test, bacteria are
trapped in a filtration medium, impurities are washed away, cells are disrupted (lysed)
chemically which releases the APS reductase enzyme, the immunoreagent is added, and the
sample is passed through a membrane. In ten minutes a color develops if SRB are present,
and a chart is used to estimate the number. The speed of the test is its greatest advantage,
hence the name RapidCheckII. A disadvantage of the test is its poor sensitivity. Remember
that if any SRB are present a problem exists, and the test only detects about 1,000 SRB per
ml. By testing 100 ml of water the detection limit is lowered to 100 SRB/ml. This is an
improvement on earlier tests, but when 100 SRB/ml are present the problem may be serious.
Phenols
Acrolein
Ethylene oxide
DBNPA
Carbamates
Trichlorophenols
Pentachlorophenols
Application of Chemicals
The method of application, batch vs. continuous injection, must also be considered. Since
chlorine is inexpensive it is often dosed continuously. Nonoxidizers are usually dosed
batchwise, which also minimizes the development of resistant organisms. Even so, it may be
necessary to switch nonoxidizers occasionally because organisms develop resistance to them.
Cleanup
A combination of chemical or mechanical cleaning prior to the application of a toxicant is
much more effective than the application of a toxicant alone. When a problem is detected in
an injection system, lines should be cleaned as required by scraping, chemicals, or acid.
Vessels and tanks should be opened and cleaned and injection wells should be backflowed.
Often, chlorine followed by acid is used in the cleanup.
Sterilization
Once the system is cleaned the bacteria can be killed with a high dose of toxicant. Proper
attention must be paid to dosage, contact time, and chemical compatibility. When possible,
the entire system, from source to injection well, should be treated.
Institute Ongoing Treatment
Complete sterilization of any system is never possible; some bacterial colonies always
survive. The survivors may have been protected by deposits which were not penetrated by the
cleaning or biocide, or they may have been located in a deadleg where the biocide could not
circulate effectively. To prevent recurrence of fouling, ongoing treatment is required.
When the system is relatively clean, surfactants (detergents) are often effective and aid in the
penetration of the biomass by the toxicants. Regularly scheduled cleaning of pipelines by
scraping is good practice. Biocide application is most effective when coordinated with such
mechanical cleaning.
Oil Field Water Corrosion, Influential Impurities and Factors, and Monitoring
and Control
In oil field water, corrosion is an electrochemical reaction between a metal and a chemical in
the water. The chemical in the water is usually dissolved oxygen, carbon dioxide, or hydrogen
sulfide. These chemicals, which react with the metal, are called oxidants or corrodants.
Basics of Oil Field Corrosion
Corrosion Cell
A simple corrosion cell is shown in Figure 10. Every electrochemical cell consists of a metal,
an anode, a cathode, and water. Oxidation, i.e., dissolution of a metal or formation of a metal
oxide, occurs at the anode. The oxidation reaction must be balanced by a reduction reaction in
which an oxidant or corrodant accepts the electrons at the cathode.
Phenols
Acrolein
Ethylene oxide
DBNPA
Carbamates
Trichlorophenols
Pentachlorophenols
Chemical Reactions
For steel, the anodic reaction involves the production of ferrous ions (Fe+2) and electrons (e-)
from iron metal (Fe).
Fe ——> Fe+2 + 2e-
Similar reactions can be written for other metals. In oxygen corrosion the cathodic reaction is:
1/2 O2 + H2O + 2e- ——> 2OH-
when dissolved oxygen is present, and where oxygen (O2), water (H2O), and electrons
combine to form hydroxide ions (OH-). Further reactions often occur in water, forming
ferrous (Fe+2) and ferric (Fe+3) oxides and hydroxides. Oxygen corrosion is characterized by
severe pitting.
When carbon dioxide is present, sweet corrosion can occur. The corrodant is the hydrogen ion
(H+) formed when carbon dioxide dissolves in water.
CO2 + H2O ——> HCO3- + H+
The hydrogen ion forms hydrogen gas in its cathodic reaction.
2H+ + 2e- ——> H2 (gas)
The corrosion product of steel with carbon dioxide is ferrous carbonate (FeCO3). Carbon
dioxide corrosion is characterized by mesa-type formations, which are localized areas of deep,
sharp-sided pits adjacent to areas of little corrosion.
Sour corrosion can occur when hydrogen sulfide is present. Hydrogen sulfide is also a weak
acid that forms a hydrogen ion which reacts at the cathode. Ferrous sulfide (FeS) is the
corrosion product. Black iron sulfide scales and black water result from hydrogen sulfide
attack.
The function of a corrosion inhibitor is to slow the rate of one or more of these reactions.
Anodic inhibitors slow an anodic reaction, i.e., the rate at which the metal is dissolved.
Cathodic inhibitors function by precipitating films of salts at locally high pH generated at the
cathodic site. These films are less protective than those generated by anodic inhibitors.
Inhibitors which affect both cathodic and anodic reactions are termed mixed inhibitors.
Temperature
The rates of chemical reactions generally increase as the temperature increases. This is true
for corrosion reactions also. In water systems that are open to the air the corrosion rate may
decrease slightly at temperatures above about 80 °C (176 °F) where the dissolved gases
escape due to their lower solubility in the hot water.
Pressure
When oxygen, hydrogen sulfide, or carbon dioxide are present as a gas above the water,
increased pressure causes more of the corrosive gases to dissolve in the water. This increased
concentration of dissolved gases will cause an increased corrosion rate.
Water Velocity
The velocity of water can affect corrosion in two ways. If the water is stagnant or the velocity
is too low, deposits can form on the surfaces of piping and equipment resulting in differential
corrosion cells. If the velocity of water is too high, corrosion increases due to the effects of
erosion or erosion-corrosion. To minimize these effects upper and lower limits on water
velocities are required.
In small diameter piping, 5-20 cm (2-8 in), typical velocities are 0.9-1.5 m/s (3-5 ft/s).
Velocities up to 2.1 m/s (7 ft/s) may be used. These velocity limits become prohibitive
economically in large seawater injection systems lines. In these systems the lines are sized for
velocities up to about 3.0 m/s (10 ft/s). Above this velocity, corrosion and pressure drop due
to friction increases at unacceptable levels.
Galvanic Effects
Coupling different metals together should be avoided in water systems. When these couples
cannot be avoided the metals must be carefully selected to avoid galvanic corrosion. Galvanic
corrosion accelerates the attack of the metal, which is inherently less corrosion resistant.
Deposits and Concentration Cells
Scales and sludges in equipment form concentration cells which cause underdeposit
corrosion. SRB thrive under deposits and cause pitting at these locations. Scheduled cleaning
of pipelines and designing equipment to avoid dead legs are used to deter underdeposit
corrosion.
Cavitation
Cavitation is caused by the repeated formation and collapse of bubbles (cavities) in a liquid. It
occurs when there is a pressure drop which forms the bubble (a small quantity of vapor with
the liquid) followed by an increase in pressure which causes the bubbles to collapse. The
forces present in these rapidly collapsing bubbles damage metal. Cavitation occurs in
centrifugal pumps when the pressure on the pump suction is too low. It can also occur
downstream of a control valve in an injection system when a portion of the flow from a high
pressure pump is sent back to a water tank at atmospheric pressure.
Methods for Corrosion Control
Methods for controlling corrosion involve changing the material, changing the composition of
the water, putting a barrier between the water and the metal, using corrosion inhibitors, or
installing cathodic protection. The role of a corrosion engineer is to determine the cause of the
corrosion and select the most cost-effective solution.
Exclusion of Oxygen
Whenever possible, oil field water systems should be designed to eliminate contact of the
water with air. Injection water systems, desalting operations, and water disposal systems can
be designed to be closed from the atmosphere from the beginning of a process to the end. This
involves covered tanks, maintaining inert gas blankets in tanks, deaerating source water
chemically and mechanically, repairing leaking pumps, etc. To control oxygen corrosion at
Qurayyah, where seawater for injection is treated, the oxygen content is maintained at less
than 0.01 ppm. Depending on the temperature and salt content, water in contact with air will
dissolve about 8 mg/l oxygen; therefore, the plant at Qurayyah is capable of removing 99.9 %
of the dissolved oxygen.
The majority of the oxygen is removed mechanically in a deaerator which will be discussed in
a following section. The remaining oxygen must be removed by a chemical oxygen
scavenger. At Qurayyah, sulfur dioxide (SO2) is used. The sulfur dioxide is produced at
Qurayyah by burning elemental sulfur. The sulfur dioxide forms sulfurous acid (H2SO3) when
dissolved in water which reacts with dissolved oxygen to form sulfuric acid.
O2 + 2H2SO3 ———> 2H2SO4
sulfurous acid sulfuric acid
The amount of these acids present is only enough to slightly decrease the pH of the water, so
acid corrosion is not a problem. The sulfite and bisulfite oxygen scavengers previously
discussed are also useful in oil field waters.
There are two common methods for measuring oxygen content of water in a treatment plant:
continuous in-line oxygen meters or off-line wet chemistry tests, e.g., Chemets.
The plant at Qurayyah utilizes continuous in-line oxygen meters at the outlet of the deaerator.
The instrument used has the capability of measuring from 0 to 20 mg/l. If the preset
specification value is exceeded, an alarm is generated by the meter to alert the operating
personnel to the problem.
Chemets is a tradename of Chemetrics, Inc., a supplier of various field test kits. There is a
series of field test kits for the determination of dissolved oxygen in either the ppb
concentration range or in the mg/l concentration range. These tests are based on the fact that
the reacting chemical will develop a color in the presence of dissolved oxygen.
The reagent is stored in an evacuated glass ampule. The ampule is inserted into a stream and
the tip is broken so the water is drawn up into the ampule without exposing the water to air.
The color is then compared to a standard color solution or chart to determine the
concentration of dissolved oxygen in the sample.
Inhibitors
Corrosion inhibitors can be used to minimize corrosion due to hydrogen sulfide and carbon
dioxide in water. Some special inhibitors are effective against oxygen, but it is usually better
to exclude the oxygen than to try to inhibit the corrosion.
After determining the cause of corrosion, an inhibitor should be selected based on laboratory
or field tests, or experience elsewhere. Compatibility of the inhibitor with biocides, oxygen
scavengers, and other treatment chemicals should be verified. Water soluble or dispersible
inhibitors are most often used in water.
Inhibitors are only effective when there is free access to the metal surface. Like biocides, they
are most effective in cleaned systems. A good inhibitor should be effective when dosed at
about 5 to 25 mg/l. After an inhibitor program is started, corrosion monitoring should be used
to track the effectiveness of the treatment.
Coatings and Linings
The corrosion of steel or other metals by water can be prevented by the application of a
coating or lining. To be effective, the coating must be impervious to water, salts, and other
corrosives, be free of pinholes or other discontinuities, and of sufficient thickness and strength
to prevent the water from contacting the metal.
The coating must be selected for compatibility with the environment and temperature. Proper
surface preparation and application of a coating is very important in maintaining long-term
trouble free protection. Since coatings lose some of their protective properties as they age,
cathodic protection is sometimes used in conjunction with a coating or lining.
Cathodic Protection
Cathodic protection (CP) is a method of controlling corrosion of steel by making the metal
surface the cathode in an electrochemical cell by the application of a direct electrical current.
In water this is most frequently achieved by attaching a sacrificial or less noble metal, such as
magnesium, aluminum, or zinc to the steel. The corrosion is not eliminated but transferred to
the sacrificial anode which corrodes at an accelerated rate. In conjunction with coatings and
linings, CP reduces corrosion at holidays or damaged locations in the coating.
CP has been successfully used for many years to protect ship bottoms, wharfs, and offshore
structures from corrosion.
Sacrificial anodes are relatively easy to install in tanks, vessels, heat exchangers, and other
equipment. Once installed there are minimal maintenance costs. The disadvantages of
sacrificial anodes are: the electrical driving force is limited so a limited area is protected, and
anode life may be short when protecting large bare surfaces.
Materials Selection
In some severe environments it is economically justifiable to select corrosion resistant
materials to solve a corrosion problem. Copper alloys, stainless steels, nickel-based alloys,
and nonmetallics are all possible choices. Each alternative to steel has its advantages and
disadvantages. All properties, such as corrosion resistance, mechanical properties, strength,
weight, availability, ease of construction and repair, and also costs, must be considered in
selecting the materials of construction.
Chemical Removal of Dissolved Gases
Since carbon dioxide, hydrogen sulfide, and oxygen are the common corrodants in oil field
water, corrosion can be reduced by removing these gases by chemical and mechanical means.
Chemical removal of oxygen was discussed previously, and mechanical removal will be
discussed in a following section.
Hydrogen sulfide can be converted to sulfate, which is less corrosive by oxidants, such as
chlorine, hydrogen peroxide, ozone, and chlorine dioxide. H2S also reacts with aldehydes
such as formaldehyde and acrolein. Figure 12 shows how much of the different reagents are
required to scavenge H2S.
Corrosion Monitoring
A number of techniques are available for monitoring corrosion both on-stream,
off-stream, and in the laboratory. Techniques that are applicable while the equipment is
in-service include: corrosion coupons, electrical resistance probes, linear polarization probes,
hydrogen probes, and chemical analysis of streams.
Coupons
A corrosion coupon is a small piece of material of interest which is exposed to the water
stream for a period of time and then removed and evaluated for corrosion or other damage.
Corrosion coupons are widely used to monitor corrosion in water systems. Some advantages
include the following:
• Inexpensive; a large number can be exposed economically.
• Various sizes, shapes, and forms (welded, stressed, with crevices) are available.
• Long exposure times are possible.
Proper selection of the coupon shape, surface finish, metallurgical condition, and geometry
allow evaluation of specific forms of corrosion. Rectangular or circular shaped coupons are
commonly used to evaluate uniform corrosion (see Figure 13). Proper preparation and
handling of coupons are required for meaningful monitoring. After the surface is finished, the
coupon must be stored in a dry container, in paper bags treated with vapor-phase inhibitors, or
in plastic bags with a sheet of paper treated with an inhibitor. Clean gloves should be worn
when handling coupons to avoid corrosion by contact with the skin. When removing coupons
from equipment, care should be taken to blot the coupon dry without removing any scales or
deposits. The appearance should be noted. When sending coupons for evaluation, the
following information should be included: the location, system or unit, location of the coupon
in system or unit, coupon identification number, metal, date installed, date removed, initial
weight, and other information.
The coupon should be cleaned and reweighed as soon as possible after removal from the test.
The procedures for cleaning depend on the test material and the extent of corrosion. After
cleaning, the forms of corrosion to be expected in the equipment are revealed. Visual and
microscopic observations may be helpful in evaluating the coupon and metallographic
examination may also be useful. Special localized effects may be present which invalidate the
calculation of a uniform corrosion rate and signal other corrosion mechanisms. For example, a
coupon might undergo edge attack, crevice corrosion, stress corrosion near the stenciled
identification numbers, pitting, selective corrosion (e.g., dealloying), blistering, intergranular
corrosion, embrittlement, or erosion-corrosion. In addition, there may be inadvertent
mechanical damage or galvanic corrosion.
If the attack is uniform the corrosion rate of a coupon can be calculated using the following
equation (note that the numbers in the formulas are conversion factors that are used to
calculate the corrosion rate in conventional units):
534 x 1000 x W = mils per year (mpy)
DAT
where:
W = weight loss, grams
D = density of the metal, gram/cc
A = Coupon area, sq. in.
T = Exposure time, hours
or,
The numbers in the preceding equations are simply conversion factors which are required to
calculate the corrosion rate in the desired units.
The major disadvantage is that linear polarization cannot distinguish solution oxidation-
reduction processes from corrosion (metallic oxidation); consequently, it is not applicable to
alkaline sour water with cyanide, polysulfide, or thiocyanate present.
Electrical Resistance Probes
Electrical resistance monitoring equipment, such as Rohrback Corporation’s
CORROSOMETER® systems, can be used to monitor process streams or other environments
through special sensing probes. The probe consists of a wire or element exposed to the
stream, and an electrical resistance sensing circuit with temperature compensation (see Figure
14). As the wire corrodes, its cross-sectional area decreases. This causes the electrical
resistance of the element to increase. Corrosion rates are obtained by converting the increase
in resistance to metal loss. Advantages include the following:
• Measurement can be made frequently without removing the probe from service to
obtain a history of corrosion.
• Measurements are rapid or continuous allowing adjustment of the corrosion control
program, if required.
• The technique is highly sensitive. Changes of less than a microinch can be detected.
Hydrogen Probes
In oil field waters hydrogen sulfide reacts with steel to form iron sulfide and atomic hydrogen
(Ho). In some environments the recombination of atomic hydrogen to molecular hydrogen is
poisoned on the surface by the sulfide.
Fe + 2HS- ——> FeS + 2Ho + S-2
The atomic hydrogen diffuses into the steel where it recombines to form molecular hydrogen,
which causes hydrogen embrittlement and blistering. Hydrogen probes can be used to
quantify this type of damage.
The probe consists of a pressure gauge connected to a hollow cavity in a steel probe (Figure
15). An inert fluid is used to fill the cavity to ensure sensitivity. The probe is inserted into a
stream. As the external surface of the probe corrodes, atomic hydrogen passes through the
probe wall into the cavity. The rate of increase in pressure is related to the corrosion rate.
Chemical Analysis
Chemical analysis of water can be used to track corrosion by detecting the presence of
corrodants, corrosion products, the concentration of inhibitors, pH, acidity, oxygen, chloride
content, conductivity, and other chemical characteristics of water.
The concentration of steel corrosion products (called iron counts) in a water stream is often a
useful relative measure of corrosion. Changes in concentration are directional guides that
relate to corrosion rates. Iron counts are not reliable in all systems because the solubility of
the corrosion products is low. If areas of low flow are present, the iron may be deposited in
these areas; therefore, the iron count in the water gives a misleadingly low indication of the
corrosion.
Seawater enters the deaerator at the top and falls down over fourteen trays into the storage
section. Stripping nitrogen enters the tower below the bottom tray, moves upward through the
trays, and exits out the vent at the top of the tower.
The deaerator vessel is constructed of steel and is coated with protective coatings. The trays
are constructed of type 316 stainless steel to prevent corrosion.
By reducing the partial pressure of oxygen by dilution with another gas (nitrogen, steam, or
others), it is possible to remove the oxygen from water. Since most gases are less soluble at
high temperatures, by increasing the temperature of the water the concentration of the
dissolved gases can be further reduced. In steam generating systems steam is available for the
stripping gas. In the oil field, natural gas, nitrogen, or others may be used.
For maximum stripping it is necessary to provide thorough mixing of the stripping gas and the
oxygen laden water. This is accomplished by the use of fourteen trays in the tower. The
amount of oxygen left in the seawater will decrease as the flow of nitrogen is increased.
Strippers will remove oxygen more effectively in the summer than in the winter months due
to the changes in ambient water temperature. The nitrogen gas used for stripping must have a
very low oxygen content.
If a water has a tendency to foam, the efficiency of stripping decreases. The design of the
column should provide low water velocities to prevent foaming. Chemical antifoams may also
be required.
Vacuum deaerators work on the principle that if the pressure of the gas in contact with water is
lowered, the concentration of dissolved gases in the water decreases. A single-stage cold
water vacuum deaerator can reduce the free carbon dioxide to less than 5.0 mg/l as CO2 and
the free oxygen to less than 0.1 mg/l as O2. To achieve these removal levels the units are
normally operated at a water flowrate of less than 73.5 m/hr (30 gpm/ft2). Incoming water is
sprayed on top of a packing bed at least 3.0 m (10 ft) deep. The breakup of the water into
small droplets permits the release of the gases from the water under full vacuum. The gases
and water vapor are removed by either vacuum pumps or steam operated jet eductors. Figure
17 depicts a cold water vacuum deaerator.
One to three stages are common in a cold water vacuum deaerator. The water enters the upper
stage, which operates at the highest pressure, and is sealed from the stage below by a layer of
water. The water flows down to the other stages and out the bottom.
Hydrogen Sulfide
Hydrogen sulfide can be removed from water in a stripping tower by using air or flue gas as
the stripping gas. When air is used the process is called aeration. This saturates the water with
oxygen so that it is not useful for corrosion control. In some locations, the odor of hydrogen
sulfide in the exhaust air also creates a problem.
Hydrogen sulfide is stripped most efficiently when the pH of the water is low and where the
strippable H2S forms predominate over the bisulfide (HS-) or sulfide (S-2) forms. The pH
should be less than 5.0 at ambient temperatures.
Carbon Dioxide
Carbon dioxide can be removed by aeration or vacuum deaeration. Like hydrogen sulfide,
stripping is pH dependent, and the stripping efficiency is improved by lowering the pH.
Suspended Solids Removal
Filtration is a common water treatment process used to remove suspended solids such as sand,
mud, corrosion products, and oil from water. Injection water is nearly always filtered to avoid
plugging of the formation by suspended solids.
A filter system will normally include a pressure vessel, either vertical or horizontal, an
internal water distributor/collection system, a media support system, and pressure gauges on
both the inlet and outlet. It will also include external piping and valving for the raw water feed
and treated water discharge, backwash, vessel draining, air scour (in some filters), etc.
Graded Bed Filters
Granular media filters using a single filter bed of sand are applicable to aqueous streams
containing up to 20 mg/l of total suspended solids (TSS) achieving an effluent quality of 1
Nepholometric Turbidity Unit (NTU). Silica sand is the most common filtration media,
particularly for single media filters. Other common materials used include anthracite and
crushed garnet.
In addition to the filtration media, different grades of gravel and stone are normally used to
provide a bed support structure for the media. The selection and configuration of the filter
media will depend upon a number of critical operational and design parameters. Figure 18
presents the various filter materials and their physical characteristics.
Single media filters utilizing silica sand will provide a limited removal of suspended solids.
They should only be applied to waters containing 1 to 20 mg/l of suspended solids.
An alternative approach to provide a limited improvement over downflow service sand filters
is to operate the filter in an upflow service mode. In this system the backwash water will also
be injected upflow. The drawback to upflow filter service is that there are limitations to the
flowrate that can be utilized. The media must not fluidize or be lifted during the service cycle.
If this occurs a sudden release and breakthrough of suspended solids in the effluent water will
result. Figure 19 provides an illustration of the two approaches.
The Qurayyah facility utilizes horizontal sand pressure filters equipped with an air scour. A
polyelectrolyte flocculant is injected into the water ahead of the filter to improve the removal
of suspended solids from the seawater.
Multimedia Filters
The multimedia filter is an improvement to the single media filter and has two or more media
layers. Multimedia filters are used for treatment of aqueous streams containing as high as 50
mg/l TSS with the capability to achieve a 0.1 NTU effluent quality. Depending on the type of
suspended solids in the raw water up to five different types of media have been utilized in a
single vessel. The most common configurations for multimedia filters are as follows:
• Dual Media: Consists of a layer of anthracite placed on top of a layer of silica sand.
• Tri-Media: Consists of a layer of anthracite on top of silica sand and a bottom layer
of garnet.
These configurations can increase the filter run length by 200 to 600 % over the single media
sand filters. Figure 20 illustrates a typical multimedia filter utilizing anthracite, sand, and
garnet media.
Where the raw water supply contains an appreciable amount of colloids or suspended solids
with a particle size less than 0.45 microns, the addition of a polyelectrolyte ahead of media
filters has been very successful in improving the filterability of these types of suspended
solids. This process is called in-line coagulation. The function of the polyelectrolyte is to
provide a nucleus where the smaller suspended solids can attach and agglomerate. This
provides a much larger particle size which is easily filtered from the water.
There are three general categories of organic polyelectrolytes: cationic, which are positively
charged; anionic, which are negatively charged; and nonionic, which are not charged. The
proper polyelectrolyte and dosage is selected using jar tests.
Cartridge Filters
Cartridge filters possess a limited capacity for suspended solids and should only be used for
their secondary, precautionary removal ahead of equipment such as reverse osmosis units,
which are very sensitive to fouling by suspended solids. Cartridges are available in pleated
paper and plastics, sintered metals, woven mesh screens, woven fibers, and other materials.
Field tests should be used to evaluate a cartridge filter before selecting one.
Cartridges often have nominal ratings, for example 5, 10, or 25 microns. These ratings must
be viewed critically, since they may have little relation to the size of particles which are
actually passed. Also, the ratings from one manufacturer cannot be compared to another since
standard tests are not used to develop these ratings. Absolute ratings are more reliable.
Disposable and backwashable cartridges are available. Backwashable types should be
considered unless it is certain that plugging will be infrequent. Maintenance and replacement
costs can be very high with disposable cartridges.
The effluent water from the desalter and the produced water are often collected in a water/oil
separator. This is a large horizontal gas blanketed vessel where water and oil separate by
gravity. Recovered oil is returned to the process stream and the wastewater is sent to disposal
wells. Sufficient wastewater storage is required to hold the water during short periods when
injection capability is lost. A wastewater surge tank (WWST) is generally provided for this
purpose. This tank is normally held at a low level and may hold a low level of stagnant water
for a prolonged period.
Parallel Plate Separators
These separators also work on gravity and consist of an array of tilted (about 45 degrees)
parallel plates about 5-10 cm (2-4 in) apart. Oily water enters the top and flows down. The oil
only has to rise less than 5-10 cm (2-4 in) before it hits a plate. On the plate the tiny oil
droplets coalesce and travel upstream where they are collected at the top. The clean water
leaves from the bottom. Tilted flat plates and corrugated plates are used.
Flotation
Flotation is another separation process based on gravity. It uses fine bubbles of gas which are
injected into or formed near the bottom of a vessel. As these bubbles rise they become
attached to the oil and solids and help lift them to the surface for collection.
Coalescer
A coalescer is a vessel packed with a media which has a large surface area. The media causes
fine oil droplets to coalesce into larger drops which rise to the surface for collection. The
following types of coalescing media are used:
• Polyurethane foam pack
• Polystyrene divinyl benzene resin beads
• Granular media
• Walnut shells.
GLOSSARY
References
1. Bansal, K. M., Holland, S., Chen, E. Y., “Corrosion in Wet Crude Transmission and
Processing”, Arabian American Oil Company, Dharan, Saudi Arabia, presented as
Paper Number 36, Corrosion 85, Boston Massachusetts, USA.
4. “Corrosion Monitoring Primer, Edition 3”, Rohrbacu Cososco Systems, 11841 East
Smith Ave., Sante Fe Springs, CA 90670.