Workforce Management New Book
Workforce Management New Book
Name_____________________________________
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
INTRODUCTION TO
WORKFORCE MANAGEMENT
Overview:
The objective of this chapter is to provide introduction to the role that workforce
management plays in various industries. It delineates choosing and calculating the
appropriate service level goals. This synopsis defines fundamental steps of workforce
management and the most commonly used WFM tools.
Forecasts Requirement: so you know how many employees with which skills
you’ll need in the future
Work Schedule Planning: so you have exactly the right number of staff to meet
your needs.
Time Management: To accurately determine your employees work time
accounts
Analysis & Monitoring: To monitor your results against the targets and take
effective actions if deviations occur.
Good to Know Facts
3. Analyze Forecast
The forecasting process begins with gathering historical data and applying forecasting
models to this data to predict future work load. Annual and monthly trend rates are
calculated to determine seasonal factors. Following monthly forecasts day of month and
time of day factors are applied to get daily or hourly even half-hourly forecasts. This will in
turn form basis of staffing.
4. Derive Base staff requirements
This step requires calculating the right number of staff to handle call volumes in a desired
service timeframe. Different staffing models exist which can be implemented to take into
account the call arrival patterns and queuing scenarios. Mainly Erlang models are used to
determine staff needed.
5. Plan Capacity
The two important resources which require planning are staff who attend the calls and
telephone trunks needed to get the calls in the contact center. Capacity Planning involves
inputs from all stakeholders and detailed process results in getting optimum balance of
projected demand and supply.
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
6. Plan Recruitments
Depending on the capacity plan we can understand our shortfalls in advance and begin
recruitment so that we can continuously meet our service level goals in spite of growth in
business and attrition.
7. Create and Organize Staff Schedules
An important step in resource planning is to create workable schedule to attain staffing
requirements. Base staff requirements are calculated and matched up with potential
staffing pool and its scheduling rules and constraints to design a schedule plan.
Real Results
Response Time
Response time is the equivalent of Service level for transactions that don’t have to be
handled when they arrive. This makes response time the key performance indicator and a
critical link between
company resources and
targets.
Think About?
2. Service level (SL) is tried and tested performance objective for all transactions that
must be handled as they arrive for example inbound phone calls.
3. Response time is the performance objective for the other category of inbound
transactions, those that can be handled at a later time.
4. ASA is average speed of answer. ACD is automatic call distributor, abandoned calls
are those calls which do not reach to an associate as the customer disconnects after
getting into a queue
NOTES
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
FORECASTING TECHNIQUES
Overview:
In order to manage contact center effectively all the contact center resources must be
accurately matched up with the workload. So, effective contact center management
would eventually translate into: “Having the right number of skilled people and
supporting resources in place at the right times to handle accurately forecasted
workload, required service level and with quality”.
So, one can imagine that if forecasting is not accurate then the rest of the planning
process would also go off the mark. In this module we will learn how forecast is the
basis for determining staffing needs and requirements for other resources
Forecasting Definition:
As per dictionary definition, Forecasting is the process of estimating the future. In
business terms forecast is to estimate future trends by analyzing available historical
information. In a contact center the purpose of the forecast is to predict workload in
terms of the number of calls expected and the time it will take to handle them. The
forecasting process involves a statistical interpretation of historical data to predict
future workload.
handling times of the transactions. Finally the art part comes into picture, where in
obtained results after factoring in handling times are modified on the basis of conditions
which are anticipated in the future and had not happened in the past.
Forecasting Timeline:
One way of classifying forecasting is to consider the timescale involved in the forecast
i.e. how far forward into the future we are trying to forecast. Short, medium and long-
term are the usual categories but the actual meaning of each will vary according to the
situation that is being studied.
1. Long term forecasts are done for a year and beyond and they are used for
estimating annual budges, establishing hiring plans and defining system
requirements.
2. Medium term forecasts in some contact center environments are done three
months ahead and are necessary for hiring and training plans and as well as for
accurately adjusting scheduling requirements, planning for holidays, and
anticipating seasonal trends (Month on Month) etc
The basic reason for the above classification is that different forecasting methods apply
in each situation, e.g. a forecasting method that is appropriate for forecasting sales next
month (a short-term forecast) would probably be an inappropriate method for
forecasting sales in five years time (a long-term forecast).
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
Plotting Data:
Basic data required for forecasting would include the following:
1. Sufficient historical data on the past transactions
2. Data on past Average Handle Time (AHT)
3. Past data on Shrinkage
4. Once this data is validated it can be plotted to visualize trends or patterns.
Forecasting Patterns:
There are various types of patterns, which may exist in a single set of data.
1. Trend: The long-term tendency of a series to rise or fall (upward trend or
downward trend). Trend is something which extend, incline, or bend in a
specified direction
2. Seasonality: The periodic fluctuation in the time series within a certain time
frame. These fluctuations form a pattern that tends to repeat from one seasonal
period to another.
3. Cycles: Long departures from the trend due to factors others than seasonality.
Cycles generally occur over a large time interval, and the lengths of time
between successive peaks or troughs of a cycle are not necessarily the same.
4. Irregular movement: The movement left after accounting for trend, seasonal
and cyclical movements; random noise or error in a time series.
the month of the year. For example, for a particular process February may experience
high volumes, while July may be the month with least volume. For some other process
this seasonality may be entirely different.
200, 000
180, 000
160, 000
140, 000
120, 000
100, 000
80, 000
60, 000
40, 000
20, 000
-
Jan Fe b Ma r Ap r Ma y Jun Jul Au g Se p Oc t No v De c
Mo n t h s
Other than few outliers (Data which seems to be out of pattern due to some special
cause), in the above mentioned graph, there is a seasonality pattern across all the years
for various months.
Graph: Month of the Year Pattern
2. Day of Week Pattern: As Mentioned in the graph further, in most of the processes
there exist patterns by the day of the week. As shown further, there is a pattern, where
in calls are maximum on every Thursday and Minimum on Sundays.
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
25
20 Week 1
Weeks
15 Week 2
10 Week3
5 Week 4
0
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
Days
3. Time of Day Pattern: Mostly calls are lesser early in the morning, however they grow
in numbers with time, for the process illustrated further in graph, Calls are at peak at
around 1:00 PM, and then they decline in the evening.
25
20 Day 1
15
Days
Day 2
10 Day 3
5 Day 4
0
00
0
:0
:0
:0
:0
:0
:0
8:
10
12
14
16
18
20
Time Interval
So, an important thing while forecasting is first to plot the data and look for various
patterns across time lines. Apart from looking patterns across various time lines, one
can also find different type of patterns in the data for a single time line, those are
discussed further.
Understanding Basic Components in a pattern:
a) Stable/Level
19
18
17
16
15
14
13
12
11
10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
35
30
25
20
15
10
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
c) Seasonality
30
25
20
15 Series1
10
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
2. Plot the historical data to determine patterns by WOM, MOY, DOW, HOD,
6. Arrived two sets of data should be further divided into two parts,
chronologically.
7. Create multiple models for forecasting on the first part of the divided data
8. Validate the forecasting models using the second part the data.
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
Time Series: is the kind of forecasting approach which works on naïve or simple rules,
and it uses averaging approaches and time series decomposition etc. The basic
assumption behind this approach is that using the past data we can predict the future.
(In above list points (i) to (viii) are Time Series Methods.
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
Kindly Note: For this module we will only elaborate on the below mentioned forecasting
approaches for detailed module please ask for the advance forecasting booklet
Averaging Approaches:
A step up from point estimation is the averaging approach, where several points of data
are used as a predictor for the future. This approach is clearly better since multiple
points of information are used, reducing the possibility that one invalid piece of
information could drive the forecast in the wrong direction. One can see how this
approach would serve as a better predictor by thinking back to the weather example.
Rather than just taking last year’s high temperature information, meteorologists
typically take the last 50 years worth of information to determine an average high and
low temperature for a particular date.
There are a variety of methods that incorporate simple mathematical averaging, ranging
from a simple average of several past numbers, to a moving average where older data
is dropped out when new numbers are available. The most accurate averaging approach
involves weighted averaging, where more recent events are given more weight or
significance than older events
Simple Average
So if the call volumes on the first Monday of April for the past three years have been
2400, 2500, and 2600 calls as shown in the above table the simple average would be
2500 calls. This number might be used to predict the call volume for the first Monday of
April next year.
Moving Average
A moving average is one in which old data is dropped out as a new information is added.
The moving average might be 2550 calls (dropping out the oldest data).
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
Weighted Average
Another averaging approach may be used to account for the fact that some data may be
more reliable as predictors than other data. So in this example, we might assign an 80%
weight to the most recent number, with only a 10% weight assigned to each of the prior
years giving us a prediction of 2570.
But while the weighted average approach is probably the closest to what an actual
forecast would be, it still misses the upward trend in the data that simply cant be
identified and incorporated by averaging together old numbers. While these averaging
approaches are preferable to the point estimation approach, they are still lacking in
terms of their applicability to a call center business model.
Contd…
Date 8:00 – 8:30 volume
June 2 234
June 9 239
June 16 244
June 23 250
June 30 252
July 7 235
July 14 258
Assume that the data provided in the above table which shows the number of calls
received from 8:00 to 8:30 am on the last seven Mondays. There is clearly an upward
trend in this data, and one would expect the next number in succession to be a higher
number than any of the numbers in the table. None of the averaging approaches listed
earlier would give a higher number than any one of the single data elements. Therefore,
averaging approaches will typically not yield realistic predictions when there is an
upward or downward trend in the calling information.
Forecasting Average Handling Time:
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
Many people focus too much on call volume, and not give enough emphasis to Average
Handling Time. However, as all of us know, that Workload is equal to the product of Call
Volume and Average Handle Time. So Forecasting Average Handle Time is also equally
important. And Luckily, Average Handle Time (AHT) also falls into predictable, repeating
patterns bracket.
When forecasting workload, it is critical to include accurate representations of handle
times. The handle time forecast should reflect the time of year, day of week, and time of
day, since call length may vary for a number of reasons having to do with business
variations as well as caller behavior. The handle time will likely vary by time of day as
well as by day of week. For example, AHT may be higher during the evening shift with
newer staff working the undesirable hours, or with callers that simply like to talk a little
longer during the wee hours of the morning.
Various techniques that are applied for forecasting Call Volumes can also be applied for
forecasting AHT. However before starting any arithmetic calculation on AHT, it should
be converted into seconds first
1. One should ideally first plot the data, after converting it into seconds and then
look for patterns, which may exist by hour of the day, day of the week, week of
the month or month of the year, it would also helps us in removing the outliers
2. Identify Average Handling Times for Different Call types. Arrange the call types in
the ascending order of AHT, and then if Call type 7 is more in proportion then
Workload will be high and if Call type 1 is more in proportion then Workload
would be lower.
600
500
400
AHT
300 Seconds
200
100
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Call Type
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
3. Assessing the impact of new associates and process changes would also help, as less
experienced associates often require more time to handle the calls, and as they learn
they can better navigate through the software and can finish the calls faster. It is
illustrated further, clearly the increasing experience is showing declining trend on AHT.
600
500
400
AHT
300 Seconds
200
100
0
2 4 6 8 10 12 >12
Weeks of Experience
4. Give training to the reps to use the ACD (Automated Call Distributor) modes
consistently because reps are not approaching to every call in a consistent way and tend
to give different call times, for the same type of calls
Forecasting Lock-in Process:
While some processes have dedicated forecasting teams which provide the forecast for
capacity planning and staffing and scheduling, the others in the organization depend on
the forecast sent by their respective clients. Its is imperative that we have a well-
documented forecast lock-in process to ensure that the staffing levels are met well in
time to avoid huge shortfalls or surplus. The shortfall or surplus if occurs can directly
impact the centers revenue and cost lines
Most of the contact centers have a 4 week lock-in period. What this means is that the
forecast for the week 20 will be locked 4 weeks in advance i.e. Week 16 (mostly Friday).
The locked forecast is used by the staffing and scheduling team to derive the staffing
plan for the week 20. Some programs though may follow a longer lock-in period where
the forecast are locked 6-8 weeks in advance. This gives the workforce management
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
team adequate time to plan the required resources in an even where there is an
increase in volume expected in the future
This is calculated on half-hourly basis and is tracked by the planning team on a daily
basis.
The forecasting accuracy for AHT & Shrinkage is calculated using the same method.
The forecasting accuracy is reviewed on a weekly basis so that the planning team can
make changes in their methodology to improve the accuracy with which they are
forecasting.
2. Forecast should accurately predict both the component of the workload, i.e. Volume
and Average Handle Time.
3. Forecasts should be aptly adjusted for the existence of Holidays, Marketing Campaigns,
and Special Events.
4. AHT should be given due importance and AHT for all call types should be determined
also by the tenure of the employees in various shifts.
5. Patterns may exist at Hour of Day, Day of Week, Week of Month, and Month of Year
level, they should be known by plotting the data
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
STAFFING PROCEDURES
Overview:
The key to achieving service level and response time objectives ultimately boils down to
have the right people in the right place at right times with the right resources. With a
reasonably accurate forecast, base staff calculations are straight forward. It needs
accurate methodologies which are explained in the module. We will also look at popular
myths about staffing and dispel wrong calculations. The module includes description
about capacity planning and Erlang C.
Introduction:
Running a successful contact center means managing by the numbers. Since over two-
thirds of contact center’s operating costs are related to personnel, getting the “just right”
number of staff in place is critical in terms of both service and cost.
Optimal contact center functioning requires accurate calculations of its two most
important resources. The first one is the number of staff, since that’s where the contact
center spends most of its finances and the other resource is the number of telephone
trunks needed to bring the calls into the contact center.
The challenge of staffing is the same, which is to get the right skilled people at the right
place at the right time. The first step in calculating network resources is to define
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
workload. Workload can be broadly defined as the man-hours spent in completing batch
of work.
Now it’s time to staff for the contact center. These employees are getting 400 calls and
each one takes an average of three minutes to handle – 3 minutes of conversation and
another minute of after-call work. Hence, have 1200 minutes or 20 hours of workload.
How many people are needed? Unfortunately, we can’t handle the calls with only 20
people. At 8:05, there may be 22 calls arriving, meaning all 20 associates are busy, with
another 2 calls in queue. Then at 8:15, there may only be 16 calls in progress, meaning 4
of our staff are idle. Those 4 people won’t be able to accomplish a full hour’s work, simply
because of the way the calls have arrived. In an incoming contact center, the work doesn’t
arrive in a back-to-back fashion. Rather, the work arrives whenever our customers decide
to place calls. So we have random workload instead of sequential work.
This brings us to the first math rule of contact center Staffing:
!!You must never have less staff hours in place than the actual hours of work to do.
So how many associates do we need? For 20 hours of workload, do we need 21 associates
or 24 associates or 30 associates? The number of associates required is dictated by the
level of service we wish to deliver. Obviously, for higher service levels we would require
more staff as this would shorter the delay and for lower service level we would require
fewer staff resulting in longer delays.
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
Improving
• Syndication of planning output
Collaborate & sign-
capacity 2 off plan with all • Discuss capacity plan numbers with operations
planning
efficiency stakeholders • Sign off on final plan
The answer to these questions is Improving efficiency of capacity planning. There are
various factors involved in building an effective and robust capacity planner mentioned
below:
Factors in Capacity Planner:
1. Shrinkage: is the deviation from planned production and it is any time that you’re
paying staff to be there but they aren’t available for production. Shrinkage is a macro
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
term used to describe the reduction is core staffing level at any point in a day / week due
to planned overheads, planned breaks, training or any planned activity. This includes paid
breaks, paid vacation or sick days, un-billable training time, team meetings, etc.Lets say
the shrinkage for a particular process is 30%, as per forecasts the process needs 20
advisors for a one hour period; the actual schedule requirement should be calculated by
building in 30% of the shrinkage factor into the requirement of 20 (20+30%=26 advisors).
This calculation denotes the 100% number needed to schedule so that when the
workforce shrinks by 30% we end up with 20 advisors. Overheads can be defined as a
buffer for planned and unplanned leaves. Planned and unplanned leaves as a percentage
are built in the capacity plan to inflate the staffing levels and enable people to go on
leave. Planned leave % can be calculated by dividing the total leaves allocated to the rep
by the total work days in the year.
2. Attrition: Regression of advisor base on a continuous basis can have detrimental effect
on the Planner. While the precise number of advisors discontinuing employment cannot
be determined/forecasted and built-in the schedule, based on historic data and other
factors, a projection can be made. Attrition needs to be built in the Capacity plan to give
an indicative view of how the staffing would look like some weeks down the line. The
attrition buffer depends on various factors line tenure of business, Complexity of business
and various other factors which impacts this metric directly. Ideally a contact centre builds
an attrition buffer of 6% ~ 12% per month.
3. Training Period: The training period for the new hires needs to be taken into account
and incorporated in the capacity plan so that the new hires go live at the right time
when the advisor base reduces to a minimum level of staffing which is required to
handle the projected workload.
80% of the calls to be answered within 20 seconds, and for the remaining 20% that will
end up waiting, the delay will be no longer than 2 minutes.
5. Occupancy: Occupancy is the percentage of time, advisors spends talking on calls and
after call work compared with the total amount of time they are logged in ready waiting
for calls to arrive. For example, in a half hour period, an advisor may spend 27 minutes
doing work (total of call talk time and after call work time). If this were the case then
occupancy would be 27 divided by 30 (as there are 30 minutes in the half hour), this
would equate to an occupancy level of 90%. Industry-wide benchmarks a healthy
occupancy level to be at 85-88% - if advisors are working at a higher level than this on a
routine basis, the contact centre is likely to encounter problems such as staff sickness or
turnover.
Once the forecasting workload has been calculated and the average speed of answer is
established, staffing numbers can be calculated. Since the workload is random in most
contact centers the process of matching the forecast with exact number of associates
per half hour intervals is very difficult. Elaborate mathematical models that reflect the
randomness of call arrivals are used to calculate staffing requirements. The most
common one is Erlang C or its variations.
Erlang C:
Most of these use the Erlang C traffic model as a base; it was developed by A K Erlang in
1917. This Erlang C can be used in any situation to calculate the number of resources
required where people have to wait in a queue. The assumptions behind Erlang C model
are that the events happen randomly in a fixed period of time. Erlang C calculates the
predicted wait time for any situation based on three factors; the number of
servers\representatives, the number of people waiting for the service and the average
time required to serve each person. Now the actual formulae
Where:
• A is the total traffic offered in units of Erlang
• N is the number of servers
• PW is the probability that a customer has to wait for service
As with any mathematical formulae the Erlang C is also based on assumptions which do
not match the real world scenario. It assumes that if a call attempt is made and no
associates are available to handle this call, it will stay in queue till it reaches an associate.
Which means there won’t be any abandoned calls? In reality there will be abandoned calls
and resulting workload and wait times would be lower than the ones calculated by Erlang
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
C. Linear Equation:
This is the simplest and most popular way of calculating staffing requirement. The inputs
required here is the Weekly Call volume, AHT, Weekly hours per advisor, Occupancy and
shrinkage.
The formulae is illustrated below
Staff Required = CV x AHT (Seconds) / 60 / 60 / WH / OC + SH
Where CV = Weekly Call Volume, WH = Weekly hrs per advisor (Net excluding breaks)
OC = Occupancy %, SH = Shrinkage %
To Recapitulate:
Before we start with our scheduling steps, let’s revisit the planning process.
Step 1: Choose the appropriate Service level and Response time objectives.
Step 2: Acquire and analyze the necessary planning data.
Step 3: Forecast the workload based on the types of work you must handle.
Finally Step 4: You calculate the base staff and trunk required.
NOTES
_________________________________________________
_________________________________________________
_________________________________________________
_________________________________________________
_________________________________________________
_________________________________________________
_________________________________________________
_________________________________________________
_________________________________________________
_________________________________________________
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
SCHEDULING EFFICIENTLY
& SUFFICIENTLY
Overview:
Once the final staff requirement has been calculated, the next step in the process is to
create workforce schedule. Scheduling is more of challenge in today’s world as a number
of new trends have contributed to this complexity. In the following chapter we will outline
the steps of effectively scheduling and discuss the most common problems faced. The
chapter explains the delicate balance between service and efficiency and offers some tips
on getting that elusive “just right” set of schedules in place
Scheduling Overview:
• First step is to ascertain the current FTEs.
• Identify where flexibility may exist (e.g., hours may be changed)
• Check different shift patterns for example, use four-hour x five day, eight-hour x five
day, and 10-hour x four day templates
• Account for Service level goals especially if goals differ by week, capture this in the
analysis.
• Can simulate outcomes using software such as IEX.
• Identify gaps by examining results for over- and under-staffed periods and to make
manual adjustments as needed to improve outcome.
• Identify schedule outcome weakness areas for business (severely understaffed periods)
and associates (schedules with start time variability greater than four hours)
• Make adjustments and reiterate the entire process
So, if 72 people are needed for the peak calling time between 10:30 – 11:00, does that
mean you schedule 72 people to work during 8:00 – 5:00 shift?
But if you have a group of associates that started at 8:00 it is obvious that they would
take a break around 10:30 and then a few will be calling in for a sick leave. So what has
just happened to the workforce? It has suddenly shrunk, hasn’t it? Hence you have to
take in to account the “shrinkage” or “overheads” factor when you calculate how many
people to schedule on certain shifts. You have to schedule enough staff so that when
the workforce shrinks; there will be enough bodies in chairs to handle the calls.
Forecasted
Peak Scheduling
Scheduled Staff
100
90
80
Number of staff
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0
0
30
:3
:3
:3
:3
:3
:3
:3
:3
:3
:3
9:
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
Intervals
Forecasted
Balanced Scheduling
Scheduled Staff
100
90
80
Number of staff
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0
0
30
:3
:3
:3
:3
:3
:3
:3
:3
:3
:3
9:
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
Intervals
Apart from this, other factors like length of shift, days off, break schedules and other work
rules are to be considered while building the roster. What will suit the process better? 8
hours-5 days schedule or 3 days-10 hours and 2 days-5 hours? There are multiple possible
rostering patterns that a process can adopt.
1. Structural Solutions -
• Schedule associates on shifts with flexible start time (+/- 90 min) to work around
variations in demand within a week (potential 3 % reduction in scheduling)
• Blocked staffing at a location with stable demand pattern and variable staffing at
locations with volatile demand pattern
• Target specific demographics for part-time recruitment
2. Process Solutions -
Create pool of skilled schedulers to create simulations on schedules and compare the
schedules on different KPI’s
• Leverage tools to generate schedules and roster all out-of-seat activities (e.g. training,
coaching, quality programs)
• Pooling teams by identifying opportunities to cross-skill associates
• Limit the number of teams that can avail common-offs to create flexibility in the
scheduling. Scores on shrinkage and floor losses can be used to provide preference to
better performing teams
3. Tactical Solutions -
• Monitor shortfalls in login hours of associates and use the compensatory login hours to
create flexibility in scheduling (e.g. Associates with shortfall can be used as part-timers for
peak periods)
NOTES
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
The chapter outlines the steps of tracking contact center performance within the day to
ensure that the plan is actually working based on realities of the day. It also provides
introduction to the role that Management of information systems plays in business
analysis and defines fundamental basics of MIS and Reporting.
Consistency:
It is important to ensure that associates maintain a consistent approach to handling
regardless to the queue conditions. Each rep has an effect on call load and subsequently
on the following forecasting and planning for future call loads. A practical way is to
postpone some of the after call work when the queue is building, this if defined ahead of
time can help in meeting your service targets without affecting quality
The most obvious way to monitor how well a contact center is doing is to evaluate service
statistics within the day. There are a number of service indicators that provide a picture of
how well the performance goals are met.
Some of these real-time indicators are number of calls in queue, age of the oldest call and
number of associates available. These indicators do not have an industry standard as
different size of contact centers will have variable threshold values for each of these
indicators. For example a small 20-seater contact center will consider 20 calls in queue as
a problem whereas a large 200-seater contact center will not even consider it as
significant. Similarly longest delay of the call represents a given period of time and
shouldn’t trigger a reaction in staffing but can be used to look at an over all service
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
picture. The image conscious call-centers who pride on excellent customer service like to
know that one associate is always available to take the next call. These centers will not
have any problems with service level but cannot guarantee quality and will have higher
costs.
Let’s take a look at the following example with half hour staffing numbers
TIME ACTUAL STAFF NET STAFF
8:00 76 -4
8:05 81 +1
8:10 82 +2
8:15 78 -2
8:20 80 0
8:25 83 +3
The example is based on 450 calls arrivals and an AHT of 300 seconds between 8:00 to
8:30. 80 staff should be logged in and available during half-hour to meet an ASA goal of 30
seconds or less. Seems like the manger realizes that 4 staff are missing and pulls in
additional reinforcements to meet service level and results in overstaffing for the next 10
minutes. Hence it is important to set a target at half hourly intervals rather than 6 sprints
of 5 minutes each. It is therefore important to use caution and carefully evaluate service
picture before using these real time measures to drive changes and adjustments
Let’s take a look at how a variation in any one of these components might affect net
staffing and service
1. Average Handle Time: what if staff adhered to schedule and the call volume forecast
was right on target, but calls took 30 seconds longer to handle than planned?
Time Call Forecast Forecast Actual Actual AHT Required Net Staff
Volume AHT Staff Calls Staff
6:00 280 320 56 280 350 61 -5
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
It's easy to imagine a scenario where calls simply take longer to handle than planned.
Perhaps the computer system is slow today, or a different format for the billing statement
causes an extra question per call. Or perhaps this is the week a new hire class comes on
the phones and their longer handle times drive up the average from 320 seconds to 350
seconds. With this longer handle time as the only variation, staff requirements are
affected significantly. In the above example, staffing at 8:00 would need to be adjusted
from 82 to 90 staff in order to meet an 80% in 20 seconds service goal. If staffing is not
adjusted, the service level will drop to only 6% of calls answered in 20 seconds
2. Call Volume: Of course, things might go the opposite direction and workload could be
less than forecast. Consider the effect on staffing requirements and service level if the
marketing campaign doesn't go as well as expected and call volume is 10% lower than
planned.
This time at 8:00, only 75 staff will be needed instead of the 82 that are scheduled to
work. With everyone on the phones, service level will be 98% in 20 seconds. And while
that's great from a service perspective, the overstaffing represents an unnecessary
expense.
2. Absenteeism: An Associate is considered absent if he/she does not show up for work
as per his/her work schedule i.e. Let us say an associate is schedule to work from 8am
to 5pm. If the associate arrives anytime before the shift end time he should be marked
as present for attendance records and the loss of production time will be recorded as
‘lateness’ in the associate tardiness report. However if the associate comes to work
after 5pm or doesn’t show up is marked as absent. If the absence is informed and
approved by the supervisor, the associate is marked as informed leave. If the associate
has informed the supervisor about the absence however it is not approved the same
shall be considered as un-informed absenteeism and will be marked as informed LOP
(Loss of Pay). If there is no information about the associate’s absence on a scheduled
day of work, then this is considered as un-informed Loss of Pay or a “no show”.
Attendance Tracker:
Attendance details need to be captured and stored in the ‘Attendance Tracker’. Following
details must be captured.
1. Date
2. Associate Name
3. Team Leader Name
4. Scheduled Shift time
5. Absence type: ILOP, LOP (no show), ECL (Emergency Casual Leave), Sick Leave etc.
The Attendance tracker provides valuable trends on Absenteeism which should be used
while planning capacity, workload or schedules. Following trends should be provided by
the MI team to track and monitor attendance.
• Shift wise absenteeism
• Team wise absenteeism
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
This is to change the caller’s perception of the wait time by extending the number of
rings before a caller is placed in the ACD. However it doesn’t affect the overall wait
time.
• Invoking other technologies such as IVR or callback messaging
Applications of MIS:
With computers being as omnipresent as they are today, there's hardly any large business
that does not rely extensively on their IT systems. However, there are several specific
fields in which MIS has become precious and irreplaceable.
• Strategy Support
While computers cannot create business strategies by themselves they can assist
management in understanding the effects of their strategies, and help enable effective
decision-making. MIS systems can be used to transform data into information useful for
decision making.
• Data Processing
Not only do MIS systems allow for the collation of vast amounts of business data, but they
also provide a valuable time saving benefit to the workforce. Where in the past business
information had to be manually processed for filing and analysis it can now be entered
quickly and easily onto a computer by a data processor, allowing for faster decision
making and quicker reflexes for the enterprise as a whole.
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
Relevance
Information provided to management must be relevant. Information that is inappropriate,
unnecessary, or too detailed for effective decision making is worthless. MIS must be
appropriate to support the management level.
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
Benefits of MIS
The field of MIS can deliver a great many benefits to enterprises such as
• Core Competencies
MIS systems provide the tools necessary to gain a better understanding of the market as
well as a better understanding of the enterprise itself giving corporation as added
advantage.
• Quick Reflexes
Better MIS systems enable an enterprise to react more quickly to their environment,
enabling them to push out ahead of the competition and produce a better service
Types of Reports:
• Operations/ Associate Activity Reporting
The most common of all reporting includes half hour or an hour reports for each associate
based on the log on, extension identification or the advisors name.
• Dashboards:
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
It presents a range of different indicators on one page. They are usually pre-defined
reports with static elements and fixed structure.
• Balance Scorecards:
NOTES
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
Schedule Adherence
Actual time spent vs. planned activities within the shift window.
Associate Yield
Number of hours an associate delivered as compared to the target hours.
Formulae: - Productive Time / Staffed time
Productive time includes Talk, Wrap, Hold / Transfer time, billable idle (Available), billable
training and any other billable time.
Occupancy
Measured as the time an associate has been productive talking to the customer / making a
contact out of the total production time and idle time.
Occupancy %:- (Production time) / (Production time + Idle time)
*COPC Definition:- An efficiency metric typically calculated by dividing the total amount of
time an associate spends performing productive work (Talk, Hold, ACW) divided by the total
number of hours the associate is logged into the system (Talk, Hold, ACW, plus available for
a call)
Leakage
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
Percentage of associates who are present as per attendance but have not logged in for
service delivery
Attrition
Percentage of people who have left the company
*COPC Definition: - Voluntary or involuntary staff separations.
Span of Control Ratio
The number of employees who are reporting directly to one supervisor
FTE to HC Ratio
Derived number of associates required for service delivery after banking in Shrinkage on
head count.
Training Yield
Difference between number of associates on second day of training and the number of
associates hitting production
Scheduling Index
Absolute sum of overs and unders between the required and scheduled FTE
Forecasting Index
Difference between the forecast and actual volumes
(*COPC: Customer Operations Performance Center Inc)
Firstsource Workforce Management Training Series
ANNEXURE B – BIBLIOGRAPHY
Brad Cleveland & Julia Mayben (2002) Call Center Management on Fast Forward:
Succeeding in today’s dynamic inbound environment
Gordon B Davis & Margrethe H Olson (2000) Management Information System: Conceptual
foundation structure and development
Penny Reynolds (2006) Call Center Staffing: A complete, practical guide to workforce
management
Natalie Calvert (2004) Grower Handbook of Call Center and Contact Center Management
Sandeep Gulati, Scott A Malcolm (2001) Call Center Scheduling Technology Evaluation Using
Simulation - In Proceedings of the 2001 Winter Simulation Conference
Alex Fukunaga et al (2002) Staff Scheduling for Inbound Call Center and Customer Contact
Center, Blue Pumpkin Software
Forecasting Fundamentals: The art and science of predicting call center workload – An
Article by Penny Reynolds, the call center school
The Math of Call Center Staffing: Calculating resource requirement and understanding staff
and service tradeoffs – An article by Penny Reynolds, the call center school
The Power of One in Call Center Staffing – An Article by Penny Reynolds, SWPP
Understanding Associate Occupancy – An Article by Penny Reynolds, the call center school