Laser Therapy For Wound Healing: A Review of Current Techniques and Mechanisms of Action
Laser Therapy For Wound Healing: A Review of Current Techniques and Mechanisms of Action
net/publication/277006639
CITATIONS READS
39 4,174
4 authors:
All content following this page was uploaded by Zohre Rezaee on 03 September 2015.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.13005/bbra/1626
Along with conventional medications, different techniques have been used for
wound healing such as ultrasound, electric field, magnetic field, pressure relieving beds,
cushions, etc. These methods are usually utilized for prevention and healing of pressure
wounds. One of these methods with great potential is LASER (Light Amplification by
Stimulated Emission of Radiation) therapy. Different parameters can affect the efficiency
of laser therapy. Several studies have attempted to develop this technique in different
medical applications. This paper aims to provide a review of the LASER techniques for
wound healing, sketch their background, determine the biological effects that support
the use of LASER sources in the treatment of wounds and as well as the optimal light
parameters such as wavelength and dose for wound healing.
primary effect of photon. Secondary effects are leads to enhancing superoxide anions O 2
not only depends on the adsorption of photon but production. It was reported that laser irradiation
also associated with the cell sensitivity. For this reversed the cytochrome c oxidase inhibition which
reason, secondary effects are less predictable as increased the rate of respiration with consequently
compared with primary effects27. They are observed more ATP synthesis37.
in several hours or even days after exposing. Effective parameters
In this stage, various metabolic effects As mentioned, several parameters can
are occurred which lead to production of different affect the efficiency of phototherapy. These
physiological changes at the cellular level i.e. parameters can determine an effective therapeutic
changes in the permeability of cell membrane19, 27, modality for the treatment of superficial wounds
32
. Releasing calcium from mitochondria into the or musculoskeletal injuries:
cytoplasm is occurred. This induces with changes Lasers
in intracellular calcium levels 5, 19 which leads to Different studies investigated the
stimulation the metabolism of cell and also therapeutic effect of each lasers. It was reported
adjusting the signaling pathways responsible for that coherent length of light which is exposed from
significant events required for wound repair such He-Ne laser are longer as compared with diode
as cell migration, RNA and DNA synthesis, cell laser. Furthermore, the biological effects of light
mitosis, protein secretion and cell proliferation25, which emitted from diode laser at 663 nm are less
33
. obvious as compared with the light from a HeNe
Tertiary effects are influenced by the laser. Also it was reported that when a diode laser
internal and external environment and as well as act at a higher power (25- 50 mW) and higher dose,
intracellular interactions. So, these effects are the its effect is similar with He-Ne laser5, 32.
least predictable than other effects. The tertiary Wavelength
effect expresses that why healing of one part of It was demonstrated that the wavelength
wounds leads to develop the treating to the both range can widely affected the efficiency of
directly stimulated area of wound and other phototherapy. For example applying laser at
lesions27. wavelength of 630 produces bacterial inhibition38.
As mentioned above, during primary In this regard, it was proved that the most effective
responses, the photon energy is transferred to the wavelength of light was 660nm39.
mitochondria25 and cell membranes of low lying Energy density
cells (fibroblasts, keratinocytes or endothelial). It was reported that effective doses of
Afterward chromophores adsorb this photonic near-IR light may be much higher than 10 J/cm2 in
energy and as well as convert it to the chemical particular for deep injuries. Too low doses produce
kinetic energy within the cell20, 32. This event leads negligible effect. On the other hands, prescribing
to changing the permeability of cell membrane, a dose above the highest one suitable leads to
improved the signaling between mitochondria, production negative effect40. Also even greater
nucleus and cytosol, shaping nitric oxide and also dose can induce a biosuppressive or inhibitory
enhances the oxidative metabolism in order to effect41.
create more ATP34-36 which causes to healing Power
wounds and also pain relief20, 27, 32. The power density is considered as an
Other mechanisms may be induced in intensity of the light on the tissue surface, and
laser therapy. After photon absorption, some also is expressed in mW/cm2. Indeed, it expresses
molecules such as porphyrins can convert into a the dividing power by the target tissue area18.
long-lived triplet state. This triplet state can interact Applying stronger power of LASER leads to
with ground-state oxygen with energy transfer reducing the treatment time.
leading to the production of a reactive singlet Continuous and pulsed wave
oxygen species37. Continuous wave is considered as a light
Another possible mechanism is that the source which has constant intensity while pulsed
change in the metabolism of mitochondrial and also light is a light source that emits light at various
activation of the respiratory chain by photon. This intensity32. If a pulsed laser is used, the power of
220 SAMANEH et al., Biosci., Biotech. Res. Asia, Vol. 12(Spl. Edn. 1), 217-223 (2015)
laser light is not constant. So, in order to determine the interstitial fluid absorption and also improve s
the dose, the average power is considered whereas tissue regeneration by enhancing the lymphatic
continuous wave lasers utilize the output power. circulation and drainage25, (5) Improves blood
Contact and non-contact circulation which is beneficial in blood-related
A laser can be employed in two different conditions such as Buerger’s and Raynaud’s
ways including Contact and non-contact32, 42. In injuries, (6) enhance autoimmune response in
order for providing great penetration into the skin, immune-deficient conditions such as psoriasis,
the laser probe must be used be in the direct rheumatoid arthritis and atopic dermatitis49, (7) and
contact with the skin and also at an incident angle can restore the normal pigment in anti-natural
of 90 degrees. This leads to minimization of any colored cutaneous lesions.
reflection from the surface of skin and great Laser therapy for superficial wound healing
penetration into the tissue is occurred13, 32. In surveying the therapeutic applications
Therapeutic applications of laser of LASER, healing of various wounds such as
Some investigators reported both pressure sores and ulcers, burns, skin donor areas
inhibitory and excitatory effect of LASER on the and postoperative wounds are considered32, 42, 52.
wound healing process40. Nevertheless, it was It was found that applying LASER following the
revealed that applying LASER can produce initial treatment with necrotic clearance lead to
beneficial effect on wound treatment. Due to the reducing infection signs, decreasing the amount
lack of knowledge about optimal therapeutic and smell of fluid in exuding wounds, decreasing
parameters, dosimetry and action mechanism of the pain and as well as resuming the immune
LASER, the exact mechanism is not thoroughly response which is initiated by the inflammatory
understood19, 41, 43. In this regard, some studies phase. In this regard, it was revealed that LASER
demonstrated Contradictory results which may due therapy produced beneficial effects on the
to lack of quality control5. It was reported that using cutaneous wound healing. Also it was suggested
LASER can reduce the duration of wound healing that applying LASER at dose of 8 J/cm2 were more
process as compared with other techniques effective than those at 4 J/cm2 48. In another study,
although it was reported that applying LASER it was found that applying HeNe laser at dose of 5
reduces pain and decreases the healing time44, J/cm2 accelerate the wound closure by
some scientists demonstrated that HeNe laser could normalization the cell function and stimulation the
not produce significant effect on wound healing45, cell proliferation and migration of wounded
46
. It was demonstrated that LASER can produce fibroblasts which were induced by exhibiting the
some effects such as: biostimulatory, analgesic, activity of mitochondria whereas they reported
anti-exudative, antihaemorrhagic, anti- molecular damage using LASER at dose of 10 J/
inflammatory, anti-neuralgic, anti-oedematous, cm2 53, 54. As well as it was demonstrated that GaAs
anti-spasmotic and vasodilatory 47. Similarly, LASER at 3 J/cm2 can stimulate the proliferation of
Medrado et al, (2003) found LASER therapy fibroblast55. Another study reported that optimal
decreased the inflammatory reaction and also effect of Er:YAG laser were achieved at dose of
enhanced the collagen deposition with a greater 3.37 J/cm2 56.
proliferation of myofibroblasts in experimental It has been reported that a visible light at
cutaneous wounds48. In addition, LASER has other wavelength of 630-780 nm can penetrate to a depth
clinical efficacies including: (1) Decreases swelling of 0.5-50 mm. this light has shown great potential
and inflammation related to the acute wounds in for wound healing and superficial skin conditions32,
superficial muscles, tendons, and sheaths19, 49, 50, 57
. In this regard, Karu et al (1993) reported that the
(2) Reduces the pain of some acute and chronic most effective wavelength of light was 660nm39.
wounds particularly related to abnormalities in Various studies revealed that applying light at 660
nerves, muscles, soft tissue, tendons and bone, nm improves superficial wounds and skin
(3) Increases tissue oxygenation which leads to conditions 40, acne, scar tissue and small lesions.
facilitation healing wounds which are nonhealing In order to treating large wounds or burns which
or have a slow healing rate particularly in soft the treatment area need a deeper effect, using large
tissues, tendons and bone4, 25, 49, 51, (4) Increases cluster probes have gained better efficiency. For
SAMANEH et al., Biosci., Biotech. Res. Asia, Vol. 12(Spl. Edn. 1), 214-223 (2015) 221
healing wounds which are placed at a medium red, continuous or pulsed), the treatment
depth, the probe should be pressed against the parameters can be changed. In order to achieve
skin. In order to heal open wounds, the laser probe full acceptance as a authentic medical technique,
is held 1-2cm from the wound, whereas in order to high quality studies are required.
expose the periphery of the wound, the probe must
be contacted directly. In addition, the skin periphery ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
of the wound should gained more dose than its
open area 5. Usually the functional probes of The present study was financially
LASER are existed in the form of single or cluster. supported by Ahvaz Jundishapur University of
A single laser probe (660 nm) is utilized around the Medical Sciences (Grant No.: U-93184).
margin of superficial wounds whereas a cluster
probe (visible red and infra-red laser light) is utilized REFERENCES
for the treatment of inflammation of soft tissue.
To heal wound, the periphery of the wound requires 1. Maiya, G.A., P. Kumar, and L. Rao, Effect of
higher dose (3-4 J/cm2) while the open wound low intensity helium-neon (He-Ne) laser
requires a lower dose (0.5 J/cm2) 5, 32. It was irradiation on diabetic wound healing dynamics.
demonstrated that for open wound, a lower dosage Photomedicine and Laser Therapy, 2005; 23(2):
p. 187-190.
are used as compared with the skin-covered
2. Poltawski, L. and T. Watson, Transmission of
periphery because the laser light is more absorbed therapeutic ultrasound by wound dressings.
in the unprotected wound. Wounds, 2007.
It was revealed that applying LASER at 3. Cutting, K.F., Electric stimulation in the
wavelength of 630 nm caused to bacterial inhibition treatment of chronic wounds. WOUNDS UK,
which may be an important consideration when 2006; 2(1): p. 62.
selecting the correct wavelength for infected 4. Enwemeka, C.S., et al., The efficacy of low-
wounds38. An infected ulcer can be treated twice power lasers in tissue repair and pain control: a
weekly until the infection clears. meta-analysis study. Photomedicine and Laser
Therapy, 2004; 22(4): p. 323-329.
It was found that LASER should expose
5. Tuner, J. and L. Hode, Laser therapy: clinical
acute wounds daily whereas chronic wounds practice and scientific background: a guide for
should be healed 1-2 times a week32. In order to research scientists, doctors, dentists,
healing chronic wound, it requires more treatment veterinarians and other interested parties within
intervals, as two or three times during a week are the medical field. 2002; Prima Books AB.
considered as the maximum32. 6. Mester, E., et al., Lasers in clinical practice. Acta
Tunér et al(2002) reported that it is more chirurgica Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae,
beneficial to apply 3-4 treatments a week with 1967; 9(3): p. 349-357.
moderate doses as compared with utilizing higher 7. Yeh, N.G., C.-H. Wu, and T.C. Cheng, Light-
emitting diodes—Their potential in biomedical
doses and fewer treatments time5.
applications. Renewable and Sustainable Energy
Reviews, 2010. 14(8): p. 2161-2166.
CONCLUSION 8. Dias, I.F.L., et al., Efeitos da luz em sistemas
biológicos. Semina: Ciências Exatas e
This paper shows that laser is an effective Tecnológicas, 2009; 30(1): p. 33-40.
therapeutic modality to promote healing of some 9. Houreld, N. and H. Abrahamse, In vitro exposure
wounds. The main biological effects of this of wounded diabetic fibroblast cells to a helium-
therapeutic technique are related to the decrease neon laser at 5 and 16 J/cm2. Photomedicine
in inflammatory cells, increased fibroblast and laser surgery, 2007; 25(2): p. 78-84.
10. Whelan, H.T., et al., Effect of NASA light-
proliferation, angiogenesis stimulation, formation
emitting diode irradiation on wound healing.
of granulation tissue and also increased collagen Journal of clinical laser medicine & surgery,
synthesis. Also biological effects of laser will be 2001; 19(6): p. 305-314.
affected by some parameters such as energy 11. Gál, P., et al., Histological assessment of the
density, wavelength and amount of dose. With effect of laser irradiation on skin wound healing
respect to the type of applied laser (visible or infra- in rats. Photomedicine and Laser Therapy, 2006.
222 SAMANEH et al., Biosci., Biotech. Res. Asia, Vol. 12(Spl. Edn. 1), 217-223 (2015)
40. Kipshidze, N., et al., Low power helium: Neon inflammatory effect of 830nm laser light using
laser irradiation enhances production of vascular C-reactive protein levels. Braz Dent J, 2001;
endothelial growth factor and promotes growth 12(3): p. 187-90.
of endothelial cells in vitro. Lasers in surgery 51. Kubota, J., Defocused diode laser therapy (830
and medicine, 2001; 28(4): p. 355-364. nm) in the treatment of unresponsive skin ulcers:
41. Coombe, A., et al., The effects of low level laser a preliminary trial. Journal of cosmetic and laser
irradiation on osteoblastic cells. Clinical therapy, 2004; 6(2): p. 96-102.
orthodontics and research, 2001; 4(1): p. 3-14. 52. Baxter, C.D. and G.W. Waylonis, Therapeutic
42. Pontinen, P., Guidelines for LLLT. Low Level, lasers: theory and practice. American Journal
1992. of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation, 1995;
43. Karu, T., et al., Biostimulating Action of Low- 74(4): p. 327.
Intensity Monochromatic. Laser Chem, 1984; 53. Hawkins, D. and H. Abrahamse, Biological
5: p. 19-25. effects of helium-neon laser irradiation on normal
44. Baxter, D., Low intensity laser therapy. and wounded human skin fibroblasts.
Electrotherapy, Evidence Based Practice, 2008; Photomedicine and Laser Therapy, 2005; 23(3):
p. 171-189. p. 251-259.
45. Allendorf, J.D., et al., Helium neon laser 54. Hawkins, D.H. and H. Abrahamse, The role of
irradiation at fluences of 1, 2, and 4 J/cm2 failed laser fluence in cell viability, proliferation, and
to accelerate wound healing as assessed by both membrane integrity of wounded human skin
wound contracture rate and tensile strength. fibroblasts following helium neon laser
Lasers in surgery and medicine, 1997; 20(3): p. irradiation. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine,
340-345. 2006; 38(1): p. 74-83.
46. Colver, G. and G. Priestley, Failure of a helium 55. Pereira, A.N., et al., Effect of low power laser
neon laser to affect components of wound healing irradiation on cell growth and procollagen
in vitro. British Journal of Dermatology, 1989; synthesis of cultured fibroblasts. Lasers in
121(2): p. 179-186. surgery and medicine, 2002; 31(4): p. 263-267.
47. Trelles, M., et al., The action of low reactive 56. Pourzarandian, A., et al., Effect of low-level Er:
level laser therapy (LLLT) on mast cells. Laser YAG laser irradiation on cultured human gingival
Therapy, 1989; 1(1): p. 27-30. fibroblasts. Journal of periodontology, 2005;
48. Medrado, A.R., et al., Influence of low level laser 76(2): 187-193.
therapy on wound healing and its biological 57. Moore, P., et al., Effect of wavelength on low
action upon myofibroblasts. Lasers in surgery intensity laser irradiation stimulated cell
and medicine, 2003; 32(3): p. 239-244. proliferation in vitro. Lasers in surgery and
49. Woodruff, L.D., et al., The efficacy of laser medicine, 2005; 36(1): p. 8-12.
therapy in wound repair: a meta-analysis of the 58. Greppi, I., Diode laser hair removal of the black
literature. Photomedicine and laser surgery, patient. Lasers in surgery and medicine, 2001;
2004; 22(3): p. 241-247. 28(2): p. 150-155.
50. Freitas, A., et al., Assessment of anti-