tutorial2
tutorial2
Tutorial 2
3. [Submission Problem for Group 3] Let P (x), Q(x), and R(x) be the statements “x is a clear
explanation”, “x is satisfactory”, and “x is an excuse”, respectively. Suppose that the domain
for x consists of all English text. Express each of these statements using quantifiers, logical
connectives, and P (x), Q(x) and R(x).
(a) All clear explanations are satisfactory.
(b) Some excuses are unsatisfactory.
(c) Some excuses are not clear explanations.
(d) Does (c) follow from (a) and (b)?
4. [Submission Problem for Group 4] For each of the following propositions, indicate which of
these are false when the domain ranges over a) Z>0 , b) Z, c) R
(a) ∀x∃y : 2x − y = 0.
(b) ∀x∃y : x − 2y = 0.
(c) ∀x, x < 10 =⇒ (∀y, y < x =⇒ y < 9)
(d) ∀x∃y, [y > x ∧ ∃z, y + z = 100]
5. [Bonus] Let P (x, y) be a statement about the variables x and y. Consider the following two
statements: A := (∀x)(∃y)(P (x, y)) and B := (∃y)(∀x)(P (x, y)). The universe is the set of
integers.
1-1
1-2
(a) Prove: (∀P )(B =⇒ A) (“B always implies A” i.e., for all P , if B is true then A is
true).
(b) Prove: ¬(∀P )(A =⇒ B) (i. e., A does not necessarily imply B). In other words,
(∃P )(A =⇒ ̸ B). To prove this, you need to construct a counterexample, i. e., a
statement P (x, y) such that the corresponding statement A is true but B is false. Make
P (x, y) as simple as possible.
6. [Bonus] Let r be a positive real number satisfying r2 = r + 1. Using induction, show that for
all n ∈ N, Fn ≥ rn−2 .