Group 23 Concept Paper11 2
Group 23 Concept Paper11 2
A RESEARCH PROJECT
November 2024
INTRODUCTION
On the other hand, even though AC servo motors offer great promise,
integration into automated shaping systems does not come easy. Some of the
concerns include system integration, control strategy tuning, and cost effectiveness
while upgrading motor systems. Optimizing the performance of AC servo motors in
shaping systems requires both an understanding of the characterization of the
motors and that of the needs of individual shaping processes in different
applications.
This study aims to explore the role of AC servo motors in food shaping
applications, particularly focusing on how these motors can help maintain product
consistency, quality, and operational efficiency. By examining the advantages and
challenges associated with integrating these motors into food processing systems,
the research will contribute valuable insights that can guide future innovations in
automation for the food industry.
the study on Process Control of Food Using an AC Servo Motor holds valuable
contributions for society, universities, and industry:
For society, it ensures improved food quality, safety, and affordability while
promoting sustainability and energy efficiency in food production.
For universities, it fosters interdisciplinary research, enhances learning
opportunities for students, and contributes to advancing the fields of
automation and food engineering.
For industry, it offers practical solutions to reduce costs, improve consistency,
and enhance productivity, positioning businesses for greater profitability and
competitiveness.
By bridging academic research with practical applications, this study has the
potential to make a lasting impact on both the food production industry and the
communities it serves.
To achieve constant quality and efficiency, the food industry needs to precisely
regulate multiple mechanical operations, including mixing, kneading, and shaping,
when producing food. The manual or less sophisticated automated processes used
in traditional dough processing methods sometimes result in inconsistent dough
texture and quality. Despite the fact that AC servomotors provide better control over
position, speed, and torque, there is still much to learn about using them in food
processing, especially when it comes to maximising performance at different loads
and speeds. The need for an advanced control strategy is highlighted by the
difficulties in managing dynamic load situations, such as changing dough
consistency and machine speed needs. When to create an optimal process control
system for food processing utilising AC servomotors that can guarantee high
precision, flexibility to adjust to dynamic loads, and consistent product quality is the
issue this research attempts to solve. In particular, this study will examine the
shortcomings of current AC servomotor control methods in this situation and suggest
ways to get over these difficulties.
1. AC servo motors can replace traditional motors with closed-loop control systems,
providing precise position, speed, and torque control. This improves shaping
accuracy and reduces energy consumption by adjusting power usage to match load
requirements, resulting in better efficiency and precision.
3. The balance between high accuracy and operational cost-effectiveness can be achieved
by right-sizing the AC servo motor for the specific task to avoid unnecessary energy
consumption. Energy-efficient programming ensures that the motor adjusts its power based
on load requirements, minimizing waste. Predictive maintenance systems help reduce
unexpected downtime and maintenance costs by monitoring motor health and anticipating
issues before they become costly. Optimizing control systems for dynamic load management
also ensures that energy use is kept to a minimum while maintaining the required accuracy
and precision for the automated shaping process.
4. AC servo motors reduce energy consumption by adjusting power usage according to the
load, unlike traditional motors, which often operate at a constant power level regardless of
the demand. This dynamic power adjustment leads to less energy waste and lower operating
costs. Furthermore, the precise control offered by AC servo motors results in smoother
operation, reducing unnecessary strain on the motor and system components, which in turn
reduces wear and extends the lifespan of both the motor and the overall system.
5. The performance of AC servo motors can be optimized by fine-tuning the control systems
to allow for real-time adjustments of speed and torque based on varying load conditions.
Advanced feedback loops ensure that the motor responds precisely to operational needs,
maintaining high accuracy. Additionally, using energy-efficient drive systems helps reduce
power consumption while maintaining optimal performance. Upgrading sensors and software
improves monitoring and control capabilities, enabling faster and more accurate responses,
ensuring that the system meets the speed, accuracy, and efficiency demands of modern
production lines.
These problem statements point out the key challenges of industries that use
automated shaping systems and suggest the possibility of AC servo motors to
overcome such problems.
PROCESS
INPUT OUTPUT
1.AC Servo 1. Control System 1.Quality of
Motor and Algorithm Food
Parameters Implementation 2. Production
2. Monitoring and
2. Food Efficiency
Feedback
Properties 3. Adjusting AC 3. System
3. Process Servo Motor Feedback for
Variables Parameters Continuous
4. Sensor Data 4. Data Analysis Improvement
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURES
The use of AC servo motors in automation has been widely studied, particularly in robotic
applications. Research by [Yin et al.,
2016](https://doi.org/10.1109/ACCESS.2016.25 [1]54512) demonstrated that AC servo
motors, when combined with advanced feedback control systems, significantly enhanced the
accuracy and dynamic response in robotic arms used for material handling and shaping
tasks. The precision offered by these motors was found to reduce errors and improve
consistency in high-volume production environments.
AC servo motors are also extensively used in CNC (Computer Numerical Control)
machines**, where high precision is critical for shaping metal, plastics, and composite
materials. A study by [Mou et al., 2019](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jom.2019.06.002) focused
on optimizing the performance of AC servo motors in CNC milling machines. The research
found that AC servos provided more precise control over feed rates and tool positioning,
resulting in improved dimensional accuracy and surface finish. Moreover, the energy
efficiency of these motors was significantly higher compared to traditional DC motors,
contributing to reduced operational costs over time.
One of the key advantages of AC servo motors is their energy efficiency, which has been a
focal point in research aimed at reducing the environmental and financial costs of industrial
automation. In a comparative study by [Liu et al.,
2017](https://doi.org/10.1109/IECON.2017.8216884), the researchers highlighted that AC
servo motors, in conjunction with advanced power management strategies, could reduce
energy consumption by up to 30% in automated systems compared to older motor
technologies. The study also emphasized that precise motor control helps reduce wasted
energy and improves system stability, thereby enhancing overall efficiency.
While the potential benefits of AC servo motors are well-documented, integrating them into
existing automated shaping systems poses several challenges. Research by [Tao et al.,
2018](https://doi.org/10.1109/TIM.2018.2875127) discussed the complexities involved in
retrofitting legacy systems with AC servo motors. The study highlighted the need for
specialized control algorithms and tuning methods to ensure smooth integration and optimal
performance. Additionally, it stressed the importance of addressing the cost-effectiveness of
such upgrades, especially for small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), which may face
financial barriers to implementing cutting-edge technologies.
5. Control Strategies and Feedback Mechanisms:
Conclusion:
The literature demonstrates that AC servo motors hold considerable promise in enhancing
both the precision and efficiency of automated shaping systems. While their integration
offers distinct advantages in terms of accuracy, energy efficiency, and operational
performance, challenges related to system optimization, cost, and control remain. This
research will build on the findings from existing studies to explore the practical applications
of AC servo motors in automated shaping systems, focusing on overcoming integration
challenges and optimizing the motors for enhanced performance in real-world manufacturing
environments.
1.How can the dynamic properties of food (e.g., viscosity, texture, moisture content)
be monitored and incorporated into real-time control algorithms for AC servo motors?
- Advanced sensors like torque sensors, rheometers, and moisture analyzers built into the
mixing machine can be used to track the dynamic qualities of dough. Continuous data on
dough behavior while mixing is provided by these sensors. In order to guarantee ideal mixing
conditions, the data is processed using machine learning algorithms or predictive models,
which modify the AC servo motor parameters (such as speed, torque, and mixing duration)
in real time.
2. How does the implementation of an adaptive control system for AC servo motors
improve food quality consistency compared to conventional mixing systems?
3. What impact does the use of adaptive control systems for AC servo motors have on
energy efficiency and processing time in industrial food processing?
- Significant energy savings are achieved by adaptive control systems, which optimize
motor operations by minimizing overmixing or excessive energy input. Furthermore, by more
effectively obtaining the required dough qualities, these technologies reduce processing
times and increase throughput in industrial applications.
4. How scalable and cost-effective is the implementation of adaptive control
technology for AC servo motors in large-scale food processing operations?
- Adaptive control systems' flexibility and suitability for use with current industrial
configurations determine how scalable they are. The system can be readily modified for
large-scale operations by utilizing scalable software solutions and common AC servo motor
components. Energy savings, waste reduction, and better product quality all contribute to
cost-effectiveness by offsetting the original investment expenses. Adaptive systems'
predictive maintenance capabilities also reduce downtime and ongoing operating costs.
High Precision
High Efficiency
Compared to hydraulic or pneumatic systems, AC servo motors use less energy. Unlike
hydraulic systems, which need power continuously to maintain pressure, they only use
power while they are actively operating. Lower operational costs and a smaller
environmental effect are the results of this efficiency.
Fast Response
The shaping process can be quickly adjusted thanks to the quick response times of AC
servo motors. For applications that demand quick changes in position or speed, this is
essential since it increases throughput.
Closed-Loop Control
AC servo motors usually run on closed-loop control systems, which means they continuously
check their speed and position and modify to keep them at the appropriate levels. This
guarantees reliable and precise operation even with different loads or circumstances.
Programmability: Because AC servo motor systems are simple to program, shaping
procedures can be made more flexible and adaptive. Applications with complex shaping
procedures or varied product requirements may especially benefit from this.
Accurate dimensions and tolerances are essential for shaping processes, and AC servo
motors are excellent at maintaining precise locations. Smooth Speed Control: They prevent
jerky motions that could harm the material or lower the quality of the product by offering
smooth and regulated speed adjustments. great Torque-to-Size Ratio: AC servo motors are
ideal for a variety of shaping applications because they can offer great torque in a small
package. Digital Communication: Advanced control features and easier integration into
automated shaping systems are made possible by the employment of digital communication
protocols by contemporary AC servo motors. Lower Maintenance: Compared to hydraulic or
pneumatic systems, AC servo motors typically require less maintenance, which lowers
operating expenses and downtime. Enhanced Repeatability: The closed-loop feedback and
accurate control systems guarantee great repeatability, which means that the same
superiorly formed product is consistently produced.
1. Foundation for Understanding - The RRL provides a solid theoretical and practical
background for understanding the use of AC servo motors in shaping systems, including
their technical characteristics and advantages over traditional motors.
6. Benchmarking Performance Standards - The RRL provides existing data and benchmarks
that can be used to measure the success of the proposed optimization strategies.
1. Outdated Information - Some studies may be outdated, especially given the rapid pace of
technological advancements in automation and AC servo motors, leading to potentially
irrelevant conclusions.
2. Limited Scope of Prior Research - The RRL might lack studies focusing on specific
applications of AC servo motors in shaping systems, making it difficult to generalize findings
to your research context.
3. Conflicting Findings - Different studies may present conflicting results regarding the
performance or efficiency of AC servo motors, complicating the synthesis of a clear
conclusion.
4. Bias in Published Literature - Some studies may favor AC servo motors due to
sponsorship or industry bias, leading to exaggerated claims of their benefits or downplaying
limitations.
5. Complexity of Integration Factors - Prior research might not comprehensively address all
integration challenges, such as cost-effectiveness, system scalability, and control strategy
optimization.
6. Focus on Specific Applications - Much of the literature may focus on robotics or CNC
machinery rather than shaping systems, limiting direct applicability to your research topic.
7. Overemphasis on Theory - Many studies may focus on theoretical aspects without offering
practical insights or experimental data, which are critical for optimizing shaping systems.
Insights
Mou et al. (2019) emphasize that AC servo motors not only optimize feed
rates and tool positioning but also contribute significantly to energy savings,
making them more cost-effective and sustainable for industries relying on
high-precision machining.
3. Energy Efficiency in Automated Systems
Liu et al. (2017) demonstrate that AC servo motors, when paired with
advanced energy management strategies, provide a clear advantage in
reducing energy consumption and improving system stability, contributing to
both financial savings and environmental sustainability.
While AC servo motors offer numerous benefits, their integration into existing
automated systems can present significant challenges. Retrofitting legacy systems
requires specialized control algorithms and tuning methods, and the financial burden
of upgrading technologies is a critical factor, especially for smaller enterprises.
Wang et al. (2020) highlight that adaptive control techniques, including Model
Predictive Control, significantly enhance the dynamic response of AC servo
motors, enabling them to maintain high performance in environments with
fluctuating loads and disturbances.
Overall Insight
The review of related literature suggests that AC servo motors are central to
improving precision, energy efficiency, and performance in automation and robotic
systems. However, integration challenges remain, particularly for legacy systems
and small enterprises that may struggle with the cost of upgrading technologies. The
implementation of advanced feedback control systems and optimization
strategies, such as adaptive control algorithms, can further enhance the
performance of AC servo motors. Ultimately, the adoption of AC servo motors in
industries like robotics, CNC machining, and automated systems appears to be a
step forward in both operational efficiency and sustainability, with notable
advantages in precision, energy savings, and system stability.
The existing studies implement traditional PID control and they do not have real-time
adaptability of food characteristics such as variation in ingredients, humidity,
temperature; thereby the systems could not change dynamically according to those
variations.
There are few studies about how AC servo motors could be integrated with existing,
non-automated, or older dough production lines. This is an issue for small to
medium-scale manufacturers that cannot easily adopt the latest servo-driven
systems.
Although far more energy efficient than standard systems, the significant costs both
in installation and maintaining the AC servo motors were not studied at all in regards
to longer-term cost savings through efficiency or economies of scale for smaller
businesses.
Currently, there are a very few studies comparing the performance of servo motors
on various types of food, including bread, burgers, or various other consumables.
This cannot aid in optimizing the system to certain food formulations and product
types.
Potential exists for revealing how artificial intelligence or machine learning may help
to optimize control of a servo motor in the food-working process. The kind of
technology could be used to adjust mixing and processing parameters in real-time
with sensor information, making it consistent and efficient.
There aren't sufficient studies that have looked at a broader outlook of environmental
benefits when employing servo motors in food processing, such as energy savings,
waste reduction, or better resource use efficiency.
This implies how your research addresses how an advanced AC servo motor and
integrating real-time sensors
which include temperature, viscosity, and moisture content among others - within an
enhanced feedback control can improve how this motor reacts to variability of
properties within the consumables.
The research might discuss retrofit solutions, whereby the study will explore ways to
apply AC servo motors to already established, nonautomated food production lines.
This way, smaller or older facilities could adopt more efficient automated systems
without requiring an entirely new system.
It could be the point at which our research takes into account the function of AI or
machine learning in the dynamic optimization of servo motor control while processing
dough. For example, with AI responding to fluctuations, better consistency and even
energy saving in the long term.
Presents our study as a possible direction the study might take in discovering how
you could have possibly saved the environment through decreasing energy
consumption, resource and dough processing waste reduction with sustainable
production.
The filling of such gaps will make our study make a meaningful contribution to further
development in utilizing AC servo motors during food processing as it has technical
and economic benefits for such industrial systems.
This study aims to develop and test a control system that uses an AC servo motor to
precisely regulate dough processing. By leveraging the capabilities of AC servo
motors for accurate control over torque, speed, and positioning, We focus on
achieving consistent dough quality with minimal human intervention.
Research Design
Our team will include engineers, food technologists, and equipment operators
working together to integrate the AC servo system into a typical dough-making
setup. The key equipment we’ll be using includes:
AC Servo Motor and Controller: This allows precise control over mixing speed and
force, making it possible to respond to subtle changes in food texture.
Real-Time Sensor Suite:A set of sensors for tracking dough temperature, moisture,
and consistency in real time.
Food Mixer with Retrofit Options: Instead of needing entirely new equipment, we’ll
modify a standard mixer to work with the AC servo motor, making it more accessible
for smaller food processors or facilities that want to upgrade their setup without a full
overhaul.
Data Collection
As we run each experiment, we’ll be collecting key data points to understand how
different settings affect dough quality:
Motor Settings: We’ll record speed, torque, and mixing duration to see how each
affects the dough.
Dough Conditions: Real-time temperature, moisture, and texture readings will show
how the dough is reacting throughout the process.
Energy Use:Tracking power consumption at each stage will help us understand how
much energy this setup can save over time.
Quality Measurements: The final dough will be evaluated based on texture,
consistency, and elasticity, using both manual assessments and automated tools.
We’ll also test different types of dough, like bread, pizza, and pastry, to see if the
system performs consistently across various formulations.
Sampling Processp
We’ll produce multiple batches of dough, each processed under different settings to
test the flexibility and reliability of the AC servo motor. Each setting will be repeated
at least five times to ensure that the results are consistent. This approach will help us
determine the best settings for various dough types, addressing the gap in
knowledge about how servo motors perform with different recipes.
Data Analysis
Machine Learning Models: We’ll use machine learning to analyze patterns between
the motor settings and dough outcomes. This will allow us to predict and fine-tune
settings dynamically, enhancing the system’s ability to adapt in real time.
Cost-Benefit Analysis: We’ll look at the initial costs of installing and maintaining the
AC servo system and weigh it against the long-term benefits in energy savings and
productivity, especially for small- to medium-scale facilities.
To make the system as effective as possible, we’ll create control algorithms tailored
specifically for dough mixing. These algorithms will guide the motor settings to
maintain consistent quality across different batches and dough types, helping to
create a standard for the industry.
We’ll integrate artificial intelligence to help the system adjust on the fly. By using
machine learning, the AC servo motor can respond to variations in the dough (like
slight differences in ingredient quality or ambient conditions), ensuring more
consistent results and potential energy savings over time.
[3]G. Zhong, Z. Shao, H. Deng and J. Ren, "Precise Position Synchronous Control for Multi-
Axis Servo Systems," in IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 64, no. 5, pp.
3707-3717, May 2017, doi: 10.1109/TIE.2017.2652343.
[5]A. Dumanli and B. Sencer, "Data-Driven Iterative Trajectory Shaping for Precision Control
of Flexible Feed Drives," in IEEE/ASME Transactions on Mechatronics, vol. 26, no. 5, pp.
2735-2746, Oct. 2021, doi: 10.1109/TMECH.2020.3045444.
[7]“IJIS_13_2_093-103”.
[8]V. Marinakis, H. Doukas, C. Karakosta, and J. Psarras, “An integrated system for
buildings’ energy-efficient automation: Application in the tertiary sector,” Applied Energy, vol.
101, pp. 6–14, Jan. 2013, doi: 10.1016/J.APENERGY.2012.05.032.
[9]D. Lee and C. C. Cheng, “Energy savings by energy management systems: A review,”
Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, vol. 56, pp. 760–777, Apr. 2016, doi:
10.1016/j.rser.2015.11.067.