1

Assignment

Student Name

University Name

Operational Excellence

Professor Name

Date
 2

1. The productivity paradox is a management concept that highlights the apparent

disparity between technological advancements and actual productivity increases. This

phenomenon was first observed by economist Robert Solow, who noticed a discrepancy

between investment in IT infrastructure and resulting output levels. He realized that despite

huge computer investments, its impact on economic growth could not be definitively proven.

One possible reason for this mismatch of outcomes may lie within the organizations

themselves. Implementing new technologies without changing workflows or optimizing

processes to capitalize on their capabilities fully will limit potential gains. When companies

adopt these innovations, they often unintentionally create silos because different departments

have their own processes, resulting in internal conflicts leading up to inefficiencies rather

than balanced process integrations.

2. In the article Does IT Matter, Nicholas Carr argues that information technology has

become a commodity, just like electricity or railroads. As such, it no longer provides strategic

differentiation for companies and cannot be leveraged to gain a competitive advantage. Carr

suggests that investing in IT does not provide significant benefits anymore since everyone

now has access to the same technologies at comparable prices. Moreover, he asserts that the

widespread adoption of standard software and hardware means few opportunities left for

customization without significant cost. According to Carr, firms should focus instead on

operational excellence by optimizing their business processes through continuous

improvement initiatives rather than chasing after new, better, supposedly transformative

technologies.

3. The study conducted by Brynjolfsson and McAfee in 2008 on operational

excellence is significant because it introduced new insights contradicting previously held

beliefs. In contrast to earlier studies, their research suggested that technology improvements

do not necessarily directly lead to more productive outcomes. Instead, the accurate measure
 3

of success lies in how well organizations leverage these technological advancements. Despite

the differences between the previous work on operational efficiency and their approach, there

are a few similarities worth noting as well. Like many other researchers before them,

Brynjolfsson and McAfee emphasized the importance of data-driven decision-making instead

of solely relying on gut feelings when considering process optimization opportunities.

4. In today's fast-paced and competitive business world, sustainable competitive

advantage is crucial for long-term success. Competitive advantage refers to any strategy or

attribute that enables an organization to outperform its rivals in terms of profitability, market

share, customer loyalty, efficiency, or innovation. Operational excellence is one such

approach that can provide a distinct edge over competitors by achieving superior results

through optimized processes and systems. It involves streamlining operations through

continuous improvement methodologies like Lean Six Sigma and reducing waste across the

value chain from procurement to delivery.

5. The value chain is a framework that helps organizations identify critical areas

where they can add value to their products or services. It involves both primary activities and

support activities. The primary activities in the value chain include inbound logistics,

operations, outbound logistics, marketing and sales, and service. Inbound logistics are

receiving goods into a warehouse or distribution centre. Operations involve transforming

these goods into finished products through manufacturing or assembly processes. Outbound

logistics encompass all aspects of getting those finished products delivered to customers.

Marketing and sales involve promoting the product to potential customers, generating leads,

and closing deals. At the same time, customer service aims to ensure a high-quality after-sales

experience for consumers.

6. In today's digital age, the influence of the internet on industry is undeniable. In

particular, it has significantly impacted operational excellence and, consequently, overall

 4

profitability within businesses. The entrepreneurial opportunities of e-commerce platforms

have transformed traditional brick-and-mortar retail operations into agile online storefronts

presenting notoriously tricky challenges for small business owners, one bad review can affect

revenue streams or completely bankrupt budding enterprises. On the flip side, with higher

profit margins borne from effective market-widening beyond geographic constraints,

streamlined supply-chain management through drop-shipping characteristics that may enable-

new niche segmented portion opportunities ordinarily unavailable in offline markets will first

emerge uninterrupted.

7. Electronic Data Interchange (EDI) is a crucial technology that has revolutionized

how information is exchanged between businesses. It enables companies to exchange data

electronically, eliminating paper-based transactions and maximizing efficiency in their

operations. In simple terms, EDI translates business documents into a standard electronic

format that can be easily transferred from one computer system to another. The process

involves three main steps: document preparation, data transmission, and a confirmation

receipt. The sender prepares an electronic version of the business document using specialized

software or through manual input. This could include purchase orders, invoices, or shipment

notices. The data is then formatted according to established industry standards such as ANSI

X12 or UN/EDIFACT which provide guidelines for creating consistent messages across

different systems.

8. Semi-structured decisions are those that involve a combination of both structured

and unstructured decision-making elements. Such decisions typically require human

judgment to weigh various factors to determine the best course of action. One example of a

semi-structured decision might be deciding which product line to cut from an organization's

portfolio due to declining sales figures. While some information – such as financial data for
 5

each product line, market trends, and customer feedback on competing products – could help

inform this decision, there would likely be more ambiguous or qualitative inputs at play here.

9. A collaborative information system (CIS) is software that enables teams and

organizations to work together efficiently by providing them with access to real-time data,

updates, and communication tools. CISs are designed to implement operational excellence in

the workplace through collaboration among team members. In an organization focused on

achieving operational excellence through teamwork and cooperation, CIS can be highly

beneficial. It allows team members to share ideas quickly while maintaining accuracy, so

everyone is up-to-date on any changes or developments within the project. Collaboration

features such as chat rooms make it possible for users located remotely from each other or

working different shifts to communicate fluidly (Andrew, 2019).

10. Information Technology (IT) has a crucial role in creating a competitive advantage

for organizations, which is evident from the research findings of Brynjolfsson and McAfee

(2008). According to their article, IT can significantly improve operational excellence,

directly impacting an organization's strategic capabilities. By leveraging advanced

technologies such as automation tools, analytics software, or blockchain solutions, companies

can streamline their business processes, leading to higher efficiency. In addition to increased

efficiency through technology-enabled process optimization, IT plays several other important

roles that contribute to improving organizational competitiveness. For instance, it provides

powerful data-driven insights into market trends and customer preferences, which enable

businesses to make better decisions regarding product development and marketing strategies.

Exercise 1

In the article Does IT Matter? Nicholas Carr argues that IT has become

commoditized, meaning that businesses need more competitive advantage from investing

heavily in technology. He cites examples like the standardization of hardware and software
 6

components, making them more affordable and interchangeable across various applications.

Applying this argument to PC vs. Mac, one could say that both platforms offer similar

functionality at different price points. In contrast, Macs are often viewed as higher-end

machines with greater design appeal for creative professionals. However, PCs have proven

better suited for business environments due to their wider compatibility with industry-

standard software. Similarly, Open Office vs. Microsoft Office comparison is another

example where the central theme fits Garr's theory. Both office suites provide comparable

productivity tools such as word processors or spreadsheets, which means it comes down

mainly to personal preference without any significant differences in function or cost-benefit

ratio (Gallo, 2019).

Regarding Microsoft PowerPoint versus Tableau, they serve distinct purposes within

analytics workflows yet complement each other. Presenting information visually can be

important, mainly when dealing with large amounts of raw data which may need to be

clarified through text-based reports alone. However, some would argue against this

perspective and contend that certain features within platforms or applications from different

brands might overlap regarding functionality. Hence reducing variation again leads us to the

commonly used term commoditization. Every company has unique requirements along its

operational procedures. Considering how divergent sets can help sustain creativity & product

development moving forward without compromising measurable outcomes such as timeliness

or resourcefulness.

Exercise 2

Nicholas Carr is a renowned writer and speaker who gained popularity with the article

IT Doesn't Matter published in the Harvard Business Review 2003. In the article, Carr argued

that IT had become ubiquitous and standardized, reaching a point where it no longer provided

a competitive advantage to businesses. Since then, Nicholas Carr has continued exploring
 7

technology's implications for business strategy. Although some have labeled it as anti-

technology due to the critical views on IT's role in creating value for companies, which

maintains that the technology can still be used strategically if deployed correctly. Nicholas

Carr argues that cloud computing will fundamentally transform business by making access to

sophisticated information technology infrastructure affordable and accessible even for small

firms. However, there is a caution against blindly adopting new technologies without

considering the broader impact on organizational structure and culture.

Carr's current position on the matter has evolved since Carr wrote controversial

pieces. In recent years, that has been argued that unless IT assets are used strategically, which

do not provide any real competitive advantage to organizations. In other words, acquiring

advanced technologies does not automatically give firms a sustainable edge over their rivals.

Carr believes that with increased digitalization across industries and society, especially with

artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning are becoming ever more prevalent. It is

increasingly difficult for businesses to differentiate themselves based solely on technological

prowess alone. Nicholas Carr maintains that IT can no longer be seen as serving purely

strategic purposes instead, how effectively one wields budgets towards investments like AI or

Big Data must also become secondary consideration when compared to organizational

effectiveness.

Exercise 3

As a student of operational excellence, one must understand the importance of

collaboration in any organization. With technology advancements, virtual meetings have

become famous for businesses to communicate and work together efficiently. WebEx is an

online meeting platform with many features that contribute to good collaboration among team

members. Firstly, it allows users to conduct high-quality video and audio conferences with

screen-sharing options. This feature is handy when discussing complex ideas or presenting
 8

visual aids during presentations. Moreover, WebEx offers advanced security protocols such as

password protection and encrypted communication channels, which are necessary for

confidential discussions between teams. Compared to other collaboration tools like Skype or

Google Hangouts, WebEx stands out due to its comprehensive set of features designed

specifically for business purposes. In comparison, Skype may be more suitable for personal

use where participants do not require sophisticated functionalities such as recording sessions

or scheduling appointments.

Similarly, Google Hangouts has limited capabilities concerning file-sharing, whereas

WebEx enables users to share files directly from their computer's desktop without affecting

call quality. In conclusion, after reviewing the WebEx website's features thoroughly, they can

conclude that it presents adequate tools required by organizations today, making it an

excellent choice when collaborating with internal teams or external stakeholders virtually.

Overall, there are various collaboration tools that individuals or organizations can use to keep

connected in today's world. Among them, WebEx has established itself as a dependable

solution for remote users who require efficient access via live meetings to ensure the best user

experiences (Ogunseye & Akinola, 2021).

 9

Reference

Andrew, M. (2019). Collaborating online with four different Google apps: Benefits to

learning and usefulness for future work. Journal of Asia TEFL, 16(4), 1268.

Gallo, C. (2022). The Bezos Blueprint: Communication Secrets of the World's Greatest

Salesman. St. Martin's Press.

Ogunseye, E. O., & Akinola, S. O. (2021). Empirical Quality and Usability Assessments of

Five Common Online RealTime E-Meeting Platforms. University of Ibadan Journal of

Science and Logics in ICT Research, 6(1 and 2), 42–56.