Get Water and Society A Critical Introduction 1st Edition Katie Meehan free all chapters
Get Water and Society A Critical Introduction 1st Edition Katie Meehan free all chapters
Get Water and Society A Critical Introduction 1st Edition Katie Meehan free all chapters
https://ebookgate.com/product/civil-society-and-development-a-
critical-exploration-1st-edition-jude-howell/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/performance-a-critical-introduction-
marvin-a-carlson/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/agamben-and-politics-a-critical-
introduction-1st-edition-sergei-prozorov/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/john-hick-a-critical-introduction-and-
reflection-1st-edition-david-cheetham/
ebookgate.com
Women and Media A Critical Introduction 1st Edition
Carolyn M. Byerly
https://ebookgate.com/product/women-and-media-a-critical-
introduction-1st-edition-carolyn-m-byerly/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/confessions-of-a-hayseed-da-robert-r-
meehan/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/critical-reasoning-a-practical-
introduction-1st-edition-anne-thomson/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/psychology-and-law-a-critical-
introduction-2nd-edition-andreas-kapardis/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/punishment-a-critical-introduction-2nd-
edition-thom-brooks/
ebookgate.com
Table of Contents
Cover
Series Page
Title Page
Copyright Page
List of Figures
List of Tables
List of Boxes
Acknowledgments
Part 1: Foundations
Chapter 1: The Hydrosocial Cycle
The Month of Big Rains
The Hydrosocial Cycle
Knowledge is Power
Scarcity is Made
Water is Life
Camp is Everywhere
Summary and What’s Next
Further Reading
Chapter 2: Water and Empire
Stillsuits and Spice
Theories of Empire and Water
Water at the Frontier
Property, Race, and Caste
Boundaries and Imperial Space
Legacies of Empire
Summary and What’s Next
Further Reading
Chapter 3: Legal Waters
The Chilean Water Code
Why Institutions Matter
Water Rights (and Wrongs)
Legal Pluralism
Institutions in Action
Does the Law Deliver Justice?
A New Day for Chile
Summary and What’s Next
Further Reading
Chapter 4: The Business of Water
Paying for the Pipes
Public or Private?
State Failure?
Privatization Debates
New Frontiers of Financialization
Streams of Revenue
Uncooperative Waters?
Summary and What’s Next
Further Reading
Part 2: Big Waters
Chapter 5: Eating Water
How Much Water Do You Eat?
The Water of Land Grabbing
Cheap Food and Unsustainable Water Use
Virtual Water Hegemony
Closed Basins, Fragmented Rivers, and Empty Aquifers
More Crop Per Drop, More Dollar Per Drop
Summary and What’s Next
Further Reading
Chapter 6: Dam Fever
A Fever Spreads
Dams as Development
Dams as Geopolitics
The “Narmada Effect”
The World Commission on Dams
The Future of Dams
Summary and What’s Next
Further Reading
Chapter 7: Shared Waters
A River in “Crisis”
The Myth of Water Wars
Limits to Water Cooperation
A Spectrum of Intensities
Power and Hydro‐hegemony
Water Diplomacy as Praxis
The Future of Shared Waters
Summary and What’s Next
Further Reading
Part 3: Water is Life
Chapter 8: Intimate Waters
Citizenship and the Toilet
The Work of Water
From Citizen to “Consumer”
“Here’s to Flint”
Emotional Geographies of Water
Take Back the Tap
Summary and What’s Next
Further Reading
Chapter 9: The Right to Water
Victory or Defeat?
What is the Human Right to Water?
Struggles in South Africa
From South to North
A Right to the Hydrosocial Cycle
Rights Beyond the Human?
The Right to Water as a Process
Summary and What’s Next
Further Reading
Chapter 10: Future Waters
At the Confluence of Change
Stationarity is Dead
Techno‐Fix 1: Desalination
Techno‐Fix 2: Moving Water
Techno‐Fix 3: Nature‐Based Solutions
Techno‐Fix 4: Resilience
Adapting to New Worlds
A Mudlarkers’ Guide to the Future
Further Reading
Bibliography
Index
End User License Agreement
List of Tables
Chapter 3
Table 3.1 Key Differences in US Surface Water Allocation
Doctrines4
Chapter 4
Table 4.1 Market Environmentalism in Water. This table
illustrates the ways...
Chapter 6
Table 6.1 World’s Largest Dams by Electric Power
Generation Capacity. Sourc...
List of Illustrations
Chapter 1
Figure 1.1 The school gardens at Manzo Elementary School
in Tucson, Arizona....
Figure 1.2 The Manzo farmer’s market. Here, student
leaders explain how they...
Figure 1.3 The O’odham calendar at Manzo Elementary
School.
Figure 1.4 The Tijuana hydrosocial cycle. Water moves
unevenly through the T...
Figure 1.5 Hydrosocial flows in the Coachella Valley.After
listening to ...
Figure 1.6 The Black Snake. This map illustrates the
geography of the Dakota...
Figure 1.7 The Oceti Sakowin Camp at Standing Rock.
Chapter 2
Figure 2.1 Sketch of Karl Wittfogel by the Hungarian artist
Lajos Tihanyi (1...
Figure 2.2 The “Imperial Federation” of the British Empire
in 1886. Note the...
Figure 2.3 Map of the Indus River basin.
Figure 2.4 A water tank near Hemakuta Hill, Vijayanagar,
India (1856). Tanks...
Figure 2.5 Problems of water supply for Palestinians. Here,
an elderly man c...
Chapter 3
Figure 3.1 Map of northern Chile, including Chiu‐Chiu valley
and towns.
Figure 3.2 Elinor Ostrom, Nobel Prize winner.
Figure 3.3 Major legal traditions in the world.
Chapter 5
Figure 5.1 The water footprint of agriculture. This graph
depicts three cate...
Figure 5.2 Portrait of J.A. Allan, or Tony, as he liked to be
called.
Figure 5.3 Head regulator of the Malibya canal new area,
Office du Niger, Ma...
Figure 5.4 Variation in blue water footprints for selected
energy crops. Thi...
Figure 5.5 The Wonderwater Project, an art‐science
collaboration that showed...
Figure 5.6 Café customers in London and Milan read the
menu and learned abou...
Figure 5.7 The expansion of soybean production in Brazil
between 1960 and 20...
Figure 5.8 Estimation of groundwater withdrawals for
irrigation.
Chapter 6
Figure 6.1 Removal of the Condit Dam on the White Salmon
River, WA (USA). No...
Figure 6.2 Dam construction in Nepal. This photograph
depicts workers in the...
Figure 6.3 The Colorado River basin. This map illustrates
the complex geogra...
Figure 6.4 Region of the Tennessee Valley Authority, USA.
The TVA project wa...
Figure 6.5 Folk singer Woody Guthrie (1912–1967), pictured
in 1943.
Figure 6.6 Social activist Medha Patkar (1954–), pictured in
2002.
Figure 6.7 Himalayan hydropower and dam development at
work.
Chapter 7
Figure 7.1 Map of the Mekong River basin.
Figure 7.2 World map of transboundary rivers, lakes, and
aquifers.
Figure 7.3 Transboundary Waters Interaction NexuS
(TWINS) matrix.
Figure 7.4 Activists ride a boat along the Mekong River,
Thailand.
Chapter 8
Figure 8.1 “Don’t Just Sit There Fred, Get a House
Renovation Grant.” This p...
Figure 8.2 A rainwater harvesting system in a Tlalpan home,
Mexico City. Thi...
Figure 8.3 Households without piped running water in the
United States, 2013...
Figure 8.4 Changes in urban plumbing poverty rank in the
United States from ...
Figure 8.5 A sign in a Hackney park in London says, “Go
home if you need to ...
Figure 8.6 Barriers to entry in Greenwich Park. Since 2015,
Royal Parks char...
Chapter 9
Figure 9.1 Timeline of key events related to the human
rights to water and s...
Figure 9.2 Demonstrations held by Right2Water in Spain.
Chapter 10
Figure 10.1 Students surveying the Okavango Delta,
Botswana.
Figure 10.2 Map of the South–North Water Transfer project
in China.
Figure 10.3 The Thames River, central London. View from
the Queenhithe secti...
Critical Introductions to
Geography
Critical Introductions to Geography is a series of textbooks for
undergraduate courses covering the key geographical sub‐disciplines
and providing broad and introductory treatment with a critical edge.
They are designed for the North American and international market
and take a lively and engaging approach with a distinct geographical
voice that distinguishes them from more traditional and outdated
texts.
Prospective authors interested in the series should contact the series
editor:
John Paul Jones III
School of Geography and Development
University of Arizona
[email protected]
Published
Water: A Critical Introduction
Katie Meehan, Naho Mirumachi, Alex Loftus, and Majed Akhter
Environment and Society: A Critical Introduction, 3e
Paul Robbins, John Hintz, Sarah A. Moore
Political Geography: A Critical Introduction
Sara Smith
Political Ecology: A Critical Introduction, 3e
Paul Robbins
Economic Geography: A Critical Introduction
Trevor J. Barnes, Brett Christophers
Health Geographies: A Critical Introduction
Tim Brown, Gavin J. Andrews, Steven Cummins, Beth Greenhough,
Daniel Lewis, Andrew Power
Urban Geography: A Critical Introduction
Andrew E.G. Jonas, Eugene McCann, Mary Thomas
Geographic Thought: A Critical Introduction
Tim Cresswell
Mapping: A Critical Introduction to Cartography and GIS
Jeremy W. Crampton
Research Methods in Geography: A Critical Introduction
Basil Gomez, John Paul Jones III
Geographies of Media and Communication
Paul C. Adams
Social Geography: A Critical Introduction
Vincent J. Del Casino Jr.
Geographies of Globalization: A Critical Introduction
Andrew Herod
Forthcoming
Energy, Society, and Environment: A Critical Introduction
Dustin Mulvaney
Geographic Thought: A Critical Introduction, 2e
Tim Cresswell
Introduction to Cultural Geography: A Critical Approach
Jamie Winders, Declan Cullen
Water
A Critical Introduction
Katie Meehan, Naho Mirumachi, Alex Loftus, and Majed Akhter
This edition first published 2023
© 2023 John Wiley & Sons Ltd
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a
retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic,
mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, except as permitted by law.
Advice on how to obtain permission to reuse material from this title is available at
http://www.wiley.com/go/permissions.
The right of Katie Meehan, Naho Mirumachi, Alex Loftus, and Majed Akhter to be
identified as the authors of this work has been asserted in accordance with law.
Registered Offices
John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, USA
John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex, PO19
8SQ, UK
For details of our global editorial offices, customer services, and more information
about Wiley products visit us at www.wiley.com.
Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats and by print‐on‐
demand. Some content that appears in standard print versions of this book may
not be available in other formats.
Trademarks: Wiley and the Wiley logo are trademarks or registered trademarks of
John Wiley & Sons, Inc. and/or its affiliates in the United States and other
countries and may not be used without written permission. All other trademarks
are the property of their respective owners. John Wiley & Sons, Inc. is not
associated with any product or vendor mentioned in this book.
Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty
While the publisher and authors have used their best efforts in preparing this
work, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or
completeness of the contents of this work and specifically disclaim all warranties,
including without limitation any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness
for a particular purpose. No warranty may be created or extended by sales
representatives, written sales materials or promotional statements for this work.
The fact that an organization, website, or product is referred to in this work as a
citation and/or potential source of further information does not mean that the
publisher and authors endorse the information or services the organization,
website, or product may provide or recommendations it may make. This work is
sold with the understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering
professional services. The advice and strategies contained herein may not be
suitable for your situation. You should consult with a specialist where appropriate.
Further, readers should be aware that websites listed in this work may have
changed or disappeared between when this work was written and when it is read.
Neither the publisher nor authors shall be liable for any loss of profit or any other
commercial damages, including but not limited to special, incidental,
consequential, or other damages.
Library of Congress Cataloging‐in‐Publication Data
Names: Meehan, Katie, author. | Mirumachi, Naho, author. | Loftus, Alex, author. |
Akhter, Majed, author.
Title: Water : a critical introduction / Katie Meehan, Naho Mirumachi, Alex Loftus,
and Majed Akhter.
Description: Hoboken, NJ : Wiley, [2023] | Series: Critical introductions to
geography | Includes index.
Identifiers: LCCN 2022052847 (print) | LCCN 2022052848 (ebook) | ISBN
9781119315216 (paperback) | ISBN 9781119315193 (adobe pdf) | ISBN
9781119315162 (epub)
Subjects: LCSH: Water–Philosophy. | Water‐supply. | Water and civilization.
Classification: LCC GB671 .M44 2023 (print) | LCC GB671 (ebook) | DDC 553.7–
dc23/eng20230123
LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2022052847
LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2022052848
Cover Design: Wiley
Cover Image: Dam at end of Fassa Valley in Dolomites © devid75/Getty Images
List of Figures
Figure 1.1 The school gardens at Manzo Elementary School in
Tucson, Arizona.
Figure 1.2 The Manzo farmer’s market.
Figure 1.3 The O’odham calendar at Manzo Elementary School.
Figure 1.4 The Tijuana hydrosocial cycle.
Figure 1.5 Hydrosocial flows in the Coachella Valley.
Figure 1.6 The Black Snake.
Figure 1.7 The Oceti Sakowin Camp at Standing Rock.
Figure 2.1 Sketch of Karl Wittfogel.
Figure 2.2 The “Imperial Federation” of the British Empire in
1886.
Figure 2.3 Map of the Indus River basin.
Figure 2.4 A water tank near Hemakuta Hill.
Figure 2.5 Problems of water supply for Palestinians.
Figure 3.1 Map of northern Chile, including Chiu‐Chiu valley
and towns.
Figure 3.2 Elinor Ostrom, Nobel Prize winner.
Figure 3.3 Major legal traditions in the world.
Figure 5.1 The water footprint of agriculture.
Figure 5.2 Portrait of J.A. Allan, or Tony, as he liked to be
called.
Figure 5.3 Head regulator of the Malibya canal new area, Office
du Niger, Mali.
Figure 5.4 Variation in blue water footprints for selected
energy crops.
Figure 5.5 The Wonderwater Project, an art‐science
collaboration that showed the hidden flows of virtual water in
café dishes and drinks.
Figure 5.6 Café customers in London and Milan read the menu
and learned about virtual water.
Figure 5.7 The expansion of soybean production in Brazil
between 1960 and 2002.
Figure 5.8 Estimation of groundwater withdrawals for
irrigation.
Figure 6.1 Removal of the Condit Dam on the White Salmon
River, WA (USA).
Figure 6.2 Dam construction in Nepal.
Figure 6.3 The Colorado River basin.
Figure 6.4 Region of the Tennessee Valley Authority, USA.
Figure 6.5 Folk singer Woody Guthrie (1912–1967), pictured in
1943.
Figure 6.6 Social activist Medha Patkar (1954–), pictured in
2002.
Figure 6.7 Himalayan hydropower and dam development at
work.
Figure 7.1 Map of the Mekong River basin.
Figure 7.2 World map of transboundary rivers, lakes, and
aquifers.
Figure 7.3 Transboundary Waters Interaction NexuS (TWINS)
matrix.
Figure 7.4 Activists ride a boat along the Mekong River,
Thailand.
Figure 8.1 “Don’t Just Sit There Fred, Get a House Renovation
Grant.”
Figure 8.2 A rainwater harvesting system in a Tlalpan home,
Mexico City.
Figure 8.3 Households without piped running water in the
United States, 2013–2017.
Figure 8.4 Changes in urban plumbing poverty rank in the
United States from 2000 to 2017.
Figure 8.5 A sign in a Hackney park in London says, “Go home
if you need to go.”
Figure 8.6 Barriers to entry in Greenwich Park.
Figure 9.1 Timeline of key events related to the human rights
to water and sanitation.
Figure 9.2 Demonstrations held by Right2Water in Spain.
Figure 10.1 Students surveying the Okavango Delta, Botswana.
Figure 10.2 Map of the South–North Water Transfer project in
China.
Figure 10.3 The Thames River, central London.
List of Tables
Table 3.1 Key Differences in US Surface Water Allocation
Doctrines.
Table 4.1 Market Environmentalism in Water.
Table 6.1 World’s Largest Dams by Electric Power Generation
Capacity.
List of Boxes
Box 1.1 Make Your Own Hydrosocial Cycle
Box 3.1 Rules of the Game
Box 3.2 First Law in Australia
Box 4.1 The Dublin Principles
Box 4.2 Thames Water, An Iconic Case
Box 5.1 What is Virtual Water?
Box 5.2 Water on the Menu
Box 6.1 What Is a Dam?
Box 6.2 Fighting for Uncle Sam
Box 6.3 Dams and Displaced Peoples
Box 6.4 Himalayan Hydropower, Hunger Strikes, and Geologic
Surprises
Box 7.1 Transboundary Cooperation and the SDGs
Box 7.2 Problemsheds, Not Watersheds
Box 8.1 Unaffordable Water in the United States
Box 9.1 The United Nations Special Rapporteurs
Box 9.2 Free Basic Water in South Africa
Acknowledgments
We hope you read this book as a love letter to the power of critique.
The references section, itself lengthy as a chapter, captures just a
small sample of the muscular, insightful, and brilliant critical
scholarship on water – including original research and stories of our
own. In the places we research and work, we are grateful to our many
collaborators, informants, and participants, who have deeply shaped
and sharpened our worldviews. May the works cited here inspire
questions, discoveries, and more skeptical superheroes.
This book is the product of four people with very different
backgrounds, interests, and life experiences. What unites us is a
curiosity about the world, a relentless drive to question, and a
responsibility to the people, places, and waters we have met along
the way. We hope that this book serves as a launch pad for readers to
do the same and see the world’s waters around them a little
differently.
We are fortunate to work together at King’s College London in the
Department of Geography, a truly inspiring and collegial
environment that supported the production of this book. The book
arrives amid exciting developments with King’s Water Centre, and
we are thankful for our new interdisciplinary community that has
formed around grand challenges of water sustainability. We are
grateful to the Department of Geography Research Impact Fund and
the PLuS Alliance (Arizona State University, King’s College London,
and UNSW Sydney) for providing funds that were crucial to making
the book more accessible and engaging for our readers. A two‐month
fellowship from the University of Arizona’s Agnese Nelms Haury
Program in Environment and Social Justice helped to shape early
content and structure.
It takes a village to make a book. The series editor, John Paul Jones
III, believed in this project (and us) from the start, and we are
grateful for his vision, patience, and skilled editorial pen – literally,
scribbled in the margins of scanned pages of text. At Wiley, editors
Charlie Hamlyn, Clelia Petracca, and Justin Vaughn shared the faith
and created a structure for this project to flourish and manifest. We
also thank Verity Stuart and others at Wiley who helped bring this
book to publication. Philip Stickler did wonders with the maps and
cartographic design.
A special thanks is due to Jen McCormack, our copyeditor, who
provided superb editorial support, poring over the text with a keen
eye and unwavering fidelity to critique. There was no hiding from
Jen’s quality control: she pushed us to improve our craft and write to
the student at the back of the classroom. All faults and errors remain
ours.
Peer review is the often‐invisible and ever‐vital reproductive labor of
our praxis. We are grateful to the anonymous reviewer for their close
reading, incisive comments, and big picture thinking. Their excellent
comments were joined by three outstanding student reviewers –
Lucy Everitt, Diana Kim, and Tamara Sbeih – who provided
constructive and candid feedback. It was a privilege to be closely read
by such brilliant people.
Writing this book involved a surprising degree of joy and intellectual
freedom. Our classrooms provided a supportive space for thought
experimentation. Special thanks is owed to University of Oregon
students from Katie’s International Water Policy class – all nine
years of you! – and members of the Salon (Shiloh Deitz, Fiona De
Los Ríos, Lourdes Ginart, Olivia Molden, and Kate Shields) who
generously read the book proposal and commented on early
material. At King’s College London, we thank students in our current
and past modules, especially Water and Development,
Environmental Justice, and Water Sustainability.
The writing of this book coincided with COVID‐19 pandemic
upheavals and major structural transformations (and struggles)
within British higher education. Chapters were frantically written
between “pingdemics” and picket lines, including many weeks of
industrial action over pension dispute, fair pay and working
conditions, gender and racial equity – all fights against the
devaluation of our profession and the erosion of education.
A healthy sense of outrage is always a good place to start writing a
critical introduction. Many people supported us along the way –
cooking meals, adjusting plans, telling us when things got boring –
and we would especially like to thank our friends and families, who
have been our best (or at least, most honest) critics and confidants.
This book is dedicated to our students, past and present, who
continue to create new worlds and teach us.
Part 1
Foundations
Chapter 1
The Hydrosocial Cycle
The Month of Big Rains
The Hydrosocial Cycle
Knowledge is Power
Scarcity is Made
Water is Life
Camp is Everywhere
Summary and What’s Next
Knowledge is Power
A key tenet of the hydrosocial cycle is that knowledge is power. In
other words, scientific knowledge, expertise, and authority shape
how water is understood, managed, and legitimized. In La Ligua
basin in Chile, Jessica Budds (2009a) explores how routine
groundwater assessments by hydrologists became fraught politicized
tools used by the water authority, the National Water Directorate
(DGA). These assessments shape water rights and access for farmers
in uneven ways. Far from science playing a neutral role in water
management, the story of La Ligua reveals how social power
saturates the nexus of science and decision‐making, influencing
which (and whose) ideas are adopted into practice.
Knowledge is not innocent or neutral but is a human construction
that shapes (and is shaped by) the world. Drawing on the field of
science and technology studies, Sheila Jasanoff (2004) argues that
scientific knowledge is coproduced by social practice and spatial
orders. In short, science and politics are a two‐way street, as the
world seeps into science from the outset of knowledge creation.
François Molle (2008) expands on this approach to explain why
certain flagship ideas manifest as practice in international water
policy. Molle examines the emergence of Integrated Water Resource
Management (best known by its acronym, IWRM), a prominent
concept that promotes a coordinated and cross‐sectoral approach to
managing water. While IWRM was welcomed as an antidote to the
perceived “chaos” of uncoordinated water management, Molle
argues that IWRM, like any hegemonic concept, tends to obscure the
political nature of natural resource management. “Ideas are never
neutral and reflect the particular societal settings in which they
emerge, the world views and interests of those who have the power to
set the terms of the debate, to legitimate particular options and
discard others, and to include or exclude particular social groups”
(Molle 2008, p. 131). For Molle, the global IWRM bandwagon
operates not due to “genius” insight but because of the social
conditions which brought IWRM into existence in the first place. For
us, a critical focus sparks even more questions: Whose water
knowledge counts? Why? To what effect or end?
A productive way forward is to consider how expert or scientific
discourse about water is more than a set of constructed facts or
words. Scientific discourse reflects a categorization and system of
power. Social power shapes our realities, knowledge, and claims
about water – it even produces the ways in which truth is made true,
what philosopher Michel Foucault (2020 [1975]) calls “regimes of
truth.” Rutgerd Boelens draws on this theory to explore the
rationalities in different kinds of Andean water knowledge, including
“scientific” knowledge and other knowledge systems categorized as
“local” or less salubrious to water management. From the vantage
point of Western science, the pecking order of knowledge sits in a
hierarchy:
Rules, rights, and duties attached to water flows and hydraulic
infrastructure are closely linked to systems of meanings, symbols,
and values, involving institutions and networks of human, non‐
human, and supernatural actors and power that influence water
control. This domain – often erroneously associated with only
“social” and not with, for example, technology – is essentialized in
romantic representations and contested or ignored in natural
sciences.
(Boelens 2014, p. 240)
Scarcity is Made
For desert cities, like Tucson and Tijuana, the notion that water is a
“scarce” resource is a common refrain in many influential
documents, textbooks, and policy principles. But what if, following
Erik Swyngedouw (2004, 2009), we started with the idea that
scarcity is relational and constructed? That a lack of available water
– or clean, accessible, secure, safe water – is not an inherent feature
or pre‐given reality, but the outcome of uneven conditions, logics,
and practices? How do we account for the fact that water – the
molecule H2O – is one of the most abundant elements on planet
Earth and yet out of reach for so many? What explains resource
scarcity?
The narratives of many “scarcity” debates can be traced to Thomas
Malthus, an English economist and demographer in the late
eighteenth century, whose ideas influenced generations of key
thinkers, including Charles Darwin. In his book An Essay on the
Principle of Population, first published in 1798, Malthus (1992)
introduced the concept of population growth causing environmental
degradation. Malthus predicted that the human population would
outgrow the available food (and water) supply, using the artfully
simple logic – he called it “logical empiricism”: that (i) people
reproduce geometrically (exponentially) and yet, (ii) food supply
reproduces in an arithmetic (linear) progression. Too many people,
not enough food.
Malthus didn’t stop there. Indeed, he argued the human population
will expand to the limits of subsistence and only through techniques
of “vice” (including war and violence), “misery” (including famine,
illness, and drought), and “moral restraint” (i.e. abstinence and
Protestant morality) could the world check excessive population
growth and avoid environmental destruction. Welfare or charity
(embodied by the Poor Laws) was a useless exercise, creating more
“dependency” by subjects on the state. Malthus’s own words offer a
window into his worldviews on race, gender, and class:4
The Poor Laws of England tend to depress the general condition of
the poor … they may be said, therefore, to create the poor which
they maintain. (p. 100)
It can scarcely be doubted that, in modern Europe, a much larger
proportion of women pass a considerable part of their lives in the
exercise of virtue than in past times and among uncivilized
nations. (pp. 43–44)
In some of the southern countries where every impulse may be
almost immediately indulged, the passion sinks into mere animal
desire, is soon weakened and extinguished by excess. (p. 212)
With the winds of privilege at his back, Malthus’s ideas about people
and the environment spread like wildfire. His ideas are found, for
example, in popular World Bank claims that the “world is running
out of freshwater.” They lurk in “population bomb” arguments and
other accounts that smack of environmental determinism (see
Robbins 2019 for explanation and critique).
What does this “scarcity” argument overlook or leave out? Let’s go
back to Tijuana. Water in Tijuana can easily be labeled as “scarce” –
but this claim requires surgical attention and critical analysis.
Tijuana is a desert city, but the provision of water to homes and
businesses is mediated by infrastructure, social institutions, law and
legal status, and money. For example, maquiladoras (export‐
oriented manufacturing plants) are thirsty customers that never run
out of municipal water; yet informal housing settlements (colonias)
are routinely denied piped water service and sewerage based on their
tenure status, and unhoused (homeless) people are reliant on
precarious or polluted water sources (Meehan 2013).
For the beneficiaries of Colorado River water, including Tijuana,
scarcity is felt unevenly (see Figure 6.3 in Chapter 6 for the map). In
Southern California, the Imperial Valley is one of the system’s major
recipients; the valley gobbles the bulk of regional water allocation
rights to grow sod for lawns, parks, and sports fields. The service
districts of Los Angeles and San Diego are also well watered. Tijuana,
as a major metropolitan area and economic engine, sucks up the bulk
of Mexico’s allocated Colorado River water through a complex
pipeline system that flows west over the Sierra Madres mountains
and delivers water to its reservoirs, after which it is unevenly
distributed to city residents. Some users can afford to pump
groundwater, at a considerable cost. South of the international
border, in the Colorado River Delta region of Mexico, small‐scale and
subsistence farmers eked out an agricultural livelihood on the
escaped flows from irrigation system leaks (at least, before the
Imperial Valley engineers sealed the leaks). In parts of the Delta,
Indigenous users have been marginalized in terms of water access
and rights allocation (Muehlmann 2013). Now, the mighty flows of
the Colorado River often never make it to the sea, ending in a sad
trickle in a desiccated wetland.
This story asks a deeper question: What produces water scarcity?
Our example does not deny the reality of aridity, or the fact that
deserts receive less rain than their temperate counterparts, or the
fact that the Tijuana metro region is urbanizing rapidly and placing
new pressures on the existing water supply.
A critical approach invites us to ask important questions about
conditions. Scarcity is produced, not ready‐made. As Tijuana
illustrates, what is “scarce” – and to whom, where, and why, across
the Colorado basin – is an outcome of relations. And so, we invite
you to put Malthusian thinking in the dustbin. In its place, we invite
you to think with the people of Standing Rock, who offer a far more
interesting and critical thesis (the third plank of this book): water is
life.
Water is Life
Early in 2016, the people of the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe mobilized
to prevent a crude oil pipeline called “The Black Snake” from
crossing their unceded lands and threatening the Missouri River, a
major water source along the tribe’s eastern boundary, located in the
Upper Midwest region of the United States (Figure 1.6). The Black
Snake is the Dakota Access Pipeline (DAPL), a US$3.8 billion, 1 172‐
mile underground pipeline that runs 570 000 barrels of oil every day
across four US states, two major rivers, and over two hundred creeks
and streams.
Early on, Indigenous youth organized camps and led protests,
galvanized by calls to “ReZpect Our Water” and defend Indigenous
sovereignty (Curley 2019a). By late September, more than three
hundred Native Nations and allies joined the movement, creating a
#NoDAPL movement and planting their flags in solidarity at Oceti
Sakowin Camp, the largest of several protest camps (Figure 1.7).
Oceti sakowin is translated as the seven council fires of the Lakota,
Dakota, and Nakota Nations, known by some as the Great Sioux
Nation. Not only the name of the largest camp, oceti sakowin is also
the unity of the oyate or people of this geography.5 The Standing
Rock Sioux were no strangers to their roles as Water Protectors.
“#NoDAPL [w]as not a departure from so much as it was a
continuation – a movement within a larger movement, but also a
movement within a moment – of long traditions of Indigenous
resistance deeply grounded in place and history” (Estes and Dhillon
2019). At its peak, the #NoDAPL struggles included thousands of
Water Protectors, galvanized by the phrase mni wiconi or “water is
life.”
The physical geography of the DAPL is massive. Operative since July
2014, it carries light sweet crude oil from six sites in the Bakken and
Three Forks oil‐producing regions of North Dakota, through South
Dakota and Iowa, to a terminal in southern Illinois, where it links to
refineries in the Midwest and Gulf Coast (Mazer et al. 2019, p. 356).
The Bakken and Three Forks production areas are part of a deposit
that runs all the way north into Montana and the Canadian provinces
of Saskatchewan and Manitoba. DAPL fuels a carbon‐dependent
empire, transnational in finance and commodity flows (Mazer et al.
2019). A rupture of “sweet crude” jeopardizes the drinking water of
millions of people and other‐than‐humans who depend on clean
rivers and aquifers for life.
Figure 1.6 The Black Snake. This map illustrates the
geography of the Dakota Access Pipeline as it routes oil
across the Standing Rock Sioux Reservation, traditional
Oceti Sakowin Lands, and the northern Great Plains to a
distribution center in Illinois, near the Mississippi River.
Source: The Authors, cartography by Philip Stickler.
Random documents with unrelated
content Scribd suggests to you:
The Project Gutenberg eBook of The Purple
Pennant
This ebook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United
States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with
almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away
or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License
included with this ebook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you
are not located in the United States, you will have to check the
laws of the country where you are located before using this
eBook.
Language: English
ILLUSTRATED BY
NORMAN P. ROCKWELL
Off leaped Perry again, not quite so nicely this time, and down the
wet path he sped, splashing through the puddles, head back, legs
twinkling. And, as though trying to make pace for him, Fudge raced
along on the turf in a valiant endeavor to judge the finish. Perry’s
Sunday trousers made a gray streak across the line, Fudge pressed
convulsively on the stem of the watch and the trial was over!
“Wh-what was it?” inquired Perry breathlessly as he walked back.
Fudge was staring puzzledly at the dial.
“I made it twelve seconds,” he responded dubiously.
“Twelve! And you said I’d ought to do it under eleven!” Perry
viewed him discouragedly.
“Well, maybe I didn’t snap it just when I should have,” said the
timer. “It’s hard to see unless you’re right at the line.”
“You must have! I’ll bet anything I did it better than twelve. Don’t
you think I did?”
“Well, it looked to me as if you were going pretty fast,” answered
Fudge cautiously. “But those trousers, and not having any spikes,
and the track being so wet—Gee, but you did get splashed, didn’t
you?”
“I should say so,” replied Perry, observing his trousers disgustedly.
“The water even went into my face! Say, let’s try it again, Fudge,
and you stand here at the finish.”
“All right, but how’ll I start you?”
“Wave a handkerchief or something?”
“I’ve got it. I’ll clap a couple of sticks together.” So Fudge set out
to find his sticks while Perry, rather winded, seated himself on the
stand. Fudge finally came back with the required articles and Perry
declared himself rested and ready for another trial. “I’ll clap the
sticks together first for you to get set and then for the start. Like
this.” Fudge illustrated. “Suppose you can hear it?”
“Sure.” Perry proceeded back to the beginning of the straightaway
and Fudge stationed himself at the finish, scuffling a line across the
track for his better guidance. Then, while the sprinter was getting
his crouch, he experimented with slapping the sticks and snapping
the watch at the same instant, a rather difficult proceeding.
“All ready!” shouted Perry, poised on finger-tips and knee.
“All right!” called Fudge in response. He examined his watch, fixed
a finger over the stem, took a deep breath and clapped the sticks.
Perry set. Another clap and a simultaneous jab at the watch, and
Perry was racing down the track. Fudge’s eyes took one fleeting look
at the runner and then fixed themselves strainedly on the line he
had drawn across the cinders. Nearer and nearer came the scrunch
of the flying sneakers, there was a sudden blur of gray in Fudge’s
vision and he snapped the watch. Perry turned and trotted anxiously
back.
“Well?” he asked.
“Better,” replied Fudge. “Of course, the track’s awfully slow——”
“How much? Let’s see?”
Fudge yielded the watch and Perry examined it. “Eleven and two-
fifths!” he shouted protestingly. “Say, this thing’s crazy! I know
mighty well I didn’t run nearly so fast as I did the first time!”
“I didn’t snap it soon enough the other time,” explained Fudge.
“Honest, Perry, eleven and two-fifths isn’t half bad. Why, look at the
slow track and your long trousers——”
“Yes, and they weigh a ton, they’re so wet,” grumbled Perry. “And
so do these shoes. I’m going to try it some time when the track’s dry
and I’ve got regular running things on. I suppose eleven and two-
fifths isn’t terribly bad, considering!”
“Bad! It’s mighty good,” said Fudge warmly. “Why, look here,
Perry, if you can do it in that time to-day you can do it nearly a
second faster on a dry track and—and all! You see if you can’t. I’ll
bet you you’ll be a regular sprinter by the time we meet Springdale!”
“Honest, Fudge?”
“Honest to goodness! To-morrow you put your name down for the
Track Team and get yourself some running things. I’ll go along with
you if you like. I know just what you ought to have.”
“I don’t suppose I’ll really have any show for the team,” said Perry
modestly. “But it’ll be pretty good fun. Say, Fudge, I didn’t know I
could run as fast as I did that first time. It seemed to me I was
going like the very dickens! It—it’s mighty interesting, isn’t it?”
“Yes,” replied Fudge, as Perry donned his things. “You don’t want
to try the two-twenty or the hurdles, do you?”
“I should say not! I’m tuckered out. I’m going to try the two-
twenty some day, though. I don’t think I’d care about hurdling.”
“You can’t tell,” murmured Fudge thoughtfully.
Later, when they had once more surmounted the fence and were
heading toward B Street, Fudge, who had said little for many
minutes, observed: “I wonder, Perry, if a fellow wouldn’t have more
fun with the Track Team than with the Nine. I’ve a good mind to go
in for it.”
“Why don’t you?” asked Perry, encouragingly eager. “What would
you try? Running or—or what?” His gaze unconsciously strayed over
his friend’s rotund figure.
“N-no,” replied Fudge hesitantly. “I don’t think so. I might go in for
the mile, maybe. I don’t know yet. I’m just thinking of it. I’d have to
study a bit. Perhaps the weights would be my line. Ever put the
shot?” Perry shook his head. “Neither have I, but I’ll bet I could. All
it takes is practice. Say, wouldn’t it be funny if you and I both made
the team?”
“It would be dandy,” declared Perry. “Do you suppose there’d be
any chance of it?”
“Why not?” asked Fudge cheerfully.
CHAPTER III
THE SHADOW ON THE CURTAIN
Our website is not just a platform for buying books, but a bridge
connecting readers to the timeless values of culture and wisdom. With
an elegant, user-friendly interface and an intelligent search system,
we are committed to providing a quick and convenient shopping
experience. Additionally, our special promotions and home delivery
services ensure that you save time and fully enjoy the joy of reading.
ebookgate.com