DOC-20241111-WA0030.
DOC-20241111-WA0030.
DOC-20241111-WA0030.
RESEARCH FINDINGS
WIDI ALFINA
A12118292
TADULAKO UNIVERSITY
2024
APPROVAL
STUDENT DIFFICULTIES IN SPEAKING ENGLISH
ENCOUNTERED BY THE ELEVENTH GRADE OF
MA ALKHAIRAT PUSAT PALU
By:
Widi Alfina
A12118292
Approved by :
Supervisor Co-Supervisor
Acknowledged by :
Coordinator of English Education Study Program
II
III
MOTTO
Widi Alfina
ABSTRACT
Widi Alfina, 2024. Students Difficulties in Speaking English Encountered by The
Eleventh Grade of MA Alkhairat Pusat Palu (A Descriptive Qualitative Research
Study at MA Alkhairat Pusat Palu) Skripsi of the English Education Department
The Faculty of Teacher Training and Education, Tadulako University of Palu
Supervised by Aminah, and Zarkiani Hasyim.
The objective of this research is to find out the difficulties in speaking English
and the factors that cause the students difficulties in speaking English. This
research used a qualitative approach, with findings that were not obtained through
statistical procedures or calculations. The type of research design employed was a
case study. A case study is a research method that specifically investigates
contemporary phenomena objects that are ongoing or have occurred but still leave
a significant impact at the time the research was conducted within the context of
IV
real life, using various data sources.This research conducted at Madrasah Aliyah
Alkhairat Pusat Palu, Jl. Sis Al Jufri, Palu, Central Sulawesi. There are 5 students
and one teacher as participants, and the reseacher find out the information
about student difficulties in speaking English.
The study found that most students in the classroom primarily used Indonesian,
with the teacher using it 95% of the time. English was only used 3% of the time,
and students struggled with assignments and presentations in
Indonesian.Additionally, students faced psychological issues such as fear of
making mistakes, shyness, and anxiety, which impacted their confidence when
speaking English. They encountered various difficulties, including language
barriers and a lack of desire to communicate.The excessive use of Indonesian
hindered vocabulary acquisition and retention, leading to challenges in
vocabulary, pronunciation, and grammar comprehension. The study emphasizes
the need to address these issues in the classroom to enhance students' learning
experiences.
ABSTRAK
Widi Alfina, 2024. Kesulitan Siswa dalam Berbicara Bahasa Inggris yang
Dihadapi oleh Siswa Kelas Sebelas MA Alkhairat Pusat Palu (Studi Penelitian
Kualitatif Deskriptif di MA Alkhairat Pusat Palu) Skripsi Program Studi
Pendidikan Bahasa Inggris Fakultas Keguruan dan Ilmu Pendidikan Universitas
Tadulako Palu Dibimbing oleh Aminah dan Zarkiani Hasyim.
Studi ini menemukan bahwa sebagian besar siswa di kelas menggunakan bahasa
Indonesia, dengan guru menggunakan bahasa Indonesia sebanyak 95%. Selain
itu, siswa menghadapi masalah psikologis seperti takut melakukan kesalahan,
malu, dan cemas, yang berdampak pada kepercayaan diri mereka saat berbicara
bahasa Inggris. Penggunaan bahasa Indonesia yang berlebihan menghambat
akuisisi dan retensi kosakata, yang mengarah pada tantangan dalam kosakata,
pengucapan, dan pemahaman tata bahasa. Penelitian ini menekankan perlunya
mengatasi masalah ini di kelas untuk meningkatkan pengalaman belajar siswa.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
complete this research as one of the requirements for getting the undergraduate
our last prophet muhammad SAW, who has guided us from the darkness to the
brightness. The skripsi that the author made with the title " Students Difficulties in
Palu " can be completed as one of the academic requirements to obtain a Bachelor
There are a number of people who have been so helpful and supportive for me
to:
1. Mukrim S.Pd., M.Pd., Ph.D. as a reviewer, thank you for your support, and
guide for this research, give suggestions and time for the researcher.
2. Dr. Mam Aminah S.pd., M.pd., M.Ed. as supervisor who always guide this
research
4. Madrasah Aliyah Alkhairat pusat Palu, who has helped the researcher
5. Rector of Tadulako University, Prof. Dr. Ir. Amar, ST, MT, IPU, ASEAN
Program, Dr. Darmawan, S.Pd., M.Phil, who has also helped a lot and
6. My beloved family, especially my uncle who always give the best pray,
7. My cutie friends, Fitri, maghfirah, dewi, asila and all my friend who
always support, accompany, comfort the researcher and thank for every
Widi Alfina
VIII
5.2 Suggestion 30
REFERENCES 32
APPENDICES 34
APPENDICES 1 36
INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT 36
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background
increase the ability to speak in academia. But despite the importance of learning
interactive language functions is an importance key and in which it is not what the
learning say the counts but how learning say it what learning convey with body
language, gestures, eye contact, physical distance and other nonverbal message. It
convey message with body language, gesture not with oral language.
learning. It has become one of the student weekly exercises, most students face
development
1
2
which must increase the ability of learners to use English effectively and
reasoning skills.
has a different grammar from Indonesian as the students' mother tongue. These
mother tongue, have nothing in common in their grammar. This includes phonetic
and syntactic aspects and even semantic aspects. This can be proven by looking at
English.
3
follows:
English and the factors that cause the students difficulties in speaking English.
The significance of this research is expected that the findings will be benefit
their students speaking issues, and the findings will provide them feedback on the
that the students confront will make it easier for the teachers to find solutions.
This research can increase the knowledge of the school to achieve school
difficulties.
speaking English. In the relation to the difficulty researcher discuss the difficulties
in speaking English.
effectively. This skill gives us the ability to convey information verbally and
achieve goals, so that better eefforts are needed to overcome these obstacles.
CHAPTER II
PREVIOUS STUDY, REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE, AND
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
relevant with this research. The first research was conducted by Sari (2017),
overcome the difficulties. This research used descriptive qualitative method. The
instruments used in collecting the data were observation and interview. The
results of this research were every student has several difficulties in speaking,
namely: inhibition, nothing to say, un-even participant and mother tongue. The
cognitive style, class condition, the students’ strategies, cognitive strategies, and
socio-affective strategies.
speaking skill and to know what were the teacher did to solve the students
speaking problems. This research used survey with quantitative approach, the
5
6
instruments used to collect the data in this research are questionnaire and
interview. The result of this research showed that the students faced speaking
mother tongue, the teacher asked the students to feel confident when they speak
by giving reward. For nothing to say, the teachers gave the topic that was suitable
to the students and gave the early concept at the beginning of learning. For low or
uneven participation, the teachers gave same opportunity to all students and made
a small dynamic group. For mother tongue use, the teachers habituated students to
speak English, avoided giving too difficult and too many topics, and change the
research and the previous ones. Data collection techniques, using questionnaires
and interviews have been used by both researchers and these will also be used by
the researcher. Another similarity lies in the objectives of the first previous
descriptive qualitative research methods. While the differences can be seen from
the two previous research subjects. The first previous study took SMA 1
Furthermore, the quantitative approach has been used by the second previous
research that will be used by researcher and the research objectives related to
7
student problem analysis are also different in the length contained in the second
previous study.
Finally, the researcher of this research will conduct the same research
communicate with each other. Brown (2004) explain that speaking is an oral
and information. In this case, the listener must understand the relationship
processing information. Its form and meaning are dependent on the context in
environment and the purposes for speaking. It is often spontaneous, opened, and
Based on the theory above, speaking is the important part of the communication.
We need to improve our skill in speaking for communicating and getting or giving
Speaking is the most important skill to master. Brings the ability to have a
communication function itself. Harmer (2007) argues that speaking skills that
aspects of speaking. There are several points which explains the aspects of
a. Pronunciation
Pronunciation is the act way speakers produce clearer language when they
speak. It is deal with the phonological process that refers to the component of a
grammar made up of the element and principles that determine how sound and
words stress, tone pitch and intonation patterns. For the reason, if the speakers
phonemes correctly.
b. Grammar
Grammar is the basic units of meanings, such as words and a set of rules
to combine them into a new sentence (Fromkin & Rodman, 2014). It is needed
for the speakers to arrange a correct sentence in a conversation. The speakers must
appropriate ones. The utility of grammar is also to learn the correct way to gain
c. Vocabulary
9
phrases, variable phrases, phrases verbs and idioms. One cannot effectively
communicate or express their ideas both in oral and written form if they do not
d. Fluency
simple term, fluency is the ability to talk freely without too much stopping or
hesitating. When fluently the speakers should be able to get the messages across
with whatever resources and abilities they have got regardless and other mistakes.
usually faces difficulties in speaking English. That can be seen from two aspects,
1. Psychological Aspects
English speaking skill can be difficult for student in any educational levels
the Islamic based school, this is caused by several factors, one of which is
psychology.
a. Fear of mistake
Many theorists argued that fear mistake becomes one of the main
factors of students reluctance to speak in English in the class room. Aftat (2008)
10
adds that this fear is linked to the issue of correction by students fear of being
laughed at by other students or being criticized by the teacher. So, the students
important for teachers to convince their students that making mistake is not a
b. Shyness
home time when they are required to speak in English class. Shyness is one
c. Anxiety
that can make students do not feel comfortable when they doing speaking
quality of oral language production and make individuals appear less fluent
than the really are. By the explanation above, the teacher should make an attempt
11
d. Lack of confidence
The situations of lack confidence are when the students who did not
apply English orally could have a negative impact. They were afraid to
speak and to make the mistakes. Often they chose to remain silent or did not
speak English in order to avoid the ridicule of friends. Sometimes they had
prepared words, but they found it difficult to express them. Therefore, this
they could do anything, then they were up for the challenge. Despite facing
tough problems, they easily found the best solution to improve themselves. Self-
confidence is the key to success in English speaking skills. Students who are
confident in their abilities are able to overcome their fears and negative
thoughts so that they will speak English fluently. Therefore, the teachers
by having positive thinking and showing love for their self. When students
could do these two things, they would be able to speak English without any
fear.
2. Language aspects
12
English language skills can be seen from four skills, namely writing,
reading, speaking, and listening. In addition, there are three language elements
that play an important role in supporting the four skills, namely these four skills,
a. Pronunciation is one part of speaking skills that will be directly and clearly
Speakers who are not native English speakers (non-native speakers) when
Lado (1964: 70), pronunciation is the use of the sound system in speaking
listening; Lado does not mention how the sound is produced. The sound is
understood (intelligible).
13
defined. Hatch & Brown (1995) say that vocabulary refers to a list or set
of words for a particular language or a list or set of words that may be used
language. From this statement, vocabulary can be defined as all the words
that are known or used by everyone, and it is all the words in a particular
language.
sentences, and more. Grammar is the first lesson learned by humans since
14
they were babies. When we are young, we often hear people around us
talking, so over time we learn how to pronounce words, then learn to form
begun since the Dutch colonial era, the dynamics of policies and curriculum
changes from the government have colored our education world, especially in
English subjects themselves. The need to use and master foreign languages,
especially English has made changes which is quite significant in the education
a society and especially educators themselves, they certainly understand and have
hope that if English does have an important role in learning in Indonesia, English
must remain in the learning curriculum in Indonesia, considering and seeing its
the low interest in learning English among students, students feeling hesitant in
from students, and also educators who are less competent in teaching so that it
15
and of course the government’s goal to include English lesson in the curriculum
competitiveness.
order they can carry out the successful speaking. They have to fulfill some
a. Participant is even
b. Motivation is high
Learners are eager to speak if they are interested in the topic have something
new to say about it, because they want to contribute to achieving a task
objective.
problem which teacher has to solve it. Ur (1991) mention that at least there are
1. Use group
This research used a qualitative approach, with findings that were not
design employed was a case study. A case study is a research method that
have occurred but still leave a significant impact at the time the research was
conducted within the context of real life, using various data sources. The case
condition and to provide insight into the processes that explain how certain events
or situations occur.
3.2 Setting
This research conducted at Madrasah Aliyah Alkhairat Pusat Palu, Jl. Sis
Al Jufri, Palu, Central Sulawesi. There are 5 students and one teacher as
participants, and the reseacher find out the information about student
collecting data in order to make it easier (Arikunto, 2000). There are the
18
19
1) Researcher
questions, observed, and analyzed the learning process from the observations
made, and the results of the interviews made the research clearer and more
meaningful.
The researcher asked the teacher during observation about several things, then
interviewed students in the class about the learning process and other relevant
things.
2) Observation checklist
to obtain data. the researcher made observation checklist to find out the
3) Interview guide
4) Recorder
It is used to record the students and teacher during speaking activity learning
data collection.
1) Observation
collecting data, the researcher used observation to get more information about
In this research, the researcher did not teach the students but only observed
their activities in the classroom while learning to speak. The researcher used an
experienced while speaking during English lessons. In this case, the researcher
observed, analyzed, and drew conclusions about the subjects based on the data.
2) Interview
focused on students who had the lowest scores in the speaking test, as suggested
by the English teacher. Additionally, the researcher interviewed one teacher who
21
taught English at Madrasah Aliyah Alkhairat Pusat Palu to gain insights into the
difficulties students faced while speaking English during the learning process.
transcripts and other materials that the researcher collected to enhance her own
Alkhairat Pusat Palu. The data collected was analyzed through data reduction,
1. Data reduction
points the most needed in research focusing on the main things from the data that
appear in interview transcript and field note of observation, describing them into
2. Data display
Data display was the second component in analyzing the data. It involved
conclusions could be drawn more easily. Sugiyono (2012) stated that the most
commonly used form of data display for qualitative research was narrative text.
22
This meant that the data was presented and explained in the form of words,
3. Conclusion Drawing
The researcher collected the data and analyzed it to ensure it was valid, consistent,
and sufficient. The researcher read the entire transcripts of the interviews and
drew conclusions from the field notes of observations and interviews. The
difficulties in speaking English. These findings are based on the analysis of data
process in the classroom. The researcher observed how the teacher teaches, the
teacher's interaction with students during the learning process, and communication
in the classroom when providing material. Here researcher also saw how students
are during the learning process, student interactions with teachers, interactions
among students, how active students are in class when asking questions and
presenting their assignments, and how often the use of English in the classroom is
Researchers conducted interviews with the same students, namely from class XI
August 21 and 26, 2024. Based on the results of observations and interview,
23
24
a. Psychological Aspect
saw that the teacher used Indonesian 95% of the time. At the
beginning of the lesson, when the teacher opened the class, English
was used, but when the teacher began to explain the subject matter,
Indonesian was used and English was no longer spoken. The teacher
used Indonesian from the provision of material to the end of the lesson,
while students used English in class only 3% of the time, both when
teacher, they found it difficult to answer and even had to use Google
Translate to help them translate words that had been classified as easy.
penyebutan kata saya jelek dan juga takut salah sebut kata." Other
25
they sometimes felt anxious about their ability to speak English, which
them feel uneasy and not confident. The students also faced
b. Language Aspect
found a lack of use of English in the classroom and during the learning
which affects the use and increase of new vocabulary due to the lack of
to the lack of direct practice in the classroom because they always use
when students try to say something in English they look difficult to put
grammar. Their first difficulty was the lack of English vocabulary that
was memorized and known by the students. The next difficulty for
by a lack of practice and a lack of use in daily life and in class, making
them less accustomed and feeling embarrassed and not confident when
they had to speak in English in class. Then the last one was grammar.
In this case, students found difficulties when they were trying to string
structure in English, which was also the reason why they had difficulty
due to a lack of familiarity in its use, students who daily used their
27
caused by the way words were mentioned, which was different from
and English was slightly different, which was also a factor in their
daily life also made it difficult for them to get used to using English
4.2 DISCUSSION
The study's findings shed light on the challenges students encounter
learning to speak as well as the methods they take to get past those challenges.
The explanation will follow the data description and be shown below.
This study revealed that students in grade XI social studies faced some
difficulties when learning to speak English. These difficulties could be seen from
were fears of making mistakes, shyness, anxiety, and a lack of confidence, and
lack of motivation. In the language aspect, there were difficulties with incorrect
understanding of grammar.
struggle in English was fear of making mistakes. The students admitted that they
28
found it difficult to learn how to pronounce vocabulary correctly, and they were
afraid of making mistakes when speaking English. They were especially afraid of
mispronouncing words because they believed that some words had the same
they made mistakes in speaking English. A number of experts argued that one of
the main reasons students were unwilling to communicate in English in class was
that they were afraid of making mistakes. This aligned with the statement made by
Juhana (2012:101), who also mentioned that this concern was related to students'
the teacher. Next was shyness, which was comparable to a lack of confidence; in
other words, when students lacked confidence, it was because they were not
students' anxiety about making mistakes because they felt embarrassed to use the
language if they made mistakes when speaking with their classmates. The last
issue was a lack of motivation. Although only one student out of five reported
having less motivation, the other students answered never in the given
questionnaire, but this had a significant impact on their ability to speak English,
making it difficult for them to form sentences and create easy speech.
The first factor causing students difficulties in speaking English from the
language aspect was the lack of pronunciation. Students had difficulty because
they had not mastered how to pronounce English words correctly. According to
them, the way words were pronounced was different when they were read and
when they were spoken. In addition, the students agreed that one of the challenges
29
they faced when learning to speak was incorrect English pronunciation because
English pronunciation and writing were different, and some words were difficult
for them to pronounce. Next was the lack of vocabulary. The majority of students
realized that they did not master English vocabulary because, according to them,
English was a foreign language that was not often used in daily life. English
vocabulary was also too extensive to memorize, which made students feel unable
to string words together when speaking English. Finally, there was the lack of
knowledge about grammar. This was also caused by the slight differences
between Indonesian and English grammar, along with the lack of instruction on
grammar during lessons by teachers, which meant they had to learn on their own
mistakes.
CHAPTER V
CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTION
5.1 CONCLUSION
lessons, the elements that produce difficulties in English speaking lessons, and
fear of appearing foolish, and limited vocabulary. They struggle to retain words
and pronounce them correctly, making it difficult for them to comprehend the
speaker's words. They also feel ashamed when making mistakes in their English
5.2 SUGGESTION
Based on the conclusions presented in the fourth chapter, researcher
suggest that students should be encouraged to speak more in their daily lives and
30
31
Google Translate. Teachers should avoid using their mother tongue when
teaching English, and the learning process should be fun to avoid boredom. The
features-oral-presentation.html
Hermaniar, Y., & Azkiya, N. (2021). Anxiety issues on English speaking class;
the analysis of students’ problems of English language education study
program. Prosiding Seminar Nasional Sensaseda. (1). 169-176.
32
33
Shen, M. & Chiu, T. (2019). EFL learners’ English speaking difficulties and
strategy use. Education and Linguistics Research, 5(2), 88-102. Doi:
doi:10.5296/elr.v5i2.15333
34
35
Interview Guide
Nama: _____________________
Kelas: _____________________
4. Menurut anda, apa penyebab kesulitan anda dalam berbicara bahasa Inggris?
APPENDICES 1
INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT
Description of the Informant:
S : Student
R : Researcher
STUDENT 1
S:Iya suka
S: 100%
S: Penyebutannya kak susah, kadang malu kak soalnya kadang kalau saya
bicara itu nada nya jelek dan penyebutannya nya juga banyak salah .
R: Oke terus menurut anda faktor apakah yang mempengaruhi kesulitan tsb
S: Faktornya karena kurang kosa kata sehingga itu membuat saya sulit dalam
R: Tapi pernah kah kau juga ada rasa takut buat kesalahan pas bicara di depan
kelas?
S: Pernah kak, sering malah apalagi kalau sudah tidak tau mau bilang apalagi
Karna vocab ku kurang atau tidak karna takut salah sebut kata.
S: Sangat berpengaruh kak karna kalau sudah gugup takut salah otomatis
bahasa inggris?
S: Kalau saya sendiri supaya kosa kata ku bertambah, saya sering dengar
lagu bahasa inggris atau tidak nonton film barat pake subtitel biar
kedepannya?
S: untuk guru mungkin kak, biasanya penjelasannya tdk merata, jadi itu bisa
di tingkatkan kayaknya.
R: Oke terimakasih
STUDENT 2
S: Iya suka
38
S: Kekurangan kosa kata sih kak, jadi kalau mau translate begitu tidak tau
artinya apa.
R: Oh susah menterjemahkan karena kurang kosa kata ya jadi tidak tau, terus
gimana pengucapannya?
R: Terus kamu kalau kita tidak tau berbicara bahasa inggris begitu kita tidak
S: Iya kak kurang percaya diri dan malu juga kak, apalagi kalau banyak salah-
salahku
R : Saran kamu agar siswa dapat mengatasi kesulitan tsb apa saja ?
S: Dengan banyak lagi belajar kosa kata dan pronunciation. Bisa dari lagu atau
R: Baik. Terimakasih.
STUDENT 3
S: Iya kak
S: Suka kak,
S: Tidak kak, terus di sekolah ini juga tidak di tekankan sekali harus
S: Sama kayak yang lain, saya sering belajar dari lagu karna lumayan suka
R : Oh baik kalau begitu saranmu agar siswa dapat mengatasi kesulitan itu apa
sih?
R: Oke makasih.
STUDENT 4
S: Karna susah dan cara baca dan tulisannya beda. Bikin bingung kak.
R: Oh iya memang sih banyak juga yang punya kesulitan kayak kau. Kalau
S: Kesulitan menghafal kosa kata kak, karna di Bahasa Inggris itu kosa
katanya banyak sekali baru satu kata kadang ada yang lebih dari satu
artinya.
S: Sama ini kak saya tidak tau tentang verb, itu kan pake rumus kak harus di
S: Iya kak sulit dlm pengucapan dn grammar.kalau percaya diri tidak terlalu
grammar ya.
S: Iya kak.
wajibkan. atau di sekolah ini misal di wajibkan atau ada hari tertentu untuk
bicara bahasa inggris mau tidak mau terbiasa, dn itu membantu bisa
berbicara bahasa inggris. dan banyak orang bisa menangkap pelajaran itu
dari di dengarkan dari pada di baca. jadi lebih mudah untuk di mengerti.
R: Baik terimasih
STUDENT 5
S: Iya suka.
kurang bagus atau penulisannya kurang tepat karena bhs inggris itu biasanya
42
seperti i think, itu tulisannya bukan tink tapi harus di tambah, jadi tidak sesuai
biasanya.
S: Biasanya saya rajin belajar, rajin mengkaji bahasa inggris itu bagaimana,rajin
menghafal kosa kata, biasanya dari dengar lagu atau dari film yang saya nonton
agar bisa mempermudah untuk berbicara bahasa inggris, itu saja sih kak.
S: Kalau dari saya sih kak mungkin suasananya dalam belajar bisa di buat lebih
santai dan seru, supaya siswa yg belajar tidak gugup dan lebih nyaman jadi tidak
R: Oke makasih.
43