Simcona Guide To Control Panel Engineering V1
Simcona Guide To Control Panel Engineering V1
PANEL ENGINEERING
275 Mount Read Blvd. Rochester, NY 14611 | 800.274.6266 | [email protected] | www.simcona.com
Table of Contents
Intro 2
PART 2: Layout 3
PART 3: Wiring 6
PART 4: Components 10
PART 5: Enclosure 14
Next Steps 25
Electric panel manufacturing is highly engineered and highly manual – it’s more than just
slapping together an enclosure and back panel to house some wires and fuses. A suc-
cessful build requires serious know-how and careful planning to develop an interface that
can efficiently manage an industrial process.
This Guide to Control Panel Engineering will empower you with best practices for quality
and safety, from conceptual design to production, installation, and maintenance. You’ll
learn how the layout, wiring, enclosure, and other factors influence the life cycle of your
panel.
With your requirements set, create a drawing that addresses both the electrical and
physical needs of the panel. Your schematic must include:
• Functional diagram
• I/O (Input/Output) diagram
• Power distribution
• Enclosure layout, including the back panel
• Bill of materials
Get specific about the configuration of wiring, circuits, controls, and every other
component of the final product.
There’s a lot to cover, so consider including a table of contents for easy reference. Don’t
rush through this stage or make assumptions when communicating – any mistakes can
compound and lead to costly repairs later.
PART 2: LAYOUT
“Keep it simple, stupid,” or KISS, is a mantra many people recommend for building anything
– from websites to war planes. There’s some validity to the idea in electronics, too – simple
panel layouts are cheaper to produce, and often easier to manufacture and maintain.
Industrial-grade control
panels are complex
creatures to lay out, so
simplicity is easier said
than done. To make
simplicity … simple, focus
on these areas of design:
• Grouping
components
• Overcurrent
protection
• Spacing
AC and DC components, as well as their grounding paths, belong on opposite sides of the
panel. By separating these types of current flow, you’ll:
• Minimize short-circuiting
• Reduce electromagnetic interference
• Make troubleshooting & maintenance easier
Heat buildup affects some components more than others, so prioritize the placement of
those at-risk parts first. Arrange components that generate significant heat, such as power
supplies and variable frequency drives, in a way that exposes them to enough airflow. Put
the risky stuff closest to a heat sink, fan, or other cooling device.
If you can, put devices of similar sizes in a bay together. Also, by grouping similarly func-
tioning components (i.e. contactors and relays), you can:
Consider whether you’re OK with needing to access the enclosure for inside-the-panel
protection. But above all else, make sure you do something to deter overcurrent –
otherwise you’ll risk unnecessary damage and downtime.
• Choosing wire
• Laying wire
• Grounding wire
• Service loops & slack
• Ferrules
• Testing early
Hopefully everyone agrees on the end goal: producing an assembly that’s logically
arranged and easy to maintain for a long service life.
While there are many universal rules for laying out and grounding wire, choosing the
product itself is mostly case-by-case.
• Size – Pick the appropriate wire gauge based on load current, The circuit must be
capable of delivering the required current without the wire breaking down.
• Mechanical properties – In certain applications, wires must be able to withstand
crushing and cutting forces. Or, there could be a need for extra flexibility in a
dynamic or compact assembly – this is a great time to use stranded wire.
• Heat, cold, & flame – Temperature ratings determine the maximum how extreme a
wire’s working environment can be without degrading. The designer must account
for not only internal heat sources, but also external heat and cold. Depending on
your application, you may need to also prove your wires won’t catch fire too easily or
emit toxic fumes when burning.
• Corrosion – Your panel’s environment might include moisture, chemicals, oil, or dust.
There are wire types purpose-built for these situations, and they’re well worth the
investment.
This is another step where it’s vital to account for both electrical and physical layout.
There are ways your control panel layout can promote safe, effective grounding:
• Route grounding wires separately from power lines. This prevents the current from
leaking between lines and becoming a shock hazard.
• Rethink dedicated grounding busbars. Mount them where they’ll be easily
accessible for connecting all grounding conductors.
• Avoid ground loops. Route grounding conductors in a direct, single-point fashion
with the appropriate length of wire to prevent unwanted noise or voltage differences.
More specific grounding best practices may vary based on your application and industry
standards, so consult with a panel manufacturing expert if you’ve got concerns.
Service loops at entry and exit points provide several potential benefits:
And yes, there is such a thing as too much slack. One balanced option is stripping each
cable’s jacket 2+ cm from its fitting. This facilitates service looping and saves space.
• Relieves strain
• Lowers electrical resistance
• No strand displacement to the sides
• Reduces oxidation from lack of air space
As with all electrical design, there are right and wrong ways to set up ferrules:
• Size: Make sure the connection is strong and they’re easy to insert into terminal
blocks.
• Space: Leave space in the termination area within the panel, around other
components, and wherever the maintenance team needs access.
• Label: To make troubleshooting quicker, clearly ID ferrules with conductor, circuit, and
other key info. Consider color-coding by circuit or function.
To perform a simple pull test, apply gentle pressure on both ends of the wire until you feel
resistance. Less resistance equals less wire separation from the terminal during vibration or
movement.
The specifics of your ideal pull testing method may vary by wire type and application.
Destructive methods tend to give more useful data.
If you find wires disconnecting too easily, adjust your layout accordingly. You may need to
add slack or a service loop, or perhaps there’s a way to arrange your components more
efficiently.
To maintain human and machine safety and maximize the assembly’s efficiency, choose
the components of your control panel based on:
• Size
• Electrical load
• Functionality
• Compatibility with your system
Here’s a little advice on squeezing the most out of various component types.
When choosing circuit breakers, consider trip characteristics and interrupting capacities
to handle fault conditions.
When choosing surge protectors, consider clamping voltage, response time, and how
they’ll co-exist with other protective components.
Here’s another case where the KISS method may work best.
When choosing control components, start by weighting the simplest options first. These
include relays and timers.
If these don’t work out, move to more advanced options, like a smart relay or PLC
(programmable logic controller). These offer a lot more to the user, but only if they know
how to program it. They also require a computer and programming software.
The point is, don’t start at the filet mignon solution (a PLC). Use the simplest controls
possible for the application – a flat-iron steak (relay) may offer enough sizzle to get the job
done.
When speccing out an operator device, shoot for a design that’s straightforward to use, yet
can meet the assembly’s functional requirements.
SIMPLE COMPLEX
When a panel concept calls for user input, some designers immediately jump to human-
machine interfaces (HMIs) as the answer. Sometimes an HMI is the way to go, but other
times there’s a simpler device type that’s perfectly suitable for the application.
(Note: OSHA requires that all industrial control panels include an emergency stop [separate from any
cycle stop]. This e-stop can’t be a button on an HMI; it must be a push button hard-wired into the
safety circuit. For optimal safety, place start buttons and switches immediately above or left of the
stop button.)
No matter your panel’s application, proper design and installation of the power supply and
distribution system are essential to meeting electrical load requirements. A reliable power
source ensures that all electrical components receive enough voltage to remain healthy.
The supply conductor you choose should allow for the highest possible load your panel
might endure. One way to calculate this is:
+ + =
All connected The full load 125% of the full Recommended
motors and current for all load current of capacity of
mechanisms resistive loads the highest rated supply conductor
motor
Don’t think of enclosures as trivial, interchangeable parts – what works for a server rack
may fail horribly for mining equipment. These enclosure design guidelines address both
electrical and physical needs so your precious equipment reaches its life expectancy:
No matter your classifications, make sure they’re printed on a metal plate and attached to
the enclosure for quick identification.
Any UL safety rating or NEMA classification your enclosure has should influence your
material and design choices. Much of that comes down to the product’s need for:
• Outdoor use
• Water resistance
• Dust & solid contaminants-proofing
• Hazardous-conditions rating
• Explosion-proof rating
If the overall installation will reside in a hazardous or classified location included in Articles
500-506 of NEC installation requirements, the enclosure must offer additional protection.
The long and short is that your assembly should stay dry, clean, and isolated from
interference. Material choice goes a long way toward that:
Painting a plain steel enclosure offers cheap protection, but it won’t last long in many
industrial uses. Aluminum enclosures may be more cost-efficient for protecting industrial
control panel components that’ll be subject to a low-to-moderate moisture or dust levels.
To extend your industrial enclosure’s life span, specify a custom finish like anodizing (for
aluminum) or powder coating (for any of the above).
• Material selection – aluminum alloys dissipate heat better than stainless steel
• Exterior color
• Sun shield
• Back panels with internal vents.
• Increased enclosure size – see Part 5-4 for more
• Keeping it away from other heat-generating equipment
Temperature needs depend on the panel’s proximity to natural and machine-made heat.
Warming features may be necessary for cold locations, or for humid locations where you
need to increase the interior temperature just enough to stop moisture buildup.
• Accurate readings
• Heat efficiency
• Installation & access
• Expansion
The number of doors necessary (usually 1-2) often determines the overall size of an
industrial enclosure. However, you’ll also have to consider the minimum and maximum
dimensions for meeting the supplier’s (even if it’s you) design-for-manufacturability
requirements. Modeling the box build with 3D software helps stamp out space and
interference concerns.
Obviously, the enclosure must be big enough to fit the components inside, and the
enclosure itself must fit in your available installation area. Some manufacturers
recommend that 20% of the enclosure’s area goes to spare space, depending on your
application.
All that advice is great for today, but what about when you want to adapt or expand your
enclosure to meet new needs? If there’s room for it to grow, leave room for the enclosure –
and its heat output – to grow too.
Besides creating more heat by adding more parts, another example of expansion issues is
the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT). Not all machine connectivity is software-based – you
may want to leave room in the control panel to include new “smart” hardware, too.
Entry and exit points matter to both installers and operators. The budget manager will care,
too, if tough-to-access panels drive up labor costs.
Your enclosure’s size and purpose will influence the success of the installation method:
• Properly mount the hardware on a back panel and wire it into the machine.
• Most applications need sufficiently sized cable-access holes on the top and bottom
of the box. For power cables, knockouts in the front and back of the frame are also
wise.
• If switches and buttons will penetrate the enclosure, you’ll likely need to seal the
area.
• When using air conditioners or fans, direct warm air out the top of the enclosure and
bring cool air in from the bottom. This aids the natural convective transfer of heat.
• Don’t block air vents!
• Handles, through-door disconnects, and interlocks can provide tagout points for
extra safety. They prevent the door from opening until the user turns off the external
power.
• Lift-off and reversible doors that move out of the way can speed up equipment
installation. Beyond that, access to interior parts will be easier if the operator can
remove the enclosure’s side panels from the outside.
• An assembly that doesn’t require forklifts and multiple workers to manage is a huge
time- and money-saver.
6-1. UL 508A
For industrial-grade control panels, the UL508A certification standard serves as official
proof that a manufacturer has made a safe, reliable product. It’s the gateway to your
products passing inspection and maximizing operational uptime.
UL standards outline specific requirements for wiring, such as materials, wire thickness,
power circuit conductor size, and labels. There are many other UL standards that relate
to control panels; most are hyper-specific (i.e. UL 218: Standard for Fire Pump Controllers). A
few others we’ll cover in a moment are specific to hazardous areas.
• Enclosures
• Overcurrent protection
• Interconnects
• Motor drives
• Switches
• Terminal blocks
• Transformers
• Contactors
All electrical ratings and instructions must be directly on the panel for safe installation and
use.
• Temperature
• Overvoltage & undervoltage
• Overload
• Calibration
• Dielectric voltage
• Short-circuiting
• Standard & high fault currents
• Transient voltage surge suppression
• Breakdown of components
• UL 698A – For panels in ordinary locations, but with circuit barrier extensions into
locations with gas, vapor, dust, or fiber hazards
• UL 1203 – For panels in locations with gas, vapor, or dust that could cause ignition or
explosion
• UL 121201 – For nonincendive equipment in locations with gas, vapor, dust, or fiber
hazards
NFPA 70 is for installation. It lays out the design practices that lead to safe installation:
• Wire size
• Spacings
• Permissible exterior equipment
• Wiring
• Electrical controls
• Other components
UL requires documented proof that each panel meets applicable NEC requirements. The
NEC is an essential tool for electronics manufacturers because it gives specific instructions
on proper design and avoiding safety risks.
We’re not here to judge your decision, but here’s some firsthand wisdom about the design
implications of insourcing or outsourcing your panel.
If a panel design looks cost-prohibitive to handle in-house, you have two options: Redesign
for manufacturability and sourceability, or offload the hassle.
Third-party suppliers already have sourcing, production, and quality processes in place.
Where a good panel specialist separates itself is how cost-efficiently it executes all that:
Think about your company’s and buyer’s timeline expectations. Is your concept simple
enough to efficiently insource with your existing talent and tech? If it’s a complex or risky
build, consider outsourcing to a dedicated team and production cells.
If you’re replacing an existing panel, there may be a simpler path. See if your company
still has the initial drawings and bill of materials, and whether you can replicate them in-
house.
Because panels are highly engineered products, there’s only so much that automated
processes can solve for you in-house. A purpose-built team and facility will probably get
better results.
You might be a great designer. But say your concept requires a 10-year service life in an
aerospace application. … Is your overwhelmed team going to deliver?
The more your design pushes the boundaries past “commodity,” the more you’ll invite risk
by going full DIY. Your design’s potential ends where your team’s ability ends – are you
missing out on a creative solution?
If you can tell your model will be a pain to make, it probably will be for a contractor too. But
at least a contractor will have the deftness to make it work (and improve it).
Start with a schematic that demonstrates your understanding of the specs, industry
standards, and environmental factors most relevant to your project. From there, choose
and arrange components, wires, and the enclosure in a way that manages heat and
current effectively – today and for future expansions.
With the right mindset (and, depending on your capacity, the right partner), you can
deliver zero-delay and zero-defect results!
RESOURCES