Download ebooks file Pragmatist Philosophy and Dance Interdisciplinary Dance Research in the American South Eric Mullis all chapters
Download ebooks file Pragmatist Philosophy and Dance Interdisciplinary Dance Research in the American South Eric Mullis all chapters
Download ebooks file Pragmatist Philosophy and Dance Interdisciplinary Dance Research in the American South Eric Mullis all chapters
com
https://textbookfull.com/product/pragmatist-philosophy-and-
dance-interdisciplinary-dance-research-in-the-american-
south-eric-mullis/
OR CLICK BUTTON
DOWNLOAD NOW
https://textbookfull.com/product/embodied-philosophy-in-dance-gaga-
and-ohad-naharins-movement-research-1st-edition-einav-katan-auth/
textboxfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/impersonations-the-artifice-of-
brahmin-masculinity-in-south-indian-dance-harshita-mruthinti-kamath/
textboxfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/ungoverning-dance-contemporary-
european-theatre-dance-and-the-commons-1st-edition-burt/
textboxfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-art-and-science-of-dance-
movement-therapy-life-is-dance-2nd-edition-sharon-chaiklin/
textboxfull.com
Dance and Creativity within Dance Movement Therapy
International Perspectives 1st Edition Hilda Wengrower
https://textbookfull.com/product/dance-and-creativity-within-dance-
movement-therapy-international-perspectives-1st-edition-hilda-
wengrower/
textboxfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/dance-and-ethics-moving-towards-a-
more-humane-dance-culture-1st-edition-naomi-m-jackson/
textboxfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/considering-ethics-in-dance-theatre-
and-performance-fiona-bannon/
textboxfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-psychology-of-perfectionism-in-
sport-dance-and-exercise-andrew-hill/
textboxfull.com
PERFORMANCE PHILOSOPHY
Pragmatist
Philosophy and
Dance
Interdisciplinary Dance Research
in the American South
Eric Mullis
Performance Philosophy
Series Editors
Laura Cull Ó Maoilearca
University of Surrey
Guildford, Surrey, UK
Alice Lagaay
Hamburg University of Applied Sciences
Hamburg, Germany
Will Daddario
Independent Scholar
Asheville, NC, USA
Performance Philosophy is an interdisciplinary and international field of
thought, creative practice and scholarship. The Performance Philosophy
book series comprises monographs and essay collections addressing the
relationship between performance and philosophy within a broad range of
philosophical traditions and performance practices, including drama, the-
atre, performance arts, dance, art and music. It also includes studies of the
performative aspects of life and, indeed, philosophy itself. As such, the
series addresses the philosophy of performance as well as performance-as-
philosophy and philosophy-as-performance.
Pragmatist Philosophy
and Dance
Interdisciplinary Dance Research in the American
South
Eric Mullis
Queens University of Charlotte
Charlotte, NC, USA
Performance Philosophy
ISBN 978-3-030-29313-0 ISBN 978-3-030-29314-7 (eBook)
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-29314-7
© The Editor(s) (if applicable) and The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer
Nature Switzerland AG 2019
This work is subject to copyright. All rights are solely and exclusively licensed by the
Publisher, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of
translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on
microfilms or in any other physical way, and transmission or information storage and retrieval,
electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now
known or hereafter developed.
The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc. in this
publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are
exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use.
The publisher, the authors and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and information
in this book are believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication. Neither the pub-
lisher nor the authors or the editors give a warranty, express or implied, with respect to the
material contained herein or for any errors or omissions that may have been made. The
publisher remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institu-
tional affiliations.
This Palgrave Macmillan imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature
Switzerland AG.
The registered company address is: Gewerbestrasse 11, 6330 Cham, Switzerland
Acknowledgments
I would like to express deep appreciation for the artists who made impor-
tant contributions to Later Rain over the five-year period it was devel-
oped: Brent Bagwell, Kadeylynn Ballard, Mark Baran, Troy Conn, Matt
Cosper, Micah Davidson, Jeremy Fisher, Daniel Flynn, Jessica Lindsey,
Rachel Rugh, John Shaughnessy, Alea Tuttle, and Scott Thompson. I am
grateful to those who provided critical feedback on drafts of the chapters
included in this book—Aili Bresnahan, Thomas DeFrantz, Ann Dils,
Kélina Gotman, Norris Frederick, Sarah Griffith, and Anna Pakes—and
for Aspen Hochhalter, Diane Mowrey, Stephan Sabo, The Wooster Group,
and Paula Court who generously provided photographs. This project was
also greatly benefited by Goodyear Arts, an independent arts organization
run by artists, which afforded me the opportunity to rehearse, perform,
and document early versions of Later Rain—many thanks to Amy Bagwell
and Amy Herman for their continued support. Lastly, I am grateful for the
inspiring movement artists and educators who encouraged me to seek out
new forms of embodied research—Ishmael Houston-Jones, Jesse Zaritt,
Paul Matteson, and Saar Harari—and for Joy Davis who listened while I
talked about church visits, who shared thoughtful insights and asked criti-
cal questions, and who provided dramaturgical feedback on Paw Creek
and The Land of Nod.
v
Praise for Pragmatist Philosophy and Dance
“In Pragmatist Philosophy and Dance: Dance Research in the American South, Eric
Mullis intertwines practical, dramaturgical, and ethnographic investigations to
develop an in-depth theoretical account of the evolution of knowledge in the artis-
tic process. This book advances an interdisciplinary approach to an individual artis-
tic journey into ecstatic embodiment and thereby develops a thorough analysis of
the relationship between aesthetics and epistemology. This impressive work con-
tributes to the study of knowledge reenactment and to the interdisciplinary
endeavor of Performance Philosophy.”
—Dr. Einav Katan-Schmid, core convener for the international network
Performance Philosophy and author of Embodied Philosophy in Dance (Palgrave
Macmillan, 2016).
ix
x CONTENTS
Index241
List of Figures
Fig. 1.1 Later Rain, 2018. Performers: Charlie Trexler, Eric Mullis,
Rachel Rugh. (Photo: Diane Mowrey) 17
Fig. 1.2 The Land of Nod, 2018. Performers: John Shaughnessy, Brent
Bagwell, Troy Conn, Eric Mullis. (Photo: Diane Mowrey) 19
Fig. 4.1 Early Shaker Spirituals: A record album interpretation. Directed
by Kate Valk. Performers pictured (l–r): Modesto Flako Jimenez,
Suzzy Roche, Bobby McElver, Bebe Miller, Frances McDormand,
Elizabeth LeCompte, Matthew Brown, Cynthia Hedstrom,
Andrew Schneider. (Photograph © Paula Court) 102
Fig. 5.1 Later Rain, 2018. Performers: Charlie Trexler, Rachel Rugh,
Eric Mullis. (Photo: Stephan Sabo) 142
Fig. 6.1 Later Rain. Performer: Matt Cosper. (Photo: Aspen Hochhalter) 155
Fig. 6.2 Later Rain. Performer: Kadeylynn Ballard. (Photo: Aspen
Hochhalter)157
Fig. 6.3 Later Rain. Performers: Eric Mullis, Matt Cosper, Troy Conn.
(Photo: Aspen Hochhalter) 172
xiii
CHAPTER 1
I was unsure how to interpret the performance. It did not enact con-
ventions of a rock concert—such as lighting cues synchronized with musi-
cal rhythms or musicians interacting with audience members—and the
aesthetics and lyrics hindered the festive communal atmosphere that
concert-goers often seek out.2 The show was not entertaining in a conven-
tional sense because it aesthetically and dramaturgically distorted a musico-
theological tradition and expressed weighty religious themes. The musical
instrumentation, lyrics, and the frontman’s commanding presence pro-
duced the sense that I had stepped back in time to a rural tent revival led
by a preacher who was working through a crisis of faith, even while the
silent band members stoically continued to play, and bewildered congre-
gation members looked on.
This raised several questions. Did the band believe in a pre-modern form
of Protestantism, or was I witnessing a purely theatrical performance aimed
at satirizing contemporary evangelical Christianity? If the band members
believed in the form of Christianity they presented, did they intend for the
audience to believe it as well? That is, was it a form of evangelical witnessing
that used powerful music and lyrics to encourage the audience to grapple
with their own moral and spiritual failings? Or, if it was satire, what was the
reason for the critical attitude? Was it using gothic folk aesthetics to critique
popular money-making televangelist empires or mega-churches that advo-
cate for a feel-good form of affluent Christianity? To return to the image of
the tent revival, as the viewer, was I being framed as a fellow Christian who
expected a more conventional religious service, as a curious agnostic
bystander, or as someone who is quite cynical about contemporary
Christianity? Both the form and content of Sixteen Horsepower’s perfor-
mance positioned me, but for what purpose was altogether unclear.3
After later listening to the band’s albums, I realized that the concert
was disorienting because several performative layers—each with its own
internal tension—powerfully intertwined at any given moment. The fusion
of American folk music and dark electrified rock and roll—reminiscent of
bands such as Joy Division or Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds—stimulates
reflection on the respective musical genres. The music is tensely poised
between a pre-modern acoustic past and a postmodern electric present. At
the same time, Edwards’ dark approach to Christian hymns is distinct
from contemporary gospel music which uses major chords and a pop-music
sensibility to support personally uplifting and celebratory lyrical content.
When asked about this in an interview, he replied that dark music more
powerfully stirs his soul and elicits a personal honesty that he channels into
his songwriting and performances.4
1 SOURCES: BEYOND THE PALE 7
And these signs shall follow them that believe; In my name shall they cast
out devils; they shall speak with new tongues. They shall take up serpents;
1 SOURCES: BEYOND THE PALE 9
and if they drink any deadly thing, it shall not hurt them; they shall lay hands
on the sick, and they shall recover. (Mark 16: 17–18)
Behold, I give unto you power to tread on serpents and scorpions, and over
all the power of the enemy; and nothing shall by any means hurt you.
(Luke 10:19)
And when they were escaped, then they knew that the island was called
Melita. And the barbarous people shewed us no little kindness: for they
kindled a fire, and received us every one, because of the present rain, and
because of the cold. And when Paul had gathered a bundle of sticks, and laid
them on the fire, there came a viper out of the heat, and fastened on his
hand. And when the barbarians saw the venomous beast hang on his hand,
they said among themselves, no doubt this man is a martyr, whom, though
he hath escaped the sea, yet vengeance suffereth not to live. And he shook
off the beast into the fire and felt no harm. Howbeit they looked when he
should have swollen, or fallen down dead suddenly, but after they changed
their minds, and said that he was a god. (Acts 28: 1–6)
Fig. 1.1 Later Rain, 2018. Performers: Charlie Trexler, Eric Mullis, Rachel
Rugh. (Photo: Diane Mowrey)
Colin did so. The road, slightly on the down grade, was working
round the edge of an immense mass of rock, that rose almost sheer
from the valley, a thousand feet below. The broad terrace—it was
about twenty yards wide—in which the road ran, was the only track
of any size on the face of the cliff, and, being partially overhung by
the mass of rock beyond it and the summit, appeared narrower than
it actually was. Beyond the valley, dense with sub-tropical foliage,
and already shaded from the rays of the setting sun, were range
upon range of rugged mountains.
CHAPTER XI
AT THE EDGE OF THE CHASM
Tiny Desmond, lying across the back of the front seat, was
breathing heavily. For one thing, he was badly scared; for another,
the brass-rimmed edge of the seat-back had well-nigh winded him.
The man went to a locker in the rear of the car and pulled out a coil
of three-inch Manilla rope of at least twenty-five fathoms in length.
Next he produced two treble-sheaved cast-iron blocks and a couple
of crowbars.
"This is our ditching gear," explained Herbert Narfield. "I don't
suppose you ever thought to see this kind of repairing kit in a car?
It's most useful out here. Now, then, McFrazer, I think that boulder
will do. We may not want the crowbars."
In ten minutes the tackle was rigged, one block being made fast by
means of a strop round the boulder, the other to the chassis of the
car.
Slowly but surely the "flake" of the tackle came home; still more
slowly did the car retrace its tracks, until it was safely in the centre of
the rough road.
By this time the sun was almost hidden behind the distant
mountains. Already miasmic mists were rising from the valley. No
longer were the dense masses of trees visible. An even pall of white
vapour hid them, presenting the appearance of a vast lake.
"Now, lads, it's outspan—we camp here for the night," announced
Colonel Narfield. "It would be folly to attempt to proceed. Collect all
the wood you can find and pile it up in front of that hollow. I'll see to
the supper, while McFrazer carries on with fitting the Stepney."
For the next twenty minutes all was activity. They were racing
against time in order to make all snug before darkness set in. From
underneath the seats in the car Herbert Narfield produced a big pile
of blankets and some waterproof sheets. These, with the cushions,
were sufficient to make up three comfortable beds, arranged in a
segment of a circle, so that the sleepers' heads were towards the
wall of rock and their feet towards the fire.
Both Colin and Tiny recognised the sound. Lions were abroad; but
when the lads were camping in the open, it seemed quite a different
proposition from hearing the roar of the king of beasts from the
comfort and security of a moving railway train.
"We may as well have a can of petrol handy," observed the colonel.
"And the petrol-squirt, too," he added, as McFrazer hurried to the
car, which was a good thirty yards from the fire. He knocked the
ashes from his pipe.
"Sure?"
"Rather!"
"Well, I'm not," said Colin slowly. "Far from it. I'm fairly certain—
mind you, can't prove it—that the fellow was——"
CHAPTER XII
BESET BY LIONS
Both lads relapsed into silence. They knew perfectly well that with
Colonel Narfield an order was an order in whatever form it was
expressed. For the time being, then, Colin's explanations of his
surprising theory had to be shelved.
Ten minutes later both lads were sound asleep beneath the African
stars. The watcher by the fire heard their regular breathing.
"Not much wrong there," he soliloquised with a smile, "if they can
sleep like that."
"Weel, I'm thinkin' not, sir," replied the man. "Them beasties seem a
bit too venturesome the nicht."
For two hours the two men waited and watched, while their younger
companions slept. Apparently the lions had decided to maintain a
safe distance. They were roaring at frequent intervals—deep,
prolonged volumes of sound, and yet Colin and Tiny still slept.
Suddenly an antelope, racing like the wind, tore along the mountain
path. For a brief instant the startled creature stopped and gazed at
the blazing fire with consternation plainly written in its large brown
eyes. Then, evidently deeming the terror behind was more
formidable than that in front, it rushed madly between the flames and
the brink of the precipice and vanished in the darkness.
"It calls tae mind that bit in Melville Wood, sir," remarked McFrazer,
in a lower tone than was his wont. "We whur twa companies strong,
you'll remember, sir, an' we were expectin' Fritz in force come dawn.
I'll no complain o' the fight; 'twas the wait as gived maist o' the lads
the creepies."
He broke off his reminiscences and gripped his rifle. The colonel,
roused to action, followed the direction of the Scotsman's glance.
The tedious wait was at an end.
Silently a huge lion had approached. It was standing with its hind
legs slightly bowed and its forelegs planted stiffly upon a boulder. In
that position, thrown into strong relief against the blackness of the
night by the fire, its bulk was enormously magnified until it resembled
a ruddy, bronzed statue.
The animal was obviously troubled by the sight of the flames. The
fire stood in its path. With its head thrown well back, its enormous
lips bared and showing its cruel, magnificent teeth, the lion gave no
sign of movement except a slow, ponderous motion of its tail.
Throwing back his maned head still further, the lion roared. It was
an intimation to his companions that they could rejoin him, for quickly
two full-grown lionesses stood behind him.
The roar, shaking the solid ground, roused the sleepers in double
quick time. Tiny, shaking off his blankets, rose to his feet. Dazzled by
the glare and with the echoes of the terrible cry ringing in his ears,
he was for a moment unable to realise his surroundings.
Quick as lightning, the lion caught sight of the roused lad. The
beast was hungry, and when thoroughly famished a lion will not
hesitate to attack human beings, even when protected by fire. His
eyes closed ever so slightly, his nostrils quivered. These were
infallible signs that the lion contemplated a spring.
Then, with a roar of mingled rage and pain, the lion, with a
convulsive movement, leapt from the flames. Partly blinded, the
infuriated animal appeared to have no other object in view than to
make for Tiny Desmond, who, still partially encumbered with his
blankets, was flattening himself against the wall of rock.
Before Herbert Narfield could fire a second time, and McFrazer was
unable to fire at all owing to the danger of hitting his master, the lion
hurled the former aside.
The lion was down again, but rallying for a final spring upon the
supposed cause of his wound—the luckless Tiny.
In a trice, and almost automatically, Colin seized the colonel's rifle,
and, without waiting to see if there were a cartridge in the breech,
pressed the trigger.
Fortunately the weapon was loaded. The bullet, fired at less than
ten feet range, hit the lion just behind the left shoulder. With a yelp
the lion turned to deal with its latest assailant, and fell quivering upon
the ground, shot through the heart.
The warning was a timely one, for one of the lionesses, rendered
desperate by the death of her mate, was bounding rapidly towards
the still prostrate man.
Yet, in her fury, the lioness was not lacking in cunning. Keeping the
abandoned motor-car between her and McFrazer, she rapidly
covered the distance between her and the fire, which, owing to being
scattered by the lion's leap, was dying down and emitting clouds of
smoke.
Colonel Narfield had already realised his danger and that of the
whole party. At all costs the fire had to be made an effectual barrier.
Rapidly unscrewing the cap of the petrol tin that lay within his reach,
he hurled the tin into the centre of the wide circle of sizzling embers.
The fierce flames had effectually scared both lionesses. All danger
in that direction was now passed, but another peril rose to take its
place. The steadily spreading petrol threatened to trap the men in
the hollow in the tremendous wall of rock.
All they could do was to back as far as possible and wait. There
was no chance of skirting the fire. Already the flames were licking
the cliff at two points fifty yards apart.
But already the tide of flame was receding, at least on the side
nearest the four men. The terrain sloped ever so slightly in their
direction, and the volatile liquid failed to flow further.
Bang!
"Some of us might have been food for the lions if you hadn't,"
observed Colin. "Of course, it's rough luck to have to lose a good car
——"
Quitting their retreat that had all but been a fatal trap, the stranded
travellers hastened back along the cliff path until a projecting rock
offered a secure barrier from chance missiles.
They were only just in time. The ammunition, consisting of both ball
and shot cartridges, was exploding like the fire of a badly-disciplined
platoon. Fragments of nickel, splaying against the face of the cliff
above their head and dislodging fragments of rock, were sufficient
evidence to justify the display of caution on the part of Colonel
Narfield and his companions.
The petrol in the back of the car had also exploded—twenty gallons
that caused a flame compared to which the ignition of the two-gallon
tin was a mere nightlight.
Luckily the car had been standing on ground shelving towards the
cliff, and consequently the flaming spirit flowed steadily in that
direction, falling in a cascade of fire into the abyss and lighting the
deep valley for miles.
"We must get a move on before the sun's up," said Colonel Narfield
briskly. Although suffering considerable pain from the concussion
sustained when the lion hurled him to the ground he made light of his
hurts. His chief concern was for the welfare of his newly-joined
assistants, and realising that a merry heart goes a long way he
endeavoured by precept and example to cheer up his inexperienced
companions. "It's a mere forty miles to Kilembonga and fairly good
going. We'll be able to find horses at Sibenga's Kraal: that's a matter
of a couple of hours' trek. Now then, McFrazer, let's collect what
remains of the gear."
Of the car nothing remained but the four cylinders, a twisted crank-
case, the steel chassis, and a medley of buckled pipes, wires, and
rods.
For the next hour progress was well maintained in spite of the
rough road. It was steadily down hill, the path skirting the bold face
of the mountain for nearly two miles before it descended into a
grassy valley.
"H'm," remarked his questioner. "And who, might I ask, spun you
this fairy tale? Your friend Van der Wyck, eh? He must be a humorist
of sorts. Let me tell you that the Makoh'lenga are almost pure-
blooded Zulus. It is true that they trekked north, but the yarn about a
secret city is all eye-wash. The Makoh'lenga invariably live in kraals,
and since they are not allowed to fight they rear cattle. A few, I
believe, work in the mines, but only a few."
Placing the rifle he was carrying in the crook of his left arm, Colin
produced the swastika which he had worn round his neck since the
day on which he had had it given him.
"Well, you see," pursued Tiny, "Colin saved his life. He——"
"Shut up, you ass!" whispered Colin, turning a dusky red. "Nothing
of the sort, sir. I threw him a lifebelt. He had fallen overboard."
"And jumped in after it to make sure that Van der Wyck got it,"
continued the unabashed Tiny. "The ship was doing about seventeen
knots at the time and it was night. They were in the water for about
an hour before a boat picked them up."
The approach of the four white men had already been observed,
and a swarm of natives—men, women, and children—poured from
the huts with loud cries that were intended as a song of welcome for
the illustrious guests.
His face was full, his eyes small and deep set. A scanty black
beard failed to conceal the full protruding lips and flabby cheeks of
the chief. His feet from the lowermost folds of the puttees were bare.
In his right hand he carried a knobkerrie, while on his left arm he
bore a small cowhide shield.
"I want to borrow four good horses," he said, after explaining who
and what he was and that his kraal was at Kilembonga.
"I will give you four good blankets for the loan of the horses," said
Colonel Narfield firmly. "You can send men with us to bring the
animals back, and I will give them two good axes and a looking-glass
as a present to you."
"No; ten blankets, four axes, a looking-glass, and a box that talks"
(a gramophone or a musical box), declared Sibenga.
"Did you dare to bargain thus with the white men with yellow hair
and blue eyes?" asked Colonel Norfield.
"It has been reported to me," said Sibenga slowly and deliberately,
"that white men can fly higher and quicker than the mountain eagles.
Let me see you do it, and then I will believe. You will not want
horses, O white chief that went in a cart that smokes and came back
without it. Spread your wings and fly."
"The old rascal hasn't kept his eyes shut," remarked Colonel
Narfield to his companions. "He saw the car going to Tabora the day
before yesterday, and apparently his watchers saw the old bus
burning. At any rate, since we are on foot he thinks us very small
beer. We can't point a rifle at the old bounder's head, because
instructions have been given that the natives are to be treated with
consideration—and Sibenga evidently knows that and regards it as a
form of weakness. The District Magistrate, backed up by a full
company of Haussas, would put the wind up the fellow, I guess."
"Any use, do you think, sir?" he asked when he had briefly stated
his inspiration.
"We see the Sign!" almost shrieked the chief. "Speak Thy will, O
Great, Great One, and we obey."
CHAPTER XV
AT KILEMBONGA
"Tiny, old son," exclaimed Colin, "we've slept the clock round."
"Might have slept the clock square, for all I know," replied
Desmond, stretching his aching limbs. "Hullo! Where are we? Honest
Injun, I thought we were back at Stockmere."
The two chums sat up and gazed at one another from opposite
corners of a large palm-thatched room. The windows were shaded
by "jalousies" or open louvres, from the almost vertical rays of the
sun.
"They can't have arrived yet," replied his chum. "The bullock
waggon——"
Welcome to our website – the ideal destination for book lovers and
knowledge seekers. With a mission to inspire endlessly, we offer a
vast collection of books, ranging from classic literary works to
specialized publications, self-development books, and children's
literature. Each book is a new journey of discovery, expanding
knowledge and enriching the soul of the reade
Our website is not just a platform for buying books, but a bridge
connecting readers to the timeless values of culture and wisdom. With
an elegant, user-friendly interface and an intelligent search system,
we are committed to providing a quick and convenient shopping
experience. Additionally, our special promotions and home delivery
services ensure that you save time and fully enjoy the joy of reading.
textbookfull.com