0% found this document useful (0 votes)
29 views10 pages

Difference

Uploaded by

amit HCS
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
29 views10 pages

Difference

Uploaded by

amit HCS
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 10

Bailable Offenses Non-Bailable Offenses

An offense for which bail can be granted at An offense for which bail cannot be granted as a
Definition the time of arrest or during the trial process matter of right at the time of arrest. Accused is
as a matter of right. required to apply to the court for bail.

Who can grant Bail can be granted by the police officer or


Bail can only be granted by a court of law.
Bail? the court.
Kind of Crime Less serious and minor offenses. Serious and heinous offenses.
Punishment -
Lesser penalties and punishments. More severe penalties and punishments.
severity

For bailable offenses, the accused can be In non-bailable offenses, the accused must attend
Need for Court
released on bail without going through a court proceedings and apply for bail in front of a
Proceedings
court trial. judge.

Court must have strong reasons to grant bail, and


Discretion of the Court can decide to grant or deny bail
it can also deny bail based on the severity of the
Court based on circumstances.
offence.

Minor assault, stalking, theft, minor traffic


Examples Rape, murder, terrorism, kidnapping, etc.
violations, etc.

Aspect Cognizable Offence Non-Cognizable Offence

Offences where police can arrest Offences where police cannot arrest without a
Definition
without a warrant. warrant from a court.

Police have the authority to start an Police require permission from a magistrate to
Legal Authority
investigation without a court order. begin an investigation.

Examples Murder, rape, robbery, theft, etc. Forgery, cheating, assault, defamation, etc.

Severity of Usually severe, potentially life Generally lighter, often less than three years of
Punishment imprisonment or death. imprisonment.

Immediate arrest possible without prior Arrest only with a warrant issued by a
Arrest Procedure
judicial approval. magistrate.

Police can conduct the investigation


Investigation Investigation only after magistrate’s approval.
immediately upon registering an FIR.

FIR (First Mandatory and can be filed by the Not applicable directly; a police diary entry is
Information police on receiving knowledge of the made and a formal complaint must be
Report) commission of the offence. submitted to a magistrate.

Swift action possible due to the serious Slower process due to the requirement of
Preventive Action
nature of the crimes. warrants and permissions.

Public and Media Typically high due to the gravity of the Comparatively lower unless the case gains
Attention offences. specific interest.

Less immediate oversight in the initial High degree of oversight from the initiation of
Judicial Oversight
stages. the process.

Generally non-bailable; requires court Typically bailable directly at the police


Bail
intervention for bail. station.
Points Compoundable Offences Non-Compoundable Offences

Nature of Offence Less serious nature Serious nature

Compoundability Accusations can be dropped Accusations cannot be dropped

Parties Involved Private individual Individual and society

Court’s Approval Settlements with/without court’s approval Only quashing, no compounding

Filing of the Case Brought by private individuals Brought by the state

Charges Dropped or Not Charges may be dropped with consent Charges cannot be dropped

Accused may be declared free after Full trial to determine guilt or


Trial after Settlement
settlement innocence

Justification of Based on leniency for less serious Ensures punishment for grave and
DIfferentiation offences unlawful acts

Compoundable offence under IPC :Theft,


Non Compoundable offence under IPC :
Examples Grievous hurt, Defamation, Trespass,
Murder, Kidnapping, etc.
etc.

Summons Case Warrant Case

Offence
Less severe offences Serious and grave offences
Severity

Potential Punishable by death, life imprisonment, or >2


Generally lower penalties
Penalty years’ imprisonment

Accused’s Accused is issued a summons by the


Arrested by the police without a warrant
Notice court

Directly filed before the Magistrate or FIR filed at a Police Station or before the
Case Initiation
Police Station Magistrate

Remains a summons case, even if a Remains a warrant case, regardless of summons


Case Nature
warrant is issued issuance
Aspect Complaint First Information Report (FIR)

Written or verbal statement alleging a Formal document prepared by the police


Definition
crime has been committed. when informed of a cognizable offence.

Anyone, including the victim, witness Only by the person with knowledge of the
Who Can Lodge
or third party. commission of a cognizable offence.

Any local police station or law Police station with jurisdiction over the area
Where to Lodge
enforcement agency. where the crime took place.

Must always be registered when a cognizable


Outcome of Lodging Does not always lead to an FIR.
offence is reported.

Both cognizable and non-cognizable


Types of Offences Only for cognizable offences.
offences.

Must be recorded in a specific format as per


Format No specific format required.
the Criminal Procedure Code.

Written vs. Verbal Can be verbal or written. Must be in writing.

Police Obligation to
Police are not required to investigate. Police are required to investigate.
Investigate

Anonymity Can be made anonymously. Cannot be registered anonymously.

Legally binding document, basis for


Legal Binding Nature Not a legally binding document.
investigation and prosecution.

Basis FIR Charge Sheet

Legal Provisions Governed by Section 154 CrPC 1973 Governed by Section 173 CrPC 1973

A final police report forwarded to the


Filed immediately after the occurrence of a
Definition magistrate after the completion of the
cognizable offence
investigation

A written document filed before a police station


Prepared and filed by the investigating
Who Can File with initial information regarding the
officer
commission of a cognizable offence

Filed immediately after the occurrence of a Filed after the completion of the
Time of Filing
cognizable offense investigation

Not substantive evidence; used to corroborate or Not substantive evidence; serves as the
Admissibility
contradict witness testimony basis for prosecution

Prepared by the investigating officer


Jurisdiction Can be filed at any police station (Zero FIR)
with jurisdiction over the crime

Further reports and supplementary


Multiple Reports Filing a second FIR is generally not permitted
charge sheets can be submitted
Basis Police Custody Judicial Custody

Police officer in charge of the


Control Magistrate
police station

Investigation Conducted by the police Relies on evidence produced in court

Based on arrest, FIR or Must be produced before a magistrate within 24 hours,


Procedure
suspicion granted bail if charges not proved

Period of 90 days for non-bailable offences with severe


Maximum 15 days
Detention punishment, 60 days for bailable offences

Court permission is required


End of Custody Kept in judicial custody until granted bail
for interrogation

Kept in prison or police station


Jail Kept in central jail
cell

Interrogation Police officers can interrogate Court permission required for interrogation

Aspect Regular Bail Anticipatory Bail

Timing Sought after arrest and during custody Sought in anticipation of arrest

Nature of Available for both bailable and non-


Available only for non-bailable offences
Offence bailable offences

Right vs. Right for bailable offences, discretion for


Discretionary, intended as a safeguard
Discretion non-bailable offences

May be granted with or without conditions,


Conditions May be granted with or without conditions
usually more stringent

Ensure accused not unjustly detained Protect individuals from arbitrary arrest and
Purpose
before trial harassment

Aspect Search Seizure

Process of examining a person, place, or premises Involves taking possession of an item,


Definition to discover and collect material evidence related to property, or evidence discovered during
a crime. a search.

Integral part of the search process;


Can be conducted with or without a warrant under
Authorization occurs when relevant evidence or items
specific provisions CrPC 1973.
are discovered.

To find and collect evidence for use in the To secure and preserve evidence or
Purpose
investigation or prosecution of a criminal offence. items that are relevant to the case.

Specific procedures outlined in the CrPC, Not subject to separate procedures; part
Procedure including the presence of independent witnesses of the search process. Must be properly
and detailed record-keeping. documented.

During a search of a suspect’s vehicle,


Searching a suspect’s home with a warrant to find
Example seizing a bag containing stolen goods as
and seize evidence related to a theft.
evidence.
Aspect Summon Warrant

To compel a person to appear in court or before To authorise law enforcement to search a


Purpose a government agency for a specific reason, specific location or seize specific items,
often in civil cases. primarily in criminal cases.

Consequences of May result in a search or arrest by law


May result in a contempt of court charge.
Non-Compliance enforcement.

Civil cases, hearings, trials, depositions and Criminal cases, evidence collection and
Common Usage
administrative proceedings. property seizure related to crimes.

Recipients Individuals or organisations. Individuals or organisations.

Can be issued without a prior court hearing, Requires a court hearing or probable
Issuance Process with the court or government agency cause showing before issuance and must
determining its validity. be executed by law enforcement.

Issuing Administrative agencies (e.g., tax and Judicial officers (e.g., judges or
Authorities regulatory agencies) and courts. magistrates).

Offence Limitation

Offence punishable with fine only. Six months

Offence punishable with imprisonment for a term not exceeding one year One year

Offence punishable with imprisonment for term exceeding one year but not exceeding three
Three years
years.

Section Type of Trial Description

Sec 225- Trial of Warrant Cases by a Court Deals with the process of trying serious cases requiring the
237 of Session expertise of a higher court.

Sec 238- Trial of Warrant Cases by Outlines the procedure for trying cases that may not be as
250 Magistrates severe but still need legal attention.

Sec 251- Procedure for Trial of Summons Provides guidelines for the trial process when cases are
259 Cases by Magistrates initiated by a summons.

Sec 260- Provisions Relating to Summary Defines the legal framework for conducting swift and
265 Trials straightforward trials for certain offences.
Aspect Discharge Acquittal

Preliminary stage before the trial begins; After the trial has commenced and all
Stage of
based on initial assessment of prosecution’s evidence has been presented and
Proceedings
evidence and documents. evaluated by the court.

Procedural decision to terminate proceedings Formal judgment based on merits of the


Nature of Decision due to lack of prima facie evidence or other case and evidence presented during the
legal reasons. trial.

Thorough examination of all evidence


Insufficient evidence to proceed with the
Basis of Decision during the trial; prosecution has not
trial; determination made without a full trial.
proven guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

Does not exonerate the accused; proceedings Exonerates the accused; once acquitted,
Legal Implications halted due to lack of evidence; accused can cannot be retried for the same offense
be re-arrested if new evidence surfaces. (double jeopardy principle).

Reviews initial evidence to decide if it is


Evaluates all evidence during the trial to
Judge’s Role sufficient to frame charges and proceed with
decide if the accused is guilty or not.
the trial.

Judge must record reasons for discharging Judge records reasons for acquittal,
Recording of
the accused, explaining the insufficiency of detailing why the prosecution’s evidence
Reasons
evidence. failed to prove the case beyond doubt.

Defence may not have a full opportunity to Defence has full opportunity to present
Opportunity for
present their case as the decision is made at a their case, cross-examine witnesses and
Defense
preliminary stage. provide evidence.

Can only happen after charges have been


Timing Can occur before framing charges.
framed and a full trial has taken place.

Occurs at a preliminary stage, halting


Requires a full trial and a verdict based on
Proceedings proceedings due to lack of prima facie
evaluating all evidence presented.
evidence.

Order of
Not included in the judgment. In the nature of a judgment.
Judgment

Releases the accused from a criminal case


Nature of Release Formally declares the accused not guilty.
without a formal declaration of innocence.

Verdict vs. Mandate indicating inadequate evidence for Verdict in a criminal case signifying not
Mandate the case to proceed. guilty.

A discharged individual may face re-arrest


Impact on Future A person who has been acquitted cannot
and further questioning if new evidence is
Prosecution be prosecuted for the same offence again.
found.

Can be ordered by both a court and an


Judicial Authority investigating police officer after completing Ordered only by a court after a full trial.
the investigation.
Basis APPEAL (413- 435) REFERENCE (436-437) REVISION (438-445)

Chapter Chapter 31 BNSS. Chapter 32 BNSS. Chapter 32 BNSS.

Section Section 372- 394 BNSS . Section 436-437 BNSS . Section 438-445 BNSS .

An appeal is made to the higher Reference is made to the Revision is made to both
Meaning court on the points of the fact higher court on the points of higher and lower court on the
and laws. the law. already adjudicated matters.

The Reference occurs while The revision begins under the


The Appeal begins on the
Stage the case is still pending in the final judgment or final order or
determination of the case.
court. final decision of the court.

Reference is to consult the


Revision is to review, change
An appeal or petition is to be High Court on insolvency or
Against or amend any grammatical,
filed against the decision passed invalid law, act, regulation or
what clerical or arithmetic error by a
by the lower court. ordinance related to the case
trial court or high court.
at hand.

In some cases, an appeal can be The revision can be initiated


By Reference is made by the
filed with leave of the court by by the trial court suo moto or
whom trial court to the High Court.
an aggrieved person or accused. the High Court.

Forum Superior Court / Appellate Court High Court High Court & Sessions Court
Factor Inquiry Investigation

An inquiry is a legal process that is The methodical gathering of data and proof
started to clear things up, ascertain the intended to initiate the circumstances
Meaning truth, or learn more about something. surrounding the case is called an investigation.
This is defined in the Code of Criminal This is defined in the Code of Criminal
Procedure's Section 2(g) (CrPC). Procedure's Section 2(h) (CrPC).

The goal is to evaluate the evidence to


The goal is to gather information and proof
Purpose ascertain if the accusations are true or
about a suspected crime.
false.

Important aspects of the investigation include:


Important aspects of the inquiry include:
 It entails methodically gathering data,
 It is an official legal procedure that a facts, and supporting documentation.
judge or court is in charge of.  It seeks to ascertain if a crime was
 It takes place following the committed and who the relevant parties
conclusion of the police's preliminary are.
Key Features inquiry.  Usually, law enforcement authorities, such
 Determining the veracity of the as the police, are responsible for carrying it
accusations is its primary goal. out.
 Witnesses testify during an  It begins with the filing of a complaint over
investigation while under oath. an alleged offense.
 If there's enough proof, official  Obtaining sufficient evidence to determine
charges may be brought about. whether to file charges is the primary
objective.

The authority to conduct an investigation is


The authority to conduct an inquiry is
Authority with a police officer and any other person who
with a magistrate or the court.
has been approved by the magistrate.

When a First Information Report (FIR) or


When the police file a charge sheet
Commencemen complaint about an alleged offense is
against the accused, based on their
t submitted at the police station, an
investigation, an inquiry starts.
investigation is triggered.

Inquiry is the second stage that comes Investigation, on the other hand, happens at
Stage
after the investigation. the first stage of a criminal case.

When charges are brought against an


Ends In accused, an investigation comes to a A police report is filed after an investigation.
close.

An inquiry is a procedure, whether


Nature of An administrative procedure conducted by
judicial or not, that is carried out under
Process executive authority is called an investigation
court supervision.
Basis Trial Inquiry

A Trial is a legal process that does not A formal procedure to get information and
Meaning result in anyone's discharge but can ask questions about a specific occurrence is
lead to either an acquittal or conviction. known as an inquiry.

Commenceme Either the charge is framed or the It begins with the filing of a complaint with
nt accused is arranged beforehand. the magistrate.

If the legal procedure is finished with the


An acquittal or conviction results from Inquiry, there won't be a conviction or
Result
a Trial. acquittal. Discharge or commitment to Trial
are possible outcomes.

The investigation may deal with an offense


or a non-offense. For instance, a public
Subject Matter There is always an offense at Trial.
nuisance inquiry would determine whether to
maintain, possess, or both.

Closure of what is true and what is


Purpose Establishing the truth.
false.

A Trial signifies two concepts. A


controversial trial that arises from a Every type of inquiry other than a Trial is
Interpretation
problem and a complaint or action tried included in the broader definition of Inquiry.
from the beginning to the conclusion.

The third phase of a criminal case is The second phase of a criminal case is an
Stage
Trial. Inquiry.

Relationship Trial follows an Inquiry. Inquiry precedes Trial.

Trial is the investigation and Inquiry covers all investigations carried out
Assessment assessment of a cause by a court panel by a magistrate or a court pursuant to the
that has authority over it. Code of Criminal Procedure, except trials.

Remedy Transfer of the order for investigation. Revision or appeal of the ruling.

It concludes with the penalty


Conclusion It ends with only the suggestions.
or agreement.
Basis Investigation Trial

Gathering evidence regarding an incident of A Trial is a legal process that does not
Meaning crime or allegation in order to ascertain the result in anyone’s discharge but can lead
truth and assign blame to the offender. to either an acquittal or conviction.

Commenceme Either the charge is framed or the


As and when the crime takes place.
nt accused is arranged beforehand.

A charge sheet or final report is the


An acquittal or conviction results from a
Result outcome (section 173 CrPC). This is non
Trial.
judicial proceeding.

There is no requirement for an offence to


Offence There is always an offense at Trial.
start any investigation.

Oath It is not an oath. It is an oath.

Usually, it begins with a police report or a It begins with a police report, a


Starts With
magistrate's order. magistrate's report, or a complaint.

Its goal is to gather information in order to The determination of what is true and
Goal
prosecute. untrue.

Stage Investigation is the first stage of the case. Trial is the third stage of a case.

It concludes with the penalty or


Conclusion It concludes with leads and evidences.
agreement.

You might also like