Statistical Mechanics: Fourth Edition. Instructor's Manual R.K. Pathria
Statistical Mechanics: Fourth Edition. Instructor's Manual R.K. Pathria
com
https://ebookmeta.com/product/statistical-mechanics-fourth-
edition-instructors-manual-r-k-pathria/
OR CLICK BUTTON
DOWNLOAD NOW
https://ebookmeta.com/product/statistical-mechanics-fourth-edition-r-
k-pathria/
ebookmeta.com
https://ebookmeta.com/product/statistical-mechanics-fourth-edition-r-
k-pathria-paul-d-beale/
ebookmeta.com
https://ebookmeta.com/product/maternal-fetal-evidence-based-
guidelines-3rd-ed-3rd-edition-vincenzo-berghella/
ebookmeta.com
Innovation in Real Places: Strategies for Prosperity in an
Unforgiving World 1st Edition Breznitz
https://ebookmeta.com/product/innovation-in-real-places-strategies-
for-prosperity-in-an-unforgiving-world-1st-edition-breznitz/
ebookmeta.com
https://ebookmeta.com/product/dark-chocolate-and-death-pacific-cove-
cozy-mystery-01-samantha-silver-et-el/
ebookmeta.com
https://ebookmeta.com/product/negotiations-of-the-new-world-the-
omnipresence-of-global-as-a-political-phenomenon-sabine-selchow/
ebookmeta.com
https://ebookmeta.com/product/kay-s-anatomy-a-complete-and-completely-
disgusting-guide-to-the-human-body-adam-kay/
ebookmeta.com
https://ebookmeta.com/product/a-primer-in-combinatorics-2nd-edition-
alexander-kheyfits/
ebookmeta.com
Business Forecasting: The Emerging Role of Artificial
Intelligence and Machine Learning 1st Edition Michael
Gilliland
https://ebookmeta.com/product/business-forecasting-the-emerging-role-
of-artificial-intelligence-and-machine-learning-1st-edition-michael-
gilliland/
ebookmeta.com
Instructor’s Manual
Containing Solutions to
Over 300 Problems
Selected From
STATISTICAL MECHANICS
(FOURTH EDITION)
By
R. K. PATHRIA and PAUL. D. BEALE
1
2
Preface
This instructor’s manual for the fourth edition of Statistical Mechanics is based
on RKP’s instructor’s manual for the second edition. Most of the solutions
here were retypeset into TeX from that manual. PDB is responsible for the
solutions of the new problems added in the third and fourth editions. The
result is a manual containing solutions to over 300 problems selected from the
fourth edition.
The original idea of producing an instructor’s manual first came from RKP’s
friend and colleague Wing-Ki Liu in the 1990’s when RKP had just embarked
on the task of preparing the second edition of Statistical Mechanics.
This should provide several benefits to the statistical mechanics instructor.
First of all, there is the obvious advantage of saving time that one would oth-
erwise spend on solving these problems oneself. Secondly, before one selects
problems either for homework or for an exam, one can consult the manual to
determine the level of difficulty of the various problems and make one’s selection
accordingly. Thirdly, one may even use some of these solved problems, especially
the ones appearing in later chapters, as lecture material, thereby supplementing
the text. We hope that this manual will enhance the usefulness of the text –
both for the instructors and (indirectly) for the students.
We implore that instructors not share copies of any of the material in this
manual with students or post any part of this manual on the web. Students
learn best when they work together and struggle over difficult problems. Readily
available solutions interfere with this crucial aspect of graduate physics training.
3
4
Chapter 1
1.1. (a) We expand the quantity ln Ω(0) (E1 ) as a Taylor series in the variable
(E1 − Ē1 ) and get
The first term of this expansion is a constant, the second term van-
ishes as a result of equilibrium (β1 = β2 ), while the third term may
be written as
1 ∂β1 ∂B2 2 1 1 1
+ E1 − Ē1 = − + (E1 −Ē1 )2 ,
2 ∂E1 ∂E2 eq. 2 kT12 (Cv )1 kT22 (Cv )2
1.2. Since S is additive and Ω multiplicative, the function f (Ω) must satisfy
the condition
f (Ω1 Ω2 ) = f (Ω1 ) + f (Ω2 ). (1)
5
6 CHAPTER 1.
so that
Ω1 f 0 (Ω1 ) = Ω2 f 0 (Ω2 ). (2)
Since the left-hand side of (2) is independent of Ω2 and the right-hand side
is independent of Ω1 , each side must be equal to a constant, k, independent
of both Ω1 and Ω2 . It follows that f 0 (Ω) = k/Ω and hence
Substituting (3) into (1), we find that the constant of integration is zero.
1.4. Instead of eqn. (1.4.1), we now have
so that
ln Ω = C + ln V + ln (V − v0 ) + ln (V − 2v0 ) + . . . + ln (V − N − 1v0 ),
N 2 v0
P N N N v0
= + = 1 + , i.e.
kT V 2V 2 V 2V
−1
N v0
PV 1 + = NkT .
2V
Since N v0 << V, (1 + N v0 /2V )−1 ' 1 − N v0 /2V . Our last result then
takes the form: P (V − b) = NkT , where b = 12 N v0 .
A little reflection shows that v0 = (4π/3)σ 3 , with the result that
3
1 4π 3 4π 1
b= N· σ = 4N · σ .
2 3 3 2
The first and second derivatives of this expression with respect to α are
N N
[−N ln α + N ln(1 − α)] and − − (2a,b)
α 1−α
It follows that
5 5
(∆S)P = Nk ln(Tf / Ti ) = (∆S)V .
2 3
A numerical verification of this result is straightforward.
It should be noted that, quite generally,
(∆S)P T (∂S / ∂T )P CP
= = =γ
(∆S)V T (∂S / ∂T )V CV
1.15. For an ideal gas, CP − CV = nR, where n is the number of moles of the
gas. With CP /CV = γ, one gets
Clearly, then,
which is the desired expression. It follows quite readily now that for this
system
∂P 1
= P.
∂µ T kT
which is indeed equal to N/V , whereas
" ( 3/2 )#
h2
∂P 5 µ 5 N Nk
= P− 2 P = 2 − ln
∂T µ 2T kT V 2πmkT V
2.3. The rotator in this problem may be regarded as confined to the (z = 0)-
plane and its position at time t may be denoted by the azimuthal angle
ϕ. The conjugate variable pϕ is then mρ2 ϕ̇, where the various symbols
have their usual meanings. The energy of rotation is given by
1
E= m(ρϕ̇)2 = p2ϕ / 2mρ2 .
2
Lines of constant energy in the (ϕ, pϕ )-plane are “straight lines, running
parallel to the ϕ-axis from ϕ = 0 to ϕ = 2π”. The basic cell of area h in
this plane is a “rectangle with sides ∆ϕ = 2π and ∆pϕ = h/2π”. Clearly,
the eigenvalues of pϕ , starting with pϕ = 0, are n~ and those of E are
n2 ~2 /2I, where I = mρ2 and n = 0, ±1, ±2, . . .
The eigenvalues of E obtained here are precisely the ones given by quan-
tum mechanics for the energy “associated with the z-component of the
rotational motion”.
2.4. The rigid rotator is a model for a diatomic molecule whose internuclear
distance r may be regarded as fixed. The orientation of the molecule in
space may be denoted by the angles θ and ϕ, the conjugate variables being
pθ = mr 2 θ̇ and pϕ = mr 2 sin2 θϕ̇. The energy of rotation is given by
1 1 p2θ p2ϕ M2
E= m(rθ̇)2 + m(r sin θϕ̇)2 = + = ,
2 2 2mr 2 2mr 2 sin2 θ 2I
where I = mr 2 and M 2 = p2θ + p2ϕ / sin2 θ .
The “volume”
R0 of the relevant region of the phase space is given by the
integral dp θ dp ϕ dθ dϕ, where the region of integration is constrained
by the value of M . A little reflection shows that in the subspace of pθ
and pϕ we are restricted by an elliptical boundary with semi-axes M and
M sin θ, the enclosed area being πM 2 sin θ. The “volume” of the relevant
region, therefore, is
Zπ Z2π
(πM 2 sin θ)dθ dϕ = 4π 2 M 2 .
θ=0 ϕ=0
1
2
1 h 2 i 1
3
1
1
2
Mj+ 1 − Mj− 1 = j + j+ − j− j+ = 2j + 1.
~2 2 2 2 2 2 2
This is precisely the degeneracy arising from the eigenvalues that the az-
imuthal quantum number m has, viz. j, j − 1, . . . , −j + 1, −j.
2.6. In terms of the variables θ and L(= m`2 θ), the state of the simple pendu-
lum is given by, see eqns. (2.4.9),
1
Ω(E) = (R + N − 1)!/ R!(N − 1)!, R = E − N ~ω /~ω. (1)
2
For R >> N , we obtain the asymptotic result
(E / ~ω)N −1 ∆ E N −1 ∆
Γ(E; ∆) ≈ · = . (1)
(N − 1)! ~ω (N − 1)!(~ω)N
The “volume” of the relevant region of the phase space may be derived
from the integral
N
Z 0Y N
X 1 1 2
(dq i dp i ), with kq 2i + p ≤ E.
i=1 i=1
2 2m i
so that
Σ(n, V, E) = V N (8π E 3 / h3 c3 )N / (3N )!,
which is a function of N and VE 3 . An isentropic process then implies
that VE 3 = const.
The temperature of the system is given by
1 ∂(k ln Σ) 3Nk
= = , i.e. E = 3NkT .
T ∂E N,V E
The equation for the isentropic process then becomes VT 3 = const., i.e.
T ∝ V −1/3 ; this implies that γ = 4/3. The rest of the thermodynamics
follows straightforwardly. See also Problems 1.7 and 3.15.
Chapter 3
3.4. For the first part, we use eqn. (3.2.31) with all ωr = 1. We get
( )
k X
−βEr
ln Γ = k ln e + kβU,
N r
A(N, V, T ) = Nf (v, T ) (v = V / N ).
It follows that
∂A ∂f −V ∂A ∂f 1
N =N f +N · 2 , and V = VN · .
∂N V,T ∂v T N ∂V N,T ∂v T N
1
2
P P
1, Es Pr,s = E and Nr Pr,s = N . Varying P ’s and using the method
r,s r,s
of Lagrange’s undetermined multipliers, we are led to the condition
X
{−(1 + ln Pr,s ) − γ − βEs − αNr } δPr,s = 0.
r,s
Pr ∝ exp(−βEr ),
2
∂P ∂V ∂P ∂P
CP − CV = T = −T > 0. (1)
∂T V ∂T P ∂T V ∂V T
Now
e−U/kT (U/kT 2 )d3N q
R
∂ ln Z kT Ū
kT = R
−U/kT d3N q
= , while
∂T N,V e T
n o Ū
k ln Z = k ln V̄ N e−Ū /kT = Nk ln V̄ − .
T
Substituting these results into the above expression for S, we obtain the
desired result for S. In passing, we note that hHi ≡ A + TS = 23 NkT + Ū .
P
For the second part of the question, we write U (q) = u(rij ), so that
i<j
Y Y
e−βU (q) = e−βu(rij ) = (1 + fij ) ,
i<j i<j
and follow Problems 3.23 and 1.4. The quantity V̄ then appears to be in
the nature of a “free volume” for the molecules of the system.
3.14. a) The Lagrangian is given by
X1 X X
L =K −V = 2
mṙiα − u(rij ) − [uw (riα ) + uw (L − riα )],
iα
2 i<j iα