[Ebooks PDF] download Electrochemical Methods: Fundamentals and Applications, 2nd Edition – Ebook PDF Version full chapters
[Ebooks PDF] download Electrochemical Methods: Fundamentals and Applications, 2nd Edition – Ebook PDF Version full chapters
[Ebooks PDF] download Electrochemical Methods: Fundamentals and Applications, 2nd Edition – Ebook PDF Version full chapters
https://ebookmass.com
https://ebookmass.com/product/electrochemical-
methods-fundamentals-and-applications-2nd-edition-
ebook-pdf-version/
https://ebookmass.com/product/molecular-diagnostics-fundamentals-
methods-and-clinical-applications-2nd-edition-ebook-pdf/
testbankdeal.com
https://ebookmass.com/product/quantitative-methods-and-socio-economic-
applications-in-gis-2nd-edition-ebook-pdf-version/
testbankdeal.com
https://ebookmass.com/product/fluid-mechanics-fundamentals-and-
applications-ebook-pdf-version/
testbankdeal.com
https://ebookmass.com/product/research-methods-statistics-and-
applications-second-edition-ebook-pdf-version/
testbankdeal.com
Fundamentals of Building Construction: Materials and
Methods 6th Edition – Ebook PDF Version
https://ebookmass.com/product/fundamentals-of-building-construction-
materials-and-methods-6th-edition-ebook-pdf-version/
testbankdeal.com
https://ebookmass.com/product/stage-lighting-second-edition-ebook-pdf-
version-the-fundamentals-2nd-edition-ebook-pdf-version/
testbankdeal.com
https://ebookmass.com/product/heat-and-mass-transfer-fundamentals-and-
applications-5th-edition-ebook-pdf-version/
testbankdeal.com
https://ebookmass.com/product/electrochemical-power-sources-
fundamentals-systems-and-applications-tom-smolinka/
testbankdeal.com
https://ebookmass.com/product/fracture-mechanics-fundamentals-and-
applications-fourth-edition-4th-edition-ebook-pdf-version/
testbankdeal.com
SECOND EDITION
ELECTROCHEMICAL
METHODS
Fundamentals and
Applications
Allen J. Bard
Larry R. Faulkner
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry
University of Texas at Austin
Section
Symbol Meaning Usual Units References
Section
Symbol Meaning Usual Units References
Section
Symbol Meaning Usual Units References
of species /
k° true standard heterogeneous rate cm/s 13.7.1
constant
xiv Major Symbols
Section
Symbol Meaning Usual Units References
Section
Symbol Meaning Usual Units References
R (a) gas constant Jmol^K"
1
Section
Symbol Meaning Usual Units References
2
*>mt rate of mass transfer to a surface mol cm s ' 1.4.1
1
Wj(A,E) probability density function for species j eV" 3.6.3
w width of a band electrode cm 5.3
Wj work term for reactant j in electron eV 3.6.2
transfer
*c capacitive reactance n 10.1.2
x mole fraction of species j none 13.1.2
>
X distance, often from a planar electrode cm
X\ distance of the IHP from the electrode cm 1.2.3, 13.3.3
surface
x2 distance of the OHP from the electrode cm 1.2.3, 13.3.3
surface
Y admittance rr1 1
10.1.2
Y admittance vector ft" 10.1.2
У distance from an RDE or RRDE cm 9.3.1
z (a) impedance n 10.1.2
(b) dimensionless current parameter in none B.1.6
simulation
z impedance vector ft 10.1.2
faradaic impedance ft 10.1.3
Z\m imaginary part of impedance a 10.1.2
^Re real part of impedance ft 10.1.2
7 Warburg impedance ft 10.1.3
z (a) distance normal to the surface of a cm 5.3
disk electrode or along a cylindrical
electrode
(b) charge magnitude of each ion in a none 13.3.2
z: z electrolyte
Z
j
charge on species j in signed units of none 2.3
electronic charge
GREEK SYMBOLS
Section
Symbol Meaning Usual Units References
Section
Symbol Meaning Usual Units References
2
surface excess of species j at saturation mol/cm 13.5.2
(a) surface tension dyne/cm
(b) dimensionless parameter used to define none 5.4.2, 5.5.2
frequency (time) regimes in step
experiments at spherical electrodes
П activity coefficient for species у none 2.1.5
Д ellipsometric parameter none 17.1.2
l/2
8 r0(s/Do) , used to define diffusional none 5.5.2
regimes at a spherical electrode
"diffusion" layer thickness for species у at 1.4.2,9.3.2
an electrode fed by convective transfer
(a) dielectric constant none 13.3.1
(b) optical-frequency dielectric constant none 17.1.2
(c) porosity none 11.6.2
complex optical-frequency dielectric none 17.1.2
constant
molar absorptivity of species у M" 1 cm " 1 17.1.1
]
permittivity of free space m"2 13.3.1
zeta potential mV 9.8.1
overpotential, E — Eeq V 1.3.2,3.4.2
charge-transfer overpotential V 1.3.3, 3.4.6
1
viscosity of fluid у gem' " V = poise 9.2.2
mass-transfer overpotential V 1.3.3, 3.4.6
none 5.4.1
s 1/2 5.8.2
fractional coverage of an interface by none 13.5.2
species у
(a) conductivity of a solution = fl" 1 -i
Section
Symbol Meaning Usual Units References
Section
Symbol Meaning Usual Units References
standard Galvani potential of ion transfer V 6.8
for species j from phase a to phase /3
Фо total potential drop across the solution side mV 13.3.2
of the double layer
ф2 potential at the OHP with respect to bulk V 1.2.3, 13.3.3
solution
X (12/7)1/2£fT1/2/Do/2 none 7.2.2
XU) dimensionless distance of box; in a none B.1.5
simulation
x
(bt) normalized current for a totally irreversible none 6.3.1
system in LSV and CV
x
(at) normalized current for a reversible system in none 6.2.1
LSV and CV
Xf rate constant for permeation of the primary cm/s 14.4.2
reactant into the film at a modified
electrode
Ф (a) ellipsometric parameter none 17.1.2
(b) dimensionless rate parameter in CV none 6.5.2
(a) angular frequency of rotation; s" 1 9.3
2тг X rotation rate
(b) angular frequency of a sinusoidal s" 1 10.1.2
oscillation; 2rrf
STANDARD ABBREVIATIONS
Section
Abbreviation Meaning Reference
Section
Abbreviation Meaning Reference
1
Letters may be subscripted /, q, or r to indicate irreversible, quasi-reversible, or reversible reactions.
Major Symbols xxi
Section
Abbreviation Meaning Reference
QRE quasi-reference electrode 2.1.7
RDE rotating disk electrode 9.3
RDS rate-determining step 3.5
RPP reverse pulse polarography 7.3.4
RPV reverse pulse voltammetry 7.3.4
RRDE rotating ring-disk electrode 9.4.2
SAM self-assembled monolayer 14.2.2
SCE saturated calomel electrode 1.1.1
SECM scanning electrochemical microscopy 16.4
SERS surface enhanced Raman spectroscopy 17.2.2
SHE standard hydrogen electrode = NHE 1.1.1
SHG second harmonic generation 17.1.5
SMDE static mercury drop electrode 7.1.1
SNIFTIRS subtractively normalized interfacial Fourier transform infrared 17.2.1
spectroscopy
SPE solid polymer electrolyte 14.2.6
SPR surface plasmon resonance 17.1.3
SSCE sodium saturated calomel electrode, Hg/Hg2Cl2/NaCl (sat'd)
STM scanning tunneling microscopy 16.2
swv square wave voltammetry 7.3.5
TBABF4 tetra-/2-butylammonium fluoborate
TBAI tetra-ft-butylammonium iodide
TBAP tetra-w-butylammoniumperchlorate
TEAP tetraethylammonium perchlorate
THF tetrahydrofuran
UHV ultrahigh vacuum 17.3
UME ultramicroelectrode 5.3
UPD underpotential deposition 11.2.1
XPS X-ray photoelectron spectrometry 17.3.2
VB valence band 18.2.2
CHAPTER
1
INTRODUCTION
AND OVERVIEW
OF ELECTRODE
PROCESSES
1.1 INTRODUCTION
Electrochemistry is the branch of chemistry concerned with the interrelation of electri-
cal and chemical effects. A large part of this field deals with the study of chemical
changes caused by the passage of an electric current and the production of electrical en-
ergy by chemical reactions. In fact, the field of electrochemistry encompasses a huge
array of different phenomena (e.g., electrophoresis and corrosion), devices (elec-
trochromic displays, electro analytical sensors, batteries, and fuel cells), and technolo-
gies (the electroplating of metals and the large-scale production of aluminum and
chlorine). While the basic principles of electrochemistry discussed in this text apply to
all of these, the main emphasis here is on the application of electrochemical methods to
the study of chemical systems.
Scientists make electrochemical measurements on chemical systems for a variety of
reasons. They may be interested in obtaining thermodynamic data about a reaction. They
may want to generate an unstable intermediate such as a radical ion and study its rate of
decay or its spectroscopic properties. They may seek to analyze a solution for trace
amounts of metal ions or organic species. In these examples, electrochemical methods are
employed as tools in the study of chemical systems in just the way that spectroscopic
methods are frequently applied. There are also investigations in which the electrochemi-
cal properties of the systems themselves are of primary interest, for example, in the design
of a new power source or for the electrosynthesis of some product. Many electrochemical
methods have been devised. Their application requires an understanding of the fundamen-
tal principles of electrode reactions and the electrical properties of electrode-solution in-
terfaces.
In this chapter, the terms and concepts employed in describing electrode reactions
are introduced. In addition, before embarking on a detailed consideration of methods
for studying electrode processes and the rigorous solutions of the mathematical equa-
tions that govern them, we will consider approximate treatments of several different
types of electrode reactions to illustrate their main features. The concepts and treat-
ments described here will be considered in a more complete and rigorous way in later
chapters.
2 • Chapter 1. Introduction and Overview of Electrode Processes
In this notation, a slash represents a phase boundary, and a comma separates two compo-
nents in the same phase. A double slash, not yet used here, represents a phase boundary
whose potential is regarded as a negligible component of the overall cell potential. When
a gaseous phase is involved, it is written adjacent to its corresponding conducting ele-
ment. For example, the cell in Figure 1.1.1ft is written schematically as
The overall chemical reaction taking place in a cell is made up of two independent
half-reactions, which describe the real chemical changes at the two electrodes. Each half-
reaction (and, consequently, the chemical composition of the system near the electrodes)
1.1 Introduction 3
Pt H2
Zn Ag
СГ СГ
j
Excess Excess
AgCI AgCI
(а) (Ь)
Figure l.l.l Typical electrochemical cells, (a) Zn metal and Ag wire covered with AgCI immersed
in a ZnCl2 solution, (b) Pt wire in a stream of H2 and Ag wire covered with AgCI in HC1 solution.
responds to the interfacial potential difference at the corresponding electrode. Most of the
time, one is interested in only one of these reactions, and the electrode at which it occurs
is called the working (or indicator) electrode. To focus on it, one standardizes the other
half of the cell by using an electrode (called a reference electrode) made up of phases
having essentially constant composition.
The internationally accepted primary reference is the standard hydrogen electrode
(SHE), or normal hydrogen electrode (NHE), which has all components at unit activity:
Pt/H2(a - l)/H + (a = 1, aqueous) (1.1.3)
Potentials are often measured and quoted with respect to reference electrodes other than
the NHE, which is not very convenient from an experimental standpoint. A common ref-
erence is the saturated calomel electrode (SCE), which is
Hg/Hg2Cl2/KCl (saturated in water) (1.1.4)
Its potential is 0.242 V vs. NHE. Another is the silver-silver chloride electrode,
Ag/AgCl/KCl (saturated in water) (1.1.5)
with a potential of 0.197 V vs. NHE. It is common to see potentials identified in the litera-
ture as "vs. Ag/AgQ" when this electrode is used.
Since the reference electrode has a constant makeup, its potential is fixed. Therefore,
any changes in the cell are ascribable to the working electrode. We say that we observe or
control the potential of the working electrode with respect to the reference, and that is
equivalent to observing or controlling the energy of the electrons within the working elec-
trode (1, 2). By driving the electrode to more negative potentials (e.g., by connecting a
battery or power supply to the cell with its negative side attached to the working elec-
trode), the energy of the electrons is raised. They can reach a level high enough to transfer
into vacant electronic states on species in the electrolyte. In that case, a flow of electrons
from electrode to solution (a reduction current) occurs (Figure 1.1.2a). Similarly, the en-
ergy of the electrons can be lowered by imposing a more positive potential, and at some
point electrons on solutes in the electrolyte will find a more favorable energy on the elec-
trode and will transfer there. Their flow, from solution to electrode, is an oxidation cur-
rent (Figure 1.1.2b). The critical potentials at which these processes occur are related to
the standard potentials, E°, for the specific chemical substances in the system.
4 Chapter 1. Introduction and Overview of Electrode Processes
Vacant
0 MO
Potential
Energy level
of electrons
0j Occupied
MO
A + e —> A
(a)
Vacant
0 Energy level
MO
of electrons
Potential
0l Occupied
MO
A - e -^ A+
(b)
Figure 1.1.2 Representation of (a) reduction and (b) oxidation process of a species, A, in
solution. The molecular orbitals (MO) of species A shown are the highest occupied MO and the
lowest vacant MO. These correspond in an approximate way to the E°s of the A/A~ and A + /A
couples, respectively. The illustrated system could represent an aromatic hydrocarbon (e.g.,
9,10-diphenylanthracene) in an aprotic solvent (e.g., acetonitrile) at a platinum electrode.
Power
supply
-Ag
Pt
-AgBr
Figure 1.1.3 Schematic diagram of the
electrochemical cell Pt/HBr(l M)/AgBr/Ag attached
to power supply and meters for obtaining a current-
1МНВГ
potential (i-E) curve.
Let us now consider the particular cell in Figure 1.1.3 and discuss in a qualitative
way the current-potential curve that might be obtained with it. In Section 1.4 and in later
chapters, we will be more quantitative. We first might consider simply the potential we
would measure when a high impedance voltmeter (i.e., a voltmeter whose internal resis-
tance is so high that no appreciable current flows through it during a measurement) is
placed across the cell. This is called the open-circuit potential of the cell.1
For some electrochemical cells, like those in Figure 1.1.1, it is possible to calculate
the open-circuit potential from thermodynamic data, that is, from the standard potentials
of the half-reactions involved at both electrodes via the Nernst equation (see Chapter 2).
The key point is that a true equilibrium is established, because a pair of redox forms
linked by a given half-reaction (i.e., a redox couple) is present at each electrode. In Figure
1.1.1/?, for example, we have H + and H 2 at one electrode and Ag and AgCl at the other.2
The cell in Figure 1.1.3 is different, because an overall equilibrium cannot be estab-
lished. At the Ag/AgBr electrode, a couple is present and the half-reaction is
AgBr + e ±± Ag + Br = 0.0713 Vvs. NHE (1.1.6)
Since AgBr and Ag are both solids, their activities are unity. The activity of Br can be
found from the concentration in solution; hence the potential of this electrode (with re-
spect to NHE) could be calculated from the Nernst equation. This electrode is at equilib-
rium. However, we cannot calculate a thermodynamic potential for the Pt/H+,Br~
electrode, because we cannot identify a pair of chemical species coupled by a given half-
reaction. The controlling pair clearly is not the H2,H+ couple, since no H 2 has been intro-
duced into the cell. Similarly, it is not the O 2 ,H 2 O couple, because by leaving O 2 out of
the cell formulation we imply that the solutions in the cell have been deaerated. Thus, the
Pt electrode and the cell as a whole are not at equilibrium, and an equilibrium potential
*In the electrochemical literature, the open-circuit potential is also called the zero-current potential or the rest
potential.
2
When a redox couple is present at each electrode and there are no contributions from liquid junctions (yet to be
discussed), the open-circuit potential is also the equilibrium potential. This is the situation for each cell in
Figure 1.1.1.
Chapter 1. Introduction and Overview of Electrode Processes
does not exist. Even though the open-circuit potential of the cell is not available from
thermodynamic data, we can place it within a potential range, as shown below.
Let us now consider what occurs when a power supply (e.g., a battery) and a mi-
croammeter are connected across the cell, and the potential of the Pt electrode is made
more negative with respect to the Ag/AgBr reference electrode. The first electrode reac-
tion that occurs at the Pt is the reduction of protons,
+
2H + 2 e - * H 2 (1.1.7)
The direction of electron flow is from the electrode to protons in solution, as in Figure
1.12a, so a reduction (cathodic) current flows. In the convention used in this book, ca-
3
thodic currents are taken as positive, and negative potentials are plotted to the right. As
shown in Figure 1.1.4, the onset of current flow occurs when the potential of the Pt elec-
+
trode is near E° for the H /H 2 reaction (0 V vs. NHE or -0.07 V vs. the Ag/AgBr elec-
trode). While this is occurring, the reaction at the Ag/AgBr (which we consider the
reference electrode) is the oxidation of Ag in the presence of Br~ in solution to form
AgBr. The concentration of Br~ in the solution near the electrode surface is not changed
appreciably with respect to the original concentration (1 M), therefore the potential of the
Ag/AgBr electrode will be almost the same as at open circuit. The conservation of charge
requires that the rate of oxidation at the Ag electrode be equal to the rate of reduction at
the Pt electrode.
When the potential of the Pt electrode is made sufficiently positive with respect to the
reference electrode, electrons cross from the solution phase into the electrode, and the ox-
1 : /
Onset of H +
reduction on Pt.
1 I i
\
\y
1
1.5 0 -0.5
L
/ \
1 \
/ Onset of Br"
/ oxidation on Pt
Figure 1.1.4 Schematic current-potential curve for the cell Pt/H + , Br~(l M)/AgBr/Ag, showing
the limiting proton reduction and bromide oxidation processes. The cell potential is given for the Pt
electrode with respect to the Ag electrode, so it is equivalent to £ P t (V vs. AgBr). Since ^Ag/AgBr =
0.07 V vs. NHE, the potential axis could be converted to EPt (V vs. NHE) by adding 0.07 V to each
value of potential.
3
The convention of taking / positive for a cathodic current stems from the early polarograhic studies, where
reduction reactions were usually studied. This convention has continued among many analytical chemists and
electrochemists, even though oxidation reactions are now studied with equal frequency. Other
electrochemists prefer to take an anodic current as positive. When looking over a derivation in the literature
or examining a published i-E curve, it is important to decide, first, which convention is being used (i.e.,
"Which way is up?").
Visit https://ebookmass.com
now to explore a rich
collection of eBooks and enjoy
exciting offers!
1.1 Introduction 7
idation of Br~ to Br2 (and Br^~) occurs. An oxidation current, or anodic current, flows at
potentials near the E° of the half-reaction,
Br2 + 2 e ^ 2 B r ~ (1.1.8)
which is +1.09 V vs. NHE or +1.02 V vs. Ag/AgBr. While this reaction occurs (right-
to-left) at the Pt electrode, AgBr in the reference electrode is reduced to Ag and Br~ is
liberated into solution. Again, because the composition of the Ag/AgBr/Br~ interface
(i.e., the activities of AgBr, Ag, and Br~) is almost unchanged with the passage of modest
currents, the potential of the reference electrode is essentially constant. Indeed, the essen-
tial characteristic of a reference electrode is that its potential remains practically constant
with the passage of small currents. When a potential is applied between Pt and Ag/AgBr,
nearly all of the potential change occurs at the Pt/solution interface.
The background limits are the potentials where the cathodic and anodic currents start
to flow at a working electrode when it is immersed in a solution containing only an elec-
trolyte added to decrease the solution resistance (a supporting electrolyte). Moving the
potential to more extreme values than the background limits (i.e., more negative than the
limit for H2 evolution or more positive than that for Br2 generation in the example above)
simply causes the current to increase sharply with no additional electrode reactions, be-
cause the reactants are present at high concentrations. This discussion implies that one can
often estimate the background limits of a given electrode-solution interface by consider-
ing the thermodynamics of the system (i.e., the standard potentials of the appropriate half-
reactions). This is frequently, but not always, true, as we shall see in the next example.
From Figure 1.1.4, one can see that the open-circuit potential is not well defined in
the system under discussion. One can say only that the open-circuit potential lies some-
where between the background limits. The value found experimentally will depend
upon trace impurities in the solution (e.g., oxygen) and the previous history of the Pt
electrode.
Let us now consider the same cell, but with the Pt replaced with a mercury electrode:
Hg/H + ,Br-(l M)/AgBr/Ag (1.1.9)
We still cannot calculate an open-circuit potential for the cell, because we cannot define a
redox couple for the Hg electrode. In examining the behavior of this cell with an applied
external potential, we find that the electrode reactions and the observed current-potential
behavior are very different from the earlier case. When the potential of the Hg is made
negative, there is essentially no current flow in the region where thermodynamics predict
that H2 evolution should occur. Indeed, the potential must be brought to considerably
more negative values, as shown in Figure 1.1.5, before this reaction takes place. The ther-
modynamics have not changed, since the equilibrium potential of half-reaction 1.1.7 is in-
dependent of the metal electrode (see Section 2.2.4). However, when mercury serves as
the locale for the hydrogen evolution reaction, the rate (characterized by a heterogeneous
rate constant) is much lower than at Pt. Under these circumstances, the reaction does not
occur at values one would predict from thermodynamics. Instead considerably higher
electron energies (more negative potentials) must be applied to make the reaction occur at
a measurable rate. The rate constant for a heterogeneous electron-transfer reaction is a
function of applied potential, unlike one for a homogeneous reaction, which is a constant
at a given temperature. The additional potential (beyond the thermodynamic requirement)
needed to drive a reaction at a certain rate is called the overpotential. Thus, it is said that
mercury shows "a high overpotential for the hydrogen evolution reaction."
When the mercury is brought to more positive values, the anodic reaction and the po-
tential for current flow also differ from those observed when Pt is used as the electrode.
8 • Chapter 1. Introduction and Overview of Electrode Processes
Onset of H +
reduction ,
Anodic
Figure 1.1.5 Schematic current-potential curve for the Hg electrode in the cell Hg/H + , Br (1
M)/AgBr/Ag, showing the limiting processes: proton reduction with a large negative overpotential
and mercury oxidation. The potential axis is defined through the process outlined in the caption to
Figure 1.1.4.
With Hg, the anodic background limit occurs when Hg is oxidized to Hg2Br2 at a poten-
tial near 0.14 V vs. NHE (0.07 V vs. Ag/AgBr), characteristic of the half-reaction
Hg 2 Br 2 + 2e«±2Hg 2Br" (1.1.10)
In general, the background limits depend upon both the electrode material and the solu-
tion employed in the electrochemical cell.
Finally let us consider the same cell with the addition of a small amount of Cd 2 + to
the solution,
Hg/H + ,Br"(l M), Cd 2+ (10" 3 M)/AgBr/Ag (1.1.11)
The qualitative current-potential curve for this cell is shown in Figure 1.1.6. Note the
appearance of the reduction wave at about -0.4 V vs. NHE arising from the reduction
reaction
CdBr|~ + 2e S Cd(Hg) + 4Br~ (1.1.12)
where Cd(Hg) denotes cadmium amalgam. The shape and size of such waves will be cov-
ered in Section 1.4.2. If Cd 2 + were added to the cell in Figure 1.1.3 and a current-poten-
tial curve taken, it would resemble that in Figure 1.1.4, found in the absence of Cd 2 + . At a
Pt electrode, proton reduction occurs at less positive potentials than are required for the
reduction of Cd(II), so the cathodic background limit occurs in 1 M HBr before the cad-
mium reduction wave can be seen.
In general, when the potential of an electrode is moved from its open-circuit value to-
ward more negative potentials, the substance that will be reduced first (assuming all possi-
ble electrode reactions are rapid) is the oxidant in the couple with the least negative (or
most positive) E®. For example, for a platinum electrode immersed in an aqueous solution
containing 0.01 M each of F e 3 + , Sn 4 + , and N i 2 + in 1 M HC1, the first substance reduced
will be F e 3 + , since the E° of this couple is most positive (Figure 1.1.7a). When the poten-
Random documents with unrelated
content Scribd suggests to you:
his chat with the reader than he did in the story. In Beppo he
constantly wanders from the tale to pursue varied lines of thought,
192
returning to the plot more from a sense of duty than from desire.
In these talks with his audience, full of satiric references to English
manners and morals, and tinctured with mocking observations on his
contemporaries, Byron follows Casti rather than Frere.
These resemblances in outward form seem to indicate along
what lines Byron was affected by Frere’s poem. The differences in
spirit and motive between the two men are indeed striking. The
Monks, and the Giants belongs unmistakably to the burlesque
division of satire: it is, said Frere, “the burlesque of ordinary rude
uninstructed common sense—the treatment of lofty and serious
subjects by a thoroughly common, but not necessarily low-minded
193
man—a Suffolk harness maker.” The poem is, for the most part,
satiric only in an indirect and impersonal way, and there is in it very
little straightforward destructive criticism, like that in English Bards.
Nor is there any underlying bitterness or indignation; it would be
futile to seek, in these verses so marked by mildness, geniality, and
urbanity, for any purpose beyond that of amusing, in a quiet way, a
cultivated circle of friends. Even in the gossipy introduction there are
few allusions to current events, and if, as has been claimed, the
knights of the Round Table are intended to represent prominent
living personages, no one uninitiated could have discovered the
secret. Frere himself said of it: “Most people who read it at the time
it was published would not take the work in a merely humorous
sense; they would imagine it was some political satire, and went on
hunting for a political meaning.” When we recall that Byron spoke of
194
Beppo as “being full of political allusions,” we comprehend the
gap which separates the two works.
The real divergence between the poems—and it is a wide one—
is due, as Eichler intimates, to the characters of the authors.
Whistlecraft’s words:—
“I’m strongly for the present state of things:
195
I look for no reform or innovation,”
A similar mood led them both to lay an emphasis on the seamy and
gruesome side of war, and to condemn it as unnecessary and
degrading. Casti, after picturing all the horrors of a battle-field,
exclaims,
This is in the same tone as Byron’s remark about the futility of war:
There is space for quoting only one of several similar endings from
Don Juan:
These asides recall the personal paragraphs and short essays which
Fielding, and after him, Thackeray, were accustomed to insert in
their novels. Their importance in Don Juan cannot be overestimated,
for, as it will be necessary to emphasize later, the satiric element in
that poem is brought out chiefly through these digressions, in which
the author gives free vent to his personality. Some traces of this
method had appeared even in the first two cantos of Childe
219
Harold ; and, to some degree, it had been utilized in several of
Byron’s short verse epistles to friends. However the discursive style
is not common in the poet’s work before Beppo, and after that, at
least in his satires, it comes to be conspicuous. Even Frere, familiar
as he was with the Italians, did not realize the full value of the
digression until he wrote the last two cantos of The Monks and the
Giants, and, moreover, he never used it as an instrument for satire.
It is, therefore, reasonable to suppose that Byron found a pattern for
his procedure in the burlesque writers themselves and particularly in
Casti. There are, however, some variations in Byron’s employment of
this device. He extended the colloquial aside until it verged almost
into a prolonged monologue or satirical sermon; and whereas Casti,
in Gli Animali Parianti, seldom made use of the digression as an
opportunity for personal satire, Byron improved the chance to speak
out directly, in the first person, against his enemies. Casti advanced
his destructive criticism largely through his narrative, by allusion,
insinuation, and irony, in a manner quite indirect, keeping himself, as
far as open satire was concerned, very much in the background. In
Don Juan, on the contrary, as the poem lengthened into the later
cantos, Byron tended more and more to neglect the plot and to
reveal himself as a commentator on life.
In many respects, Casti’s third poem, Il Poema Tartaro, which
has never been mentioned in connection with Byron and which was
never referred to by the English poet, is even more closely akin than
Gli Animali Parlanti to Don Juan. It is possible that it may have
offered a suggestion for a portion of the plot of Don Juan—the
episode of Catharine II. It shows Casti speaking, for once, directly
against great personages, bestowing upon them fictitious titles, but
not at any pains to conceal the significance of his allusions. As Il
Poema Tartaro is little known, it is essential to dwell somewhat upon
its plot and general character.
The poem, which is made up of twelve cantos in ottava rima,
treats mainly of the Russia of the Empress Catharine II. Most of the
important actors are historical figures, disguised under pseudonyms:
thus Catharine is called Cattuna or Turrachina; Potemkin, her famous
minister, is Toto; and Joseph II, who receives his share of adulation,
is Orenzebbe. No one of these characters is drawn with any effort at
secrecy; indeed, in most editions, a complete key is provided.
In its chief features the narrative element of Il Poema Tartaro is
not unlike that of some sections of Don Juan. The hero, a wandering
Irishman, Tomasso Scardassale, like Juan a child of pleasure and
fortune unembarrassed by moral convictions, joins a pilgrimage to
the Holy Land. Eventually he is captured by the infidels, falls into the
hands of the Caliph of Bagdad, and while a prisoner at his court,
engages in a liaison with Zelmira, a member of the harem. An
appointment to the office of Chief Eunuch having been forced upon
him, he flees with his inamorata and, after some escapades, arrives
at St. Petersburg, where he has the good luck to please the
Empress. Soon, without any manifest reluctance on his part, he
occupies the position of official favorite, is loaded with money and
honors, and becomes, for a time, the second highest personage in
the realm. After various incidents, including a rebellion against the
empress suppressed only with difficulty, and visits of many
contemporary monarchs to the capital, Potemkin, Catharine’s former
lover, jealous of Tomasso’s rise to power, succeeds in bringing about
his downfall, and the discarded Irishman, suffering the usual penalty
of the Empress’s caprices, is exiled to a far corner of Russia. At this
point, Casti’s poem, becoming prophetic, diverges entirely from
history. There is an uprising led by the Grand Duke; Catharine and
Potemkin are seized and banished; and the Grand Duke is declared
emperor. Somewhat dramatically the poet describes the meeting
between the dethroned Catharine and Tomasso. Finally the latter,
recalled to St. Petersburg, dies in the arms of his earlier love,
Zelmira, and is buried with elaborate ceremony.
The Catharine II episode in Don Juan begins with Canto IX, 42,
and ends with Canto X, 48. That, there is a superficial resemblance
between the adventures of the two heroes, Tomasso and Juan, is
sufficiently obvious. Both are modern picaresque knights at the sport
of circumstances. Each comes to St. Petersburg from Turkey,
bringing with him a Turkish girl; each is installed as a favorite at the
court and attains, at one bound, nobility and riches; each falls from
his lofty state, and is sent away. It is evident, of course, that Byron
in no sense borrowed from Casti’s plot as he did from other writers
in his description of the shipwreck. However, since Casti’s poem is
probably the only one of the period dealing with the court of
Catharine II, and since Byron was well acquainted with the other
two long works of the Italian, there are grounds for surmising that
he took Il Poema Tartaro, in its general scheme, as a model for a
part of Don Juan.
This supposition is strengthened by some resemblances in
details between the two poems. Catharine II is portrayed by both
authors in much the same way. Casti says of her that,
The scene in which Tomasso has just been especially favored by the
Empress and is receiving congratulations from courtiers is paralleled
by that in which Juan is being flattered after a warm greeting by
225
Catharine. Another curious coincidence occurs in the efforts of
the court physician to cure the apparent debility of Tomasso and
226
Juan. These similarities are striking enough to furnish some
probability that Byron was familiar with the plot of Il Poema Tartaro,
and, consciously or unconsciously, reproduced some of its features in
Don Juan.
Casti’s satire in this poem, as in Gli Animali Parlanti, is
227
comprehensive. Like Byron, he ridicules the Russian language,
228
attacks literary fads, criticises customs-duties, and enters into a
vigorous denunciation of war. In speaking of soldiers who clash in
civil strife, he says, with bitter truth:
The exiled Empress, coming upon her old favorite, Tomasso, cries,
“Ah, non m’inganno no, quegli è Tomasso
235
Mel dice il core e lo cognosco al naso.”
There is, however, one important distinction between the two poets
in their use of the digression: Pulci employs it for cursory comment
on his story, or for chat about himself; Byron utilizes it not only for
these purposes, but also for the expression of satire. It is in his
digressions that he speaks out directly against individuals,
institutions, and society in general. The Morgante is a tale, with an
occasional remark by the author; Don Juan is a monologue,
sustained by a narrative framework.
Pulci’s comparison of his poetry to a boat is introduced so
frequently that it may possibly have suggested the figure to Byron. A
typical instance of its usage may be quoted in the lines:—
However this may be, it is certain that Pulci, in his more thoughtful
moods, inclined to pessimism and intellectual scepticism.
“Pulci’s versification,” says Foscolo, “is remarkably fluent; yet he
is deficient in melody.” Another critic, the author of the brief note in
the Parnaso Italiano, mentions his rapidity and his compression: “Tu
troverai pochi poeti, che viaggino so velocemente, come il Pulci, il
qualo in otti versi dice spesso piu di otte cose.” For this fluency and
its corresponding lack of rhythm, the conversational tone of the
Morgante is largely responsible. The many colloquial digressions and
the use of common idioms hinder any approach to a grand style.
Pulci’s indifference to the strict demands of metre, his employment
of abrupt and disconnected phrases, and his frequent sacrifice of
melody to vigor and compactness, are also characteristic of Byron’s
method in his Italian satires. Although Don Juan contains some of
Byron’s most musical passages, it nevertheless gives the impression
of having been, like the Morgante, composed for an audience, the
speaker being, perhaps, governed by rough notes, but tempted from
his theme into extemporaneous observations, and caring so little for
regularity or unity of structure that he feels no compunction about
obeying the inclination of the moment. It is not without some
acuteness that he alludes to,