oaem-13-373
oaem-13-373
oaem-13-373
Etika Emaliyawati 1,2 Purpose: Because Indonesia has a high risk of natural disasters, nurse preparedness is
Kusman Ibrahim 3 necessary to reduce and prevent deaths in the aftermath of such disasters. The aim of this
Yanny Trisyani 1 study was to determine the factors associated with nurse preparedness in disaster manage
Ristina Mirwanti 1 ment among a sample of community health nurses in coastal areas.
Patients and Methods: A cross-sectional study was undertaken from May to August 2020.
Fitri Muthiara Ilhami 4
The sample consisted of 142 nurses who worked at six Public Health Centers in
Hidayat Arifin 3
Pangandaran, West Java, Indonesia. Participants were recruited using the total sampling
1
Department of Critical Care and technique. The data were collected using the Emergency Preparedness Information
Emergency Nursing, Faculty of Nursing,
Universitas Padjadjaran, Bandung, Questionnaire and analyzed using Chi-Square and binary logistic regression.
Indonesia; 2Doctoral Study Program, Results: Of the 142 respondents, 54.24% had a high level of preparedness. Multivariate
Faculty of Medicine, Universitas analysis showed that nurses with higher levels of preparedness had worked between 6 and 10
Padjadjaran, Bandung, Indonesia;
3
Department of Medical-Surgical Nursing, years (adjusted odds ratio (AOR): 12.755, 95% confidence interval (CI): 2.653–61.314).
Faculty of Nursing, Universitas Respondents who lacked disaster training were less likely to have a high level of disaster
Padjadjaran, Bandung, Indonesia; 4Under-
preparedness (AOR: 4.631, 95% CI: 1.604–13.367). Respondents who had never served as
Graduate Program, Faculty of Nursing,
Universitas Padjadjaran, Bandung, disaster volunteers were also less likely to have disaster preparedness (AOR: 0.18, 95% CI:
Indonesia 0.053–0.616).
Conclusion: With nearly half of the respondents (45.77%) having a low level of disaster
preparedness, this topic needs more attention from the government and healthcare workers.
Several actions are needed to improve community nurses’ disaster preparedness: providing
them with routine disaster-related training, encouraging them to serve as volunteers in
various disaster conditions, and offering them useful disaster-related information.
Keywords: nurses, disaster, disaster management, coastal area, preparedness
Introduction
The trend of disaster events in Indonesia continues. The National Agency for
Disaster Management Indonesia recorded an increase in the incidence of disasters
from August 2018 to August 2019 of around 7.3%. From January to August 2019,
the average number of people affected by a disaster was 2.5% of the population.1 In
the West Java province of Indonesia, the Pangandaran Regency ranks sixth in
Correspondence: Etika Emaliyawati
Department of Critical Care and
earthquake and tsunamis risk. These types of disasters result in injuries, missing
Emergency Nursing, Faculty of Nursing, people, deaths, displaced families, and economic problems.2 Frequent disasters
Universitas Padjadjaran, Bandung, 45363,
Indonesia require disaster management efforts that involve all possible parties, including
Tel +62 817-222-086 nurses. Because nurses are the largest and most important group of healthcare
Fax +62 22 7795596
Email [email protected] providers in disaster management, their competencies need to be continually
assessed and improved.3–5 Given these facts, disaster man preparedness among community health nurses in coastal
agement preparedness remains a strong area of concern for areas.
nurses in disaster-prone areas.
Disaster management preparedness is a very important Patients and Methods
professional skill for nurses, as nurses with a strong sense
Study Design
of readiness can provide assistance to disaster victims.6
A cross-sectional design was used for this study.
Furthermore, nurses can perform comprehensive relief
management services, such as mapping the disaster loca
tion, providing disaster mitigation, triaging patients, and Setting and Sample
organizing first aid involving cross-sector collaboration The study was conducted from May to August 2020 in six
and interdisciplinary professional teams.7–9 Nurse prepa PHCs in the coastal areas of Pangandaran, West Java,
redness can be measured using the following eight dimen Indonesia. The sample consisted of 142 community health
sions: triage and basic first aid; detection; accessing nurses who were recruited using the total sampling tech
critical resources and reporting; the incident command nique. The inclusion criteria were community health
system (ICS); isolation, quarantine, and decontamination; nurses with a minimum of a diploma in nursing education
psychological issues; epidemiology and clinical decision- who were employed at one of the PHCs in the coastal
making; and communication and connectivity.10 Another areas and had worked for a minimum of three months. The
recent study reported that nurses with emergency prepa exclusion criteria were community health nurses who were
redness competencies are more likely to have profes on leave, too busy with their duties to participate in the
sional competence in disaster responses, maintain study, or were not able to complete the study. The data
personal disaster preparedness, and report to work after were collected using questionnaires.
a disaster.11
One of the roles of community public health centers Variables
(PHCs) is to minimize the effects of disasters on the The independent variables were age, education level, gen
population. Despite nurses being primarily responsible der, number of years working as a nurse (referred to as
for most (72.97%) PHC disaster programs, previous work history), disaster training, disaster preparedness
study results indicated that 50% of PHC nurses had low knowledge sources, disaster volunteering, and disaster
disaster preparedness.12 Furthermore, nurses’ service cap management experience. The age variable was divided
abilities for treating disaster victims at PHCs were limited into four categories: 21–25 years, 26–35 years, 36–45
to caring for victims flagged as green during triage years, and >45 years. Nursing education level was divided
(84.21%).13 into three categories: diploma, Bachelor’s degree, and
Another study showed that high levels of readiness in professional nursing education. Respondent gender was
nurses serving in disasters are related to nurse age, classified as either male or female. Work history was
experience,14 knowledge,15 responsibilities,16 support divided into four categories: ≤1 year, 2–5 years, 6–10
from the government,17 and training.18 In addition, the years, and >10 years. Responses about disaster training
average level of nurse preparation to respond to disaster were divided into one of two categories: yes (having any
conditions was low. Results from several other studies level of training) or no (having no training). Preparedness
indicated that many nurses did not know the tasks required knowledge sources were classified into the following cate
during disaster or post-disaster conditions.19–22 Providing gories: lectures, seminars, training, simulations, participa
nurses with disaster management training will increase tion, and other methods. Disaster volunteering history was
their ability to handle disaster conditions. Other factors classified as either yes (have served as a volunteer) or no
that can affect nurse preparedness include work experi (have never served as a volunteer). Finally, disaster man
ence, length of time spent preparing to face disasters, agement was classified into ever (having provided disaster
disaster volunteer experience, and access to information management services) or never (having provided these
sources. Unfortunately, there is a lack of studies about the services).
disaster preparedness of nurses working in disaster-prone The Emergency Preparedness Information
coastal areas of Indonesia. Therefore, this study aimed to Questionnaire (EPIQ) was used in this study to determine
determine the factors associated with disaster management the dependent variable, preparedness level.23 The EPIQ
assesses eight dimensions of preparedness: triage and (X2: 5.459; p < 0.05) all had a significant correlation with
basic first aid; detection; accessing critical resources and nurse preparedness. In contrast, age, education level, and
reporting; the ICS; isolation, quarantine, and decontamina gender were not correlated with preparedness (Table 1).
tion; psychological issues; epidemiology and clinical deci Multivariate analysis using binary logistic regression
sion-making; and communication and connectivity. The showed that nurses with a work history spanning 6–10
nurse preparedness variable was divided into two cate years were 12.755 times more likely to have a high level
gories: Low (if the value was less than the mean) or of preparedness than those with a work history of ≤1 year
High (if the value was greater than the mean). Each (AOR: 12.755; 95% CI: 2.653–61.314). Interestingly,
category was coded as Low = 0 and High = 1. The nurses with no disaster training history were 4.631 times
Cronbach’s alpha result was 0.951. more likely to have a high level of preparedness than were
those with such training (AOR: 4.631; 95% CI: 1.604–
Data Analysis 13.367). Finally, respondents who had never served as dis
To manage and analyze the data, we used STATA/MP aster volunteers were 0.18 times less likely to have a high
version 16.1 (Mac). Chi-Square and Binary Logistic level of preparedness than were those who had served as
Regression were used to analyze the factors associated volunteers (AOR: 0.18; 95% CI: 0.053–0.616; Table 2).
with nurse disaster management preparedness among the
sample of community health nurses from the coastal areas. Discussion
The significance value was p < 0.05, and the adjusted odds It is important to consider the disaster preparedness of
ratio (AOR) had a 95% confidence interval (CI). nurses working in coastal areas that face disasters more
frequently than non-coastal areas. The results of this study
Ethical Considerations indicated that almost half of the nurses surveyed had a low
We received approval from the Health Ethics Commission level of disaster preparedness. This finding is consistent
of Universitas Padjadjaran (439/UN6.KEP/EC/2020) on with study results showing low to moderate readiness
April 30, 2020. Respondents were informed about the among nurses in Cambodia, China, Laos, Nepal, and the
study objectives and provided informed consent and this Solomon Islands.24 Likewise, in the Philippines, three-
study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of quarters of nurses (80%) stated that they were not fully
Helsinki. Participation was voluntary, and the study did prepared to work during a disaster.25
not have the potential to harm the participants physically In this study, we found that three factors were signifi
or mentally. cantly correlated with preparedness among the nurses:
work history, disaster training history, and service as
Results a disaster volunteer. Disaster nurses are defined as nurses
The demographic data showed that more than half the who have the expertise to help victims by minimizing life-
participants (54.23%) had a high level of disaster prepa threatening health risks.26 Given this definition, we can
redness and 45.77% had a low level of preparedness. One- surmise that nurses are expected to be able to adapt to their
third of the respondents were 26–35 years of age. environment and disaster conditions.23
Regarding education, 50% had either a diploma or profes The results of this study showed that work history had
sional nursing education and most had worked for more a significant relationship with disaster preparedness. This
than 10 years. A majority of respondents had attended finding is likely due to the fact that these nurses gained
disaster training, served as a disaster volunteer, and gained a great deal of disaster management information and
knowledge about disasters while attending lectures. Apart knowledge from working and living in a coastal area.
from that, many respondents had never provided disaster The ideal work history is in the range of 6–10 years,
management services. a period when nurses are still active and enthusiastic at
The bivariate analysis conducted using Chi-Square work and have good cognitive abilities. This finding is in
showed that the variables of work history (X2: 13.784; line with that of a previous study showing that nurses with
p < 0.01), disaster training (X2: 16.986; p < 0.01), knowl the ideal length of work history can have increased pro
edge sources (X2: 13.972; p < 0.05), disaster volunteering ductivity, performance, and ability in providing care.27–30
(X2: 9.574; p < 0.01), and disaster management experience However, it should be noted that nurses who have worked
Table 1 Respondents’ Characteristics and Bivariate Analysis of Nurse Preparedness in Disaster Management Among the Community
Health Nurses in the Coastal Areas (n=142)
Variable n % Nurse Preparedness X2 p
Low High
n % n %
Age
21–25 years old 31 21.83 14 9.86 17 11.97 0.962 0.810
26–35 years old 53 37.32 25 17.61 28 19.72
36–45 years old 41 28.87 20 14.08 21 14.79
>45 years old 17 11.97 6 4.23 11 7.75
Education level
Diploma in nursing 65 45.77 27 19.01 38 26.76 2.148 0.342
Bachelor’s in nursing 14 9.86 5 3.52 9 6.34
Professional nursing 63 44.37 33 23.24 30 21.13
Gender
Male 51 35.92 21 14.79 30 21.13 0.677 0.410
Female 91 64.08 44 30.99 47 33.10
Length of working
≤ 1 year 19 13.38 16 11.27 3 2.11 13.784*** 0.003
2–5 years 40 28.17 15 10.56 25 17.61
6–10 years 31 21.83 11 7.75 20 14.08
>10 years 52 36.62 23 16.20 29 20.42
Disaster training
Yes 95 66.90 55 38.73 40 28.17 16.986*** 0.000
No 47 33.10 10 7.04 37 26.06
Source of knowledge
Lectures 54 38.03 25 17.61 29 20.42 13.972** 0.016
Seminars 35 24.65 14 9.86 21 14.79
Training 4 2.82 3 2.11 1 0.70
Simulations 32 22.54 17 11.97 15 10.56
Participation 9 6.34 6 4.23 3 2.11
Other 8 5.63 0 0 8 5.63
Disaster volunteering
Yes 105 73.94 40 28.17 65 45.77 9.574*** 0.002
No 37 26.06 25 17.61 12 8.45
for a long time with a heavy workload can experience effective enough to improve nurses’ disaster preparedness.
decreased productivity due to boredom and burnout when This finding is consistent with previous studies indicating
working as a disaster nurse.31,32 that a training approach that uses easy-to-understand meth
One surprising finding of this study was that nurses ods is likely to be more effective.33,34 Based on this find
who had not participated in disaster training had a greater ing, it is important that future research be conducted to
likelihood of having a higher level of disaster preparedness evaluate common disaster training methods. Our respon
than those who had engaged in such training. This result dents indicated that most of their knowledge came from
may be due to the fact that the provided training was not lectures, seminars, and simulations.
Table 2 Multivariate Analysis of Nurse Preparedness in Disaster levels—efforts that address the salient factors are needed to
Management Among the Community Health Nurses in Coastal increase the disaster preparedness among nurses in coastal
Areas (n=142)
areas. For example, nurses’ history of work experience, disas
Variable AOR p 95% CI ter training, and volunteering can serve as the basis for further
Lower Upper policy formation to address this crucial issue. However,
because this research was limited to specific areas in the
Length of working
Pangandaran Regency, future research covering more areas is
≤ 1 year Ref.
2–5 years 9.313*** 0.003 2.144 40.452 needed to further explicate the factors that affect nurses’ dis
6–10 years 12.755*** 0.001 2.653 61.314 aster preparedness in coastal areas.
>10 years 9.403*** 0.006 1.888 46.836
5. Aitsi-Selmi A, Egawa S, Sasaki H, Wannous C, Murray V. The 20. Ibrahim FAA. Nurses’ knowledge, attitudes, practices and familiarity
Sendai framework for disaster risk reduction: renewing the global regarding disaster and emergency preparedness–Saudi Arabia. Am
commitment to people’s resilience, health, and well-being. J Nurs Sci. 2014;3(2):18–25. doi:10.11648/j.ajns.20140302.12
Int J Disaster Risk Sci. 2015;6(2):164–176. doi:10.1007/s13753- 21. Kalanlar B. Effects of disaster nursing education on nursing students’
015-0050-9 knowledge and preparedness for disasters. Int J Disaster Risk Reduct.
6. Xia SS, Yang BX, Pm A. Application and effects of a disaster nursing 2018;28:475–480. doi:10.1016/j.ijdrr.2017.12.008
simulationtraining for Chinese undergraduates. Nurse Educ Pract. 22. Salmani I, Seyedin H, Ardalan A, Farajkhoda T. Conceptual model of
2018;28:156–162. managing health care volunteers in disasters: a mixed method study.
7. Pilemalm S, Mojir KY. ICT enabled cross-sector collaboration in BMC Health Serv Res. 2019;19(1):241. doi:10.1186/s12913-019-
emergency response: emerging forms of public-sector network 4073-6
governance. Int J Emerg Manag. 2020;16(3):249. doi:10.1504/ 23. Baack S, Alfred D. Nurses’ preparedness and perceived competence
IJEM.2020.113936 in managing disasters. J Nurs Scholarsh. 2013;45(3):281–287.
8. Xue C, Shu Y, Hayter M, Lee A. Experiences of nurses involved in doi:10.1111/jnu.12029
natural disaster relief: a meta-synthesis of qualitative literature. J Clin 24. Usher K, Mills J, West C, et al. Cross-sectional survey of the disaster
Nurs. 2020;29(23–24):4514–4531. doi:10.1111/jocn.15476 preparedness of nurses across the Asia–Pacific region. Nurs Health
9. Al Harthi M, Al Thobaity A, Al Ahmari W, Almalki M. Challenges Sci. 2015;17(4):434–443. doi:10.1111/nhs.12211
for nurses in disaster management: a scoping review. Risk Manag 25. Labrague LJ, Yboa BC, McEnroe-Petitte DM, Lobrino LR,
Healthc Policy. 2020;13:2627–2634. doi:10.2147/RMHP.S279513 Brennan MGB. Disaster preparedness in Philippine nurses. J Nurs
10. Wisniewski R, Dennik-Champion G, Peltier JW. Emergency prepa Scholarsh. 2016;48(1):98–105. doi:10.1111/jnu.12186
redness competencies: assessing nurses’ educational needs. J Nurs 26. Kulig JC, Edge D, Smolenski S. Wildfire disasters: implications for
Adm. 2004;34(10):475–480. doi:10.1097/00005110-200410000- rural nurses. Australas Emerg Nurs J. 2014;17(3):126–134.
00009 doi:10.1016/j.aenj.2014.04.003
11. McNeill C, Adams L, Heagele T, Swanson M, Alfred D. Emergency 27. Hudak G. Keperawatan Kritis. 6th ed. EGC; 2010.
preparedness competencies among nurses. JONA J Nurs Adm. 28. Goniewicz K, Goniewicz M, Burkle FM, Khorram-Manesh A. The
2020;50(7/8):407–413. doi:10.1097/NNA.0000000000000908 impact of experience, length of service, and workplace preparedness
12. Wahidah DA, Rondhianto R, Hakam M. Faktor-Faktor yang in physicians’ readiness in the response to disasters. J Clin Med.
Mempengaruhi Kesiapsiagaan Perawat dalam Menghadapi Bencana 2020;9(10):3328. doi:10.3390/jcm9103328
Banjir di Kecamatan Gumukmas Kabupaten Jember [Factors 29. Far SST, Marzaleh MA, Shokrpour N, Ravangard R. Nurses’ knowl
Influencing Nurse Preparedness in the Face of Flooding in edge, attitude, and performance about disaster management: a case of
Gumukmas District in Jember]. Pustaka Kesehat. 2016;4 Iran. Open Public Health J. 2020;13(1):441–446. doi:10.2174/
(3):568–574.
1874944502013010441
13. Emaliyawati E, Prawesti A, Yosep I, Ibrahim K. Manajemen Mitigasi
30. Goniewicz K, Goniewicz M. Disaster preparedness and professional
Bencana dengan Teknologi Informasi di Kabupaten Ciamis [Disaster
competence among healthcare providers: pilot study results.
Mitigation Management with Information Technology in Ciamis
Sustainability. 2020;12(12):4931. doi:10.3390/su12124931
District]. J Keperawatan Padjadjaran. 2016;4(1):79–88. Indonesian.
31. Diehl E, Rieger S, Letzel S, et al. The relationship between workload
doi:10.24198/jkp.v4n1.8
and burnout among nurses: the buffering role of personal, social and
14. Hodge AJ, Miller EL, Skaggs MKD. Nursing self-perceptions of
organisational resources. PLoS One. 2021;16(1):e0245798.
emergency preparedness at a rural hospital. J Emerg Nurs. 2017;43
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0245798
(1):10–14. doi:10.1016/j.jen.2015.07.012
32. Tavakoli N, Shaker SH, Soltani S, et al. Job burnout, stress, and
15. Setyawati AD, Lu YY, Liu CY, Liang SY. Disaster knowledge, skills,
satisfaction among emergency nursing staff after health system trans
and preparedness among nurses in Bengkulu, Indonesia: a descriptive
formation plan in Iran. Emerg. 2018;6(1):e41–e41.
correlational survey study. J Emerg Nurs. 2020;46(5):633–641.
33. Nazli NNNN, Sipon S, Radzi HM. Analysis of training needs in
doi:10.1016/j.jen.2020.04.004
disaster preparedness. Procedia - Soc Behav Sci.
16. Ning N, Kang Z, Jiao M, et al. Factors affecting emergency prepa
redness competency of public health inspectors: a cross-sectional 2014;140:576–580. doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2014.04.473
study in northeastern China. BMJ Open. 2014;4(1):e003832. 34. Potter MA, Miner KR, Barnett DJ, et al. The evidence base for
doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2013-003832 effectiveness of preparedness training: a retrospective analysis.
17. Kim H, Zakour M. Exploring the factors associated with the disaster Public Health Rep. 2010;125(5_suppl):15–23. doi:10.1177/
preparedness of human service organizations serving persons with 00333549101250S504
disabilities. Hum Serv Organ Manag Leadersh Gov. 2018;42 35. Phakdeechanuan K, Songwathana P, Sae-Sia W. Thai nurses’ learning
(1):19–32. doi:10.1080/23303131.2017.1380737 needs regarding disaster nursing: high needs? Nurse Media J Nurs.
18. Labrague LJ, Hammad K, Gloe DS, et al. Disaster preparedness 2015;5(2):56–66. doi:10.14710/nmjn.v5i2.10529
among nurses: a systematic review of literature. Int Nurs Rev. 36. Whittaker J, McLennan B, Handmer J. A review of informal volun
2018;65(1):41–53. doi:10.1111/inr.12369 teerism in emergencies and disasters: definition, opportunities and
19. Corrigan E, Samrasinghe I. Disaster preparedness in an Australian challenges. Int J Disaster Risk Reduct. 2015;13:358–368.
urban trauma center: staff knowledge and perceptions. Prehosp doi:10.1016/j.ijdrr.2015.07.010
Disaster Med. 2012;27(5):432. doi:10.1017/S1049023X12001045