Electrical_Electronic Issues - Breville 800ESXL Repair
Electrical_Electronic Issues - Breville 800ESXL Repair
Electrical_Electronic Issues - Breville 800ESXL Repair
Preventive Repairs
Other Approaches
In the summer of 2011, a kind reader provided me (and us all) with what appears to
be the service manual for the Breville 800 series of machines, as of early 2008. There is
enough to say about it that i discuss it on the separate Breville 800 Series Service
Manual page (including prominent differences between my schematic and the one in
the service manual).
The service manual has a newer schematic, circa 2008. Years before 2011, i drew up
my own schematic, presented below. The 800ESXL here was received as a gift for
Christmas 2006 and appears to have a 637 date code, which would mean the machine
was manufactured during the 37th. week of 2006, thus it is an early(-ier) production
model. Please note that so far i do not have enough information to know at what date
the circuit changed, or for that matter whether there were other circuit variants
besides these two. It is up to each Breville 800-series machine owner to confirm
which—if either—of the schematics applies.
Having no documentation of production changes, knowing the production date code
is useful mainly as a sweeping generalization guide. Information on locating and
decoding the production date code for the model 800 is on this article’s home page.
Again, tracing the wiring of the machine in front of you and matching it to either
the drawn schematic below else the one in the PDF service manual is essential,
and far more relevant than the date code.
Failure and Repair: Pump Motor Runs When Unit is Off
This is a fun one… you’re sitting there at home, possibly reading something in your
seat on the Comfy Couch as i was, and all of a sudden you hear a familiar buzz. Then it
stops (maybe… maybe not). Later, it comes back. You investigate, find it is coming from
the kitchen, and indeed from the Breville 800ESXL. But… the front panel of the Breville
is dark: it is Off. Like many modern electrical/electronic products, the 800ESXL has a
“soft” (logic controlling) power switch rather than the “hard” (removes all electricity
from the device) power switches of decades past, so this failure is all too possible! (I feel
very fortunate to have been at home, rather than having no one home, possibly on vacation, and
the pump grinding away for hours, days, or weeks… probably cycling on and off thanks to its
thermal breaker.) One can certainly add a “hard” power switch, and Doug McNutt has
suggestions for a convenient mechanical arrangement.
The failure just described—the pump running when the machine is plugged in yet
powered off—is specific to older production 800 series espresso machines. If the pump
on your machine is running when it is not supposed to, but only when the 800-series
espresso machine is On, check the next two sections: Continuously On, Keeps running
but does pulse.
By now it is (might be) running continuously, so you quickly unplug it and get to
work, starting with the disassembly described on the previous page. Let’s have a look at
the schematic for a North America 120VAC unit:
Steam
Breville 800 ESXL schematic
R15 Power
Transcribed by
470Ω Switch
Rev. 3 27 March 2024
x2
Hot Heat
R14 Power
Water LED
LED
R11 C9
Closed for through-filter flow. R22 470Ω
10kΩ Steam 10nF
R23 Klixon YS11A75B-C7
x2 x2
NO 470Ω Thermal Cutout 7A
S1 R12 C10 R10 10kΩ 250V 75°C open, 45°
C close
1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5
C13 10nF V+ C8 10nF V+
Q1 M
V+
Through Filter/ NEC 2P4M
D4 R21 10kΩ
Standby R4 6
NC 3 2 13 14 12 5 R6
S2 C
T/F +
9
P64 P66 P67 P52 P51 P53 P65
47kΩ C6 4.7kΩ
C12 R8 P61
NO 1/2W 47µF ZD2 P62 8 M
Low temp. 4.7kΩ Breville IC1835bsaa
Nozzle 16V C14
thermostat, U1 Elan EM78P153SPJ Pump
8-bit microprocessor R7 41W
1, rearmost R5 D6 P60
10kΩ
H + C7
10 Vdd RST Vss P50 To N
47kΩ R9
C11 4 7 11 1
1/2W 47µF ZD3
4.7kΩ
16V
Heater C5 .1µF
RL1
R
Troubleshooting
After verifying that, yes indeed, R7 was intact, the correct value, and working, the
next troubleshooting step was looking at the sillyscope waveform of the SCR’s gate-to-
cathode junction (across R7) with the unit failing and working:
During failure, the 60 Hz half wave humps drop from their approximately 1V peak to
(or very close to) the 0V baseline. During normal operation, the drop only goes to 0.6V,
or there may be almost no visible humps nor drop at all (this latter condition is more
likely with a good SCR in place). Clearly, the failure was happening close to this
observation point.
Next, i placed a voltmeter (set to D.C.) across R6, to effectively measure the current
into (or, if failing, out of) the SCR gate:
Here came the smoking gun: During normal operation pump running conditions,
current flow was from the IC into the gate of Q1. During failure, the current flow was
very clearly from the gate of Q1 into pin 8 of the IC, which is not ever supposed to
normally happen!
To further nail down the bad SCR diagnosis as being definitive, i disconnected one
end of R6, so that Q1 was entirely isolated from the IC: the IC had no way to control Q1.
In this condition, Q1 should remain forever Off. The Breville failed in exactly the same
way as when R6 was attached, totally eliminating everything except Q1 and R7. Yet R7
was already found to be just fine, so that left only the NEC 2P4M SCR, Q1.
Add a Snubber
Another interesting design choice of the Breville design team was omitting a snubber
network across the anode to cathode junction of Q1. Consisting of a series resistance
and capacitance, the snubber component values are selected to counteract the effects
of an inductive load, such as the Ulka pump used in the 800ESXL. Snubbers can further
decrease dV/dt unwanted turn-on, and also somewhat diminish the effects of powerline
surge pulses that would otherwise stress Q1.
While i do have an EE degree, i lack experience designing snubber networks, and for
many years (actually, decades) have been curious at how component values for them
have been chosen. What i could find online led to 3 basic categories of approaches:
I chose the middle method. Making things more exciting is the fact that the Ulka pump
unit contains an internal rectifier diode, so even though it is marked A.C., it operates
with half-wave D.C. power. This explains why Breville is using a single SCR to control
the pump. It also makes it more difficult to directly measure the inductance (say, with
my nifty early 20th. century General Radio impedance bridge). Trying to think of a way to
bias On the diode and simultaneously measure the inductance made my head spin, so i
went for an indirect method: measured the current draw at 120V and did the math.
I measured a reactance, XL, of 120V/0.57A(AC)=211Ω. With the equation
XL=2πfL=377L (for 60Hz), L=211/377=0.56H=560mH. Using equations found on or near
p. 163 of the aforementioned ON Semiconductor HBD855 document, i somehow (my
notes are incomplete) concluded that ω0=29400. C=1/ω02L≈2nF (known to old-timey people
as .002µF, or even .002mfd). I chose a damping factor ρ=0.6, so
Rs=2ρ√(L/C)=1.2√(.56/2.07x10-9)=19.7kΩ≈20kΩ. And thus came about the values i’m
using for the added-on snubber network.
Findings
Even with all these added-on measures to reduce spontaneous turn-on, the existing
SCR continued to fail. Why would this be?
From my extensive reading, apparently power spikes exceeding the SCR rating can
degrade the SCR hold-off voltage (voltage across the anode-cathode junction which the
SCR can effectively block) over time. In other words, as power spikes continue to whack
the SCR, it gradually takes lower and lower spikes to actually turn On the SCR via the
overvoltage instead of the gate lead.
In theory, the MOV V1 ought to be eating powerline spikes before they get to Q1. Yet
was this happening? The NEC 2P4M is rated at holding off 400V repetitive voltage
peaks, and 500V non-repetitive peaks. The TVR 07471 MOV is rated to start whacking
transients nominally around 470V, with an 8/20µsec. maximum clamping voltage rating
of 775V. Hmmm… anyone else notice a problem here? Seems to me Breville either
needed to specify the 2P6M 600V SCR, or use a lower voltage MOV in their North
American 120V units (MOVs with a lower clamp voltage than the existing device would
likely be unsuitable for worldwide power sources up to 240V nominal, and actual
voltages sometimes higher than that). This mismatch in abilities is likely why we see so
many apparent SCR failures. Here i am guessing that the many intermittent pump
spontaneous turn-on events i’ve read about in researching this issue with the unit here
are also caused by diminished Q1 hold-off abilities, to the point where normal power
line transients exceed the reduced hold-off threshold and activate the pump for a
moment or quite awhile.
Repair
Add a Snubber
To further eat any transient pulses that make their way to the SCR, add a series 2nF
and 20kΩ snubber network across the SCR (anode to cathode). There should be little
enough energy that 1/4 watt should be OK (that’s what i used). There could be a
significantly high transient voltage across this network, so i’d go for at least a 500V
capacitor. I happened to have a 1nF 1kV disc capacitor that was also small, so it went in
the unit here.
The key here is the normal pulsing cycle. This tells us that the IC has control of the
SCR—the SCR is not randomly going off, nor is it shorted. In the two sections above
where the SCR itself failed, the IC has no control of the SCR. It might not always be
possible to distinguish between these failure modes, so you may have to try both what
is in this section and those above.
So far and until further notice, i have yet to receive a report of the IC itself failing.
Thus if the IC is able to control the SCR and the pump is running at improper times, we
need to look at the input signals to the IC. Far and away the most likely source of
problems are the two microswitches on the function knob assembly. The knob itself
controls the hydraulics: where the water flows:
The switches are needed to convey function knob mode information to the IC. The
schematic references differ between my schematic and Breville’s, and frankly, i think
mine are clearer, so let’s use those for the purposes of this explanation.
In Standby, mains power flows through the common (C) and Normally Closed (NC)
contacts of S2, sending a high signal to the T/F terminal.
In Brew Head mode, this switch remains in this position, and additionally S1
closes, telling the IC to pump.
In Steam Wand mode, S2 switches from NC to Normally Open (NO). The T/F signal
goes low, and i believe S1 is open so P64 (on my circuit) is high, as it is for Standby.
If any of these switch signals are incorrect, the IC may activate the SCR and operate
the pump on one of the water-flow cycles at inappropriate times. For one example, let’s
say that S2 fails such that it goes high resistance or open circuit between C and NC. If
this happens, the IC will think it is in steam wand mode, and the pump should keep
pulsing. Second example: if instead there is a short in S1 or C13 or the wiring to S1, the
IC will think that S1 is closed and that it should run the pump in brew head mode, no
matter which position the function knob is in.
There are likely other combinations of failures. The thing for you to do is ensure that
the proper high/low signals are being sent to the IC, following your machine’s
schematic, for each function knob position.
I believe the caption was meant to read: Solenoid pump from Sunbeam machine adapted to fit
I did some measurements on RL1 pins and, as you expected, the problem
was there. At a cold temperature and with some taps on the relay, the
circuit is open. When I plug the unit, the heating circuit stays off.
Things start to get funny once the machine is turned on. It seems that
once warmed up, the relay contacts are stuck closed and stay in that state
when the unit is powered off. Only if I tap on the relay, once the machine is
unplugged, do I get an almost open circuit. My analog meter’s needle is
pointing a very high resistance. Almost infinite but not quite much.
Louis-Martin later wrote to confirm that replacing RL1 resolved this problem. As of
November 2017, a second report of RL1’s contacts being shorted and replacing RL1
solving the problem came in from site correspondent Soroush, also coincidentally of
Montreal, Canada.
Now, go to your favorite electronic parts vendor. I like Digi-Key, so for this example i
searched on their site, plugging in the parameters above (details omitted… it will vary
with different companies’ websites). On 14 June 2010 around 6 PM PDT, limiting the
results to items in stock, i got 13 results. Three of these had minimum order quantities
much greater than one, so really 10 usable results. I then scanned the results for power
rating, and found one 3W diode (i’ll provide direct links to the relevant Digi-Key page until i
discover the links next break):
1N5934BG 24V 3W 5%
This is the direct relative of the 1N5935B in the 800ESXL here. It should work very well
—every bit as well as the 1N5935B. It is quite possible that Breville used the 27V diode
because they could get it in quantity for a lower price… these things are huge
consideration for “consumer” goods, to keep them affordably priced.
My next choice would be one of the 5W options:
1N5361B 27V 5W 5%
1N5360B 25V 5W 5%
1N5359B 24V 5W 5%
Note that the actual suffix varies: some of these are BG, some are BRLG. I’m so
unconcerned with the details of these differences that i did not even look them up. The
primary electrical specs (including some not retyped here) match exactly between
these types. In terms of which voltage to pick, i might go with what was cheapest or flip
a coin: it just doesn’t matter… precise voltage is not a requirement in this part of the
circuit. As opposed to ZD1, where precision matters a lot.
My last choice would be the 2W options:
2EZ27D5 27V 2W 5%
2EZ24D5 24V 2W 5%
They’re my last choice because they’re under 3W, and i’d prefer the larger margin of
safety, given that Breville decided to go with 3W… or did they do that because at that
moment in time 3W zeners were cheaper and/or more readily available than 2W
zeners? If i were concerned about problems drilling the PCB holes bigger, then my
preferences would flip and i’d take the 2W before the 5W (yet would still prefer the 3W
with its higher wattage rating and still smaller lead diameter).
The examples above are just that: examples of other choices which will work. Don’t
be afraid of wholly different part numbers, as long as the parameters are within the
range in the summary above. Use any electronic parts source you prefer/have
available.
I ascertained that the power switch was not closing, and remained mostly
open circuit. This was done without unplugging the control circuit so I
don’t know what the real resistance was, but it was extremely high. The fix
I used was to submerge the board in methylated spirits (95% adulterated
ethanol) and repeatedly operate the button. This had to be repeated three
times before I finally got it to beep on my continuity meter.
Other contact cleaners could certainly be used, or one could replace the small
pushbutton switch, sometimes called a “tact” switch. The issue which Chris cleverly
resolved is how to get the chemical into the switch assembly.
Replacing the “tact” or “tactile” switch is another option. These small pushbutton
switches are extremely common on home electronics, so if you have a dead DVD or CD
player, or VCR, or cable or satellite box, or just about anything else with pushbuttons
(on the main device, not a remote control), you may well already have a suitable
replacement on hand. On a Breville 800 series espresso machine, these switches are
fairly non-critical, so if you have one that physically fits and is normally open (off
unless pressed), it should be just fine. Note: on these switches, it is normal for two legs
(contacts) on each side to be tied together in common—“shorted” together. Use either
diagonal pair when taking your measurements, and you should be OK. Something like
99% of these should be normally open, but there are probably some normally closed
ones out there as well.
If you don’t have any old donor electronics or don’t want to futz around with a used
switch of unknown provenance, there are all sorts of replacements available. Site
correspondent Steve P. has found one of these many perfectly suitable options:
Alcoswitch Tactile SPST-NO 0.05A 24V from Digi-Key
As of the 24 March 2017 revision of this web page, it was all of US10¢.
Failure and Repair: Intermittent Operation: Pump
Fails when Heater On. White LEDs Dim.
Kindly contributed by Jade, in his words with minor style editing. His Breville is a 240V
Australian unit.
Fault: Coffee machine turns on, heats up, pump intermittently operates.
When the pump fires up, it works normally. Pump will always fail if the
pump and heater are both on at the same time. When the red light blinks
during heating, the white LEDs dim during the blink cycle.
Breville’s pathetic attempt at a 24V and 5V power supply checked. 5V
across the 5V zener, but only seeing 9-18V across the 24V zener. Replaced
zener, no change. Removed the 0.89uF poly cap, measured only at 0.35uF.
Replaced for about $3.50 at Jaycar (common place in Australia to obtain
components, much like USA Radio Shack). Everything working perfectly
again. Never would of suspected the cap to fail; it was the last thing I
checked.
The capacitor in question is C1, which on (at least some) 120V models is 1.5µF.
Interestingly, it appears on the official Breville schematic in the service manual as
“334”, a.k.a. 330000pF a.k.a. 0.33µF. Starting in early 2012 there have been a flurry of
reports of 800-series machines with all sorts of odd problems being fixed by replacing
C1, especially in the 240V machines where the original C1 is marked 0.8µF or
thereabouts. C1 apparently loses capacitance, dropping the V++ voltage below where
the machine can reliably operate. Historically in other equipment, the main filter
capacitor (C2 in the 800s) would lose capacitance (being an electrolytic capacitor), and
could possibly cause this same symptom, or one close to it (this particular failure has
not yet been reported to me in 800-series machines). It’s always a good idea to verify
that V++ is at least 24V, and ideally figure out whether it is supposed to be 24V or 27V in
your particular machine and that it matches that voltage, as discussed in the No Power
section above this one.
a. Machine turned on, pump operates (sucks water) then stops and red
light blinks (heating water).
b. Place cup under filter, turn dial lever to make coffee.
c. Pump activates, coffee flows to cup, however a full cup of coffee is
interrupted as the pump stops after several seconds.
d. At this point the power and steam lights blink in unison,
dull/bright/dull/bright. Continuous.
e. Turn the dial lever to stop filling cup (pump is stopped anyway).
f. Turn dial lever back to fill cup again, but there is no more pumping,
no more filling, no more coffee.
g. The only way to recover at this point is to turn the machine off at the
push button power switch (front of unit), turn machine back on at the
same switch, and start (or rather continue) the process again. This
fault happens reliably for each and every cup of coffee.
Safety Capacitors
Note the rectangular yellow 0.82 µF capacitor in the C1 position. Unlike the 1.5 µF
capacitor in our North American unit, Trevor’s Australian 240V machine has a safety-
rated capacitor for C1. All those icons are various safety agency approvals from
agencies around the world. That’s also the origin of the dual voltage ratings: some
agencies such as Underwriter’s Laboratories and the Canadian Standards Association
only approve this particular capacitor for use up to 250VAC (A.C. because of the tilde [~]
following the 250V), whereas other agencies approve this same capacitor for voltages
up to 275V (and i can’t find any definition of “- GMF”, so i have no idea whether that
value is a peak D.C. or an A.C. rating). X2 denotes the safety class of this capacitor (as
discussed in the article on the Just Radios website, linked in the following paragraph).
Safety-rated capacitors in addition to having been explicitly tested for use on A.C.
powerline (mains) circuits directly have been designed to fail in a minimally
destructive manner. The ABCs of Safety (Interference Suppression) Capacitors for Tube
Radios page on the Just Radios website has a plethora of information on this type of
capacitor. While that article is tube radio and North American-centric, most of its
safety content applies to the use of capacitors in appliances other than there is no
shock hazard in our Breville 800 series machines… that aspect is specific to the old
radios (and other similar-age old audio electronics) being discussed on that site.
Outside of legal/regulatory requirements, the main reason for using a safety
capacitor in a device such as an espresso machine is to minimize damage if/when the
capacitor fails. Direct and near-direct connection to the powerline is a tough job for
any electronic component, and definitely for capacitors (as discussed on the ABCs
page). A typical non-safety capacitor could easily fail and catch fire. Now, given that
this would be happening inside a sturdy thick metal enclosure with limited air, the
damage may not escape the Breville machine itself, though it could easily char-broil its
interior. Safety capacitors are designed to fail in a much more peaceful manner. They
may or may not also be built to better withstand the constant onslaught of powerline
transients and surges (i did not find specific information on this in my brief research,
and it likely varies quite a bit between capacitor makes).
Replacing C1
If your machine is like ours and the existing C1 has no specific safety rating
markings, legally you may replace it with the same sort of standard capacitor (of
matching or near-matching capacitance and same or higher rated voltage), or with an
equivalent safety-rated capacitor. If your machine currently has a safety-rated
capacitor in the C1 position, legally you’ll need to replace it with an equivalent (or
superior) safety-rated capacitor, approved at least by the safety agency with
jurisdiction where you live. (Or assume any legal liability if you are unable to do so or
choose not to do so and use a standard capacitor instead.)
To select a replacement C1:
1. Match the capacitance of the existing C1 in your unit, ±20%. Try to get as close as
you reasonably can to the existing value, but don’t kill yourself: for a 220/240V
model originally equipped with a 0.82 µF C1, any value between and including
0.66 to 0.98 µF (±20%) will be plenty close enough (and 0.98 is close enough to 1.0
µF that i’d use it in my machine). For 120V units originally equipped with C1 at 1.5
µF, the ±20% range is 1.2 to 1.8 µF (and 1.5 µF is a standard value, so it ought not to be
too difficult to find). If you can’t find anything within the ±20% range (and you
should really try), use the next highest value you can find… but not too high: the
1.5 µF value used in 120V North American units will be too high for 220-240V
units (otherwise Breville would have saved money and specified 1.5 µF for all
machines in all markets).
2. Choose a working voltage sufficient for your location. 250VAC should be sufficient
anywhere in the world.
3. If your original C1 is safety-rated, be sure your replacement is as well, with safety
rating approval from the organization in your jurisdiction which covers such
matters (UL in the U.S.A., C.S.A. in Canada, etc.). If your original is not safety-rated,
you may choose a safety-rated capacitor or a regular capacitor (ideally rated for
use with powerline alternating current).
Note: the shape, color, and exact size of the capacitor do not matter. As long
as it physically fits and meets the electrical and regulatory specifications, it
is a suitable replacement part.
399-5468-ND
399-5867-ND
399-6792-ND
Even though Digi-Key lists each of these as having a different voltage rating under
the Description column, the first and last have the same rating and the middle one is a
bit higher. All are fully sufficient for any line voltage up to 240VAC. They’re nearly
identical in size and construction. The choice comes down to price and what’s in stock
—any one will work equally well.
Glued In Place
Big parts like C1 are often glued in place during manufacture. Here’s another view of
Trev’s board (compression artifacts are mine, not his), showing the glue holding the
original C1 (just beneath and to the left of the screw hole), and the replacement C1:
It will be necessary to snap the existing C1/circuit board glue bond before the failed
part can be successfully unsoldered.
Trev reports that replacing C1 with the similar 1.0 µF capacitor he’s holding in his
hand in the photo successfully solved the problem with his 800ES.
Seeing a pattern here? On any 800 series espresso machine, though especially any
220-240V units, if you’re having any problems anything close to these, check or replace
C1!
I don’t know if it is normal for that machine, but once the unit is turned
on and the heating cycle starts, the heating LED flashes and RL1 does a
very weird buzzing.
It goes like this:
LED on for 1 second, RL1 buzzes
LED off for 1 second, RL1 does not buzz.
Thermoblock is heating. […]
I remember the faulty relay was buzzing too, with the heating LED
flashing (and a slight dimming of the power and water level LEDs in
rythme with the heating LED flashes, but in a very muffle and
inconspicuous. The new relay, however, buzzes like an alarm clock an it is
a little anoying, although I could put it on a timer and the breville can, in
only one step, wake me up in the morning and getting ready for a dose of
coffee!
The only noise RL1 should ever make is a momentary click when it activates and
deactivates, which is normally when the machine is turned on, and when it is turned
off. The only item in a Breville 800 series which should make any ongoing noise is the
pump, when the pump runs. That and water-flow hydraulic sounds are the only
normal sounds. The rapid on-off of the relay which creates the buzz leads to all sorts of
arcing and contact heating, which is why the original relay failed in his machine.
The “smoking gun” is that the buzzing happens when the Heating LED is on. The
slight dimming of the Power and water level LEDs is further evidence and seals the
case. The relay buzzes because it is starved for power: it just barely has enough for its
coil to move the contacts, but not really enough. The power and water LEDs should not
perceptibly dim at all… just very slightly when the heating element is actually heating.
The relay does not buzz when the heating LED is off because that small difference in
power consumption for the LED is enough to shift the relay from Enough to Not
Enough power for it to work properly. The V++ power supply is not working properly,
and the repairs are the same ones covered in other sections. Fractured solder joints are
possible, and should be checked first. Far and away the most common failure is C1
losing some of its capacitance, which “starves” the rest of the machine for power. But it
could be C2 or ZD6 itself, or even one or more of the other nearby parts.
On Louis-Martin’s particular machine, this is how the failure happened. He reported
that replacing C2 solved the problem—proof that it’s not always C1 which fails. Your
Breville 800 may have a different pattern of buzzing. It could be C2, or one of the other
V++ power supply parts failing in yours. If RL1 buzzes ever, at all, your machine has a
power supply problem.
As of November 2017, we have a second report of C2 being the component causing
the buzzing. Site correspondent Soroush from Montreal, Canada has the report:
This was his parents’ machine. They didn’t notice the buzzing, causing the relay’s
contacts to bond together, and the Heating Element Runs When Unit is Off problem.
Failure and Repair: Intermittent Operation:
Intermittent heating. LEDs flicker randomly
Site correspondent G, from a secure undisclosed location in the great nation of
Canada, had the following problem:
What’s going on is an open, as opposed to short, circuit. Note the solder joints encircled
in red. Those happen to be each end of C1 (C1 again!), though in this case capacitor C1
itself has not failed. Overheating, likely due to high resistance of unknown cause (poor
factory solder joints are only one of many possibilities) has led to the solder joint
between the wire lead of C1 and the metal foil traces of the circuit board failing. The
failure is visible as the dark circle (ring) around the middle of the “mountain cone” of
each of the two solder joints.
In electronics jargon this is generally called a fractured solder joint, as the solder fails
in such a way that the joint electrically and mechanically fractures. I have a whole
separate article on this subject. (You may see this same picture over there.)
The fix is straightforward: resolder the fractured joints, and any others which look
suspicious. Let’s look at G’s entire board:
I have circled two other suspect joints in purple, which may or may not be fractured.
The spot labeled “This is a problem” is an area where it appears there was an arc
between two adjacent foil traces which ought not to be electrically directly connected.
This could have happened from molten solder dripping off one of the fractured joints
onto this area, melting through the protective coating of the board.
Other visibly unpleasant aspects of this board are not causing problems, will not
cause problems, and do not need to be corrected. One of these is marked as “Solder
flux: OK”. Yellow or golden or golden brown deposits like this on the foil side of the
board are non-conductive flux. These areas can be left alone.
Anyone who’s going to be doing any soldering on these boards owes it to themselves
to read the section Preventive Repair: Resolder Questionable Solder Joints below, for
important information regarding the protective coating on the foil side of the P.C.B. and
RoHS lead-free solder considerations.
Yes friends, that white tank illumination LED is a functional circuit component, not
merely a user aesthetic feature. But wait, there’s more from wrangler June:
Upon further testing, the parallel diode in the LED is actually a zener diode
with a breakdown voltage of 6.75V.
I’m unsure what Breville had in mind here. June S. reports a serial number indicative
of an early production machine plus circuit traces which better match my schematic,
so we’ll use that for this discussion. Maybe when U1 pin 1 P50 is high—which is any
time the machine is turned on—Q2 would start to conduct but as it did the emitter
voltage across R20 might rise too high and possibly(?) the C-B junction of Q2 might rise
high enough in voltage towards V++ that even with R13, U1 pin 1’s internal circuitry
might be damaged? That’s all i’ve got, and it’s such a stretch, my brain is starting to
hurt.
When everything is working, the white LED clamps the voltage at Q2’s emitter
somewhere in the 3.5 to 4V range. When Q2’s base is activated with something under
but close to 5V at the IC side of R13, that’s enough to fully forward bias Q2’s B-E
junction and turn it all the way on, at which point Q2’s collector should be somewhere
in the, oh i dunno, 3.6 to 4.3V range? (White LED voltage drop plus Q2’s C-E saturation
voltage drop.)
When the white LED opens up, with the 6.75V zener, if U1 attempts to turn on Q2, the
voltage will rise too high for the 5V from U1 to keep Q2’s B-E junction forward biased.
Q2 will not be able to turn on enough (if at all) to energize relay RL1. That zener can’t
be low enough in zener voltage to allow circuit operation with white tank LED failure
because at any voltage low enough for 5V on the base to turn on Q2, it would steal
current from the LED and the LED would not light. I’m still missing why there would be
a zener diode in parallel with the white tank LED. I welcome thoughtful analyses, and
intend to update this section accordingly once one that makes sense to me gets through
my fuzzy skull.
So why wouldn’t Q2 and RL1 operate with just R20, ignoring the white tank
illuminator LED and zener?
Specs for RL1, some/many?/all? of which are Song Chuan 833H-1A-F-C 24VDC relays,
include a coil resistance of 1,600 Ω and current draw from a 24 VDC supply of 15 mA.
Pretend the white LED, zener, and Q2 are all not there, and that RL1 is connected to
R20 directly. Well, we’ve got ourselves a voltage divider, and if my illness-fuzzed too-
late-at-night calculation is correct, there would be the V++ of 24 or 27V at one end of
RL2 and circa 13.9 or 15.6V at the R20 end. That’s about 10-11V trying to actuate a 24V
relay. Might work for some 24V relays, and even for others of this brand and model, but
might not! If there’s still no Q2 and no white LED, the 6.75V zener clamping the voltage
across R20 at that voltage and allowing higher current flow as well yields 17 or 20V
across the relay (depending on V++ value), and that ought to be enough to operate most
relays with coils rated at 24V. But Q2 does exist, and i cannot see how it could be
forward biased and pass current to actuate RL1 when its base cannot be driven by U1
higher than right about 5V.
Even if my circuit analysis is cuckoo coconuts, it makes sense that U1 and Q2 will not
be able to power on RL1 unless that white tank LED is present and operational,
clamping the emitter of Q2 at or below 4V—and this is what site correspondent June S.
reports. Check that tank LED! No light = no hot coffee (or tea or whatever) for
youooooooo!
What if the white tank LED is lit up normally? Before you do anything else beyond
checking the tank LED, try:
Noel’s Workaround/Test
Site correspondent Noel T. of New Jersey’s 800ESXL had the following symptoms:
Red HEATING LED fails to light during standby warmup (see Normal Sequence of
Operations - Breville 800 Espresso Repair step 1)
Machine operates normally (electromechanically and hydraulically other than the
water being cold)
Turning the knob to the steam wand position makes the red HEATING LED
illuminate. After a few minutes, when steam comes out of the wand, the knob
may be turned to the brew head position and the machine will produce hot coffee.
Try that last step: put the knob into the steam wand position. If, like Noel T., you
eventually get hot water (after the thermal block has a few minutes to heat up), that’s a
smoking gun that the low temperature thermostat is open. Looking at the schematic,
we see that switch S2 bypasses (shorts across) this thermostat when the water flow
knob is in the steam nozzle (turned right) position, to allow the thermal block to rise to
the higher temperature needed for steam operation. If the low temperature thermostat
is stuck/failed open, with the knob on standby or through-brew-head flow, the power
path to the heating element remains an open circuit.
Noel reports that tapping that thermostat (rear-most on our unit, looking at the
machine from the usual coffee-making user’s position, but trace the wiring and verify
on yours [or tap both]) restored operation, and cleaning the thermostat contacts
ensured that normal heating would continue, coffee time after coffee time.
Overheated R24?
Site correspondent Larry G. resolved his heating problems thus:
Startup cycle and pump was working fine, the water would even heat up
at first… but after running water through the machine, the temperature
would drop and although the thermostats would work and the heating LED
would come on, the heater would not kick in.
After opening the casing and looking at the main board, i eventually
noticed black hardened soot in between R24 and C1. I decided to change
both: a 1.5kOhm 2W and a 1µF 250V capacitor (they didn't have any 1.5,
and by reading here I saw that would the job*). I got the parts at Fry’s for a
few bucks.
The protective film over the board was a pain, but a few hours in an
isopropyl alcohol puddle fixed that (thanks for the tip).
It ended up being R24, it read over 3kOhm. Replaced both parts anyway
and it’s working fine now! No more microwaved re-reheated bitter coffee
for me.
Bitter coffee!
* Actually 1 µF is a bit on the low side for a 120V unit, which Larry is almost certainly
using given that he conveniently picked up parts at Fry’s Electronics. I have clarified
this in the section on replacing C1. Apologies to Larry and anyone else for whom this
might have been unclear. Due to circuit tolerances 1 µF might work on some or all 120V
units, though once again, if the Breville engineers could have specified 1 µF for
everything (all voltages), they would have (saves money).
Other Failures
If Noel T.’s workaround/test fails to work for you, you’ll need to buckle down for some
more in-depth, inside the machine troubleshooting. First:
This is discussed in the section above. I cannot over-emphasize the importance of this.
If you can’t or won’t properly test the V++ power supply, see the section below about
throwing parts at the problem.
If V++ is OK, you need to figure out whether the problem lies in the heater circuit
itself or the control circuit which operates it. You’ll need a decent multimeter and the
skills to use it.
2. Set your meter to read A.C. voltage. Connect your meter’s common lead to the L
terminal: circuit common. Connect the voltage test lead of the meter to the R
terminal. Plug in the 800.
a. Plugged in and with power Off, you should measure line (mains) voltage.
b. With power On, you should measure very close to 0 VAC.
If both a and b test correctly, the machine is working—at least at the moment! If a
fails and b succeeds, you have a primary power circuit problem: if the voltage is
well below line voltage the whole time, one of the thermostats, the heater itself, or
the wiring between them is bad. If a passes and b fails (the voltage stays at/near
line voltage even when the machine is On), you have a control circuit problem:
RL1, Q2, and other components near them.
Primary Circuit Testing
You can unplug the machine and do a resistance test, or leave it plugged in and move
the meter lead in steps back towards the power source, doing a voltage test to find the
failure. I’ll describe the voltage test. The resistance tests works the same way with the
unit unplugged, the common lead moved to the N terminal, and the meter set to read
resistance (ohms), with the goal being low (near zero) ohms rather than line voltage.
3. Measure the voltage at terminal H. If you now have line voltage, the heater may
be bad (verify with a resistance reading across the heater terminals [same as from
H to R] with power removed). If you still don’t have line voltage, continue.
4. Measure the voltage at the common wire between the two thermostats. If you
now have line voltage, thermostat 2 (frontmost) may be bad (verify with a
resistance reading). If you still don’t have line voltage, continue.
5. Measure the voltage on the opposite (not shared with thermostat 2) terminal of
thermostat 1 (rearmost). This is directly across the power line and you should be
seeing line voltage now. If you’re not, there’s a wiring problem or a problem with
your meter or how you’re using it.
3. Plug in and turn on the 800. With your meter set to A.C. volts, re-check that the R
terminal is not close to 0 VAC. If it now is, the problem may be intermittent and
you’ll have to wait for it to fail to properly troubleshoot (or throw parts at it).
4. Remove the meter’s voltage test lead from the R terminal. Reset the meter to read
D.C. voltage (30V maximum). Connect the meter lead to V++ and ensure it is still
correct. If it isn’t, the problem should be obvious: go to the section on Check
Power Supplies.
5. Move the meter DC voltage lead to the collector of Q2. The voltage should be
under 5 VDC (approximately). If it is much higher than this, take a quick look to
see whether the water tank LED is illuminated. If it is, even very dimly, Q2 has
failed. If it is totally dark, continue to the next step.
6. Move the meter’s lead to the emitter of Q2. If the voltage is higher than about 5
VDC and the water tank illuminator LED is unlit, the LED has failed. If the voltage
is 5 VDC or lower and the LED is unlit, it is likely that Q2 and/or the coil of RL1
have failed (and probably it is Q2), or that Q2 is not being turned on.
7. Measure the base of Q2: it should be about 5V with the unit On. If it is much lower
or 0, Q2 is not being turned on. Move the meter lead to the other side of the
resistor (same as pin 1/P50 of the IC): you should be seeing right about 5 VDC
when the machine is On. If you do not, and you are certain that V++ and V+ are
both OK (check them again), you are the first person in the world to my
knowledge who has a bad IC. You need to replace the circuit board.
8. If Q2 is being turned on but the voltage on the emitter of Q2 is 5VDC or lower and
the water tank LED is unlit, unplug the machine and measure the resistance
across the coil of RL1: it should be roughly 1600Ω, give or take oh say 400Ω or so.
If it is very close to 0Ω, D9 is probably shorted (extremely unlikely—no reports of
this failure yet). If it is very high, the coil of RL1 is open and the relay needs to be
replaced (no reports of this yet).
9. If everything above tests OK, that really only leaves the contacts of RL1. Unplug
the unit and temporarily jumper terminals R to L (this shorts across the contacts
of RL1). Plug the unit in: it should heat up whether it is Off or On. If it does, RL1
needs to be replaced. If it does not, something went wrong in the testing or i made
an error or oversight in these troubleshooting steps (contact me with all your test
results to this point).
Replacing Q2
Selecting a new Q2
There is nothing particularly special about the 2SC945 transistor. Hundreds of other
NPN small-signal transistors can work in this position. All that matters is that the
replacement is a general-purpose wire-lead small-signal NPN transistor meeting or
exceeding the following specifications:
BVceo ≥ 50V
Ic ≥ 100mA (.1A)
PD ≥ 250mW
hfe (beta) average ≈ 200
Get whatever is easy to obtain where you live. In North America, a few of many
options which should be easy to find include:
Since the supply voltage of the 800-series is not more than 27VDC working, probably
BVceo ≥ 35V would be OK, which adds:
BC547B
BC237B
far too many others to list
I did a parameter search at Digi-Key to come up with the part numbers listed above.
I’m sure there are many common legacy standard U.S. 2N-series transistor types which
will work great, but apparently they’re not sold any more (probably because the U.S.
hardly makes anything any more).
Properly specifying/selecting discrete electronic components is outside the scope of
this article. If what you see here is insufficient, please consult your usual technical
sources for further information. Experts can measure the actual current draw of RL1
and likely get away with a lower Ic and PD value, and as long as the transistor is driven
fully into saturation at ambient temperature extremes, it may be possible to get away
with a lower hfe value. Such are the considerations of experienced circuit designers
(and i know at least some of you reading are exactly that).
For this particular application, it is totally OK to go to your local Rat (Radio) Shack or
other convenient local electronic parts store (if such things still exist where you live)
and use whatever they suggest. Places like this tend to sell a line of generic replacement
transistors (NTE or similar). These tend to be overpriced and not always a close enough
match for critical circuits, but for non-critical circuits like this, they should be OK. (I am
not impressed with the 30V BVceo on their recommended NTE 85 replacement for the
2SC945, but even it would probably work.)
Installing a new Q2
During an email exchange with a Breville 800ESXL owner “absolutely new to
electronics repairs” having odd problems with a repair, i realized i’d made a major
omission in the section above: transistors that look identical may be internally
wired differently. This is so basic to those of us in electronics and so obvious to me
that i neglected to mention it (nor is this Breville article intended to be a course on
basic electronic repairs).
Specifically what i mean is that if one is looking at a transistor in a TO-92 or similar
package (like the original 2SC945 in position Q2 in the 800 series machines) with the
flat face facing the viewer and the leads pointing downwards, counting the leads left to
right 1-2-3:
1
2
3
Public domain image courtesy Wikipedia
the lead assignments to the internal elements of the transistor inside the plastic
package differ between different parts. 2S transistors, including 2SC945, were originally
Japanese designs. For reasons i don’t know, they often (not always) prefer the lead
order to be:
Emitter—Collector—Base (ECB)
Americans have always preferred:
Emitter—Base—Collector (EBC)
It is up to You the User to verify the lead arrangement of the replacement
transistor you obtain. Consult the data sheet for whichever new part you obtain, then
compare it to the known ECB order of the original.
Some transistors may be available with different lead arrangements. The KSC945
from ON Semiconductor available (as of September 2019) through Digi-Key is one
example:
KSC945YTA with EBC lead arrangement
KSC945CYTA with ECB lead arrangement (note the C in the part number)
If you want to get a part which you can install exactly as the original with the same
lead wire order, you’ll want to order that second part number (with the C).
The machine turned on, but the heating light kept flashing red. Switching
the knob to espresso resulted in very warm water coming out (as expected,
but less hot). Switching the knob to water/steam didn’t do anything—the
water/steam lights never lit up.
The problem was the contacts to the heater block were slightly corroded
and not making good contact causing them to heat up and worsen the
situation. I cleaned them up and attached them again and it seems to be
working fine for now.
Notice in Anil’s photo how the Quick Connect terminals are discolored from
overheating, to the point where the black insulation has cracked and fallen away,
especially on the red wire terminal. The metal is no longer a shiny to dull aluminum
color, but various shades of brown, chalky gray, and other colors. Any time you have
your espresso machine open, please inspect all terminals for visible overheating
like this—especially these two terminals attached to the heating element in the
thermal block. One nice thing about machines like the Breville 800 is that the metal
case is so thick that even when the wiring catches on fire, it won’t likely start a fire in
Water flow and temperature through the brew head are totally normal
Liquid flow through the steam wand seems normal, but it’s water rather than
steam even though you’re using the Steam setting (not Hot Water)
Site correspondent Mark F. went through all the decalcification cleaning and valve
work described in the sections linked above, with no improvement. He eventually
found success by cleaning the contacts on the microswitch to the left (when facing the
front of the machine) of the flow selector knob, e.g. this one:
When i made my schematic years before ever seeing the official Breville service
manual, i arbitrarily labeled this switch as S2. Breville labels it S1. No matter what the
nomenclature, it’s the switch that bypasses (shorts across) the low temperature
thermostat when in the Steam Wand flow setting. This bypass is what allows the
thermal block to heat to a higher temperature and generate steam.
But what if there is an intermittent connection with this switch? The T/F line will be
open, which is correct for the Steam wand flow position. But the thermostat bypass may
also be open if there is a loose or intermittent connection, inside the microswitch (very
common) or externally to it, on its connection lugs, wires, etc. If you have an ohmmeter
(for most people: a DMM set to its ohmmeter/resistance mode), now’s the time to bust it
out and do some resistance readings across the N and H connections on the circuit
board. Doing this will include all the wiring as well as the microswitch. To test just the
switch itself but not the wiring, instead measure across the NO and C contacts at/on the
switch, with the knob in the steam wand flow position. You should get a consistently
low resistance (under about 5Ω, preferably lower), even when you gently tap on the
body of the microswitch with the handle of a screwdriver or similar, with about the
force of softly knocking on a door. If the resistance suddenly jumps around when
tapping the switch and measuring directly across its contacts, replace or repair the
microswitch. I have a whole other article on this site discussing microswitch
unreliability and even—gasp!—repairs. Most people will replace microswitches rather
than repair them, which is in general a prudent idea, applicable here.
While odds are that it’s the microswitch if you have this particular set of symptoms, it
could be something else. Check the rest of the wiring for intermittent connections,
which may not be visible at all, via standard resistance testing.
Thanks to Mark F. for sharing this useful information!
Caution: removing both side panels at once removes structural integrity for
the center chassis, with the heavy thermal block, pump, etc.! Be sure to
provide a means of support (i used my hand) if you remove both sides at
once!
Standard 1.6mm board pins are a good replacement for the connector for
the LED and switch, should someone else pull theirs off the board. They
make sense for the switch, but the circuit won’t work correctly without the
LED as the voltage at the emitter or Q2 will be too high, so I’d recommend
just unscrewing the LED per your guide. The LED also serves to hold the
emitter voltage low.
I soldered some pins in for the switch connector. Since they are fairly
tall, I bent them 90 degrees and can plug in the connector from the side.
1. Clean the mystery stuff off the back of the board. I did this in an inelegant manner
(an overly strong solvent, not evenly applied). Contributor Doug McNutt provides us a
more elegant solution:
“The coating on the back side of the board interferes with soldering. An overnight
soak in a plate with enough dry isopropyl alcohol to cover the solder side but not
the component side and it was all gone.”
2. Remove the existing solder (maybe… it did not play nice with my solder. I have
old lead-based solder and this device is new enough to maybe have RoHS lead-
free solder).
3. Resolder every joint with good, fresh solder.
4. Carefully reconnect the wiring and plug in the 800ESXL, still disassembled. Test all
functions for correct normal operation before reassembling.
The picture above shows a lot of original grey joints, some partially unsoldered joints
in the top center, and some freshly resoldered shiny joints in the top left.
Whether or not to go to this effort is up to you. I have no clear proof that there was a
problem, yet it sure did not look good, so i resoldered mine.
Looking at it another way: you can always skip the troubleshooting and ASSume that
the parts listed in a given section related to your problem elsewhere on this page also
need replacing in your particular machine. You may well waste time and money
obtaining and changing parts which were perfectly fine, yet if you’re successful, you
may have saved troubleshooting time and even test equipment purchases/loans.
I found the e-replacement website that sells the entire circuit board with
the side boards/switches/buttons. I also called Breville directly and
requested the part, but they have a policy not to sell internal components
to individuals. They did give me the number to a Texas authorized repair
shop: Fort Worth Shaver and Appliance. I called them via 817-335-9970 and
talked to a technician for about 15 minutes. He was very helpful with
telling me about his experience fixing the machines. He sold me the same
part that e-replacement offers for $80 something with shipping included.
Maybe I'll get another year out of this machine, maybe several, but it's been
a fun project and I feel good about it. =)
In terms of the ease/difficulty of doing the board swap, Ian followed up a couple of
weeks later:
I got the new main board/side board/buttons in today. Put them all in and it
worked like it never broke. Easy as cake. Wish it wouldn't have cost me $80
and change, but now you have another fix solution for your website.
In October 2012, site correspondent Dan shared another North American source for
the PCB:
Forum Home Appliance in Vancouver, BC stocks the part for [C]$17.50 plus
about $15.00 for shipping.
When doing link checks on 7 January 2015, i found that the price has increased to
C$49.68, and it is a limited stock item (listed as no longer available as of 20 March 2018).
Have any Breville 800ESXL repair tips? Send ’em in! I’ll endeavor to add the
seemingly good ones to these pages, at my usual glacial pace. (Please let me
know if you want to be credited or remain anonymous. Thanks!)
[1] And another couple of days redoing it as a digital diagram and all the other things related to setting up
this web page. You’re welcome… if you haven’t already (and many of you have… Thanks!), hope you’ll
return the favor to all of us repair types in the future.
[2] Long not sure of the difference, if any, i did a couple of minutes of research, and found an interesting
article claiming that “preventive” is the preferred form. Praise be to the Internet Archive and their
Wayback Machine!
World O’ Appliances/Household/Plumbing/Irrigation/HVAC/Hardware