An Introduction To Semantics
An Introduction To Semantics
Neuro-semantics Nano-semantics
Run
Table
Walk
They will help differentiate this class of objects from similar class of objects. Sum or total
of these properties or features constitute the designatum. In the case of table the
material by which it is made of, size, shape, number of legs, colour etc., may vary.
Only the following properties are shared by all the objects which are called table,
which belong to a class of objects called furniture:
(1) having flat or horizontal top,
(2) standing on one or more legs,
(3) used for putting things on or sitting around.
• These are the criterial features and these features together constitute the
desingnatum of the English word table. Thus we can see that the relation between
word form say English table; through the designatum i.e. the sum of criterial or
contrastive features given above to the denotatum i.e. the class of objects referred
to by the word form constitute the relation of designation.
• Finding out the criterial or contrastive features is the most important aspect of the
study of lexical meaning.
Ogden and Richard's meaning triangle
The relation of designation was explained in the form of a triangle by Ogden and
Richards (The Meaning of Meaning (1923) by Ogden and Richards) which they called
'basic triangle‟
The diagram shows that there is no direct relation between words (symbol) and the
things they stand for (Referent); the word 'symbolizes' a thought or reference which in
its turn 'refers' to the feature or event we are talking about.
• REFERENCE-- indicates the realm of memory where recollections
of past experiences and contexts occur.
• REFERENT-- are the objects that are perceived and that create
the impression stored in the thought area.
• SYMBOL-- is the word that calls up the referent through the
mental processes of the reference.
(Ogden & Richards, pp. 9-12)
This triangle is used here with the labels and terms used by Zgusta (1971,p.34).
Designatum
Expression Denotatum
(form of the word)
REFERENCE DESIGNATUM
--------------------------------------- -------------------------------------
EXPRESSION DENOTATUM
SYMBOL REFERENT
dog
Zgusta(1971,p.34).
Ogden and Richards
2.CONNOTATION
Geoffrey Leech
LEECH'S SEVEN TYPES OF MEANING
INTRODUCTION
• Semantics in the broad sense of the term may be considered to
study 'all that is communicated by language, But some scholars
would like to restrict semantics to the study of logical or
conceptual meaning i.e. only those aspects of meaning which
are logically acceptable leaving out deviation and abnormalities.
Geoffrey Leech (1981, Ch.2. p.9-23) in his book semantics
breaks down 'meaning' in its widest sense into seven
different types giving primary importance to logical or
conceptual meaning.
The seven other types are
(1)Logical or Conceptual meaning
(2) Connotative meaning
(3) Social meaning
(4) Affective meaning
(5) Reflected meaning
(6) Collocative meaning and
(7) Thematic meaning (Leech, Semantics -1981, p-23).
Here Leech discusses meaning as a whole both sentential meaning and
word meaning.
• For example, the meaning of the English word woman can be specified
as consisting of the semantic features
+ HUMAN, -MALE, +ADULT.
• This word is differentiated from the word man having the features
+HUMAN, +MALE, and +ADULT and the word boy having the features
+HUMAN, +MALE, and -ADULT.
The contrastive features of conceptual meaning are the same as what
Zgusta (1971, p.27 -29) calls as criterial features which constitute the
designatum of lexical meaning.
• 2.CONNOTATIVE MEANING
• From this we infer that the three properties 'human', 'adult', and
'female' must provide the criterion of the correct use of that word. These
contrastive features in real world terms become attribute of the referent
or denotatum.
• This means that all persons to whom the word, 'woman' is used to refer
to will have the properties 'human', 'adult', 'female'.
• But the referent of the word woman will have a large number of
additional non-criterial properties, which the users of the word woman
expect a referent of woman to possess.
• Such properties include:
• physical characteristics (having two legs, having a womb
etc.,)psychological and sociological properties (having motherly
character, soft nature etc.,). Such properties constitute the
connotative meaning.
• As described above some of these properties are typical of a woman.
There are other assumed properties or attributed properties due to the
view point adopted by an individual or a group of people or a
whole society.
• For example,
girl boy
boy man
woman car
flower vessel
language use.
MEANING
Structuralism
• The Definition of sense
• Sense refers to the inherent(natural) meaning of
the linguistic form; it is concerned only with
intra-linguistic relations. It is the collection
of all the semantic features of the linguistic
form; it is abstract and de-contextualized(In
general)
• What is the sense?
41
Sense and Denotation
• A lexeme which is related to other lexemes is related to
them in sense; and that a lexeme which is related to the
outside world is related by means of denotation .
For example „cow‟ denotes a class of entities which
is a proper subclass of entities denoted by animals ;
which differ from the class of entities denote by „bull‟ or
horse; which intersects with the class denoted by calf and
so on. (Lyons, 1981, p.152)
• Lexical meaning is derived from thousands
of sentences in which they are used by
thousands of speakers of the particular
language. This also has to account for the
future use of these words in newer contexts,
based on the productivity of language (see
Hockett, 1970 (1958) p.575).
Reference and sense
Lexical semantics
Lexical meaning from two point of view :
Lyons theory of sense or sense relations is based on the extension of Ferdinand de Saussure„s
structuralist approach to semantics
• Reference and sense are two complementary aspects of
lexical meaning. In other words , study of either referential
meaning or the sense relation of words alone will make
semantic description incomplete.
synonymy
multiple meaning
W1 W1 W2 W3 W4
M1 M2 M3 M4 M1
The first category is referred to as multiple meaning and the second synonymy.
The broad category of multiple meaning in which a single word form is related to one or
more meanings.
52
English:
crane 1.a kind of bird (common heron) 1.The first category in
2.a machine for raising heavy weight which the meanings of a
single word form are
relatable or similar is
called polysemy.
bank 1.a financial institution
2.sides of a river
2.The second category in
which the meanings are
not similar or unrelated
is called homonymy.
Tamil:
kaal 1.human/ animal body part
2.lower bearing part of the furniture like chair, table, bench, etc.,
3.post or pole on which a shed is erected.
paTi
1.read a book or study a subject
2.an instrument for measuring grains, milk etc.
53
3.the steps of a building, staircase etc.,
• But when we observe the two meanings of the English word form bank
and the three meanings of the Tamil word form paTi, they have no
such similarity between them.
• They are totally unrelated and in the case of Tamil word paTi, the first
meaning is an action in contrast to the other two, which are
objects or things.
The English word crane and Tamil word kaal are polysemous. The
English word bank and Tamil word paTi are homonymous.
Polysemy is considered as a case of one word having a number
of meanings.
Homonymy is considered as a case of different words :having
identical forms.
On this basis in dictionaries polysemous words are presented as
a single 'entry' or 'aritcles' continuously. 54
• Homonymous words are given as different entries or articles one
below other with superscript numerals
• (e.g.)
bank l,
bank 2
and
pati l,
pati 2,
pati 3,
where as English crane and Tamil kaal there will be only one entry
each and their meanings will be listed one after another.
55
Homonymy
Homonymy is the case of a single word form
having a number of meanings, which are not
relatable .
Polysemy
single word form having a number of
relatable or similar meanings which is
called polysemy
Polysemy
Meaning 1
Meaning 2
Meaning 3
Meaning 4
Meaning 5
Two or more words if they are substitutable at least in one context without
meaning difference, then they are synonymous.
• A, B are synonyms A means B, B means A
• Take two sentences, S1 and S2, which differ only in one word – x is
substituted by y. If S1 and S2 are identical in meaning, then x and y are strict
synonyms in that context.
Paradigmatic sense relations:
Binary opposition
Binary opposition
• Binary opposition is of the most important paradigmatic sense
relations governing the semantics structure of language .
• In earlier on semantics it was called oppositeness of meaning
or antonymy. They are used more or less equivalently for
various kinds of binary contrast or contrast between two
lexemes.
• People generally think that binary opposite extreme from
identity of meaning; but it‟s not true. Opposites are drawn along
some dimensions of similarity.
• 1.this is big house
• 2. this is small house
John Lyons: Binary opposites are divided into four types. The
four types can be primarily classified into
1.gradable opposites and
2.ungradables.
This is on the basis whether the sets of opposites have the
feature of gradability or not. Gradability or grading means that
two object can be compared with reference to some quality
and can be placed in scale showing degrees of comparison.
Fore example the English
I. Gradable opposites big and small can be used to compare and arrange
object in a scale as follow.
En.
1. A big house
2. A little big house
3. Very big house
4. Very very big house
5. A small house
6. A little small house
7. Very small house
8. Very very small house
These gradable opposite are called antonyms by John Lyons
• II. All other opposites are ungraddable and belong to three subtypes called
1.complementaries,
2.converses and
3.directional opposites.
• The set of opposites belonging to these three subclasses cannot be graded or
will not involve comparison. For example ,in English day and night are
comlementaries.
• We cannot grade them. We cannot say ,
little day’,
very day ,
little night ,
very night,
very very night.
• Among the ungradable opposites complementaries divide a semantic domain
or field into parts.
• Paradigmatic sense relations:
Non- Binary contrast or incompatibility
• When semantically related lexemes show contrast between more
than two lexemes than its is called non- binary contrast.
• The relationship between lexemes or words included in sets such as
colour terms, names of flower , days of a week, months of a year , etc
are many member sets of incompatibility.
• “ the relationship of sense which holds between the lexemes in many
member sets (Sunday , Monday .. Saturday) ”
• Identity test for incompatibility
• If they differ only in that where s1 has the lexical item x and
the others have y, z, etc ., then ,x and y, z etc., are
incompatibles .
• This is blue shirt it implicitly denies this sentences
1. This is a white shirt
2. This is a red shirt
3. This is a green shirt
4. This is an yellow shirt etc.,
the sentence (1) again explicitly implies
1. This is not a red shirt
2. This is not a green shirt
3. This is not an yellow shirt etc.,
O
B
Point of origin or root
F labeled with O
A E Two branches are shown
from the point of origin :
C broken lines are drawn to
D show further branches on
H the tree .
I J Here C and D are the
G hyponyms of A ; E and F are
the hyponyms of B . G, h
are the hyponyms of C and
L I, J are the hyponyms of D .
K But G and H are not the
immediate hyponyms of A .
• Theory of semantics and semantic fields heavily influenced by de Saussure’s
structuralism and German idealism
• Origins: ideas of Wilhelm von Humboldt and Johann Gottfried Herder in the mid
19th first proposed by German and Swiss linguist. in the 20s and 30s of the 20th
Century
1. Jost Trier in the 1930s,
2. Stephen Ullmann 1960s,
3. John Lyons in the 1970s
4. Eva Kittay in the 1980s
5. Charles J. Fillmore in the 1990s
6. Porzig, Weisgerber
7. Adrienne J. Lehrer
8. K.Balasubramanian
9. S.Rajendran
ந
ன்
றி
Sithantha irattinam
Dr.Sundarabalu.S
Department of Linguistics
BharathiarUniversity,Coimbatore-46
[email protected]
9715769995 3/14/2022