5842-20441-4-DR
5842-20441-4-DR
5842-20441-4-DR
EDUCATION
Proceedings of the International Scientific Conference. Volume II, May 24th, 2024. 91-101
Abstract: The article was prepared within preparatory phase of research on impact of
Feuerstein Instrumental Enrichment (FIE) on self-concept of learners with behavioural
problems. Its goal is to reveal the current state in research field concerning this topic in the
Czech Republic. The programme FIE has been used in the Czech Republic since 1999, mostly
for learners with special educational needs. The theoretical and research sources mostly
describe the impact of FIE on the development and change of cognitive structures, the
development of the art of learning and thinking (metacognition). Moreover, as one of the
secondary objectives is also mentioned the restoration of a positive self-concept of the learners,
precisely in compliance with the criteria of the mediated learning experience, e.g. by increasing
the sense of competence of the learners and by learning to regulate their own behaviour. Thus,
it influences the formation of healthy self-concept, self-confidence and self-acceptance of
individuals participating in FIE. Generally stated, people who have a negative self-concept
and/or low self-confidence are more likely to exhibit problem behaviour, whether in the family,
school or wider social environment.
In the Czech provenance, we found three studies that primarily address the impact of FIE on
learners with behavioural problems - first on learners with serious behavioural problems living
in residential educational institutions, second on learners with ADHD and third on children
with problem behaviour. We managed to find four studies that partially aim to determine the
level of self-concept/confidence/self-esteem/self-acceptance of FIE attendees. Five studies then
report on the effect of FIO on self-concept/self-confidence/self-esteem/self-acceptance and six
other studies present the impact of FIO on behaviour change of attendees (mentioned mostly
as a side effect because the studies primarily did not address these aims).
Keywords: behavioural problems, Feuerstein Instrumental Enrichment, study search.
Introduction
The goal of the search study was to reveal the current state in research field
concerning the impact of FIE method on self-concept of its attendees in the Czech
Republic to prepare the basis for planned further research. In schools, quite a lot
of energy is devoted to dealing with problem behaviour of learners. School
counselling workers, and also counselling workers from external counselling
facilities search for appropriate solutions on a daily basis. Learners with problems
in behaviour may have a distorted self-concept (self-esteem), which can make the
situation even worse. We suspect that Feuerstein Instrumental Enrichment (FIE)
method may be a potential tool that can be used in such cases. FIE method has
been used mostly for the development of cognitive functions of children, pupils
and students with special educational needs (underachievers), but also for children
and adults without any significant difficulties to develop their metacognition.
But FIE method has also been reported to have a positive impact on the self-
esteem and sense of competence of its attendees, potentially leading to the
restoration of their positive self-concept that may be distorted (partially negative
or negative). We intended to reveal if some studies already confirmed this impact
and also to gain some inspiration for our further research.
Literature Review
92
SOCIETY. INTEGRATION. EDUCATION
Proceedings of the International Scientific Conference. Volume II, May 24th, 2024. 91-101
their inner experiencing and quality of life. We should never see problem
behaviour as given; we should talk about the individuals who have the problem,
not the problem individuals. We need to separate the negative manifestations
of the individuals’ behaviour from the individuals themselves. This brings us to
the question of individuals’ value orientation, self-assessment, self-esteem and
overall self-concept. When working with such an individual (in attempts to help
him/her), we should be based on his/her self-reflection (Pokorná, 2004).
All of above mentioned leads us to seek for a tool that has an impact on the self-
esteem (self-concept) of its users and FIE method was reported to have such
an effect on its attendees.
FIE represents method of cognitive education that as opposite to content
education focuses on development of cognitive abilities of persons and it is
founded on several theoretical pillars such as (deficient) cognitive functions,
cognitive map, the theory of structural cognitive modifiability and mediated
learning experience. Feuerstein understood cognitive functions (thinking skills) to
be prerequisites to operational, internalized representational thinking. He grouped
them and their deficient versions according to three phases of thinking to level
of input (taking in stimuli), level of elaboration (thinking through the problem),
and level of output (communicating a response). The deficit cognitive functions
at the input level cause difficulties in collecting data prior to solving the task,
at the elaboration level deficit functions hinder effective use of data, and at the
output level they limit adequate communication of task results. (Harth, 1982) The
concept of the cognitive map explains how the structure of human cognitive
functions is organised. The cognitive map enables the description of human
cognitive processes (thinking and acting) on the basis of seven parameters
(content, modality, operation, phase, level of complexity, level of abstraction and
level of difficulty) and, it facilitates the preparation of content, structure,
materials, etc. for the instrumental enrichment method. (Pokorná, 2004; Málková,
2008; Lucká & Chadimová, 2019)
The theory of structural cognitive modifiability can be explained briefly in
simple terms as a belief in the enduring potential of humans to develop and to
change throughout life, and its neurobiological basis is the neuroplasticity
(the process of brain development, which is modelled by both internal and
external aspects, i.e. the environment). Cognitive functions of a person do not
develop only by person’s own experience or contact with stimuli (the surrounding
world, environment), but also in connection with the so-called mediated learning
experience, in which the mediator - the adult (parent, grandparent, teacher, ...)
plays an important role. The mediator stands between the child and the stimuli
and transmits/mediates them to the child on the basis of his/her own experience
with them in order to ensure that the child perceives, understands and integrates
them in a meaningful way. The learning situations can be considered mediated
learning experiences only if they meet certain criteria. Three criteria are essential:
93
Jeřábková, 2024. Potential Impact of Feuerstein Instrumental Enrichment on Self-Concept of
Learners with Behavioural Problems
Methodology
94
SOCIETY. INTEGRATION. EDUCATION
Proceedings of the International Scientific Conference. Volume II, May 24th, 2024. 91-101
Results
1
Meaning FIE method.
95
Jeřábková, 2024. Potential Impact of Feuerstein Instrumental Enrichment on Self-Concept of
Learners with Behavioural Problems
(Hutyrová et al., 2014, 1027). Second, it is inspiring in terms of the used method
of data collection because one of the used tools was Questionnaire on children's
self-perception of school success - SPAS (the questionnaire that provides
information on the children’s approach to his/her own school performance) that
might be used in our study alongside other tools when determining the
self-concept of FIE method attendees. And the third reason is the character
of research approach of this study. It was planned to collect the data from over
400 individuals meaning that the results could be more representative than those
of most other studies we found (mostly qualitative or mixed research design with
low numbers of participants).
The second study from this group was presented in master thesis by
Z. Tihelková. This study was aimed at learners with attention deficit hyperactivity
disorder (ADHD). The study was qualitative in its nature, it was conducted
on 2 pupils at the age of 7 and 8 that participated in FIE method over seven months
and for the whole time they were being observed and their tasks were analysed.
The author set 4 goals – how the FIE method impacts pupils’ development
of communication, concentration of attention, impulsivity and working
autonomy. According to the results of this study pupils positively changed in all
above mentioned aspects, concerning the behaviour they were more likely to
regulate their behaviour while working on the task. (Tihelková, 2016)
M. Bořkovcová was in her study interested in the potential effect of her own
method “Children together” (based strictly on principles of FIE method)
on collecting diagnostic data on learners with behavioural problems and
behavioural disorders. The author used action research method – precisely
analyses of observations, audio-recordings, pupils’ works and interviews.
The results show that the method can be used to collect diagnostic data about
pupils’ problems in behaviour, self-regulation, ability to deal with conflicts, social
recognition and self-reflection. The advantage of the method “children together”
is according to the results of the study also in its potential to be used
as intervention method for individuals with problems in behaviour (Bořkovcová,
2017).
The second group of studies – those that partially aimed to determine the
level of self-concept/confidence/self-esteem/self-acceptance of FIE method
attendees – is represented by the study described in doctoral dissertation
of H. Burešová. The author primarily targeted at the development of reading
strategies in individuals with dyslexia while using teaching material based on
principles of FIE method. The quantitative part of study examined the change in
the self-concept concerning school success of learners with dyslexia. The author
used Questionnaire on children's self-perception of school success (SPAS) and
Questionnaire Myself as a learner (MALS) in pre- and post- intervention phase.
The results of this quantitative part of study did not show any significant
difference in learners’ self-concept concerning school success which might be
96
SOCIETY. INTEGRATION. EDUCATION
Proceedings of the International Scientific Conference. Volume II, May 24th, 2024. 91-101
97
Jeřábková, 2024. Potential Impact of Feuerstein Instrumental Enrichment on Self-Concept of
Learners with Behavioural Problems
The third group consists of five studies mentioning the effect of FIE method
on self-concept/self-confidence/self-esteem/self-acceptance of FIE attendees.
A. Schmaltzová’s qualitative study targeted at the effect of FIE method on
pre-school children with communication disorders. In this study, among others,
improved self-esteem, reduced impulsivity and increased attention, were observed
in all attendees (Schmaltzová, 2015). The main goal of J. Suchánek’s study was
to describe possibilities to implement FIE method into school curriculum.
His participants – lecturers of FIE method – reported influence on learning,
behaviour, attention and self-concept, specifically on raise of self-esteem, respect
to others, development of empathy and prevention of drop-outs (Suchánek, 2020).
The study of V. Jašková during which were observed changes in learners with
different special educational needs attending FIE method and at the same time
using principle of mediated learning experience throughout the whole school
instruction lasted over three years. Within the in-depth description of changes in
each of participants were also mentioned the raise of self-esteem and reduction
of aggression (reported by parents), development of self-confidence (reported by
teachers) and significant progress in the ability to assess oneself leading
to increasing healthy self-esteem (based on long-term observations) (Jašková,
2020). V. Beranová conducted a qualitative study with 5 special education
teachers that were trained in FIE method and used it while working with pupils
with different special educational needs. Participants were asked about their
motivation to choose FIE method, experience when being trained and practical
experience with its use. The participants most often agreed on following
advantages of FIE method: calming down attendees, developing of independence
and planning skills. Some of the participants also mentioned effect on self-esteem
of FIE attendees. (Beranová, 2022) Also 5 lecturers od FIE method that
participated in B. Grisníková’s study agreed on the positive effect of method on
self-esteem of its attendees (Grisníková, 2015).
The last group of studies mentions some impact of FIE method on behaviour
of its attendees (different ages, different characteristics) as side effect of the
research. Reading the results of these studies we conclude that the behaviour
of FIE method attendees has changed in pro-group/pro-social direction. The
authors mostly mentioned: greater respect and tolerance to others in the group
(Foltýnová Nešporová, 2022; Baštová, 2019; Křížková, et al. 2018), increased
willingness to listen to others in the group (Foltýnová Nešporová, 2022; Fišarová,
2013; Klausová, 2019; Křížková et al., 2018), improvement in cooperation with
others (Foltýnová Nešporová, 2022; Mikošková, 2017) and V. Baštová added
development of empathy (Baštová, 2019). Moreover, the authors indicated
reduction of impulsivity while working on task but interestingly also in
connection with group communication – FIE method attendees controlled more
effectively their need of self-promotion (Foltýnová Nešporová, 2022; Mikošková,
2017; Klausová, 2019; Křížková, Pecharová, Váňová, Žišková & Vysopal, 2018).
98
SOCIETY. INTEGRATION. EDUCATION
Proceedings of the International Scientific Conference. Volume II, May 24th, 2024. 91-101
Conclusions
We have found studies that focus on the impact of the FIE method on
individuals with problems in behaviour. However, only one of these studies has
partially focused on uncovering the possible impact on the self-concept of this
target group. Unfortunately, we were unable to locate any source describing the
results of this study. Before starting the next phase of our research, we will try
again to track down these results so that, if nothing else, we can at least compare
them with the results of our planned study.
Some studies examining the effect of the FIE method describe impact on
either self-concept (self-esteem) or behaviour of its attendees (or on both of them).
Yet, the results of these studies diverge. This may be due to the use of
a particularly qualitative or mixed research design in these studies with
a relatively limited number of participants. So that the results cannot be
generalised and are valid only for the specific target group of each of these studies.
To conclude, just as the participants are diverse, so are the results.
We did not find any study that purely dealt with the self-concept of FIE
method attendees, and certainly not in the context of individuals with problems in
behaviour. This supports our belief that the planned research is original, of high
importance and may yield important insights regarding the impact of the FIE
method on its attendees' self-concept, particularly those with problems in
behaviour.
References
99
Jeřábková, 2024. Potential Impact of Feuerstein Instrumental Enrichment on Self-Concept of
Learners with Behavioural Problems
100
SOCIETY. INTEGRATION. EDUCATION
Proceedings of the International Scientific Conference. Volume II, May 24th, 2024. 91-101
101