Some Guidelines For Design and Construct
Some Guidelines For Design and Construct
system
W.A. Weerasooriya, Dept. of Library and Information Science, University of Kelaniya, Sri
Lanka, E-mail:- [email protected] Qualifications: - BA (Hons) Kelaniya; M.Lib.Sc.
Panjab; PhD. Pune
Abstract
Library classification is a system which could classify both printed and non-printed
sources in a library or information center with the prime intension of organizing those
sources in a most helpful order to assist library users and library staff to find and to locate
them efficiently and effectively. The intension of this paper is to study the different steps
an editorial committee of a library classification system has the responsibility and the
study are:
Since a library classification is a scientific based system, one who prefers or the
different concepts, principles, theories, techniques related to the process. This article
discusses the classification policy, types of library classification, and three planes of
work, notational system and models, characteristic of divisions, prescription, main parts
and the steps for construction of different parts of a library classification system.
1
Keywords: Library classification; Classification theory; Classificationist; Notation;
Facet analysis; Helpful sequence
Introduction
Knowledge is growing very fast. In library science context, the fact that accumulation of
knowledge in the forms of subjects is highly taken into consideration. The subjects are
one kind of groups that accrue knowledge for learning, teaching, education, research,
perception, argumentation, evidence and experimental purposes. Therefore the term and
context of the subject provide enormous help for theorists and practioners in library
classification. Before library classification, it is better to define what the subject is. “It is.
an organized or systematized body of ideas whose extension and intension are likely to
fall coherently within the field of interest and comfortably within the intellectual
remained upon on the classificatory order of the subjects. The purpose of library
according to their likeness and unlikeness. Those like materials or contents are placed
together while the unlike things are separated”. According to chronological development
of library classification, the word classification has been used in three terms. They are
library classification, book classification and the subject classification which indicate the
same meaning. On the other hand, library classifications are two types i.e. general and
2
special classification. General classification means a system which covers whole subjects
or universe of subjects, while special classification deals with only one subject e.g.
involves sound planning and plan implementation. Any knowledgeable person can
commence the process but, its success totally depends upon a cooperative venture. Even
though, Melvil Dewey founded the Dewey Decimal Classification (DDC) in 1876, the
editorial history of DDC (Dewey, 1996) shows that complete success and development is
The term ‘Classificationist (Maltby, 1975) indicates one who found a classification
system, while who applies the system is called the ‘Classifier’ (Satija, 2004). The
editorial committee brings the success and development of the above classification
3
systems. The important point here is the classification policy maintained by the editorial
policy. This policy covers the step by step approach of design, construction and
classification. They are History, Introduction and Instruction part, Tables, List of Main
Classes, Schedules (Divisions and Sub-divisions), Generalia Class, Notation, and the
Index. Both enumerative classification and faceted classification are generally comprised
which lists all possible class numbers whereas faceted classification is preoccupied with a
sound mechanism for building class numbers. Enumerative scheme is a ready made
system and it has built class numbers for subjects. In faceted scheme, the user, client or
the librarian has to follow a set procedure and has to work out for class numbers. Next is
the discussion of guidelines for design and construction of a library classification system.
If an individual plans to design, he or she should decide who would take the ultimate
future plans viz. design, construction, development and maintenance and how to involve
with the step by step approach. If the editorial committee takes the full responsibility, it
4
As discussed, the other step is the selection of the type of classification. Individual or
editorial committee has to pre-plan and decide to work out either general or special
UNESCO, WHO, WTO, UNIDO, FAO, it is better to use a special classification system
collection. The criteria for this specially designed classification system for the
Subject coverage
There are three kinds of subjects’ i.e. simple subject, compound subject and the complex
subject. Classification system should have the capability to accommodate these three
5
Compound subject means one subject containing two or more consecutive and relative
different subjects or non-relative subjects at a time. When two or more subjects are
combined together, it leads to a complex subject viz. Physics and Chemistry; Economics
treatment of bone diseases. Following illustration denotes the idea of a complex subject.
the general subject viz. Economics, Sociology, Chemistry, while depth subjects are
6
2. Depth subject Investment Abortion Proteins
system. The classificationist must know the extension and intention of a subject. The
extension is the width or surface of the subject. The extension of the subject of economics
is the totality or the whole subject areas of economics from beginning to the end. In other
words, all subjects belong to economics are an example for the extension of the subject
economics. The intension indicates one depth subject point in a subject. In this context,
“Rural credit” is an example for the intension of the subject of economics. Intension
specifies the depth of the subject. Moreover, the classificationist should know what are
subjects and the subject coverage, definitions, terms, concepts, history, modern trends
and the developments of the relevant subjects. For this purpose, it is necessary to collect
data and literature of the subjects or the subject areas. He or she will have to collect and
refer general and special encyclopedias, dictionaries, basic books, handbooks, manuals,
7
Next step is to collect the subjects, followed by the designing the list of main classes. The
collection of subjects and idea of a list of main classes and the design of list of Tables are
Tables in library classification consist of all types of subject forms. Column three of
Table 02 shows the generation of different subject forms of a subject or subjects. These
subject forms appeared in Table 02 could be categorized into total 8 Tables. Eight Tables
8
are Concept, Source, Space, Time, Language, Community group, Literary form and the
Equipment and materials. Construction of schedules is very clearly shown in the first
column of the Table 02. Generation of different subjects are illustrated in the first column
of Table 02 and the design of main classes and depth schedules could be done based on
the idea of constructing a general or special classification scheme.
Construction of Tables
Individual table should be designed on the basis of subject forms and their variations.
Idea of construction of tables is fully described in the Table 02. Table 02 indicates the
forms of subjects and how to name each table on the basis of internal and external
phenomenon which is implanted in each subject form. Name given to each table is
decided on the basis of the phenomenon illustrated in the individual table i.e. Time,
9
Designing the main class list
Main class forms the first and mutually exclusive and exhaustive array of the division of
knowledge in classification (Satija, 2004). A main class is a one unit that divides the
whole universal knowledge or a branch of it which each unit has its own name, content
and value. Main class is a part of whole knowledge that divides or groups the same
universe of knowledge into few general categories based on the principle of helpful
sequence. Helpful sequence indicates that subjects are grouped based on the mutual
relationship (Krishan Kumar, 1988) among those subjects. Relative concepts and ideas
coined in different subjects help for grouping those subjects into subject bundles and
these subject bundles are called main classes. One subject bundle contains specific
subjects which include similar subjects. ‘Facet’ (Ranganathan, 1989) was used as a term
to denote the subject bundle. The above Table 02 shows the process of how subject
bundles are formed. The arrangement of main classes in the main class list should be
done on the basis of the helpful sequence. Helpful sequence is the arrangement of
documents according to their likeness and unlikeness. The like materials are put together
while unlike ones are placed according to their content and demand. For this purpose,
subjects which are mutually related are brought together, while the other contrasting
subjects are positioned in their relevant places in library classification systems. Therefore
helpful sequence should be preserved firstly in a library classification system i.e. in its
main classes, subdivisions and in the whole schedule. This will directly aid for preserving
the helpful sequence of both library shelves and the classified catalogue. The rationale of
10
helpful sequence in main classes connotes that similar main classes are put together while
unlike main classes are separated and arranged in their constituent positions. There are
two types of modules when these main classes are arranged in the main class list. Two
000-Generalities 0-Generalities
100-Philosophy 1-Philosophy
200-Religion 2-Religion
300-Social Sciences 3-Social Sciences
400-Language 4-Relocated to 8 Interpolation (possible)
500-Natural Sciences 5-Natural Sciences
600-Applied sciences 6-Applied sciences
700-The Arts 7-The Arts
800-Literature 8-Language and literature
900-Geography and history 9-Geography.biography.history
11
impossible Extrapolation (impossible)
In DDC, above the 000 and below 900, outer- insertion (extrapolation) of any new main
class is impossible owing to the fact that finite order of main classes. This situation is
prevailed in UDC too. But in CC, both outer- insertion (extrapolation) and in-insertion
(interpolation) are sharply possible due to the flexible and non-finite order of main
classes.
12
Order of Main classes
As discussed above, the order of main classes in the main class list should be made on the
basis of helpful sequence. The DDC violates this principle (Figure 02) and it separates
the related or similar subjects viz. Language and Literature and further dislocates
Geography, History from Social Sciences. But the UDC sticks to this principle (Figure
The list of main classes can be arranged according to the principle of helpful sequence
which is illustrated below in Figure 03. It is better to compare the list of main classes of
DDC (Figure 02) with the following modified list (Figure 03).
000-Generalities
(Generalia) Group 1-Generalities
100-Philosophy
Group 2-Humanities (One subject bundle)
200-Religion
300-Language
400-Literature
500-The Arts 13
600- Social Sciences Group 3-Social Sciences
700- Geography and (One subject bundle)
History
Applied Sciences
800-Natural Sciences Group 4-Natural and Applied Sciences
900-Applied Sciences (Two subject bundles)
The helpful sequence should be preserved in ordering subjects in the schedule too, which
is discussed below.
list. In other words, the list of main classes is a summary of schedule, while its
descriptive or explanatory part is the schedule. The lengthiest part of any classification
system is the schedule. Under each main class, it should state the subdivisions.
Subdivisions here indicate the constituent subjects of a main class and their relative
subdivisions, sub-subdivisions, notation for each subject and their subdivisions and
micro level subjects, certain instructions and guidelines for classification, example
developed in two ways. One is to develop it, in single scheduling system and the other is
classes are developed as separate schedules. DDC follows single scheduling system,
14
Generalia class is an area which composes subjects and documents that contain
knowledge common to other subjects and disciplines. There are certain subjects and
documents which commonly apply to all other subjects viz. computer science, library
science, research methods, general knowledge and intelligence and the documents viz.
is rather rigid to classify these subjects and documents into mass disciplines like social
classify them in a new mass discipline which is called generalia class or generalities in
any classification.
000-Generalities
010-Bibliography
020-Library and Information Science
030-General encyclopedia
040- …
050-General serial publications
060-General organization and museology
070-New media, journalism, publishing
080-General collections
090-Manuscripts and rare books
Notation is the translation of subjects or subject forms into a code system in the form of
symbols, numerals, and letters of alphabets, punctuation marks, digits or any linguistic or
scientific codes. Notation is the symbols or marks or code numbers used to represent the
15
subjects or their forms in a classification system mainly in schedules, moderately in
implies the use of only one type of symbol i.e. only Arabic numerals while mixed
notation connotes the use of several types of symbol i.e. numerals, letters, and
1. Brevity
2. Simplicity
3. Extendability
4. Expressiveness
5. Flexibility
6. Hospitality
Brevity indicates that notation should be brief as much as possible preserving the context
of the subject. Simplicity means that notation or class number must be quickly
understandable and legible to the reader or user. If a notation or class number has the
power to extend more of its numbers, it denotes the quality of extendibility. If any class
number has a facility to accommodate more numbers at the end of the class number as
additional portion, it is the extendibility. Expressiveness of notation illustrates the ability
to show individual roles of each constituent part of a class number. If a class number has
the ability to change its positions, or alter any location, it is called the flexibility.
Hospitality is identified as the power of notation or a class number to accommodate new
numbers or newly emerging subjects. It is better to maintain two values in notation, when
and where necessary. They are hierarchical and mnemonics values (Figure 04 and 05).
Hierarchical value or order means the preservation of relationship of constituent parts of
16
a subject or showing structural order of a subject. Mnemonic value means the ability to
memorize or to keep in mind the relevant class number or numbers. Both values are
illustrated in Figure 04 and Figure 05.
891.48-Sinhala Literature
891.481-Sinhala poetry
891.482-Sinhala drama
891.483-Sinhala fiction
891.484-Sinhala essays
891.485-Sinhala speeches
891.486-Sinhala letters
891.487-Sinhala humour and satire
891.488-Sinhala miscellaneous writings
17
Selection of a model of classification
Basically, there are two types of model of classification systems. Faceted/Analytico-
system that provides a high-quality mechanism for constructing class numbers for
number for a subject that system is called faceted model (Whitrow, 1983). Here role of
the classifier is to apply various techniques for building class numbers. Colon
Application of five fundamental categories viz. Personality; Matter; Enery; Space and
Time to analyze the subject into these facets and to synthesize them into focal numbers is
the unique process of Colon Classification which is also called the Analytico-Synthetic
preparing class numbers, while the enumerative system possesses the built class numbers.
Enumerative classification is a system which accumulates all possible class numbers and
here the role of the classifier is to find class number from the enumerative classification
mechanism like faceted system instead it tries to provide all possible built numbers in the
the classification system, while the enumerative system follows the ‘top-down
classification starts when preparing class numbers and in other terms the system is being
built when making class numbers. Top-down approach purports that the construction of
the classification system starts before preparing class numbers. In top down approach, the
18
arrangement of list of main class begins at first, so that preparation of classification
down approach belongs to ‘priori’ system. These two approaches are illustrated through
000-Generalities (Generalia)
100-Philosophy
200-Religion
300-Social Sciences
400-Language
500-Natural Sciences
600-Applied Sciences
700-The Arts
800-Literature
900-Geography and history
E M P S T
Title of the document:- Classification of maps in college libraries in India in 2007
19
Process of Facet analysis
P M E S T
Class number for the above Title:- 233;17:51.44 ‘P07
Notation
Citation order of the class number: - Subject, Sex, Colour, Age, Material, Country, Type.
A title: - Read smart silk socks for girls aged 10: - Class number: - SFRe(4)SiSm
Characteristic of division
required when preparing classes and divisions in schedules, and generating tables.
20
Characteristic of division
Prescription
Classificationist or the editorial committee has to develop, maintain and revise or to add
new items or the different items in the prescription when and where necessary. The items
in the prescription could be used when designing and constructing a classification system.
The whole work of a classification system could be categorized into three planes, viz.
idea, verbal, and notational plane. When a person or an editorial committee is ready to
work out for a classification, the first step is the planning stage. Firstly, he or she has to
think and sharply contemplate about the classification system which is going to be
prepared. Therefore, idea plane involves the type and model of classification system,
how to design the list of main class and subdivisions and how to start the work of
different parts of the system. Idea plane chiefly deals with the thinking stage of design
and the idea of universe of subjects, how they are arranged, categories, subject
relationship etc. Idea plane is the mental stage. Verbal plane involves how to adopt and
use the best terminology in the classification system. How to put the subject concepts to
21
more useful, current and opportune demanded terms or subjects or terminology is focused
in verbal plane. The verbal plane is the linguistic stage. The rationale behind the
representing the term or subjects in the system. Notational plane is the codifying stage.
There is a cyclical process in three planes of work. On the other hand, three planes of
work are visible in the classification process too. It is illustrated Figure 08.
There should be seven major components in a classification system. They are mentioned
following components in the system. Except History, introduction and instruction part
and the Index, other parts are exclusively discussed in the above paragraphs. These two
particular parts are compiled after the work of the other main parts from Table to
Notation is over.
22
History, introduction and instruction part does not contain any design. It is a mere
narration of how the historical development of the scheme takes place and the overall
introduction of the system. There must be instruction on how to make class numbers with
sharp examples when and where necessary. Index needs some design and must be pre-
planned. Index is a list of terms, names, topics and concepts arranged mostly
alphabetically, along with their class numbers or item numbers where they are placed.
Indexes are two types. They are direct and indirect or relative. Examples of both indexes
are given below. Direct index does not show the subject relationship. It only arranges a
list of subjects, terms and topics on alphabetical order. Conversely, the relative index
shows the subject relationship. While arranging subject, terms and topics on alphabetical
order, the relative index tries to show different hierarchical and symmetrical relationships
of a subject. The subject ‘women’ in Figure 09 demonstrates its different subject
relationships.
23
------------------
.
Poly subject relationship
It is better to examine how a general classification is composed its different parts or
components. Table 03 gives you an idea about what are the principal parts and how they
are organized in DDC 21st edition.
Conclusion
system. Most of all steps in the design and construction process are included and the
exposition of the major parts of a classification system along with the guidelines helps the
24
References
Ranganathan, S.R. 1990. Prolegomena to library classification 3rd ed., Asia Publishing,
Bombay, 82.
Dewey, Melvil 1996. Dewey Decimal Classification and relative index 21st ed., Forest
Press, New York, lxix.
Satija, M.P. 2004. Exercises in the 22nd edition of the Dewey Decimal Classification, Ess
Ess, New Delhi, 16.
Satija, M.P. 2004. A dictionary of knowledge organization, Guru Nanak Dev University,
Amritsar, 137.
Krishan Kumar 1988. Theory of classification, 4th rev.ed. Vikas Publishing, New Delhi,
9.
Ranganathan, S.R. 1960. Colon classification, 6th ed. Sarada Ranganathan Endowment,
Bangalore, 2.4.
25