LPM Lecture Notes
LPM Lecture Notes
What a lawyer must do when he or she suspects that there is a potential conflict :
- When it looks like a duck, when it walks like a duck , it quacks like a duck, it is likely to be a duck. So
when it is likely to be a conflict, then presume there is conflict.
I. First determine whether the lawyer should
II. Meet with the potential client
III. Collect any information form the client
IV. Represent the client
V. Continue to represent the client or act on the matter i.e. if the representation has already started
What decision is made if you conclude that there is conflict :
I. Simply reject
II. Inform the client if it arises in the course of the work
III. Ask for waiver where relevant. NB: waiver is asked in only specific instances. Conflict cannot be waived
when there is a dispute since in a dispute you cannot represent two parties. Representing two or more
criminals may lead to conflict –when they begin to lie against each other in such an instance, you will
find yourself in conflict
IV. If waiver is denied, stop and inform the potential client and refuse the representation
V. Denton’s case-there is a need for a global conflict of interest check if you are a global firm
VI. Do not obtain any confidential information from the client . Subject to the client’s consent, you may
recommend an alternate law firm. Do not recommend the law firm before you ask the client since you
may be recommending a law firm of your brother doing the same thing as yours
VII. Be very familiar with the legal profession Act and the rules of Etiquette LI 613 and understand that
for the lawyer to safeguard his integrity, he must continuously check whether there is conflict or not .
Guidelines
1. An intended internet profile, must include the following :
The full name of the legal firm or lawyer
The location address and postal address
The particulars of telephone contacts.
The email address
The passport pictures of the partners, associates and juniors
The history of the firm
The profile and areas of practice of the firm and or individual members of the firm
2. The firm or lawyer may subject to the approval of their clients list the names of former and current
clients in the profile.
3. Firms and lawyers cannot add phrases, adjectives and description such as “best”, “expert” among other
such phrases
4. Firms cannot add statements which are inaccurate or likely to mislead, diminish public confidence in the
legal profession, the administration of justice or otherwise bring the legal profession into disrepute.
5. Firms cannot criticise other legal firms or lawyers.
6. Firms cannot put out statements about their success rate.
7. Firms cannot put statements which are obstructive as to cause annoyance to those to whom it is directed.
8. A portal will be opened at the GBA website for firms who want to put in their profile at a discounted rate
to do so through the GBA. Individual firms will also be permitted to create their own websites.
9. The breach of these guidelines to internet profiles would amount to misconduct.
SUSPENSION OF LAWYER FRANCIS XAVIER SOSU FROM LEGAL PRACTICE
- NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that Lawyer Francis Xavier Sosu is hereby suspended from legal practice
for a period of period of three (3) years commencing 2nd day of June, 2017 and ending on 1st day of June,
2020. There were two cases against him, to wit:
- Complaint of Francis Agyare against Francis Xavier Sosu
Lawyer Sosu was formally charged under Rule 9 (9) of the Legal Profession (Professional Conduct
and Etiquette) Rules, 1969 L.I. 613 that he; having assisted Mr. Francis Agyare, in Human Rights
litigation in Accra, charged him GH₵ 50,000.00 which was excessive and an over-estimation of the
services rendered to him, when he represented to him that he was offering pro bono legal services.
He was also charged under Section 19(5) of the Legal Profession Act that he, having been duly
notified, failed to appear before the Disciplinary Committee of the General Legal Council on 9th June,
2016.
Lawyer Sosu was convicted on his own plea of guilty on both counts.
- Conduct of Lawyer Francis Xavier Sosu
The Disciplinary Committee of the General Legal Council formally charged Lawyer Sosu under Rule
2(4) of the Legal Profession (Professional Conduct and Etiquette) Rules, 1969 L.I. 613 that he; while
acting as Counsel for Torgbui Afede XIV, in a matter between Torgbui Afede XIV and the Chief of
Defence Staff, Minister of Interior, Attorney General and another took to Facebook with pictures of
the parties and made comments on the case to the public with his firm’s name, address and telephone
numbers attached, with the primary motive of personal advertisement and touting.
He was further charged under Rule 2 (4) of the Legal Profession (Professional Conduct and Etiquette)
Rules, 1969 L.I. 613 that he; while acting as Counsel for Patrick Reynolds Yeboah, in a matter
between Patrick Reynolds Yeboah and M.DEX Company Limited Accra, Ledzokuku-Krowor
Municipal Assembly (LEKMA) Accra, Ghana Standard Authority Accra, National Road Safety
Commission, Accra, took to Facebook posting the Writ of Summons in the said case and made
comments to the public with his firm’s name, address and telephone numbers attached, with the
primary motive of personal advertisement and touting.
Lawyer Sosu was convicted on his own plea of guilty on both counts and was sentenced to a period of
three (3) years suspension commencing 2nd day of June, 2017 and ending on 1st day of June, 2020.
He is to be mentored by a senior for a period of one year commencing 2nd June, 2020 and ending on
1stJune, 2021. The senior to mentor him shall lodge periodic reports on him to the General Legal
Council’s Disciplinary Committee at the end of every month during the mentorship period.
- Both sentences run concurrently. During the period of suspension, he shall not hold himself out as a Legal
Practitioner or attend Chambers, or render, or purport to render any professional legal service to any
person whomsoever, wheresoever.
- The licence of Lawyer Francis Xavier Sosu to practise for the next three (3) years is hereby withdrawn
forthwith.
Management
- Henry L. Sisk: Management is the coordination of all resources through the process of planning,
organising, directing and controlling in order to attain stated objectives.
- F. W. Taylor: Management is the art of knowing what you want to do and then seeing that it is done in the
best and cheapest way.
- Henry Fayol: To manage is to forecast and to plan, to organise to command, to coordinate and to control.
- The management function: In any management scenario, there will be an external environment, inputs to
he organisation, output in the form of problems of the client and feedback.
- Management is a daily process and cuts across 3 broad areas: Internal mechanisms, External Mechanisms
and Historical Mechanisms
Evolution of Management
- Up until the industrial age, there were 2 main approaches to management
1. The Stick and carrot approach
2. The Servant-Leadership approach
- The concept of management science entered the scenes under the influence of Adam Smith who
propounded the 3 factors of production: Land, labour, entrepreneur, where the entrepreneurs were
manages of business also known as Entrepreneur capitalists
- As business expanded, Managerial capitalists evolved. These were persons who were not entrepreneurs or
owners of the business but nevertheless performed the task of managing the business
The Management theory of Frederick Taylor
- Frederick W. Taylor propounded the Scientific Management theory
- A healthy management is based on the scientific management approach to work in which objective
standards are set by means of time, method, motion and fatigue studies.
- Taylor concentrated on the components of work rather than the structures within which it is carried out.
He argued that it is in the best interests of both worker and manager to break tasks down into components
which will enable workers to use minimum energy while producing maximum output, thereby maximising
their earnings for the least possible effort
- His theory is hugely based on the concept of ‘Time’ and extended this to man hour. So the efficiency of a
worker should be determined based on the amount of work he or she can do within an hour
- Taylor’s scientific management consisted of four principles:
1. Replace rule-of-thumb work methods with methods based on a scientific study of the tasks.
2. Scientifically select, train, and develop each employee rather than passively leaving them to train
themselves.
3. Provide “Detailed instruction and supervision of each worker in the performance of that worker's
discrete task”.
4. Divide work nearly equally between managers and workers, so that the managers apply scientific
management principles to planning the work and the workers actually perform the tasks.
- Taylor posited that as a result of his theory it was possible to measure the productivity of labour per month
per hour and compare that productivity per machine per hour. This is what shaped the concept of time for
wages
Management theory of Jules Henri Fayol
- Fayol, a Frenchman, like Taylor was an engineer. He is generally hailed as the founder of the classical
management school not because he was the first to investigate managerial behaviour, but because he was
the first to systematise it.
- He was the first person to group management functions that today are summarised as planning,
organising, leading/Commanding, coordinating, and controlling; otherwise known as the 5 basic
functions of management
- He authored a book titled, General and Industrial Management in French that was later on translated into
English. The book contains the concept that management is an activity common to all human undertakings
which can be taught in the classroom or the workplace, home, business etc.
- He believed that management was an everyday skill which could be learnt as opposed to the belief at the
time that management was an innate skill and urged for the teaching of management as a subject in
schools
- He identified fourteen management principles:
1. Division of labour (specialisation leads to greater efficiency);
2. Authority (managers have the authority to get things done);
3. Discipline (members of the organisation need to respect the rules and regulations that govern it);
4. Unity of command (avoid conflicting and/or confusing instructions);
5. Unity of direction (only one manager should be responsible for an employee’s behaviour);
6. Subordination of individual interest to the common good (the interests of individual employees
should not take precedence over the interests of the entire organisation);
7. Remuneration (pay for work done should be fair to both the employee and the employer);
8. Centralisation (managers should retain the final responsibility);
9. Scalar chair (a single uninterrupted line of authority should run rank to rank from top management to
the lowest level position in the company);
10. Order (materials and people need to be in the right place at the right time);
11. Equity (managers should be both friendly and fair to their subordinates);
12. Stability and tenure of staff (stability and tenure should be enhanced and high staff turnover should
be avoided);
13. Initiative (subordinates should be given the freedom to formulate and carry out their own plans);
14. And esprit de corps (promoting team spirit gives the organisation a sense of unity).
Management theory of Max Weber
- Max Weber was a German socialist who developed a theory of bureaucratic management that stressed the
need for a strictly defined hierarchy governed by clearly defined regulations and lines of authority.
- Weber also believed that technical competence should be emphasised and that performance evaluations
should be made entirely on the basis of merit.
- He posited that organisations had grown beyond large and the industrial era that persons where given
“legal authority” to make decisions
- Weber also believed that personal and social roles were important to organisational structure. In one with
this managers should no just impose ideas, but consult with the workforce. That group pressure had a
better impact on productivity than other management strategies
- Max Weber identified seven characteristics of bureaucratic management:
1. Rules (formal guidelines for the behaviour of employees while they are on the job);
2. Impersonality (all employees are evaluated according to rules and objective data);
3. Division of labour (the process of dividing duties into simpler, more specialised tasks);
4. Hierarchical structure (helps control the behaviour of employees by making clear to each exactly
where he or she stands in relation to everyone else in the organisation);
5. Authority structure (determines who has the right to make decisions of varying importance at
different levels within the organisation);
6. Life-long career commitment (job security is guaranteed as long as the employees is technically
qualified and performs satisfactorily);
7. Rationality (managers operate logically and scientifically with all decisions leading directly to
achieving the organisation’s goals).
- The bureaucratic approach is most effective when the organisation is required to handle large quantities of
standard information, the needs of the customer are known and not likely to change, the technology is
routine and stable, and the organisation has to coordinate the activities of numerous employees in order to
deliver a standardised service or product to the customer
The Human Relations Movement of Elton Mayo
- Managers should become more “people-orientated”.
- Conducting experiments on conditions in the workplace and incorporating the well-published findings of
the Hawthorne Studies, Mayo declared that, “logical factors were far less important than emotional factors
in determining productive efficiency”
- He concluded that participation in social groups and “group pressure”, as opposed to organisational
structures or demands from management, had the strongest impact on worker productivity,
- The work performed by individuals has to satisfy their “personal, subjective” social needs as well as the
company’s productive requirements.
- He and other proponents of this movement therefore called for managers to “accept a new role” in their
relationship with workers; develop a new concept of authority; and help foster a new social order in the
workplace. In practice managers were encouraged to consult workers about change, take note of their
views, and to show concern for their physical and mental health.
Management Theory of Robert Greenleaf
- Robert Greenleaf reinvented the concept of Servant-Leadership
- Author of book “The Servant as a Leader”. He explained that becoming a servant-leader “begins with the
natural feeling that one was to serve” followed by the aspiration to lead.
- The concept of this theory is that as leaders lead by example, they identify with the subordinates and thus
are obeyed because the subordinates follow his example.
- Greenleaf separated leadership as a concept from the concept of management unlike Weber
- Greenleaf posited that the measure of leadership is reflected in the expansion of the followers a leader has
- Greenleaf’s “servant-leader” is intended to describe a type person-a person that has two distinct and
different roles : one as a servant and another as a leader. He describes this leader as follows :
The servant–leader is servant first…It begins with the natural feeling that one wants to serve, to serve
first. Then conscious choice brings one to aspire to lead. He is sharply different form the person who
is a leader first, perhaps because of the need to assuage an unusual power drive to acquire material
possessions. For such it will be a later choice to serve-after leadership is established. The leader-first
and the servant –first are two extreme types. Between them there are shadings and blends that are part
of the infinite variety of human nature.
Management theory of Peter Drucker
- Peter Drucker, a mathematician is a modern day advocate for management, author of the “The End of the
Economic Man”
- Drucker insisted that management is not merely about the delivery of results(Fayol and Taylor) but rather,
entails knowledge as well as thoughts about people. He thus, sought a review of the management theories
earlier propounded. He also believes in co-operation and argued against imposition on employees by
managers.
- He says, “management is doing things right and leadership is doing right things”
- Drucker defines a manager as having two specific tasks. Nobody else in the business discharges these
tasks. And everyone charged with them works as a manager. The manager has the task of creating a true
whole that is larger than the sum of its parts, ... [and of harmonising] in every decision and action the
requirements of immediate and long-range future
- Drucker also states that the most important thing in communication is to hear what is not heard
- He invented the concept of management by objective and management by results; a systematic way of
defining objectives and setting a sequence by taking into account all factors on how that is to be achieved
- Drucker identifies three broad types of production each of which needs a different type of organisation:
1. Unique product production in which articles are produced individually
2. Needs centralisation and specialisation;
3. Mass production in which many articles are produced simultaneously and which may require a high
degree of coordination but not necessarily centralisation;
- Drucker argues for a minimum of hierarchy, decentralisation wherever possible and decisions to be taken
as far down an organisation as possible. He also argues that productivity can only be improved through
human resourcefulness, that, to liberate that resourcefulness, people must be encouraged to use their brains
productively and that they will only do that if that are given the freedom to develop their own ideas about
how to carry on the business of the organisation.
- Drucker implicitly rejects mechanistic models of management and assumes that differences of view will
arise within organisations. He integrates these tensions into his descriptions of good management and
argues that the structures and relationships an organisation has must serve the people who are to carry on
the business of the organisation, not the other way round.
D. Compensation
- A law firm manager must understand compensation and benefits. The challenge about compensation in
law firms include competitiveness. Salaries you are paying your lawyers is competitive so your lawyers
tend to compare. The most serious aspect about the competition of law firms compensation is that it is not
public. Very difficult to know what firms pay.
- The other factor about compensation is industry and country factors. If a law firm does the lock step, the
compensation takes factors in the country like the living standards in the different countries.
- Compensation Models in Law Firms
Profit based compensation. This is normally for a proper partnership (set up under the partnership
Act). In this method, the partners do not earn salaries as such but estimate the profit and make
drawings
Contribution to business: similar to the contribution u bring to the business eg how you market
Partner compensation: This will normally be only one of the two : lock step or eat what you kill. With
a lock step, Once you become a partner u get the same compensation and doesn’t matter the work you
bring in. Another situation is what is based on experience so if you have a certain number of years as a
partner u all get the same. For eat what you kill, you get based on the cases you bring (whether you
worked on it or not)
Level of effort compensation. This is what you contribute to a particular case
Time based compensation : This is normally used for of counsel. Multiply your rate by hours
Case based compensation: This normally applies when there is more than one lawyer in the case and
the person wants to pay based on the case based compensation
Incentive based Schemes
- Challenges of Compensation in Model law firms
i. Uncertainty in income sources
ii. Cost Control challenges
iii. Competition with the salaries of both rival law firms and non-law firm employment. As a result law
firms have developed compensation methods such as the case based compensation method. The
disadvantage may be that you may not get your SSNIT etc
E. Performance Assessment
- This is the evaluation of an individual employees to determine the strengths and weakness of staff. It is a
measure of performance
- It is an appraisal and should be nonjudgmental and for the purposes of measuring productivity
- The purpose of this exercise is to lead to improved performance, award/reward, incentives for best
performances.
- Concept of Career Development : Nobody expects to remain at his level forever. Evaluation is used as a
basis for career growth.
Independent Paralegals
- These are independent contractors who sell their paralegal services to and works under the supervision of
one of the attorneys. They could also refer to paralegals who sell their services directly to the public
without attorney supervision
Legal Secretary
- A legal secretary (also known as an administrative assistant, legal assistant or executive assistant) is a
secretary who is trained in law office procedure, legal technology and legal terminology.
- While legal secretaries perform clerical functions such as filing, typing, answer the phone and organising
files, they also possess specialised, practice-specific skills and knowledge that help lawyers' practices run
smoothly. Legal secretaries usually work for one or more paralegals and/or attorneys.
Law Clerk
1. Checks conflict of interest where the barristers in the firm are working for opposing clients
2. Discuss with the client the most appropriate lawyer to handle the case.
3. Keep records of specialisation, skills and experience of barristers.
4. Negotiating fees charged with the person who instructs.
5. Planning timetable of cases.
6. Arranging meetings on behalf of barrister
7. Planning the workload of barristers to avoid clashes
8. Monitor accounts and cash
9. Proactively seeing work for the chambers
Court Runner
- Also known as a law firm messenger, the court runner files documents with the court and performs other
errands for law firm lawyers and staff. Court messengers are often law students who work part-time with a
law firm to gain legal skills and exposure to the law firm experience.
Law Librarian
- A law librarian conducts legal research using both computerised and manual methods; acquires and
preserves library materials; is an expert in legal and nonlegal research methods/tools; advises attorneys
and legal professionals on legal research methods; maintains, classifies, indexes, and stores library
materials; manages the library/legal research budget and may coordinate the use of electronic resources,
such as West-law, LexisNexis, and other services.
Finance and Accounting as a Component of the Law Firm Practice and Management
Law Firm expenses and how Layers Generate Income
Money as a Resource to the Firm
- Account Receivables: This entails monies that the law firm will be expecting and as part of the heads of
expenses, the law firm would be spending money
- Client Account
- Trust Account: The purpose of this account is to hold monies the client asks the firm to keep for them and
not necessarily for client expenses or recoveries made on behalf of the client. The account must be in
accordance with the Anti-money laundering provisions to ensure that unscrupulous clients do not use the
account to launder money
Expenditure (Expenses)
- The expenses of a firm varies depending on the type of practice
Expenses of Traditional law firms
- This is also referred to as the Chamber System or Office Sharing Arrangements
- Expenses are narrowed down because they go into a “common pot” in other words a common fund
consisting of contributions from partners in the firm. The fund covers all expenses and money is
withdrawn usually by the office clerk or practice clerk
- Other expenses the firm incurs include:
Salaries and wages
Staff Cost: This comprises medical expenses and the like. Costs that are not directly staff related but
which are incurred or likely to be incurred by staff
Individual expenses like cost of newspapers etc
Client related expenses like filing fess, costs
Individual taxes
Modern law firms
- In modern law firms the expenses can be can be individualistic, because there is not “Common Pot” for
which expenses must enter. Examples of such expenses are ICT, Internet, Office Equipment,
Transportation, Furniture and Fittings, Corporate tax, Audit fees, salaries, staff cost etc
Filing Systems
A. The Alphabetical System: In an alphabetic filing system, cases are stored based on the last name of the
client or name of the organisation. There is a natural tendency to alphabetise because it is a system that
most people understand. In addition, staff members do not need to memorise case numbers or use
numerical lists. On the down side, The larger the number of cases the law office is handling, the more
problems it will experience with an alphabetical system. This is because names are not all that unique;
many clients may have the same last name, unlike the numerical system where each client is identified
by a unique number. Plus the system is difficult to expand and can require constantly shifting files to
make room for more.
B. The Numerical System: In a numerical filing system, each case or legal matter is given a separate file
number. This is similar to when a case is filed with a court; a clerk assigns each action or lawsuit a
separate case number. Case identifiers can be, but do not necessarily have to be, composed of all
numbers. Variations can be used, such as alphanumeric, in which letters and numbers are used. For
instance, a letter might be used in the case number to reflect which branch office is handling the case,
and two of the numbers might reflect the year the case was filed. Another numerical filing method is to
assign a range of numbers to a particular type of case, such as 000–999 for trusts, 1,000–1,999 for tax
matters etcetera. A filing rule that sometimes bears out is that the longer the case number, the more
misfiling and other types of errors occur; shorter numbers can also be remembered more easily
C. The Bar-Coding System: Bar coding is a file management technique in which each file is tracked
according to the file’s bar code. Each time a user takes a file, the file’s bar code and user’s bar code are
scanned into a computer. The computerised system then tracks which user checked out which file. When
the file is returned, the file’s bar code is scanned back into the computer. A report can be generated any
time, listing what files are checked out and by whom. Using this system, it is possible to find the location
of files quite easily.
Opening a File
- When a new or existing client comes into the office with a new legal matter, a new file should
immediately be opened. The opening of a file should be standardised and requires certain information
about the legal matter. A file-opening form or an electronic version (sometimes called a new client/matter
form or case sheet) is customarily completed when opening a new file.
- The file opening form is used for a variety of purposes, including to check potential conflicts of interest, to
assign a new case number and attorney to the matter, to track the area or specialty of the case, to set forth
the type of fee agreement and billing frequency in the case, to enter the case in the timekeeping and billing
system, to make docketing entries (such as when the statute of limitations in the matter might run), and to
find out how the client was referred to the law office.
- Although file-opening forms are commercially available, most law offices choose to customise the form to
reflect their own needs.
- Copies of the file-opening form may be sent to the managing partner, other attorneys, accounting
department, docket-control department, and the responsible attorney.
- A client must be made completely aware before his or her file is closed. It is strongly recommended that
the law firm send a disengagement letter to the client, letting him or her know in writing that the file is
being closed and that the client can have documents, evidence, or even the whole file returned to him or
her. Electronic records also need to be purged or backed up at the same time the hard copy of the file is
closed.
- Retention of client files and client-related documents depends on the ethical rules in your state.
- Before destroying a client file, contact the client to make sure he or she does not want the file or want
something out of the file.
- When destroying client files, burn, shred, or recycle them to ensure client confidentiality.
Calendar Systems
Calendaring is typically a generic term used to describe the recording of appointments for any type of
business. For example, an accounting or engineering firm might use a generic calendaring or scheduling
form that comes with an office suite of software programs to track appointments.