REL 1110 Notes 3
REL 1110 Notes 3
Introduction
Religion comes into being when religious experiences express and find expression in a distinctive
system of expressing symbols
In the expression of religion there is the good understanding object of Supreme Being, beyond heavens,
spirits.
The symbolic objects can exist in the following ways
They exist within this common world
They exist beyond this world
They exist both within and beyond the common world.
It is from this religion that emerged distinctive types of religion
A. Cosmic
The word cosmos means the universe, therefore cosmic religion means the religious object of alternate
concern and this religion is polytheistic in nature. Under this religion the deities/ gods are located within
the common world.
This religion is also referred to as nature, culture religion and takes the universe or the world itself as
divine.
This type of religion is mainly found in the place of Mesopotamia (Egypt) and Greece
B. A cosmic
This type of religion locates the religious objects beyond the common secular world of nature and
society.
In this type of religion, the religious objects are conceived to singular or plural, this is either a high god,
God, deity or the supreme power.
It has a vocal point which is referred to as transcendental monism and is mainly found among the
Hinduism and Jainism.
C. Historical/ Natural religion
The religious objects found both beyond and within the common world.
1
It shares with the a cosmic type of religion whose transcendental point beyond this common world. It
shares with cosmic type of religion the reality of the world of religion and culture, where the object is
recognised within the world.
It is monotheistic in nature whereby the Supreme Being is both in this world and outside world.
In this type of religion, the object is imminent meaning ‘yet far and yet near.’
In this religion, life is viewed historically and the development to final fulfilment found among
Christianity, Judaism and Islam.
There are other types of religion which are minor, they are referred to as sycletic, sycletic means symbols
of features of religion that are being borrowed from 2 or more religion which are matched and result in a
unique religion e.g Sikhism came up with features being borrowed from Islam and Hinduism. Features
were being borrowed from Aryan races and indigenous people of India.
D. Pseudo Religions
These are movements and symbolic actions which claim to be at same level with a particular religion
but they are fake but not really.
Example of Pseudo religion is magic.
Magic- is all the formulae for act beyond the ordinary human control this implies the manipulation of
Supra- empirical means for empirical ends.
Empirical means something that is common, natural, material concrete, earthly
Supra means above the ordinary.
Magic is the methodology of manipulating, tapping the mystical powers for the good or harm of the
individual or the community.
They operate through spells and rituals in the following ways
1) Simple tools which include pebbles, hair, and other tools that gives other feeling or air of mystery.
2) They use feathers, coins, quarts
3) Technical knowledge, these techniques will differ from one person to another example rainmaker has
different technique from that of healer.
4) Use of language-the language is used as stimuli of the real act or as the ritualized expression of
emotional desire on the part of performer enacted by use of word and deed.
The condition of the performer of magic has important bearing employed.
The success of magic depends on the skill of operation.
The magician is an actor but plot an actual agent of the mysterious power, he is surrounded with taboos
designed to protect him as an agent of the mysterious power, he is surrounded with taboos designed
protect him against any conduct with influence which might interfere the power of his act.
Magic is related to superstition through centuries and 15th century in Europe all magic was superstition
which was mistaken liken to experiential, dimension of religion, however the natural science resulted
discovery that shuffled the belief in magic especially in the west. Magic however lingers on in-spite of
the new scientific discoveries in the world ever. Magic is said to be good while the practices are
performed to benefit others.
2
It is said to be evil/black if the practices are intended to harm or cause harmful effects on others.
Magic can be defensive /destructive. The right performance of the ritual is essential and brings about the
desired effectiveness which must be accompanied by ritual of the magic words.
If the motives are made by the magician then the practices become harmful, this is because magic is to
be performed for specific effect i.e there must be a particular purpose. Magic performance is based on
the principle of sympathy and this principle has two laws;
1. Law of similarity
2. Law of contagion
Law of similarity
It implies those things which are alike/are the same. This means that the law is based on the belief owing
certain likeness
Influence can be exerted from one to the other without physical contact e.g an action taken against an image
or symbol or picture can have similar effect on the real object by use of magic.
The Law of Contagion
It leads to contagious magic. This is based on the assumption that once some object or person have been
connected they will influence each other even when separate. Because of the effects of magic on the people
and society it has been regarded as religion due to some similarities.
James Frazer pioneered the theory that magic is the origin of religion because there are similarities and
differences it can be referred to as pseudo religion.
Similarities between Religion and Magic
1. According to social functional theory, magic and religion are a set of belief and practices which is a
characteristic of human society.
2. Both magic and religion share the concept of the beyond.
3. They share the idea that human beings are capable to establishes a contact with supernatural realities.
4. Magic like religion offers way of adjusting to those aspects of human situations which lie beyond
human control.
5. Both arise and function in situations of emotional stress and both open up escapes from situations.
6. Both are based on mythological condition and exist in the atmosphere of miracles and surrounding
by taboos and observances which separate these acts from the secular world.
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN RELIGION AND MAGIC
Religion is a body of self-contained acts which are themselves the fulfilment of the purpose while magic
aims at a practical end.
Religion offers a variety and more complex supernatural sphere which can’t be manipulated while magic
beliefs are simple rituals, limited and techniques are circumspect.
Magic implement human practical abilities enhancing one’s confidence of hope over fear, religion on the
other hand contribute to human morals by enhancing all valuable mental attitudes courage and
confidence to face reality.
3
Religion provides a definition beyond the extent of our knowledge and security beyond the guarantee of
human relationship while magic providence is empirical and for a particular end.
Religious rituals places man in relation to supernatural realities and express the supernatural realities to
bring changes and effects in the natural world.
Magic is manipulative while religion is persuasive.
Religion is petitionary i.e does not force or compel and admits one depending on the supernatural
powers while magic manipulates the supernatural powers by the right use of formulae and techniques
whose results can not be questioned.
- Religion and Magic are two different phenomena, 2 alternatives and 2 opposites. Indeed magic is
pseudo religion.
- Devil worship is an entire religion for it is subjectively used for personal good and not for the
common good. One is subjected to no freedom. This is unethical and immoral especially when
practiced deliberately. To shock the world order and to reverse it e.g use of human sacrifices and
other rituals, amount to crime rather than the common good.
- The Greek religion are pseudo because of their nature; they have many gods and semi gods and
human deities which are worshipped for empirical ends.
-
1. Transcendental & immanent type
Usually religion can be divided into these two main types.
Religion that believe that God is transcendental are Christianity and Islam
When we say that God is transcendental we mean that He is wholly “other” and separate from the
universe. Which he created. E.g Isaiah 6:1-3 God’s glory fills the earth which he created but God
himself is “high and lifted up”, separate from his creation. Similarly in Isaiah 40:12-26, God created
the world and the stars, but he himself ‘sits above the circle of the earth’ Vs. 22 God cannot be
confused with creation and separate from it.
2. Immanence:
Religions which believe that God is immanent include philosophical Hinduism. This means that God
is in all things throughout the natural world. God is often identified with creation itself since God is
one and creation is an extension of God Himself.
God is in everything. The chair you are sitting on, the house you live in – God is in all & all is God.
This point of view is also called PANTHEISM.
Immanence can be understood in another way which says that God is in his world without being
identified with it. This is the teaching of Psalm 139. We cannot escape from the presence of God.
He is always close to us. We cannot say either that Gods world is far from us. On the contrary it is
very near us and in our heart as Deut 30:11-14 & Rom 10:6-9 says. Supremely Christians say that
God was immanent in his world when the “word became flesh & dwelled among us.” ((Jn 1:14).
And He dwells in the World still be His Spirit (Jn 14:16-17).
3. TRADITIONAL TYPES OF RELIGION
This used to be called Animism (belief in spirits) but this title has been dropped in favour of the
word traditional. Traditional is used because there is no written record of beliefs, but there is a very
4
strong oral tradition about religion which is passed by word of mouth from generation to generation.
Sir E. Tylor noted that traditional religion is characterised by belief in spiritual beings especially in:
The non-material (Spiritual) part of man.
Existence or life after death (eg the ancestors or living dead)
The ‘soul’ can leave the body in trances or dreams etc.
Animals, plants, birds and objects have souls.
There are other spiritis independent of God.
4. PROPHETIC & REVELATORY TYPE
This classification is particularly relevant to religious with transcendent ideas of God since it describes
the way in which God, who is separated from his creation, communicates with it. Prophets, sacred
Kings, medicine men or other types of mediator convey the messages (Revelations of God or the gods to
mankind. They were considered as holy men who would cure the sick, offer sacrifice and contact God
or the spirits.
5. UNIVERSAL TYPE
Buddhisim, Christianity & Islam claim to be universal religious. By this they mean that their religion is
valid not just in the area where it began, but also thorough the whole world. Some Hindus claim that
Hinduism is universal but probably it is more ethnic and traditional than universal. Islam was founded
by prophet Muhammad so it is a prophetic religion. Similarly Christianity is a prophetic religion for two
reasons:
(A) Firstly it was founded by a prophet of Nazareth (Jesus)
(B) Secondly prophecy is described as one of the gifts of the Holy Spirit given to the church by God (1
Cor. 12:10). There are different types of prophecy. One function of O.T prophet was to speak God’s
word against the social evils of the time. So Christians like Willberforce in England, Dr. Martin
Luther King in USA & Arch Bishop Janal Luwum in Uganda were “prophets” because they spoke
out against the evils of their day.
6. MYSTICAL TYPE
Most religions have mystical elements or people who practice mystecisms. It is difficult to describe but
we can say that the mystic seeks to break away from this world in order to achieve unity and fellowship
with the inifinite or with God who is beyond this world. God is experienced in a non-rational way
through traunces or spiritual experiences that are hard describe. Mystics have an insight or understanding
of God that ordinary people do not have. W.T stance mentions? Characteristics of mysticism:
(I) A sense of oneness with God & with eternity and the universe.
(II) A sense of being outside space and time – again with God.
(III) A sense of being in touch with reality or objectively greater than this world.
(IV) Feelings of blessedness, joy, peace, happiness etc.
(V ) Feeling that one is in touch with something or someone holy, sacred or divine.
(VI) A feeling of paradoxicality ie. One is oneself yet nolonger oneself.
(VII) The experience is “ineffable” i.e impossible to describe (2 COR 12:1-7)
5
CONCLUSION
The 6th classification of religion in terms of mysticism is often the most interesting. You may find it
difficult but if you stop & think of how you become a Christian, then give a testimony explaining how
you experiences God through the H/Spirit coming into your life. This meaning you have had a sense of
oneness with God, the feeling of peace & joy in a wonderful way is what is mysticism.
6
It helps to understand the events of human history and understand the religious traditions of various
people.
It helps us to plan ahead for events of life through history by learning from the past.
It helps us to understand the behaviour of the society and the individuals
It helps us to understand and familiarize ourselves with spiritual universe.
Religion contributes to intellectual expressions i.e it seeks to understand meaning, makes the inquiry
of human life, purpose, destiny condition, nature, death etc.
Religion contributes to actions of the society, affirms on its reality in the respective aspects in human
experience.ie the use of symbols, language, rituals etc. beliefs determine the mode of human actions.
Contributes to social relationships in that people who had intellectual positions in common and who worship
together form a community