HDP Module III (Revised 2022)
HDP Module III (Revised 2022)
HDP Module III (Revised 2022)
Module III
August 2022
Managing Learning and Assessment
1
Table of Contents ------------------------------------------------------------------3
3
Module 3: Managing Learning and Assessment
Introduction (1 hr.)
This module is written with the assumption that there are no final answers to questions
concerning school learning (Bigge and Shermis, 2004). Issues of learning vary in time,
place and level. Not only differing landscapes of education pose different kinds of issues
of learning, but also the dynamism in the conception of learning itself challenges the
claim for universal applications of theories and strategies in classrooms. Thus, teachers or
readers of this module are rather advised to use theories of learning to improve their
understanding of students, learning and the learning process, and to continuously modify
their classroom approaches. In other words, methods may depend on learning theories
which are not universally applicable in all conditions and for all purposes. The
effectiveness of methods depends on many factors that should be learned from the actual
classroom situation. This interplay between classroom landscape and the learning process
affects the way we select and apply methods of teaching in classrooms.
4
Unit 1: Understanding Learning: Principles and Processes (4 hrs.)
1.1. Introduction
Learning outcomes
Reflective activity 1
1. Recall your experiences as a student. What were the focuses of instruction of most of
your teachers?
5
2. How did your teachers try to ensure learning (what strategies and techniques did they
use)?
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
There are three broad and competing stand points with considerable influences as to how
learning should be conceived.
The Behaviourist view point – Knowledge is gained through empirical experiences and is
a set of responses to environmental stimuli. Motivation plays a role of strengthening or
weakening the linkage between stimulus and response. And, only observable stimulus-
responses connections characterize learning and gives basis for assessment. In this sense,
the learner is assumed as passive to environmental influences and behaviours are shaped
by the nature of stimulus. The teacher as the subject expert is in control of the learning
process.
The Cognitivist view point – This theory defines learning as a result of the interaction
between the environment and the individual to produce insights. These insights are
true reflections of human thought helpful to design personal behaviours. They are not
physical descriptions of objects or processes in the environment but are interpretations
of one-self or the perceived environment. They are one’s own perceptions and hence,
learners should be able to develop their own meanings out of these insights. The role
of the teacher is helping children to develop insights through adoption. Thus, the
learner is supposed to be active. However, there are two critics against this
perspective. First, the claim of congruence between stages of cognitive development
and the knowledge arrangement in the curriculum is not always linear and universal.
Second, it is possible to perform some learning activities without developing insights,
like memorizing the multiplication table.
6
The situationist view point– Learning is a result of the interaction between the individual
and the environment. It is not the individual shaping the environment or vice-versa; rather
they interact with each other. Thus, the learner in the classroom is not only active but
interactive. According to this perspective, meaning is embedded in action, and it is not a
function of formation of insights or stimulus-responses associations as in the case of
cognitivist or behaviourist theorists. Situationist perspective emphasizes on the socio-
cultural situation of learning and on students’ existing knowledge aimed at extending
such knowledge through interaction with the environment. Major contenders being
pragmatists (like John Dewey) and socio-culturalists (like Vygotsky), the theory
gives due attention to the role of others (e.g. peers and teachers) in supporting students’
learning and development.
Reflective activity 2
From your reading on the three theories of learning (in Box 1), what is your
understanding of the learner, the learning process, the role of the teacher, the objectives
of instruction, the assessment mechanisms, and the limitations of each perspective? Put
your answers in the table below.
7
Emphasis of assessment of learning
Please note that in practice the teaching-learning process may not necessarily be shaped
by only one single learning theory. It rather benefits from multiple of them.
8
ability to manage the learning as opposed to managing the learners. Quality of instruction
is largely a function of multiple variables including the amount of practice and
participation students are afforded in learning a task and the reinforcement or
encouragement mechanisms teachers use to motivate the students learn. Obviously, the
teacher’s role is critical in this process.
As we discuss the quality of instruction, there are what are often called principles for
instruction. These principles are mechanisms which help operationalize theory to
teaching/learning practices. Let’s examine the following nine principles and discuss the
resulting questions.
Dear HDL/HDT, please ask the students to discuss on the ‘discussion questions’ in pair
and report the result to the whole team.
9
7 Students should be engaged in both independent study Compare independent and
and cooperative learning and give and receive tutorial cooperative learning.
instruction.
8 To a great degree, it is the mode of instruction that Explain what mode of
determines what is learned and how well it is learned. instruction means?
9 You must hold high expectations for the learning of State your expectations
each student (but not necessarily identical expectations from your students?
for every student) and not waiver from those
expectations.
1
0
No Bruner's aspect of Explanations and Examples Your Comments
instruction
1 What is the nature of Man is not a naked ape but a culture-clothed human being,
persons as learners? hopelessly ineffective without the prosthesis provided by
culture. The very nature of his characteristics as a species
provides a guide to appropriate pedagogy, and the nature of his
nervous system and its constraints provide a basis for devising
reasonable if not inevitable principles for designing a testable
pedagogy.
2 What is the nature and Knowledge, we know now as never before, is power. This
structure of knowledge does not mean that there are not canons of truth or that the idea
developed for optimal, of proof is not a precious one. Rather, let knowledge as it
insightful appears in our schooling be put into the context of action and
comprehension? commitment.
3 What is the nature of How do you teach something to a child, arrange a child's
knowledge-getting environment, if you will, in such a way that he can learn
process structured for something with some assurance that he will use the material
optimal insightful that he has learned appropriately in a variety of situations?
comprehension?
10
4 What optimal experiences Problem solving requires the exploration of alternatives.
predispose learners to ...Students should be in on where they are trying to go, what
learn? they are trying to get hold of, and how much pertinent progress
they are making.
5 How are success and Success and failure are inherent to the task at hand; thus, they
failure, and reward and constitute intrinsic motivation. Reward and punishment
punishment involved in usually are controlled by one's parents or teacher; thus, they
learning? constitute extrinsic motivation.
6 What are optimal An important task of the teacher is to convert knowledge into
sequences of presentation forms that fit growing minds or intellects. Any idea or
of materials to be problem can be or body of knowledge can be presented in a
learned? form simple enough so that any particular learner can
understand it in a recognizable form.
11
experience a n d ( 2) a conformation check, in which the
tentative hypothesis is tested against further sense data. If the
two matches, the hypothesis is maintained; if they mismatches,
the hypothesis is altered in a way that acknowledges the
discrepant evidence.
12
Reflective activity 3
2) Which of the nine principles of learning or teaching presented in this section (i.e.,
1.3) do you accept? Which ones do you reject? Why?
13
Teacher’s Focus Relationship with students Your comments
leadership
styles
Laissez-Faire Encourages students to Non-interference with students' choice
disregard the prevailing and actions, deliberately abstains from
cultural norms and "do directing students or developing lesson
one's own thing". plans, void leading students.
Reflective activity 4:
(1) When you were a student, which of these teacher leadership styles was dominant in
your teacher’s relationship with you?
____________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
(2) Which of these teacher leadership styles seem to be dominant in your
relationship with your students?
.
__________________________________________________________________________________.
(3) Given the current change in the higher education landscape in Ethiopia, which teacher
leadership style would you like to adapt for yourself? Why?
14
1.5. Learning styles
In recent years there has been a cultural shift from an emphasis on teaching to an
emphasis on facilitating learning. Developing individuals and personalized learning have
become part of the twenty first century. This approach which is termed as student
centred approach incorporates assessment for learning, improving students’ higher order
thinking skills, encouraging learners to be independent and developing strategies for
consulting students about their education. It also emphasizes that the quality of learning
is shaped by the learner’s experience. Hence, it is mandatory that a higher education
teacher pay careful consideration to the needs and potential of each and every student in
their classes. This calls for a need to study the kind of learning styles likely to be
represented in our classes.
It is now widely accepted that people have different learning styles that account for
differences in students’ performance. And writers both in psychology and education
categorize learning styles in several ways. The most popular categorization of the
learning styles is, however, the one that put them into three: visual, auditory, and
kinesthetic. Everyone uses a range of learning styles. Therefore, higher education
teachers need to be aware of these and support their students at individual level.
As a model visual, auditory, and kinesthetic (VAK) provides a useful framework for
helping us reflect about how we think and learn. The model suggests that we receive
information through our senses – what we see, hear, feel, taste and smell, that is how we
construct our thoughts
15
However, what may happen as a tendency to favour one rather than the other of the forms
of thought construction through habit and practice become established as a preference.
Use the following questionnaire to explore what your preferences are in the way you
think and learn.
Read each statement carefully. To the right of each statement, write the number that best
describes how each statement applies to you as follows:
There are no right answers, respond to each statement as quickly as you can. Once you
have completed all 36 statements, total your score in the spaces provided.
Section 1: Visual
No. Statement Score
1 I take lots of notes
2 When talking to someone else I find it hard to if they do not maintain good
eye contact with me
3 When reading a novel I pay a lot of attention to passages picturing
the clothing, scenery, setting etc.
4 I make lists and notes because I remember things better if I write them
down
5 I need to write down directions to a new place so that I remember them
6 I need to see the person I am talking to in order to keep my attention
focused
7 When meeting a person for the first time I notice the style of dress, visual
characteristics first
8 When I am at a wedding, I like to stand back and observe others
9 When I recall information I can see it in my mind and remember where I
saw it
16
10 If I had to explain a new procedure or technique, I would prefer to write it
out
11 With free time I am most likely to read or watch television
12 If the Dean has a message for me, I prefer if s/he sends me a note
Total for visual (note the minimum is 12 and maximum is 60)
Section 2: Auditory
No. Statement Score
1 I do not take a lot of notes but I still remember what was said
2 When talking to someone else I find it hard with those who do not talk back
to me
3 When I read I read out loud, or move my lips to hear the words in my head
4 When reading a novel I pay a lot of attention to passages involving
conversations, talking, speaking, dialogues
5 I like to talk to myself when solving a problem or writing
6 I can understand what a speaker says, even if I am not focused on the
speaker
7 I remember things more easily by repeating them again and again
8 When I am at a wedding, I like to talk about a subject that is important to
me
9 I would rather receive information from the radio than the newspaper
10 If I had to explain a new procedure or technique, I would prefer talking
about it
11 With free time I am most likely to listen to music
12 If the Dean has a message for me, I am most comfortable when s/he
telephones
Total for Auditory (note the minimum is 12 and maximum is 60)
Section 3: Kinesthetic
The area in which you have the highest score represents your preferred learning style,
which is
Remember that they are preferences, not fixed and permanent categories.
Reflective activity 5
Discuss the following questions with a colleague and note the result:
18
.
2. How may this affect your planning and preparation for teaching?
In addition to learning styles, the research literature indicates that students in higher
education manifest a number of different approaches to learning that are dependent upon
the context, the content, and the demands of the learning task. In particular, they adopt a
deep approach in so far as they acknowledge the more abstract forms of learning that are
demanded in higher education and are motivated by the relevance of the syllabus to their
own personal needs and interests. Also, students adopt a surface approach in so far as they
encounter an overloaded curriculum and methods of assessment which emphasize the
superficial properties of the material that is to be learned. Furthermore, they adopt a
strategic approach to the extent that they receive cues about their assessment schemes from
members of teaching staff. Researchers most often use the terms approach to learning and
approach to studying interchangeably. Please read summary of the three approaches to
learning given in the table below and write your comments in the space provided.
19
Approach Characteristics Your Comments
to
Learning
Deep Students who take a deep approach to learning:
Approach Actively seek to understand the material / the subject
to Interact vigorously with the content
Learning Make use of evidence, inquiry and evaluation
Take a broad view and relate ideas to one another
Are motivated by interest
Relate new ideas to previous knowledge
Relate concepts to everyday experience
Tend to read and study beyond the course requirements
Surface Students who take a surface approach to learning:
Approach Try to learn in order to repeat what they have learned
to Memorize information needed for assessments
Learning Make use of rote learning
Take a narrow view and concentrate on detail
Fail to distinguish principles from examples
Tend to stick closely to the course requirements
Are motivated by fear of failure
20
Reflective activity 6
1. Which approach to learning did you use mostly when you were a student? Why?
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
2. Which approach to learning do you think the students use mostly in the subject you are
teaching currently? What evidence could you bring in order to support your answer?
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
4. Do you think that as a teacher, you can help students to change their approaches to
learning? How?
______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________
21
Unit 2: Active Learning Methods (4 hrs.)
2.1. Introduction
While there is increasing support for and popularity of active learning methods, there is
also confusion regarding what actually constitutes it. This part of the module is devoted
to creating opportunities for the HDP candidates regarding what active learning is and
how they can actually apply the methods in their own classrooms. In so doing it strives to
achieve the following learning outcomes:
Learning Outcomes
Reflective activity 7
“Engagement of the learner with the learning material” is central to most arguments in
support of active learning methods. In your view, what is the reason behind this?
Below, there are three different descriptions of active learning from three different
authorities. Please comment on the extent to which of learner engagement is implied in
22
each. Please consider also how well you create the kind of learning situation described
for your students.
Definitions Comments
23
'learner centred approach' :
Reflective activity 8
Based on the descriptions of active learning given above, please provide your definition
of active learning.
Reflective activity 9
Here are nine active learning methods. A description of each of them is provided in the
table below with appropriate examples. Please match the names of the methods with their
descriptions.
25
Hot seating Decision line Case study
24
(4) In a History course/module student are given the names of 10
important characters in Ethiopia who are floating in the basket of a
hot air balloon in the sky above the Indian Ocean. The balloon is
sinking, and the only way to keep it from falling into the sea is to
‘throw out’ one of the characters. Which character would you
throw out first? Second? Third? Etc. The decision is to be based on
a certain criteria of worth. This method can be used in any subject,
for example with famous scientists, modern inventions,
characteristics of good teachers, etc.
(5) Students are divided into groups to discuss a given topic in any
subject. After 5 minutes, 2 members of each group move to the
next group to share ideas from the first group and to join a new
discussion. After another 5 minutes they move again, so that
during the course of the lesson all students have been able to share
information. This avoids the need for a lot of feedback.
(6) One member of the class is assigned to be a character from
literature, history, science etc. This member is placed in the centre
of the room to role play the character. Other members of the group
direct questions to the person in the centre that has to respond in
role. After 10 minutes, change the person in the centre and the
character.
(7) You organize students into groups for a particular topic, give clear
instructions and explain how you want them to work together. You
may assign different group behaviours to each member of the
group e.g. facilitator, note taker, time keeper, leader, observer,
reporter. Students are expected to interact, share ideas and ask
their peers first if they need help. They are all responsible for the
outcomes, which are evaluated against agreed criteria. Over a
series of sessions, each group member can be asked to take on
different responsibilities so all students are encouraged to develop
25
different skills.
(8) You are planning a lesson on the characteristics of good teaching.
Instead of giving students a list of these characteristics, you
provide a description of six different teachers and what they do in
their classrooms. The students have to identify the positive and
negative characteristics of each teacher. The whole class then
comes to an agreement of the characteristics of good teaching.
(9) You want to encourage students to think about a topic and form an
opinion that they can defend. E.g. genetic engineering can help in
food security. Students are asked to physically move and stand in a
line that represents a continuum from strong agreement with the
statement to strong disagreement with the statement. Students then
have to find a partner and explain why they chose to stand at a
particular point on the line.
Reflective activity 10
1. Did your teacher use one of the above active learning methods when you were a
student? If so, which? If no, why?
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
______
2. Which of the above active learning methods can you comfortably use to teach
topics/lessons in your area? Please justify your answer.
28
28
2.5. Collaborative and Independent learning (2 hrs.)
(a) Collaborative Learning
Barkley, Cross and Major (2005) stated that collaborative learning assumes
knowledge is socially produced and this process of learning facilitates the group
meaning making process. Knowledge is something people construct and not
something that exists out there for people to discover it. As collaborative learning
actively engages students in the process of learning, students will be less dependent on
the teacher.
There are two basic claims for collaborative learning: (1) it contributes to content
mastery, critical thinking, problem solving and other cognitive attributes, and (2) it
contributes to the development of interpersonal skills and other cognitive factors.
Whereas the goal of Collaborative Learning is to develop autonomous thinking people,
Cooperative Learning is to work together in harmony and mutual support to find
solutions to problems.
29
29
Reflective activity 11
(1) In higher education collaborative learning takes different forms. Would you please
present the kinds (forms) of collaborative learning you are familiar with?
(2) How do you group your students for collaborative learning activities?
(3) In your view, what are the challenges to collaborative learning in Ethiopian higher
education?
(1) The teacher must be prepared to ‘let go’ and trust their students to take responsibility
for their own learning. This will mean placing more emphasis on guiding, coaching
30
30
and supporting students to explore the subject on their own or in groups.
(2) The students need to want to take responsibility for their own learning. To achieve
this goal students need support and encouragement to increase their motivation and
A teacher cannot give empowerment; it can be constructed by the actions the teacher and
the student take. Helping students to become independent learners involves:
Helping them develop their skills for life and eventually for employability
Reflective activity 12
31
31
Dear HDL/HDT, please ask two members to search for and review the following
articles and present the review to the class. The articles are:
Robert B. Barr and John Tagg (Nov 1995) “From teaching to learning-A new
paradigm for undergraduate education, Change, 27 (6), 12-25.
As the common sense tells, ‘large class size’ is any number of students in a classroom
beyond which a teacher does n o t feel convenient to manage. It is task dependent
(compare class size for clinical courses and those for general knowledge courses). The
ideal class size is a sort of one-to-one situation (e.g. the Socratic approach). As noted
above, we cannot always control class size due to scarcity of resources and due to the
current push for economic efficiency.
32
32
Reflective activity 13
In a large class in higher education context the most commonly used method is the
lecture method. This is a situation where the teacher is the principal presenter. There are
three important questions to make productive lecture in large class:
Reflective activity 14
(1) In your opinion, are the questions asked above so as to make lecture productive
important? Why?
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
(3) Some say, “Since higher education students are adults, we don’t have to worry about
the structure of our presentations.” Do you agree or disagree with this saying? Justify
your position.
33
33
.
(4) What is your experience of teaching in large classes? What were the challenges?
What did you do to make learning possible in large classes?
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
34
34
Unit 3: Learning Assessment and Grading
The assessment of learning in higher education in general and at Addis Ababa University
in particular should be done with the objectives that it guides and encourages effective
approaches to learning; validly and reliably measures expected learning outcomes, in
particular the higher-order learning that characterizes higher education; and that it defines
and protects academic standards. HDP candidates are, therefore, expected to revisit their
own practice related to assessment of students learning and are encouraged to make some
adjustments as required.
In this unit, attempt has been made to introduce the various concepts used in educational
assessment and different types of assessment procedures used in the process of assessing
students’ learning.
35
35
Learning Outcomes
In the contemporary higher education the increase in enrolment and the shrinking unit of
resource create pressure for more cost-effective assessment methods. The pressure also
comes from the introduction of modularization which has increased the volume of
assessment as each small block of learning must be formally assessed and graded. The
tendency on the part of students, particularly at graduate level, to relay on part -time work
and other commitments appear to be turning students into very strategic learners (Kneale
1997 as cited in Bloxham and Boyd, 2007) and unwilling to devote effort to study create
another pressure in the assessment process.
Moreover, the employability and graduate skills agenda is placing pressure on instructors
to design assignments and examinations which assess a much broader range of
competences. Instructors are therefore expected to modify assessment procedures so that
they support learning through student involvement in assessment, prompt feedback,
flexible and formative approaches and by the use of a wide variety of assessment
methods.
36
36
In general, we assess our students, among others, due to the desire to:
determine the extent to which the intended learning outcomes of the module/
course are being achieved,
Reflective activity 15
(1) Write a brief summary of the meanings of and levels in cognitive, affective and
psychomotor domains and present it for your HDP team.
2) It is often stated that Continuous Assessment is systematic, comprehensive,
cumulative, and guidance oriented. Please discuss the implication of each of these
attributes of continuous assessment and write a brief note on the space provided.____
____________________________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________________
37
37
____________________________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________________
(3) Read the statements in the table below and decide whether the statement refers to CA.
Mark each statement as Yes or No in the right hand column. Compare and discuss
your responses with other colleagues.
(a) You prepare and administer five tests during the course period with a
constant time interval.
(b) You may collect data on students’ classroom participation on regular basis
as part of the assessment process.
(c) You provided two tests and one project or term paper during the semester.
ensures that the learning styles of all students including those with disabilities are
accommodated.
38
38
3.4. Assessment for and of Learning
Assessment for learning, also known as formative assessment, is defined as ―all those
activities undertaken by teachers and/or students, which provide information to be used
as feedback to modify the teaching and learning activities in which they are engaged
(Black and William, 2004). It is conducted while learning is still underway. As an
assessment for learning, formative assessment requires high quality interactions,
involving students in their learning, providing timely feedback and sharing criteria for the
process of assessment. Assessments of learning are those assessments that happen after
learning is supposed to have occurred to determine if it did. It generally occurs at the
conclusion of a class, course, semester, or academic year. At the individual level,
39
39
assessment of learning can have a sorting function, separating qualified students from
unqualified students (Terenzini, 1989).
Reflective activity 16
Discuss in a group of three your assessment practices. Relate to the idea of ‘assessment
for learning’ presented above. After the discussion, please write in the space provided
below what you want to change to make proper use of assessment for learning.
The following are the general principles of assessment as indicated in Miller, Linn and
Gronlund (2009).
Dear participants, after the HDP team discusses these principles, please indicate which of
them holds true in your assessment practice so far. Indicate also what you would like to
improve in the future.
40
40
.
Reflective activity 17
41
41
Development Centre of Victoria University of Wellington (2004), instructors should
answer the following questions before finalizing an assessment program.
Should you give students all the same mark or a mark based on each person's
contribution to the group performance?
If you assess each student's contribution, how will you know what each person
has contributed?
What do you do if a group member leaves, thus leaving the group with a gap in
the allocation of duties to members?
A fundamental principle that should inform all assessment decisions is that marks should
be allocated in a way that is consistent with achieving the learning outcomes of the
course. It is also important to take into account that learning in higher educational
institutions is based on an assumption that final grades reflect individual student
achievement. Whenever groups are assessed there must be room for assessing the
contributions of individual members of a group. That is, the allocation of individual
grades should take account of the contribution of each member. However, caution must
be taken so that this action may not contradict the feeling of collaboration that this type of
work is going to develop.
The contribution of individual member of the group can be identified using any one or
more of the following assessment methods:
Reflective activity 18
(1) Have you ever used the methods of identifying the contribution of individual group
members mentioned above? If yes, which method (s) have you used? Please state your
experience and present to the HDP team.
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________.
(2) Do you think that it is practical/feasible to use these methods in most of Addis
Ababa University classrooms?
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________.
43
43
Summary of Planning for Assessment for and Assessment of Learning
Ensuring Accuracy and consistency of observations and Accuracy, consistency, and fairness of judgments based on
Quality interpretations of student learning high-quality information
Clear, detailed learning expectations Clear, detailed learning expectations
Accurate, detailed notes for descriptive feedback to each Fair and accurate summative reporting
student
Using the Provide each student with accurate descriptive feedback to Indicate each student’s level of learning
Information further his or her learning Provide the foundation for discussions on placement or
Differentiate instruction by continually checking where promotion
each student is in relation to the curricular outcomes Report fair, accurate, and detailed information that can be
Provide parents or guardians with descriptive feedback used to decide the next steps in a student’s learning
about student learning and ideas for support
41
3.7. Methods of Assessment
While all learning outcomes should be assessable, the tradition in universities and higher
learning institutions is to design assessment schemes that only measure some of these
learning outcomes. These assessment schemes are mainly meant for measuring the
knowledge base associated with a course or module but should be less so of skill base.
There are also learning outcomes which are beyond knowledge and skill that need to be
assessed in higher educational institutions like work habits, social and scientific attitudes,
academic self-concept, interests, appreciations, and social adjustments (Miller, Linn and
Gronlund, 2009). It is important to select assessment techniques that will most directly
assess all types of learning outcomes that a course or module is designed to develop in
students.
There are different methods of assessment used in the process of assessing students’
learning in higher learning educational institutions. Some of such methods are presented
in the following table:
(1) Essays A standard method, essentially concerned with trying out ideas
and arguments, supported by evidence. Has potential for
measuring understanding, synthesis and evaluative skills. In most
essays, there are no absolutely right or wrong answers and
marking for feedback can be time consuming.
(2) Case Studies and Case studies have potential for measuring application of
Open Problems knowledge, analysis, problem-solving and evaluative skills. This
method allows students to apply theory to practical situations.
42
(3) Projects Good all-round ability testing. Potential for sampling wide range
(Individual and/or of practical, analytical and interpretative skills. Develops
Group) instructor/student and student/student relationships. Wider
application of knowledge and skills to real/simulated situations.
Motivation tends to be high. The assessment methods may include
seminars and tutorials, case studies, simulation, role-plays,
problem solving exercises, team-building and experiential (‘live’
project) learning.
(4) Seminar Feedback potential from tutor, self and/or peers; assesses
Presentations preparation, understanding, knowledge, capacity to structure
information and oral communication skills. Can broaden possible
topic and approaches.
(5) Laboratory/ Can be used to assess preparation and practical skills and can help
Clinical Practical broaden topic and approaches, particularly in terms of application
Work of knowledge.
43
Formative feedback potential.
(11) Short Answer, Simple learning outcomes usually at knowledge levels are being
True – False, & assessed with the use of such assessment procedures.
Matching
Reflective activity 19
(1) Please prepare a brief summary of the strengths and limitations of each of the above
listed methods of assessment and submit for grading.
(3) Are there assessment methods which you make use of yet not mentioned here? If
yes, please state and describe them.
44
.
The assessment method does not test any significant learning outcomes that are not
explicitly stated as such. Assessment should never go beyond the learning outcomes.
Please avoid over-assessing students.
While planning for methods of assessment, give attention to the following things:
45
........................... instruction
3.8. Self-Assessment
Planning My Assessment Practices
With the subject matter and grade level at which you plan to teach in mind, examine the
following list of assessments that we have discussed in this chapter. Rate each of the
assessments on this scale: 1 = I don’t plan to use this at all, 2 = I plan to use this
occasionally, 3 = I plan to use this moderately, 4 = I plan to use this often, and 5 = This
will be one of the most important assessments I will use.
(3) Reviews
46
(8) Matching
(10) Essays
(11) Projects
(14) Performances
(laboratory, clinical, etc.)
(15) Portfolios
Using assessment sheet: since objectivity is central to assessment and marking, we need
to develop some kind of assessment sheet depending on what we want to assess. For
instance, the assessment sheet we use to assess a presentation, a portfolio, or
contributions during classroom interactions vary significantly. One thing is true though:
we need to have assessment sheet with clear criteria. Dear participant, what is your
experience in this regard? Please write your reflections in the space given below.
47
3.9. Test Construction (3 hrs.)
Test construction mainly deals with the preparation of classroom tests. Classroom tests
provide instructors with essential information used to make decisions about instruction
and student grades. Too often, teachers give little thought to the preparation of their tests
until the last minute and then rush to get the job done (Oermann and Gaberson, 2009). A
test that is constructed in this manner often contains items that are poorly chosen,
ambiguous, and either too easy or too difficult, as well as with all kinds of errors
including grammatical, spelling, and other topographic errors. This shows that test
construction requires planning and the construction of good tests also need skill in test
construction apart from the knowledge of the subject matter.
Good tests require adequate and extensive planning so that the instructional objectives,
the teaching strategy to be employed, the textual material, and the evaluative procedure
are all related in some meaningful fashion. The steps that would be followed in the
construction of classroom tests can be summarized in the following manner:
Outline subject-matter content to be considered as the basis for the test: we may
not consider all contents in a course. For such a selection we often refer to
learning outcomes to be assessed.
Prepare table of specifications: this is a table prepared to relate course content with
the instructional objectives (or learning outcomes). It indicates emphasis to be
given to each learning outcomes while preparing assessment procedure – e.g.
number of items to be drawn from each area.
48
Choose appropriate type (s) of test items for evaluation of learning outcomes as
summarized in the table of specifications.
Write test items according to rules of construction for the type (s) chosen.
Arrange items: decide on grouping of items; sequence of items within groups and
sequence of groupings
Prepare directions for the test; if necessary, prepare directions for individual item
format or for sections.
Reflective activity 20
(2) How does your experience of test preparation compare with the Steps in Test
Construction discussed above? Please write a note on your observations including
what you would like to improve, if any.
(3) Please browse the internet and prepare a brief summary of the suggestions for
constructing each of the tests (including Multiple Choice, True-false, Matching,
Completion, Interpretative Exercises, Essay) and submit for grading.
49
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
4) It is said that using table of specifications helps instructors ensure content validity of a
test. Discuss the meaning of content validity and how table of specifications helps
instructors ensure content validity.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
(5) Please prepare a table of specification for one of your courses – ask the support of
the HDL/HDT, if needed.
Begin writing items far enough in advance so that you will have time to revise them
Match items to intended outcomes at the proper difficulty level to provide a valid
measure of instructional objectives. Limit the questions to the skill being assessed
Be sure each item deals with an important aspect of the content area and not with
trivia.
Be sure that each item is independent of all other items. The answer to one item
should not be required as a condition for answering the next item. A hint to one
answer should not be embodied in another item
Be sure that the item has one correct or best answer on which experts would
agree.
50
Avoid replication of the textbook in writing test items; don’t quote directly from
textual materials. You are usually not interested in how well the student
memorized the text. Besides, taken out of context, direct quotes from the text are
often ambiguous
Avoid trick or catch questions in an achievement test. Don’t waste time testing
how well the students can interpret your intentions, and
Try to write items that require higher level thinking. Here you need to write
objectives that measure comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis, or
evaluation to ensure that your items will be at the higher than knowledge level and
write items that match these objectives. Dear HDL/HDT, please ask the
participants to discuss each of these guiding criteria in group.
3.10. Grading
Introduction
Grading is a process of translating descriptive assessment information into letters,
numbers, or other marks that indicate the quality of a student’s learning or performance
(Santrock, 2011). Grades are important for students as well as for instructors as they
influence a wide variety of opportunities such as access to scholarships, awards,
advanced education and employment. Hence, instructors should pay attention to grade
and the system of grading while assessing and describing students’ learning. In this
section an attempt shall be made to bring to your attention the various aspects of
grading.
Administrative - grades help determine, for example, credits for graduation and
promote students to the next level.
51
Informational - grades can be used to communicate with students and others (such
as registrar office).
What aspects of students’ performance will you use to assign grades, and
How will you weight different kinds of evidences you obtained from different
sources in giving grades.
When teachers fail to carefully consider these guidelines, variability occurs in their
grading practice which obviously disadvantages some students and communicates faulty
performance report.
Reflective activity: 21
(1) Review the Addis Ababa University Guidelines on Grading, Examination and
Assessment of Student Learning and share your understanding of the guideline with
your colleagues.
52
(2) In your opinion, is it possible to implement this guideline as it is?
______________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
(3) What mechanisms do you use to reduce variability in grading and to increase its
objectivity?
The grading process should be impartial and compare each student to the same
criteria
Grades should be based on sufficient data to permit you to make valid evaluations
of student achievement
53
viewed as the ends of a continuum rather than as a clear-cut dichotomy. Criterion-referenced
test emphasizes description of performance, and the norm-referenced test emphasizes
discrimination among individuals.
Reflective activity: 22
1. While assessing your students’ learning, was it Norm-Referenced or Criterion-
Referenced Assessment that you were using predominantly? Why?
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
2. Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of Norm-Referenced and Criterion-
Referenced Assessments.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
3. According to the Senate Legislation of the Addis Ababa University, is the assessment
system Norm-Referenced or Criterion-Referenced? Why?
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
Scoring Rubrics
Connoley (2004) proposed that a rubric, or scoring matrix, is a very useful device for
presenting criterion-referenced assessment tasks. A rubric is designed to make grading
easier and faster, as well as to provide more useful feedback to students. When grading
projects, essays, portfolios, performances, rubrics scoring rubrics offer an easy, fast, and
consistent method for grading. Miller, Linn and Gronlund (2009) considered a
scoring rubric as a set of guidelines for the application of performance criteria to the
responses and performance of students. It typically consists of verbal descriptions (set of
characteristics) of performance or aspects of student responses. A rubric is a printed set
of scoring guidelines (criteria) for evaluating work (a performance or a product) and for
giving feedback.
54
A rubric is usually handed out before the assignment begins in order to get students to
think about the criteria on which their work will be judged. It is suggested that rubrics
improve students' end products and therefore increase learning. When teachers evaluate
papers or projects, they know implicitly what makes a good final product and why. When
students receive rubrics beforehand, they understand how they will be evaluated and can
prepare accordingly.
Teachers can increase the quality of their direct instruction by providing focus,
emphasis, and attention to particular details as a model for students
Reflective activity 23
(1) Some argue that students will perform better if they understand how they will be
graded in advance. What is your reaction?
(2) Do fellow instructors in the subject you teach follow the same criteria for grading
students’ performance? If not, what are the possible reasons?
(3) Do you think that instructors and students have the same understanding of
assessment criteria most of the time?
55
________________________________________________________________________________
(4) Do instructors teaching the same course share the same understanding of
assessment criteria?
Miller, Linn and Gronlund (2009) provide the following guideline for teachers/instructors
to follow while grading:
Make clear to students that course grade will be based on achievement only.
Explain how other elements (effort, work habits, and personal – social
characteristics) will be reported.
Relate the grading procedures to the intended learning outcomes (i.e., instructional
goals and objectives).
Obtain valid evidence (e.g., tests, assessments, reports, or ratings) as a basis for
assigning grades.
Take precautions to prevent cheating on tests and assessments.
Return and review all test and assessment results as soon as possible.
Be fair. Avoid bias, and when in doubt (as with a borderline score), review the
evidence. If still in doubt, assign the higher grade.
56
Dear participant, which of these guidelines do you think would be difficult to follow?
Why?
3.11. The Importance of Feedback
[
Reflective activity 24
57
(4) Should it be oral or written? Which of these is more effective?
____________________________________________________________
(6) What is your experience of providing feedback? Do you think you have benefited
from this practice?
58
Unit 4 Student Advisement and Support
4.1. Introduction
Student advising plays crucial role in helping higher learning institutions retain their
students and minimize the rate of attrition (Nutt, 2003). It is, therefore, critical that
students learn to take full responsibility for their education and their academic progress.
Cuseo (2003) mentioned that academic advising exerts a significant impact on student
retention through its positive association with, and mediation of, variables that are
strongly correlated with student persistence, namely: (1) student satisfaction with the
college experience, (2) effective educational and career planning and decision making,
(3) student utilization of campus support services, (4) student-faculty contact outside the
classroom, and (5) student mentoring. Other researchers (e.g., Pargett, 2011) also
indicated the positive effect of advising on student development. According to this writer
the discussion between a student and his or her advisor on personal and school-related
issues, career options, college policies, academic deadlines, and study skills and tips
increase student’s level of satisfaction with college and enhances student’s positive
development.
The purpose of student advising and support services is to help students set out their
life/career goals, develop meaningful plans to achieve those goals, evaluate their
progress, resolve challenges they might encounter in the process of achieving their goals,
understand policies and procedures of the University, engage fully in their education, and
assume responsibility for their lives, their success, and their future career.
59
Learning outcomes
At the end of this unit, the HDP candidates will be able to:
Help students in developing and achieving realistic academic and career goals
based on learner’s interests, abilities, values, and needs
Guide students toward appropriate resources, including the counselling centre, the
Office of Dean of Student, etc.
There are many services and support programs available on campus by different parties.
Student support services are critical to student success, especially at campuses that enroll
large numbers of students with diverse background. These programs assist students in
addressing areas of academic deficiency and provide necessary resources to maximize
students’ intellectual and social capital while in the University. Designed to facilitate
students’ transition into college, promote retention, and lead to graduation, student
support services are most effective when they are tailored to match the campus culture
and address the needs of the typical student on the campus.
Advisors should be able to provide students particularly new entrants with valuable and
appropriate information about the services that are available. The provision of such
information would help students adjust to campus life and focus on their learning. Some
of the on-campus services include:
59
Dean of students
Academic advising
Library service
Campus security
Counselling services
club activities
Health services
It has to be clear that some of the services are commonly required by all students and other
services are required by some. Advisors need to be aware of the services that are made available
to students and become familiar with each of the services that are made available.
Reflective activity 25
(1) In a group of three, please examine the situation of student support services at Addis
Ababa University. Note what you would learn in the space provided below.
60
(2) List out what can be done to provide effective student support services. Include what you
can do in this process.
An advisor is someone who helps students become more self-aware of their distinctive interests,
talents, values, and priorities; who enables students to see the connection between their present
academic experience and their future life plans; who broadens students’ perspectives with respect
to their personal life choices, and sharpens their cognitive skills for making these choices—e.g.,
effective problem-solving, critical thinking, and reflective decision-making. The work of
advisors is based on the belief that, students:
have diverse backgrounds that can include different ethnic, racial, domestic, and
international communities; ages; gender and gender identities; physical, emotional, and
psychological abilities; political, religious, and educational beliefs,
hold their own beliefs and opinions,
are responsible for their own behaviours and the outcomes of those behaviours,
61
have learning needs that vary based upon individual skills, goals, responsibilities, and
experiences, and
use a variety of techniques and technologies to navigate their world.
Reflective activity 26
As a member of your academic department, you might have served as academic advisor or else
you have received academic advisement services as a student. Hence, from your experience:
(1) What should come under academic advising or what areas/concerns should academic
advising cover?
___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
(2) What are the challenges and opportunities to academic advising, if any, at Addis Ababa
University?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
62
Unit 5: Managing Student Discipline
5.1. Introduction
Anderson & Van Dyke (cited in Ajayi and Adeniji, 2009) considered discipline as a state of
order based on submission to rules and authority. Defined this way, individuals tend to perceive
discipline either positively or negatively. Discipline to some may involve punishment, repression
and sternness, infliction of pain, restriction of freedom, threat and outright condemnation. To
others, it is viewed as a way of guiding the individual to make reasonable decisions, to help
teachers in class to achieve desirable behaviour, to train the minds of others for constructive
purposes, willingness to obey orders or simple instructions, gentleness, simplicity and quietness
(Ajayi and Adeniji, 2009). If seen positively, considerable intellectual discipline and respecting
the rules and regulations of the institutions is important for the process of inquiry. The process of
inquiry helps students acquire the attitudes and skills to become critical thinkers and to continue
their learning beyond the narrow scope and time limit of a formal educational experience.
Discipline is essential for deep and meaningful experience. Discipline provides the mind-set to
engage in critical discourse and reflect ion. For tacit knowledge and individual insights to be
externalized and made explicit, students must have the discipline to engage in educational
experience. In this lesson an attempt has been made to identify the possible disciplinary
problems that instructors may encounter and the methods of dealing with these disciplinary
problems.
63
Learning outcomes
At the end of this lesson, HDP candidates will be able to:
Identify the common type of disciplinary problems in their institutions;
Ajayi and Adeniji (2009) categorized the causes of disciplinary problems at tertiary institutions
in the following manner:
College factor
Teacher factor
Societal factor
Government Influence
Dear HDL/HDT, please group the participants to discuss on these causes of disciplinary
problems. Encourage them to bring in and reflect on their own encounters.
Disciplinary problems in higher learning institutions manifest in various ways. Seeman (2010:
21) identified the following as disruptive behaviours that instructors encounter in institutions of
higher education. Some of these are extreme disruptive behaviours than others and some are
campus wide disruptive behaviours that would affect the overall teaching-learning process. The
disruptive behaviours include the following.
64
Not respecting the rights of other students’ viewpoints
Inappropriate demands or too many demands for the instructor’s time and attention
Sexual assaults/rape
Binge drinking
Seeman (2010) argued that not all behaviours listed above as disruptive should be handled with
the same treatment from instructors or university management. Not all behaviours that are
disruptive are ―discipline problems. According to Seeman, a disrupt ive behaviour is a real
discipline problem when it is a behaviour (not merely the expression of a feeling) that disrupts
65
(or is potentially disruptive to) the learning of the rest of the class (not just the learning of the
disrupter), or disrupts the role responsibilities of the teacher (not just the personal feelings of the
teacher).
Reflective activity 27
Present your work to the class. Discuss on what has been presented and try to reach a consensus
about the disruptive behaviours observed at AAU.
As explained earlier, all discipline problems cannot be handled in the same way by the instructor.
Some of discipline problems will be handled by the university management with clearly
established rules and regulations and some could be handled by the instructor in the classroom or
out of the classroom conditions. In-class discipline problems should be handled by the teacher
and the teacher should be able to use their own strategies to deal with discipline problems.
66
Reflective activity 28
Here are some techniques you may consider as you try to maintain acceptable disciple in your
classroom:
Spell out carefully your rules and grading system in your course syllabus as best as you can.
Try to keep careful records of your judgments, grades, and criteria.
The best way to handle cheating during exam is by curtailing and preventing it . Devise
mechanisms for in-built ways of discouraging cheating on exams.
Dear HDL/HDT, please ask participants to reflect on mechanisms they used to apply to
discourage cheating on examinations and/or plagiarism when students conduct their
research projects.
Managing student discipline does not mean keeping students quiet and orderly but one in which
their voices and behaviours serve the purpose of learning (Moreno, 2010). Therefore, having a
quiet classroom should not be taken as a sign of successfully managing student discipline.
Instead, you should think about whether the management methods that you use in the classrooms
are conducive to the learning and motivation of all students. Effective management of student
discipline should maximize students’ learning opportunities.
67
Module Assessment
2. Write a reflective comment on your overall performance and achievements in this Module.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
3. Would you say that for your overall performance in this Module you should receive a
PASS or REFER? Underline one.
68
II) Higher Diploma Leader’s Module Assessment
2. Please comment specifically on areas where you disagree with the self-assessment. Please
comment on what the candidate should do in the next Module to improve.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
69
References
Ajayi, K. & Adeniji, A. (2009). Pursuing Discipline and Ethical Issues in Tertiary Institutions in
Nigeria. African Review: An International Multi-Disciplinary Journal, 3 (1), 284-300.
Bigge, Morris L. and S. Samuel Shermis (2004). Learning Theories for Teachers: Classic Edition
(6th ed.). Boston: Pearson.
Brown, Sally and Peter Knight (1994). Assessing Learners in Higher Education. London:
RoutledgeFalmer.
Cuseo, Joe. (2003). "Academic advisement and student retention: Empirical connections and
systemic interventions." National Academic Advising Association.(linked from
http://www. nacada. ksu. edu/clearinghouse /advisingissues/retain. htm, retrieved 10-15-
08)
Erwin, TD (1991). Assessing Student Learning and Development. San Francisco CA: Jossey
Bass.
James, Mary (1998). Using Assessment for School Improvement. Chicago: Heinemann.
Kellough, Rechard. (2003). A Resource Guide for Teaching. (4th ed.). New Jersey: Merrill
Prentice Hall.
Kubiszyn, T. & Borich, G. (2003). Educational Testing and Measurement: Classroom
Application and Practice (7th ed.). USA: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
70
Kyriacou, Chris (1998). Essential Teaching Skills. (2nded.). Cheltenham: Nelson Thornes Ltd.
Manen ,M.V.(1992). The tact of teaching: The meaning of pedagogical thoughtfulness. USA:
State University of New York press.
McCombs, Barbara L. and Jo Sue Whisler (1997). The Learner-Centred Classroom and School:
Strategies for increasing student motivation and achievement. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass
Publishers.
Moreno, R. (2010). Educational Psychology. USA: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
NACADA (2005). NACADA Statement of Core Values of Academic Advising. Retrieved fro m
the NACADA Clearinghouse of Academic Advising Resources Web site.
http://www.nacada.ksu.edu/Resources/Clearinghouse/View-Articles/Core-values-of-
academic-advising.aspx
Nutt, C. L. (2003). Academic Advising and Student Retention and Persistence. Retrieved August
7, 2013from the NACADA Clearinghouse of Academic Advising Resources Web
site.http://www.nacada.ksu.edu/tabid/3318/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/636/article.as
px
Oermann, M. H. & Gaberson, K.B. (2009). Evaluation and Testing in Nursing Education (3rd
ed.). New York: Springer Publishing Company.
71
Arts. University of Nebraska – Lincoln.
Plessis, J., et al (2003). Continuous assessment: A practical guide for teachers. Washington, DC:
American Institutes for Research.
Santrock, J.W. (2011). Educational Psychology (5th ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.
Sliberman, M (1996). Active Learning: 101 strategies to teach and subject. Boston: Allyn and
Bacon.
Turnbull, J (2009). Coaching for Learning. London: Continuum International Publishing Group.
University Teaching Development Centre (2004). Improving Teaching and Learning: Group
Work and Group Assessment. Victoria University of Wellington.
72