Paper Fytofarmaka 5
Paper Fytofarmaka 5
Paper Fytofarmaka 5
Me t h od 6 3 8 9 9
of Pesticide Residues by Gas Chromatography –
Triple-Stage Quadrupole Mass Spectrometry
Laszlo Hollosi, Katerina Bousova, Michal Godula
Thermo Fisher Scientific, Food Safety Response Center, Dreieich, Germany
Key Words
TraceFinder, TSQ, Chromatography, GC, GC-MS, Pesticide Residues,
QuEChERS, Triple Quadrupole
1. Schematic of Method
Homogenization
Sample + IS
Extraction
2. Introduction
Pesticide residue analysis in food is one of the most
2. Add 9.8 mL acetonitrile (20 mL water + 10 mL
important and challenging tasks in routine laboratory
acetonitrile for wheat flour) and 200 μL stock IS
practice. The European legislation, which is currently the
3.
Shake for 10 min, centrifuge at 5000 rpm for 5 min
most strict legislation (European Regulation 396/2005
and Commission Directive 2006/125/EC), sets maximum
residue limits (MRL) of pesticides in different products
Clean up
of plant and animal origin. This presents a significant
analytical challenge with respect to the low limits of
4. Transfer supernatant into a 15 mL clean-up tube
quantification (LOQ) required for some specified food
5. Centrifuge samples at 5000 rpm for 5 min matrices. A variety of GC and HPLC methods have been
6. Transfer supernatant into a GC vial developed for multi-residue determination of pesticides
7. Add 50 µL sorbitol and 20 µL of injection standard employing a variety of sample preparation and cleanup
techniques. In recent years the QuEChERS method has
become widely adopted for preparing samples of fruit
GC-MS/MS and vegetables, but the continuous need for more
sensitive and accurate measurements requires new
developments from the instrument producers as well.
2
7.1 Individual Pesticide Standard Stock Solutions 8.1 Fisher precision balance XP-1500FR
Prepared gravimetrically in ~1000 mg/L concentration
8.2 Sartorius analytical balance ME235S
by weighing 10 mg from each analyte into a 20 mL
amber screw cap vial on a five digit analytical balance 8.3 Thermo Barnstead EASYpure®II water 3125753
and dissolving in 10 mL of appropriate solvent (acetone,
8.4 ULTRA-TURRAX – G25 dispergation tool
®
1713300
toluene or acetonitrile depending on the individual
compound). Concentrations of each individual standard 8.5 ULTRA-TURRAX 3565000
stock solutions were calculated gravimetrically using 8.6 Vortex shaker 3205025
weight of added compounds and solvents. All individual
standard stocks were stored in a freezer at -20 °C. 8.7 Vortex universal cap 3205029
Validity of individual standard stock solutions was 8.8 Horizontal shaker 1069-3391
6 months.
8.9 Horizontal shaker plate 1053-0102
7.2 Intermediate Standard Stock and Working 8.10 Thermo Heraeus Freco 17 micro centrifuge 3208590
Standard Solutions
Prepared by pipetting the appropriate amount of each 8.11 Pesticide Analyzer (TSQ 8000 Triple Stage
Quadrupole GC-MS with Thermo Scientific™
individual standard stock and diluting it with acetoni-
TRACE™ 1310)
trile. The concentration of intermediate standard stock
solutions was 5000 ng/mL. Working standards were
prepared by diluting intermediate standard stock
solution accordingly. Intermediate standard stock 9. Consumables Part Number
solutions were stored in a freezer at -20 °C, and the 9.1 GC vial kit 60180-599
working solutions in a fridge at 4 °C. Validity of
intermediate stock solutions was 3 months. 9.2 Pipette Finnpipette 100–1000 µL 3214535
9.3 Pipette Finnpipette 10–100 µL 3166472
7.3 Individual Internal Standard Stock Solutions
Prepared gravimetrically in ~1000 mg/L concentration 9.4 Pipette Finnpipette 500–5000 µL 3166473
by weighing 10 mg from each analyte into a 20 mL 9.5 Pipette holder 3651211
amber screw cap vial on a five digit analytical balance
and dissolving in 10 mL of acetone for TPP and 10 mL 9.6 Pipette tips 0.5–250 µL, 500/box 3270399
toluene for BFB. Exact concentration values were 9.7 Pipette tips 1–5 mL, 75/box 3270420
determined based on the gravimetrical values of both
9.8 Pipette tips 100–1000 µL, 200/box 3270410
weighed compound and added solvent. Individual
internal standard stock solutions were stored in a freezer 9.9 Spatula, 18/10 steel 3458179
at -20 °C. Validity of individual internal standard stock 9.10 Spatula, nylon 3047217
solutions was 6 months.
9.11 Centrifuge tube rack 1066-3721
7.4 Working Internal Standard Stock Solutions
9.12 QuEChERS extraction tube, 50 mL, 250 pack 60105-216
Prepared individually by pipetting the appropriate
amount of each individual standard stock solution and 9.13 QuEChERS clean-up tube, 15 mL, 50 pack 60105-225
diluting it with acetonitrile. The concentration of 9.14 GC column Thermo Scientific TraceGOLD
™ ™
working internal standard stock solutions was 5000 ng/mL TG-5SilMS, 30 m × 0.25 × 0.25 mm 10177894
and was used for direct spiking of the samples. Validity
9.15 PTV Baffle Liner (Siltek), Deactivated,
of working stock solutions was 3 months.
2 mm ID × 2.75 mm OD × 120 mm Length 453T2120
7.5 1% Sorbitol Solution (Analyte Protectant) 9.16 2 mL vial rack 12211001
Prepared in 70/30 v/v% ACN/H 2O and used for adding
prior to injection. Protectant solution was added to the
sample prior to injection in order to prevent undesired
10. Glassware Part Number
analyte interaction and consequent losses during the
injection.8 10.1 Volumetric flask, 10 mL FB50143
10.2 Volumetric flask, 25 mL FB50147
10.3 40 mL screw cap vial 1054-1593
10.4 Caps for 40 mL screw cap vial 1009-0962
10.5 500 mL bottle 9653640
10.6 100 mL bottle 1006-8060
4
11.1.2.3 Add 10 mL ACN to SB and LK samples. For PTV cleaning flow: 75 mL/min
WF, first add 20 mL H 2O to the samples, let it PTV cleaning phase: post cycle temperature cool down
completely wet the sample and then add 10 mL
ACN to it.
The GC oven settings were as follows:
11.1.2.4 Shake samples for 10 min on a horizontal
shaker and centrifuge with 5000 rpm for 5 min. Carrier gas: 1.2 mL/min Helium (constant flow)
Transfer supernatant (~8 mL) into the 15 mL
PTV cleaning phase: post cycle temperature cool down
QuEChERS clean-up tubes containing 1200 mg
MgSO4, 400 mg PSA and 400 mg C18.
Table 1. GC temperature programming
11.1.2.5 Vortex for 1 min and centrifuge samples with
Rate Temperature Hold Time
5000 rpm for 5 min. #
[°C/min] [°C] [min]
11.1.2.6 Collect supernatant and transfer 1 mL into a Initial 40 1.5
GC vial for instrumental analysis.
1 25 90 1.5
11.1.2.7 Add 50 µL sorbitol solution (protectant) and 2 25 180 0
20 µL 5000 ng/mL injection standard (BFB) to
3 5 280 0
the GC vials prior to injection.
4 10 300 5
5
11.2.2 Triple Quadrupole MS Settings Calculations of sample amount in each sample (the
Mass spectrometric detection was carried out using the absolute amount of pesticide extracted from the sample):
TSQ 8000 triple-quadrupole mass spectrometer in
A analyte X IS
X analyte =
+
timed-SRM mode. All method and SRM settings were
taken from the Thermo Scientific TSQ 8000 Pesticide A IS Rf
+
Analyzer system method.6 Ion ratio values were revised
and adapted for each investigated matrices. Xanalyte – the absolute amount of pesticide that was extracted from
the sample
The settings were as follows:
A analyte – the area of pesticide peak in the sample
Scan type: timed-SRM (details in Table 2) A[IS] – the area of the internal standard peak in the sample
Ionization: EI + X[IS] – the absolute amount of internal standard added to the sample
Calculations of sample amount in each sample (the
MS transfer line temp: 250 °C
absolute amount of pesticide extracted from the sample):
Ion source temp: 300 °C
Cycle time: 0.3 s X analyte
C=
Minimum baseline peak width: 3 s m
Desired scans per peak: 10 m – the weight of sample [g]
12.1 Selectivity
A St c [IS]
+
12.2 Linearity, Response Factor, Matrix Effect compounds in these matrices have to be measured with
The calibration curves were created at six levels (matrix- separate, specially optimized analytical methods.
matched) and injected in duplicate. R f values for internal Method bias was established by means of external
standardization were determined from the calibration quality control materials obtained from FAPAS (York,
curves for all matrices and internal standards by UK). Available FAPAS materials were #19140QC
calculating cumulative average response factor over the (lettuce puree), #19141QC (green bean puree) and
whole calibration range. The linearity of calibration #19142QC (melon puree). The available Fapas samples
curves was assessed in three groups of compounds represented only a limited number of the target com-
(depending on the relevant MRL values) in calibration pounds and different matrices from those targeted.
ranges of 0–200, 0–1000 and 0–2000 ng/g, respectively, However, measured values showed good agreement with
(details and results in Table 3). Calibration levels were the assigned values in all cases except carbofuran, in
equidistantly distributed over the calibration range. which the measured value was slightly below the
Linear function was evaluated according to Mandel’s acceptance range. This could be due to differences
fitting test and plotting of residuals for which <20% between the two different matrix characteristics. Details
acceptance limit was set. 3 Correlation coefficient values on the measured FAPAS values are listed in Table 7.
were additionally established for which an artificial
12.4 (Intermediate) Precision
0.985 was set as an acceptance limit, as no legislative
Instrument injection precision was tested for both
limits are defined for them. The set value wasn’t met for
retention time and peak area for all target compounds
fenpropathrin and dichlofluanid (LK) and propargite
by subsequent injections (n=6) of low concentration level
(WF) based on the high LOQ values related to the
(L1) standard solutions. Instrument injection precision
calibration levels. No weighted function was applied.
for retention time was below 0.5% for all compounds
Matrix effects were evaluated by (Youden-) plotting of and between 1.2–18.04% (fipronil and fenamiphos-
measured relative peak areas of calibration standards in sulfoxide) for peak area without internal standard
solvent against the areas in the relevant matrix. No compensation indicating reliable instrument perfor-
matrix effect is observed if the difference of the slope mance. Method within-day and between-day precision
(dif%) of the fitted line is less than 20% from the ideal values were determined for each matrix at middle
(y=x) curve, while matrix effects are observed when the spiking level (L2) and expressed as %RSD over 3 days
difference is between 20–50% (minor matrix effect) or with individually prepared samples (n=6). Mean
exceeds 50% (major matrix effect). Matrix effect results within-day precision values were determined as an
are listed in Table 3. For the compounds with demon- average of the 3 individual days’ mean precision, while
strated matrix effect application of matrix matched between-day precision was expressed as mean of the
calibration is required. overall precision data. According to SANCO require-
ments <20% was set as acceptance criteria for the target
12.3 Accuracy
compounds and matrices. 3 Measured values are shown
Method trueness was assessed by recovery studies using in Table 5.
blank matrices spiked at three concentration levels (L1,
L2 and L3) and injected in six individually prepared 12.5 Limit of Detection, Limit of Quantification
replicates. (Table 4). Spiking of samples occurred prior Limits of detection and quantification were estimated
to sample preparation. Found concentrations, recovery following the IUPAC. Measured method LOD, LOQ
and relative standard deviation (% RSD) were calculated and the relevant legislative limits (MRLs) are listed in
(Table 5). According to SANCO requirements recovery Table 6.7 An artificial MRL=10 ng/g was set as target
values are deemed acceptable if between 70–120%. 3 value for compounds, for which no MRL values are
Values were calculated only for those cases in which legislatively defined. The expectation of the method was
spiking levels were higher than the compound LOQ in to meet MRL values at least at LOQ level which was
the particular matrix. Recovery values could not been achieved for the vast majority of target compounds. For
established for amitraz in WF and captan, chlorthalonil methiocarb (WF, LK), carbofuran (SW), oxadyxil (WF)
and tolyfluanid in LK matrices due to the high LOQ and propargite (WF, LK) the established LOQ values
values measured relative to the spiked levels. Strong were below the targeted MRLs’ value. However, with
influence of matrix on the results were observed in exchanging of quantifier and qualifier ions the target
several cases and results could not been established at values can be reached. For fenpropathrin (WF, LK),
one or two spiking levels based on the measured amitraz (WF) and tebufenocid (all matrices), the target
different LOD/LOQ values in the different matrices values could not be reached even when exchanging the
(details in Table 4). For routine measurement these quantifier and qualifier ions.
7
15. Annex
Tables and Figures
Table 2. Selectivity parameters for the target compounds * retention times for all isomers ** internal standard compound
Table 2 continued * retention times for all isomers ** internal standard compound
Table 2 continued * retention times for all isomers ** internal standard compound
Name
RT Precursor Product Collision Precursor Product Collision Precursor Product Collision (for qualifier ion 1/
(min) Mass Mass Energy Mass Mass Energy Mass Mass Energy qualifier ion 2)
[m/z] [m/z] [V] [m/z] [m/z] [V] [m/z] [m/z] [V] [% of quant. ion]
29.03/
Fluvalinate 180.8 152.1 22 250.0 55.1 16 250.0 199.9 18 45 / 35
29.16*
Folpet 16.54 104.0 76.0 10 130.0 102.0 12 259.9 130.1 14 92 / 62
HCH alpha 11.71 216.9 180.9 8 218.8 182.9 8 95
HCH beta 12.19 216.9 180.9 8 218.8 182.9 8 90
HCH gamma_
12.39 216.9 180.9 8 218.8 182.9 8 100
Lindane
Hexaconazole 17.54 213.9 123.5 28 213.9 159.0 18 231.0 175.0 10 950 / 1100
Imazalil 17.58 172.8 109.0 26 174.7 147.0 16 215.0 173.0 8 90 / 130
Iprodione 21.77 314.0 245.0 10 315.7 247.0 10 315.7 273.0 8 50 / 22
Isofenphos-methyl 15.65 199.0 65.0 34 199.0 121.0 10 241.1 121.1 20 395 / 70
Kresoxim-methyl 18.12 116.0 62.9 24 116.0 89.0 14 130.9 130.1 10 324 / 102
Linuron 14.63 159.8 133.0 12 187.0 124.0 20 248.0 61.1 8 70 / 120
Malathion 14.68 92.8 63.0 8 125.0 79.0 8 173.1 99.0 12 110 / 300
Mepanipyrim 17.21 222.0 206.0 26 222.0 207.1 14 223.1 207.4 24 220 / 41
Metalaxyl 14.01 131.9 117.0 12 160.1 130.0 18 160.1 144.8 10 100 / 80
Methacrifos 9.8 125.0 79.0 8 180.0 93.0 10 240.0 180.0 10 55 / 40
Methamidophos 8.03 141.0 64.0 18 141.0 79.0 20 141.0 94.8 8 420 / 520
Methidathion 16.7 145.0 58.0 14 145.0 85.0 6 302.6 284.9 14 370
Methiocarb 14.98 153.0 45.0 12 153.0 109.1 6 168.1 153.0 10 225 / 554
Metribuzin 13.67 198.0 55.0 26 198.0 82.1 16 198.0 110.0 10 300 / 100
Monocrotophos 11.4 96.9 82.0 10 127.0 95.0 16 127.0 109.0 10 105 / 350
Myclobutanil 17.98 179.0 90.0 28 179.0 125.0 14 179.0 151.7 8 320 / 60
Ortho-phenyl-
10.09 141.1 115.1 14 170.1 115.0 34 170.1 141.1 22 91 / 100
phenol
Oxadiazon 17.87 174.9 76.0 28 174.9 112.0 12 174.9 147.2 6 226 / 52
Oxadixyl 19.12 131.9 117.0 16 163.1 117.0 24 163.1 132.1 8 110 / 260
Paclobutrazol 16.97 125.0 89.0 18 236.0 125.0 12 236.0 167.0 10 290 / 90
Paraoxon-methyl 12.83 95.9 65.0 12 109.0 79.0 6 230.0 105.9 16 140 / 110
Parathion (ethyl) 15.07 109.0 81.0 10 124.9 97.0 6 291.0 109.0 12 75 / 48
Parathion-methyl 13.85 124.9 47.0 12 124.9 79.0 6 263.0 109.0 12 105 / 60
Pendimethalin 15.81 252.1 161.0 14 252.1 162.0 8 252.1 191.3 8 130 / 85
25.38/
Permethrin 163.0 91.1 12 183.1 153.0 12 183.1 168.0 12 100 / 105
25.64*
Phenthoate 16.25 121.0 77.0 22 246.0 121.0 8 274.0 121.0 10 100 / 120
Phosalone 23.15 121.1 65.0 10 182.0 74.8 30 182.0 111.0 14 105 / 190
Phosmet 21.89 160.0 50.9 38 160.0 76.9 22 160.0 133.0 10 170 / 110
Phosphamidon 13.47 127.0 94.9 16 127.0 109.0 12 264.1 127.0 12 380 / 100
Pirimicarb 13.08 166.1 55.0 18 166.1 96.0 12 238.1 166.1 10 120 / 230
Pirimicarb-p-
13.36 152.1 42.0 25 152.1 96.0 10 224.1 152.1 10 230 / 120
desmetyl
Pirimiphos methyl 14.37 290.1 125.0 20 290.1 233.0 8 305.1 180.1 8 60 / 70
Prochloraz 25.74 69.9 42.0 8 180.1 138.1 12 308.0 147.1 12 160 / 10
Procymidone 16.4 95.9 53.0 16 95.9 67.1 8 283.0 96.1 8 400 / 65
11
Table 2 continued * retention times for all isomers ** internal standard compound
Name
RT Precursor Product Collision Precursor Product Collision Precursor Product Collision (for qualifier ion 1/
(min) Mass Mass Energy Mass Mass Energy Mass Mass Energy qualifier ion 2)
[m/z] [m/z] [V] [m/z] [m/z] [V] [m/z] [m/z] [V] [% of quant. ion]
Profenofos 17.73 296.7 268.9 10 336.9 266.9 12 336.9 308.9 8 190 / 35
Propargite 20.97 135.1 77.1 26 135.1 107.1 12 150.1 135.1 8 310 / 110
20.19/
Propiconazole 172.9 74.0 38 172.9 109.0 26 172.9 145.0 16 110 / 155
20.39*
Propyzamide 12.5 172.9 74.0 38 172.9 109.0 26 172.9 145.0 14 105 / 190
Prothiofos 17.57 266.7 220.9 18 266.7 238.9 8 308.9 239.0 14 142 / 160
Pyraclostrobin 28.89 132.0 51.1 35 132.0 77.0 20 164.0 132.1 10 230 / 220
Pyridaben 25.62 147.1 117.1 20 147.1 119.1 8 147.1 132.1 12 55 / 58
Pyrimethanil 12.66 198.1 117.9 30 198.1 157.6 18 198.1 182.9 14 10 / 120
Pyriproxyfen 23.54 136.1 78.0 20 136.1 96.0 10 226.1 186.1 12 90 / 10
Quinoxyfen 20.18 237.0 208.0 26 271.8 237.1 12 307.0 237.0 18 55 / 33
Spirodiclofen 25.09 156.9 73.0 20 156.9 86.7 32 312.2 259.0 8 60 / 105
Tebuconazole 20.85 125.0 89.0 16 125.0 99.0 16 250.0 125.0 20 50 / 110
Tebufenocide 22.58 145.1 117.0 10 160.1 145.1 12 8
Tebufenpyrad 22.58 276.1 171.0 10 318.1 131.1 14 318.1 145.1 14 43 / 31
Tefluthrin 12.79 177.0 127.0 14 177.0 137.0 16 197.0 141.1 10 34 / 40
Tetraconazole 15.18 100.9 51.0 10 159.0 123.4 16 336.0 204.0 28 8 / 100
Tetradifon 22.97 159.0 74.8 32 159.0 111.0 20 159.0 131.0 10 125 / 252
Tetrahydroph-
9.96 151.0 77.1 30 151.0 79.9 6 151.0 122.1 8 140 / 80
thalimide (THPI)
Thiabendazole 16.36 174.0 103.0 18 174.0 130.1 10 201.0 174.0 14 110 / 700
Tolclofos-methyl 13.86 265.0 219.9 20 265.0 250.0 12 266.8 252.0 12 285 / 80
Tolyfluanid 16.1 137.0 65.1 28 137.0 91.1 18 238.0 137.0 10 150 / 110
Triadimefon 15.17 208.0 111.0 20 208.0 126.7 12 208.0 180.8 8 65 / 120
Triadimenol 16.39 112.0 57.6 8 128.0 65.0 18 168.2 70.0 10
Trifloxystrobin 20.16 116.1 63.0 24 116.1 89.0 14 145.0 95.0 14 295 / 40
Trifluralin 11.17 306.1 159.7 20 306.1 206.0 10 306.1 264.1 8 150 / 900
Triphenylphos-
21.01 215.0 168.1 16 326.1 168.6 28 326.1 325.3 10 6 / 62
phate (TPP)**
Triticonazole 23.17 217.0 167.0 18 235.1 181.9 12 235.1 217.1 8 92 / 120
Vinclozolin 13.73 241.1 58.1 12 241.1 184.1 10 284.9 269.9 12 160
12
Table 3. Linearity and matrix effect results (see text 12.2 for details on Youden plot slope results). – residue plot RSD% <20% – residue plot RSD% >20%
Table 3 continued – residue plot RSD% <20% – residue plot RSD% >20%
Table 3 continued – residue plot RSD% <20% – residue plot RSD% >20%
Table 3 continued – residue plot RSD% <20% – residue plot RSD% >20%
Table 4 continued * spiking levels are 50, 100 & 500 ng/g ** spiking levels are 100, 200 & 1000 ng/g <LOD/LOQ – spiking value below LOD/LOQ value
Table 4 continued * spiking levels are 50, 100 & 500 ng/g ** spiking levels are 100, 200 & 1000 ng/g <LOD/LOQ – spiking value below LOD/LOQ value
Table 4 continued * spiking levels are 50, 100 & 500 ng/g ** spiking levels are 100, 200 & 1000 ng/g <LOD/LOQ – spiking value below LOD/LOQ value
Table 5 continued * spiking levels are 50, 100 & 500 ** spiking levels are 100, 200 & 1000 <LOD/LOQ – spiking value below LOD/LOQ value
Table 5 continued * spiking levels are 50, 100 & 500 ** spiking levels are 100, 200 & 1000 <LOD/LOQ – spiking value below LOD/LOQ value
Table 5 continued * spiking levels are 50, 100 & 500 ** spiking levels are 100, 200 & 1000 <LOD/LOQ – spiking value below LOD/LOQ value
Table 6: Method LOD, LOQ and current legislative residue level values (all values in ng/g). * default value of 10 ng/g set as no MRL values defined
Table 7: External quality control (FAPAS) results for the relevant compounds.
www.thermofisher.com
©2016 Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc. All rights reserved. Sigma-Aldrich is a registered trademark of Sigma-Aldrich Co LLC. ULTRA-TURRAX
is a registered trademark of IKA-Werke GmbH & Co. All other trademarks are the property of Thermo Fisher Scientific and its subsidiaries.
This information is presented as an example of the capabilities of Thermo Fisher Scientific products. It is not intended to encourage use of
these products in any manners that might infringe the intellectual property rights of others. Specifications, terms and pricing are subject to
change. Not all products are available in all countries. Please consult your local sales representative for details.
Africa-Other +27 11 570 1840 Denmark +45 70 23 62 60 Japan +81 45 453 9100 Singapore +65 6289 1190
Australia +61 3 9757 4300 Europe-Other +43 1 333 50 34 0 Latin America +1 561 688 8700 South Africa +27 11 570 1840
Austria +43 810 282 206 Finland +358 9 3291 0200 Middle East +43 1 333 50 34 0 Spain +34 914 845 965
Belgium +32 53 73 42 41 France +33 1 60 92 48 00 Netherlands +31 76 579 55 55 Sweden +46 8 556 468 00
Canada +1 800 530 8447 Germany +49 6103 408 1014 New Zealand +64 9 980 6700 Switzerland +41 61 716 77 00
China 800 810 5118 (free call domestic) India +91 22 6742 9494 Norway +46 8 556 468 00 UK +44 1442 233555
400 650 5118 Italy +39 02 950 591 Russia/CIS +43 1 333 50 34 0 USA +1 800 532 4752
TG63899_E 07/16M