Paranoid Pedagogies: Education, Culture, and Paranoia 1st Edition Jennifer A. Sandlin All Chapter Instant Download
Paranoid Pedagogies: Education, Culture, and Paranoia 1st Edition Jennifer A. Sandlin All Chapter Instant Download
Paranoid Pedagogies: Education, Culture, and Paranoia 1st Edition Jennifer A. Sandlin All Chapter Instant Download
com
https://textbookfull.com/product/paranoid-
pedagogies-education-culture-and-paranoia-1st-
edition-jennifer-a-sandlin/
https://textbookfull.com/product/biota-grow-2c-gather-2c-cook-loucas/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/culture-and-technology-a-primer-
jennifer-daryl-slack/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-power-of-education-education-for-
all-development-globalisation-and-unesco-1st-edition-colin-power-auth/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/creative-dimensions-of-teaching-and-
learning-in-the-21st-century-1st-edition-jill-b-cummings/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/constitutional-law-2020-case-
supplements-6th-edition-erwin-chemerinsky/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/usmle-step-1-lecture-
notes-2021-7-book-set-kaplan-medical/
textbookfull.com
Going Down 1st Edition Ally Crew & Brynn Hale [Crew
https://textbookfull.com/product/going-down-1st-edition-ally-crew-
brynn-hale-crew/
textbookfull.com
Asthma, COPD, and Overlap: A Case-Based Overview of
Similarities and Differences 1st Edition Jonathan A.
Bernstein
https://textbookfull.com/product/asthma-copd-and-overlap-a-case-based-
overview-of-similarities-and-differences-1st-edition-jonathan-a-
bernstein/
textbookfull.com
Edited by
EDUCATIONAL FUTURES
Palgrave Studies in
Jennifer A. Sandlin and Jason J. Wallin
PARANOID
PEDAGOGIES
Education, Culture, and Paranoia
Palgrave Studies in Educational Futures
Series Editor
jan jagodzinski
Secondary Education
University of Alberta
Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
The series Educational Futures would be a call on all aspects of education,
not only specific subject specialist, but policy makers, religious education
leaders, curriculum theorists, and those involved in shaping the educational
imagination through its foundations and both psychoanalytical and
psychological investments with youth to address this extraordinary precarity
and anxiety that is continually rising as things do not get better but worsen.
A global de-territorialization is taking place, and new voices and visions
need to be seen and heard. The series would address the following questions
and concerns. The three key signifiers of the book series title address this
state of risk and emergency: The Anthropocene: The ‘human world,’ the
world-for-us is drifting toward a global situation where human extinction is
not out of the question due to economic industrialization and
overdevelopment, as well as the exponential growth of global population.
How to we address this ecologically and educationally to still make a
difference? Ecology: What might be ways of re-thinking our relationships
with the non-human forms of existence and in-human forms of artificial
intelligence that have emerged? Are there possibilities to rework the
ecological imagination educationally from its over-romanticized view of
Nature, as many have argued: Nature and culture are no longer tenable
separate signifiers. Can teachers and professors address the ideas that
surround differentiated subjectivity where agency is no long attributed to
the ‘human’ alone? Aesthetic Imaginaries: What are the creative responses
that can fabulate aesthetic imaginaries that are viable in specific contexts
where the emergent ideas, which are able to gather heterogeneous elements
together to present projects that address the two former descriptors: the
Anthropocene and the every changing modulating ecologies. Can educators
drawn on these aesthetic imaginaries to offer exploratory hope for what is a
changing globe that is in constant crisis? The series Educational Futures:
Anthropocene, Ecology, and Aesthetic Imaginaries attempts to secure
manuscripts that are aware of the precarity that reverberates throughout all
life, and attempts to explore and experiment to develop an educational
imagination which, at the very least, makes conscious what is a dire situation.
Paranoid Pedagogies
Education, Culture, and Paranoia
Editors
Jennifer A. Sandlin Jason J. Wallin
Arizona State University University of Alberta
Tempe, Arizona, USA Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
v
vi SERIES EDITOR FOREWORD
vii
viii PREFACE
those espoused by Donald Trump or Jack Chick, they are equally capable
of producing particular kinds of subjectivities around what it means to be a
good American citizen. Helmsing turns his attention to the social studies
classroom to explore how social studies marshals paranoid affect to pro-
duce particular kinds of citizens and consumers. He presents two case stud-
ies of social studies teachers teaching the high school courses American
History and Geography and History of the World, to explore how the para-
noid pedagogies utilized within social studies education employ certainty
and centrality to fix a particular vision of what social studies is and what
‘correct’ interpretations of US history are. Helmsing describes how social
studies helps to present a paranoiac fantasy of American history and culture
that baptizes students into a particular patriotic vision of American citizen-
ship, where Middle Eastern countries and peoples are presented as ‘the
enemy,’ learning about the ‘Other’ involves seeing America as the center of
the world, and the superiority of the United States is reinforced at every
turn. Furthermore, Helmsing argues that social studies itself is a paranoid
fantasy, as it does not exist in ‘the real world,’ but, rather, is a fiction con-
structed out of the fear that young people will not grow up to become
patriotic citizens who inhabit conservative, neoliberal values. Helmsing
argues that social studies education—through certainty and centrality—
fixes its vision and practice on certain ways of thinking and being, which
closes off all other possibilities. Thus, we are provided with another exam-
ple of how meaning becomes coded with a paranoiac structure, which helps
us to further understand how meaning becomes concretized in univocal
ways and thus difficult to change.
One final example of how paranoiac social structures code meaning in
ways that are certain, sweeping, regressive, and dogmatic is presented in
the final contribution to this section. Here, Nathalia Jaramillo and Erik
Malewski explore the resurgence of nativist educational policy reforms
across the United States and the corresponding public discourses that
position immigrants as invaders of a foreign body. Jaramillo and Malewski
discuss how the kinds of social paranoia we discuss above—which are cur-
rently front and center in political discussions across the globe and gaining
even more attention via Donald Trump’s presidential campaign and presi-
dency—thrive under fears of scarce resources where immigrants are por-
trayed as taking jobs and public resources. Using Arizona as a case study,
Jaramillo and Malewski illustrate how social paranoia over immigration
manifests in successive attempts by government leaders to mask, erase, and
PREFACE
xi
deny historical trauma. The authors argue that while the United States is
made up of largely unceded territories, this fact is lost on a nation that
continuously equates immigration control with the war on terror. Jaramillo
and Malewski address the history of nativist ideologies and their connec-
tions to a wider geopolitical struggle for wealth and resources and the
transformation of democratic impulses toward isolationism and hierarchy.
Finally, to counter such paranoiac affective investments and the oppressive
meanings they code into society and culture, they call for what they term
epistemological studies of ignorance and the use of decolonial pedagogies,
and offer the concept and practice of comunalidad as a tactic for finding
voice and community.
Finally, in SECTION THREE: PARANOID PEDAGOGIES, authors
address questions such as: How might paranoia be rehabilitated from
under its pathological and negative conceptualization as to mobilize new
conditions for understanding and critiquing the present state of society
and education?; How might paranoia function as a mode of cultural cri-
tique and aesthetic imagination recalcitrant to the obfuscating powers of
the media and/or public opinion?; What are the specific functions and
forms of paranoia as a form of social production and in turn, what kind of
social body is paranoia capable of producing?; and, What is the character
of the transferential relationship between social paranoia and individual
pathology? This final section aims to reclaim paranoia from its condemna-
tion as a psychical disorder and bulwark against social progress and change.
Significant to the scope of this project, this final section takes seriously the
proposition that paranoia functions as a mode of social production that
might resist present trajectories of neoliberal capitalism.
Towards this productive rethinking of paranoia, Jennie Stearns and
Charlie Blake develop a vision of pedagogy born from the nuptials of
paranoia and parasitosis. Drawing upon a diversity of educational and phil-
osophical thinking, Stearns and Blake speculate that the parasite and the
paranoia it induces is capable of reorienting the pedagogically implicated
concepts of hospitality, sacrifice, and the Freirian liberatory impulse of
pedagogy of the oppressed. They argue that the ostensibly ‘delusional’ para-
noia of Morgellons (the paranoiac belief that the skin is infested with
imperceptible, inanimate material) is a conceptual and affective resource
for instantiating new forms of subjectivity and resistance significant to the
challenges of the twenty-first century. Accelerating the paranoiac
tendencies of Morgellons, Stearns and Blake argue for a productive
xii PREFACE
mode that Lucero ‘shocks’ the reader by inducing the paranoiac’s capacity
for imagining the other, thereby producing a dilated image of the world in
potentially productive, transversal tension, with the accepted world and its
establishment imaginaries.
Jennifer A. Sandlin
Jason J. Wallin
Contents
xv
xvi Contents
Index 207
Notes on Contributors
xvii
xviii NOTES ON CONTRIBUTORS
A Feverish Genealogy
The use of the term paranoia to connote both bad judgment and insanity
run corollary to the meanings of the term in Ancient Greece, where it
referred loosely to both ‘folly’ and ‘derangement’ (Lewis, 1970). Yet,
beyond such bald definitions, allusions to paranoia in Ancient Greece
attended to more nuanced aspects of social and psychological life. In the
Grecian playwright Aristophanes’ Wasps (422 BC), for instance, references
to paranoia made manifest a particular social concern for the return of
tyranny figured via the threat of Persian invasion (Mitchell-Boyask, 2009).
The Grecian playwright Euripides’ (460–430 BC) Electra (413 BC)
employs a paranoiac mode of thinking that upends the Trojan War’s sacred
justification and privileged point of reference in the cultural history of the
Greeks (Hampsey, 2004). Plato used the term paranoia in reference to the
‘off-track’ or rather, irrational thinking of Aeschylus’s character Orestes in
Oresteia, who in a moment of what Plato refers to as ‘distracted conscious-
ness’ commits matricide (Glass, 1998; Hampsey, 2004). Aristotle posits in
paranoia the means to control social unrest and revolt through the inven-
tion of terrors capable of diverting the attention of the people upon some
common malefactor against which the State rises up as a savior and protec-
tor (Brady, 1971). For Hippocrates, paranoia described a form of derange-
ment symptomized in delusion (false ideas), madness, dementia, and fever.
Across these very general and all too brief remarks on paranoia, we might
extrapolate at least two ideas. First, from the point of its etymological ger-
mination, both the implicit definition and function of paranoia vary greatly.
While we might be familiar with the definitions of paranoia advanced by
Hippocrates, in which the term refers generally to a psychosomatic disorder,
OUT OF OUR MINDS: A HAPHAZARD CONSIDERATION OF PARANOIA... 3
and Plato, for whom paranoia marks the suspension of rational and ordered
thinking manifest in degrees of ‘bad judgment’, there insists within the use
of the term quite different inflections. For instance, Euripides seemingly
uses paranoia as a technique for troubling prevailing cultural metanarra-
tives, hence expanding the field of potential responses or conceptualizations
of historical events by positing potential contradictions or alternatives to
accepted thought. Aristotle lays bare a particular strategy of ideological con-
trol through the creation of social panic hinged to the paranoid idea that an
enemy more virulent than the State lurks at the borders, or rather, outside
of the polis. For the different functions of paranoia in antiquity, the idea of
paranoia nevertheless remains linked to the notion of being ‘out of’ or
‘beside’ one’s mind. Hippocrates’ connection of paranoia to the symptoms
of delusion and madness, Euripides’ pessimistic fabulation of a counter-
myth to the common metanarratives of the State, Plato’s critique of thought
and behavior antithetical to rational self-control, or Aristotle’s strategy for
social control in the fabrication of enemies peripheral to the State each posit
the idea that the mind exists or functions in relation to ‘outside’ forces.
Hence, and in summation, while the function of paranoia varies in antiquity,
such variance remains hinged to the idea that paranoia describes the decen-
tered mind, or rather, the ‘mind’ presupposed by the prevailing ideals of
rationality, psychological health, and acquiescence to established or com-
monly accepted cultural truths.
Language: English
Say! What does that jerk, The Amphibious Android, mean by calling
me a "mere child"? His assertion that I'm but a youth of fifteen is a
good way off the beam. I've been reading Galactic Adventures for
the past eight years and I was nine years old when I picked up my
first copy, so figure it out for yourself. A jug of sour zeni to him. May
fire burst out in his s.f. collection and utterly destroy it. No! I retract
that. That's too horrible a fate, even to visit upon The Amphibious
Android. Let him wallow in his ignorance. I, The Super Intellect, will
smile down on him and forgive him his sins.
That's an interesting letter from Charlie Lane. The Miserable Mutant
has propounded an amazing theory that has set me to wondering.
Perhaps G. A. can induce one of its authors to work this theory into
a story. I'm reserving my four wooden nickels right now for the tale,
if it is written. I'll even suggest a title—Those Who Are Froze In The
Cosmos. How's that? Well, I didn't like it either.
Once again I tear my hair and roar: GIVE US TRIMMED EDGES! Ye
Ed must know by now that the majority of fandom is in favor of
trimmed edges. As it is, one comes suddenly to the most interesting
part of a story, at the very bottom of a page and spends several
moments feverishly attempting to gain a hold on the ragged edge
and go on to the next passage. By the time he has accomplished
this, he is a raving lunatic, a martyr to trimmed edges. I am not a
crusader, as is The Misled Biped, but I insist on seeing justice done.
As a whole, this is a fair issue. I might even call it good, if it were
not for the artwork and stories. Ron's epic will live forever in my
mind, although its ending was rather weak and it could have been
developed into a more powerful tale by having the Slads all die in
the Inferno.
I enter my plea for longer stories. A long novel by M. S. Jensen
would be appreciated. His last, Dr. Higbaum's Strange Manifestation,
was a gem. On the other hand, short stories are not without merit
and good old G. A. wouldn't be the same without them. I believe the
story policy had best remain as is.
Give Higgins a rest. His yarns are rapidly degenerating into hack,
with only four out of the last five meeting with this reader's
approval. I don't like to be finicky, but it seems like he isn't
contributing his best material to G. A.
Well, this missive is growing to huge proportions and I would like to
see it in print, so I'd better sign off.
Oh, yeh, almost forgot to comment on the departments. They are all
good, with The Reader's Opinion being the most interesting. Ye Ed's
ruminations come in for a close second. Do not change the
departments in any way, although the quiz and the Strange
Phenomena feature could be discontinued, without any great loss.
Before I close, I wish to make a revelation which will rock the world.
Yes, Ed, I have a secret weapon! Nothing can stand against this
terrible invention and, with it, I could even destroy Earth, with Mars
and Pluto thrown in for good measure. Beware, Ed, lest you arouse
my ire and cause me, in my wrath, to unleash this vast force upon
helpless, trusting mankind.
Having read G. A. from cover to cover, I crawl back to my cage,
drooling with delight. Prying up a loose stone in the center of the
floor, I tenderly deposit the mag among the other issues of my
golden hoard. Replacing the stone, I sigh contentedly and
manipulate my lower lip with two fingers to indicate complete
satisfaction. See you next issue!
Joe Carson
The Super Intellect
Joe carefully placed the letter in a previously addressed envelope,
mentally complimenting himself for authoring such a masterpiece.
Slapping a stamp on the back, he sealed the envelope and rushed
forth to post it at the nearest mail-box.
Harl and Kir-Um slowly materialized and glanced about to take stock
of their surroundings. They were on the roof of some tall building
and night pressed in all about them, relieved only by the intermittent
winking of a huge neon sign anchored on the roof.
They had come from far off Mars to draw out and discover the
weaknesses of Earth—for the Great Invasion was not far in the
offing and the Grand Councilor had deemed it wise to know in
advance where best to strike and in what manner.
Mars was in its final death throes and its inhabitants must soon
immigrate to a new world or perish. Their sister planet, Earth, was
best adapted to their particular form of life, thus it had been
selected for subjugation to their purpose.
The atoms that were Harl and Kir-Um were hurled, in a state of
fluidity, through space, to be reassembled on Earth. For the purpose
of escaping detection, they had assumed the bodies of terrestrials
and now they stood, staring triumphantly out over this world that
was soon to be theirs. The conquering hordes would follow later in
spaceships, as soon as Harl and Kir-Um had gathered the necessary
data.
Harl spoke—mastering the strange vocal-cords with an ease that
amazed him. To be sure, he spoke an alien, unintelligible tongue. We
translate:
"Well, Kir-Um, what now? We have arrived at our destination, but I
haven't the slightest idea what to do next."
Kir-Um pondered this a moment and eventually answered: "The
situation suggests we first descend to the surface of this world and,
from there, perhaps we can map a line of attack."
"E-e-e-ump!" Harl made the noise, which, on Mars, denoted extreme
pleasure. "Excellent, Kir-Um. How can a decadent civilization, such
as this one undoubtedly is, stand against such brilliant minds as
ours?"
"You are right, as usual, Harl," Kir-Um agreed. "My analysis of the
problem was only typical of a Martian. Now, let us proceed to the
base of this crude structure."
By diligent search, they finally located a stair leading downward and
cautiously made their way into the bowels of the building.
Reaching the fifth floor, Kir-Um placed a restraining hand on Harl's
shoulder and pointed excitedly to a door at the far end of the hall.
Light streamed from beneath it and glowed faintly through the
frosted glass panel set in its upper half.
Scarcely daring to breathe, they approached the door and stood,
regarding it with apprehensive eyes. Harl noted the gold-leaf
lettering on the glass panel, but the cryptic legend had no meaning
to his Martian mind. But, to an Earthly member of that rabid army
known as scientification fans, the words would have brought a tinge
of awe. For this was the room where far-flung systems were denied
existence, by one shake of a firm, unyielding head; where the most
expressive cuss-words of super villains were brutally censored with a
fiendish swipe of a little, blue pencil—the editorial office of Galactic
Adventures.
"Harl," Kir-Um whispered softly. "There's a creature in that room! Do
you not detect its thought vibrations?"
Harl opened his mind to reception and stood a moment, as if in a
trance. His eyes slowly dilated and he gasped in astonishment.
"Yes, Kir-Um, there is a creature in there. A strange, horrible
creature, possessed of mad, meaningless thoughts. I—I wonder
what it looks like?"
Instantly they were after him, pounding across the dew-laden sod
with all the agility and grace of a couple of rampaging
hippopotamuses. Joe bounded through the front door and swung to
snap the night-lock. At that moment, something grasped his mind in
a firm, unrelenting grip. He no longer had any desire to resist the
intruders and stood waiting for them to enter and make him
prisoner. Quickly Harl and Kir-Um forced him into a chair and stared
down at their victim with triumphant eyes.
"So," Harl panted. "At last we shall learn the secret of Joe Carson,
Earth's most amazing genius. Kir-Um, he is but a youth. I shudder at
the thought of one so young possessing so much knowledge. Could
it be that we have made a mistake?"
Kir-Um looked up at Harl reprovingly. "Do Martians ever err?" he
demanded. "No, this boy has a powerful, secret weapon and we
must get it from him, at all costs. I can't understand you, Harl. It
would seem as if you actually sympathize with these puny Earth
people. The Councilor wouldn't like to hear that, Harl. I would hate
to see my best friend put to death because he was too friendly with
the enemy."
"I'm not friendly with these Earthlings, Kir-Um," Harl hastily
objected. "I merely think we should be cautious and not proceed at
too fast a pace but what we shall be lured into some sort of death
trap."
"Well and good," Kir-Um nodded. "I believe we both realize our task
calls for vigilance and a meticulous sifting of fact from fancy. That
much goes unsaid. Conceding this genius is merely a boy, perhaps
he is a child prodigy or, then again, he may have invented this
weapon by accident. That is of little import, however. He has the
weapon, we want it and we shall have it."
Harl bowed humbly. "You are right again, Kir-Um. Your deductive
powers constantly amaze me. Shall we begin the questioning?"
Kir-Um wasted no time in preliminaries, but came right to the point.
"Where is your secret weapon, boy?" he snapped. He spoke in his
native Martian tongue, but the thought behind the words was quite
clear in Joe Carson's receptive mind. Joe fumbled for words and
finally answered:
"Weapon? What weapon? The only kind of weapon I've got is my
Daisy B-B gun, and that's no secret. Mr. Jones, next door, found out
about it yesterday when I shot out his front room window. Boy, was
he sore!"
Kir-Um nodded knowingly at Harl and said, in an aside: "He's trying
to mislead us. But he won't succeed. The truth will out."
Harl leaned forward to try his hand at the cross-examination. "You
know very well what weapon we mean, creature. You have kept your
secret well, but now you must relinquish it. Do not try to delude us
with fanciful stories and false denials."
"Somebody's been feeding you a line, chum," Joe laughed. "Your
trolley's jumped the track. Go on back to your cage, pa, and dream
up another one. You bore me."
The Martians realized the youth's mental barrier was going to be
more difficult to break through than they had anticipated. The
situation called for tact, yet the amount of time left to them
necessitated a direct attack. Kir-Um summoned all the powers of
concentration at his command and slowly, but surely, forced Joe's
mind into a state of passiveness. Satisfied, at last, the Earthling
would give direct replies to his questions, Kir-Um once more took
over the interrogating duties.
"You cannot deceive us, boy," he began. "A few days ago, you wrote
a letter to Earth's great science center, Galactic Ventures, I believe it
is. In this letter, you stated you possessed a secret weapon, powerful
enough to destroy this whole planet. You did not divulge the details
of this invention, but promised dire happenings to anyone
unfortunate enough to have this weapon directed upon them. We
want the plans of this amazing contrivance and you will do well to
place them in our hands, without delay."
"Oh, that," Joe's voice came dull and emotionless. "That's just a
joke. Just something I dreamed up to give the ed. a laugh."
Harl and Kir-Um didn't know what a 'laugh' was, but they did know
that they were finally making some progress. A meaningful glance
passed between them and they silently congratulated themselves for
uncovering the genius' secret in such short order.
"And these Jokes, creature," Harl spoke, "does anyone beside
yourself possess them?"
They pressed buttons concealed under their coats and slowly began
to fade, their outlines becoming indistinct and hazy. Kir-Um raised a
hand to his head in salute.
"Poor, foolish Earthlings," he murmured, "this is the end. Always
remember, if it had not been for Joe Carson's Joke, you would never
have found your demise. I salute you, strange creatures."
And they were gone.
*** END OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK JOE CARSON'S
WEAPON ***
Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
be renamed.