Instant Access To Microbial Bioprospecting For Sustainable Development Joginder Singh Ebook Full Chapters
Instant Access To Microbial Bioprospecting For Sustainable Development Joginder Singh Ebook Full Chapters
Instant Access To Microbial Bioprospecting For Sustainable Development Joginder Singh Ebook Full Chapters
com
https://textbookfull.com/product/microbial-
bioprospecting-for-sustainable-development-
joginder-singh/
https://textbookfull.com/product/microbial-biotechnology-basic-
research-and-applications-joginder-singh/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/solid-state-physics-an-introduction-
to-theory-1st-edition-joginder-singh-galsin/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/thieves-liars-1st-edition-shaw-hart-
hart-shaw/
textbookfull.com
Living the revolution: urban communes & Soviet socialism,
1917-1932 First Edition Willimott
https://textbookfull.com/product/living-the-revolution-urban-communes-
soviet-socialism-1917-1932-first-edition-willimott/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/computational-systems-biology-
approaches-in-cancer-research-1st-edition-inna-kuperstein-editor/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/uncertainties-in-gps-positioning-a-
mathematical-discourse-1st-edition-alan-oxley/
textbookfull.com
https://textbookfull.com/product/mathematical-modeling-of-unsteady-
inviscid-flows-jeff-d-eldredge/
textbookfull.com
Vietnamese food and wine pairing With recommendations for
100 Vietnamese popular dishes First Edition De La Casa
https://textbookfull.com/product/vietnamese-food-and-wine-pairing-
with-recommendations-for-100-vietnamese-popular-dishes-first-edition-
de-la-casa/
textbookfull.com
Joginder Singh · Deepansh Sharma
Gaurav Kumar · Neeta Raj Sharma
Editors
Microbial
Bioprospecting
for Sustainable
Development
Microbial Bioprospecting for Sustainable
Development
Joginder Singh • Deepansh Sharma
Gaurav Kumar • Neeta Raj Sharma
Editors
Microbial Bioprospecting
for Sustainable
Development
Editors
Joginder Singh Deepansh Sharma
Department of Microbiology, School Department of Microbiology, School
of Bioengineering and Biosciences of Bioengineering and Biosciences
Lovely Professional University Lovely Professional University
Phagwara, Punjab, India Phagwara, Punjab, India
Amity Institute of Microbial Technology
Gaurav Kumar
Amity University
Department of Microbiology
Jaipur, Rajasthan, India
Lovely Professional University
Phagwara, Punjab, India
Neeta Raj Sharma
Department of Biochemistry
Lovely Professional University
Phagwara, Punjab, India
This Springer imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd.
The registered company address is: 152 Beach Road, #21-01/04 Gateway East, Singapore 189721,
Singapore
Contents
v
vi Contents
vii
viii About the Editors
Dr. Neeta Raj Sharma is currently Professor and Associate Dean of the School of
Bioengineering & Biosciences at Lovely Professional University, Phagwara, India.
She received her Ph.D. in Biochemistry from Jiwaji University, Gwalior in 1995.
She has more than 20 years of experience in research, industry, teaching, and admin-
istration. Her scientific and technical research interests span various facets of bio-
chemistry, toxicology, nutraceuticals, instrumentation, microbial biotechnology,
computational biology, herbal chemistry, product development, microbial enzymes,
fuel biochemistry, and PCR for industrial and health sector applications. She has
published more than 40 research articles, book chapters, and articles in respected
journals. She is a member of various scientific societies, including the International
Science Congress Association and Indian Society of Agricultural Biochemists.
Part I
Microorganisms for Sustainable Agriculture
and Environmental Applications
Small at Size, Big at Impact:
Microorganisms for Sustainable 1
Development
Abstract
From being the first life originated on Earth ~3.8 billion years ago to the present
time, microorganisms have enormously impacted the human, animal, and plant’s
lives and global biogeochemical cycles in one way or another. These are widely
distributed in almost all habitats and ecosystems on Earth, including the most
hostile and extreme habitats which are otherwise uninhabitable to other organ-
isms. Domain Bacteria and Archaea are composed entirely of prokaryotic micro-
organisms, whereas eukaryotic microbes, viz., fungi, algae, protozoa, slime
molds, and water molds, belong to domain Eukarya. Archaea and bacteria repre-
sent the majority of life-forms on our planet. Recent estimate predicts 1011–1012
microbial species on Earth of which 99.9% microbial species are yet to be cul-
tured in the laboratory. Ocean, soil, rhizosphere, human gut, animal body, etc. are
some of the most densely populated microbial habitats. Microorganisms are
excellent model organisms for the study of metabolism and genetics at cellular
level. Considered as Earth’s greatest chemists, microorganisms have unparal-
leled metabolic capabilities, extraordinary adaptability, and remarkable survival
strategies which undoubtedly make them the most successful living creatures.
Most microbes are beneficial to humans, plants, and animals. These contribute
significantly to ensure the quality of human life and in sustaining life on our
planet. Microbes have established ecologically important symbiotic and
N. Singh (*)
Department of Microbiology, Akal College of Basic Sciences, Eternal University,
Baru Sahib, Himachal Pradesh, India
J. Singh
Department of Microbiology, School of Bioengineering and Biosciences, Lovely Professional
University, Phagwara, Punjab, India
K. Singh
Department of Chemistry, Akal College of Basic Sciences, Eternal University,
Baru Sahib, Himachal Pradesh, India
Keywords
Microbial diversity · Sustainable development · Microbiome · Rhizosphere ·
Nitrogen fixation · Probiotics · Microbial cell factories · Biopharmaceuticals
1.1 Introduction
Prof. Carl Woese proposed three domains of life, i.e., Bacteria, Archaea, and
Eukarya on the basis of ribosomal RNA sequence analyses (Woese and Fox 1977;
Woese et al. 1990). This marked the birth of a new group of microbes called archaea
which are phylogenetically distinct from bacteria and eukaryotes. The available evi-
dences point toward the origin of life about 3.5–3.8 billion years ago amidst extreme
and inhabitable environmental conditions (Bekker et al. 2004; Hug et al. 2016). Our
most likely ancestor was a single-celled microscopic organism, LUCA or last uni-
versal common ancestor (Weiss et al. 2016). Thriving in hydrothermal vents, LUCA
was strictly anaerobic, N2-fixing, CO2-fixing, and H2-dependent autotroph with a
Wood-Ljungdahl pathway (Weiss et al. 2016). Recently, Hug et al. (2016) con-
structed a new tree of life using genome sequences of thousands of species includ-
ing genomes of uncultured microbial species from three domains of life. Remarkably,
this tree has 92 bacterial phyla and 26 archaeal phyla along with eukaryotic fungi,
algae, protozoa, and other protists.
ORFs among free-living cells. Ostreococcus tauri, a green alga, is a dominant pho-
tosynthetic eukaryote in water bodies (Derelle et al. 2006). Several unique aspects
of microorganisms are described in Table 1.1. According to Pomeroy et al. (2007),
microbial biomass is 5–10 times bigger than that of all multicellular marine organ-
isms. Whitman et al. (1998) predicted 1.2 × 1029 prokaryotes in seawater and
2.6 × 1029 in the soil. Kallmeyer et al. (2012) gave higher estimate of 2.9 × 1029
microbial cells in subseafloor sediments. Recent estimate predicts 1011–1012 micro-
bial species on our planet (Locey and Lennon 2016). However, just 11,000 species
belonged to 30 bacterial and 5 archaeal phyla have been isolated and validly classi-
fied so far (Gutleben et al. 2017). There are approx. 8.74 million species of eukary-
otes existing on the Earth of which approx. 611,000 are fungi and approx. 36,400
are protozoa (Mora et al. 2011).
The gastrointestinal tracts of human and other mammals contain dense, complex,
and unique microbial communities (Ley et al. 2006; Human Microbiome Project
Consortium 2012). Human gut is one of the densest and complex ecosystems occu-
pied by bacteria, archaea, fungi, protozoa, and viruses. This microbial consortium,
also called gut microbiota, is highly dynamic and diverse (Ley et al. 2006; Mirzaei
and Maurice 2017). The human gut harbors 102 cfu/g (proximal end) to 1011 cfu/g
(distal end) bacteria (Donaldson et al. 2016). Similarly, human oral cavity is home
to about 700 bacterial and 90 fungal species. The combined gene content of human
microbiota is staggering 50–100 times the size of human genome. In general, human
gut is dominated by bacterial phyla Bacteroidetes, Actinobacteria, Firmicutes,
Proteobacteria, and Verrucomicrobia. The small intestine, in particular, is mostly
inhabited by families Lactobacillaceae and Enterobacteriaceae, whereas the colon
is dominated by the families Bacteroidaceae, Prevotellaceae, Lachnospiraceae,
Rikenellaceae, and Ruminococcaceae (Donaldson et al. 2016). Apart from bacteria,
human body also has archaea, fungi, protozoa, and viruses (Human Microbiome
Project Consortium 2012; Mirzaei and Maurice 2017). In sharp contrast to generally
accepted view of 10 microbial cells for each human cell, Sender et al. (2016) gave
revised estimates of 3.8 × 1013 bacteria in the whole body of a 70-kg reference man
having 3.0 × 1013 own body cells. The bacteria to human cell ratio is now estimated
to be 1:1.3 which is much lower compared to earlier estimates. These estimates
found only about 0.2 kg of bacteria in the whole human body, whereas NIH-
Microbiome Project estimated 1–3 kg of bacteria in a normal human being. Further
refinement and actualization in these estimates are expected in the near future.
Many microbes prefer company of a partner for survival and growth. The best
known examples of these relationships are lichen and obligate insect endosymbi-
onts. Lichens represent one of the oldest and most recognizable symbioses in nature.
Recently, the existing theory of two-partner (ascomycete fungus and algae/cyano-
bacteria) lichen association has been challenged with the discovery of third symbi-
otic partner, a basidiomycete yeast Cyphobasidium in macro-lichen Bryoria
fremontii (Spribille et al. 2016). Insect endosymbionts or nutritional symbionts
reside in the cells of plant sap-feeding insects such as aphids, whiteflies, leafhop-
pers, and cicadas. These endosymbionts have extremely minimized genome size
and provide essential amino acids and vitamins to insect hosts (Moran and Bennett
1 Small at Size, Big at Impact: Microorganisms for Sustainable Development 7
2014). One widely known example of such bacteria is Wolbachia (Lo et al. 2016).
Interestingly, the obligate endosymbiotic bacterium carries minimal genetic con-
tents. “Candidatus Nasuia deltocephalinicola” is characterized by smallest genome
size (112,031 bp) and as few as 140 genes among all cellular organisms (Moran and
Bennett 2014; Bennett et al. 2016; Table 1.1).
Viruses, the acellular microorganisms, infect cells from all three domains of life.
These have significant ecological and genetic functions in the biosphere such as
microbial population control, gene transfer, and genome novelty. Bacterial viruses
(bacteriophages) are key in controlling bacterial numbers in aquatic ecosystems,
acquiring genetic novelties through transduction, and also offer an affordable solu-
tion to tackle antibacterial drug resistance. Other acellular agents, i.e., animal
viruses, human viruses, plant viruses, viroids (naked ssRNA), virusoids (ssRNA),
and prions (proteinaceous infectious particles), are pathogenic to plants and ani-
mals. Their study is equally important from human health perspective, biomass
turnover, and for developing strategies to tackle ever-increasing multidrug resis-
tance in bacterial pathogens. Contrary to century-old accepted view of submicro-
scopic viral size, a giant virus was discovered in 2003 which can be seen under the
light microscope (Aherfi et al. 2016; Colson et al. 2017). It was named Mimivirus
and had huge dimensions as well as genome size. Later, Philippe et al. (2013) iso-
lated giant micrometer-sized viruses, called Pandoravirus, having a genome and
cell sizes bigger than some of bacterial species. In terms of size, Pithovirus siberi-
cum is the largest virus known so far (Legendre et al. 2014). The various giant viral
families/genera described so far include Mimiviridae, Marseilleviridae, pandoravi-
ruses, faustoviruses, mimivirus virophages, Pithovirus sibericum, and Mollivirus
sibericum (Aherfi et al. 2016; Colson et al. 2017). Giant viruses are not only larger
(2–15 times) than traditional viruses, but these also have 50–250 times more genes
(Aherfi et al. 2016). It is now a matter of debate and controversy whether these giant
amoebal viruses represent the possible fourth domain of life or not.
Table 1.1 Some extraordinarily unique microorganisms across three domains of life
General
Microbial species Domain category/phyla Habitat Unique characteristics References
Armillaria solidipes Eukarya Fungi Malheur National Forest, Approx. 965 ha with an estimated age of Smith et al. (1992)
Oregon (USA) 1900–8650 years (largest living organism
on Earth)
Caulerpa taxifolia Eukarya Green alga Freshwater World’s largest single-celled organism Ranjan et al. (2015)
(size in meters)
Pelagibacter ubique Bacteria Proteobacteria Ocean; in ultraoligotrophic Smallest free-living cell Giovannoni et al.
habitats Length: 0.37–0.89 μm (2005)
Diameter: 0.12–0.20 μm
Volume: ~0.01 μm3
Thiomargarita Bacteria Proteobacteria Namibia (at the bottom of the Largest bacterium on Earth (can be seen Schulz et al. (1999)
namibiensis ocean) “sulfur pearl of with naked eye)
Namibia” Diameter: 180–750 μm
Volume: 3–28 × 106 μm3
Pelagibacter ubique Bacteria Proteobacteria Ocean; in ultraoligotrophic Most abundant heterotrophic bacterium in Giovannoni et al.
habitats ocean (2005)
Prochlorococcus Bacteria Cyanobacterium Oceans, seas Most abundant and smallest Dufresne et al.
marinus photosynthetic microbe on Earth (cell (2003)
size 0.5–0.7 μm)
Ostreococcus tauri Eukarya Green alga Oceans, sea, coastal waters Smallest free-living eukaryote (diameter Derelle et al. (2006)
2–3 μm)
“Candidatus Nasuia Bacteria Proteobacteria Obligate insect endosymbiont Smallest bacterial genome Bennett et al. (2016)
deltocephalinicola” (112,031 bp)
Pelagibacter ubique Bacteria Proteobacteria Ocean; in ultraoligotrophic Smallest genome (1,308,759 bp) and Giovannoni et al.
habitats predicted ORFs (1354) for a free-living (2005)
cell
Ktedonobacter Bacteria Chloroflexi Soil Largest bacterial genome (13,661,586 bp) Chang et al. (2011)
racemifer
N. Singh et al.
General
Microbial species Domain category/phyla Habitat Unique characteristics References
1
Sorangium Bacterium Myxobacterium Soil Second largest bacterial genome Schneiker et al.
cellulosum strain (13,033,779 bp) (2007)
So015 7-2
Encephalitozoon Eukarya Microsporidia Human parasite Smallest eukaryotic genome (2.3 Mbp) Corradi et al. (2010)
intestinalis (Fungi)
Pandoravirus – Giant virus Infect Acanthamoeba Largest viral genome (length 1.0 μm; Philippe et al. (2013)
salinus castellanii diameter 0.5 μm)
Genome: 2,473,870 bp
Pithovirus sibericum – Giant virus Infect A. castellanii Largest virus in terms of size (length Legendre et al.
1.5 μm; diameter 0.5 μm) (2014)
Trichomonas Eukarya Protista Obligate human parasite Largest microbial genome Carlton et al. (2007)
vaginalis (176,441,227 bp)
Highest number of protein-coding genes
for a eukaryotic microbe (~60,000)
Small at Size, Big at Impact: Microorganisms for Sustainable Development
9
10
Table 1.2 Some record-holder extremophilic microorganisms adapted to grow and survive under most extreme and unusual habitats on Earth (Compiled from
Pikuta et al. 2007; Clarke 2014; Lebre et al. 2017; Krüger et al. 2017)
Microorganism Domain Growth parameters Habitats Remarks
Methanopyrus kandleri strain Archaea 122 °C (survive at 130 °C up to Kairei hydrothermal vent field, Record for growth at highest
116 3 h) Central Indian Ridge (depth temperature
2450 m)
Geogemma barossii strain 121 Archaea 121 °C Hydrothermal vent, Juan de Survive at 130 °C for 2 h
Fuca Ridge, Pacific Ocean
Pyrolobus fumarii Archaea 113 °C Hydrothermal vent, Atlantic Extreme thermophile
Ocean
Pyrodictium abyssi Archaea 110 °C Hydrothermal vents Extreme thermophile
Geothermobacterium Bacteria 100 °C Yellowstone National Park, Record for growth at highest
ferrireducens USA temperature (for domain Bacteria)
Cyanidium caldarium Eukarya 55–56 °C Yellowstone National Park, Most thermo-tolerant eukaryote
USA
Nitzschia frigida Eukarya −8 °C Brine in frozen sea water Record for growth at lowest
temperature
Natrialba hulunbeirensis; Archaea Na+ 3.4–4.5 M, pH 9.0–9.5 Soda lakes Halophilic alkalithermophiles
Natronolimnobius aegyptiacus Temp. 50–55 °C
Deinococcus radiodurans Bacteria Resistance to radiations, oxidizing Meat, animals, hot springs World’s toughest bacterium.
agents, and mutagens Can tolerate up to 1500 kilorads
γ-radiations
Picrophilus torridus Archaea pH 0.07 Hot spring in Hokkaido, Japan Most acidophilic living organisms
Picrophilus oshimae
Anaerobranca gottschalkii Bacteria Survive at 65 °C, pH 10.5 Hot inlet of Lake Bogoria, Thermoalkaliphilic bacterium
Kenya
Aspergillus penicillioides Eukarya Water activity 0.585–0.637 Raisins, Australia and Antique Most extreme xerotolerant fungi
Xeromyces bisporus wood, Thailand
Thermococcus piezophilus Archaea Pressuremax: 130 MPa Ocean bottom Extreme piezophilic archaeon
N. Singh et al.
1 Small at Size, Big at Impact: Microorganisms for Sustainable Development 11
(Weiss et al. 2016). The current high-temperature limit for growth is blistering
122 °C exhibited by hyperthermophilic methanogen Methanopyrus kandleri strain
116 (Takai et al. 2008; Clarke 2014). M. kandleri could remain viable for up to 3 h
at 130 °C. Hyperthermophilic archaeon, Geogemma barossii (also called strain 121)
isolated from a hydrothermal vent, is another extreme thermophilic microbe which
grows at 85–121 °C and can survive at 130 °C for up to 2 h (Kashefi and Lovley
2003). Pyrolobus fumarii is another archaeon capable of growth at 106 °C.
Natranaerobius is a polyextremophile which shows optimal growth above pH 9.5,
69 °C, and 4 M Na+ salt concentration (Canganella and Wiegel 2014). In case of
higher eukaryotes, growth is seldom reported above 60 °C except some nematodes,
algae, and polychaetes (Clarke 2014). Unicellular alga, Cyanidium caldarium, is
reported to complete its life cycle at 55–56 °C. However, other eukaryotes usually
not grow but survive in this temperature range. Some other extremophilic microbes
are discussed in Table 1.2. Recently, the Extreme Microbiome Project (XMP) is
launched to explore the microbial diversity of several extreme habitats, viz., acidic
hypersaline ponds (Australia), Lake Hillier (Australia), “Door to Hell” crater
(Turkmenistan), ocean brine lakes (Gulf of Mexico), deep ocean sediments
(Greenland), permafrost tunnels (Alaska), ancient microbial biofilms (Antarctica),
blue lagoon (Iceland), and toxic hot springs (Ethiopia) (Tighe et al. 2017).
Deinococcus radiodurans (nicknamed Conan the Bacterium by NASA) is a
Gram-positive, extremely radiation-resistant bacterium that can tolerate ionizing
radiations up to 3000 times more than human cells and survive in extreme heat,
desiccation, acidity, and oxidative damages (Cox and Battista 2005; Slade and
Radman 2011). It is rightly regarded as the “world’s toughest bacterium” due to its
remarkable capacity to repair DNA double-strand breaks. Space environment is an
extremely hostile environment characterized by microgravity, intense radiation,
extreme temperatures, and high vacuum (Horneck et al. 2010; www.nasa.gov).
Survival and growth in such conditions is one of the toughest challenges for micro-
organisms. Remarkably, two species of lichens (Rhizocarpon geographicum and
Xanthoria elegans) remained viable for 2 weeks in outer space (Horneck et al.
2010). Dust samples from Russian segment of International Space Station found to
harbor 80 bacterial and 1 fungal species (Mora et al. 2016). More than 90 species of
microorganisms (including bacteria, archaea, fungi, algae, and viruses) have been to
outer space for experimental research studies of NASA and other space agencies
(www.en.wikipedia.org. accessed 12 June 2017). Recently, a bacterium was iso-
lated from high-efficiency particulate arrestance filter system of the International
Space Station and named Solibacillus kalamii (Checinska et al. 2017) in honor of
Dr. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, the former President of India.
Neufeld (2014) have rightly stated that “microbes sustain life on this planet” and
“life would become incomprehensibly bad” in the absence of microbes. Although
prokaryotic microorganisms have tiny size and minimal cell volume, yet they con-
tribute huge biomass in marine and aquatic ecosystems. Cyanobacteria (formerly
called blue-green algae) are photosynthetic prokaryotes which are responsible for
the present oxygen-rich atmosphere of Earth (Bekker et al. 2004; Mazard et al.
2016). Algae and cyanobacteria are primary producers of oxygen and fix CO2 to
generate food for other organisms. Similarly, phytoplanktons (unicellular protists-
algae, diatoms) and protozoa also play significant role in sustainability of food
chains and food webs. Ocean is the largest ecosystem on Earth harboring phenom-
enal microbial diversity and huge microbial biomass. One liter of ocean water har-
bors more than 10 billion organisms, mainly prokaryotes, protists, viruses, and
zooplanktons (www.embl.de). The first life-forms have their origin in ocean, and it
is this ecosystem which sustains life on our planet. Billions of trillions bacteria
(cyanobacteria, methanogens), viruses, and algae (phytoplanktons) constitute the
base of food chain, absorb CO2, and release O2 into the atmosphere. Further, metha-
nogens play a major role in primary production in deep-sea ecosystems (deep-sea
hydrothermal areas and sediments). Microorganisms remained an essential part of
human life either through their natural activities or by producing recombinant phar-
maceuticals. These have the capabilities to help mankind in tackling the newer chal-
lenges of food, energy, and clean water in a sustainable manner while maintaining
and improving the health of our ecosystems.
Fermented foods are high-value foods and beverages produced by the controlled
microbial metabolic activities. Fermented foods and beverages remain an integral part
of the human diet since time prehistoric. The microorganisms most commonly
employed in these processes are S. cerevisiae, Acetobacter, lactic acid bacteria
(Leuconostoc, Lactobacillus, Streptococcus, Lactococcus), Propionibacterium
1 Small at Size, Big at Impact: Microorganisms for Sustainable Development 15
freudenreichii, Bacillus, and several filamentous fungi (Tamang et al. 2016; Marco
et al. 2017). Some examples of fermented foods and beverages are alcoholic bever-
ages, yogurt, cultured milk, cheeses, sauerkraut, pickles, bakery products, kimchi,
sausages, etc. Microbial activities impart enhanced shelf life, organoleptic properties,
nutritional value, and functional properties to the foods. The types, properties,
microbes involved, and health benefits of fermented foods have been extensively
reviewed by van Hylckama et al. (2011), Tamang et al. (2016), and Marco et al. (2017).
Probiotics are nonpathogenic bacteria or yeast that can survive the harsh
environment of gastrointestinal tract to confer health benefits to the host when
consumed in adequate amounts (O’Toole et al. 2017). WHO defines probiotics as
“live microorganisms that, when consumed in adequate amounts, have a positive
influence on the individual’s health.” The global probiotic market is projected to
reach a turnover value of US $46.55 billion by 2020 (http://www.market-
sandmarkets.com). The more commonly exploited strains/species among the
lactobacilli and bifidobacteria have been accepted as having generally regarded as
safe status (O’Toole et al. 2017). A list of various probiotic strains of microbes is
given in Table 1.4. Health benefits of probiotics are well documented for prevention
and treatment of acute gastroenteritis, antibiotic-associated diarrhea, necrotizing
enterocolitis, allergies, infantile colic disease, Helicobacter pylori infection,
cholesterolemia, lactose intolerance, irritable bowel syndrome, and certain types of
cancer (Fontana et al. 2013; Doron and Snydman 2015; Chua et al. 2017).
Table 1.3 Microbial cell factories employed for the industrial productions of biopharmaceuticals,
proteins, enzymes, organic acids, and many other bioproducts of industrial importance
Prokaryotic microbial cell factories Eukaryotic microbial cell factories
Bacillus subtilis Aspergillus niger
B. clausii A. oryzae
B. amyloliquefaciens Ashbya gossypii
B. megaterium Candida famata
Brevibacterium lactofermentum Crypthecodinium cohnii
Corynebacterium glutamicum Hansenula polymorpha
Escherichia coli Mortierella alpina
Pseudomonas fluorescens Penicillium chrysogenum
Pseudomonas putida Pichia pastoris
Ralstonia eutropha Saccharomyces cerevisiae
Yarrowia lipolytica Schizosaccharomyces pombe
Trichoderma reesei
Table 1.4 Microbial species generally recognized for their beneficial role as probiotics (Compiled
from Fontana et al. 2013; Doron and Snydman 2015; Chua et al. 2017)
Bacteria Fungi
Escherichia coli Nissle 1917 Saccharomyces cerevisiae
Lactobacillus reuteri DSM 17938 Saccharomyces boulardii CNCM I-745
Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG Kluyveromyces spp.
Lactobacillus acidophilus CL1285 Torulaspora spp.
Lactobacillus casei Shirota Pichia spp.
Lactobacillus paracasei B21060 Candida spp.
Enterococcus faecium
Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis DN-173010
Bifidobacterium longum subsp. longum 35624
Streptococcus thermophilus
Pediococcus pentosaceus
Leuconostoc mesenteroides
Bacillus subtilis
Clostridium butyricum
and Demain 2014; Krüger et al. 2017). Some details about the sources of microbial
strains, genome databases, and other biotechnological and bioinformatic aspects are
provided in Table 1.6.
Table 1.5 List of various industrial products, biopharmaceuticals, and other bioproducts derived from prokaryotic and eukaryotic microorganisms
Microbial products Microbial source Applications References
Antibiotics (penicillins, tetracyclines, Streptomyces spp., Penicillium spp., Bacillus Treatment and control of Demain and Sanchez
cephalosporins, quinolones, lincomycins, spp., Saccharopolyspora sp., Amycolatopsis sp., bacterial, fungal, and protozoal (2009); Sarkar et al.
macrolides, sulfonamides, glycopeptides, Micromonospora sp., Fusidium sp. infections in humans and (2017)
aminoglycosides, carbapenems Pseudomonas animals
Anticancer chemotherapeutics Streptoalloteichus hindustanus, Streptomyces Treatment of cancers Demain and Sanchez
(actinomycin D, bleomycin, doxorubicin, peucetius, Sorangium cellulosum (2009); Cragg and
mithramycin, streptozotocin, epothilones, Newman (2013)
etc.)
Cholesterol-lowering drugs (lovastatin, Monascus ruber, Aspergillus terreus, Nocardia In human health for reducing Lippi and Plebani
simvastatin, mevastatin, pravastatin) autotrophica, Penicillium citrinum cholesterol and treating cancer (2017)
Biopharmaceuticals (recombinant human E. coli, Saccharomyces cerevisiae Diabetes, immunological Sanchez-Garcia et al.
insulin, other hormones, cytokines, disorders, cancers, growth (2016); Bandyopadhyay
growth factors, interleukins, interferons) disorders; as biosimilars and et al. (2017)
biobetters
Microbial enzymes (amylase, protease, Bacillus licheniformis, B. stearothermophilus, In food, baking, dairy, Canganella and Wiegel
lipase, pullulanase, cellulases, xylanase, B. amyloliquefaciens, Clostridium, Thermotoga, biopharmaceuticals, feed, (2014); Poli et al.
glucoamylase, endoglucanase, Methanopyrus, Pyrococcus, Thermococcus, agriculture, paper, pulp, leather, (2017); Krüger et al.
endoxylanase, β-glucosidase, chitinase, Halobacterium, Halobacillus, Aspergillus, textile, detergents, biofuels, (2017)
pectinase) Penicillium, Streptomyces chemical, cosmetics, and
bioremediation industries
Biofuels (biodiesel, bioethanol, Clostridium acetobutylicum, Chlamydomonas An eco-friendly alternatives to Kung et al. (2012);
isoprenoid, butanol, fatty acids, hydrogen) reinhardtii, E. coli, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, conventional petroleum-based Show et al. (2017)
Zymomonas mobilis, Synechococcus elongatus, fuels
Chlorella protothecoides
Small at Size, Big at Impact: Microorganisms for Sustainable Development
Microbial biomass protein (MBP) Spirulina (Arthrospira platensis and A. Nutritional supplement for Mazard et al. (2016)
maxima), Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Chlorella, human; feed additive
Dunaliella, Aspergillus, Chaetomium,
Paecilomyces, Penicillium, Trichoderma
(continued)
17
18
358. The system which accounts for such phenomena as have been
considered in this and some of the preceding notes, by the operation
of a great deluge, or debacle, as it is called, has been already
mentioned. In Dr Hutton's theory, nothing whatever is ascribed to
such accidental and unknown causes; and, though their existence is
not absolutely denied, their effects, whatever they may have been,
are alleged to be entirely obliterated, so that they can be referred to
no other class but that of mere possibilities. A minute discussion,
however, of the question, Whether there are, on the surface of the
earth, any effects that require the interposition of an extraordinary
cause, would lead into a longer digression than is suited to this
place. I shall briefly state what appear to be the principal objections
to all such explanations of the phenomena of geology.
359. The general structure of valleys among mountains, is highly
unfavourable to the notion that they were produced by any single
great torrent, which swept over the surface of the earth. In some
instances, valleys diverge, as it were from a centre, in all directions.
In others, they originate from a ridge, and proceed with equal depth
and extent on both sides of it, plainly indicating, that the force which
produced them was nothing, or evanescent at the summit of that
ridge, and increased on both sides, as the distance from the ridge
increased. The working of water collected from the rains and the
snows, and seeking its way from a higher to a lower level, is the only
cause we know of, which is subject to this law.
360. Again, if we consider a valley as a space, which perhaps with
many windings and irregularities, has been hollowed out of the solid
rock, it is plain, that no force of water, suddenly applied, could
loosen and remove the great mass of stone which has actually
disappeared. The greatest column of water that could be brought to
act against such a mass, whatever be the velocity we ascribe to it,
could not break asunder and displace beds of rock many leagues in
length, and in continuity with the rock on either side of them. The
slow working of water, on the other hand, or the powers that we see
every day in action, are quite sufficient for this effect, if time only is
allowed them.
361. Some valleys are so particularly constructed, as to carry with
them a still stronger refutation of the existence of a debacle. These
are the longitudinal valleys, which have the openings by which the
water is discharged, not at one extremity, but at the broadside Such
is that on the east side of Mont Blanc, deeply excavated on the
confines of the granite and schistus rock, and extending parallel to
the beds of the latter, from the Col de la Segne to the Col de Ferret;
its opening is nearly in the middle, from which the Dora issues, and
takes its course through a great valley, nearly at right angles to the
chain of the Alps, and to the valley just mentioned. From the
structure of these valleys, Saussure has argued very justly against
Buffon's hypothesis, concerning the formation of valleys by currents
at the bottom of the sea.[182] It affords indeed a complete refutation
of that hypothesis: and it affords one no less complete of the system
which Saussure himself seems on some occasions so much inclined
to support. For if it be said, that this valley was cut out by the
current of a debacle, that current must either have run in the
direction of the valley of Ferret, or in that of the Dora, which issues
from it. If it had the direction of the first, it could not cut out the
second; and if it had the direction of the second, it could not cut out
the first. Besides, the force which excavated this valley must have
been nothing at the two extreme points, viz. at the Col de la Segne
and the Col de Ferret, and must have increased with the distance
from each. It can have been produced, therefore, only by the
running of two streams in opposite directions, on a surface that was
but slightly uneven, these streams at meeting taking a new
direction, nearly at right angles to the former. A clearer proof could
hardly be required than is afforded in this case, that what is now a
deep valley was formerly solid rock, which the running of the waters
has gradually worn away; and that the waters, when they began to
run, were on a level as high, at least, as the tops of those mountains
by which the valley is bounded toward the lower side.
[182] Voyage aux Alpes, tom. ii. § 920.
362. Longitudinal valleys, with the water bursting out transversely
from their sides, like the preceding, are by no means confined to
mountains of the first order. We have a very good example, though
on a small scale, of a valley of this sort, within a few miles of
Edinburgh. The Pentland Hills form a double ridge, separated by a
small longitudinal valley, that runs from N. E. to S. W., the water of
which issues from an opening almost in the middle, and directed
towards the south. This, therefore, is not the work of any great
torrent, which overwhelmed the country; for no one direction, which
it is possible to assign to such a torrent, will afford an explanation,
both of the valley and its outlet.[183]
[183] In Scotland there is one valley, of a kind that I believe is extremely rare in
any part of the world, in accounting for which, the hypothesis of a torrent or
debacle might, if any where, be employed to advantage. This is the valley which
extends across the island, from Inverness to Fort William, or from sea to sea,
being open at both ends, and very little elevated in the middle. It is nearly
straight, and of a very uniform breadth, except that towards each end it widens
considerably. The bottom, reckoning transversely, is flat, without any gradual slope
from the sides towards the middle. From the sides the mountains rise immediately,
and form two continued ridges of great height, like ramparts or embankments on
each side of a large fossé. A great part of the bottom of this singular valley is
occupied by lakes, namely, Loch Ness, Loch Oich, and Loch Lochy. Its length is
about sixty-two miles, and the point of partition from which the waters run
different ways, viz. north-east to the German Ocean, and south-west to the
Atlantic, is between Loch Oich and Loch Lochy; and, by the estimation of the eye,
I should hardly think that it is elevated more than ten or fifteen feet above the
surface of either lake. The country on both sides is rugged and mountainous, and
the streams which descend from thence into the valley, either fall directly into the
lakes, or turn off almost at right angles when they enter the valley. Though the
bottom of this valley, therefore, is every where alluvial, with the exception,
perhaps, of a few rocks which appear at the surface, it is certainly not excavated
by the rivers which now flow in it. The direction of the valley, it is to be observed,
is the same with that of the vertical strata which compose the mountain on either
side.
Here, then, we have a valley, not cut out by the working of any streams which
now appear; and we may therefore make trial of the hypothesis of a debacle. This,
however, will afford us no assistance; because, if we suppose what is now hollow
to have been once occupied by the same kind of rock which is on either side, no
force of torrents can have suddenly loosened and removed from its place a body
of such vast magnitude. A greater column of water, than one having for its base a
transverse section of the valley, could not act against it, and this would have to
overcome the cohesion and inertia of a column of rock of the same section, and of
the length of sixty-two miles. It is not hazarding much to affirm, that no velocity
which could be communicated to water, not even that which it could acquire by
falling from an infinite height, could give to it a force in any degree adequate to
this great effect.
The explanation of this valley, which appears to me the most probable, is the
following. It will be shown hereafter, that there is good reason to suppose, that, in
most parts of our island, the relative level of the sea and land has been in past
ages considerably higher than it is at present. In such circumstances, this valley
may have been under the surface of the sea, the highest part of it being scarcely
100 feet above that level at present. It may have been a kind of sound, therefore,
or strait, which connected the German Sea with the Atlantic; and the strong
currents, which, on account of the different times of high water in these two seas,
must have run alternately up and down this strait, may have produced that
flatness of the bottom, and straightness of the sides, and that widening at the
extremities, which are mentioned above. In this way, too, some difficulties are
removed relative to Loch Ness, which is so deep as hardly to be consistent with
the indefinite length of the period of waste that must be ascribed to the mountains
on each side of it. Its depth is said, where greatest, not to be less than 180
fathoms. According to this hypothesis, it may, at no very distant period, have been
a part of the bottom of the sea.
363. They who maintain the existence of the debacle, will no doubt
allege, that though these valleys were not cut out by means of it, yet
others may. But it must be recollected, that if some of the greatest
and deepest valleys on the face of the earth, such as that just
mentioned, on the east side of Mont Blanc, are thus shown to be the
work of the daily wasting of the surface, what other inequalities can
be great enough to require the interposition of a more powerful
cause? If a dignus vindice nodus does not exist here, in what part of
the natural history of the earth is it likely to be found?
364. The large masses of rock so often met with at a distance from
their original place, are one of the arguments used for the debacle.
It has, however, been shown, that, supposing a form of the earth's
surface considerably different from the present, especially, supposing
the absence of the valleys which the rivers have gradually cut out,
the transportation of such stones is not impossible, even by such
powers as nature employs at present. Now, without the supposition
that the surface was more continuous, and that its present
inequalities did not exist, no force of torrents, whatever their velocity
and magnitude may have been, could have produced this
transportation. No force of water could raise a stone like the pierre
de goutté from the bottom of a valley, to the top of a steep hail.
Indeed, if we suppose a great fragment of rock to be hurried along
on a horizontal or an inclined plane, by the force of water, the
moment it comes to a deep valley, and has to rise up over an ascent
of a certain steepness, it will remain at rest; the water itself will lose
its velocity, and the heavy bodies which it carried with it will proceed
no farther. Thus, therefore, we have the following dilemma. If the
surface is not supposed to have had a certain degree of uniformity in
past times, a debacle is insufficient for the transportation of stones:
If it is supposed to have had that uniformity, a debacle is
unnecessary.
365. Another fact, which has been supposed favourable to the
opinion of the action of great torrents at some former period, is, that
in countries like that round Edinburgh, where whinstone hills rise up
from among secondary strata, a remarkable uniformity is observed
in the direction of their abrupt faces. Thus, in the country just
mentioned, the steep faces generally front the west, whiles in the
opposite direction, the slope is gentle, and the hills decline gradually
into the plain. Hence it is supposed, that a torrent, sweeping from
west to east, has carried off the strata from the west side of these
hills, but, being obstructed by the whinstone rock, has left the strata
on the east side in their natural place.
But, besides that no force which can ever be ascribed to a torrent
could have removed at once bodies of strata 300 or 400 feet, nay
even 800 or 1000 in thickness, which must have been the case if this
were the true explanation of the fact, there is a circumstance which
may perhaps enable us to explain these phenomena without the
assistance of any extraordinary cause. The secondary strata in which
the whinstone hills are found in this part of Scotland, are not
horizontal, but rise or head towards the west, dipping towards the
east. The side, therefore, of the whinstone hills which is precipitous,
is the same with that towards which the strata rise. Now, from the
manner in which these hills are supposed to have been elevated, the
strata are likely to have been most broken and shattered towards
that side, while, on the opposite, they had the support of the
whinstone rock. They would become a prey, therefore, more easily
to the common causes of erosion and waste on the upper side than
on the lower. The streams that flowed from the higher grounds
would wear them on the former most readily; and the action of
these streams would be resisted by the superior hardness of the
whinstone, just as the great torrent of the debacle is supposed to
have been.
It should also be observed, that this fact of the uniform direction of
the abrupt faces of mountains, is often too hastily generalized. In
primitive countries, it is no farther observed than by the steep faces
of the mountains being most frequently turned toward the central
chain. In Scotland, as soon as you leave the flat country, and enter
the Highlands, the scarps of the hills face indiscriminately all the
points of the compass, and are directed as often to the east as to
the west.
366. Where the strata are nearly horizontal, they afford the most
distinct information concerning the direction and progress of the
wasting of the land. The inclined position of the strata, which in all
other cases must enter for so much into our estimate of the causes
which have produced the present inequality of the earth's surface,
disappears there entirely; and the whole of that inequality is to be
ascribed to the operations at the surface, whether they have been
sudden or gradual. A very important fact from a country of this sort,
is related by Barrow, in his Travels into Southern Africa. The
mountains about the Cape of Good Hope, and as far to the north as
that ingenious traveller prosecuted his journey, are chiefly of
horizontal strata of sandstone and limestone, exhibiting the
appearance, on their abrupt sides, of regular layers of masonry, of
towers, fortifications, &c. Now, among all these mountains, he
observed, that the high or steep sides look constantly down the
rivers, while the sloping or inclined sides have just the opposite
direction. When, in travelling northward, he passed the line of
partition, where the waters from running south take their direction
to the north, he found, that the gradual slope, which had hitherto
been turned to the north, was now turned to the south: The abrupt
aspect of the mountains, in like manner, from facing the south, was
directed to the north; so that, in both cases, the hills turned their
backs on the line of greatest elevation.[184]
[184] Barrow's Travels into Southern Africa, p. 245.
The great system of currents thus traced through the Atlantic, has
no doubt phenomena corresponding to it in the Indian and Pacific
Oceans, which the industry of future navigators may discover. The
whole appears to be connected with the trade winds, the figure of
our continents, the temperature of the seas themselves, and
perhaps with some inequalities in the structure of the globe. The
disturbance produced by these causes in the equilibrium of the sea,
probably reaches to the very bottom of it, and gives rise to those
counter currents, which have sometimes been discovered at great
depths under the surface.[191]
[191] Histoire Naturelle de Buffon, Supplément, tom. ix. p. 479. 8vo.
379. A remark which Major Rennell has made concerning the mouths
of rivers, in his Geography of Herodotus, deserves Mr Kirwan's
attention, though perhaps he may not be able to put on it an
interpretation quite so favourable to his system. The remark is, that
the mouths of great rivers are often formed on principles quite
opposite to one another, so that some of them have a real delta or
triangle of flat land at their mouths, while others have an estuary, or
what may not improperly be called a negative delta. Of the latter
kind are some of the greatest rivers in the world, the Plata, the
Oroonoko and the Maranon, and by far the greatest number of our
European rivers. Nobody can doubt, that the three rivers just named
carry with them as much earth as the Nile, or the Euphrates, or any
other river in the world. All this they have deposited in the sea, and
committed to the currents, which sweep along the shore of the
American continent, and by these they have been spread out over
the unlimited tracts of the ocean.
Indeed, nothing can be more just than Dr Hutton's observation, that
where low land is formed at the mouths of rivers, there the rivers
bring down more than the sea is able to carry away; but that where
such land is not formed, it is because the sea is able to carry off
immediately all the deposit which it receives.
380. Mr Kirwan has denied on another principle the power of the sea
to carry to a distance the materials delivered into it:
"Notwithstanding," says he, "many particles of earth are by rivers
conduced to the sea, yet none are conveyed in any distance, but are
either deposited at their mouths, or rejected by currents or by tides;
and the reason is, because the tide of flood is always more
impetuous and forcible than the tide of ebb, the advancing waves
being pressed forward by the countless number behind them,
whereas the retreating are pressed backward by a far smaller
number, as must be evident to an attentive spectator; and hence it is
that all floating things cast into the sea, are at last thrown on shore,
and not conveyed into the mid regions of the sea, as they should be
if the reciprocal undulations of the tides were equally powerful "[197]
[197] Kirwan's Geol. Essays, p. 439.
381. But if the attentive spectator, instead of trusting to a vague
impression, or listening to some crude theory of undulations, reflects
on one of the most simple facts respecting the ebbing and flowing of
the tides, he will be very little disposed to acquiesce in the above
conclusion. He has only to consider, that the flowing of the tide
requires just six hours, and the ebbing of it likewise six hours; so
that the same body of water flows in upon the shore, and retreats
from it, in the same time. The quantity of matter moved, therefore,
and the velocity with which it is moved, are in both cases the same;
and it remains for Mr Kirwan to show in what the difference of their
force can possibly consist.
The force with which the waves usually break upon our shores, does
not arise from the velocity of the tide being greater in one direction
than in another. In the main ocean, the waves have no progressive
motion, and the columns of water alternately rise and fall, without
any other than a reciprocating motion: a kind of equilibrium takes
place among the undulations, and each wave being equally acted
upon by those on opposite sides, remains fixed in its place. Near the
shore this cannot happen; the water on the land side from its
shallowness being incapable of rising to the height necessary to
balance the great undulations which are without. The water runs,
therefore, as it were, from a higher to a lower level, spreading itself
towards the land side. This produces the breakers on our shores,
and the surf of the tropical seas. A rock or a sandbank coming within
a certain distance of the surface, is sufficient, in any part of the
ocean, to obstruct the natural succession of undulations; and, by
destroying the mutual reaction of the waves, to give them a
progressive instead of a reciprocating motion.
382. It is, however, but from a small distance, that the waves are
impelled against the shore with a progressive motion. The border of
breakers that surrounds any coast is narrow, compared with the
distance to which the detritus from the land is confessedly carried;
the water, while it advances at the surface, flows back at the
bottom; and these contrary motions are so nearly equal, that it is
but a very momentary accumulation of the water that is ever
produced on any shore.
If it were otherwise, and if it were true that the sea throws out every
thing, and carries away nothing, we should have a constant
accumulation of earth and sand along all shores whatsoever, at least
wherever a stream ran into the sea. This, as is abundantly evident,
is quite contrary to the fact.
So, also, the bars formed at the mouths of rivers, after having
attained a certain magnitude, increase no farther, not because they
cease to receive augmentations from the land, but because their
diminution from the sea, increasing with their magnitude, becomes
at length so great, as completely to balance those augmentations.
When properly examined, therefore, the phenomena, which have
been proposed as most inconsistent with the indefinite
transportation of stony bodies, afford very satisfactory proofs of that
operation.
383. It is true, that bodies which float in the water, when carried
along on the tops of the waves towards a shelving beach, having
acquired a certain velocity, are thrown farther in upon the land than
the distance they would have floated to, if they had been simply
sustained by the water. The depth of water, therefore, at the place
where they take the ground, is not likely to be such as to float them
again, and to carry them out towards the sea. They are, therefore,
left behind; and this produces an appearance of a force impelling
floating bodies towards the land, much greater and more general
than really takes place.
These observations may serve to show, how unsound the principles
are from which Mr Kirwan's conclusions are deduced: they are
perhaps more than is necessary for that purpose: it might have been
sufficient to observe, that the increase of land on the sea shore is
limited, though the augmentation from the land is certainly
indefinite, a proof that the diminution from the sea is constant and
equal to the increase.
384. "Mariners," says Mr Kirwan, "were accustomed, for some
centuries back, to discover their situation, by the kind of earth or
sand brought up by their sounding plummets; a method which
would prove fallacious, if the surface of the bottom did not continue
invariably the same."[198]
[198] Geol. Essays, p. 440.
The fact here stated, that mariners, when navigation was more
imperfect than it is now, had very frequent recourse to this method,
and that they still use it occasionally, is very true. But from this, the
only inference that can be fairly deduced is, that the changes at the
bottom of the sea are very slow, and the variation but little; not
merely from one year to another, but even from one century to
another. The rules by which the mariner judged of his position from
the quality of the earth which the lead brought up, and which were
deduced no doubt from observations made at no very great distance
of time, might be sufficient for his purpose, though a slow change
had been all the while going forward. Such observations could at
best have little accuracy, and could not be affected by small
variations. It is the slowness of the change, that makes the
experience of one age applicable, in this, as in innumerable other
instances, to the observations of the next. If a long interval is taken,
we will look in vain for the same uniformity of results. A pilot, who
would at present judge of his position in the German Ocean, by
comparing his soundings with those taken by Pytheas, (supposing
them known) in his navigation of that sea, more than 2000 years
ago, could hardly be expected to determine his latitude and
longitude with great exactness; and I know not if the most zealous
advocate for the immutability of the earth's surface, would be willing
to trust his safety in a ship that was guided by such antiquated
rules.
Note xx. § 118.
Inequalities in the Planetary Motions.
385. The assertion that, in the planetary motions, we discover no
mark, either of the commencement or termination of the present
order, refers to the late discoveries of La Grange and La Place, which
have contributed so much to the perfection of physical astronomy.
From the principle of universal gravitation, these mathematicians
have demonstrated, that all the variations in our system are
periodical; that they are confined within certain limits; and consist of
alternate diminution and increase. The orbits of the planets change
not only their position, but even their magnitude and their form: the
longer axis of each has a slow angular motion; and, though its
length remains fixed, the shorter axis increases and diminishes, so
that the form of the orbit approaches to that of a circle, and recedes
from it by turns. In the same manner, the obliquity of the ecliptic,
and the inclination of the planetary orbits, are subject to change; but
the changes are small, and, being first in one direction, and then in
the opposite, they can never accumulate so as to produce a
permanent or a progressive alteration. Thus, in the celestial motions,
no room is left for the introduction of disorder; no irregularity or
disturbance, arising from the mutual action of the planets, is
permitted to increase beyond certain limits, but each of them, in
time, affords a correction for itself. The general order is constant, in
the midst of the variation of the parts; and, in the language of La
Place, there is a certain mean condition, about which our system
perpetually oscillates performing small vibrations on each side of it,
and never receding from it far.[199] The system is thus endowed with
a stability, which can refill the lapse of unlimited duration; it can only
perish by an external cause, and by the introduction of laws, of
which at present no vestige is to be traced.
[199] Exposition du Systéme du Monde, par La Place, Livre iv. chap. 6. p. 199. 2d
edit.
386. The same calculus to which we are indebted for these sublime
conclusions, informs us of two circumstances, which mark the law
here treated of as an effect of wise design, to the entire exclusion
both of necessity and chance. One of these circumstances consists in
the planetary motions being all in the same direction, or all in
consequentia as it is called by the astronomers. This is essential to
the compensation and stability above mentioned:[200] had one
planet circulated round the sun in a direction from east to west, and
another in a direction from west to east, the disturbances they
would have produced on one another's motion would not necessarily
have been periodical; their irregularities might have continually
increased, and they might have deviated in the course of ages from
their original condition, beyond any limits that can be assigned.
[200] La Place, ibid.
The other circumstance, on which the stability of our system
depends, is the small eccentricity of the planetary orbits, or their
near approach to circles. Were their orbits very eccentric, an opening
would be given to progressive change, that might so far increase, as
to prove the destruction of the whole. But neither the movement of
all the planets in the same direction, nor the small eccentricity of
their orbits, can be ascribed to accident, since that either of these
should happen by chance, in as many instances as there are planets,
both primary and secondary, is almost infinitely improbable. Again,
that any necessity in the nature of things should have either
determined the direction of the planetary motions, or proportioned
the quantity of them to the intensity of the central force, cannot be
admitted, as these are things unavoidably conceived to be quite
independent of one another. It remains, therefore, that we consider
the laws, which make the disturbances in our system correct
themselves, and by that means give firmness and permanence to it,
as a proof of the consummate wisdom with which the whole is
constructed.
387. The geological system of Dr Hutton, resembles, in many
respects, that which appears to preside over the heavenly motions.
In both, we perceive continual vicissitude and change, but confined
within certain limits, and never from a certain, mean condition,
which is such, that, in the lapse of time, the deviations from it on
the one side, must become just equal to the deviations from it on
the other. In both, a provision is made for duration of unlimited
extent, and the lapse of time has no effect to wear out or destroy a
machine, constructed with so much wisdom. Where the movements
are all so perfect, their beginning and end must be alike invisible.
Note xxi. § 122.
Changes in the apparent Level of the Sea.
388. In speaking of the natural epochs marked out by the
phenomena of the mineral kingdom, we have supposed a greater
simplicity, and separation of effects from one another, than probably
takes place in nature. We have, for instance, abstracted, in speaking
of the waste and degradation of the land, from that elevation which
may have been carried on at the same time. This appeared
necessary to be done, in order to simplify as much as possible the
view that was to be given of the whole; but there can be no doubt,
that, while the land has been gradually worn down by the operations
on its surface, it has been raised up by the expansive forces acting
from below. There is even reason to think, that the elevation has not
been uniform, but has been subject to a kind of oscillation,
insomuch, that the continents have both ascended and descended,
or have had their level alternately raised and depressed,
independently of all action at the surface, and this within a period
comparatively of no great extent.
It will be easily understood, that the facts we are going to state,
each taken singly, prove nothing more than a change of the line in
which the surface of the sea intersects the surface of the land,
leaving it uncertain to which of the two the change ought really to
be ascribed. Taken in combination, however, these facts may
determine what each of them separately cannot ascertain. I shall
first, therefore, mention some of the principal observations relative
to the change above mentioned, and shall then compare them, in
order to discover whether it is most probable that this change has
been produced by the motion of the land or of the sea.
389. If we begin with examining the coasts of our own island, we
shall find clear evidence every where, that the sea once reached
higher up upon the land than it does at present. The marks of an
ancient sea beach are to be seen beyond the present limits of the
tide, and beds of sea shells, not mineralized, are found in the loose
earth or soil, sometimes as high as thirty feet above the present
level of the sea. Some of these on the shores of the Frith of Forth
are very well known, and have been often mentioned. Indeed, on
the shores of that frith, many monuments appear, which would seem
to carry the difference between the present and the ancient level of
the sea, to more than forty feet. The ground on which the Botanic
Garden of Edinburgh is situated, after a thin covering of soil is
removed, consists entirely of sea sand, very regularly stratified, with
layers of a black carbonaceous matter, in thin lamellæ, interposed
between them. Shells I believe are but rarely found in it, but it has
every other appearance of a sea beach. The height of this ground
above the present level of the sea is certainly not less than forty
feet.
390. On almost every part of the coast where the rocks do not rise
quite abrupt and precipitous from the sea, similar marks of the
lowering of the sea, or the rising of the land, may be observed. On
the shores opposite to ours, the same appearances are remarked.
The author of the Lettre Critique to M. de Buffon, tells us, that he
had found the bottom of a bason at Dunkirk, which he had reason to
think was dug about 950 years ago, ten feet and a half above the
present low water mark, though it must have been originally under
it. The bottom of this bason is in the native chalk. From this, the
same author concludes, that the sea at Dunkirk lowers its level at
the rate of an inch nearly in seven years. The observation was made
in 1762, (Lettre à M. le Comte de Buffon, &c. p. 55.)[201]
[201] In the county of Suffolk, near Wood Bridge, at the distance of seven or eight
miles from the sea, are the Crag-pits, in which prodigious quantities of sea shells
are discovered, many of them perfect and quite solid, (Pennant's Arctic Zoology,
Introd. p. 6.) Lincolnshire affords various proofs of the same kind; but some other