Lecture 1 - Hadi
Lecture 1 - Hadi
2022-01-10
Issues in Traffic Simulation Modeling
Categorization of Traffic Simulation Models
Overview on Traffic Simulation Software
2
SYSTEM AND MODEL
2022-01-10
System
Part of an environment that could be divided by a physical or logical
boundary.
Model
It is a simplification of the reality.
A (usually miniature) representation of something; an example for
imitation or emulation.
A model can be Physical, Mathematical [Analytical (Queuing Theory) or
Simulation].
Simplified, abstract tool use to observe or predict behavior of real systems.
3
CHARACTERISTICS OF A MODEL
2022-01-10
A model is never equal to the real system, because it is always simpler than the
reality.
The accuracy of a model is determined by its tendency to approach the real
system.
Pe an 2 bn c(a 0)
Pe= engine power and n=the rotational speed
4
ROAD TRAFFIC SIMULATION: NEEDED
COMPONENTS
2022-01-10
Prepared by Dr. Md. Hadiuzzaman
road network vehicles / flow signalling
5
HOW CAN WE EVALUATE PERFORMANCE
OF A SYSTEM?
2022-01-10
SYSTEM
Experiment with the Experiment with a
2022-01-10
Traffic operations on roadways can be improved by field research and field
experiments of real-life traffic flow.
However, apart from the scientific problem of reproducing such experiments,
costs and safety play a role of dominant importance as well.
2022-01-10
The description of observed phenomena in traffic flow is not self-evident.
General mathematical models aimed at describing this behaviour using
mathematical equations include the following approaches:
8
ADVANTAGES OF TRAFFIC SIMULATION
2022-01-10
Improve the decision making process
Evaluate and prioritize planning/operational alternatives
Improve design and evaluation time and costs
9
IMPROVE THE DECISION MAKING
PROCESS
2022-01-10
Traffic analysis tools help practitioners arrive at better
planning/engineering decisions for complex transportation problems.
Used to estimate the impact of the deployment of traffic management
and other strategies.
10
EVALUATE AND PRIORITIZE
PLANNING/OPERATIONAL ALTERNATIVES
2022-01-10
This typically involves comparing “no build” conditions with
alternatives, which include various types of potential improvements.
The impacts are reported as performance measures and are defined as
the difference between the no-build and alternative scenarios.
11
IMPROVE DESIGN AND EVALUATION
(TIME AND COSTS)
2022-01-10
Traffic analysis tools are relatively less costly when compared to pilot
studies, field experiments, or full implementation costs.
Furthermore, analytical tools (not simulation) can be used to assess
multiple deployment combinations or other complex scenarios in a
12
REDUCE DISRUPTIONS TO TRAFFIC
2022-01-10
Traffic management and control strategies come in many forms and
options, and simulation tools provide a way to cheaply estimate the
effects prior to full deployment of the management strategy.
13
PRESENT/MARKET STRATEGIES TO THE
PUBLIC/STAKEHOLDERS
2022-01-10
Some traffic simulation tools have excellent graphical and animation
displays, which could be used as tools to show “what if” scenarios to the
public and/or stakeholders.
2022-01-10
Some simulation tool provide a way to integrate optimization tool.
Thus capable of recommending the best design or control strategies to
maximize the performance of a transportation facility.
2022-01-10
Simulation tools can also be used to evaluate and monitor the
performance of existing transportation facilities.
Monitoring systems (in TMC) can be directly linked to simulation
16
LIMITATIONS OF TRAFFIC SIMULATIONS
2022-01-10
Simulations are resource limited
Resolution: Level of detail
Fidelity: Degree of realism
17
STEPS IN SIMULATION
2022-01-10
Certain sequential operations are involved in any problem
wherein simulation techniques are adopted. These are:
Definition of the problem
(You want to optimize signal; you need traffic and existing signal data;
may be the max green will provided to the approach having maximum
demand; code road geometry, signal head, presence detectors; Tune the
model’s operational and system parameters; Check the model accuracy.)
18
CATEGORIZATION: LEVEL OF DETAILS
2022-01-10
Microscopic simulation models:
2022-01-10
Macroscopic simulation models:
2022-01-10
Mesoscopic simulation models:
2022-01-10
Models
parameters
Describes the mobility at of anumber
for
intermediate specific
level of of
car.
cars,
It such
as
details.
flow, commands
usually speed, or density.
the car’s acceleration/deceleration in order
to maintain either a safe distance headway or to guarantee a
safeMicroscopic
time headway. < Mesoscopic <
Macroscopic
X Y
22
CATEGORIZATION :
SCALE OF THE INDEPENDENT VARIABLES
2022-01-10
Since almost all traffic models describe dynamical systems, a natural
classification is the time-scale.
2022-01-10
In this respect, we distinguish deterministic and stochastic models.
24
CATEGORIZATION:
OPERATIONALISATION
2022-01-10
With respect to the operationalisation criterion, models can be
operationalised either as analytical solutions of sets of equations, or
as a simulation model.
But analytical models require large amount of field data such as, road width,
lane width, roughness, complete information on geometric design, vehicle
composition, type, traffic volumes, speeds & density etc.
Extremely costly & tedious
Often uncertainties are involved in the data
The simulation models are, where the successive changes of the traffic
system over time (space-time dynamics) are reproduced (approximated)
in the model.
Simulation models are dynamic
25
CATEGORIZATION:
STATIC VERSES DYNAMIC
2022-01-10
Static
Models average steady-state traffic situation
Dynamic
(If input demand remain unchanged, flow will also remain unchanged)
Static
Dynamic
26
7:00 10:00 15:00 18:00
CATEGORIZATION:
SCALE OF APPLICATION
2022-01-10
The application scale indicates the area of application of the model.
For instance, the model may describe the dynamics of its entities
for a single roadway stretch, an entire traffic network, a
27
MICROSCOPIC TRAFFIC FLOW MODELS
2022-01-10
detail DI
MODEL NAME / REF. v v0 y o SC RE OP AR
level
MIXIC (Van Arem and Hogema (1995)) + + + d s s ml
SIMONE (Minderhoud (1999)) + + + + d s s ml, d
DI: dimension (other than time / space): velocity v, desired velocity v0,
lateral position y (lanes), and other
SC: scale (continuous, discrete, and semi-discrete);
RE: process representation (deterministic, stochastic);
OP: operationalisation (analytical, simulation); 28
AR: area of application (cross-section, single lane stretches, multilane
stretches, aggregate lane stretches, discontinuities, motorway network,
urban network, and other).
MESOSCOPIC TRAFFIC FLOW MODELS
2022-01-10
detail DI
MODEL NAME / REF. v v0 y o SC RE OP AR
level
headway distr. models (Hoogendoorn and Bovy (1998a)) + + c s a c
reduced gas-kinetic model (Prigogine and Herman + c d a al
DI: dimension (other than time / space): velocity v, desired velocity v0,
lateral position y (lanes), and other
SC: scale (continuous, discrete, and semi-discrete);
RE: process representation (deterministic, stochastic);
OP: operationalisation (analytical, simulation);
AR: area of application (cross-section, single lane stretches, multilane
stretches, aggregate lane stretches, discontinuities, motorway network,
urban network, and other).
29
MACROSCOPIC TRAFFIC FLOW MODELS
2022-01-10
detail DI
MODEL NAME / REF. v v0 y o SC RE OP AR
level
LWR model (Lighthill and Whitham (1955)) + c d a al
DI: dimension (other than time / space): velocity v, desired velocity v0,
lateral position y (lanes), and other
SC: scale (continuous, discrete, and semi-discrete);
RE: process representation (deterministic, stochastic);
OP: operationalisation (analytical, simulation);
AR: area of application (cross-section, single lane stretches, multilane
stretches, aggregate lane stretches, discontinuities, motorway network,
urban network, and other).
30
COMMERCIAL SIMULATION TOOLS
2022-01-10
Many road traffic simulations have been developed to investigate many
different aspects of traffic management.
The most popular type of simulations are motorway and urban systems
due to the high traffic densities and problems of congestion making them the
31
TRAFFIC SIMULATION TOOLS
2022-01-10
Urban Traffic Modeling
Urban traffic simulators have been used to model urban congestion. They
have to cope with large numbers of vehicles and signaled junctions.
32
TRAFFIC SIMULATION TOOLS
2022-01-10
Rural Traffic Modeling
Rural simulators are less common because they are less cost effective than urban simulators. Rural
simulators pay particular attention to models of road slopes and over-taking behavior
ROADSIM (Rural road Simulator) microscopically simulates the movement of vehicles along two lane
two-way rural roads.
2022-01-10
Public-Transport Traffic Modeling
As a response to a government initiative for public transport, simulations have made attempts to
find more efficient routes for public transport vehicles.
AVM is a model developed to simulate the operation of buses equipped with automatic vehicle
34
TRAFFIC SIMULATION TOOLS
2022-01-10
Evacuation Simulations
IDYNEV (Interactive DYnamic EVacuation Model) was developed for the
Federal Emergency Management Agency. It is used to develop evacuation plans
and to estimate evacuation times in response to natural and technological
Environmental Simulations
Governments and environmental agencies are often interested in fuel-consumption
and emission rates made by traffic vehicles.
The TRansportation ANalysis SIMulation System (TRANSIMS) is a set of
transportation and air quality analysis and forecasting procedures developed to
meet the Clean Air Act.
35
MICRO-SIMULATION SOFTWARE: 2D
MODEL
2022-01-10
Prepared by Dr. Md. Hadiuzzaman
Traffic simulation of the city of Cologne conducted CORSIM TRAFVU software package - traffic
in the SUMO software package network simulation a spaghetti junction example
http://sumo-sim.org/userdoc/Downloads.html
2022-01-10
Prepared by Dr. Md. Hadiuzzaman
Link-node network coded in CORSIM Portion of U.S. 280 coded in SimTraffic
37
MICRO-SIMULATION SOFTWARE: 2D
MODEL
2022-01-10
Prepared by Dr. Md. Hadiuzzaman
Nodes, Links and Zones in PARAMIC modeler Bus Stops and Bus Route in PARAMIC modeler
38
2022-01-10 Prepared by Dr. Md. Hadiuzzaman
39
MICRO-SIMULATION SOFTWARE: 3D
MODEL
MICROSCOPIC CA-BASED SIMULATOR
2022-01-10
Prepared by Dr. Md. Hadiuzzaman
http://www.fit.vutbr.cz/units/UPSY/prod/index.php?file=%2Fproduct%2F314%2Fsrc&id=314¬itle=1
40
GUI OF VISUM MACRO-SIMULATOR
2022-01-10
Prepared by Dr. Md. Hadiuzzaman
VISUM is a comprehensive, flexible software system for transportation planning, travel
demand modelling and network data management.
VISUM is used on all continents for metropolitan, regional, state wide and national
planning applications.
Designed for multimodal analysis, VISUM integrates all relevant modes of transportation
(i.e., car, car passenger, goods vehicles, bus, train, motorcycles, bicycles and pedestrians) 41
into one consistent network model.
GUI OF TRANSCAD MACRO-SIMULATOR
2022-01-10
Prepared by Dr. Md. Hadiuzzaman
TransCAD is a special GIS for transportation applications:
Extended data model: TransCAD provides some special data models required to represent the
static/dynamic phenomenon specific to transportation applications such as matrices (Origin-Destination
data), route system (eg. bus route), linear referencing system (eg. location of accident along highway),
special topological network (eg. one-way street system, overpass/underpass), turning restriction (eg.
necessary for finding the best route), and so on.
Special operations for transportation applications: With TransCAD, you can input (eg. reading GPS data,
address matching), process (eg. editing network topology), manipulate (eg. conflation), and analyze 42
transportation data, Besides, TransCAD provides a complete application suite for transportation planning,
vehicle routing, and distribution logistics (available in Standard Version only).
GENERAL CONCLUSION
2022-01-10
‘If all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail’ by Abraham Maslow
Most of the micro-simulation software provide reasonable results for typical
simulation applications. There is no ranking of ‘best’ or ‘worst’ software!!!!
Statistics of 2005:
Micro (around 65 software packages)
Macro (around 16 software packages)
Meso (around 3 software packages)
43
QUESTIONS WHICH CAN BE ANSWERED
BY TRAFFIC SIMULATION (EXAMPLES)
2022-01-10
Is our traffic network sufficient for the travel demand in 15 years?
And others………………………………………………………………
44
USE OF VISSIM MICRO-SIMULATION MODELLING
2022-01-10
Multi-modal integration
Car park guidance system
Insane vehicle
45