Tutorial 04. Arch Bridge As Per AASHTO
Tutorial 04. Arch Bridge As Per AASHTO
Summary ······································································································1
Analysis Model and Load Cases / 2
Summary
This tutorial illustrates the modeling and interpretation of the analysis results of a
single span arch bridge subjected to moving traffic loads.
The explanations for the basic functions of MIDAS CIVIL NX (“Tutorial 1”) are
omitted. The Icon Menu is primarily used. Refer to “Tutorials 1 and 2” and the
Online Manual for understanding the basic functions in MIDAS CIVIL NX and the
structural analysis processes.
The modeling and analysis processes presented in this example are as follows:
1
Tutorial 4
The Figure below shows the arch bridge model. The specifications for the
structure are as follows:
2
Summary
Stringer B4
B3
Strut
[email protected]=14.0
Brace
X
B1 B2
Origin Cross Beam
Framing Plan and Front View Elevation of the Arch Bridge [Unit: m]
3
Tutorial 4
Load Case 1: 90 kN/m Dead Load (applied only on the main girders)
Load Case 2: 6 kN/m Sidewalk Load (applied only on the main girders)
Load Case 3: Vehicle Loads (HL93-TRK, HL93-TDM)
This example focuses on the explanation for the relevant functions in MIDAS
CIVIL NX. The assumptions made in this example may differ from those in
practical applications.
4
File Opening and Preferences Setting
Open a new file ( New Project) to model the bridge and save the file as “Arch
AASHTO LRFD” ( Save).
Click the unit system selection button in Status Bar at the bottom of the screen.
Choose the unit system and select “kN” and “mm”. Change the unit system as
frequently as necessary for the convenience of data entry.
The structure is modeled using the Icon Menu instead of the Tree Menu or Main
Menu to improve the modeling skills of the user.
Save File
5
Tutorial 4
Material Properties
1: A36 – cross beam, bracing
2: A572-50 – main girder, arch rib, hanger
Section Data
1: TS 210060010/10 – Main Girder (Box)
2: I 154050014/27 – Cross Beam (I-Section)
3: TS 60060016/14 – Arch Rib (Box)
4: I 60040012/16 – Hanger (I-Section)
5: TS 60050010/14 – Strut (Box)
6: W16100 – Bracing & Stringer (W-Section)
Sections 1 to 5 are built-up sections. Use the User functions to enter the principal
section dimensions. Use DB, the AISC standard sections, contained in the
program for Section 6.
6
Enter Material and Section Properties
7
Tutorial 4
1. Select the Section tab in the Properties dialog box or select Property >
Section from the Main Menu.
2. Click .
3. Confirm “1” in the Section ID field of the DB/User tab.
4. Type “Main Girder” in the Name field.
5. Select “Box” in the Section Shape selection field.
6. Select “User” in User or DB.
7. Enter “2100” in the H field.
8. Enter “600” in the B field.
9. Enter “10” in the tw field.
10. Enter “10” in the tf1 field.
11. Click .
There are 2 methods to
12. Repeat steps 3 to 11 for Sections 2 to 5 (See Page 6 for details).
specify the Section Note that for Sections 2 and 4, use I-section instead of Box
Name: 13. Confirm “6” in the Section ID field.
1).Click button to the
right of the field and 14. Type “Bracing & Stringer” in the Name field.
select the desired
section name with Scroll
15. Select “I-Section” in the Section Shape selection field.
Bar. 16. Select “DB” in DB or User and select “AISC” in the field to the right.
2) Type in directly the
desired section name. 17. Click the Sect. Name field and type “W 16 100” or use Scroll Bar to
select the type.
Convert the unit system 18. Click .
from “mm” to “m” for
structural modeling. 19. Click .
20. Click the unit system selection button of the Status Bar and change “mm”
to “m”.
8
Enter Material and Section Properties
Define section
9
Tutorial 4
Use Extrude Elements to generate the hangers. Extend the nodes generated on
the arch rib by projecting them perpendicularly downward.
Extrude Elements generates 1. Click Extrude Elements in Node/Element > Elements > Extrude
geometrically 1-dimensional higher
elements by following the moving from the Main Menu.
path of the nodes or elements
(nodeline element, line surface 2. Click Node Number (Toggle on) in the Icon Menu.
element, surfacesolid element).
3. Click Select Window to select nodes 2 to 10 from which the hangers
are generated.
4. Select “NodeLine Elem.” in the Extrude Type selection field.
5. Select “Beam” in Element Type of the Element Attribute selection field.
6. Select “2 : A572-50” in the Material selection field.
7. Select “4 : Hanger” in the Section selection field.
8. Select “Project” in the Generation Type selection field.
Base Line Definition 9. Select “Project on a line” in the Projection Type selection field.
requires 2 nodes of the line
onto which it is projected. 10. Click the P1 field of Base Line definition. Once the background color
turns to pale green, assign node 1 and then assign node 11 for P2 filed.
The Direction choice in
the Project function 11. Select “Normal” in the Direction selection field.
represents the projection
direction of the element. 12. Click .
13. Click Change Element Parameters.
Click Shrink and Hidden (Toggle on) to check the entered Beta Angle.
Check the current data entries and click Shrink and Hidden to toggle off.
11
Tutorial 4
Hanger Generation
12
Enter Structure Boundary Conditions
Create the main girder by connecting both ends of the arch. Duplicate the
completed part of the arch frame including the main girder at the opposite side.
In this example, Point 1. Click Point Grid and Point Grid Snap (Toggle off).
Grid is not used. To
avoid confusion while 2. Click Iso View.
assigning the nodes
with the mouse, toggle 3. Click Create Elements in Node/Elements > Create Elements from
off Point Grid and the Main Menu.
Point Grid Snap.
4. Select “General beam/Tapered beam” in the Element Type
selection field.
5. Select “2 : A572-50” in the Material selection field.
6. Select “1 : Main girder” in the Section selection field.
7. Select “0” in the Beta Angle field of Orientation.
8. Check () in Node of the Intersect selection field.
9. Click the Nodal Connectivity field. Once the background color turns to
pale green, assign nodes 1 to 11.
10. Click Select All.
11. Click Translate Elements.
12. Select “Copy” in the Mode selection field.
13. Select “Equal Distance” in the Translation selection field.
14. Enter “0, 14, 0” in the dx, dy, dz field.
15. Enter “1” in the Number of Times field.
16. Click .
13
Tutorial 4
14
Enter Structure Boundary Conditions
Use Extrude Elements to create the cross beams by extending the nodes on one
of the main girders to the nodes on the opposite main girder.
15
Tutorial 4
16
Enter Structure Boundary Conditions
Completed Stringers
17
Tutorial 4
18
Enter Structure Boundary Conditions
Floor Plane
19
Tutorial 4
Create the bracings on the arch ribs located symmetrically on each side of the mid
span.
Completed Struts
20
Enter Structure Boundary Conditions
1. Click Select Single to select the 5 struts generated in the previous step.
When an undesirable 2. Click Activate.
location is selected
during the data entry of 3. Click Element Number (Toggle on).
elements, click the Esc
key. Alternatively right- 4. Click Create Elements.
click the mouse and
select Cancel at the
5. Select “General beam/Tapered beam” in Element Type.
bottom of the Context 6. Select “1 : A36” in the Material selection field.
Menu to cancel the
entry. 7. Select “6 : Bracing & Stringer” in the Section selection field.
8. Enter “0” in the Beta Angle field of Orientation.
9. Check () in Elem of the Intersect selection field.
10. Click the Nodal Connectivity field. Once the background color turns to
pale green, connect successively the centers of elements 111 to 115 to
To create the bracings create the bracings.
in the central portion of
the arches, selectively 11. Click Element Number (Toggle off).
activate the elements
that are connected to 12. Click the Nodal Connectivity field. Once the background color turns to
the elements being pale green, connect separately nodes 4 and 53, 24 and 53, 5 and 54, 25
generated.
and 54, 54 and 7, 54 and 27, 55 and 8, and 55 and 28.
21
Tutorial 4
22
Enter Structure Boundary Conditions
Use Beam End Release to specify the boundary conditions at both ends of the
beam elements.
Both ends of hangers: Pin joint conditions about the ECS z-axis
Both ends of bracings: Pin joint conditions about the ECS y- and z-axes
Both ends of cross beams connected to the main girders: Pin joint
conditions about the ECS y- and z-axes
23
Tutorial 4
22. Type “80 to 90” in the element selection window and press [Enter].
23. Click the Fixed-Pinned button in the General Types and Partial Fixity
selection field.
24. Click .
25. Click Element Number (Toggle off) in the Icon Menu.
26. Click Activate All in the Icon Menu.
27. Click Node Number (Toggle off) in the Icon Menu.
24
Enter Structure Boundary Conditions
25
Tutorial 4
Generate the Cross Beam Group, which will be used to enter the moving loads.
26
Enter Moving Traffic Loads and Static Loads
27
Tutorial 4
The dead and sidewalk loadings are assumed to be applied only on the main
girders for simplicity.
28
Enter Moving Traffic Loads and Static Loads
29
Tutorial 4
30
Enter Moving Traffic Loads and Static Loads
31
Tutorial 4
The method for defining the moving traffic loads, HL93-TRK and HL93-TDM, is
MIDAS CIVIL NX contains the
standard vehicle loads such as explained below.
AASHTO LRFD, AASHTO
Standard, Caltrans, BS 5400,
BS BD 37/01, etc.
1. Select Load > Moving Load Analysis Data > Vehicles from the Main Menu.
2. Click in the Vehicles dialog box.
3. Select “AASHTO LRFD Load” in the Standard Name field.
4. Confirm “HL-93 TRK” in Vehicle Load Name & Vehicle Load Type fields.
5. Enter “33” in the Dynamic Load Allowance field.
6. Click .
7. Click in the Vehicles Load Type dialog box.
8. Select “AASHTO LRFD Load” in the Standard Name field.
9. Confirm “HL-93 TDM” in Vehicle Load Name & Vehicle Load Type fields.
10. Enter “33” in the Dynamic Load Allowance field.
11. Click .
12. Click .
32
Enter Moving Traffic Loads and Static Loads
33
Tutorial 4
34
Verify and Interpret Analysis Results
Use Moving Load Analysis Control 1. Select Analysis> Analysis Control> Moving Load from the Main Menu.
to input the number of points on
each line element where influence 2. Select “Exact” in the Analysis Method field.
lines should be generated. For 3. Select “All Points” in the Analysis Method field.
example, if “5” is inputted in
Influence Generating Point 4. Enter “5” for the field of Numer/Line Element within the Influence
No./Line Element field, it means
Generating Points.
that the concentrated axle load is
applied successively at 5 equally 5. Select “Normal” in Frame in the Analysis Results field.
spaced points on each line
element, along the direction of the 6. Select “All” in Reactions, Displacements and Forces/Moments within
traffic lane. (Also refer to the Calculation Filters.
Structural Analysis functions in the
Online Manual for details) 7. Click .
8. Click Node Number (Toggle off).
Calculation Filter in Moving Load
Analysis Control Data groups
only the desired part of the
results for review. The grouping
reduces the computation time
and the size of Results file for
large structures.
35
Tutorial 4
Click Analysis.
Load Combinations
We will now examine the Linear Load Combination method of the 3 load cases
(dead load, sidewalk load and moving load) for which structural analyses have
been completed.
In this example, we specify only one load combination as noted below, and check
its results. The load combination case has been arbitrarily chosen and, as such, it
may be irrelevant for any practical design application.
Load Combinations (LCB): 1.00 Dead Load + 1.00 Sidewalk Load + 1.00
Moving Load.
36
Verify and Interpret Analysis Results
Use Results> Load Combinations in the Main Menu to open the Load
Combinations dialog box and enter the following load combination:
37
Tutorial 4
Deformed Shape
38
Verify and Interpret Analysis Results
The method for reviewing the shear force and bending moment diagrams are quite
similar. Therefore, only the method for displaying the bending moment diagram
is reviewed in this case. This method is not intended to capture the bending
moment diagram of the entire structure. The purpose is to display only the results
related to a specific part of the structure. For instance, the following steps illustrate
Quite often, analysis results the procedure to display the bending moment diagram in the X-Z plane.
for the structural behavior of
specific parts are required in
practice. Use the Select
Plane to separately extract 1. Click Hidden (Toggle off).
the results at the desired
planar section. 2. Click Initial View in the Icon Menu.
3. Click Select by Plane.
4. Select “XZ Plane” in the Plane tab.
5. Click in the Y Position field and select a point with the mouse, which
defines the desired X-Z plane (the color of the selected plane changes).
For convenience to follow the given instruction, choose y = 0.
6. Click .
7. Click Activate.
MVmin: The minimum
member force resulting from
8. Click Front View.
the vehicle load applied to the 9. Select Beam Diagram in Results > Forces from the Main Menu.
structure.
MVmax: The maximum 10. Select “MVall: MVL” in Load Cases/Combinations selection field.
member force resulting from
the vehicle load applied to the 11. Select “My” in the Components selection field.
structure. 12. Select “5 Points” and “Line Fill” in Display Options selection field.
13. Enter “1.0” in the Scale field.
14. Check ()“Contour” and “Legend” in the Type of Display selection
field.
15. Click .
39
Tutorial 4
40
Verify and Interpret Analysis Results
41
Tutorial 4
Use animation to investigate the results of the support reaction influence line.
42
Verify and Interpret Analysis Results
43
Tutorial 4
1. Click Beam Forces/Moments in Result > Moving Load > Influ. Lines
from the Main Menu.
2. Confirm “Lane 1” in the Line/Surface Lanes selection field.
3. Enter “23” in the Key Element field.
4. Enter “2.0” in the Scale Factor field.
5. Select “i” in the Parts selection field.
6. Select “My” in the Components selection field.
7. Check () “Legend” in the Type of Display selection field.
8. Click .
44
Verify and Interpret Analysis Results
Use Moving Load Tracer to check the reactions on the structure resulting from
Moving Load Tracer can be the movement of vehicular traffic.
applied to the results
obtained from the structural
analysis related to Moving 1. Select Iso View and Initial View.
Vehicle Load. It displays the
results similar to an 2. Click Select Plane.
influence line or influence
3. Select “XY Plane” in the Plane tab, click in the Z Position field, and
surface diagram by tracking
the location of the vehicle select node 1 with the mouse.
loading.
4. Click .
5. Click Activate.
6. Select Results> Moving Load > Moving Tracer>Reactions in the Main
Menu.
7. Select “MVmax : MVL” in the Moving Load Cases selection field.
8. Enter “1” in the Key Node field.
9. Enter “1.0” in the Scale Factor field.
10. Select “FZ” in the Components field selection.
11. Check () “Contour”, “Legend” and “Applied Loads” in the Type
of Display selection field.
12. Click .
45
Tutorial 4
Using Moving Load Tracer, we can now check the moving load location, which
Moving Load Tracer causes the movement at the ith end of element 28.
generates a particular
loading condition, which
produces specific results
due to a vehicle moving 1. Select Results>Moving Load > Moving Tracer > Beam Forces/Moment
load. The traced moving in the Main Menu.
load condition is
expressed in terms of an 2. Select “MVmax : MVL” in the Moving Load Cases selection field.
influence line or surface.
3. Enter “28” in the Key Element field.
4. Enter “1.0” in the Scale Factor field.
5. Select “i” in the Parts selection field.
6. Select “MY” in the Components selection field.
7. Check () “Contour”, “Legend” and “Applied Loads” in the Type
of Display selection field.
8. Click .
Confirming the load position that induces moment using the Moving Tracer
46
Verify and Interpret Analysis Results
Having determined the moving load location by the Moving Load Tracer, we
will now examine the method of converting the live load into a static load. If we
click the button of the Moving Load Tracer Function,
the converted static load is saved in an MCT file. When we execute the MCT file
using the MCT Command Shell in the model file already generated, the static load
will be entered in the model. (For details on MCT Command Shell, refer to the
Online Manual).
1. Click .
2. Click in Moving Load Converted to Static Load dialog box.
3. Select File>Exit in the MIDAS/Text Editor.
4. In the Main Menu, select Tools>MCT Command Shell>Open >File
Name (MVmaxMVLMy28.mct)>Open.
5. Click in the MCT Command Shell dialog box.
6. Click [Yes] when prompted for “Analysis/design results will be deleted;
Continue?” in the CVLw dialog box.
7. Click in the MCT Command Shell dialog box.
8. Select Load>Static Loads > Static Load Cases in the Main Menu.
9. Confirm that “MVmaxMVL1My28.mct” is generated under the Name
column in the Static Load Cases dialog box.
10. Click in the Static Load Cases dialog box.
11. Click Analysis.
47
Tutorial 4
48
Verify and Interpret Analysis Results
We can now check the bending moment due to the static load that was
generated from the live load which caused the movement at the ith end of
element 28.
1. Select Beam Diagram in Results > Forces from the Main Menu.
2. Select “ST:MVmaxMVLMy28” in the Load Cases/Combinations
selection field.
3. Select “My” in the Components selection field.
4. Select “5 Points” and “Solid Fill” in Display Options selection field.
5. Enter “1.0” in the Scale field.
6. Check () “Contour” and “Legend” in the Type of Display selection
field.
7. Click .
My beam diagrams for the live load converted into static load
49